& Francis ("")

& Francis

& Francis
Francis

http://www.tandfonline.com/page/termsand-
: ''
Florian Waldowa * Takayamab Sungc
aHumboldt 6D 10099 ;bUniversity
;cKyung
2009 ' '

'
'

(Zymek Zymek 2004)

''
20 60
(
) order.1
( Khamsi 2003) (Nvoa 2003 )


' '

( 2009 ;2013 Kamens; Benavot 2013 ;

2013 ; 2010 ) (
) (PISA)
(2011 ) '

(Kamens 2013);
; '
'
(Waldow 2013 )
pisa

2009
( )

''
2009

(SMH
) (TA)
(SZ) (HN)
(DD) (FAZ
) ( 1)

'''' ''
2001 1 2012 6
2009 (2010 12 )

 ''

( 2000 )

'' '' (1990

) '' '
' (Waldow 2012 418)
-Khamsi (2004 )

( 2011 ; 2010 )

: (1)
? ? (2)
? (3)
?

'

(2000 )

('';
Scheufele 2007 )
( 2004)
''
''

( 2)
''

15 scandalise
(Tillmann 2008 )
'' '' (Ulla Burchardt 2010 )

2006 2009

 2000

PISA PISA
''

(Waldow
2010) (