Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Reading Log 1
Reading Log 1
1/2Period
Aristotle,WhoDeservesWhat?
Entry#1,Pg.184207,9/3,46min.
Sec.AReadingSkills
Ikeptreadingtoseeifthingslaterbecameclearafterthefirstparagraphwhereitsaidthat
Calliewaskickedoffthesquad.Iwasntsurewhyshewas,butitexplainedthereasonin
thenextparagraph.
Iwasconfusedbythewordteleological,butafterreadingthenextsentence,Iunderstood.
InJustice,Telos,andHonor,thefirstpointgivesadefinitionoftheroottelos.Itmeansthe
purpose,end,oressentialnature.
InthesectionWhatstheTelosofaUniversity?Iwasremindedoflegallyblond.The
sectiontalksaboutWhohasarighttobeadmitted.Itmentionsthatsomebelievethe
purposeofauniversityistopromotescholarlyexcellence,andthatacademicpromise
shouldbethesolecriterionforadmission.Inlegallyblondhowever,ElleWoodsis
admittedtoHarvardforherlooksandmoney.
IdidntexpecttohearthatAristotledefendedslavery,andevenjustifiedit.
Sec.BObservations
IwassurprisedtofindAristotledefendingslavery,becauseinthepastthephilosophies
Ivereadofhisdidnotpointtohimbeingamanforslavery.
Themainideaofthetextisthatinordertodecideifsomethingisethical,youhaveto
figureoutwhattheessentialnatureoftheiteminquestionis.Thenyoucandecideifthe
solutionwouldchangethatnature,orleaveitbe.
Iagreewiththeauthorbecauseifsomethingisgoingtobeethical,itneedstobe
consistent.Therefore,thebasicnatureofsomethingshouldntbechangedbythechoice
beingmade.
Sec.CAskingquestions
IansweredmyownsmallquestioninsectionA.
Mybigquestionis:Isteleologicalthinkingsomethingweshoulduseeveryday?Ifitsused
inourJudicialbranch,andinpoliticalthinking,thenisitsomethingtobepracticingdaily?
Howhasthisthinkingbeenappliedtoourschoolsystem?Ithinkthiswouldbean
interestingthingtoresearch,andfindoutifthereareotherwayswecanapplyteleological
thinking,orifitshouldbeusedinaschoolsetting.
Sec.DQuotationAnalysis
OnequotethatIthoughtwasinterestingwasaboutpeoplewhodontinvolvethemselves
inpolitics.Themanwhoisisolatedwhoisunabletoshareinthebenefitsofpolitical
association,orhasnoneedtosharebecauseheisalreadyselfsufficientisnopartofthe
polis,andmustthereforebeeitherabeastoragod.Theauthorwastryingtomakethe
pointthatwecantliveinaworldwherepeoplearecompletelyselfsufficient.Wereall
heretogether,andneedtoworkasateamthroughpolitics,lestwebecomebeastsor
godsbothofwhichdonotlivecohesivelywiththemselves.Hemeanstosaythatwithout
politics,webecomeuncivilized.