You are on page 1of 34

Proceedings of International Conference Iran and Bulgaria in the Mirror of History (Past, Present, Future),

ed. by I. Panov, A. Pourmohammad, pp. 263- 303.



. - . , . - . , . -
; . ; . -
,

STUDY OF THE POTENTIAL RELATIONS OF BULGARIANS WITH


DIFFERENT NATIONS LIVING IN IRAN.
Y. Y. Shopov, L.T. Tsankov, T. Yalamov, Institute of Ancient Civilizations; H. Azady ;
Petko Dimitrov, Section of Sea Geology and Archeology of the Institute of Oceanology of BAS,
Varna, Bulgaria.
Abstract:
We identified 3 different archaeological layers (periods) of traces of the ancient Bulgarians
in Iran. The earliest period between 3900- 1700 B.C. has been left by Kutigurs (Kuti) who are
one of the branches of the ancient Bulgarians. It is represented in Sialk tepe III (3900-3000
B.C.), Godin tepe V (3200-3000 B.C.) and VI (3500-3200 B.C.) and tepe Yahia- IV (3300-1800
B.C.). It includes also scripts written on clay tablets.
We studied the history of people of Kuti and demonstrated that national name Kuti is
older version of Kutiguri (the biggest branch of ancient Bulgarians living in the Great Bulgar in
VI- VII-th century AD). The affix -guri means people in ancient Bulgarian language, i.e.
Kutiguri means people of Kuti. This result links the ancient Bulgarians with the land of Kuti
where landed the house-boat of Ut- napishtim. Therefore we studied the locations of the Kuti by
toponims and hydronames they left in Asia. We placed them on the map to obtain a map of their
settlements.
We studied the earliest version of the Deluge story, which was found on two clay tablets
excavated from the Older Nippur library in Tablet Hill, Nippur by H. Hilprecht. These two
tablets with cuneiform inscriptions were written by the tsar (emperor) of Kutians Erridu- pizir
after he conquered the whole Sumer and Akkad in 2478 B.C. (accordingly the Nippur
chronology). They state that the house-boat of the Ut- napishtim (the Babylonian Noah) landed
on the mount Nisir in the land of Kuti (Guti). Kuti established settlements in Zagros Mts in Iran
in the beginning of the 4-th millennium B.P. Probably Erridu- pizir considered these territories
under land of Kuti. We found in Iran 210 toponims and hydronames formed on the base of
Kuti. We studied the morphology of these ancient Bulgarian ethnonims. They are compared with
Bulgarian ethnonims in Bulgaria and in the ancient states of Volga Bulgar and the Great Bulgar,
and with synthetic toponims formed from the same base with the same suffixes as these forming
the toponims in Bulgaria. This way we determined the different Bulgarian toponims in Iran,
which coincide with the theoretical (synthetic) Bulgarian toponims. 68 of them still exist not only
in Iran, but also in Bulgaria, the Great Bulgar or Volga Bulgar territories (now in Ukraine and
Russia).

We found also many toponims in Iran, which coincide with the names of the major cities
and peaks in Bulgaria, which were named by ancient Bulgarians (Varna, Burgas, Madara,
Balkan etc.). Some of them form the name of up to 43 different places in Iran each (they are
repeated in up to 43 toponims each).
The second period came from the participation of the ancient Bulgarians in the
Achaemenian Persian Empire. It is represented in the Bas- reliefs in Naqsh-e Rostam and
Persepolis, in written historical documents, in Persian legends and the Bulgarian folklore.
The third period is from the Sassanian Empire and is represented in the Bas- reliefs in
Naqsh-e Rostam. This period suggests dynastic tides and equivalent cultural traditions with the
Great Bulgar, Volga Bulgar and Danube Bulgaria, but does not suggests direct involvement of
large consistent Bulgarian masses in the Sassanian Empire.


:
1.
2.
:
1.
.
2.
.
3.
, .
:
781 ( ()
() (,
, ..)). - .

,
. 216 - ,
() .
,
, , (,
, , , ..). 43
, ).
,
.
, () 3900-1200 . . .
() . 210
. 68
, ,
( ).
3
. - 3900-1700 . . .
(). III (3900-3000 . . .), V

(3200-3000 . . .) VI (3500-3200 . . .) -IV (3300-1800 . . .).


.

. -
.

- .
, ,
.
:
,
( (1996) - ) ,
,
.
(, 1941; , 1967).
.
1971- 2500-
,
, ,
.
.
1997 .
(, 2000, 2001, 2002)
(2478-2354 . . . ).
(, 2002),
() .
,
,
(
, , ..).

.
:
(
) 2003 .
.
,
, .
(GIS) , .
,
,
(
, , ..).

(. , 2001).

(
). .

.
.

, ( ).
,
( (), (, ),
(), , - , - , ) ().
:
- , -
( ., 2002). -
-
. ,
- ( ., 2002 , 2002) (, 2002,
, ) -
. .
(, 2004), .
, (1998, 2001), .(2002), (2002) (2002) ,

. (1998) ,
-
. (, 1900)
(,
, .). ,
.
.
(, 1900).
(, 2002)
-
(, 2002). ,
,
(- , 1945),
.
.
(
(1925), (1946), (1995), (1998, 2000, 2001, 2002a, 2003, 2007),
. (2002-) , () -
. , V-IV .
. . .

(2004). ,
- ,
(

), - 3900 . . .
( ., 2005).
, ,
-
(), (), , ,
( , 1981). .
, ,
-.
(, 2003). ,
, . ,
(- )
(). 4 (. 1).
(- )
- .
. .
1. ()


()

()

- (**)

, ()
_*

(_)- ( _)
(_)- (_)
(_)- (_)
( )

_
(_)- ( _)
(_)- ( _)
(_)-
* _ ,
** - . (1958)
(-)

__
=

- ,

-
-


//

/ /

//

. .

,
//

-
()
=()
()()

()

()

()

()
()

=
()

-
, =
,
=

/,
- /

//,
-

//, //
/ /
//

//
?

()

(,
//
//

//

,,

,
, , //

/,- /
/.
/
/, /
//
/,/
,

//

//
//
-,

//
24 (36%)

/
/

/,/

21 (32%)

41 (62%)

14 (21%)

4 (6%)

7
2 (3%)
(11%)

2. ,
- .

.
3.

()
.
.
3 .
, (-)

.
.

.
.

.
.
.
.
.
.()
.
.

.
.
.
.

.
.,.,.,.

.
.
.
,

.
.
.


.
.,
,
.,
.

4 .
52 .
3 .

2 .
2 .
5 .

4 .
2 .
7 .
32 .
2 .

- ,
, (-)
, -
- ,
-
, (-)
- , ?
- ,
(-)
- ,

- ,
, - , ,

-
-
, - ?
-

()
, ()
( -)
()
()
( -)
()
()
()

.
.

.
., .
.

2 .

12 .
2 .

.

(, )

43 .

- , ?
,
-

.
.
(-)
.
.
3 .
'- , *, ,
an
(23 ) (8 ).

.

4.

(b)

B'lg=Balg, Balgh, Balk, Balkh; B'lgar(in)= Balgar, Balghar, Balhar(a), Balkar, Balkhar
B'lg=Bolg, Bolgh, Bolk, Bolkh;
Bolgar, Bolghar, Bolhar,
Bolkar, Bolkhar
B'lg=Bulg, Bulgh, Bulk, Bulkh;
Bulgar, Bulghar, Bulhar,
Bulkar, Bulkhar
Kuh-e Balghar b
Balgari, Balgarka
Balghar
Balgar_i
ar
Kuh-e Balgi
Balgartschewo
Balgi
Bani
i
Balkeh
eh
Chureh
Balkeh Sar
Bolghan ~
Bolghan
Kochan
an
Bolghar (, b)
Bolgar Kosuy
Bolghar
Bolgar Kosuy
ar
Chay
Bolgur
Gora Bolgarka
Bolgur
ur
Cham_ur_li
Bulgan ~, +
Bulgarka
Bulgan
Kochan
an
Bulghan
Bulgaria, Bulgaristan Bulghan
Kochan
an
Bulquri
Bulgari
Bulguri
ur_i
Cham_ur_li

Duchia
Cham-i- Duchiyah

Doli (b) Pik

Dolla'i
Dolli (b)
Dolu +
Dul ~, ~b
Dulak
Dulakan
Dulama
Dulan (Khani)
Dulatabad**, ~+
Dulay
Dula ~, ~b
Gora Dulcha-Dag

Duch- Duchi Bulgar, Doch


Duchowez
Duchiya
Duchowez
Duchiya

Dolie
Dolie
Dulovo

Dulovo

Dul= Dulu, Dulo, Dolu, Dolo*


Doli
Dolla
Dolli
Dolu
Dul
Dulak
Dulakan
Dulama
Dulan
Dulat**
Dulai

chiya
chiya

Kamchiya,Pamukch
iya
Kamchiya,Pamukch
iya

i
la
li
u

Balgari
Cham_la
Barakli
Dolu, Kututsu

ak

Kochak

ma

Koch_ma_lar_e
Kochan
Kovat K'oy
Glaschatai, Dolni
Kray jena
Kula,
Dim_cha,
Dalak_cha

an
at
ai

Dula

Dulch

cha

Duleh Sar
Kuh-e Dulgir
Duli ~, +
Duliaban
Kuh-e Dulik
Duliskan ~
Dulkan
Dullu
Dulu
Dulyatabad ~+

Koopkan
Kop , +
Kopa , ~+, ~b
Kopchi ~+, ~b
Kopi ~+, ~b
Kupak
Kupan
Kupen +, b
Kuper ~
Kuh-i- Kupi ~+
Kupkan

Dulovo
Dulgeri
Dulovo

Dulovo
Dulovo
Dulovo
Dulovo

Duleh
Dulgeri
Duli
Duliya
Dulik
Duli
Dul
Dullu
Dulu
Dulat**

Kup- Kupi Bulgar, Kop, Kopi


Kop
Kop
Kopadan Dere
Kopa
Kopchali
Kopchi
Kopilovo, Kopeni
Kopi
Kupak
Kupena
Kupan
Kupena, Koupena
Kupen
Kupena
Kuper
Kupi
Kup

eh
ger_i

ik
i

Chureh
Kutuger_tsi
Balgari
Blgariya
Chernik
Balgari

lu
u
at

Kut_lu_dzha
Dolu, Kututsu
Kovat K'oy

Kula, jena
Sandakchi
Balgari
Kochak
Kochan
Blgarene,
Ograjden
Koch_er_in_ov_o
Balgari

i
iya

chi

i
ak

an
en
er

Kot- Kotragi, Kotra


Kotra

Kotra ~

Kuch- Kuchi Bulgar, Koch, Kochi


Kochan , b
Kochan
Kochan
an
Kuh-e Kocheksar Kocheklari, Kochak Kochek
ek
Kocheri ~b
Kocherinovo
Kocherin
er_in
Kochi ~, ~b
Kochevo
Kochi
i
Kuchalk
Kochak
Kuchal
al
Kuchar ~
Kuchkar
Kuchar
ar
Kuchenan
Kuchenan
en_an
Kuchi (,+,~b)
Kuchina
Kuchi
i
Chal ~+
Kuchu
Kuchuk Belova
Kuchi
i
Kuchungari
Kuchina
Kuchun
un
Kut- Kuti guri=Kutri guri, Kot, Koti, Gut, Guti**
Gutay
Kutai
ai
Gutin
Gutu

Kutino
Kutino

Kutin
Kuti

Kochan
Kochek_lar (i)
Koch_er_in_ov_o
Balgari
Chukal_a,
Chernal_evo
Kuchkar
Ograjden, Kochan
Balgari
Balgari

Sladun

in

Glaschatai, Dolni
Kray
Blgarin

Balgari

Kotak
Kuh-e Kotal
Kotalli
Kotiabad ~+
Kotich ~b
Kotik Pass
Kotlar ~+, b
Kotur +
Kutabad ~+
Kutak
Kutan
Kutar Pass
Kutena ~
Kuteyan
Kutgurg
Kuti , +, ~b
Kuti (, +, ~b) Sar
Kutian
Kutir
Kutiyan
Kutli , +
Kutmar ~
Kutna ~+
Kuttal
Kutur ~

Onar
unak ~
Unar
Unareni ~
Unik ~
Kuh-e Uninak
Uniyat ~, ~+

Urachi !
`Uraki
Uran
Urchan
Urchi ~
Urchini ~

Kot'ya
Kotich_in
Kotlari

Kutugeron
Kutino
Kutovo, Onogur
Kutino
Kutino
Kutugeron
Kutludzha
Kutina
Kutugertsi
Kututsi, Kutugeron

Kotak
Kotal
Kotalli
Kotia
Kotich
Kotik
Kotlar
Kotur
Kut
Kutak
Kutan
Kutar
Kutena
Kuteya, Kutien
Kut
Kuti
Kuti
Kutian
Kutirya
Kutiya
Kutli
Kutmar
Kutna
Kutal
Kutur

ak

al
al_li
iya
ich

ik
lar
ur
ak

an
ar

en
eya
gur

i
i

an
ir_iya
iya

li
mar
na

al
ur

On- Ono guri= Un guri, Unoguri , Ona, Una, Uno


Onogar, Onogur
Onar
ar
Yunak
Unak
ak
Unirya, Unirea,
Unar
ar
Yuner Unirea
Unirya,
Unareni
en
Unik
ik
Uninak
in_ak
Unirya
Uniya_at
iya_at
Ur- Ur guri, Uri
Urgari
Orach, Uraevitsa
Urachi
ach
(a,o,i)
Urak
ak
Oranovo, Yuren
Uran
an
Orchanie,
Uran_an
an
Orchanowo
Orchenlar
Urchin
in
Urchini

in_ni

Kochak
Chukal_a,
Chernal_evo
Chukal_a,
Barakli
Blgariya
Dobrich
Chernik
Kochular
Chamur_li
Kochak
Kochan
Balgar
Blgarene,
Blgareni
Balaleya
Onogur, Ungur_i_te
Balgari
Balgari
Kochan
Unirya
Blgariya
Barakli
Kochmar
Kutina
Chernalevo
Chamur_li

Balgar_i
Kochak
Balgar_i
Blgarene,
Blgareni
Chernik
Edinak_ov_tsi
Zlatiyata,Ostriyat
Kamuk

Kosacha
Kochak
Kochan
Kochan
Blgarin
Blgarin

Urdan ~
Urdan ~
Ureban
Uri , ~U
Kuh-e Urin
Urlik ~
Urma , ~U, ~b
Urmia
Urta Bolagh
Urya
Uryat ~

Urdin Tsirkus
Urdini Ezera,
Urdoviza
Urovene
Urovene, Orisari

Urdan
dan,
Kopadan, Kopadina
din
Urdan
dan
Kopadan
Blgarene
Ure
e
Uri
Balgari
i
Urin
Blgarin
in
Urlar
Ur_li_ik
li_ ik Barakli, Chernik
Ormachevo
Urma
Koch_ma_lar_e
ma
Urma_iya
ma_iya Blgariya
Yurta, Orta Makhle Urta
ta
Ogosta, Pozlata
Ortadzhi
Urya
Burya, Gurnya
ya
Urya_at
Kovat K'oy
at
Ut- Utu guri, Utri guri, Utii
Utali
Otalkioj
Utali
Skali, Mahali
al_i
Utan
Otantsi
Utan
Kochan
an
Utar
Utar
Balgar_i
ar
Uterabad ~
Yute Makhle
Uter
Koch_er_in_ov_o
er
216 ,
68 ,

eh (It, 12pt)

al (13 pt)
iya (bold, 12pt)

ik (bold, 13pt)

. .

ek(It,1
.

.
er(b,

13pt) .
en(b,It
.

,
Kutgurg
Kutovo, Onogur
Kut
gur
Onogur, Ungur_i_te
Kuh-e Dulgir
Dulgeri
Dulgeri
ger_tsi Kutugertsi
Kotich
Kotich_in
Kotich
ich
Dobrich
4:
- (, , ,
( )) ,
- ( ).
.
-
- ,
,
, . 68 ,
.
- , :
kuh- ,
chal- (, )
abad- ,
khan- ()
sar- , , ..

ban- ( , )

(GIS)
* O U , .
O U . Dulo= Dolo
..
**Dulat . , Dulatabad
. ( dulat
-at) () !

( ).
*** K G
Ku Gu ( )
. Gutiru= Kutiru ..
- ,
. ~
,
U- U ,
. ~U ,

781 ( ,
) , (,
, , ..).
, .
,
:
()
(). V .. ..
(1994) , -
, - ( )
- .
- (2002) .
, - .

( ) IV-III
( , 1955; .., 1948).
(2002).
, ()
,
(, 2002 ) .
. .

. 1 .
K , (), x, k- , B- , n- , O- , m- , u-
L- .

:
1. -
-
(, 2002) ,
, - ( )
. ,
() - ,
(, 1946, (1925),
(1994), , 1998, 2001, 2002-, ; ., (2002-, )). ,
()
. , V- IV .
. . .

.

. 5 500 . . .
, , , , ,
, (.2,3).
- , -
, .
(, 2004).
.2.

(IE),
(Ba)
(U) 5500 . .
Kalevi Wiik (1999) Europes
oldest language.

.3:
(IE)
5500 . . .
(B),
(C), - (FU),
(G), (I)
(S) 5500-3000
. . . Kalevi Wiik
(1999)
Europes
oldest
language.




( ., 2005).

()
(). V .. ..
(1994) , -
, - ( )
- .
- .
,
. (. 4) IV-III
( , 1955). 2478 . . . (
) (Hilprecht, 1910)
125 (, 1948). (Matheson, 2001),
2500 . . . ( ),
.
8-10 . . .
( , 1955).
(), VI-IV . .
. (, 2001),
Shopov et al. (1996) 5600-5500 . . .
. -
2
(Hilprecht, 1910), , magur (- )
, .
, , .. ,
( ).
() (2478 . . .)
.
, (Hilprecht, 1910).

. 4. IV-III . . . (1955)
, ,
, .. .
. -
( ) - (2354 .
. . ). ,
- .
, .. .
, 12 . - a
() Matheson (2001).


: - ,
. - 3 , 2 :
() 27- . .. 5000 100 .
.
(Bell, 2003).
, . . ( )
(Laessoe, 1963).
. ,
(Izady, 2004). 27- . ..
1000 100 . ()
, -
. (Kramer,
1987).
.
2354 . ..
(, 1948). .
(, 1948).
.
,
, (Hallo, 1957).
V (3200-3000 . .
.) VI (3500-3200 . . .) (Izady, 2004), III (3900-3000 . . .)
-IV (3300-1800 . . .). III ,
() (Matheson, 2001).
, III IV . . .
(, 2003).
, . - IVc (33002900 . . .) (Matheson, 2001).
V (3200-3000 . . .)
XIX - ,
, .
().
(Matheson, 2001).
(Matheson, 2001) (Nissen, (1986), Schmandt-Besserat, (1986)).
.
1696 . . . (Laessoe, 1963).

XV . . . . (, 2001, 2003).
,
- .
(Parpola, 1970).
( - ).

2. .

, ,
( (1996) -
) , .
. .
, , ,
( , XIX XX , 1974).
,
- (Saidi, 2001).
3 - ,
.
.

1.

III (338
. . .). (. . . )

2.
- (465 . . .).
6 (
5
) (. . . )

. 5.
(),
(Kazwini, 1283).

(VI . . .)
,
.

3.
1100 .
. (
) 539 .
. . (Oppenheim, 1969)
( 1971- . 2500-
).
.
,
( 1). ( 2)
4 - .

,
(Saidi, 2001).
, 28- , ..
.
( 1), .

(),
(Kazwni, 1283) (. 5) 1283 .
- .

. 23
. ,
, 3
, ..
.
,
-
21 2004 . 10-
. (1141-1209 )
:

. ,
, . ,
(331 . . .). -
-
( ),
-, -
.
(. 6-9).
2 .
(. 8) (. 9)
(. 6) (. 7).
.
. - 2

(, , 2001).
, ,
.
.

. 6. Matheson (2001).

. 7. Matheson (2001).

. 8.
.
, (, 1977).


.

I (.6).

. 9.
.


.

II (. 7.f).

3. - (260 . . .)
. ( )
( ).
(. . . )

. 10. - (260 . . .)
Saidi (2001).
.
- ( 3, .10) - !
( 4)
1 .

4. 1
.
. .
(. . . )

.
, ( , ).

( - 22
2003 ). .

.
, ,
.
:
8-10 . . .
.
( , 1955),
(, , , , , , , , ..).
,
(Vernesi et al., 2004).
,

.
(2004). ,
-
,
( ), - 3900 . . .
( ., 2005).

.
, ,
(Calafell et al. , 1996).

.
, ..
- ,
..
2002 .
.
,
(
) (
) Y- .
, Y- .
,
. ( ).
( ) - 1. (

) 2. (

). -,
(HG). ,
Y-
. ( ) 10 000
, 150 000
( ) .
. - .
- .
.
( U), - ( U7).
Q #2 (- ) -
Q #2 , .
, , .
(Faux, personal communication).

Pakistan [Hazara]
Isfahan, Iran
Bulgaria
Tehran, Iran
Brussels, Belgium
Turkey
Budapest, Hungary
Munster, Westphalia
Gdansk, Northern Poland

%
4.35
2.08
1.64
1.25
.80
.63
.51
.51
.18

5. Q #2
G #10
G10 (2.48 %) (Faux, personal
communication). .

.11. U7 Quintana-Murci et al. (2004).


(#) U7 ().

.12 ,
(, , , ..),
. ().
,
- , (2003)

. 13 K ,
Quintana-Murci (2004)
: west Eurasian ( HV, pre-HV, N1, J-T, U-K, I, W,
X), South Asian (M*, U2a-c, U9, R*, R1-R2, R5-R6, N1d, HV2), east Eurasian (M-CDGZ, A, B, F,
and N9a) sub-Saharan African (L1, L2, and L3A). U7
,
( - ) .

U7 .
U7 -.

:
/ - Armenians (AM), Turks (TR), Kurds (KR) Richards et al.
(2000); Turks (TT) Tambets et al. (2000); Kurds (KC) Comas et al. (2000), PersianCentral and southern central Iran (PE), Gilaki-Northern Iran (GI), Kurdish-Western Iran (KI),
Lur-Southwestern Iran(Zagros Mountains) (LU), Turkish-Anatolia (AN), Turkish-Azerbaijan
(TI),
/ - Iraqis (IQ), Palestinians (PL), and Druze (DZ),
Egyptians (EG).
/- Pakistanis (PK), Baluch-Southwestern Pakistan (BA), BrahuiSouthwestern Pakistan (BR), Parsi-Southeastern Pakistan (PA), Sindhi-Southeastern Pakistan
(SI), Pakistani-Southeastern Pakistan (KA), Hazara-Balochistan Pakistan (HZ), MakraniSouth Pakistan (MK), Kalash- Pakistan (KL), Hunza Burusho-Northern Pakistan (HU),
Indians (IN) Andhra Pradesh (AP), Uttar Pradesh (UP), Gujarati-Northwestern India (GJ),
- Uighur (UG), Uzbek (UZ),
- Basques(BS), Sicilians (SC), Bulgarians (BL), Italians-Tuscany (TS),
Sardinians (SD).
U7 : Armenians
(AM), Turks (TR), Kurds (KR) Richards et al. (2000); Turks (TT) Tambets et al.
(2000); Kurds (KC) Comas et al. (2000), Gilaki-Northern Iran (GI), Kurdish-Western Iran
(KI), Lur-Southwestern Iran(Zagros Mountains) (LU), Pakistanis (PK), Sindhi-Southeastern
Pakistan (SI), Brahui-Southwestern Pakistan (BR), Makrani-South Pakistan (MK), KalashPakistan (KL), Hunza Burusho-Northern Pakistan (HU), Indians (IN) Andhra Pradesh
(AP), Uttar Pradesh (UP), Gujarati-Northwestern India (GJ), Uighur (UG), Sicilians (SC),
Egyptians (EG), Iraqis (IQ), Palestinians (PL)
U7 : PersianCentral and southern central Iran (PE), Turkish-Anatolia (AN), Turkish-Azerbaijan (TI), Druze
(DZ), Baluch- Southwestern Pakistan (BA), Parsi-Southeastern Pakistan (PA), PakistaniSoutheastern Pakistan (KA), Hazara-Balochistan Pakistan (HZ), Uzbek (UZ), Basques(BS),
Italians-Tuscany(TS), Sardinians (SD)
11 , U7 7
(. , , .), 3 (
), 3 (, ),
, , , , .
100%
(.12, 13)
(, 2003; ., 2005a).
.
.. , ..
- - , ( ., 2005).
(
, ) VII . . .

(, 2003),
( , ).
, ( , 1956).
.
, ( ) XV . . .
:
,
(. 2),
. (
mother), , (- , 1983).
, ..

(, 2003). .
(, 1943) - (
, 1971), - .
' , -
. .
43 , , .
,
.
. cingar (, , )
. , -
(, 1943)

.
( )
, .
, . 2.
,
-,
- .

. , ; - , ;
(
(, 1943)), , (Steingass, 1892).
- 52 7 ,
3 . .
47 , .
- .
,
(-) . 2. (
- () . 2), ,
(Steingass, 1892). ,
, .

(, ) -
.
781 , (
12 ). 216 ,
(.3).
- (.3)
.
,
.
. , ..
(, ).
4
, . ,
( Dulat)
.
4
. ,
.
( ., ).


IV-
. . (Ilinkina, 1994).
.
- ( , 1955),
(, , , , , , , ,
..). .
( , 1948))
(Laessoe, 1963).

.
.
, .
10 . -
(, 1976).

?
6. (
, 2007)
~3900 . ..
2478. ..*
2478-2354 . ..*
2354 . ..*

() . (
)
()

() .

1696 . ..
539 . ..
VI- IV . ..
I . ..-II . ..
119 . .. ?
?
165 . .. ?


,


, -

(
) ( )

:
,
,
. -

(. , 2001) .


(). .
25 .
- .
(, .. )
(
).
- .
XXI .
.
,
, ,
,
, ,
.
:
..(1948) . , , .63-65.
. .- : . . ., 1967,
237-247.
. (2001) . (). ,
, 280 .
(1971), .1, - , , , 679 .
(1955), .1, .. (. ) , , .214222, 530-1, 594

.. (1946) , .1
.,, ., . 2037
.. (2002) - ( .
).
:
, 15 16 2002 ., , .6.
http://www.seedot.com/esf/historyconference.html
. (1994) . -, , .26
. .. (2001) . ,
, 289 .
(1976) 1: 2 500 000.
, .
(1981), .2, . . , 505 .
- . (1958) .. , , 1080 .
.. (2003)
.- 50 - . ,
, .46, I, , , .1-7.
.. (1977) , ., , 232 .
. (1925) , . V, . 323-372.
. (1943) , , ,
. , , 316 .
M., . ( )
. . :
, 15 16
2002., .
. (2002) .-
:
, 15 16
2002., , 11-12. Nissen H. (1986) The Development of Writing and of
Glyptic Art, in U. Finkbeiner and W. Rlling, eds., Gamdat Nasr: Period or Regional Style?
(Wiesbaden: Reichert, 1986)
(1996) -
, 7. X. 1995 ., , ,
1996, .
- (1983) , 60 000 .
. (2002)
.- . , .18, . 44-54.
, XIX XX
(1974), . , , 606 .
. (1900) ( ).
. , 1900 ,
, , 1972 ., 424 .
- (1945) 40 000 ( . ..). II ., ,
,704 .

. (2004) . . , ,
, . , , 116 .
. (2002) .-
:
, 15 16
2002., , 14-15.
. . (1998) -
- :- . , ,
, .179-183
. . (2000) - . : 2000:
, 1- 2 2000 , .
. . (2001) -
.
http://tribal.abv.bg/shopov/tradicia.htm
. . (2002) -
.- :


, 15
16 2002., , 9-10.
http://www.seedot.com/esf/historyconference.html
., . , . (2002)
.
:
, 15 16 2002., , .8.
http://www.seedot.com/civilization/bigprogram.html
.., .., . , . , . (2002)

.- . , .19, . 21- 30.
. . (2002) .
.-
:
, 15 16
2002., , .24-5.
http://www.seedot.com/esf/historyconference.html
. . (2003) -
.- 22 2003 ,
. .,
, .1 (1), . 40-44
. ., . , . , . , . , . (2005)
: ,
. - . " , . ,
, . 241- 251.
. ., ., (2005) . -
.
; : ,

.-
- , 18- 20 , 2004 .
, , . 31-46
. . (2007)
-
10-
. ,
, .1 (1), 24-34
. . (2007)
. , .1 (2), .3-47
. ., . (2007) (
) , .1 (1), 53-56
. ., . , . , ., . , , . , (2008)
, . -
10-
. , Annali,
v.15, 2-4, pp.104-115
. (1941) .- ,
1940/1941, 2, 103- 114.
Bell, J.W. (2003) Sumerian Cities. http://www.jameswbell.com/geog004sumeriancities
Calafell F, Underhill P, Tolun A, Angelicheva D, Kalaydjieva L (1996) From Asia to Europe:
mitochondrial DNA sequence variability in Bulgarians and Turks. Annals of Human Genetics
60:35-49
Comas D, Calafell F, Benchemsi N, Helal A, Lefranc G, Stoneking M, Batzer MA, Bertranpetit
J, Sajantila A (2000) Alu insertion polymorphisms in NW Africa and the Iberian Peninsula:
evidence for a strong genetic boundary through the Gibraltar Straits. Hum Genet 107:312319
Hallo W. (1957) Gutium, in Reallexicon der Assyrologie III, Berlin and New York, 1957-71,
pp.708- 720.
Hilprecht H.V. (1910) The Earliest Version of the Babylonian Deluge Story and the Temple
Library of Nippur. University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia. 65 p.
Ilinkina V. (1994) Code knowledge on clay figures of prehistoric age in Bulgaria.- VI-th World
Congress of Scientific Acupuncture in the Framework of Modern Medicine. ICMART94,
Istambul, 2- 5 Jume 1994 (ed. by M. Abut), p. 56
Izady M. (2004) Evidence for the Worlds earliest Beer and Wine making in Kurdistan.
http://www.kurdistanica.com/english/history/archeology/arch-articles/arch-articles-04.html
Kramer N. (1987) Ancient Sumer and Iran: Gleanings from Sumerian Literature, Bulletin of
the Asia Institute, I
Laessoe, Jorgen (1963) People Of Ancient Assyria Translated from the Danish by F. S. LeighBrowne- Assyrian International News Agency. Books Online. www.aina.org
Matheson S.A (2001) Persia - An Archeological Guide. Yassavoli Publications, Tehran, 204 p.
Oppenheim L. (1969) Babylonian and Assyrian Historical Texts Relating to the Old Testament.
3-rd edition, Princeton, 1969, pp. 265-317.
Parpola S. (1970) Neo-Assyrian Toponyms, Alter Orient und Altes Testament 6, Kevelaer
Quintana-Murci L., Raphaelle Chaix, R. Spencer Wells, Doron M. Behar,Hamid Sayar,
Rosaria Scozzari, Chiara Rengo, Nadia Al-Zahery, Ornella Semino, A. Silvana SantachiaraBenerecetti, Alfredo Coppa, Qasim Ayub, Aisha Mohyuddin, Chris Tyler-Smith, S. Qasim

Mehdi, Antonio Torroni, and Ken McElreavey (2004) Where West Meets East: The Complex
mtDNA Landscape of the Southwest and Central Asian Corridor.- Am. J. Hum. Genet., 74:827845
Richards M , V Macaulay , E Hickey , E Vega , B Sykes , V Guida , C Rengo , D Sellitto , F
Cruciani , T Kivisild , R Villems , M Thomas , S Rychkov , O Rychkov , Y Rychkov , M Glge ,
D Dimitrov , E Hill , D Bradley , V Romano , F Cal , G Vona , A Demaine , S Papiha , C
Triantaphyllidis , G Stefanescu , J Hatina , M Belledi , A Di Rienzo , A Novelletto , A
Oppenheim , S Nrby , N Al-Zaheri , S Santachiara-Benerecetti , R Scozari , A Torroni , H J
Bandelt (2000). Tracing European founder lineages in the Near Eastern mtDNA pool. Am J Hum
Genet. 2000 Nov ;67 (5):1251-76
Rosser Z. H., Tatiana Zerjal, Matthew E. Hurles, Maarja Adojaan, Dragan Alavantic,
Antnio Amorim, William Amos, Manuel Armenteros, Eduardo Arroyo, Guido Barbujani,
Gunhild Beckman, Lars Beckman, Jaume Bertranpetit, Elena Bosch, Daniel G. Bradley,
Gaute Brede, Gillian Cooper, Helena B. S. M. Crte-Real, Peter de Knijff, Ronny Decorte,
Yuri E. Dubrova,
Oleg Evgrafov,
Anja Gilissen,
Sanja Glisic,
Mukaddes Glge,
Emmeline W. Hill, Anna Jeziorowska, Luba Kalaydjieva, Manfred Kayser,
Toomas Kivisild, Sergey A. Kravchenko, Astrida Krumina, Vaidutis Kuinskas, Joo Lavinha,
Ludmila A. Livshits, Patrizia Malaspina, Syrrou Maria, Ken McElreavey, Thomas A. Meitinger,
Aavo- Valdur Mikelsaar, R. John Mitchell, Khedoudja Nafa, Jayne Nicholson, Sren Nrby,
Arpita Pandya, Jri Parik, Philippos C. Patsalis, Lusa Pereira, Borut Peterlin, Gerli Pielberg,
Maria Joo Prata, Carlo Previder, Lutz Roewer, Siiri Rootsi, D. C. Rubinsztein, Juliette Saillard,
Fabrcio R. Santos, Gheorghe Stefanescu, Bryan C. Sykes, Aslihan Tolun, Richard Villems,
Chris TylerSmith, Mark A. Jobling (2000). Y-Chromosomal Diversity in Europe Is Clinal and
Influenced Primarily by Geography, Rather than by Language. Am. J Hum. Genet., 67: 1526
1543.
Saidi F. (2001) A Guide to Persepolis, Pasagardae and Naghshe- Rostam. Behdid publishers,
Tehran, 192 p.
Schmandt-Besserat, D. (1986) An Ancient Token System: The Precursor to Numerals and
Writing, Archaeology (November/December 1986)
Shopov Y.Y., L.Tsankov, L.N.Georgiev, A.Damyanova, Y. Damyanov, E. Marinova, D.C.
Ford, C.J.Yonge, W. MacDonald, H.P.R.Krouse (1996) Speleothem Luminescence proxy
Records of Annual Rainfall in the Past. Evidences for "The Deluge" in Speleothems."- in book
"Climatic Change- the Karst Record", Ed. by S.E. Lauritzen. KWI , Bergen, p. 155-156
http://www.karst.edu.cn/igcp/igcp379/1997/part3-4-3.htm
http://www.glnet.edu.cn/IGCP379/1997/part343.htm
Steingass F.J. (1892) Comprehensive Persian- English Dictionary.
http://dsal.uchicago.edu/dictionaries/steingass/
Tambets et al. (2000) The topology of the maternal lineages of the Anatolian and TransCaucasus populations and the peopling of Europe: preliminary conclusions. In: Renfrew C,
Boyle K (eds) Archaeogenetics: DNA and the population prehistory of Europe. McDonald
Institute for Archaeological Research Monograph Series, Cambridge University, Cambridge,
United Kingdom, pp 219235

Vernesi C., David Caramelli, Isabelle Dupanloup, Giorgio Bertorelle, Martina Lari,
Enrico Cappellini, Jacopo Moggi Cecchi, Brunetto Chiarelli, Loredana Castr, Antonella Casoli,
Francesco Mallegni, Carles Lalueza-Fox, and Guido Barbujani (2004), The Etruscans: A
Population-Genetic Study. The American Journal of Human Genetics, volume 74, page 694-704
Zakarija ben Muhammed ben Mahmd El-Kazwni's Kosmographie (1283), Fuess Verlag,
Leipzig, Jahr: 1868;
Zakaria Kazvini (1283), Kosmographie, Leipzig, 1985

You might also like