You are on page 1of 34

July 1995

Ref : 23002Ren9531

......................................................................................................

Measurement guide for voltage


characteristics
......................................................................................................

Electricity product characteristics and


electromagnetic compatibility
......................................................................................................

The Union of the Electricity Industry - EURELECTRIC, formed as a result of a merger in


1
December 1999 of the twin Electricity Industry Associations, UNIPEDE
and EURELECTRIC2, is the
sole sector association representing the common interests of the European Electricity Industry and its
worldwide affiliates and associates.
Its mission is to contribute to the development and competitiveness of the Electricity Industry and to
promote the role of electricity in the advancement of society.
As a centre of strategic expertise, theUnion of the Electricity Industry - EURELECTRIC will
identify and represent the common interests of its members and assist them in formulating common
solutions to be implemented and in
coordinating and carrying out the necessary actions. To that end it
will also act in liaison with other international associations and organisations, respecting the specific
missions and responsibilities of these organisations.
The Union of the Electricity Industry - EURELECTRIC is also the association of the Electricity
Industry within the European Union representing it in public affairs, in particular in relation to the
institutions of the EU and other international organisations, in order to promote the interests of its
members at a political level and to create awareness of its policies.
The reports published by EURELECTRIC are the result of the work of its structure of expertise: they
represent one of the most direct methods of circulating knowledge and information throughout the
sector, on subjects of common interest.
They are intended for wide circulation both within the electricity supply industry and outside it.
Please do not hesitate to ask for the latest available printed
EURELECTRIC publications
catalogue (with summaries of EURELECTRIC reports) from:

Union of the Electricity Industry EURELECTRIC


Documentation
66 Boulevard de l'Impratrice
BE-1000 Brussels
BELGIUM
Tel:
Fax:
Email:

+32 2 515 10 00
+32 2 515 10 10
cpalermo@eurelectric.org

You can also use the EURELECTRIC Internet Web site, which provides the following
information:
-

EURELECTRIC general information

EURELECTRIC positions and statements

Events & Conferences

Publications Catalogue

http://www.eurelectric.org

1
2

International Union of Producers and Distributors of Electrical Energy


European Grouping of Electricity Undertakings
The Union of the Electricity Industry EURELECTRIC has been formed through a merger of the two associations

and

Measurement guide for voltage characteristics


............................................................................................
Electricity product characteristics and
electromagnetic compatibility
............................................................................................

Paper prepared by:

Roger OTT (FR); Gerrit BLOM (NL); Michel DUSSART (BE); Pierre
FERRAND (FR); Peter LODERER (AT)
The work has been started by Andr MENDES (FR) and was carried out
with the contribution of Jean-Louis JAVERZAC (FR), Richard NOTTELET
(FR) and Pierre PICARD (FR)

Copyright
Union of the Electricity Industry - EURELECTRIC, 2000
All rights reserved
Printed at EURELECTRIC, Brussels (Belgium)

CONTENTS
Part 1: General ................................................................................................................ 2
1.1 Introduction ..................................................................................................... 2
1.2 Normative references........................................................................................ 3
1.3 General and environment .................................................................................. 4
1.4 Auxiliary supply voltage ................................................................................... 11
1.5 Measurement transformers ............................................................................... 12
Part 2: Specification of measurement methods .............................................................. 13
2.1 Power frequency .............................................................................................. 14
2.2 Magnitude of the supply voltage....................................................................... 15
2.3 Rapid voltage changes: flicker severity ............................................................. 16
2.4 Supply voltage dips .......................................................................................... 17
2.5 Short and long interruptions ............................................................................. 19
2.6 Temporary power frequency overvoltages between live conductors and
earth................................................................................................................ 20
2.7 Transient overvoltages between live conductors and earth ................................ 22
2.8 Supply voltage unbalance ................................................................................. 22
2.9 Harmonic voltage ............................................................................................. 23
2.10 Interharmonic voltage..................................................................................... 25
2.11 Mains signalling voltage ................................................................................. 25
Part 3: Withstand and immunity characteristics........................................................... 26
3.1 Permanent monitoring ...................................................................................... 26
3.2 Temporary surveying or general purpose investigations: general mechanical
requirements.................................................................................................... 28

SUMMARY
The purpose of this report is to provide a practical approach for measuring and
evaluating the characteristics of supply voltage as specified by the European standard EN
50160, issue of November 1994.
The problem has been analysed with a view of the different situations which can
occur in practice:
- permanent verification of supply characteristics, depending on contractual
obligations
- temporary surveying motivated by distributor's requirements or by user's complaints
- surveys to check the performance of a supply system for general purpose
investigations.
After having defined the reference environmental conditions and the required
operating characteristics of the measuring instruments, the report describes the measurement
methods and the information processing criteria for the evaluation of each of the voltage
characteristics considered in the European standard.
This document provides a suitable solution for the assessment of the voltage
characteristics and represents an effective contribution of UNIPEDE to the definition of a
complete frame of reference for the electricity supply service, according to the general policy
being pursued by the European Union.

23002Ren9531

July 1995

PART 1: GENERAL
1.1 Introduction
The CENELEC standard EN 50 160 defines the voltage characteristics of the
electricity supplied by medium voltage and low voltage public distribution systems at the users
supply terminals.
To check the compliance of the actual voltage characteristics with the EN standard it
is necessary to provide more detailed information on measuring and evaluation methods.
Moreover the functional and constructive specifications for the measuring equipment
should be established with reference to the application requirements and the relevant
international standards.
The aim of this report is to describe a possible approach to the measurement and
compliance verification of the voltage characteristics for which the EN gives definite values,
by giving the measurement techniques and the performance characteristics with which the
instruments intended to be used should comply with.
The document is subdivided into three parts:
- Part 1 General,
- Part 2 Specification of measurement methods,
- Part 3 Withstand and immunity characteristics.
Three categories of application have been considered:
- 1st category:
verifications),

permanent

monitoring

(for

example

for

contractual

- 2nd category
temporary surveying (for example to check the performance of
the supply system, or in case of user complaints),
- 3rd category

for general purpose investigations.

For each of these categories specific requirements exist, in particular those dealing
with environmental conditions.
As far as these requirements are concerned, the report deals only with the influencing
factors which should be complied with for each category.
When some parameters are not expressly given, it is understood that they are left to
be declared by the manufacturer.
The guidelines given in the report may also be used for verification of voltage
characteristics with tolerances different from those stated in the EN 50160 Standard, by
making the necessary modifications.
23002Ren9531

July 1995

1.2 Normative references


IEC

CENELEC

TITLE
Voltage characteristics of electricity supply by
distribution systems

EN 50160
IEC 60

High-voltage test techniques

IEC 68

Environmental testing

IEC 85

Thermal and evaluation and classification of electrical


insulation

IEC 186 & 186A

Voltage transformers

IEC 255

Electrical relays

IEC 529

Degree of protection provided by enclosures (IP code)

IEC 695

Fire hazard testing

IEC 868

EN 60868

Flickermeter - Functional and design specifications

IEC 801-2

Electrostatic discharge requirements

IEC 801-3

Radiated electromagnetic field requirements

IEC 801-4

Electrical fast transient/burst requirements

IEC 817

IEC 1036

Spring-operated impact-test apparatus and its


calibration
EN 61036

Alternating current static watt-hour meter for active


energy (classes 1 & 2)

IEC 1000-2-2

Electromagnetic compatibility

IEC 1000-4-5

Surge immunity tests

IEC 1000-4-7

General guide line on harmonics and inter harmonics


measurements and instrumentation, for power supply
systems and equipment connected thereto

IEV 50(301)

General terms on measurements in electricity

CISPR 22

23002Ren9531

EN 55022

Limits and methods of measurement of radio


interference characteristics of Information technology
equipment
3

July 1995

1.3 General and environment


1.3.1 Organisation of the measurements
The voltage to be measured is either directly accessible as it is generally the case in
low-voltage supply systems, or accessible via measurement transformers. The instrumentation
performs the measurement of certain voltage characteristics by means of an analog, digital or
other data acquisition technique. As a last step, the measured parameters are subjected to a
conditioning which is most often meant to eliminate the effect of spurious phenomena and
processed for evaluation.
This principle is illustrated by the following figure.

Measurement
transformers

Us :
voltage
supplied

Measurement
unit

Um :
voltage to be
measured

Evaluation unit

Gm :
measurement
result

Ge :
measurement
evaluation

Figure 1: Block diagram of a measurement chain


The term measurement instrumentation theoretically covers the whole chain between
the voltage supplied and the measurement evaluation. For the purpose of this guide the term
"measurement instrumentation" will be restricted to the blocks "measurement unit and
evaluation unit". In particular, the requirements dealing with accuracy will only apply to these
units, the specifications for measurement transformers being defined separately.

1.3.2 Environment
1.3.2.1 General
The voltage characteristics given in the standard EN 50 160 are related to normal
operating conditions, so that when making evaluations it is to be intended that any time
interval in wich the supply system is not in normal operating conditions (e.g. interruptions,
faults, etc.) should be excluded from the evaluation.
The measurement of a specific voltage characteristic can be affected by the variation
of another characteristic of the voltage measured. As a consequence, influence quantities
23002Ren9531

July 1995

include the characteristics of the measured voltage given by CENELEC standard EN 50 160 in
addition to "external" influence quantities.
Moreover, the supply of the measurement system shall be designed in such a way that
it has no significant effect on the measurement result when the auxiliary supply voltage is itself
disturbed.
Several variation fields for parameters are defined for each category. These are:
- reference conditions,
- specified operating range,
- limit range of operation,
- storage and transportation conditions.
The influence quantities wich are not mentioned in the following tables shall be
specified by the equipment manufacturer of the measurement.
The connection devices of "voltage" circuits must comply with safety rules and with
related regulations.
1.3.2.2 Reference conditions
Definition of influence quantity

Any quantity, generally external to the measurement


equipment, which may affect its working performance (
IEV 301-08-09 modified).

Definition of reference conditions

Appropriate set of influence quantities and performance


characteristics, with reference values, their tolerances
and reference ranges, with respect to which the intrinsic
error (r) is specified (IEV 301-08-10 modified).

The basic reference conditions (influence quantities with their reference values and
tolerance) are reported in the following table:

23002Ren9531

July 1995

Influence quantity

Nominal

Permissible tolerance

Frequency

50 Hz

Voltage magnitude

nominal value

Flicker (Pst)

0.1

Voltage dips

Interruptions

Transient overvoltages

IEC 1000-4-5, level 1

Unbalance

0.5 %

Harmonics (THD)

3%

Interharmonics (at any frequency)

1%

Ripple control signals

1%

Ambient temperature

23C

2C

Humidity

50 %

10%

Magnetic induction of external origin at


the reference frequency (50 Hz)in any
direction

0.05 mT(1)

External electric field at reference


frequency (50 Hz) in any direction

0.1 kV/m

0.5 Hz

1%

Auxiliary supply voltage

see sub-clause 1.4

Air

absence of corrosive atmosphere

These reference conditions are valid for categories 1, 2 and 3 equipment.

(1) IEC 1036 table 19 page 67.

23002Ren9531

July 1995

1.3.2.3 Specified operating range


Definition of specified operating range

Range of values of a single influence quantity


which forms a part of rated operating
conditions (3.6.9 IEC 1036).

1.3.2.3.1 Operating range for category 1


Influence quantities

Range

Frequency

42,5 Hz - 57,5 Hz

Voltage magnitude

nominal 15 %

Flicker (Pst)

0-4

Voltage dips
Interruptions

up to 1,5 s ; 99%
up to 4 hours(2)

Unbalance

0 - 5(3) %

Harmonics (THD)

0 - 15 %

Interharmonics (at any frequency)

3%

Ripple control signals

0-9%

Ambient temperature

-10C - + 45C

Humidity

20% - 95 %
up to 0,5 mT(4)

Magnetic induction of external origin at


the reference frequency (50 Hz) in any
direction

Accuracy

External electric field at reference


frequency (50 Hz) in any direction

up to 1 kV/m

Transient overvoltages

6 kV (IEC 1000-4-5)

Electrostatic discharges

15 kV (IEC 801-2)

Electromagnetic HF fields

10 V/m (IEC 801-3)

2 r

Fast transients

2 kV (IEC 801-4)

2 r

Auxiliary supply voltage

see sub-clause 1.4

Air

absence of corrosive atmosphere

(2) Only valid for time measurement accuracy.


(3) Only valid for polyphases measurements - see part 2.
(4) IEC1036 table 14 page 45.

23002Ren9531

July 1995

The accuracy r is specified for each measurement mode (refer to Part 2).
In addition to this, for a permanent installation the measurement device shall have
immunity to mechanical and external electromagnetic stresses. These are described in Part 3.
1.3.2.3.2 Operating range for category 2.

Influence quantities

Range

Accuracy

Frequency

42,5 Hz - 57,5 Hz

Voltage magnitude

nominal 15 %

Flicker (Pst)

0-4

Voltage dips

up to 1,5 s ; 99%

Interruptions

up to 4 hours(5)

Unbalance

0-5%

Harmonics (THD)

0 - 15 %

Interharmonics (any
frequency)

3%

Ripple control signals

0-9%

Transient overvoltages

2 kV (IEC 1000-4-5)

2 r

Auxiliary supply voltage

see sub-clause 1.4

Air

absence of corrosive atmosphere

(5) Only valid for time measurement accuracy.

23002Ren9531

July 1995

3.2.3.3 Operating range for category 3


Influence quantities

Range

Accuracy

Frequency

42,5 Hz - 57,5 Hz

2 r

Voltage magnitude

nominal 15%

2 r

flicker (Pst)

0-4

Unbalance

0-5%

Harmonics (THD)

0 - 15 %

Interharmonics (at every


frequency)

3%

Ripple control signals

0-9%

Transient overvoltage

0,5 kV (IEC 1000-4-5)

Ambient temperature

+15C, + 30C

4 r

2r

Auxiliary supply voltage

see sub-clause 1.4

Air

absence of corrosive atmosphere

1.3.2.4 Limit range of operation


Definition of limit range of operation

23002Ren9531

Extreme conditions which an operating


measurement equipment can withstand without
damage and without degradation of its
metrological characteristics when it is
subsequently operated under its rated operating
condition (3.6.10 IEC 1036).

July 1995

1.3.2.4.1 Limits for category 1


Influence quantities

Range

Voltage magnitude

0 to 1.25 U nominal

Ambient temperature

-20C, + 55C

Humidity

10% - 100 %

Auxiliary supply voltage

see sub-clause 1.4

Transient overvoltages

9 kV (IEC 1000-4-5)

Air

absence of corrosive
atmosphere

Electromagnetic influence quantities are given in Part 3.


1.3.2.4.2 Limits for categories 2
Influence quantities

Range

Auxiliary supply voltage

see sub-clause 1.4

Transient overvoltages

2 kV (IEC 1000-4-5)

1.3.2.4.3 limits for categories 3


Influence quantities

Range

Auxiliary supply voltage

see sub-clause 1.4

Transient overvoltages

0.5 kV (IEC 1000-4-5)

1.3.2.5 Storage and transportation conditions


Definition of storage and transportation
conditions

23002Ren9531

Extreme conditions which a non-operating


measurement equipment can withstand without
damage and without degradation of its
metrological characteristics when it is
subsequently operated under its rated operating
condition (3.6.11 IEC 1036).

10

July 1995

1.3.2.5.1 Conditions for category 1


Influence quantities

Range

Ambient temperature

-25C, + 70C

Humidity

10% - 100 %

Air

absence of corrosive atmosphere

1.3.2.5.2 Conditions for categories 2 and 3


No mandatory additional requirement.
1.4 Auxiliary supply voltage
The table below gives the requirements of auxiliary supply voltage for auxiliary
supply interruptions.
The magnitude and two different durations of the interruption of the auxiliary supply
voltage interruption are considered:
- t1: duration during which the measurement equipment continues its normal
operating mode.
- t2: duration during which the measurement equipment keeps the time.
Categories

Permanent operation

Back-up operation
From 0 to 75% Un

Un 25%

t1= 4 minutes
t2= 4 hours
From 0 to 85% Un

Un 15%

t1: not specified


t2= 4 hours
From 0 to 85% Un

Un 15%

t1: not specified


t2: not specified

23002Ren9531

11

July 1995

1.5 Measurement transformers


1.5.1 Connection arrangement
The instrumentation is connected between phases or between phase and neutral
depending on the measurement requirements.
If the instrumentation is installed behind measurement transformers, the connection of
voltages directly applied to the instrumentation shall be the image of the voltages delivered by
the distributor (phase-phase or phase-neutral voltages).
If, for cost reasons for instance, the measurement is made at the supply transformer
secondary terminal, the voltage characteristics are not exactly the same as at the transformer
primary. The interpretation of the measurement results is delicate and is not dealt with in the
present guide. It may nevertheless be agreed upon between distributor and customer.
1.5.2 Main characteristics of measurement transformers
The single-phase voltage transformers required for the measurement of the
characteristics of the "Medium Voltage" comply with IEC recommendations 186 and 186 A.
These transformers are wound-type transformers with a magnetic core.
The voltage at the secondary terminal of a measurement transformer is standardised
and is either equal to 100 V/3 , 110 V/3, 100 or 110 V (at present 200 V).
The rated burden of measurement transformers is limited. It shall not exceed 25 VA
in all cases. The accuracy class is 0.5.
The accuracy of voltage transformers, in frequency range from 45 Hz to 2000 Hz is
better than 5 %.
1.5.3 Influence of existing voltage transformers
As far as these devices are concerned, before any measurement, it will be necessary to
check the compliance of their characteristics with the recommendations of IEC 186 and 186 A
and sub-clause 1.5.2.
Single-phase capacitor (VCT) transformers complying with IEC recommendations
may be used for the measurement of the voltage characteristics, except for the measurement of
harmonic and interharmonic voltage.

23002Ren9531

12

July 1995

PART 2: SPECIFICATION OF MEASUREMENT METHODS


Each measurement mode for instrumentation is specified as follows:
- requirements on measurement accuracy
- requirements for influence quantities on the disturbances of the voltage to be
measured.
For each measurement mode the accuracy is specified, unless otherwise indicated,
assuming that the other influencing magnitudes on the voltage to be measured are under their
reference conditions as defined in Part 1, sub clause 1.3.2.2.
Notes
1) - Except for frequency measurements, the instrumentation concerns either single
phase or phase to phase connections
2) - Unbalance measurement is specific to polyphase systems.
In the following, for each measurement mode, the measurement evaluation is carried
out on the basis of the the valid samples.
A sample is considered valid if the mean value of the voltage over the applicable
specified basic fixed time interval, measured as stated at sub-clause 2.2.1, remains within the
range 15 % of the supply nominal (or declared) voltage.
The basic fixed time intervals used in the different measurement modes are the
following:
- for power frequency: 10 seconds
- for magnitude of the supply voltage, flicker severity, and supply voltage unbalance:
10 minutes
- for harmonic/interharmonic voltages: 3 seconds and/or 10 minutes
- for mains signalling voltages: 3 seconds.
As an example, for the measurement of the supply voltage magnitude, the following
approach is applied:
- Number of 10-minute intervals in the observation period of one week: 1008
- Number of non valid 10-minute intervals (intervals with mean voltage outside the
15 % tolerance): Nnonvalid
- Number of valid 10-minute intervals (intervals with mean voltage within the 15 %
tolerance): 1008-Nnonvalid = N

23002Ren9531

13

July 1995

- Number of valid 10-minute intervals with voltage not complying with EN 50160
(intervals with voltage outside the tolerance of 10 % and within the tolerance 15
%): N1,
Compliance with EN 50160 is given by:

N1
N
= 1 5%

1008 N nonvalid N

2.1 Power frequency


2.1.1 Measurement
Frequency measurement is a mean value over 10 seconds fixid time intervals.
2.1.2 Specification of the instrumentation
When an a.c. voltage that fulfills requirements of reference conditions is applied at the
instrumentation input, the instrumentation presents an intrinsic error r:

r 50 mHz
for categories 1,2 and 3.
2.1.3 Influence quantities at the specified operating range
For this measurement mode, the range of one of the influence quantities given in subclause 1.3.2.3 Part 1 is extended. The following table gives the variation range of the
concerned quantity:
Nature

Variation range

Harmonics (THD)

0-20 %

Note:
Accuracy is given in Part 1: table of sub-clause 1.3.2.3.1 for category 1 equipments, table of
sub-clause 1.3.2.3.2 for category 2 and table of sub-clause 1.3.2.3.3 for category 3

2.1.4 Measurement evaluation


- Observation period of one week in fixed steps of 10 seconds
- Determination of the number of 10 s intervals during which:
- the supply voltage is within 15 % of its nominal value(6) : N
- the frequency differs by more than 0.5 Hz from the nominal value and the supply
voltage is within 15 % of its nominal value: N1
(6) Mean arithmetic value over a then minutes time period.

23002Ren9531

14

July 1995

- the frequency differs by more than - 3 Hz, + 2 Hz from the nominal value and the
supply voltage is within 15 % of its nominal value: N2
2.1.5 Nominal value and limits for compliance
Nominal value:
fn = 50 Hz

The requirements of the standard are fulfilled if:


N1/N 5%
and N2=0
2.2 Magnitude of the supply voltage
2.2.1 Measurement
The instrumentation shall measure the r.m.s. voltage(7) . Each basic measurement
value is the mean value over a fixed 10 minutes time period. Every measurement updates
previous one at the end of the 10 minutes period.
2.2.2 Specification of the instrumentation
When an a.c. voltage that fulfills requirements of reference conditions is applied at the
instrumentation input, the instrumentation presents with respect to the nominal value an
intrinsic error r less than:
- for category 1 equipment: 0.5 %,
- for category 2 equipment: 0.5 %,
- for category 3 equipment: 1 %.

(7) The r.m.s. value U of a signal u(t) is defined by the relation

U=

1 T 2
u (t )d (t ) . T is equal to a
0
T

period time (according to IEC definition).


23002Ren9531

15

July 1995

2.2.3 Influence quantities at the specified operating range


For this measurement mode, the range of one of the influence quantities given in subclause 1.3.2.3 Part 1 is extended. The following table gives the variation range of the
concerned quantity:
Nature

Variation range

Harmonics (THD)

0-20 %

Note: Accuracy is given in Part 1: table of sub-clause 1.3.2.3.1 for category 1 equipments,
table of sub-clause 1.3.2.3.2 for category 2 and table of sub-clause 1.3.2.3.3 for category
3
2.2.4 Measurement evaluation
- Observation period of one week in fixed steps of 10 minutes.
- Determination of the number of 10 minutes intervals during which:
- the supply voltage is within 15 % of its nominal voltage: N
- the supply voltage differs by more than 10% from the nominal value and it is within
15 % its nominal value: N1
2.2.5 Nominal value and limits for compliance
Nominal value:

- In LV: nominal = 230 V between phase and neutral,


- In MV: declared voltage is defined by agreement.

The requirement of the standard is fulfilled if:


N1/N 5%
2.3 Rapid voltage changes: flicker severity
2.3.1 Specification of the instrumentation
The instrumentation shall measure the Plt value and shall comply with IEC
Publication 868 - EN 60868.
2.3.2 Influence quantities at the specified operating range
For this measurement mode, the range of one of the influence quantities given in subclause 1.3.2.3 Part 1 is extended. The following table gives the variation range of the
concerned quantity:
Nature

23002Ren9531

Variation range

16

July 1995

Harmonics (THD)

0 - 20 %

2.3.3 Measurement evaluation


- Observation periods of one week in fixed steps of 10 minutes
- Acquisition of all Pst values (short term flicker severity measured in each 10 minutes
interval)
- Determination of valid Pst values by elimination of Pst values related to 10 minutes
intervals during which the voltage is outside the range 15% of its nominal value
and/or a voltage dip with depth 15% of the nominal voltage has occurred
- Evaluation of the Plt values (long term flicker severity) on the basis of 12 valid
consecutive values of Pst
- Determination of:
- number of the evaluated Plt values: N
- number of Plt exceeding 1: N1
2.3.4 Limits for compliance
The requirement of the standard is fulfilled if:
N1/N 5%.
2.4 Supply voltage dips
2.4.1 Measurement
The instrumentation shall measure the r.m.s. voltage every half-cycle.
2.4.2 Specification of the instrumentation
An a.c. voltage that fulfills the requirements of reference conditions is applied at the
instrumentation input; at zero crossing, the voltage shifts to a fixed value comprised between 1
and 90 % of the nominal voltage in less than one half cycle. The measurement equipment has
to measure the new voltage value at the end of the first half cycle following the modification of
the voltage magnitude (excluding the half cycle during which the voltage modification takes
place).
Any other functional arrangement giving equivalent or improved performance is
acceptable.

23002Ren9531

17

July 1995

The instrumentation presents with respect to the nominal value an intrinsic error r
on the depth of the voltage dip less than:
- for category 1 equipment: 0,5 %,
- for category 2 equipment: 2 %,
- for category 3 equipment: given by the manufacturer.
The same process applies when returning to reference voltage.
The voltage dip is defined by a pair of data:

- duration
- depth.

The duration corresponds to the period during which the r.m.s. values measured
remain less than 90 % of the declared value. The depth of a voltage dip is defined as the
difference, expressed in % of the declared voltage, between the minimum r.m.s. value during
the voltage dip and the declared voltage.
As a consequence of the absence of measurement during a half cycle (i.e. during the
voltage changes) at the beginning and at the end of a voltage dip, voltage dips with a duration
shorter than 20 ms are not measured with the required accuracy. For the same reasons, the
accuracy of the duration of a voltage dip is equal to:
20 ms
for categories 1, 2, and 3 equipment.
2.4.3 Measurement evaluation
Indicatives values are given in EN 50160.
- Observation periods of one year for category 1 and case by case for the other
categories.
- Determination of numbers Nij (source UNIPEDE-DISDIP):
Depth (d % ) 10 mst<100
/ Duration (t) ms

100 mst<500
ms

500 ms
t<1s

1s
t<3s

3s
t<20s

20s
t<1min

10 < d < 15

N11

N21

N31

N41

N51

N61

15 d < 30

N12

N22

N32

N42

N52

N62

30 d < 60

N13

N23

N33

N43

N53

N63

60 d < 99

N14

N24

N34

N44

N54

N64

23002Ren9531

18

July 1995

2.5 Short and long interruptions


2.5.1 General
Only categories 1 and 2 instrumentation are concerned by interruption measurements.
2.5.2 Measurement
The instrumentation shall measure the r.m.s. voltage every half-cycle.
2.5.3 Specification of the instrumentation
An a.c. voltage that fulfills requirements of reference conditions is applied at the
instrumentation input ; at zero crossing, the voltage shifts to a fixed value comprised between
0 and 1 % of the nominal voltage in less than one half cycle. The measurement equipment has
to detect the "zero" voltage at the end of the first half cycle following the modification of the
voltage magnitude (excluding the half cycle during which the voltage modification takes
place).
Any other functional arrangement giving equivalent or improved performance is
acceptable.
The same process applies when returning to reference voltage.
The evaluation of an interruption is defined by the duration of the interruption.
The duration corresponds to the period during which the r.m.s. values measured
remain less than 1 % of the declared value.
As a consequence of no measurement during a half cycle at the beginning and at the
end of an interruption, interruptions with a duration shorter than 20 ms are not measured with
the required accuracy. For the same reasons, the accuracy of the duration of an interruption is
equal to:
20 ms
for categories 1 and 2 equipment

23002Ren9531

19

July 1995

2.5.4 Measurement evaluation


Indicatives values are given in EN 50 160.
- Observation periods of one year for category 1 and case by case for the other
categories.
- Determination of numbers Ni:
Duration of
interruptions

Duration < 1 s

Number of interruptions

N1

3 min > Duration 1 Duration 3 min


s
N2

N3

The evaluation of N1, N2 and N3 could be made not only in terms of the individual events but
also by determining "equivalent interruption" as a combination of a sequence of individual
events or by neglecting interruptions shorter than a threshold value.
2.6 Temporary power frequency overvoltages between live conductors and earth
2.6.1 General
Only categories 1 and 2 instrumentation are concerned by overvoltage measurements.
2.6.2 Measurement
The instrumentation shall measure the r.m.s. voltage every half-cycle.
2.6.3 Specification of the instrumentation
An a.c. voltage that fulfills requirements of reference conditions is applied at the
instrumentation input ; at zero crossing, the voltage shifts to a fixed value equal to3 times the
nominal voltage in less than one half cycle. The measurement equipment has to measure the
new voltage value at the end of the first half cycle following the modification of the voltage
magnitude (excluding the half cycle during which the voltage modification takes place).
Any other functional arrangement giving equivalent or improved performance is
acceptable.
The instrumentation presents with respect to the nominal value an intrinsic error r on
the overvoltage less than:
- for category 1 equipment: 0,5 %,
- for category 2 equipment: 2 %.
The same process applies when returning to reference voltage.
The evaluation of an overvoltage is defined by a pair of data:
23002Ren9531

20

July 1995

- duration,
- magnitude.
The duration of an overvoltage corresponds to the period during which the r.m.s.
values measured remain more than 110 % of the declared value. The magnitude of an
overvoltage is defined as the ratio expressed in % between the maximum value during the
overvoltage and the declared value.
As a consequence of not measuring during a half cycle (i.e. during the voltage
change) at the beginning and at the end of an overvoltage, overvoltage with a duration shorter
than 20 ms are not measured with the required accuracy. For the same reasons, the accuracy
of the duration of an overvoltage is equal to:
20 ms
for categories 1 and 2 equipment.
2.6.4 Influence quantities at the specified operating range
For this measurement mode, the range and the accuracy of some influence quantities
given in sub-clause 1.3.2.3 Part 1 are extended. The following table gives the variation range
and the accuracy of the concerned quantities:
Accuracy
Nature

Variation range

Voltage

greater than 200%

magnitude

up to 200%

2%

5%

Frequency

from 42.5 to 57.5 Hz

2%

given by

Harmonics(THD)

0-20 %

2%

manufacturer

23002Ren9531

21

category 1

category 2

given by manufacturer

July 1995

2.6.5 Measurement evaluation


Indicatives values are given in EN 50160.
- Observation periods of one year for category 1 and case by case for other
categories.
- Determination of numbers of overvoltages Nij :
Overvoltages /

t<1s

1st<1 min

t1 min

110 < magnitude 120


%

N11

N21

N31

120 < magnitude 140


%

N12

N22

N32

140 <magnitude 160 %

N13

N23

N33

160 <magnitude 200 %

N14

N24

N34

magnitude >200 %

N15

N25

N35

Duration "t"

2.7 Transient overvoltages between live conductors and earth


The measurement of transient overvoltages is well established on the basis of the
gained experience.
Specific measurement instrumentation is needed in relation to the nature of the
phenomenon.
2.8 Supply voltage unbalance
2.8.1 Measurement
The instrumentation shall measure the r.m.s. unbalance voltage(8) . Each basic
measurement value is the true r.m.s. value over a fixed 10 minutes period(9) . Every
measurement updates the previous one at the end of the 10 minutes period.
2.8.2 Specification of the instrumentation
(8) The unbalance voltage is given by the ratio below, expressed as a percentage:

Vi

negative sequence voltage


positve sequence voltage
Vd
(9) 10 minutes true r.m.s. value as stated at following footnote 10, thus giving priority to the aspect of
additional losses.
Uu =

23002Ren9531

22

July 1995

When a 3 phase a.c. voltage fulfilling the requirements of reference conditions and
presenting an unbalance ratio between 0 % and 5 % is applied at the input, the
instrumentation presents an intrinsic error r less than:
- for category 1 equipment: 0,2 %,
- for category 2 equipment: 1 %.
Category 3 equipment are not concerned with unbalance measurements.
2.8.3 Influence quantities at the specified operating range
For this measurement mode, the range and the accuracy of one of the influence
quantities given in sub-clause 1.3.2.3 Part 1 are extended. The following table gives the
variation range and the accuracy of the concerned quantity:
Nature

Variation range

Accuracy

Phase to ground voltage

0 - 200 %

Harmonics (THD)

0-20 %

2r

2.8.4 Measurement evaluation


- Observation period of one week in fixed steps of 10 minutes.
- Determination of the number of 10 minutes intervals during which:
- the line to line supply voltage is within 15 % of its nominal voltage: N
- the unbalance 10 minutes measurement exceeds 2 % (3% in some area) and the
line to line supply voltage is within 15 % of its nominal value: N1
2.8.5 Limits for compliance
The requirement of the standard is fulfilled if:
N1/N 5%
2.9 Harmonic voltage
2.9.1 Measurement
Measurements give true r.m.s. values relative to the nominal voltage over either 3
seconds or 10 minutes intervals(10) .
(10) In the case of an effective measuring time equal to 10 minutes (no gaps between measuring windows), the

10 minute r.m.s. value is the true r.m.s. value evaluated with an integrating time of 10 minutes.
When the effective measuring time is less than 10 minutes (with gaps between windows), the integration time
for the evaluation of the r.m.s. value is obviously equal to the effective measuring time.
The 10 minute r.m.s. value UhSh for a voltage Individual Harmonic Distortion of order h , is then given by:
23002Ren9531
23
July 1995

2.9.2 Specification of the instrumentation


The instrumentation shall comply with the IEC Publication 1000-4-7.
When an a.c. voltage that fulfills requirements of reference conditions combined with
permanent individual harmonic voltage is applied at the instrumentation input, the
instrumentation presents an error given in IEC 1000-4-7:
- for category 1 equipment: class A,
- for category 2 equipment: class B.
Category 3 equipment are not concerned with harmonic measurements.
2.9.3 Influence quantities at the specified operating range
For this measurement mode, the ranges and the accuracy of some influence quantities
given in sub-clause 1.3.2.3 Part 1 are extended according to the indications given by IEC
1000-4-7.
2.9.4 Measurement evaluation
- Observation period of one week in fixed steps of 10 minutes.
- Determination of the number of 10 minutes intervals during which:
- the supply voltage is within 15 % of its nominal value: N
- the individual harmonic 10 minutes measurements exceed the values defined in
EN 50 160 and the supply voltage is within 15 % of its nominal value: N1
- the T.H.D. 10 minutes measurement is greater than 8% and the supply voltage is
within 15 % of its nominal value: N2
2.9.5 Nominal value and limits for compliance

N
2
/N

U
U hSh =
hVs, i

i = 1

where:

N
= number of 3 seconds r.m.s. values evaluated during any interval of 10 minutes
UhVs,i = i th 3 seconds r.m.s. value of the harmonic voltage of order h, given by:

U h, k 2 / M
=
U hVs

k = 1

where: M
Uhk

= number of samples in the effective measuring time of about 3 seconds


= individual harmonic voltage of order h of the kth sample (each sample is
relevant to a single calculated Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) value Ch
corresponding to the chosen sampling window Tw).
The THD is then evaluated from the measured IHD values, with a similar approach.
23002Ren9531

24

July 1995

The requirement of the standard is fulfilled if:


N1/N 5%
and N2/N 5%
2.10 Interharmonic voltage
If the measurement concerns an interhamonic with a specific frequency, the
specification of the measurement instrumentation is equal to that for harmonic components.
If the frequency range of the signal is unknown and wide, the frequency bandwidth
has to be split into several bands. The results of the measurement is in relation with the
bandwidth of each band.
This phenomenon is still under consideration.
2.11 Mains signalling voltage
2.11.1 Measurement
The measurements give the mean value, not true r.m.s. value, over a fixed interval of
3 seconds.
2.11.2 Measurement evaluation
- Observation period of one day
- Determination of 3 seconds interval during which the supply voltage magnitude is
within
15 % of its nominal value: N
- Determination of 3 seconds interval during which the average value of the signalling
voltage exceeds the curve define in EN 50 160 and the supply voltage magnitude is
within 15 % of its nominal value: N1
2.11.3 Limits for compliance
The requirement of the standard is fulfilled if:
N1/ N 1 %.

23002Ren9531

25

July 1995

PART 3: WITHSTAND AND IMMUNITY CHARACTERISTICS


3.1 Permanent monitoring
For permanent monitoring it is important that the measurement instrumentation for
the voltage characteristics is able to withstand and be immune to external electrical and
mechanical stresses identical to those specified for electric energy metering.
The following specifications are accordingly taken from standards already in use in
the energy metering equipment (EN 61036), when it applies.
3.1.1 Requirements
3.1.1.1 Mechanical requirements
See sub-clause 4.2 of EN 60136
3.1.1.2 Electrical requirements
See sub-clause 4.4.1 and 4.4.5 of EN 60 136
3.1.1.3 Electromagnetic compatibility (EMC)
See sub-clause 4.5 of EN 60 136
3.1.2 Tests and test conditions
See sub-clause 5 of EN 60 136
3.1.2.1 General testing procedures
See sub-clause 5.1 of EN 60 136
3.1.2.2 Tests of mechanical requirements
See sub-clause 5.2 of EN 60 136
3.1.2.3 Tests of climatic influences
See sub-clause 5.3 of EN 60 136
3.1.2.4 Test of electrical requirements
See sub-clause 5.4 of EN 60 136
3.1.2.5 Tests for electromagnetic compatibility (EMC)
See sub-clause 5.5 of EN 60 136

23002Ren9531

26

July 1995

3.1.3 Recommended test sequences


test
sequence

Test description

n
1

Subclause
of Part 3
3.1.2.4

Insulation test

1.1

Impulse voltage test

1.2

AC voltage test

Accuracy tests

Part 2

Electrical requirement tests

3.1.2.4

3.1

Circuits load

3.2

Influence of temperature rise

Electromagnetic compatibility tests (EMC)

4.1

Radio interference measurement

4.2

Fast transient burst test

4.3

Withstand to HF electromagnetic field

4.4

Withstand to electrostatic discharges

Dry heat test

5.2

Cold test

5.3

Damp heat cyclic test

3.1.2.3

Climatic tests

5.1

3.1.2.2

Mechanical tests

6.1

Withstand to vibration

6.2

Shock test

6.3

Spring hammer test

6.4

Tests of protection against penetration of dust and water

6.5

Test of resistance to heat and fire

23002Ren9531

3.1.2.5

27

July 1995

3.2 Temporary surveying or general purpose investigations: general mechanical


requirements
For these two categories of instrumentation only mechanical requirements are
recommended.
Reference is made to sub-clause 4.2.1 of EN 60136

23002Ren9531

28

July 1995

Publications Order Form


Name: ...............................................................................................................................................
Position:............................................................................................................................................
Undertaking: .....................................................................................................................................
Address:............................................................................................................................................
Town: .......................................................Country:..........................................................................
(with postal code)
Telephone: .......................................................Fax:..........................................................................
(with regional code)
E-mail:
p Yes

EURELECTRIC member:

p No

Title1

Reference No.

(Tick the appropriate box)

Quantity

To be returned to:
Concetta PALERMO Union of the Electricity Industry - EURELECTRIC
Documentation
66, Boulevard de lImpratrice BE-1000 Brussels
Tel.:
Fax:

+ 32 2 515 10 00
+ 32 2 515 10 10

E:mail: cpalermo@eurelectric.org
Web:
http://www.eurelectric.org

Some documents are available in French (FR) and German (DE).


Please indicate the language of your choice, when possible.

Boulevard de l'Impratrice, 66
B 1000 Brussels
tel: + 32 2 515 10 00 fax: + 32 2 515 10 10
http://www.eurelectric.org

You might also like