ea The Reappeerarce ct Pace 190m, encouterabiliy i describod in tems ofa faceo-fce mesg in the terse of» selghbarood for exami, the Yount” of region ™ The Bava is more than merely ik makes good on a promissory wae fat boved in Heidegger's ery masterwork, and thn neglected out of 3 pe fccpation wih ie nd tempor For Heleegger now procs hat “be peli of which be bd event spoken in is ects on Logic 925 {oa6: another way of conefving Beng apart from be ba of tie." nh comia ting (od efusng Wo itera place nthe aermath of Beng and Tone, Heidegger a it susceds nealing hime from ie Imsrownes of thse cooceps of Being which merely hase tobe avible [dvwich ae forte tos pr rer ough He has venerated i= {Ei Yom the narrowness of bi own concepts of ine and temporality tha sod ode is vison of an aentve out Benga iso via ple (God thus as via the Opes region, things and nearnes). The ceo and Aligessive characte of Heldegge’ ph over marth for does shoal ‘ot blind ws to he fat at he ends by giving the mot sgetv ad ss tained wean’ of place in hs etary eis remartblecooogh hat Heidegger managed 1 o justice wo plce in tte ac of his owa tempore, What Bere di fo uation Hide Uf does for place-—despte the primacy he acoso tenporaiy, Ad ts Ae mare remaable n Hendegger scsomplchee (his even though be ‘acl teases plac elf aa hamat op To recognize he ingeiece [St place in Beg ose ita th ery seing ofthe event of Approiation ‘Sms nx call for tuning plc nto tin top of pops dscoase. Kis {S sehmowtedge instead te spoil vale of prulg, even trough the most ‘Shoow cro, apology of Being" Buco. Tatelg, 12 Giving a Face to Place in the Present Bachelard, Foucault, Deleuze and ‘Guatari, Derrida, Irigaray veything takes fom, even ia in "A son Bachar The Pots of Space Spe is everyre open. We are i his ple —eaLueNaney, The Inperatie Conary In racing ou Heldgg'thnkng stout place and “varios phenomenal sp tile och epi nd ighboriood, we have pused plc ino some tis more rane enters dsr mre. We hve eared mich about the panoply of meanings at place can exit 5 wel the ange of les it (sume in wey eget ones te effets akosopie—led- Ing eto vor place's "tee sop," Ze Spe Rum —it bas allowed us to ‘recap, indeed wo reveogne, the power of place. Eales easomin of ace (ict ate nomen of ks ding ecogaln ne Wes} ead {Oe fe as we sec in Aha fnpmenaryulerstces end Artes ‘meses ok ore a he Opposite exteme hey we efsve nd paegyril, ain Lanblchur's aod Poca ham. Heldegget ‘Sores mil pth For im plac ining and valable indeed fen Iniapral, yt nt rometing 10 be adult as such I doesnot ke on {he conta highlighted sats Blog oe Beingin-th- wor, Tahoe {Langng, he Fourfld or he eve of Appropnion. Ye never becomes ‘meely parse on thse major terme, nor ts iY pest or of ving eis owe etres ad fn ts own neal ig "Te fact remains, bowever, ht fn the couse of Heiepger'sdawa-ot cxengerent wit lace, thephesomenca isl all 0 oe slips rom view ‘No prund ec, lace goes undergo, econ part of Heep’ oe plot plglogue wih te hiker sad oter concep The eu a the26 ‘he Reapperarce of Pace netstat oF nerment, Pl sae in he coting coro of Hee fs abyenhine ewer Fey hae coir, we ae let ak nat time 1 fee i ke of ev and sexi fl face? 5 ot ie 1 es cae Ov rea to pve x ew at, thal we can at at id oe doom neatly placed eve, nce asi? 1h at (od somes dtinty aha) the fomg shadow ty He impinge here esis vgn ofa enened nd nS esa pa of peng mined nathrs who ik in vty mk of Being He sg ae proved by Sc dey of fachard,Bael Foe, Delete and Cutt, Desi aoe iad Ney, it Gerany, Bean and Acad snd ate aed in North Arc, Relph, Tan, Eatin Sj Seok Moo Seger cman, Tc a Wale Ea of hese eet fr nceaied in faeioning est fle fo as ne ee cocoverar of he imporiance of plac 8c a gals ofc hing: as 0 tenes sens, Where Vitae at opt soething csening cnet as of place (85 Het tng regi ning) noe othe uae es aes acta anying ike + ei, much es nite h Intempo ruin of ac nse each ies 1 id plas at work Fak for fore Sngoing 08 dyna, igsedint ut someting cs: i oat oy adel, Foucault stra wort (Bey, Syd) Sem en tec, Llebve in ene eins od nl th Pease the rons of ore agian Cache OS5) 8 a tie open sn ety (can, Tan, Sot Rh ESA) earn Sep pls en the cy (Bei, Arey Wale ito a ee oe unl Guat), in ache (Dera, Escoman, Tech), madi ognny, Nam) ea th te tf ame 08 tos 1 i Cr abang oe only it amity resemblance of hanging aca cesT sogest at hr 0 Sng, much ee a pany fren (0 teas leet ras, To tis ete Pe af plac my acon all the ore hide, since et 02 ee Be lol sien signin incidents tobe rented ci aga Hior, “everghing fakes form, even i init” Or Ba yaks ace ina ave Yt intens meson athe subject of place, eof place in Western thought has rey calle form apes sc Book and dono want prolong i way. This st cope, ae coin mere sites of seer only hemos promi scorn wi Sempoary diets, ning ct tos wih am 2 to nse man Not aig fb ehaatine of i we _pressly philosophical ovlentainot neo are meant to serve as signposts for fur~ Civ Facet Pace inte Present a the exploration. Bt ty dosage ot ways in which wo revalrize place in Ur oie to gv potato place Tne gue tobe etd in re sees ‘i Weauon othe cuper—Bacelr Foal, Deleuze and Gastar, De 5S. Sad tigre cpu to acknowledge a appreciate more fly the ‘aces th pcs tae Be found with and In a aun ws ce nen as tig st Sigmund Freud oe of Angst 23, 1938 We do ot tage plc, we change our mate "Gaston Bata, The Pos of Space ato Bacher offers» ist refcing of plae—ia and hough he may ‘Se speifcaly, the pot imagen Bachela'sweisgs om the pocic eeadioe uted om the lt 19300 ut the ery 1960), he so of ‘Splenda rom continuing concer wit undestndng Bow poetic ‘hymen te bumanpyohe. As Bacher ty in La ret es SEES levlome (in) -Ifone ps inapes interes in chic ‘Rien. betre thoughts poses) vane cannot ep bot engnize hat the age of men is esti nage" To put iages i heir ince (eur ate place) id for hem x proper loca i he mind, Bee eat tesel? Arte fd sine tte soa “the place of ‘Raa bt be the ple of imager ato be avery flat pice than ‘Rim Bd ie mt wo be receive and abortive of images i ‘Azar at has if anything to Jo with pecs poston in Nerarchial ‘Muilcao te mst hres wey lnwhich concepts cei the ‘Hhomal salon Arstod'e acount). Metaphors ofthe pigeonole andthe [derive way to the spiders web or the Dechive as we bei o appre ‘vm iat ela pete agey: nese eforescenr. The very mel of Jakes era surface aoter stent stl theme brs be ese etme ine poyhi imlacemet of images nat how they ae “rnd yates if thirfae were tobe sy sande but ow hoy appeay ara sre that ofthe eal elf: "The pote tag” ries Bechler a The Pots of Space "is suden sec oa the rac ofthe eyeie I lnges ae ined efrescet phenomena, ten the place in Tic ey eppear tb apd of eeing or “reveberang”wit tem, erGlopelunt the Receptace the Tacs the sys Tie the Re prac mas be eompurtvely characters in oreo fsoete with te (SRE act a scr sertace The pete src mus send fort the Sng receiver mut ive pice them by folesane with tem,a8 Te Reapposance Pace shining wit tit momentary presence. Te snse of pace ta coun ere wth of lc si cota nd perdu Dut asi ighs up with he suden Spark ofa sngleskig age, Eke shooting tar in he dark bys of sieht "Atk nhs nus of Buchel’ works majors: the pata fy x tet the laity ofthe py In proposing that th sou provides lice for images acl i conesiog ot only Arte but Deserts ‘ell Coxe Art, he Holding that here avai ease of place for Tmonscsle tems plae ca be nonptyical nd yet sil cot fly a plc. {the ance werk, ely Planes aad his sucesrs had ded fo posit a ‘sly nonsenl fm of place, ta, “nelle plac.” (The aslogse in apace to nell lace fas we have sen, th infinite iagiory space tt medial thesogian took to be equal! to God) ln te meri, ‘Bacto endorses ster igpifcan except the sense-tound Ariote Tian cher: pyc place But fom he soul a place ore of pass ir sao fy fete fee of Desa, for how he sou as no extension of fy Kin. evideat Bacher, however, ta poetic images Gare op hehe and the place in whic hey do i pyc in mature. This tu toms ta peyeic place Is thee-dimesiong, noch ss thats scaly empty. Here thinking aguas bth Descartes and Pilopons ‘ocean a he etemsion of soul a is own propre abd parame {erramong tem, spec Kind nsidenes sd sown modalities of a evant dept (hereby, for example, u poetic image may och the eps ‘fre sti the sac) "The more we tik i ist dct, he loser we come Fre, who sso props psytledeth and istioy and who, at he very ead fi ite Pocsined the wososiou tobe exteadod” Becher ware of he lralel omuse be is oe wit Freud-—and sith Jung aswell. Areltion of ‘Sng competion wih peychoanalysis palgble rom The Paychownly Sir of Pre (038) ©The Petr of Space (195) the evo books tat frame ‘aches thinking abst pete imager and te psyche: What sn ex9- {ona comme! in Hed, oan egy exceptional Gren in Jung” beoomes oe Bechlard agin of esearch tha deserves its own name: "tpossalyi” Tn tgoealya, desi peyton, depth paycnogy, psychoanalysis, Sd phewomencogy all come gee na coma eters, ae thc fe dened as be sypemaic pychnlogial study of he lcaliies of Ime ves Lew utd tha a tte, opal oss o he Pinca! properties of esa twgs, for stance te hose: “On whatever eschew examine ite hunt kage woud appear fo have become the ‘Gpography of ou nimate being" tee cvllay of apna is hither serious, opoand ue dermines temporocenaae The tote we ead 1 the topo of payee i, Nees ieee thot tis life--coutrary 10 what Kant and Bergson, James Caving a Facet Pace into Prosent Ey and Huse contend—is not merely fenton of ts datos ow. Spee ‘ita han ine the foem of inne sete.” When we look within ousves Fath lai gesture of Slt Augustine, we dont nda beer sequence of ‘omnis mich ess cabeonte fa” Gower instead, “all we know B® sof Baton nthe spc ofthe subi of being—a being bo does ‘ot want met sy and who, eves i the past when eset oot in search tings pst, wants ane pend” sgh" Wht intoxpecion ‘ees resins” memories al he more "sl fr being bt! pe ze" To comet re with he net fet is ot eng coastite Nogspty er ebiogaphy in arative terms ne ns i and mote rly do opty ofthe places one bas ited or expences far + Enewlege of inti, lcm in the spaces of ex inimacy Is ‘hore uge than determina of dos" Not ly moe urgent bat more Pas foie emporal contig fe gives aly "aso extras, fox xtara ee fob commence oer” ha ths way Buchel the bles on tine ater ta Being re eiveral hin space (8 Kant ad iy or Serpe oe ep sl (Bergson msstaned) ane aso ito payee spt "in coumessaveol space conaos compressed time nce, when we immn oreve in psjehiea pth ad tin Ay we find ta “hare sce severing nd tate unconscious fa oe ing set of pre drat ox ered amis, inpy abies" The fer we pute inert lacy othe wncoscas, he es impe= Uetecone te dcmoods of ne —wbeber a he eve of cases arin ‘rofunconcous Keaton To aim pyc lcfulnest st refomalle the Arcytn ssc: be psychical be in place. “Ph fs hen, Bacheard pes forthe peo sal sa lac cep cle or imagen dove a pst images. Ae sume ine mages offer a= ‘So et own content wheter hese coatens be coat, ev, it~ ui, o (gin) imagining. Senling on the src of the psyche, ‘Thies pocectng fom the dep, parca imapes ato place such Comnts flting thes nan nega bome fri comin prose ing Bachelor cals bis specllyimapnal sense of place ftcous pecs cont i he infeet pcs” ofthe svar, hi te TREE we lve” tha “elie pace Hosters vest “opp” hte pat of thone wh savor tiie inlacement—sbve al de ‘Sted ear of pouty. love fc nips goes had in hand with opm Js "fponalse ear he stamp of poplin” "Wo ar remied € Heidggn's cl for» poly of Bein” This al waned out of Heidegger concern io nove he peting chart of Thnkingeece chat at, song wi space, ssid to be “ill ved tree" Moreover ja space ras sud In Being and Toe 0 be “slit Upto pce” 0 pote images are for Bachlard spit ino te places they ofr for thir wm cae, Helge wool not aie tha poet abd=o The Reappewancect Pisce lwp come together inthe age term f which he wes deeply shy Fear would concert these sk he conjit vesture of oe ‘gam philoephzing so ay bares toplogy, logos (acount) of te pa ‘GES inn ouch poctzing inking fs ad where Being tds Hs ove (oe ace (Orachef >" What Baca calls "opoamays”Heieeget ere pera “im-pacing”o-plncig hog” In th a phase of is ee rch seks pinoy lnsped poec images as much # SeeSTasegacr in isle wating. ln heen bowers, despite a sted ‘nor tepeiag pct a8 of prvieged pot, he wo tikes past PeSpey. "The topology tat mts mot for Bacelrd i ot ht wich STEP nse “ou [ows] imate eing”* And the aia tremcendence of Hepp ein Beng is considered "Si intconons pore ani single"=exnnt be econced with he prc ‘Bt immancnce of Bache pean, anes preposag he pyc ashe seat ofl significa es sects dese ception of parcult iages, Sch images belie co ‘Sot ut arange hemssves it systema themes, for example aw te fre which taken togeter,cnstinte Bochelas owe ditve ‘aan Aa imagite poy opie tus inborn hema I 9 ‘eaty foal or avr he coment tee of given pi informs om witia, Moreover, here in principle mo init he umber otpcly regal thmes an subse al te bj to tpoanass. Yet cer ‘Menta undue piled ox notably, th fe Rouse, ich er eco ctuplrs of The Pets of Space ae deve Fo he house — 2 Sip wen ts als bomecomuin “Ie opm de ate ve Fe i iseger considered th world be “he ase in which mor ached wl ay he same of the image (nd menor) of he Tous wtich ensues owe poet placer habit by te rade ti ane topo! ake Aeon to the ule scares ofthe Supnedemerberes bse its naga tpoerapy, wil eve wa emcee feo ofthe sope and itso tpoaalyss "fe bur na prdoncl ety. As a home, is Your ist universe” a cou tao mod" hs auch, ik precedes ut sese a» more capecous ad aay weere. Buchel side piosopbes who post te univers ‘Rong before, ad independent of the house qua home. They lai © now viverse before they Kn the Rouse” whereas in fact wit Ruan ‘ngs now fasta never frget—are “he iain vaoes of inside se tape a set apa from be hosehe at a ae with TPS ot yt poeta” Sas ielevant » simple ut has mor, not Hee cea tan amuse, What mans isthe degree of itinacy {ee meni of our expense there; when tee are ssl Fels the very ‘Bilatine Semoon univers aa wotd—ich we cima elp but ma {be challenge o gan, we ru ot justo bay ut oa canonical et Has ieloe spved body -plce of atc of ex specie meaing ar Asti be propery i plc, to bein lice prope ous topes, is Fe Suis any foc meaning, whch he woul conser pisphially Trade or tun, tee to beng ln place exept for 3 tng who $TURES, Gecmincd te erntnace with Boal speciy—aod dep} Sorned wih seal sty. Mreoves, Jos 8 Aristotle dead wo plac 2 Ets pota or rlpowssgnieancs (lice fas sch signee only (San ant wee fm he polis fom te Fist Moves ary Sul tenplo restora kinds fiance to place—but ony insofar Place fr unertood a sncthing sexual sian to bela wih “T bgin wih thee ae bodes and there are plas Or rte: hte ae tearpacs For expe the mute’ toy a pce forthe prenatal (SU Her in place for someting" hats the his sowing body Sicha body pice not aly erica bed and reuse it May ‘Stozed by vial all ace, given the pied sats of clean. Mach ess tare (and presales cesar from a apie po Utviw) na woman'sboly place fr plesre—forjouinance gus ema EEE Sue peesure plc case for dub it coset, om Soin standin for he fi one of rss, bly je, pil ‘Stem tir ongne cote In crn (oh sale a fea) th By ‘Stun fal ts proper purpose Her, need, “fui ibe fundamental ‘Saailon™! Woman's pewu paral ismean revel the Bow (Ganchonen) of whatever in the plac th she is when se cot com (etnert wie’ perp, that un igh spl ou nthe eel ac? Eli (tambon ad of place i" Tapnay tes Aste’ tar of laceas-veselserosly—oe se ‘uty ng les eral tha the Master of Those Who Know, Not ony inthe tear venal be moved om one place to another, bu ever whet So moving ft eet place of place. froaling on Asse’ cose {Nout a infin ogra of place cogaiive nightmare fat rouse by ‘Rene and Zoo rgny afin theft tat ov oly Is woman 8 ne (ea abn) ba lae ine, in place, nt aly a ora (thin er bet ay eset or veep. Ie place twice over: a mote and at stoma" The rer ony itt mea wool ke to deny 29 sgnicat placement women, sal and plicl as well as pie and crt, byas ‘The Reappearance ol Pace posting "a ema placement" Woman, hough doubly imple, sb ei deprived fay “proper place.” Nevertheless, woman a plac, iss Tigany, Aor wom ss ple. Doers ve beeing sn gst ALEC Tea ttt siats intent he pce tts be ale ‘oneal, he pce tt be ye pes cell hough accel eters emo beleAnl aoe th er eth NS) hermetic e st asume epgs Dene Ie ina ree iin sal ‘Bt te aceon te passage between the iatinely ge and the ify Smut pbtemste terms of Zon’ pradoxes nd of Kans antso- ‘cristo deal wi plage a4 middle ground tetwen execs: the “ps ‘oe fom en place ante, fo et, reins the problem of place a ach, ‘hens wii te context of the mobility of er coatto."™” Rather than ‘far lig tet or at pce oc singe Rnd ter ez 1 mn), se ‘bon pace in rela fo» el, her own ote, oOo kia, she Bante pace abe sony across or hugh (0 aver) many oe“ PeStingos though sn indefaie wamber of bodies, hough nate, ove ‘Sa for the body ta coe served as place for me."™ The pony of Salva by pce glimmer jot whete diperson ino many ples ons {ing woman canbe natteed nome of places thal are never gnbered topter no saying se knows of bet" rir tale Bly Becomes te tenet etesive place Hts na aly through erection wth eer pacer buts though her owe beng My For het body is lady place Insofar a sl cael ‘fining ep. ‘Ste set move wile pice, Wii te teat of ple. Oe Nite bow cet msrp be arte alee sale ELA cea wee te oe ere she be ae conta 1 ‘aed mate beraen emetpe Neto ber cating ora SSSR chee in And rn sean erate ™™ Like the Patonic Reopcle—tke chore—woman-a-place is 8 moving once. Bute chs ri 8 dvb envelope of aes eovelping (Gsby the sin fhe etie Soy and enveloped ier vagina and wort). ‘(Soha oan extension witout (ex body asa velop of es) and “Emon wit (Oy vie of Re genalia aod intral ons). Wit ‘hn dul eens she wos bess ud lend tert an aby. IW she i anthng bt eendd Ina Caran verse, ware everythings ‘nernl to eveying ee: pots exo parts. Nor be “purely exter” Feito mame ofthe “outside thought of Deleuze and Guatar's nomad space, CGvng Face io Pace inthe Present oes Her ody lace i mat, stead of pres ina pares, fps ta = ‘op oer parte—both «woman's Wn bodypars and those of oes (ert i ie ver intercourse), Seal dese elects thi n= Notun in te fom os doble encour: "If ees sbi, x vble ‘ice ences, double envelope." Pu otherwise feninne bodyan pace i dowlyengasing: It engages ‘fy fs aac nogiaton (ey nes pacs ise ts 0), tu thnks ot active receptivity engages oes (cide, lovers, ote, ‘Got. For a woman's body, donblenes tet ofthe mat, 8 fo ody Arse dtm rosin pines “Te minima number, stely Speaking isto" If were not for he pregien woes ofthe ele ‘hays oem pac, her engagements could not take place. would ot ‘al besa ally engaged would aot be engaging tal, oven with ‘eae ‘Whereas Arist’ model of envelope as sc content esti 9 ‘enclosed wih et omever, igatay’s paradigm leads in js the op ote cso tow pros ody tht existe openness ofthe {per (esdeggers por s eaken over by Tay) "I qostion of ‘String ot jst comings bt i prince ope: "Worst ash ‘Brelaes ever a closed ferme) ose Pc sneer closed (ls). The runes ft or body] touch sit one antber while ll remaining pen Conary to Arsade’selsiny pss, Yo be doubly exvel- ‘he i tobe uly pen: pen fo ones wa oneseif ad ope othe (hc ose oneself But the here alo wih in the interval imag of theater in reetany or again a soon intercourse. These interaliztions| ‘tbe te Some of whlch acer in males ss wel) wuld no be posble less he wom’ ny were peso begin wit Or ore exactly haope ‘or alghty opt" (nomen). Foran Aiton container to be even fay porous dass sac the contents woud then ow ut an as ther pce, Conan ay sgnous eae ia loathing afi, The Snes te of Spinosdefision of God as + cau sul whose esence avelos existence tcl ah ily nto be envelope nhs way at {Srexewot withthe ney ht belongs tod follows fom this {ition that woman “des shave 0 est worn Becase, 6 wom, fer envelope is abwysalghlyopen.">" Woman falls th test of Gode— tol surpesgh piven that God rdefiaed by mea fr roen™—js a she {tobe a poprContier recely Because her bathe wrong Kind of fnvlope: tt a tt suroundet No wonde. As ley spe ™ this ouy apes open instead ling ly. Won’ od as an xy a0- toni aca: san openeclsare. To wondet gala wom’ bod, ullke God's or tht ofa physica hig isan owpanc ba. This mee fact makes al he ference Fo! a ody whose rary property is extension in anything ike Caen snse—inding28 ‘The Reappestance of Place Innit exesion inthe ese of Spina (r Mor) Gob 9 tera ‘lows, The sane ue forthe py hing ensconced ia an Asotin tuner ence when his hing water or i conceived w someting ‘Se Sed uniformly thera alagle seule substance witout zap. Just SSS stg in body tbat err passage, 0 eveope fou hte Both ve closed ion tenses, npr vo contin STM one coining ad the ter contained By he sme tke Seen om ee lminscallyuochanglng ad smovingSpiocz's God Se Ra place on Arts ofa definiion: the ist unchengeabe Tint of at which suru" itguay propose the fsa boy athe scandaloes exception hat proves sheers ptdig of lace ad es che npr nr station ‘ie he conry is vay (les slighl) open ad abways ose See inesog Ths peialy what we wines In the eof ips facia Ree IaT ip tever nop moring aod neve stop opening. They toch ech Serene not ony in sexu acy bat in every acy AB sch {hey perform lace; toey a6 out any bythe sme tke, ct it i Lis cere and ote a common tresbold when whats wii he Sap Senta withot play anda ony ws Cocalo ie iguana charaer—tat wet in such away a oii ingestion, rod Ceelyagueus; vac ter tun hard-edged, etmovng rater is ucly moved slpacing ter ha place by someting le. body Rupped ith ips exentalytwofld ms body equipped with arms, ‘EVPES ands Te ater thee pion whic Kant fos in is ny of 135 ete wh he surrounding wri wheres monte the amsacins ce tt worl and be wold wit Oo ran’ eaig ips are quasi. (isnot ys parts Tir brat being cal in question any snch (Bio at of “ne ody without organ” (Deewe nd Guta). Lips ‘Haprocs and eutigons counterparts sued at cea lina of ho (en tay ey ae tht body's fei bu teria dy wT tl hel emerges on gaa deslysogsxive wing, THe thet ted more bay han gary esl rr fact es it a (th scaly fretted) oa and (i) place are so niet linked 2 2 essay trchangeable The pln nol jst hat her place without ‘dy oe versn, Eu tht boy self place and that place is as bods ‘wd tthe by il senally speci" Deleuze nd Gata wish {Scola place and rez (herby elgg he scope of poe) ry [Botan teal ona place oa bod}—tereby etendng the range of ince na difrent deco. The effects burst the bounds of place when RES de are detemined bythe mits logan, sexally woes ee eaap sto make place something eat and alive interactve “td engatng envelope eat refs he eoelped dy i i yumi and a ee ere eault, both place and body lose the inelastic and Civ a Face to Paco te Present = pty! mots, for example, ose of rer exensa oF Go at Fit Mone [ERcred tom theve moog, ech takes on properis of the oer ace comes porns (and ot st lsd} ad ody becomes sounding (a ot Jat surounded) Both become ets moves, nd they move ogee el Iga) bere would aot et content with sch secping sae mensions of which on aly be detected in Huser ation of {Bc nme lao between he ved bys i fe word. Her concerns {a iment ay such popins in way tat ea nce ei, pois td rigs For ber the body tht mater sin place—the Body that is pr movable materi the fle Buy. Thanks 1 this oy and re rads implacenest a potent plc a eis inert rele Jounin ts coseqpnces. For example, as special polis inane FEota be fone bod, wheter as motto as fves, all 00 on be mer 2 plce for man fr his exuive ibabaton and explitaton— ‘Scr than place cojoyed by woman fr Uacl/ and om tis own ems. “tomenta Pesos ray ask bt Bios male lve: “Bat what 3 1 for you ober han that place fom which you sbsis? Your suse. Or ‘baunce™ Pace inva” she peace pint home: ris a 8 loving act shlrng double sheath, womsa’s Dy becomes formas“ ‘im ant unique plata whi whe dispston witha is offering ta woman a plas of hs nor even ay appreciation of the diflreat ft place the to aes mb pce ht ae ric wrenchangabl*” ‘Man ay soppy space for example the loa jace of ora expo tow_but bef fo provide place, Not oflering pace, ined being ety of plac seman esperysxks lace else’ In woman. "The mas ‘Binet tothe materiale a place" Why? Bena the female body seems toler te, poling fo satisy man's “ned fr ai lig for na vocal home = Wheter asa plac fr conesion ff ‘hut nivenre ot merely fr cotlann, wona’seneopiaplenclped foc bncomes mircoemiedvelig place, “te ony pace where he an vehi race plc fossa expoationr plese r commis tron, «ome pace, witht allowing woman fo sue () lee fe Eien boc place ay uch a once php snd metpsial—wih- ‘ut the opporny to be sera specie Sodylocs ti eter mee “Thing” ar ered essence To be place Such So lack a place fon ‘oe mica mining ei plae parted for is" om pl ped af ple She came tcome te pl he er no ‘mt seu isl ra Wit her sown wing i se Beh ‘eng ecu of wt abe ks 9 pope pce ™ ‘Aman 'stowised and preci n worman ss bomen doing8 ‘he Reappesrance Pace foc los domesticity “prevents im om fing eles the the tins“ Pressly becuse Western man ha Dull a wold dati sy nisi hig" he al the moe obtesed with unlag woman ino babi Fome-tody wit dasrows cnsegueaces fr both sexes and (th world large Al he se tine, e evades he peicity of is wn body, the Way iting betme a place istnvely efferent fm the pace pred by ‘cnt’ bay Feelng no med pce, be delegates o woman the ete ‘epost for body and pc. "Wh thc, st be done To aie a qpesion wit politica edges st call foc an aawer wit polialInplicaons Iga’ answer shat men ad ‘omc ought Yo cote abd cate places tht are eefitve of hi “Geena sexu enti" any mesg ob pose between man and ‘fom each ust bea pce, Sproat oad ore te, and twa Wilcke or she may ove”= eh difereatal placement shoal bappen or jut in tchtectrl terms ut sso i the two relms men and womea ‘hie mot uly "erent and "eonrpion” tat i the way they Sse ‘ak tou tings Sill mre bsizaly ought wo app nh or of ihe capt f each sent “cv he sl abd envelope the sl." Be- ‘Recamnen and women tee has fo be recgrocl (et asymmetries Bt "mul eaveloping in nove” x movement by which ech sex ‘ict he thet oh een td mca. But his cn Oey onee ore “nly in fretted placing of each in relation vo te oe, “which would ‘Seu that a each pete weve two places inerdeterining each tht, {tod one in the oex"™ Fo this ntrlacemet Lobe pose, Boner, Re coocept ote maselae would have wo ease fo eaveloe hat of he {ontin, se te feminiae atmo exes TCH exit nigcly foe te (masculine Intend, what Is uly ulgue—woman’ dovbly enoled feuy st be respected for what it «place of plssire and of posible frown that spotted by maa or desined fr is se. Then the fle Bhp will ke seen a ct case asa place with sown cal ecacy fate ha place that s merely an efa.™ hwil be place fo maa and ‘Tomato be rather than fr man ale Yo eve. Insad of woman being [Bnsed Bodapace inthe generic *he"~to make a place for ben here ‘ts teras—nan ight cone od bis place In he “she,” a n-ended flac a longer defined excosivel in pangenei masciie ays, “iguny moto male a tobelee tha the relonsBewoes the sexes— {npn telaons Setwete the Hinde of laces exch repress for the ‘utrrean be amcor ln any det or sple way. The sation 00 cactd fo ey satis Appeals o eipecty td respec fr ex: ples the mark these premume « homogenous cilia spac. ‘tie at stakes place soya and iosyocais ad inners i bow ks charecterii oon: bear oneal and pli us ee Ginga Facet Pace inthe Present 29 ‘nde! ech ober 3 peroas—eonret relations of intimacy and er ese (io vn) are of greater periaencs "Above al is aecesry {0 recognize tha hi histrel moment men canoe sil give ove ther places women (odo so would be ony to rife a aeaty overbearing [traction while wees, fr lp, mst cata ther ow places [er tema od fo each ober, These pce oght orf thir bly bids an inte, that ber ved Species, a elas possible ‘The same bos te fr mea, who mat atempt to consti pcs inthe light of hele que diferent organic sacar snd eomporeal pees. If the were to be done by th sexes, te pcs tht esl Wald moe e- ‘nly ret the ene seaal renttions and gender Heats of tse ‘ho sap them ad ve inthe ‘Dimensions oer tan he pols, puis religious ons ae so a stake in gays core shout dye. nded, gray mass that “the opeing inte enveloper between mes atd women should avays be smelted by God" The not rail 8 eactonry—atoupt2 Ima ate apeae. Not Ga,o,pace: Gos "hat which is omn place forte tn whe tos sel side ots thas const» we {ae (oy isle" Oterin sid: God tan alia envelope an et at velopeshimsliherlt (a everyting ee) and for ti eason isl ‘Sure, cms mt gan, however, does wo remain stisied wit pe ‘Relocate sch x “God” For ea piled pathy to gos a tells fo interpersonal le ob found nthe nique congo a the Female body, whic issu and tansendet intr very corporeal ‘Tank oe paco-tlording rtm, woman's body Both ecles God and moves toward Gods “Nothing (e] eee spa, inh er, ha ele feruaiy”>* Female sexualty i spiral astro it cents "space of trnrendence forthe sen" Iigary takes the ters "pra ia 2 (ule clemenlal sas, tat i ta akhemial miimation of he nite Stern of th female oly gua lace: This plas, he prodction of it ‘oy soe meme 2 tang fee. ee ‘rw iimacy I no more cle of than he Boy thal expec nd ‘tnd els imped wih vin nity, not wih pays immes). ‘And if eral dor eases toward th fn, oes oly by a Suble ‘novemeat back tad the ate mo hs body and taneoiy, tn toward God conte senha conalnr?” he sera hus he “ht divin fa" "The prado x eat it i precy boca the fein body enclosed twice ve tha It i capable of ean sown ses toward God Tis resumes in teeth Os no ngs conse abt bo cose 1 body abet a waprbody, ht Becomes” At the sae ime, sages I tary, womens God by vine of ber elfvansceading imanence: “She ‘Zondd be cause for herslf—and ina less contingent manner than men—if0 ‘he Reappeatance ot Pace she covlped ent, e-envelped bel in that envelope tat hei ‘Bice provide’ Only woman ean provide this envelope because oly an ogy, and has» pce, tat es envelope Het i tel, Tie ‘Rats ad fice Implved—oman moves a) and comets (vit) te ‘eligi eal evasion, despite te wsiqunes of woman's bodys, and dex spies engin of woman a" lace fatto" rignay bos TEESE Tume-come when a more mamced, ta 2 ore place SUR sna tuy.apeciie claoshp between men and women wil be Soni e tie, to, whe opnnese t efleret religions reepivity and [eSSiy wit emerge, Sbe ene he commentary on Ars Pics wih ‘ties of quests ht area suing as they ae promising ‘Det ma ce pli in ot rr sec as ms eile ‘Pecsnc! Ho Dees onus bean pce cs he a eid ale Fen ft Ho drone mit he to br fon pyc 0 ara pc empath emo 8 etter nge oval btwn maes aee™ How, ind, wless by ming room or place in theives of men ad woe {tC_plc i the bay aod a he by, place Derwera ods pice pve he divine? Such ver would not sbandon chromo 08 ‘att tly whone name Space” or “Time,” much ess on etal of Sel ato" hates, (ene netl, nflerettd) space woud be ome (oly-seraaly specie) lace re serch lor cena” wl cca i he oly place wher it can be sel: i eeapendered odie of tow who envelop tesises and rate aun embrace of mul eeoaion and aisacton wae mai ‘ning and respecting sexo ilerence, however Hid this ference may 22 Hom wii his embrace, the cctv eamestment of body and lace—and sof woman ad tu, paren and chisel and Cod— od Orel “Paat de Poles s°"Ths ptf view Ges te Station ie Gai) Te 7A beter Pee Ean amb 2.13 (1990: 111: “rm fe ty Tum we, feo eo he mae fr eens (th ‘tea rogaine renin ‘fice ahr oman mts” Buena ioe ops fhe p> Seihin npr "Wt hee in wchcae? eer ioe ‘Sti ene tetera’ ean tbe bowen some eal pce hee esol has ben sot ope’ at en fp en be renown eran soer he tgs wie pr” (Pee sca Ble "ee eles m1 (10) echt pol at ces tei mente Jape ett pe “Po Cre A Rep sper Doi” ase, 9.13 (98 4 “Sie cor D's phe in" ei 10 or lop beer a an dg, Kent Ble nl Chae W Moe, SS emt ge a en 7h a 1S for Em Eomananne 12% 9 ic. 7g ore doom friar of Wee eet se Dei Past def et tyr Pom a tere: aes De i Dcanion with isp Nori” In Deora nas ane 140 Nets to Pages 318-022 78 Pity Apri” 029. evo wih Nori eri ye it Ihe tt chee ava ben nee es eigenen ‘Povelindweting fr ants oven fs arte ace whee Sarai epee gna ring aca va wih ‘equine (Decor, 70 ‘9p. iy Two Agora” 0. ‘de html Bveercie 15 {Beis ag-a Abou henge Tchr hs toy: We so xtc trot png ee pa even nc orci, wc SEE toui pod ero Hee, Weg a como o oa? ‘SE oms ety pe we cy omen! ade at, ‘itil mcm no ea compa her ent vet SECRET inte te enn fence fh ey Tene ly af ay, of dele Bat tn our mnie qos sc wek torso goes gy ene ae Seale toby ty el (8 BS). “roi oman eu mp ily Ak og Si yw oy pera wot ee See Oleg Bs Pe p12, Cla Eun 2 ee in el nnn at de ceptions pe ning tations pono a ce Paceconang ow ee brn Ce 25 fe. 9.35: = sn cops ol pin eo aan, i i ee ee ele oni yi ESTEE we cons pop be Nae yo Fe ak Set fac omen tito nee oo > erst "pena cP eo ad snip ie npsono - Te Arson eo ome achice etc a cei hp oa ance l eee aS artes pe Wino yam ome eae Smt wee” Gummer Sour the enc snd eee ce "i Fas cy sewn bc we enc “ey sl, SSG of mln acm pow he ai Se 0 ea ae te ects enc sd a we “Mk acl Bence ae ont lhe poeny by Dei ise see ey, Patera A Reig, Ps i An Note Page 229 ” pe emt re eC of ar ity Sura morro Spaeanee teers Sosremeecn Sea eeattntgiopntommantine watery Serene ea meee LEDS S nea meee SoS canon nabrarntae pages ‘wer re Ca?) adele (pede) Her coco wih el es ‘Sacer hae aay pendo"arec ores migh a eh ‘Tove crilesion oats Gr wo mde eee ate se ‘hu rpeig hi seton) Ou soe npc bly hve wo cain ha lack and ene ctu detomined asec of Saco, moles te ‘macy apn crt Nv geno Forth it of ee oe els etn ee Mil Foca Te ry Soma ane Hay (New ‘Yous, 9to) st forte con, at Ba, Cee role Fo ‘amon he sermon (ev Rote 199) 9.72425, 28 Tis nah fhe ae Mi Gonder (New Ya Pant, 1982 “Chats we ining nope Seite» ply he ‘nano yom apse essing om Bah det {due mie he gel or no aol ay Ce aes) te Septic aa 8 ‘Sear apc iy ceo ea ier] csp te cape ie Se ay i ne pt os et bye tots Fr clan's eye The Pons of Reis Rei Rew trie Wain" Arma)" Bcd msn sing ree, ‘Sings ort wo ci tie oo compare ane of ‘ina her On anne nang sc Anima’ A Antony of Pree Noo ‘Tame ina ale: Sing 983) pi: or Del nd Cut se tog ma wend Pa ape See fu Maden oto wt ae Spc mero Tou, Teal ert it Pidy ithe fn codon, a the ison seals any enn meen nsw Exe Pann Odean oF Rest se Bom (Ca Sg Gg ire an Mace 3 snc sie food wk ner eveomen a be fe” (Spe of oe Oster Homan 39 On he alone te ting Dol Foe sein evaeinn wsplace ocxum e “Panera 3 Mha oes a Page 323-825, ancl uy ema ty plain: “the women mabe EE eae eng ery seve Botol om women do sy Me te wr (Cede 2) Mgr One nie repens etd i 3435 a ee heer oo place tint we er Biase Ae aeting Foritt min soe ple, pce api win thr rs eto wins od Forth wry enon sce het ee ac pce ote nang” (ced Sil mn ae ry cmmenaram td eased iS Sami, The Coney of ‘ace Le Rept) Se era etal Te Pech "san i einen (96 mi 5 er a. a le ts et ae sa ce pa. te fps eva ae ck Fa hl tne fis eon ate ton“ Wora, Ca, Delia pace, Ti nd Fitch dee oan lame sa ataing and eats le ree ey mh coat forma’ epi nd Ae ae ag pamela wheel een Pata ad De ae pera” pain be ese of stil Site SENOS wots eccie ath pe ne”) recur aad Gaye nino). Arde inet i alo a gee peta ine, at a ewe pli, Be cre aot conned yey Spend udinpenden er et yk “Tre te) toms ae To eae ord coming pa, To pes td th tess, FB oe ao er imetemianns At stn. Toy ea? (4-8; ‘ny tae) ne cso te ceet tne ier emma ots Counon (New Ye Sok, 8, 99-108 ae tcermten (von wom si] Ferner te tame as) The ask of engages ot ls Pacts cnc or by Mee ont’ obcion Dat emis sh i rks eese Dat meng tht ue li soba (Se Wate ony, The Ve anh midi 33-38) sc OS ese ssw, ier” Cs he aes reer tne pgs cme See-Toe via oft Fe A Reading of The TRIN nd heb Te nerwnng—De Cha in An Es of Sea cone eee Note to Pages 325-827 a 10, “Ceing nthe cecum mew Th pening pees” mecca 1 Cli a) Sa[owYo Rtg, 99) 39 tre nea Se sd “Thre eto aches Dee mies nd ictus in ch nebo eb oc Be PEE Sict sath mera ch oy fa (i). sa pe: A Reng Spe, Eis “Of Gol" An ES of Seal ieee, 5 a, cystine wh eters an” (The Eco. 2a Sy apse an npr eran ih ne smoth aa ly copoly tenor see Dees ad Guta A Toon Flats. 3s So. Asn, Pye 2319-2 Hcy aoe yarn Tie = ee te vie at om se ‘coat at mount ue highs an side pe it ate ver Go descent hee gan, eco oy, hich pat TEBE esicene mer merino Des 960 27:5 SEE Sets os a a his oo ton ih ity SRS SS ut Py Mme ie wring se of May 19, Stat Tc able on te ile {Te Marr conn fe ci cance of egy’ “Whee ‘oe Lj Spent Tegan Ti Sor Wh so On ws C. Pre sc Sry Pes) The mths pr congrens contr eal Care Peers tans hey (ihe al Hp) om be ped Sree canta Thre boy wit orgs airs oy cae eke ayo a-derng machine” it deve by Dee md Caren Ae eae won Rey, MC Seem, nd TR ate (spl Se atime ay 9) cape 25 Te iene ike papain A ‘usnd Pas 4-105, 238 ny es A he fet at ie plan Be ing and log nin be pce” (Pe nora 49 Te ist Ge les sal’ way aie rs ng tsp in pce tg orm pon eat teen non en eb pose os: Pe in hee bad ithe mck eta plce Sh comme ae“ iin ad win Sens move” i In as nex), Foal moe ger SOLTETi an beeen plata tyne tt ds ot eg whe ‘Patra cunts ny etn Bc Plan, hp & 1015 Sem isc, pre gene me ae eal ha does sot oy aa nee 2p, et Always tring «rein ire SESE eintfavccpe so) Techn rt ens pr sone ee wom Sey Cat ep ep mse # mrly aioe ee Bare ies ps spy rises air. Sig. Elnena Pos. 1 ine ner". ig tal aver be na man's pice, ee wil smi bei la, Winn cio we ple oe wiley cup Oe pce os te ‘Beta ont be cher (Seno Diesen lente! asi 1) 2 Sen Direct” MY aesNoten to Pages 27-829, 219, “Teo os womb seal boty ase pn youn ty for cio leno Psion Tr cr snun ating ny by enn bam wos pocampal an ha on ae ig” CS [Pinsent her. Tove ene of out in ise gh Sen wil ny cng a Cano 23) tome we Le fe "i es of Sali cect gyn 6s slg re it ig pees Sr eS See ig wih ce Nan cee eal fhe pial wea (id) One enti techs tpl my ae “The Wolf Notp Men ond Wel 20 (987) 31-386, Maeve Oe BS Ri at _ BE TAS tapes op The pops oz” at perp wt nln wna vec com ura. 93 wb ewe ea (Shu tomer and" bene” rapes yA erase ebeoc be ne sade oe te sone mata cajog tence ot oe leer move wound wits ae" O8 SSG ce ecesiy ad edn” Te elope 8, Ppa mea Ou fa adn n'y on pe fe ft nen pe fr gst cet peel ch 8 ‘SEE ote psc ods rberce pln nd hen tetova tee neta fe ber (id). Sao. Even 93. eee om i te ere ich ler ema, for gay “ial elton wet © be seta ese snes jim, sed ini hat niger core TES chy nd ec no comptes of meee cnt em tinny fr act ye ce, eh ‘Epon Guth Br Bera Mey 0). Dt cain of ma SEigE Lit peat ters tenes 0 Pac chow of ec (Bur ed 6-5) cope 93. ers Fa itiet tenn of God «plat ce gp. 17 each et ead "Ceo eso ini ce so taunt on Sel ment” Ay rie eh [Stomecloe wih wom opal ps nF Sy dy Th ne nen wa mata ad enna eed Diy 3 ee eee tes to Page 290-505, a * py ey. Tee of Gd aa ctl ey who acne is eee by ‘which ia Provan asl oD. Gi ma, W, Ses lw Yo: Mac, 98, 5a. 3, "Oo ante Wott” So. nie Eaves Bi Pace era 5 SEL dey aia, “Mes ple” ease ot ew Ths psd te coped Dt pee "nn ese In Sen V ore Mp ie wn fr eo conrated whe slat a Wc "he oe sod ards the pe fhe he ebig Ismay ve he we ‘Ges they pone ose onl ons) Whoe and dese ering $eithe ral (strc betwen the The wo i estoyed mea ‘Swi tc cpla fe et ae hs ed oes to ey ‘fn (eum fo ko geen the sh fort” (Ps Iva” ‘Semasi sghty meaied). 1. Fora dscring aie fe mit ington of Piston hre—in> cio ney Dean eed et fen gay. gaye A ‘Been, "Acete Cenes Pop” Sots Arches! Tan (1 Whom 1 Kip and Bae (Cane MI res, 1952) 7. {tote Psi sopm26 Hey li 3} Teor conte canta ifn nd woman ett oe, te provid ater ihrer rates raster and vat hr ctr sore erence ae gaat oe std mere ses | ‘Titan cava ona (ren? (Th vel" in Eh of Se sation ns Ban 2G Oi ti: Corll Unter Pre 93) We tr an Arh one te, yan at an at rem i "prove ‘scede Ene a ne pnb of wes Wo he ve he ‘Stpeet of ere). “STs nyo of Dae and Goat fo A Twn Pita a Hr ant inespleUnvery of Mets Pr (873 ee edby Ltr nc tpn ter parenor cmn eon ‘Tike or a tayo wer eter eed everyting das [shes ove tay wine nen ious a Ha UndecuingFRennut ii. Bene Cane Camshp Univer Pra sot) ok2 cap, p. 43 bas). Clay on ral elton ‘lw pce hp fi ive ne, mad ce oa omen af abi“ tar weve hig edi he nie, ef fh ‘Spon lb decid ty racing) "Tag “Pcl” cs of Sel Diferecy, 4 Bes slash ig be med tn depen oa he sing fe a ‘Serer cenmy ovine tt cane olde heb aap he ‘Sus fly tery "Ow of te ere semen ste ssfiane of eet in Deni’ hk ing sos ts eo nr" ane fe pecs wt Mayes frre wil aver eege ler ne or ey ing ner maa