Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Komprimovan Vazduh Knjiga I
Komprimovan Vazduh Knjiga I
AIRPOWER USA
Prepared for
Prepared by
Hank van Ormer
President
Proceedings of the Twenty-Seventh Industrial Energy Technology Conference, New Orleans, LA, May 10-13, 2005
ESL-IE-05-05-10
ESL-IE-05-05-10
Another approach is matching the discharge connection of the upstream piece of equipment
(filter, dryer, regulator, or compressor). Well, a 150-hp, two-stage, reciprocating, double-acting,
water-cooled compressor delivers about 750 cfm at 100 psig through a 6-inch port. But most
150-hp rotary screw compressors, on the other hand, deliver the same volume and pressure
through a 2-inch or 3-inch connection. So which one is right? Its obvious which is cheaper, but
port size isnt a good guide to pipe size.
Charts and Graphs
Many people use charts that show the so-called standard pressure drop as a function of pipe
size and fittings, which sizes the line for the what is referred to as an acceptable pressure drop.
This practice, too, can be misleading because the charts cant accommodate velocity- and flowinduced turbulence.
Some might call pipe sizing a lost art, but
we see the issue as a lack of attention to
detail, basic piping principles, and
guidelines. Read on to learn how to size air
piping using velocity, which when combined
with appropriate piping practice, ensures an
efficient compressed air distribution system.
As compressed air system consultants and
troubleshooters, we use certain guidelines
to design new piping systems and to
analyze existing system performance and
opportunities for improvement.
There are four different categories of
compressed air piping. They all have a job
to do, and therefore, require different design
criteria:
Inlet piping
Interconnecting piping of the air supply
Distribution piping headers/sub-headers
Piping to feed the process.
As we look at each of these groups, we will list some of the rules of thumb or guidelines, which
are appropriate.
Inlet Piping
Guidelines: It is important to air compressor efficiency and integrity that the inlet is as cool as
possible, at as high pressure as possible, and free from contaminants such as dirt, pollen, birds,
etc. and water.
AirPowerProceedings
USA, Inc. of the Twenty-Seventh Industrial Energy Technology
2
Conference, New Orleans, LA, www.airpowerusainc.com
May 10-13, 2005
ESL-IE-05-05-10
Inlet piping is often ignored today, because many of the fully packaged units have the intake
inside or on the package and take in room or ambient air. However, some plants will remove
the room air intake (particularly when it is contaminated) and install a pipe to an outsidemounted filter for a more appropriate air source. Many larger compressors, such as centrifugals
or oil-free rotary screws, will have cooler outside inlet where the cooler inlet air has a much
higher impact on performance efficiency then a lubricant-cooled rotary compressor.
When this happens, what size pipe? Dont size the pipe by the size of the inlet opening!
The objective is to deliver the air to the compressor inlet at the highest possible pressure after it
leaves the outside intake filter or pick-up point. Like all piping, the pressure loss is a function of
flow (scfm), pipe material, distance, and turbulence.
Size for negligible pressure loss by function it doesnt usually cost much to step up to the next
size.
It can be good practice to provide a large volume
in the suction lines as shown here, just before
the compressor intake flange. This will:
Material: The proper inlet pipe brings the air from the filter to the compressor with no pressure
loss and should not create operational problems with any type of self-contamination on the
inside. It is important to realize that the ambient inlet air condition may well dictate the selection
of one type of pipe over another.
GALVANIZED INLET PIPING has the advantage of resisting corrosion better than standard iron
pipe. However, over time when the corrosion does set in, the galvanizing material then peels
off. The inlet pipe is now a producer of potentially very damaging, solid contaminants between
the filter and the compressor. This would be particularly dangerous to the mechanical integrity
of a centrifugal compressor.
During high humidity weather, it is quite conceivable that condensation will form in the inlet
pipe (therefore, the OEM installation manual should recommend a drain valve be installed on
the pipe before the inlet). Condensation in the pipe will obviously accelerate the time frame
before the coating breaks down. This time frame is dependent upon where the thinnest portion
of the coating is applied.
Stainless steel inlet pipe is the best possible material or such large-diameter, low-pressure
inlet air, as long as it is installed properly and the inside is properly cleaned.
AirPowerProceedings
USA, Inc. of the Twenty-Seventh Industrial Energy Technology
3
Conference, New Orleans, LA, www.airpowerusainc.com
May 10-13, 2005
ESL-IE-05-05-10
There are also many grades of plastic material suitable for inlet air piping.
Summary: We recommend either stainless steel or proper plastic-type material for inlet piping
and do not recommend galvanized piping.
Design: Heres where common sense comes in:
Tight turns may cause pressure loss through turbulence run as straight and smooth as
possible and as direct.
We want the air to stay cool if you have to run the pipe into a hot room, or by a heat source
such as a boiler -- then insulate it.
With reciprocating compressors, be sure you are not in critical length. Support the weight of
the inlet pipe dont let it hang on the compressors.
Assuming the filter does its job on dirt, frogs, etc. as contaminants is there any chance of
internal piping condensation. If so, just to be safe, install a drain point at the low point in the
inlet pipe just before it enters the compressor. On centrifugals and oil-free screws, we always
recommend this drain.
Seem simple? All these moves seem logical and easy to follow, particularly having read the
guidelines. We have corrected problems in all these areas time and time again in the field. For
example, recently in a foundry, we found:
Inlet air to compressors 6 pipe
260-300 ft measured vacuum 18
Hg = 9.5 psia inlet pressure
assuming a normal 14.2 psia/inlet
pressure, this lowers the scfm
from 725 scfm at 60F to 501
scfm at 60 -- a loss of 31%
volume per unit.
To supply required 1400 scfm, the
plant had to run one extra 150hp full load estimated electrical
energy cost wasted -- $54,000
/year for 26 years = $1,400,000
wasted energy!
Filter Separator
Filter
Separator
Separator
SULLAIR
20-
20-
20-
150L
150L
150 HP
2
SULLAIR
SULLAIR
150L
Zurn RA 1400
Refer Dryer
Filter
150 HP
150 HP
Interconnecting Piping
This is the piping area where we find the most opportunities in compressed air systems,
particularly in those installed after the late 1970s. The older systems were put in more carefully
and the introduction of lubricant-cooled rotaries created many misconceptions recommended by
well-meaning but untrained personnel.
Guidelines: the higher the pressure the compressor has to produce, the more electrical energy
is required to run (1/2% per psig). With a few exceptions, the most energy efficient point for all
AirPowerProceedings
USA, Inc. of the Twenty-Seventh Industrial Energy Technology
4
Conference, New Orleans, LA, www.airpowerusainc.com
May 10-13, 2005
ESL-IE-05-05-10
compressors to run is at full flow. A well-designed and controlled system will have no more than
one unit at less efficient part load all others at full load or off.
The piping from the compressors to the filters, dryers, and the air receiver is what we call the
interconnecting piping. At todays recognized energy costs, its job is to get the air from the
compressor discharge to the dry air receiver (or system header, if there is no receiver with the
lowest possible pressure loss.
Part of this loss is filter and dryer selection, which is either implemented well or not. However,
we often find significant problems, particularly in multiple compressor installations in pipe sizing
and even more in layout or design.
Too much backpressure in the interconnecting piping can have many consequences, not
immediately obvious:
Reduce effective storage and cause short cycling in step-controlled units not only
wasting electrical energy, but also shortening the life of coolers, motors, air end, and
coupling.
Keep modulated-type controlled units from being fully loaded and subsequently running
multiple units at plant load.
Cause the compressor to run higher pressure to deliver appropriate pressure to the
system.
Nominal
Pipe Size
2
Schedule
40
Cfm
Free
Air
75
100
150
200
250
300
400
500
600
800
1000
1250
1500
1750
2000
2250
2500
15
20
30
.19
.28
.69
1.20
.16
.24
.57
1.00
1.53
.13
.20
.49
.85
1.31
1.89
.10
.16
.38
.66
1.02
1.47
2.50
3.87
40
50
.13
.31
.54
.83
1.20
2.04
3.16
4.50
.11
.26
.46
.70
1.01
1.73
2.67
3.81
75
100
12
150
.19
.33
.51
.73
1.25
1.93
2.75
4.87
7.55
.15
.26
.40
.57
.98
1.51
2.15
3.82
5.90
9.12
.12
.21
.33
.47
.80
1.24
1.77
3.13
4.85
7.49
10.8
.10
.18
.28
.40
.68
1.05
1.50
2.66
4.12
6.35
9.17
12.5
16.3
200
250
300
350
.14
.21
.31
.52
.81
1.05
2.04
3.16
4.87
7.02
9.54
12.5
15.8
19.4
.11
.17
.26
.42
.65
.93
1.65
2.56
3.96
5.70
7.74
10.1
12.8
15.8
.15
.21
.36
.55
.79
1.39
2.16
3.32
4.80
6.50
8.50
10.8
13.3
.13
.18
.31
.48
.68
1.20
1.86
2.87
4.14
5.62
7.35
9.30
11.4
Most often, inexperienced compressed air system design personnel use only the Standard
Pressure Loss Charts (see above). These charts reflect pressure loss in piping what we
normally call friction loss the air pressure being lost to the friction on the pipe walls. As you
see, the chart is in psig loss per 100 of pipe based on flow (scfm) and entry pressure (psig).
This is generally very accurate and satisfactory for distribution air, but in the interconnecting
piping, we have to consider another cause of pressure loss turbulence.
AirPowerProceedings
USA, Inc. of the Twenty-Seventh Industrial Energy Technology
5
Conference, New Orleans, LA, www.airpowerusainc.com
May 10-13, 2005
ESL-IE-05-05-10
6 Discharge Line
2 Discharge Line
6
2
3 Header
6
2
AirPowerProceedings
USA, Inc. of the Twenty-Seventh Industrial Energy Technology
6
Conference, New Orleans, LA, www.airpowerusainc.com
May 10-13, 2005
ESL-IE-05-05-10
Interconnecting piping
should never exceed 20
fps. There is no such
thing as too low velocity
(or too large pipe) for
this application.
1 Pipe
56.8 scfm
20 fps
2 Pipe
838 scfm
20 fps
492 scfm
20 fps
3 Pipe
All pipeline velocities to be
20 fps or less at 100 psig.
For Example:
4 Pipe
3295 scfm
20 fps
1901scfm
20 fps
6 Pipe
220 scfm
20 fps
8 Pipe
5191scfm
20 fps
10 Pipe
At velocities below 20
fps, design is much less
critical.
7368 scfm
20 fps
12 Pipe
90o Turns
Crossing T
Dead Head
AirPowerProceedings
USA, Inc. of the Twenty-Seventh Industrial Energy Technology
7
Conference, New Orleans, LA, www.airpowerusainc.com
May 10-13, 2005
ESL-IE-05-05-10
4 psid
5 psid
4 Header
2000 ft
176.5 cuft
1321 gallons
4 psid
500
gallon
1 cuft
1 cuft
500 cfm
100 hp
66.84 cuft
3 cuft
EFFECTIVE STORAGE
71.84 cuft / 537 gallons
<1 psid
<2 psid
500
gallon
500 cfm
100 hp
66.84 cuft
4 Header
2000 ft
176.5 cuft
1321 gallons
Oversized Heat
Sink Cycling
Dryer
2 cuft
3 cuft
EFFECTIVE STORAGE
248.34 cuft / 1857 gallons
AirPowerProceedings
USA, Inc. of the Twenty-Seventh Industrial Energy Technology
8
Conference, New Orleans, LA,www.airpowerusainc.com
May 10-13, 2005
ESL-IE-05-05-10
AirPowerProceedings
USA, Inc. of the Twenty-Seventh Industrial Energy Technology
9
Conference, New Orleans, LA, www.airpowerusainc.com
May 10-13, 2005
ESL-IE-05-05-10
Dead Head
6
Air from Compressor
Room 1
Crossing Tee
1/2
Air Leak
1/2
We start with what scenarios the average flow and size for 20 fps or less velocity (although
many feel up to 30 fps is all right and actually will work). Then we check for friction loss for the
maximum flow at the largest runs. You will have to know or estimate accurately the process
demand for this.
As stated earlier, oversized header can act as storage and perhaps be the most economical
selection.
Oversized Header Piping to create effective storage at the process. Often this can work, as
show below.
In Figure 1, the plant installed a large air receiver with an intermediate controller trying to hold a
critical steady pressure at the regulator discharge for optimum production and quality. There
was a 200 run of 4 pipe from the intermediate controller or regulator and the pressure varied
from 85 to 90 psig as the regulator opened and closed randomly. The process regulators also
delivered erratic pressure to blow off and usually well below the setting. The pull down band in
the main 4 feed was 4 psig. The regulator feed variance was much greater some well above
10 psig.
The following actions were taken (see Figure 2):
Oversize feeder header to the regulator to 12. This now created enough storage that
regardless of the timing of the regulated bursts of air, there was enough storage to feed
each line at full capacity without pulling the inlet pressure down at the nearby feeds or
even in the overall header.
ESL-IE-05-05-10
59 PSIG
AIR PEELER
AIR PEELER
AIR PEELER
61 PSIG
AIR PEELER
64 PSIG
AIR PEELER
4
HEADER
65 PSIG
AIR PEELER
72 PSIG
72 PSIG
72 PSIG
AIR PEELER
72 PSIG
AIR PEELER
71 PSIG
AIR PEELER
72 PSIG
AIR PEELER
68 PSIG
AIR PEELER
72 PSIG
AIR PEELER
85 PSIG
3200 GAL
4 FROM
COMPRESSOR ROOM
MULTIPLE 90O TURNS
5 OR 6 STRAIGHT
FROM COMPPRESSOR
ROOM
Figure 1
85-80 PSIG
Figure 2
90 PSIG
1 1/2
1 1/2
Supply Air
CIP Solenoid
Regulator
105 psig
Cashco Regulators
Check valve
Air to Pulsers
90-50 psig
1
1/2
Filter
Instrument Air
Filter
Regulator
12
HEADER
ESL-IE-05-05-10
Trying to use the pipe volume 2 and a quick response regulator did not work out:
No regulator has quick enough response to handle this 640-scfm rate of flow in 0.75 seconds,
so we will supply the demand with storage and allow a metering valve to refill the receiver over
a longer time frame (4 seconds), which will reduce the rate of flow from the air system
significantly.
Calculating maximum air receiver pressure loss 8 cfm demand in 0.75 seconds:
TDecay =
Recommended action to deliver a consistent minimum pressure of 90 psig to the process during
pulsing (see figure below):
Install 2 piping to a metering valve (gate valve); adjust valve to refill the receiver in four
seconds after the pulser closes. Once set, remove handle to eliminate possibility of
inappropriate adjustment.
1 1/2
Supply Air
CIP Solenoid
1 1/2
Air to Pulsers
90+ psig
Regulator
105+ psig
2
Metering
Valve
120
Gallon
Check valve
2
2
1/2
Filter
Filter
Regulator
Instrument Air
There is not a regulator, which can react in the short amount of time in which the pulsers hit at
the required rate of flow. The receiver and metering valve will cushion the distribution piping
from this high rate of flow experienced by the system and the 2 main feed, thus allowing it to
operate correctly.
ESL-IE-05-05-10
Our piping modification shows a new metering valve sized to handle the new flow at 120 cfm.
The bypass is piped with angle entry and exit around the metering valve. The process now
operates correctly.
What we have had here are two downstream processes that require a little special attention.
Until you get into the details, you cant be sure what the answer is. However, any surge
demand should be reviewed as to what effect it is having on the rest of the system and what
type of piping design it needs.
If the header is sized to 20 fps, not to exceed 30 fps, it will generally not have problems except
from these type demands or over very long runs.
Loop design systems are always a good idea and often a system that has become restrictive
over time may be corrected by creating loops AFTER PROPER INVESTIGATION. There are
many other considerations, which are always discussed which we will not cover here
centralized or decentralized system, top or side header connections, pipe slope, etc.
Be careful of subheader:
WATCH THE SUB-HEADERS
6 Header
1
1
1
D7
1/2
ESL-IE-05-05-10
Size the line size by -- ?? certainly not opening size! Who in the plant knew the average
demand in flow rate? Who knew in rate of flow? What is the minimum required pressure?
Why? If you dont know most of these answers, you are shooting blind.
Again, there is no such thing as too big a pipe or hose, unless the size interferes with
productivity. Most of the time when we have a low pressure problem because of being too far
from the compressors, we dont find the problem in the main headers it is usually in the
subheader, feeds, or connections.
You must know or estimate the flow demand (and the pressure), then check sizing on all feed
lines, hoses, tubes, filter, quick disconnects, regulators, etc.
The Book talks about allowing from 35 fps to 50 fps. Common sense says run it as large as
you can and when you have to go to smaller line, hose, etc., make it as short as possible. Look
for condensate control at all low and drop points.
Some general guidelines to evaluate feeds:
Always measure pressures at load and at rest to accurately see the results
Know the performance data on all valves, regulators, quick disconnects on the feed lines
what effect on pressure drop the anticipated rate of flow will have.
Recommendation: Pipe to all filters and dryers with pipe sizing to handle the expected
maximum flow at less than 20 fps at pipeline conditions. At these conditions, a drain leg
ahead of the filter is always a good idea to extend it full performance life and remove any gross
load before it reaches the element. Twenty-five to 35 pipe diameters in length of the correct
size pipe will effectively slow the air down before it reaches the filter (drain leg). This may
improve filter performance and will extend element life.
ESL-IE-05-05-10
Compressed Air Facts That Will Help to Keep the Process Air Clean and Dry
Use common sense: Typical application considerations that affect performance.
Many air systems we review with
poor air quality problems have
ignored some common sense rules
that always apply. Keeping these
in mind will assure proper
performance over a longer period
of time at a lower operating cost.
DRY AIR
Water
Vapor
Liquid water left to stand in air receiver, filter housing, separators, low spots,
etc., will evaporate into the dry air raising the relative humidity and pressure
dewpoint within the system. Drain condensate immediately and continuously.
Example -- Piping to Bagging Unit Regulator:
Original System Connection
Corrected Connection
Hose
C
o
n
d
e
n
s
a
t
e
Regulator
Pipe
Regulator
Pipe
Support
Floor
Drain Point
No changes to the compressed air system should be made without permission from the Compressed Air
Czar. No equipment ordered unless the central air utility can handle or has plans to handle.
ESL-IE-05-05-10
APPENDIX
OTHER GENERAL PIPING & SYSTEM DESIGN GUIDELINES
NOT SPECIFICALLY COVERED IN MAIN PAPER
ESL-IE-05-05-10
ESL-IE-05-05-10
ESL-IE-05-05-10
ESL-IE-05-05-10
ESL-IE-05-05-10