Cee ean eects
Dieses ict aI MLN
INTRODUCTION
Vitamins are ntvents essential to human health, andar present
in almostall types ffods.in ation o food sources, vitamin
supplements fon consumed to ensue adequate aint
cu ns owe sullen vitamin
tobias andor mito inthe choice of fooes, or maltunctons in
digestion and ingestion. Vitamin supplements are avaliable in various
forms such as single- or multivitamin tablets, formula, and vitmin-
eich eve ot comercial ft tied wt
vitamins andor oternuttionl essentials such as minerals. Based on
ther solubility, vitamins are divided int vo categories: water-soluble
vitamins (WSV) and fat-soluble vitamins (FSV). WSVS include vitamin
C (ascorbic acid, B, (thiamine), B, (tte), , (niacin, niacinamide),
B, (pentathenic acid), 8, (pyrodoxine),B biotin, 8, ois acid), and,
(Gyanocobalamine). Accurate quantitative measurements for vitamins are
required to ensure product quality and regulatory compliance as well as
to monitor vitamin nak.
r
Established methods for vitamin analysis include microbiological
‘mathads, which are typically designed for single vitamin analysis and
are time consuming, “and chromatographic methods, including gas,
chromatography capillary electrophoresis, and liquid
chromatography (LC) with various methods of detection."
a vty of matrices wth various mades of deletion "*""-" Here we
present a high throughput mend for simultaneous determination for
the above mentioned ten WSVs using utrahigh-pertormance LC and
tandem mass spectrometry (UHPLC-MS/MS). Chromatography was
optimized forthe total resolution ofall target analytes ona Thermo
Scie Dio Aslam C30 reversed-phase (RP) column. An MS)
IMS instrument was operated in selected reaction monitoring (SRM)
‘mode forthe best selctiy and sensitivity, and an isotope labeled
internal standard (Std) was used for accurate quantitation
Randomly selected VEBs were assayed by this method forthe selected
vitamins, and when compared with product labeling, much higher values,
were observed for mast ofthe vitamins.
EXPERIMENTAL
Chemicals and Reagents
‘A set of WSY standards was purchased from AccuStandard (P/N
\IT-WSK-R1-SET) conlaining ten individual chemicals. sotope labeled
intemal standard pydoxine-d, was purchased trom C/DYN Isotopes
(PIN: D-6819). Ammonium formate and fomic acd were purchased
‘om Sigma-Aldrich, Acetonitrile was oblained trom Burdick & Jackson
(HPLC/UV grade). Deionized water (DIH,0) was wilt 0 @
Milipore water station
Preparation of Standards
Individual stock solutions were prepared by aissoving an appropiate
amount of purechemial in 1% formic aida! my (1000pas-
per milion, po s rnd. F
by anmonta, 4% and0 respective) The was prepared n
1% formic acid at 10 ppm to prepare calibration standards and spike
unknown samples.
Calibration standards were prepared in 0.1% formic acid and ranged
‘rom 10 parts-per-bllion (ppb) to 5000 ppb at 7 levels: 10 ppb, 50 ppb,
100 ppb, 500 ppb, 1000 ppb, 2000 ppb, and 5000 ppb Target analytes
‘were divided into three groups: Group 1 containing only B,; Group
2 containing B, and B,,: and Group 3 containing B,, 8, (niacin and
niacinamide), Band, IStd was spiked in each calibration standard at
500 pab.
Preparation of Vitamin-Enriched Beverage Samples
‘EB samples were randomly selected and purchased from a local
{grocery store and kept at room temperature until analysis. Carbonated
\VEBs were degassed using a sonication bath for 30 seconds. A mL
aliquot of each sample was transteredtoa1.5 mL autosampler val,
spiked with Std at 500 ppb vortex med, and analyzed for Group 1
and Group 2 vitamins. A10 ul alquot ofeach sample was pipetted to
another 1.5 mL autosampler via, diluted with 990 pL DI HO, spiked
with IStdat 500 ppb vortex mixed, and then analyzed for Group 3
vitamins.UHPLC-MS/MS Analysis,
med using @ Therma Sent
Table 2. SRM MS/MS Events and Parameters
ae fe Retention [cot
gystem coupled wth a Thermo Scns "
TSO Quantum Access MAX” MS/MS instrument via a heated ots ah ana
electrospray ionization (HES!) source. Chromatographic separation was
achieved using a Acclaim C30 column (P/N: 075725, 2.1 x 150 mm, 3 ‘Ascorbic Acid cl] 12 a
pi), Mobil phase consisted of three components: A) 10 mM formate 15 | 8
buffer (pH 4.0; B) 10mM formate bute (pH 3.0); and C) 90% CH,CN, w | 2
10% 10 mM formate butter (pH 3.0) Gradient elution was used with a B17 |S 1h lino
deta liste in Table . Flow rate was seta 0.6 mL/min an the column
‘temperature was set at 15 °C. The MS/MS instrument was operated in Thiamine a) 30 |2s47| 25 21
SRM mode wit he details listed in Table 2. The HES| ionization source : 18
parameters were set as follows: Spray Voltage (4000 V); Vaporizer im pa
Temperature (250°C); Capillary Temperature (200 °C); Sheath Gas (40 Pionne so Jaro] 1m
arbitrary units) and Auliary Gas 60 arbitrary units) 5
1Si:Pyodoried, {st 50 |4r-ro] 172
4 wm | 8
wo | 2
Pee Niacin 58 [47-70] 3 P=
Time a 8 c wf
7 00 7 7 Panohesicted |a,] 72 Jro-g0] 20 |
a0 100 0 a oe [iw [ar
5 a0 a 7 Cyanccotaine 8] 106 foo-tsop—— +
35 a 100 a a |
a0 7 7 a Folic Ai 8] 109 fool wo POO
at a 20 ® war |
ig 7 a a Biotin a] m2 poral 26 -EE
150 700 0 a 2 | 8
Fist 8] 7 fossa) av
23 [21
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Chromatography
‘Although many LC methods have been reported for simultaneous analysis
‘of WSs, these methods usually suf tom low traughput or incomplete
chromatographic resolution, and several highly hydrophilic analytes are
poorly retained onthe commonly used C18 RP columns. In this study, a
30 column was used to improve the retention of poorly cetaned analytes,
suchas vilamin C and thiamine. In ation, ammonium formate was
buffered at wo pl condtions: pl 3.0 and pH 4.0, withthe higher pH butter
used in the early phase ofthe gradient to further improve thertention for
thiamine, andthe lower pH bufer used to provide complete resolution for
leer eluted vitamins,
Under the optimized conditions al target vitamins were baseline
separated within 12 min. The minimum retention factor was observed
for vitamin Cat 1.3 (retention time 1.2 min), and the retention factor
t ain was obse'ved at £5, which was gr ficantty imotoved aver
ously ebotedmetoes wre than elec frst wi ee tir
fcr fst 1" Varn and, aa WV hoop
and were nt visible inthe UV chromatogram. However, the peak
labels for both analytes ae show in Figure 1A to demonstrate the
chrometographic separation. These two analytes were detected by MS}
[MS with great senstvy s seen in Figure 28 and Figure 2C
2 Simultaneous Analysis of Water-Soluble Vitamins in Beverages by UHPLC-MS/MS‘rman Catan erspectaner non
Seer mee awesc | See etree
Sree seein o Sera. oe
Tee BE sae
| - 6.00
0382
aes [Eo
Ea [| fe
| fe
=
mi ao
Figure 14) chromatograms of al target WSUS. 8) O-SAIM chromatograms
of Group § and 2 vias. C)0-SAM cromaograns of Group 3 vans
Mass Spectrometry
Electrospray ionization (ES!) was used inthis study asthe ionization
interface de ots suitability and beter sensiity for polar compounds
than other atmospheric pressure ionization (AP) techniques. lnization
souroe parameters forthe HESI probe used in his study were optimized
to provide best sensitty and were described in the Experimental
section, Under the optimized chromatographic and ionization
conditions, most analytes exhibited strong protonated molecular ions
(i, [MsH) excep for vitamin C and folic acid where deprotorated
molecular ions [M-H]- were observed as the dominant MS peak. A
trong doubly-charged MS peak was observed fr vitamin B,, a 679
‘mz wells the [MH] at 1356 m/z For each analy, the two most
intense fragments were selected asthe monitored produc ions, which
are listed in Table 2 along with the optimize colsion energies. Thus
foreach analy, two SRM transitions were monitored with one being
‘quantitative SAM (Q-SRM), which showed relatively stronger MS
response, arth olar oe ng contmaive SAM (C-SAM) The 1-SRM
chromatograms are shown in Figure 18 and Figure 1C, with each of
the vitamins at 50 ppb. The MS/MS detection demonstrated great
sensitivity and selectivity fr vitamin analysis even at low pp levels
'AL50 ppb, the minimum signal-to-noise ratio (SiN) was observed at
20 for niacin (26 for niacinamide) withthe rest ofthe target analytes
showing SIN greater than 100. The great senitty provided by MS/MS
instrumentation enables the quantitation for low level vitamins suc a8
8, and flic acid in complex matrices, which were not achievable with
previously reported methods using only UV detection
Quantitation
(One ofthe challenges encountered in his study was the large
diterences in concentration o the vitamins present in beverages or
tablets. the tested samples, the concentrations of Group 3 vitamins
(mg levels per serving) were roughly 1000 times the concentrations
of Group 1 and 2 vitamins (ug levels per serving). The lowest
concentration observed was 0.6 wg per serving (B,) while the highest
concentration was at 20 mg pe serving (8).
Asingle assay trying to cover the whole concentration range is beyond
the linear response range of any mass spectrometer. Two approaches
are usualy practiced to address this challenge among reprted methods
covering these wide concentration anges. Some reported methods use
MS fr lower concentration analytes and less sensitive detectors such
25 UV forthe quantitation of high concentration vitamins, thus lasing
the selectivity of MS quantitation and may utter rom interferences
and/or lower quantitation accuracy. Another approach performs several
assays for each sample with diferent dilution factors and results are
reported wit the most appropriate ciltion. In this study, te ater
approach was used and two assays were performed: the primary one
quantitating low concentration vitamins including BB, and, which
were assayed directly ater spiking intemal standard; and the secondary
assay quantitating the remaining vitamins a higher concentrations ater
4 10-fold ition and espiking the cuted sample with ISt o 500
foo This technique too ul advarcage of Ie selectivity ane soeciity
Provided by MIS detection thus ensuring quantitation accuracy.Stability of vitamins in solution was another challenge. Vitamin C was
estremely unstable in muiiitamin solutions, and degradation was
observed within 20 min eventhough the sample was prepared in acdc
solution and placed ina thermostatted autosampler at 4°C. istbility
of he analyte tse can cause substantia variance inthe quantitative
determination of vitamin C, and thus it was not included for quantitation
inthis study Instability was also reported for other vitamins, such as
ribotiain, pyridoxine, a thiamin, which ae ligt sensi," and
thiamin, pentothenic acid (in acid or basic condition) folic ci, and
Pyridoxine, which are heat labile. To avoid oss of analytes during
analysis, samples wee prepared in amber autosampler vials and
promptly placed in the rtrigeated autosampler a 4 °C.
An addtional challenge for accurate quantitation was the interactions
of vitamins when present together in solution. Interactions between B,
tolicacid, and botevin have teen pare" thus targeted lamin
were dived int three groups wih additional consideration of thelr
concentrations in samples: Group 3 included higher concentration
vitamins (8, B, 8, and B,) and Group 2 included lower concentration
vitamins (8, and). hough folic acid was also present in lover
concenration in samples and could be included in Group 2 vitamins,
observations revealed that quantitation of lw concentration folic acd
oul ly ela w by theo B, and... Thus
thre calibration standard ses were prepared forthe tree groups of
vitamins to generate individual calibration curves for quantitation
Method Performance
Method performance was ev
cf determination, precision, and acura, Caliban cures foreach
analyte were generated fom calibration standards with concentrations
fo tos Is 2 used fT
the experimental ata ard was sed 25th weighting factor. Detaled
resul 3. Evale cooticirt lat
precision, nd accuray were achieved for each target vitamin. Limits
of quantitation (LOs) were determined a the lowest concentration in
calibration standards exiting signal-to-noise ratios (S/N) greater
than 10. LOQ was observed at 10 ppb for most analytes, excep for
niacin and niacinamie at 50 pob, and folic acid at 100 ppb. Although
SiN for folic acid was achieved with values much greater than 10 at
lower concentrations, por quantitation accuracy was observed, which
was believed to be the reduced stbity ofthis analyte when present
isis ore Th etd i sy
f cuartfication of toe it s
iis thd, proven byte Sales observed at LOO. Howee this
‘method was designed and the calibration range set to minimize sample
preparation procedures, number of dilutions, and assays tobe run in
oder to maintain a high analytical throughput.
Fable 3. Calibration, Coefficient of Determination, Precision, Accuracy and Detection
it 50 ppb 2000 po
Anaine ce
8, [Nasi soso [came [as [ou | a2 | 0 | 3% | 0 | wom
8, | Thanine “o-soo0 [ove [20 [30 | eo | emo | 2 | ims | wea
8, | rile 70-5000 [0906 [a [3m | aoe | 1s [ae | 32 | voerom)
8, [_ Neate so-soo0 [0909 [0 | 3m | 19 |e | 20 | a2 | wor
8, | Paiatencact | s0-2m0 | osooa [ar | as7_| eae | 102 | sar | ot | 106100)
8, | Pyridoxine osm [100 [soa [iz | 1 | 190 [18 | ro | 10680)
8, | Bian 70-5000 | oa%es [re | az | ee [190 [as | 55 | tocr000)
8, | Folic aaa voo-soo0 | oaea [a [ase [113 | 19% [a3 | ora | soocotomoy
Cyanocotsranine | 10-000 | _oserr [a7 | 102 [ss | 1s [aot | esa | 10(>1000
“Al ecion ad aca sus were sunmarizdom sven repeat assays
“Prison ard azz eu fr lal otal am 100 pan 2000p tarda.
4 Simultaneous Analysis of Water-Soluble Vitamins in Beverages by UHPLC-MS/MSAnalysis of Vitamin-Enriched Beverages Samples
‘As described inthe Experimental section, ten beverage samples were
selected and analyzed for tei vitamin content. Among te selected
bev viami-ored wat
Ive were vtamin-ere creo ene
clink, The results are shown in Table 4. Large diferences were
‘observed between measured and labeled values, and this observation
agreed with previously conducted studies ®* An explanation for these
descrepancis coule te fal te k rormad tk
higher than label claims, deviating inthe direction of no harm: to
‘compensate for extrapolated degradations during slorage and ste lite
ea
Gene eat
This study describes a UNPLC-MS/MS method for simultaneous
uaniation of WSV in beverages. Tis method demonstrated excellent
correlation of determination, precision, accuracy and selective and
sensitive detection with low quantitation its. This matod was
successfully applied to the determination of WSVS in beverages and
energy supplements with presented results.
einer
‘Analyte vest | vee2 | vees | vena | vees | vee | vee7 | veee | veeo | veow0
Fito 22007) 53a [ 1407)
Nicatinarie s7@ | 2a | 30 [26a | 2@ | eo [ wen | en [2600 [ aon
Parohenicacd [as [ toy [ 3@ | 35m | asa | 5306) zai) | 24g) [ 3925)
Pyrdorne sijoay [03502 [0704 | oso | ison [ 63s) | 2a@ | sea | aia | sses)
Cyanocobalanine 47a [36a [ sa | 79@ [som [ites
Label vals of vitins are ncudedinparenteses
Duplicate assays were performed foreach sampleREFERENCES %
1. Davis, RE; Moulton, J; Kelly, A An Automated Microbiological
Method forthe Measurement of Vitamin ,,. Journal of Cinial
Pathology 1978, 26(7), 494-496.
2. Boke, H.; Sobota, H, Microbiological Assay Methods for
Vitamins. in Advances in Ciinical Chemistry Hay, S.; Stewart, C.
P, Eds. Elsevier 1963; Vol. 5, pp 173-236,
3. Kory, W. Gas Chromatography of Vitamin B, In Methods in
Enzymology, Donald, B. M.; Lemuel, D. W, Eds: Academic Press:
1970;Vol. 18, Pat 1, pp 500-504
4. Lin,H.J Chen, CW; Hwang, B.S; Choong, Y. M. Rapid and
Simple Gas Chromatographic Method for Direct Determination of
Nicotinamide in Commercial Vitamins and Tonic Drinks. Yaowas
Shipin Fenxi 2000, 6 2), 113-123
5. Jegle, U. Separation of Water-Soluble Vitamins via
High-Performance Capillary Electrophoresis. J. Chromatogr, A
1993, 6522), 495-501
6. FotsingL: Boulanger B.; Chiap, P Filet, M; Huber, P; Crome,
4. Multivariate Optimization Approach forthe Separation of
‘Water-Soluble Vitamins and Related Compounds by Capillary
Electrophoresis. Bimectcal Cromatogrphy 2000, 14(1), 10-11.
7. Cho, C.M:; Ko, J.H.; Cheong, W.J. Simultaneous Determination
of Water-Soluble Vitamins Exreted in Human Urine ater Eating
an Overdose of Vitamin Pills bya HPLC Method Coupled with a
Solid-Phase Extraction. Talnts 2000, 51 (4), 799-806.
8. Hau, 0; Kling; Fontanaz Separation of Water-Soluble Vitzins
by Reversed-Phase High-Performance Liquid Chromatography wth
Uttavilt Detection: Application o Plyitainated remixes. J
Chromatogr, A200, 1070 1-2), 49-56.
9. Leporat, A; Callan, D.; Suman, M.; Andreoli, R; Manin, P;
Niessen’ W’ MLA. Application of Liquid Chromatography Tandem
Mass Spectrometry Method tothe alysis of Water-Soluble
Vitamins in alin Pasta, Anal. Chim. Acta 2005, 5371), 87-88.
Chen, 2: Chen, B; Ya, S. High-Performance Liquid Chromatography?
Electrospray lonization-Mass Spectomety for Simultaneous
Determination of Taurine and 10 Water-Soluble Vitains in
Mutvitamin Tbs. Anal. Chin, Acta 2006, 569(1-2), 169-175,
Nelson, B. C.; Sharpless, KE: See, L.C. Improved Liquid
‘Chvomatogracy Who and
Bion in NST Senda Reeene Mata 3280 utivamin’
Muttilement Tables. J. Agric. Food Chem 2006, 54(23),
8710-8716,
13
14,
18,
16
17.
18
19,
20,
21
10
11.
Ors CLS
satiny
such 98518 beta aE
Nelson, B.C.; Sharpless, KE. Sander, LC. Quantitative
Determination of Folic Acid in Multivtamin/Muttilement Tablets
Using Liquid Chromatography/Tandem Mass Spectrometry.
Chromatogr, A2006, 1135(2), 203-211
‘Zatra-Gémez, A; Garbalo, A: Morales, J.C; Garcia-Ayuso, LE
Simuitaneous Determination of Eight Water-Soluble Vitamins in
Supplemented Foods by Liquid Chromatography. J. Agri. Faod
Chem. 2006, 5413), 4531-4526,
CChen,P; Wolf, W. LC/UV/MS-MRM forthe Simultaneous
Determination of Water-Soluble Vitamins in Muitvitamin Dietary
Supplements. Anal Bioanal. Cher, 2007, 387(7), 2441-2448,
Goldschmidt, R.: Wolf, W. Simultaneous Determination of
‘Water-Soluble Vitamins in SRM 1849 Infant/Adult Nutritional
Formula Powder by Liquid Chromatograpty-Isotoe Dilution Mass
Spectrometry. Anal. and Bioanal. Chem. 2010, 397(2), 471-481
Phinney, K. Wl; Rimmer, C. A. Thoms, J.B. Sander, LC.
Sharpless, K E; Wise, S.A. stop Dilution Liuid Chromatography-
Mass Specrometry Methods for Fat-and Wale Soluble Vitamins in
Nutonal Formulations. Anal. Cher 2010, 83(1), 92-98.
Chen, MF; Boyce, HW; Triplet, L Stability of 8 Vitamins in
Mixed Parenteral Nutrition Solution. Journal of Parenteral and
Enteral Nutrition 1983, 7(5), 462-464
Choe, €; Huang, R; Min, D.B. Chemical Reactions and Stability of
Rtotavin in Fads a Food Sct 2008, 70(1), 28-36
Blitz, M; Eigen, €; Gunsber, E. Studies Relating to the Stability
of Vitamin, B-Complex injectable Solutions. Journal of the
American Pharmaceutical Association 1956, 45 (12), 803-806,
Feller, B. A; Macek, TJ. Etetof Thiamine Hydrochloride onthe
‘Stability of Solutions of Crytaine Vitamin B,. Journal ofthe
‘American Pharmaceutical Assocation 1958, 44(11), 662-665,
Scheindlin, Les, A. Gri, | The Action of Risovin on
‘Acid. Journal ofthe American
Pharmaceutical Association 1952, 41 (8), 420-427
Biamonte, AR; Schneller, 6. H.A Study of Folic Acid Stability
in Solutions of the B Complex Vitamins. Joural ofthe American
Pharmaceutical Association 1951, 40(7), 313-320.
Dionex Corporation, Application Note 216: Determination of Watr-
and Fat-Soluble Vitamins in Functional Waters by HPLC with
UV-PDA Detection. Sunnyvale, CA, 2008
‘Sarpless, KE; Margolis, Thomas, J. B. Determination of
Vitamins in Food-Matrix Standard Reference Materials. J
Chromatogr, A2000, 881 (1-2), 171-181
nuabnes
man Ue
Je Mea sh St
eer of Dn Copan.
Pi
etd 2020 Oa 0 ws) 2.26275
ety 22 Sent 8 0
Ste ge2 68 gi ven
‘rt 1 on 21058 Sep)
‘wav. thermosciontile.camiéionex
Bi