Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
The present paper involved a study on Glocal communication strategy adopted by select global companies while
foraying into India and Indian companies foray into the foreign markets. Glocalization concept in specific terms
implies Think Global and Act Local which has been developed through Japanese business practices. The
requirement of this global localization idea arrived in the late 1980s to bridge the gap between local, regional,
national, global management of the businesses 20.
PROBLEM STATEMENT
I do not see anything wrong with McDonalds doing business in India. After all, it is not McDonaldization
that we know of; It is a Big MaCcomodation As quoted by A Senior Bureaucrat in New Delhi 3. This is
exactly what Glocalization concept in specific terms implies and is usually practiced by the global giants. The
present paper would highlight on the dimensions of Glocal strategy with a focus on cultural adaptability of
global MNCs who have entered into the Indian market across industries and Indian MNCs glocal strategy in
foreign markets.
Going global and Going international are entirely different. In order to go global, one requires a global
mindset; while to go international, historically means to supply out of India. A blend of both is utmost
necessary in creating a global organization system 24.
INTRODUCTION
Alan Rugman in his book In The End of
Globalization: Why Global Strategy is a Myth &
How to Profit from the Realities of Regional
Markets. Says Think regional, act local; forget
global. where-in he emphasizes that we have
reached the phase of globalization death and argues
that globalization never existed at all as envisioned
6
.
Today,
to
be
successful
multinational
organizations;
the
GLOCAL element
is
indisputably important for all the managers,
leaders, entrepreneurs with respect to various
flavors and dimensions of the business operations.
The concept of GLOCAL strategy focuses on a
core global standard strategy which has local
elements and in turn signifies localization of the
global strategy.
The major GLOCAL mix
strategic components include organization mission
& goal, organizational resources and Locus
(Geography and Control). The synergy of the 3
constituents facilitates localization, adaptation and
customization of the worldwide resources, goals
and location of the firm 16.
The focus of the paper would be studying one of
the Global elements which is the marketing
strategy of select global companies entry in India
and Indian MNCs which have entered into foreign
markets to provide a glocal perspective. In
particular, the critical factors which will be
examined for each select company would be Brand
www.borjournals.com
METHODOLOGY
This research paper would follow a case study
approach of select companies which would be from
the Global Fortune 500 Companies for year 2011
and other successful Indian multinationals from the
varied industries like Apparel (Nike), Beverages
(CocaCola), Food Services (McDonalds), General
Merchandisers (Wal-Mart), Food Consumer
Products (PepsiCo), Household & Personal
products (P&G), LG Electronics, Hyundai Motors,
Kelloggs, Toyota, Pizza Hut etc. Indian MNCs
would include Dabur, TATA & Marico.
The sample size would be approximately 3 Indian
companies and 8 multinationals (global). Data
collection would be specifically secondary data
from various conference papers, e-databases,
articles, journals pertaining to information on the
Glocal element Marketing strategy of the select
multinational companies viz-a-viz their ability to
get connected culturally into the local communities
through the global network.
30
CONCLUSIONS AND
IMPLICATIONS
The scope of the research paper was to discuss the
concept on glocal communication strategy adopted
by various global and Indian companies while
entering the foreign market. This analysis and
discussions has been administered by selecting
certain successful companies from the Fortune 500,
2011 listing and other successful Indian companies
which have made a mark in India. This concept and
discussion can be extended through primary data
collection methods to further strengthen the topic
into various dimensions of global, local and glocal
strategic implementation.
KEYWORDS: Glocal, Global, localization,
globalization
DATA COLLECTION
ENTRY OF INDIAN
FOREIGN MARKETS
COMPANIES
IN
www.borjournals.com
31
COMPANIES IN
www.borjournals.com
32
www.borjournals.com
33
GLOBAL STRATEGY
LOCAL STRATEGY (Entered UAE
1987)
www.borjournals.com
INDIA (1884)
CPG (Consumer Packaged Goods)
Dabur ranked 200 in the Fortune India 500 list that ranks India's 500
largest corporations 2010-11 (Dabur, 2013).
Priced for and targeted at the mass market (Arab consumer Arab
female, Asian consumer Asian male, African consumer African
male & female)
Adopting local Diaspora, using local ingredients
The template for Daburs international operations focuses on the
aspect of localizing whereby the technology of the new geography
should be in sync with Daburs technology for adapting to suit local
needs. Local manufacturing units were also set up for the portfolios
of the Asian markets (Pakistan, Nepal, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka,
Malaysia). In Nigeria (customers beyond the Indian Diaspora),
under the product portfolio of skin care, Dabur launched an herbal soap
with localized ingredients.
Challenge rested on Dabur when it entered the Nigerian market
(African market which was beyond the Indian Diaspora). Dabur had
traditional strengths in personal care (hair oil) and not oral care and
home care which the African market was dominant in. Hair care
products sold in Nigeria are cosmetics and the consumers are used to
34
RANKING
TARGET AUDIENCE
GLOBAL STRATEGY
LOCAL STRATEGY
TABLE 3:
MNC NAME
ORIGIN
INDUSTRY
RANKING
TARGET AUDIENCE
GLOBAL STRATEGY
Tata Group
INDIA (1868)
Engineering (Tata Motors, Daewoo-2004, Jaguar and land rover-2008),
Materials(Tata steel, Corus: UK, 2007), IT(TCS), Consumer Products
(Tata Tea, UK-2000), Energy(Tata Power, Indonesia-2007),
Chemical(Tata Chemicals: Indo maroc, Morocco-2005), Services (Taj
Hotels, Starwood group: Australia, 2005)
Tata Motors ranked 359 and Tata steel ranked 370 , Fortune 500 list
2011
Driving for Multi-industry global leadership
To be seen as a local company than an Indian company.
Tata philosophy was to think global locally to be a contributing part of
those countries into which it expands to experience the pain and
ecstasies of the community.
Thus local management and working to augment and support them was
the focus point.
The local strategy adopted operating with the local government or
culturally by involving in the various activities like the Indian food
festival of the music program.
Marico
INDIA (1988)
CPG (Consumer Packaged Goods)
Targeted at the mass market having the household name in India
Expansion into similar markets but realized that it had to move from
India-centric approach to serving local needs of the local markets to
penetrate further.
Set up local manufacturing plant in markets whose consumption
pattern was very similar to Indian markets which would be within the
South-Asian markets;
However, to penetrate beyond South Asia, Marico realized that it
needed to innovate and move from Indian-centric approach to the one
that serves the needs of the local markets.
Marico learned that Arab consumers did not prefer the smell of
coconut oil; they preferred less stickiness and would use the product in
an environment with high water chlorination which damaged hair. To
address this concern, Marico launched a reformulation of the product
that counteracted the harmful effects of chlorine.
www.borjournals.com
Coca-Cola
U.S.A (1886)
Beverages
Number 1 in Beverages, 70th overall (Source: Fortune 500, 2011)
Most Coke products satisfy the requirements of all age groups ranging
35
GLOBAL STRATEGY
LOCAL STRATEGY (Entered India 1993 after a 16 year absence since 1977)
TABLE 5:
MNC NAME
ORIGIN
INDUSTRY
RANKING
TARGET AUDIENCE
GLOBAL STRATEGY
LOCAL STRATEGY (Entered India
Oct, 1996)
TABLE 6:
MNC NAME
ORIGIN
INDUSTRY
RANKING
TARGET AUDIENCE
GLOBAL STRATEGY
Wal-Mart
Rogers (Arkansas - 1962) 19
General Merchandisers
Number 1 in General Merchandisers, 1st rank overall
(Source: Fortune 500, 2011)
Wal-Marts positioning strategy Always low prices targets middleclass and lower-middle class customers (300 million approx.).
Global presence in Mexico, Brazil, Argentina, Hong Kong, Indonesia,
Korea, China, India and in every country Wal-Mart says Discount
retailing is a very multi-local business where local market share is
critical.
Localization of the product mix being one of the prime corporate
values Wal-Mart holds, discount retailing has been a multi-local
business agenda of the company with a local partner - Bharti
Enterprises, local government, local purchasing power, local
economies of scale and local logistics.
As per the company; their policy has always been At Wal-Mart, we
go to great lengths to ensure our international stores reflect the local
needs and wants of our customers
TABLE 7:
www.borjournals.com
36
Kellogg
ORIGIN
INDUSTRY
RANKING
Michigan (1906) 12
Food Consumer Product
Number 5 in Food Consumer Product, 199th rank overall (Source:
Fortune 500, 2011)
Breakfast Cereal (Cornflakes) for the Indian market promoted by
targeting Indian Women
Concept of Cold Reception Consuming breakfast cereal with
something cold : i.e. pouring cold milk on your breakfast cereal like
cornflakes which was a success in America, Britain, Japan, Korean and
China but a disaster in India.
Indians have the habit of having hot or lukewarm milk which makes
the flakes soggy as opposed to the West. Indian women were used to
the breakfast palate of being hot, fresh and savory.
They began to innovate with the new product development of wheat
and rice cereals like Chocos & Frosties with flavors appealing to the
Indian local cultural habits.
Japan (1945) 17
Moto Vehicles - Automobile
Not in the listing of Fortune 500, 2011
Middle and Upper class segment
Toyota philosophy in global markets localize / adapt the design and
production facilities of its products to build long-term relations with
the suppliers and labor of the local market.
Affordability of the Indian consumers : It clearly understood the
means to enter the Indian market which was focus on the middle and
upper class segment as the economy and small car segments were
already crowded with less opportunity to do business.
Toyota launched Camry and Corolla which are the middle and higher
car segments which have been a great success for the company. Toyota
focused on minivans which had very little competition and targeted
large and bigger families.
www.borjournals.com
U.S.A (1981)
Music TV Network
Not in the listing of Fortune 500, 2011
Middle class segment, youth culture
Musical genres mostly pop music, soft rock, Latin pop, and hip hop
music was the programming culture targeted towards youth at the
global scenario especially in Latin America. Each of the music genres
included music in English and Spanish language.
MTV at no stage bombarded the Indian teenagers with American
programming (preferring rap and rock music) rather tailored its
operations to fit the masses. MTV Bhakra, MTV roadies, MTV
Web Watch, MTV Kitne Mast Hai Zindagi being some innovative
programs launched by MTV.
MTV is programmed differently in different countries. MTV
India focuses on color, self-efficacy, full of humor and huge street
culture. MTV being a national music channel now also competes
37
Korea (1958)
Electronics & Telecommunications
Not in the listing of Fortune 500, 2011
Cater to the needs and requirements of the diverse customers, primarily
focus on semi-urban towns and rural markets.
Extensive market research, product localization and aggressive and
large scale advertising campaigns has been the key drivers for Koreas
LG Electronics.
"One reason LG is successful in India is that we listen carefully to our
customers. We have realized that not just localization, but microlocalization, is required." According to an official of LG Electronics
9
.
LG focuses on customizing its products based on the customer
lifestyle. E.g. Since in many Indian families, washing machine is
operated by house maids who are either illiterate or cant read English;
LG's alternate strategy was to incorporate speech technology that
allows the instructions in the various local languages. Innovations that
fit every customers lifestyle helped LG to connect to its customers 9.
CONCLUSIONS AND
IMPLICATIONS
The scope of the research paper was to discuss the
concept on glocal communication strategy adopted
by various Indian and Global Companies while
entering the foreign market. This analysis and
discussions has been administered by selecting
certain successful foreign Companies from the
Fortune 500, 2011 listing and other successful
Indian Companies which have made a mark in
India and foreign market. This concept and
discussion can be extended through primary data
collection methods to further strengthen the topic
into various dimensions of global, local and glocal
strategic implementation.
LITERATURE CITED
[1] Bansal, N. (2009). Walmarts Strategy through
the World. Retrieved October 1, 2012 from
Business magazine Web site:
[2] http://business.in.com/article/magazineextra/walmarts-strategy-through-theworld/6042/1
[3] Bhan, N., Nemer, B. (2006). Brand Magic in
India. Retrieved from Bloomberg business week
Web site:
http://www.businessweek.com/innovate/content
/may2006/id20060508_952455.htm
www.borjournals.com
38
www.borjournals.com
[22]
http://www.iitk.ac.in/infocell/announce/co
nvention/papers/Marketing,%20Finance%20and
%20International%20Strategy-01R%20Krishnan.pdf
[23]
Management Paradise. (2011). Marketing
Plan Coca Cola. Retrieved October 1, 2012
from Web site:
[24]
http://www.managementparadise.com/foru
ms/marketing-management/4403-marketingproject-coca-cola-india-3.html
[25]
Raghavan, L. (2007). Lessons from the
Maharaja Mac: Five rules for entering the
Indian market. Landor Associates. Retrieved
October 5, 2012 from Web site:
[26]
http://www.landor.com/index.cfm?do=thi
nking.article&storyid=559&bhcp=1
[27]
Toyoland. (2011). Toyota History:
corporate and automotive. Retrieved November
16, 2011 from Web site:
http://www.toyoland.com/history.html
[28]
Toyota. (2011). Toyota Legacy. Retrieved
October 4, 2012 from Toyota Web site:
[29]
http://www.toyotabharat.com/inen/about/t
oy_legacy.aspx
[30]
Walmart. (2011). History Timeline.
Retrieved September 23, 2012 from Walmart
Corporate Web site:
http://walmartstores.com/AboutUs/7603.aspx
[31]
Wikipedia. (2011). Glocalisation.
Wikipedia The Free Encyclopedia.
[32]
Kumar, N., Mohapatra, P., Chandrasekhar,
S. (2009). Seeking Global Consumer Brands
from India. Harvard Business Press.
[33]
Kumar, N., Mohapatra, P., Chandrasekhar,
S. (2009). Tata Group Driving for MultiIndustry Global Leadership. Harvard Business
Press.
[34]
Chandrasekhar, R. (2009). Dabur India
Ltd. Globalization. Richard Ivey School of
Busines, The University of Western Ontario.
[35]
Ramachandran, J.,et al. (2004). Indian
Companies in Overseas Markets: Perspectives,
Patterns, and Implications. Retrieved October 1,
2012 from Web site:
[36]
http://www1.ximb.ac.in/users/fac/Amar/A
marNayak.nsf/dd5cab6801f1723585256474005
327c8/060eac2cc3faa40265256c78003ff893/$F
ILE/Indian%20companies-colloquium.pdf
39