Professional Documents
Culture Documents
This Digital C Opy Is Brough Ttoyouby
This Digital C Opy Is Brough Ttoyouby
u
o
y
o
t
t
h
g
u
o
r
b
s
i
y
p
o
c
l
a
t
This digi
0.53
0.50
STI 3353.45
14.59
RM/USD 3.8044
CPO RM2190.00
5.00
OIL US$57.10
0.41
GOLD US$1131.90
PP 9974/08/2013 (032820)
PENINSULAR MALAYSIA RM1.60 (INCLUSIVE OF 6% GST)
FINANCIAL
DAILY
MAKE
BETTER
DECISIONS
www.theedgemarkets.com
4 HOME BUSINESS
Exciting times
ahead for Taliworks
4 HOME BUSINESS
Signature
International
growing from
strength to strength
67 HOME BUSINESS
10 stock picks
in current
weak market
8 HOME BUSINESS
Greek banks to
reopen, PMs new
cabinet takes over
12.00
ON EDGE T V
www.theedgemarkets.com
Analysts see
limited upside
for Maxis
earnings
The site has not been accessible from Malaysia since yesterday evening, though it could
still be accessed through proxy
servers.
Sarawak Reports editor and
founder Clare Rewcastle-Brown
was planning to issue a statement on the matter at press time.
The Malaysian Insider
IN BRIEF
Taiwans KMT picks
pro-China Hung for
presidential race
TAIPEI: Taiwans ruling Kuomintang (KMT) officially endorsed pro-China candidate
Hung Hsiu-chu yesterday to
run for president next year, as
the deeply divided party faces
a battle to regain public support. Known as xiao-la-jiao
or little hot pepper for her
straight-talking style, Hung is
one of two main female presidential candidates, in elections
likely to see the countrys first
woman leader voted in. But
Hungs conservative views fly
in the face of voter sentiment as
fears grow over increased Beijing influence. Concern about
the islands warming ties with
China was one reason behind
the Beijing-friendly KMTs rout
in November local elections, a
barometer for the presidential
vote next January. AFP
Netanyahu urges US
to hold out for a better
Iran deal
WASHINGTON: Israeli Prime
Minister Benjamin Netanyahu
urged US lawmakers to hold
out for a better Iran deal and
said there was no way to compensate Israel if the nuclear
agreement goes through. I
think the right thing to do is
merely not to go ahead with this
deal. There are many things to
be done to stop Irans aggression and this deal is not one
of them, Netanyahu said on
CBS Face the Nation as he
continued a string of US media
interviews denouncing the deal
reached last Tuesday between
Iran and six major powers. The
deal must be reviewed by Congress, where lawmakers will
have up to 82 days to decide
whether to reject it. AFP
4 HOME BUSINESS
Lim (left) and Chin. Lim says the company hopes to achieve double-digit net prot
increase through organic growth and future acquisitions. Photo by Patrick Goh
KUALA LUMPUR: Signature International Bhd is set to end its financial year ended June (FY15) with
a record net profit, having already
surpassed earnings for the whole of
FY14 in the second quarter ended
December 2014 (2QFY15).
Analysts expect the kitchen system designer and distributors net
profit to continue to gain traction
over the next two years on the back
of a tender book totalling some
RM400 million.
An analyst at a local brokerage
said Signature is currently bidding
for RM400 million worth of jobs,
including Phase 2 of the Battersea Power Station project (BSP2)
in London and Chinas Country
Garden condominium project in
Iskandar Malaysia, Johor.
The tender bid winner for the
BSP2 kitchen work job, which is estimated to be worth around RM20
million to RM30 million, is expected to be known by the middle of
next year.
The kitchen job contract for the
Country Garden condominium
8 HOME BUSINESS
BY TA N A I L EN G
From left: Mah Sing commercial COO Andy Chua, The Edge Communications managing director Au Foong Yee, Mah Sing marketing and
special projects deputy general manager Rachel Leong, Ng, Ho, Mah Sing corporate communications general manager LyannaTew and
The Edge Media Group senior managing editor Azam Aris during the ocial launch of The Edge-Mah Sing Millionaire Contest.
theedgeproperty.com.
The contest is open to all Malaysians and permanent residents in
Malaysia as well as Singaporeans
and permanent residents in Singapore aged 21 years and above.
Participants must register at theedgeproperty.com and use the
Fair Value tool before moving on to
the dedicated contest page on Mah
Sings website, where they will have
to take part in several online games
and activities to collect tokens.
P R O P E RT Y S NA P S H
T 9
Source: theedgeproperty.com
The Analytics are based on the data available at the date of publication and may be subject to further revision as
and when more data is made available to us.
For more of such information across Malaysia and Singapore, log on to the
theedgeproperty.com. The one-stop portal for all your property needs,
theedgeproperty.com oers price and transaction records, trend analysis,
research classieds, and more all for FREE!
Source: theedgeproperty.com
UK house prices
jump 1.7%
BY J IL L WA R D & S COT T H A MILTO N
10 ST O C KS W I T H M O M E N T U M
This column is an analysis done by Asia Analytica Sdn Bhd on the fundamentals of stocks with momentum that were picked up using proprietary algorithm by
Anticipatory Analytics Sdn Bhd and that rst appeared at www.theedgemarkets.com. Please exercise your own judgment or seek professional advice for your specic
investment needs. We are not responsible for your investment decisions. Our shareholders, directors and employees may have positions in any of the stocks mentioned.
Financials
Turnover
EBITDA
Interest expense
Pre-tax prot
Net prot - owners of company
Fixed assets - PPE
Total assets
Shareholders' fund
Gross borrowings
Net debt/(cash)
DPS ($)
Net asset per share ($)
ROE (%)
Turnover growth (%)
Net prot growth (%)
Net margin (%)
ROA (%)
Current ratio (x)
Gearing (%)
Interest cover (x)
Financials
Turnover
EBITDA
Interest expense
Pre-tax prot
Net prot - owners of company
Fixed assets - PPE
Total assets
Shareholders' fund
Gross borrowings
Net debt/(cash)
DPS ($)
Net asset per share ($)
ROE (%)
Turnover growth (%)
Net prot growth (%)
Net margin (%)
ROA (%)
Current ratio (x)
Gearing (%)
Interest cover (x)
Financials
Turnover
EBITDA
Interest expense
Pre-tax prot
Net prot - owners of company
Fixed assets - PPE
Total assets
Shareholders' fund
Gross borrowings
Net debt/(cash)
DPS ($)
Net asset per share ($)
ROE (%)
Turnover growth (%)
Net prot growth (%)
Net margin (%)
ROA (%)
Current ratio (x)
Gearing (%)
Interest cover (x)
FY12
FY13
FY14
FY2015Q4
31/3/2012
31/3/2013
31/3/2014
31/3/2015
78.3
0.4
2.3
(9.4)
(9.2)
55.1
55.1
35.0
23.2
21.1
87.0
9.1
1.4
1.1
0.8
49.4
50.6
39.3
20.8
19.3
74.4
4.1
0.9
(4.5)
(3.6)
44.4
45.6
36.3
17.1
16.8
22.8
3.3
0.2
1.9
2.8
54.3
69.4
53.5
13.7
11.3
FY12
FY13
31/3/2012
31/3/2013
31/3/2014
0.33
(23.23)
(31.03)
(11.74)
(14.86)
0.82
60.21
0.18
0.38
2.11
11.06
0.90
1.48
1.04
49.08
6.50
0.35
(9.55)
(14.39)
(4.85)
(7.50)
1.04
46.16
4.84
0.51
7.91
7.71
3.86
6.23
1.48
21.16
8.90
FY12
FY13
FY14
FY2015Q1
31/12/2012
31/12/2013
31/12/2014
31/3/2015
603.3
124.4
0.6
121.1
90.7
113.9
495.4
479.9
(198.8)
548.4
118.6
0.4
114.0
85.2
123.5
552.6
537.0
(157.8)
604.7
109.5
0.4
103.2
76.9
120.3
611.5
596.0
(149.4)
186.5
28.0
0.1
26.3
19.6
121.8
630.7
615.6
(85.0)
FY12
FY13
31/12/2012
31/12/2013
31/12/2014
0.03
0.82
20.40
3.74
3.93
15.03
19.70
1.85
213.37
0.03
0.98
16.76
(9.09)
(6.05)
15.54
16.26
2.07
272.47
0.03
1.08
13.58
10.26
(9.71)
12.72
13.22
2.55
280.93
0.03
1.12
14.33
27.54
(2.38)
11.87
13.94
2.98
292.54
FY12
FY13
FY14
FY2015Q1
31/12/2012
31/12/2013
31/12/2014
31/3/2015
978.8
252.6
1.4
154.2
125.8
865.8
1,443.4
1,383.9
56.9
(242.3)
919.4
195.9
4.1
94.1
51.7
1,087.7
1,498.3
1,407.3
208.6
52.2
831.0
126.0
5.3
18.6
27.9
1,077.9
1,809.3
1,404.6
580.9
123.9
198.0
43.7
1.4
18.1
11.6
1,055.6
1,906.6
1,416.2
474.9
3.4
FY12
FY13
31/12/2012
31/12/2013
31/12/2014
0.66
2.94
8.34
5.47
(20.87)
12.85
8.00
1.76
180.45
0.08
2.99
3.70
(6.07)
(58.90)
5.62
3.51
0.79
3.71
47.80
0.07
2.99
1.98
(9.61)
(46.10)
3.35
1.68
1.39
8.82
23.64
0.07
3.01
1.49
(6.64)
(10.05)
2.55
1.33
1.77
0.24
24.22
1 2 I N V E ST I N G I D E A S
Note: This report is brought to you by Asia Analytica Sdn Bhd, a licensed investment adviser. Please exercise your own
judgment or seek professional advice for your specic investment needs. We are not responsible for your investment
decisions. Our shareholders, directors and employees may have positions in any of the stocks mentioned.
I N S I D E R A S I AS S TO C K O F T H E D AY
Insider Asia will feature a new stock pick on every alternate day.
Income Statement
Turnover
EBITDA
Depreciation
EBIT
Associates
Interest income
Interest expense
Extraordinary gain/(loss)
Pre-tax prot
Net prot - owners of company
Balance sheet
Fixed assets - PPE
Biological assets
Intangibles & goodwill
Cash and equivalents
Total current assets
ST borrowings
Total current liabilities
Total assets
Shareholders' fund
Long term borrowings
DPS ($)
Net asset per share ($)
ROE (%)
Turnover growth (%)
Net prot growth (%)
Net margin (%)
ROA (%)
Current ratio (x)
Gearing (%)
Interest cover (x)
FY12
FY13
FY14
FY2015Q4
29/2/2012
28/2/2013
28/2/2014
31/3/2015
217.0
25.6
6.4
19.1
0.5
0.3
0.1
19.4
15.8
279.4
46.6
6.1
40.5
(0.1)
0.7
0.5
1.3
42.0
34.4
306.9
54.7
5.5
49.2
(0.0)
0.6
0.7
0.9
50.0
38.8
100.4
23.7
1.6
22.2
0.1
0.3
0.2
(0.4)
22.0
19.2
72.1
5.4
29.7
149.9
7.1
43.9
189.5
185.5
1.6
75.0
5.3
38.3
202.0
10.7
73.2
211.7
204.0
2.8
74.1
5.3
47.5
241.5
12.4
99.4
223.3
220.7
1.0
80.2
4.9
67.5
226.6
12.5
76.8
238.0
230.9
0.8
FY12
FY13
29/2/2012
28/2/2013
28/2/2014
0.05
0.62
8.67
17.43
29.73
7.30
8.47
3.42
83.96
0.07
0.68
17.66
28.71
116.99
12.31
17.14
2.76
95.06
0.09
0.73
18.28
9.84
12.89
12.65
17.84
2.43
79.32
0.10
0.77
19.23
24.89
11.14
11.24
18.76
2.95
87.49
14 B R O K E R S C A L L
Maxis takes
conservative
dividend approach
AirAsia Bhd
FYE DEC (RM MIL)
Revenue
Ebitda
Ebit
PBT
Net profit
Core net profit
Core EPS (sen)
Core EPS growth (%)
PER (x)
Net dividend (sen)
2014
2015F
2016F
5,415.7
1,358.9
639.4
22.7
82.8
355.6
12.8
0.4
10.1
4.6
5,621.1
1,857.6
1,042.7
738.7
561.4
561.4
20.2
57.8
6.4
7.0
5,923.2
2,175.8
1,332.7
789.3
599.9
599.9
21.4
6.3
6.0
8.0
Maxis Bhd
(July 16, RM6.51)
Maintain hold with an unchanged
target price (TP) of RM7.19: Maxis Bhd continued to show a positive turnaround in the second
quarter of financial year ending
Dec 31, 2015 (2QFY15), but took
a conservative approach to dividends with a second interim dividend per share (DPS) of five sen
(1QFY15: five sen). We maintain
our hold rating on the stock as
we believe earnings forecast reratings are unlikely due to a more
competitive environment.
Maxis first-half (1HFY15) results
were within our and consensus expectations, as its core net profit of
RM922 million accounted for 47%
of our and consensus full-year estimates, respectively. Maxis declared
a second interim DPS of five sen
(85% payout), bringing year-to-date
(YTD) DPS to 10 sen (88% payout).
We maintain our FY15 (estimate)
DPS of 26 sen, in anticipation of a
special DPS in 4QFY15.
Maxis had a decent 2HFY15, as
service revenue grew 3.3% yearon-year (y-o-y) to RM4.22 billion,
mainly on good growth traction in
prepaid. Service revenue growth
would have been higher at 4.5%
y-o-y if not for three months or
RM50 million worth of free voice
and SMS given to prepaid users as
part of the goods and services tax
(GST) implementation. 1HFY15
net profit, however, was flattish
y-o-y at RM923 million due to
higher interest expense (+15.2%
Maxis Bhd
FYE DEC (RM MIL)
Revenue
Ebitda
Pre-tax profit
Net profit
EPS (sen)
PER (x)
Core net profit
Core EPS (sen)
Core EPS growth (%)
Core PER (x)
Net DPS (sen)
Dividend yield (%)
EV/Ebitda (x)
Affin/Consensus (x)
2013
2014
2015E
2016E
2017E
9,084.0
4,573.0
2,496.0
1,765.0
23.5
27.7
2,097.0
27.9
2.3
23.3
40.0
6.1
12.4
-
8,389.0
4,296.0
2,436.0
1,721.0
22.9
28.4
1,910.0
25.4
(8.9)
25.6
40.0
6.1
13.5
-
8,607.9
4,312.5
2,665.5
1,968.4
26.2
24.8
1,968.4
26.2
3.1
24.8
26.0
4.0
13.4
1.0
8,724.9
4,353.7
2,760.1
2,038.5
27.2
24.0
2,038.5
27.2
3.6
24.0
27.0
4.1
13.3
1.0
8,831.0
4,415.5
2,934.3
2,167.4
28.9
22.5
2,167.4
28.9
6.3
22.5
28.0
4.3
13.1
1.0
AirAsias valuation
remains attractive
AirAsia Bhd
(July 16, 18.5 sen)
Maintain buy with a lower target price (TP) of RM1.82: Since
December, AirAsia Bhds share
price has been languishing on
a barrage of bad news, most of
which we believe is caused by
external factors out of managements control. It started with the
unfortunate crash of QZ8501 in
December 2014, which we opine
is the worst thing that could happen for an airline.
When things were turning for
the better, the department of civil
aviation of Thailand came under
scrutiny by the International Civil Aviation Organization, which
prompted a review of flight permits imposed by countries like
Japan and South Korea.
Then came the earthquake
in Nepal, the Middle East respiratory syndrome outbreak in
South Korea, a review by the Indonesian ministry of transport
on airlines with negative equity
positions and ash cloud troubles
within the Indonesian archipelago causing a temporary closure
of several airports. Add in to the
mix a report by a foreign research
firm drawing attention to AirAsias receivables, and we arrive at
todays share price lower steeply by 52.6% year-to-date (YTD).
While not all of these events
had an impact on AirAsias operations directly, we believe that
both investor and customer sentiment has been dented for AirAsia
which was still recovering from
an intense competition from Malaysia Airlines (MAS).
Financial year ending Dec
31, 2015 (FY15) core earnings
forecasts have been reduced as
we impute a slower recovery in
yields and lower load factor. We
have reduced our yield growth
forecast for FY15 to -2% (from flat
growth). In addition, we are revising our load factor assumption
down to 78% (from: 81%) as the
impact of fuel surcharge removal
was milder than expected. As a
result, we have reduced our FY15
core earnings to RM561 million.
Value emerged from the selldown. AirAsia is currently trading
at an attractive valuation of 6.4
times forward FY15 price-earnings ratio (PER) and 0.79 times
price-to-book value. We believe
that the current share price has
priced in most of the negative
factors. At this juncture, we opine
that the major risk faced by AirAsia is an impairment of its receivables from associates amounting to RM1.2 billion which are
overdue.
However, we believe that the
possibility of a write-down is unlikely and will only be used if all
other options have been exhausted as impairment tests have been
conducted and the associates
remain a going concern.
Nevertheless, management is
actively working to alleviate this
risk through a sale and leaseback of 16 of its aircraft fleet
owned for RM1.5 billion, which
we believe should be completed
in the second half of 2015; and
issuance of convertible bonds
amounting to RM1 billion followed by the initial public offering of Indonesia AirAsia and
Philippines AirAsia.
We expect jet fuel prices to remain low in line with our house
view of crude oil prices of between US$60 (RM228) per barrel and US$70 per barrel for this
year. Additionally, the anticipated
rationalisation of routes by MAS
is starting to take shape with frequency reductions of between
20% and 50% to begin in August
on popular destinations such
as Kuala Lumpur (KL) to Hong
Kong, KL to Manila and KL to
Ho Chi Minh City, which would
benefit AirAsia through pricing
fares more profitably and securing higher load factors.
We maintain our buy call
on AirAsia as its business prospects are on the mend. Most
notably, forward ticket sales as
at July for the third quarter of
FY15 (3QFY15) and 4QFY15 have
been brisk at +18% year-on-year
for the group while forward load
factors are estimated at 80%, in
line with our latest forecasts for
the year.
Fuel expenses have come
down 9.2% y-o-y in 1QFY15 and
we are further expecting an improvement of 21% for FY15. Our
TP of RM1.82 is based on 9 times
forward PER to FY15 earnings
per share.
We have reduced our forward PER to 9 times (from 10
times) due to external factors.
In the worst-case scenario, we
believe that the floor price of
AirAsia should be at 1 times its
FY14 book value translating into
a share price of RM1.68 MIDF
Research, July 16
16 B R O K E R S C A L L
2014
2015
2016F
2017F
2018F
Total turnover
1,107
1,146
1,454
1,889
2,187
Reported net profit
233
210
263
352
422
Recurring net profit
233
210
263
352
422
(0.2)
(9.9)
25.4
33.8
19.9
Recurring net profit growth (%)
0.31
0.27
0.32
0.43
0.51
Recurring EPS (RM)
0.15
0.12
0.14
0.19
0.23
DPS (RM)
27.5
31.9
26.7
20.2
16.8
Recurring P/E (x)
6.86
5.46
4.77
4.24
3.85
P/BV (x)
25.8
32.4
14.7
14.3
14.3
P/CF (x)
1.7
1.4
1.7
2.2
2.7
Dividend yield (%)
18.1
21.7
16.3
12.4
10.3
EV/Ebitda (x)
27.3
19.0
19.1
22.2
24.0
Return on average equity (%)
Net cash Net cash Net cash Net cash Net cash
Net debt to equity (%)
Our vs consensus EPS
(7.6)
5.6
14.8
(adjusted) (%)
Source: Company data, RHB
Nitrile glove.
2013A
2014A
2015F
2016F
2017F
Revenue
35,857
Operating Ebitda
10,446
Net profit
5,356
0.96
Core EPS (RM)
19.9
Core EPS growth (%)
13.17
FD core PE (x)
0.25
DPS (RM)
1.97
Dividend yield (%)
8.01
EV/Ebitda (x)
53.5
P/FCFE (x)
35.1
Net gearing (%)
1.90
P/BV (x)
14.4
ROE (%)
CIMB/consensus EPS (x)
40,859
12,054
6,467
1.09
13.0
11.65
0.29
2.29
7.34
na
39.9
1.65
15.2
-
43,490
13,381
6,242
1.11
1.8
11.45
0.30
2.41
6.91
na
44.4
1.50
13.7
0.96
40,323
14,643
6,574
1.16
5.3
10.87
0.32
2.53
6.42
501.6
43.6
1.36
13.1
0.98
43,170
15,398
6,684
1.18
1.7
10.69
0.34
2.65
6.16
72.1
41.5
1.25
12.2
0.95
18 H O M E
New Hope
Movement is PAS
internal problem,
says Azmin
BY RA M A N A ND
SHAH ALAM: PKR has yet to discuss and come to any conclusion
about Gerakan Harapan Baru
(GHB), the splinter movement
from PAS, party deputy president
Mohamed Azmin Ali said. Mohamed Azmin, who is Selangor
menteri besar, told reporters at
the state governments open house
yesterday that he considers GHB
to be PAS internal affair and
refused to weigh in with his own
opinions on the matter.
This is not an issue about personal opinions. The party hasnt
discussed it, he said.
The splinter movement, formed
with the aim of starting a new political party, is led by progressive
PAS leaders who were axed in the
partys fractious muktamar last
month. Mohamed Azmins statement comes despite PKR secretary-general Rafizi Ramli saying
previously that he would support
GHB and speak at their roadshows.
Although Pakatan Rakyat has
ceased to exist at the national level,
the Selangor government has continued to function with the former
Pakatan framework. However, DAP
has said it will make a decision on
its state government participation
after discussions with Mohamed
Azmin, with no resolution to date.
I am confident the PAS leadership can resolve this matter amicably, so the people can see a
change through Pakatan Rakyat
in the next elections, he said.
The Malaysian Insider
shop caught the suspects and assaulted them before handing them
over to the plazas security guards
who called the police.
One of the suspects was later released and it was believed that he
returned to the plaza with his friends
and attacked the store where the employees had helped detain the suspects earlier.
The next day, some 200 people
congregated at the plaza, forcing
authorities to order businesses at
the premises to close early. Police
cordoned off the area, but a crowd
gathered again after midnight and
fights broke out. At least five people,
including media personnel, were
reportedly injured in the incident.
So far, Bagan Umno division head
Datuk Shaik Hussein Mydin, Papagomo and army veteran Mohd Ali Baharom, popularly known as Ali Tinju,
have been arrested.
Papagomo and Shaik Hussein
were released last Friday by police,
while Ali was charged with sedition
over racially charged comments
made before the brawl. He claimed
trial to the charge. The Malaysian
Insider
ing flight paths. If thats true, its unforgivable and so, yes, this is about
getting justice.
Lawyer Jerry Skinner from Sydney
law firm LHD Lawyers, acting for the
plaintiff and other victims families,
said they were asking the court to
define the list of what categories of
damages were available to make up
at least the US$113,100 in compensation. We are suggesting there is a
gap in the law which is what we are
seeking to fill, he reportedly said.
He also said MAS will not state
how they are calculating what they
offered to our client and the figures
are all low. The SMH said that MAS
did not appear to know the summons had been served. The airline
reportedly said in a statement: Malaysia Airlines has not been served
with any writ allegedly filed in the
NSW Supreme Court. The Malaysian Insider
On May 28, High Court Judge Vazeer Alam Mydin Meera told Abdul
Gani and the other defendants to file
their defence within 30 days. Abdul
Ganis counsel Tan Sri Cecil Abraham
had asked for more time and was
given until July 6. A second extension
given by Rosli expired on July 13. The
document sighted by The Malaysian
Insider revealed that the defendants
submitted the defence of bare denial.
Rosli and former commercial
crime investigation department chief
Datuk Ramli Yusuf filed lawsuits in
November 2013 against Abdul Gani
and the rest for, among others, al-
IN BRIEF
Over 30,000 attend Sabah
CM, Cabinet open house
KOTA KINABALU: More than
30,000 people called at the Aidilfitri open house hosted by
Sabah Chief Minister Datuk
Seri Musa Aman and the Sabah Cabinet yesterday. Sabah
Yang Dipertua Negeri Tun Juhar
Mahiruddin and his wife Toh
Puan Norlidah RM Jasni also
attended the open house, held
from 10am to 1pm, at the Kota
Kinabalu Sports Complex. Musa
handed out Aidilfitri goodies
to orphans and the disabled
from welfare homes in the city.
He told reporters that a festival
open house provides the opportunity for the people to meet
their leaders and for the leaders to get closer to the people in
an atmosphere of goodwill and
harmony. Bernama
FO CU S 19
20 FO CU S
F RO M P RE V I O U S PAG E
with another PetroSaudi executive Patrick Mahony on Sept 29, 2009. The chief
investment officer of Good Star in the
agreement was Seet Li Lin, an employee of
Jho Low at Jynwell Capital. The metadata
of this document in an email attachment
showed Jho Low to be the last person to
save this file on Oct 1, 2009.
6. On July 21, 2010, Jho Low emailed to Mahonys Good Star bank account details at
RBS Coutts in Zurich to receive part of the
US$500 million that was to come from the
Murabaha notes 1MDB was to subscribe.
7. On Sept 13, 2010, Jho Low emailed again
to Mahony asking him to remit the money
to Good Star.
Key Findings:
1. Good Star Limited received in total
about US$970 million from the US$1.83
billion that 1MDB invested with PetroSaudi Holdings Cayman between 2009
and 2011. From this amount of US$970
million, US$529 million went to the bank
9. Jho Low has been identified as the bene- account of Abu Dhabi Kuwait Malaysia
ficial owner of that bank account which was Investment Corp (ADKMIC) at BIS Bank
closed in February, 2014.
in Singapore. Jho Low was the beneficial
owner of that account.
10. Jho Low had declared himself as a shareholder of ADKMIC when he was involved 2. Javace Sdn Bhd, the company that Jho
in the acquisition of the then Bursa Malay- Low used in the 2010 takeover of UBG Bhd,
received US$260 million via a loan from
sia-listed UBG Bhd in 2010.
PetroSaudi International Seychelles. That
money was transferred from the JP MorWho got what and the trail of
bank account of Tarek Obaid which
international money laundering gan
he received from the US$500 million Mu8. Between June 2011 and September 2013,
Good Star remitted a total of US$529 million
in several transfers to a bank account at the
Swiss private bank BSI in Singapore that
belonged to Abu Dhabi-Kuwait-Malaysia
Investment Corp (ADKMIC).
MO
ah
Kin
6.
an
1M
Sw
the
an
7. W
no
al
inv
Kin
Glo
Cre
Ba
ne
US$30 million
US$65 million
US$125 million
via AmBank (M) Berhad
1MDB PetroSaudi
Ltd (BVI)
JP Morgan (Suisse)
A/C 7619400
Sep 16, 2010
US$300 million
UBG buyout
Abu D
Inves
Kampac Oil
PetroSaudi
International
(Cayman)
JP Morgan (Suisse)
A/C 7601900
May 5, 2010
US$50 million
PetroSaudi
Holdings
(Cayman)
JP Morgan (Suisse)
A/C 7625400
May 4, 2010
Aug
9, 2010
US$50
million
US$5.5 million
Mar 4, 2010
US$10 million
Offshore Services
Managment
Feb 1, 2010
US$5 million
BSI Ban
Tarek Obaid
JP Morgan
A/C 7573800
Aug 9, 2010
Mar 4, 2010
US$6 million
May 5, 2010
U$50 million
PetroSaudi Oil
Services Ltd.
(Cayman)
JP Morgan (Suisse)
A/C 7649600
100% Shareholder
`
Majestic Masterpiece
Sdn Bhd
Neptune Marine
Invest SA
PDVSA Petroleo SA
Servicios Mercantiles
Mercantile CommerceBank
N.A. (New York)
Rig Services
International
PSI UK
HSBC (U.K.)
Pegasus
Investment Pte Ltd
Other Transfers
FO CU S 21
pt,
rt)
aid
on
was
nce
nd
ney
ved
185
ese
nal
ed
buy
2. By 2012, all the US$2.23 billion was captured as Murabaha notes issued by PetroSaudi. It was later redeemed for a 49%
stake in PetroSaudi Oil Services Ltd (PSOSL).
3. On Sept 12, 2012, 1MDB sold this 49%
interest in PSOSL to Bridge Partners International Investment Ltd for US$2.32 billion.
Bridge Partners International did not pay
cash but issued promissory notes as payment.
Key Findings:
1. With the US$1.83 billion cash 1MDB
invested with PetroSaudi Holdings Cayman all gone, how then can it cover the
hole plus the so-called US$400 million
in declared profit that it was supposed
to have made?
4. On the same day, 1MDB through its subsidiary Brazen Sky Ltd, invested these US$2.32
billion of promissory notes in a fund called
Bridge Global Absolute Return Fund SPC
which was managed by Bridge Partners Investment Manager (Cayman). According to its
prospectus, the fund makes high risk investments and investors can lose all its money.
million
Shareholder
$55 million)
20 million)
120 million)
38 million)
153 million)
42.5 million)
.46 million)
Almamlaka Limited
BSI Bank
(Switzerland)
Banque Saudi
Fransi
(Riyadh)
eb 18, 2014
Interstate
Investment N.V.
HSBC Bank (US)
A/C 003029-215
Tarek Obaid
Banque Saudi Fransi
(Riyadh)
Palantir
Technologies
Nawaf Obaid
HSBC (U.K.)
A/C 01444182
Justwin
BSI Bank
(Switzerland)
Oct 5, 2010
US$1 million
Tarek Obaid
Credit Suisse (Zurich)
A/C 0835 969428 82
Patrick Mahoney
JP Morgan (Suisse)
A/C 7619300
der
ece
Graff Diamonds
Other Transfers
Patrick Mahoney's
'House' Account
Credit Suisse
Tarek Obaid
Morgan Stanley
(Zurich)
A/C 051-57777
Celestial
Citibank (US)
A/C 36921581
May 7, 2010
US$2.5 million
Tarek Obaid
EFG Private Bank Ltd, Curzon Street
April 5, 2010
US$12.5 million
Zink Imaging
Bank of America
22 FO CU S
Sdn Bhd) which also set up other companies that Jho Low owned. These include
Javace Sdn Bhd, Majestic Masterpiece
Sdn Bhd and Wynton Private Equity Sdn
Bhd. All five companies have registered
offices at the Petronas Twin Towers and
they have the same company secretary
Lim Poh Seng.
F RO M P RE V I O U S PAG E
7. B&M Consultancy is tied to Wong & Partners, the principal legal firm of Jho Low
and 1MDB.
Key Findings:
1. Between 2008 and 2010, Jho Low (pic)
made RM166 million entering and exiting
listed companies like Putrajaya Perdana
Bhd, Loh & Loh Corp Bhd and another
RM350 million through the injection of a
piece of land he owned in Medini, Iskandar to UBG Bhd via an asset management
8. The termination fee totalling US$2.22 company called Unity Capital.
billion that 1MDB paid to Aabar between
May and November, 2014 was, however, 2. In September, 2010, a Jho Low-connot reflected in the FY December, 2014 trolled company called Javace Sdn Bhd
7. The scheme to cover the US$2.32 billion
hole at the Cayman SPC is by paying Aabar
US$2.22 billion as option termination fee.
Aabar then passes the money to the Cayman SPC from which 1MDB would then be
able to redeem the money, thus covering
the money that was already gone.
. sm
g
un
yo
u
rt .
ns
to
a
pp
L
N
O
IS
ble
E
IN
http://edgy.my
COMMENT 23
hinamaybethrowingits
all at the stock market
not because that is its
most important problem, but its the one
Beijing can most easily, if ham-handedly, control.
Intimidating short sellers is, after
all, a lot easier, and cheaper, than
breathing life into a sagging housing
market suffering chronic (and worsening) oversupply.
Allowing people to pledge their
houses as collateral for the purchase
of more shares is easier than managing the transition from over-investment to, well, whatever comes after.
Suspending trading in major issues, trapping investors, is easier, and
quicker, than addressing the ways
in which pledged shares are part of
the expanding web of indebtedness
in China.
Chinas resolve to overawe markets into rising seems to harden daily.
Chinese media reported last Friday that the state-run China Securities Finance Corp (CSF) had received 1.3 trillion yuan (RM796.52
billion) in loans from banks, money
which in turn will be made available
for stock-purchase loans through
brokers.
Last week the CSF, not satisfied
An investor smiling as she walks past an electronic board showing stock information at
a brokerage house in Fuyang, Anhui province. The Chinese stock market has stabilised,
with the Shanghai Composite Index closing at 3,957 last Friday. Photo by Reuters
ECB has used its Emergency Liquidity Assistance (ELA) facility to pump about US$100 billion
(RM380.48 billion) into the Greek
banking system. Even so, the injection of funds has proved insufficient
to avoid a shutdown of the banking
system that has lasted three weeks.
As a result, the ECB is now under significant political pressure
to increase the banks access to
the ELA, despite clear evidence
that the Greek institutions are experiencing problems of solvency,
not liquidity.
This substitution of public money for private funding isnt a new
phenomenon. It has been happening on a large scale since 2010 for
Greek public finances. As the country sought to avoid bankruptcy, the
exodus of private creditors has been
met by growing exposure on the
part of official European entities
and the International Monetary
Fund (IMF).
Even on the investment side,
what little real economic activity
has occurred has been driven more
by public institutions than private
investors.
24 F E AT U R E
hat kind of
chief executive officer
(CEO) does a
big modern
bank need?
Apparently not a traditionally hyper-competitive investment banker
like Anshu Jain, who lost his co-CEO
job at Deutsche Bank last month
but evidently not a quiet retail
banker like Antony Jenkins, Barclays freshly ousted chief, either.
Perhaps the reason its so hard
to find a leader who can credibly
run all the diverse parts of a big
universal bank is that such institutions are doomed. Jain and Jenkins
had opposite ideas about which
businesses were core to the crisis-racked banking empires they
inherited.
True to his high-octane Wall
Street personal history, Jain concentrated on investment banking
and scorned the retail part. In his
April presentation on Deutsches
strategy, there were four slides titled
Reshape Retail, but two of them
dealt with divesting Postbank, the
omnipresent German main street
lender that Deutsche acquired in
2010, and one of them focused on
making Deutsches retail operation
more like its investment banking
Jains (left) investment banking focus looked obsolete and dangerous while Jenkins management style seemed too timid when it
came to cutting costs. Photos by Reuters
On the Iran deal, I think people are waking up to the fact that
Iran is ... saying it wants to double
its exports once the ban is lifted,
said John Kilduff of Again Capital.
Blanch said while there is no
agreement yet, the deal over Irans
nuclear programme appears closer and the market is beginning to
price in the flow of Iranian oil.
If a deal gets done this week,
maybe its a few more dollars
down. That may be a buying opportunity, Blanch said. Blanch
said the 30 million to 40 million
barrels Iran currently has in floating storage could be on the market
fairly quickly.
Negotiators have set a deadline for the talks between Iran,
the United States and five other
powers. Iran is reportedly pushing for a complete lifting of the
United Nations arms embargo.
Views vary on how quickly Iran
will start to get more oil out onto
the world market if there is a deal.
I think oil markets understand
very well, depending on what gets
decided one way or the other, its
going to be months, said Wittner.
The only thing fast is the floating
storage, but again, thats going
to have to wait until restrictions
are lifted.
H O M E B U S I N E S S 25
WEEK
IN FOCUS
Photos by Sam Fong
1
1
CIMB CHEQUE PRESENTATION ... (from left) Malaysia Wakaf Foundation chief executive ocer Professor Datuk Dr Sudin Haron, Minister in the Prime Ministers
Department Datuk Seri Abdul Wahid Omar, Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak, Minister in the Prime Ministers Department Datuk Seri Jamil Khir Baharom, and CIMB Islamic Bank
Bhd chairman Datuk Dr Syed Muhamad Syed Abdul Kadir at a mock cheque presentation by CIMB Islamic to the foundation at the launch of the National Wakaf Corp Bhd and the
Corporate Wakaf Programme in Putrajaya last Tuesday.
6
3
26 W O R L D B U S I N E S S
Fiat Chrysler
mulls auto parts
unit sale
BY PA MEL A B AR BAGLIA
& AGNI ESZK A F LAK
A security worker leaving after bringing money to a National Bank branch in Athens,
Greece last Friday. Following last Thursdays vote, Tsipras told his associates that
he would be forced to lead a minority government until a nal deal with creditors is
concluded. Photo by Reuters
Jurong Islands
chemical romance
SINGAPORE: Jurong Island
the cornerstone of Singapores
petrochemicals industry is
looking to the speciality chemicals field to keep it ahead of its
global competitors, The Straits
Times reported. The government is behind the push, with
the Economic Development
Board setting its sights on significantly growing the sector,
said Eugene Leong, its director of energy and chemicals.
Speciality chemicals refer to
niche chemicals and polymers
which are usually higher up in
the value chain as they have
unique functions that enhance
a products performance. They
include automotive-related
chemicals, which can be used
to produce fuel-efficient cars,
and agro-chemicals to raise
farm efficiency.
IN BRIEF
JPMorgan reaches
US$388m accord in suit
NEW YORK: JPMorgan Chase
& Co agreed to pay US$388 million (RM1.47 billion) to settle a
suit by investors who claimed
the bank misled them about the
safety of US$10 billion worth of
residential mortgage-backed
securities, a lawyer said. The
suit, brought by the Fort Worth
Employees Retirement Fund
and other investors in nine offerings made before the financial crisis, claimed JPMorgan
misled them about the underwriting, appraisals and credit
quality of home loans underlying the securities. Bloomberg
W O R L D B U S I N E S S 27
Indonesian
infrastructure
derailed
BY EVEL I N E DA N U B R ATA &
C I N DY SI LVI A NA
US$483b unleashed
to stem stock turmoil
Shanghai Composite Index jumped 3.5% last Friday
SHANGHAI: China has created
what amounts to a state-run margin
trader with US$483 billion (RM1.84
trillion) of firepower, its latest effort to end a stock-market rout that
threatens to drag down economic
growth and erode confidence in
President Xi Jinpings government.
China Securities Finance Corp
(CSF) can access as much as 3
trillion yuan (RM1.84 trillion) of
borrowed funds from sources including the central bank and commercial lenders, according to people familiar with the matter. The
money may be used to buy shares
and provide liquidity to brokerages, the people said, asking not to be
named because the information
wasnt public.
While its unclear how much CSF
will ultimately deploy into Chinas
US$6.6 trillion equity market, the
financing is up to 25 times bigger than the support fund started
by Chinese brokerages earlier this
month. Thats probably enough to
IN BRIEF
Miramax explores sale as
content demand grows
NEW YORK: The investors behind Miramax, the studio that
owns Oscar winners Shakespeare in Love and Pulp Fiction,
are exploring a sale, people with
knowledge of the matter said, as
demand for content has grown
with the rise of online viewing.
Miramax, which owns more
than 700 films, could fetch as
much as US$1 billion (RM3.8
billion), said one of the people,
who asked not to be named because the discussions are private. The company, controlled
by billionaire Thomas Barrack
Jrs Colony Capital and Qatar
Holding, is interviewing banks,
the people said. Bloomberg
28 WORLD
Filepic of Cosby
at the American
Comedy Awards in
New York on April
26, 2014. He was
accused of drugging
and molesting
Constand 10 years
ago. Photo by
Reuters
IN BRIEF
Suspect texted link to
Islamic verse before
Tennessee rampage
CHATTANOOGA, Tennessee:
Hours before the Tennessee
shooting that killed five US
servicemen, the suspected
gunman texted a close friend
a link to an Islamic verse that
included the line: Whosoever shows enmity to a friend of
Mine, then I have declared war
against him. The gunmans
family said in a statement late
on Saturday he had suffered
from depression, and that
they had experienced shock
and horror over the violence.
The suspects friend said he
thought nothing of the text
message at the time, but now
wonders if it was a clue to last
Thursdays rampage in Chattanooga, which has reignited
concerns about the radicalisation of young Muslim men.
Reuters
AC/DCs drummer
Phil Rudd arrested again
in New Zealand
WELLINGTON: AC/DC drummer Phil Rudd has been arrested again in New Zealand
and was behind bars yesterday night, his lawyer said.
Details of the charges were
unclear and police refused
to confirm the 61-year-old
had been arrested, less than
two weeks after he was sentenced to home detention after pleading guilty to threatening to kill and drugs charges.
However, his lawyer Craig
Tuck told journalists Rudd
would be appearing in court
today. AFP
S P O RT S 2 9
MACAU: Veteran boxing promoter Bob Arum has blasted the injured Manny Pacquiao for missing
a planned rehab visit to his doctor
and says he has no idea when Pacman might return to the ring.
After watching Argentinas Cesar Cuenca beat Chinas IK Yang
to lift the IBF junior welterweight
Tevezs Boca
return put
in shade by
teammate
BUENOS AIRES: Carlos Tevez was
overshadowed on his return to Boca
Juniors after 11 years away on Saturday when teammate Jonathan Calleri
scored a spectacular rabona goal in
the 2-1 win over Quilmes.
Sebastian Palacios gave Boca a
first-half lead before Calleri grabbed
the crucial second for the league
leaders after his first attempt was
blocked.
Alexis Canello reduced the arrears
later in the game for the visitors at a
packed Bombonera stadium.
Tevez, 31, had spent the last decade in Europe, playing for Manchester City, Manchester United and Juventus.
Last season, he scored 29 goals in
Turin, earning a second Serie A title
and a runners-up spot in the Champions League.
Tevez played for his beloved
Boca from 2001 to 2004 before
moving to Corinthians in Brazil.
From there he joined West Ham
in England in 2006 and then played
for Manchester United before moving to rivals Manchester City for
more than 40 million in 2009.
He joined Juventus in 2013 after
four seasons at City, and last season was the Italian leagues second
top scorer with 20 goals as Juventus
won the league and reached the
Champions League final where they
lost to Barcelona. AFP
title in Macaus Cotai Arena on Saturday night, the 83-year-old toprank chief Arum responded angrily
when asked when Pacquiao might
fight again.
As far as Im concerned hes not
an active fighter, said Arum, adding
that Pacquiao had not been acting
very professionally.
Pacquiao had surgery on May 7
to repair a torn right shoulder rota-
F1 driver Bianchis
funeral tomorrow
He had spent nine months in a coma after Japan crash
PARIS: The funeral of Jules Bianchi,
the French Formula One (F1) driver who died after spending nine
months in a coma following a crash
at last seasons Japanese Grand
Prix, will be held in his home city
of Nice tomorrow.
Bianchi, 25, who died last Friday, had been fighting for his life
under controlled medical conditions in the Centre Hospitalier Universitaire hospital in Nice, southern France.
He is the first F1 driver to perish
from a racing accident since triple
world champion Ayrton Senna in
San Marino in 1994.
His funeral will be held at 0900
GMT at the Sainte-Reparate cathedral in the old part of Nice city.
The gifted young drivers death
sparked a flood of tributes from his
pitlane colleagues and the world
of politics.
Bianchi joined Marussia in 2013
and competed in 34 Grands Prix,
notching two world championship
points still the teams best result.
Bianchi suffered a traumatic
brain injury when his car careered
Bianchi speaking at a news conference at the Suzuka circuit on Oct 2, 2014. He is the
rst Formula One driver to perish from a racing accident since triple world champion
Senna in San Marino in 1994. Photo by Reuters
IN BRIEF
30
live it!
MO
Personal
ASSISTANT
COMPI L ED BY S U ANN QUAH
More than
JUST SONGS
TREAT yourself to a ne dining express
lunch today at Nobu Kuala Lumpur which
oers dishes such as seared salmon
tataki with matsuhisa dressing, beef
kushiyaki, spicy tuna cut roll, white sh,
langoustine and vegetable tempura as
well as miso soup. This express lunch is
a condensed version of the restaurants
bento box oering and is the best choice
to have if you are running on a busy
schedule. Priced at RM128, it is available
from noon to 2pm on weekdays. Nobu KL
is located at Level 56, Menara 3 Petronas,
Persiaran KLCC, Kuala Lumpur. For
reservation call (03) 2164 5084.
H E A RT & S O U L
Performing the first of their two
shows annually, the Philharmonic Society of Selangor choir will be
presenting their fourth Heart & Soul
Charity Concert 2015, themed Lets
Rock, from July 24 to 26 at the Kuala Lumpur Performing Arts Centre.
Conceived by choir director and society chairperson Cheryl Teh in 2003,
the biannual programme features
a selection of songs from different
genres of popular music. This years
show will see a throwback to rock favourites and soothing classics from
both sides of the Pacific Ocean, from
Queen to Bon Jovi, Bette Midler, The
Carpenters and even Culture Club.
Proceeds will go to Assumption
Orang Asli Ministry (July 24, 8.30pm),
The Befrienders Kuala Lumpur (July
25, 3pm) and towards the Societys
upcoming joint-charity concert in
India. For more information, visit
www.klpac.org or call (03) 4047 9000
to purchase.
Personally, I have seen it work. Ive
done three months of what they call workplace singing with a company here
they are now continuing on their own.
The company has said its the best activity theyve invested in. Anyone can do it,
points out Teh.
The diversity in PSS is testament
enough, with the age of the current choir
me
yea
An
Infl
Au
wh
exa
mu
non
ab
on
the
sho
ove
wa
list
and
a fu
An
cho
wit
mo
phy
out
nee
wa
its
me
of t
as
com
acc
crit
thr
the
Or
Som
doi
to C
Tou
we
Ch
one
ind
all
lea
live it! 31
SCENE
BY E LAI NE LAU
Fever Pitch: The movie-inspired musical is set to hit the stage in Kuala Lumpur.
Chairperson
and choir
director
Cheryl Teh.
Photo by
Izwan
o
e
ul
s
e.
3,
s
t
s
m
m
e
b.
,
y
s
n
t
0
ve
rk
wn.
iviit,
ent
oir
32
live it!
Zen TODAY
BRIDGING
two crafts