Professional Documents
Culture Documents
L E C T U R E S
Professor, F. Eng., Ph.D., D.I.C., F.C.G.I., D.Sc. Hon., London, UNITED KINGDOM
ABSTRACT: The steel industry witnessed within the last decades a remarkable acceptance of space structures for many structural
applications. The popularity of three-dimensional structures has been growing steadily, but their present acceptance all over the world is truly
phenomenal. Nowadays, space structures are willingly used by architects and engineers for sport halls, gymnasia, leisure centres, industrial
buildings and hangars. References 1,2,3 describe in detail the recent developments in many countries. The large number of space frames built
shows clearly that, through prefabrication and industrialisation, these systems often compete very successfully with more conventional
structures, at the same time providing architects with more impressive forms. As a rule, space frames are built with simple prefabricated units
which are often of standard size and shape. Such modular units, mass produced in the workshop, can be easily and rapidly assembled on site
by semi-skilled labour.
Key words: Joint, system, modular, prefabricated, steel, space structures
1. INTRODUCTION
In the past, the chief barriers towards the general use of these systems,
were the complexity of analysis of space structures and the difficulty of
joining several members in space at different angles. The introduction of
electronic computers solved the first difficulty.
Fig.2. The famous Eiffel tower, erected in Paris for the 1889 exhibition
by the French engineer Alexandre Gustave Eiffel is a typical
example of a three-dimensional structure. It also illustrates the
complexity of a three-dimensional joint in the age of gusset plates
and riveting.
OPENING SESSION
17
OPENING SESSION
18
a)
OPENING SESSION
b)
c)
19
Fig.5. The MERO system, introduced in 1942, consists of modular bars and connectors. The spherical joint is cast in steel, drilled, tapped and
threaded to receive high tensile bolts. The tensile forces carried along the longitudinal axis of the bolts are taken over through the coneshaped end pieces welded to the ends of the tube. An excellent, widely used system. Thousends of buildins using this system are
constructed all over the world.
OPENING SESSION
20
Fig.6. The MODUSPAN system (previously known as the UNISTRUT system) is used exclusively for double-layer grids. The structures
consist of framing struts, all of the same length, the same for top and bottom layers and the diagonals. The struts are connected at the joints by
one bolt only to the specially shaped pressed-steel plate.
OPENING SESSION
21
Fig.7. The SPACE DECK system, the first British system pyramidal units which are erected apex downwards with the angle frames butting
against each other and inter-connected with bolts. The bottom layer is formed by tie-members of high-tensile steel which are fitted with
turnbuckles.
OPENING SESSION
22
OPENING SESSION
23
a)
b)
Fig.12. Examples of a recently introduced Yugoslav system for doublelayer grids. Fig 12a gives details of the TORUS joint, Fig 12b of
the second version known as the TORUS-GUSTO.
OPENING SESSION
24
possible for UNIBAT system are not limited as it usually is in other systems,
by the node connector, but simply by the maximum size of structural
section available. Theoretically, UNIBAT can be used for double- or multilayer structures. This system is rarely used now in France being replaced by
another system based on SPHEROBAT connector (see Fig 14).
7. THE NODUS SYSTEM
It was introduced in 1972 by the Tubes Division of the British Steel
Corporation. The development of the NODUS joint (see Fig 19 - in
chapter 8 Illustrations) has been an outcome of several years of research
and extensive testing carried out at the research centre of the British Steel
Corporation the Tubes Division at Corby. The NODUS joint is a typical
example of a mechanical connector. It comprises a body divided into two
half casings which are clamped together by means of a high strength
friction grip bolt. The bolt head is accommodated in a hexagonal recess in
one half casing, thus leaving the exterior of the joint flush with the outside
of the chord member so that cladding can be fixed directly onto the chords.
The mating half casting has four protruding lugs drilled for connecting to
the bracing members, either in line with or at 45 degrees to the chords, by
use of the appropriate half casings. The horizontal chord members are butt
welded to connectors having circumferential rings which lock into
corresponding grooves in the half casings. The bracing members have steel
forked connectors welded to their ends. These members connect to the
casings lugs by means of headed pins, secured with split cotter pins. A
sealing gasket is inserted between the half casings and is clamped with the
central bolt, which is tightened to a specific torque value.
Although the NODUS system has been used principally in the construction
of horizontal double-layer grids, it can be adapted to a variety of other
applications including vertical, inclined or multi-layer grids. These
applications are particularly effective in the covering of exhibition halls,
shopping centres, museums or similar buildings where the structure is
exposed or viewed through glasing. Numerous buildings have been erected
in this system during the last nine years in the U.K., Middle East, and many
other countries. Altogether some 500,000 square meters have been covered
with the NODUS space frames.
In the early stage of the development of the NODUS joint, prototypes were
rigorously tested in a specially designed rig at the BSCs Tube Divisions
Research Centre at Corby. These tests applied loads to the joint in all
directions simultaneously and account was taken of varying bracing angles
which induced an eccentric moment. These tests enabled the yield strength
of the joint and the maximum working load to be determined. Due to the
construction of the joint, it was found that compression loads resisted by
members meeting at the NODUS joints would be 15% higher than those for
tension loads. The design of this connector makes it suitable for automatic
welding process (see Ref 8).
8. THE REVIEW OF RECENT DEVELOPMENTS
It clearly shows that the search for an economical connector for various
types of space structures did not lose momentum.
An interest in this field is probably best illustrated by the competition
organised in 1964 by the French Chambre Syndicale des Fabricants de Tubes
dAcier for the development of efficient connectors for tubular space
structures. Over 40 entries were received. Reference 9 gives details of the
various proposals submitted during this competition. Several articles and
even books have been published to discuss the relative advantages and
disadvantages of numerous connectors.
It is also known that some commercial concerns have tested their own and
their competitors connectors. However, as a rule, the results of these
comparative tests are not available to the general public.
In addition to extensive tests on various connectors carried out during the
period of 1969-70 by Stewarts and Lloyds Co. Ltd., the Mannesmannrhre
Werke A.G. have produced results of their tests on the strength of the
OKTAPLATTE (see Fig 3) and OKTAPLATTE-S systems. Their tests were
carried out at the Technical University of Karlsruhe. There are also
publications giving details of tests on joints for space structures carried out
OPENING SESSION
25
Fig.16. The three basic configurations used in the Pyramitec system consisting of pyramids having triangular, hexagonal and square bases. The
top layer is constructed by bolting the flanges of the adjacent bases of the inverted pyramids using horizontal bolts. The bottom layer
consists of long tubular members flattened at nodal points and connected together by means of vertical bolts passing through the apices of
the pyramidal modules.
Fig.17. The details of connection used during the construction of the dome over the Fort Regent leisure centre at Jersey. The dome is a singlelayer grid structure consisting of almost square trays made of hollow sections which are joined together at their corners by site bolts and
finally site-welded.
OPENING SESSION
26
Fig.18. The French system known as the NEWBAT consists of members with flattened ends which fit into a cast node. The structure is assembled
by bolting and pinning only, no welding is required neither in workshop or on the work site.
OPENING SESSION
27
Fig.19. The NODUS joint has been developed in 1972 by the British Steel Corporation Tubes Division for prefabricated steel tubular doublelayer grids. The joint consists of two castings, the chord connectors and the fork connectors for the disagonals. The main casings are
held together by means of a centre bolt. Four basic layouts of the grid can be obtained using the NODUS joint:
a) square on square offset
b) square on large square offset
c) square on diagonal
d) diagonal on square.
OPENING SESSION
28
Fig.20. The plan and elevations of a three-way double-layer grid supported at four points only over a square in Kuweit. The structure
supports sun shades designed by a French firm of Space Engineering.
OPENING SESSION
29
a)
b)
c)
Fig.21. The details of the three-way double-layer grid for the Kuweit roof. The structure consists of tetrahedral modular units made in tubular stee
The cast end pieces are welded to the tubular members which are bolted together at the joints.
OPENING SESSION
30
Fig.22. The K.T. Space Frame system developed in Denmark for double-layer grids. The tubular bars are fitted with internally fixed bolts
which are screwed into the spherical connectors.
OPENING SESSION
31
Fig.24. An American system known as the POWER-STRUT. Suitable for double-layer grids. There are only two types of basic components web
members (for diagonals) and chord members. They are connected to the module connector by means of bolts and nuts.
a)
b)
c)
OPENING SESSION
32
Fig.26.
OPENING SESSION
33
Fig.27. A very economical system developed in France and known as the TRIDI 2000. The node consists of an assembly of plates welded
together. Members of any shape can be connected to the gusset plates by means of high tensile friction bolts. Many industrial buildings,
sport halls and assembly halls covered with this system.
OPENING SESSION
34
Fig.28. An Italian PREMIT system developed for prefabricated double-layer grid industrial buildings. It consists of two standard structural
components: a) the diagonal member, b) the chord member. Both elements have special end pieces. The connection is ensured without
eccentricity be means of four high strength friction bolts.
Fig.29. The Spanish ORONA system developed for double-layer grids and domes. The tubular members have specially formed ends with high
tensile bolts which are screwed into a spherical connector. Used with great success over a number of large span buildings.
OPENING SESSION
35
Fig.30. The COSMOS joint developed recently in South allowing variable angle adjustments from flexible knuckle joint. Tubular members are
fitted in the workshop with an end piece. No welding on site.
Fig.33. A simple joint used for small span single-layer shell structures or do
layer grids. In France this system is referred to as the SARTON system
tubes are flattened at the joint and connected by a single bolt. Suitab
moderate loads.
OPENING SESSION
36
Fig.36. A Polish joint developed for steel tubular three-way single-layer grid domes. Three bars are bolted to the gusset plate, and the other three bars
specially shaped end pieces welded to the gusset plate.
OPENING SESSION
37
Fig.37. This the NS Truss system U-type developed a few years ago by the Japanese Nippon Steel Corporation for tubular members. The node is a
steel sphere with threaded holes for the connection bolts. Used for numerous double-layer grids. The tubular members have cones welded to
both ends. The bolts are fitted into the end cones before welding. The fastening tool is inserted through the node opening into the square
hole at the end of the bolt. A spring at the head of the bolt presses the bolt to engage with the thread of the node.
OPENING SESSION
38
Fig.38. Stressed skin space grids introduced in the 1960s take advantage of the roof covering becoming an integral part of the load carrying
structure. They consists of thin sheet pyramidal modular units made in aluminium, glass fibre reinforced plastics sheets which are
interconnected in space systems. The drawing shows several examples of such structures designed by the author with the details of
aluminium cast connectors.
OPENING SESSION
39
Fig.39. The connector used for the aluminium stressed skin space
grid designed by the author for International Union of
Architects Congress Headquarters building erected in 1961 in
London.
OPENING SESSION
40
10. REFERENCES
1. Z.S.Makowski (editor): Analysis, design and construction of doublelayer grids. Applied Science Publishers/Halsted Press, London and
New York, 1981.
2. Z.S.Makowski (editor): Analysis, design and construction of braced
domes. Granada Publishing Ltd., London and Nocholls Publishing
Company, New York 1984.
3. Z.S.Makowski (editor): Analysis, design and construction of braced
barrel vaults. Elsevier Applied Science Publishers Ltd., London, 1985.
4. V.Hauk: The Mannesmann Okta-S joint for tubular space structures.
Proc. of the 2nd International Conference on Space Structures,
University of Surrey, 1975, pp.432-6.
5. (a) G.M.Rose: A comparative examination of a wide variety of joints
for space structures. Space Structures Conference, British Steel
Corporation, London 1970.
(b) S.Boar, M.Raskin: Noeuds de structures tubulaires spatiales. Sm80
St6, Liege, 1970.
6. Z.S.Makowski (editor): New trends in spatial structures. Bulletin of
the International Association for Shell and Spatial Structures. April
1986, No. 90, vol XXVII, pp. 21-43.
7. S.C. Hsiao, G.C. Dygert: The Moduspan space-frame system. Proc. of
the 2nd Intern. Conf. on Space Structures. University of Surrey, 1975,
pp.296-299.
8. Design Manual: Space Frame Grids, 3rd Edition, 1976, British Steel
Corporation, Tubes Division.
9. Chambre Syndicale. Le Tybe dacier dans la construction metallique
noeuds et assemblages. CSFA, Paris, 1966.
10. Toader et al.: Aspecte privind calculul si realizarea unor invelitori
reticulate, Bul. Stiint., Institutul de constructii Bucuresti, T.21, No.3-4,
1978, pp.77-93.
11. Z.Kowal: Przestrzenne struktury prtowe z wzami toczonymi.
PNIB P.Wr. Wrocaw, 1975.
12.Raport Instytutu Budownictwa. Nr.1-2/R-131/75. Badanie wzw.
Wrocaw, 1975.
13. D.Mitaritonna, G.Prete: Proposta e sperimentazione di un nuovo
sistema di connessione nodale per grigliati spaziali in acciaio.
Construzioni Metalliche, No. 4, 1977.
14. K.Thomsen: Trends in the design of double-layer space grids. Proc.
of the 2nd Intern. Conf. on Space Structures, University of Surrey,
1975, pp. 382-398.
15. T.Arciszewski, Udmak: Shaping of spherical joints in space
structures. International Journal of Space Structures, vol.3, No.3,
1988, pp. 171-183.
OPENING SESSION
16.
G.S.Ramaswamy, M.Eekhout, G.R.Suresh: Steel space frames,
analysys, design and constrution. Produced by Thomas Felford
Publishing, London, 2002
1
41
OPENING SESSION
L E C T U R E S
42
OPENING SESSION
43
OPENING SESSION
1.
2.
3.
44
Viewed from the outside, the Mount Angel Library building is quite
modest in scale. This is true whether it is observed from the south at the
level of the campus above, or from the north at the base level of the
building. In each case, it blends well with its neighbors, with which it
shares the brick veneer facing. At the south side, the building is only one
story high, and at the north side only three. Thus it is quite unobtrusive no grandiose statement here. What may attract attention is the curved
shape of the faade, behind which the fan-shaped reading/stack rooms are
located, but this form, too, is quite restrained. It appears that Aalto
accepted the exterior space definition provided by the existing buildings
of the Abbey.
The spaces inside are treated differently. The offices and service areas
are quite simple, no different, really, from any that have been designed
by a competent architect.
The main reading/stack areas are treated quite differently. The fan shape
area, the roof skylight, the large floor opening, and the interior column
design were already mentioned. Their very rich forms are accentuated by
the fact that all surfaces are plain, and painted off-white. Thus the form
reigns supreme, and what a rich and dramatic form it is! The interior
space is strongly defined, but in a very restrained way, so that it does not
overwhelm the user of the Library.
The overall mood is enhanced by the fact that many of the interior
furnishings of the building were designed by Aalto. This includes reading
lamps, desks and chairs, etc., as well as some fixtures such as door
handles.
In fulfillment of the intentions of the Abbey, the Aalto Library has been,
since it completion in 1970, a focal point for many wider community
activities. As an example, a seminar was held there in 1998,
memorializing the 100th anniversary of Aaltos birth. And this was just
one event out of many. One cannot help but feel that all those involved in
the project should be well pleased with the results of their efforts.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The photograph shown in Fig. 1 was taken by John Wells, and his
permission to use it here has been much appreciated. All other
photographs were taken by the author.
The important assistance of John Wells in gathering materials necessary
for the preparation of this paper is gratefully acknowledged.
Above all, the assistance, advice, insights and patience of Betty
Medwadowski have been truly beyond measure.
REFERENCES
1.
2.
3.
Fig. 7: Interior view of the main reading/stack area and the sky
OPENING SESSION
45
OPENING SESSION
46
OPENING SESSION
47
OPENING SESSION
48
OPENING SESSION
49
L E C T U R E S
ABSTRACT: Some important structural features of Pantadome System are described. A structural system developed and named Pantadome System
by the principal author has successfully been applied to seven major spatial structures of various shapes and dimensions in different corners of the
world. Pantadome is a structural system (not a construction method) incorporating a temporary kinematic mechanism in it during construction for
a rational erection of domical structures. One of its important structural features is that the system does not need any such provisions as guys or braces
against possible lateral forces due to winds or earthquakes during the erection of a spatial structure. Thanks to this special feature a Pantadome
structure can be lifted even in an inclined direction as is shown in erection of Namihaya Dome. A Pantadome changes its shape very largely during its
erection, and the reactions in pushing posts change the magnitudes accordingly. In some special cases the reactions in the pushing posts become
negative, and a kind of unstable phenomenon becomes prone to occur. This was foreseen in construction of a recently built coal storage, and a
shock-absorbing device was developed to realize a safe construction.
1. INTRODUCTION
OPENING SESSION
50
(a)
(air pressure j
hydraulic jacks
(b)
No.1 Hinge
No.2 Hinge
No.3 Hinge
(c)
removed temporarily
No.1 Hinge Line
No.2 Hinge Line
No.3 Hinge Line
No.1 Hinge
No.2 Hinge
No.3 Hinge
No.4 Hinge
No.5 Hinge
(d)
dome has taken the final shape, the hoop members which have been
temporarily taken off during the erection are fixed to their proper
positions to complete the dome structure. The lifting means such as
air pressure or hydraulic jacks can be then removed, and the dome is
completed. When the dome is very big, it can be doubly folded as
shown in Fig.1 (d), so that assembling works can be done at a level that
is very close to the ground level.
The Pantadome System is sometimes misunderstood as a construction
OPENING SESSION
51
OPENING SESSION
52
RHOMBIC PLAN
m2
ABROAD
12
20
1,250
2,600
14,000
FIRST ATTEMPT
m2
1989
200
SINGAPORE
OVAL PLAN
18
SPECIAL
FEATURES
20
760
STEEL
WEIGHT
LIFTING
POINTS
1,680
TOTAL
WEIGHT
LIFTING
HEIGHT
7,700
1984
110
WORLD
COVERD
AREA
BUILT
PUSH-UP POSTS
PLANS INDICATE
SMALL CIRCLES IN
DIMENSION
AND
SHAPE
NAME
m2
Table 1.
ABROAD
HEAVY SNOW
PURE CIRCLE
28
2,770
5,430
10,500
m2
1995
116
FUKUI
m2
QUICK LIFT
INCLINED ROOF
16
29
1,160
4,690
11,000
1996
127
NAMIHAYA
UNFINISHED SHAPE
12
32
950
3,000
12,000
1990
128
ST.JORDI
m2
UNITS
PRESTRESSED CONCRETE
32
14
4,660
6,500
1998
127
NARA HALL
m2
14
30
6,500
7,500
40,000
2001
251
COAL STORAGE
3.IMPORTANTCHARACTERISTICS OF A PANTADOME
3.1
OPENING SESSION
53
3.3
Folding of Walls
Phase 1
Assembly of
Roof Structure
Phase 2
Assembly of
Wall Structure
Phase 3
Lifting
1FL
B1FL
Phase 4
Works on
Interior
Structures
Pantawalls
Fig. 7 Pantawalls to Take Transverse Shear Forces During and After Erection
OPENING SESSION
54
OPENING SESSION
55
COMCLUSIVE REMARKS
OPENING SESSION
56
6. REFERENCES
1.
(D)
(C)
(B)
(A)
OPENING SESSION
57