8 3

2012 3

Journal of Safety Science and Technology

Vol 8 No 3
Mar 2012

1673 193X2012 03 0108 06

257061

5 24

X913 4

The accident-causing analysis and evaluation indexes for offshore drilling platforms
GUO HengCHEN Guo-ming
Centre for Offshore Engineering and Safety TechnologyChina University of Petroleum
Dongying 257061China

Abstract In the paperaccident-causing element consisted of human errorprocess equipmentoil and gas hazardmanagement error and environmental hazardwas studied systematically On the one handaccident-causing evaluation framework for offshore drilling platform was proposed based on the wide investigation about the accidents
of offshore platform happened at home and abroad on the other handthe evaluation indexescomsisted of five
main partsincluding human errorprocess equipmentoil and gas hazardmanagement error and environmental
hazardand the other 24 secondary evaluation indexeswere presented in the evaluation framework Whats more
the weights of all the evaluation indexes were calculated with the help of analysis hierarchy process and Matlab software In additionthe evaluation framework and indexes were applied to an offshore drilling platform in serviceit
was found that the jack-up was in critical state and inclined to safety state This paper presents a new methodsfor
risk evaluation and control of offshore drilling platform in China
Key words

offshore drilling platform

accident accident-causing analysis

evaluation index

analysis

hierarchy process

2011 08 28
*
09CX05008A

109

47%

1. 2

1. 1

1970 2006
1

93. 53%

EDS

2010

1. 3

Sleipner A

110

1. 5

BOP

1. 4

1979

72 1983

81 2005 15

Deepwater Horizon

111

3. 1

6-8

9-13

3. 2

3 2 1

14-16

U1

U2

U3

U4

U5

U1

U2

1 /3

U3

1 /4

1 /2

U4

1 /4

1 /2

1 /2

U5

1 /6

1 /4

1 /3

1 /2

3 2 2

Mv = max V

1
max
2

5
2

max

5. 1041

0. 8607

0. 3845

0. 2616

0. 1807

C1 - C4

4. 0484

0. 8233

0. 5115

0. 2089

0. 1032

C5 - C9

5. 0988

0. 8460

0. 3989

0. 2478

0. 1528

0. 0983

C10 - C15

6. 1040

0. 7706

0. 4948

0. 3150

0. 1985

0. 1265

C16 - C20

5. 0548

0. 7937

0. 5093

0. 2776

0. 1539

0. 0995

C21 - C24

4. 0511

0. 8881

0. 2239

0. 1362

v
0. 1016

0. 0817

0. 3777

R I

3 2 3

= 1. 41
C R =

C I
=
R I

max

n ) / n 1
R I

2 C R = 0. 0232
0. 1
C R

3 2 4

3
4
3

U1

U2

U3

0. 4811

0. 2149

0. 1462

U4

U5

0. 1010 0. 0568

112

U1

U2

C1

C2

C3

C4

C5

C6

C7

C8

C9

0. 4999

0. 3106

0. 1268

0. 0627

0. 4851

0. 2288

0. 1421

0. 0876

0. 0564

U3

C10

C11

C12

C13

C14

C15

0. 3878

0. 2490

0. 1585

0. 0999

0. 0637

0. 0411

U4

U5

C16

C17

C18

C19

C20

C21

C22

C23

C24

0. 4328

0. 2777

0. 1513

0. 0839

0. 0543

0. 5462

0. 2323

0. 1377

0. 0838

30 45 60
75 90

100

V = 62. 875

V = V1 V2 V n =

Matlab

R 3 3
B
= 0. 1417
0. 1754
0. 2563
0. 1915
0. 2351
b1 0 1219 0 1719
b 0 1299 0 1813
2
R = b3 = 0 1300 0 1499

b4 0 2248 0 1780
b5 0 2177 0 2189

0 2814 0 1905 0 2344

0 2514 0 1873 0 2130

0 2491 0 2042 0 2669

0 1988 0 2040 0 1869

0 1323 0 1353 0 2959

3

4. 3

b j j = 12n v j j = 1
2n

4. 2

b j vj

j =1

4. 1

V =

5 24

1
M

2006 4-190
2 M
2006 18-31
3
J 201030 8 98-100
ZHANG HongWANG KaiZENG Hong Feture analy-

113

1 244-249
GUO HengCHEN Guo-mingZHU Yuan Study on the
risk chain of the offshore oil-drilling platform accidents
based on the dynamic risk balanceJ Journal of safety
and enviroment201212 1 244-249
11

sis and countermeasures of human error on drilling blow-

J 201033 4

out incidentsJ Natural gas industry201030 8

90-93

98-100

DENG JianHUANG Li-wenWANG Xianget al Re-

4 HAZOP J
200722 1 43-46
DOU Pei-ju Study on hazop of offshore drilling platform
J China offshore platform200722 1 43-46
5

search on marine oil spill risk assessment index system

for the three gorges reservoir areaJ Navigation of china201033 4 90-93
12
J 201020

J 200631

3 156-160

5 689-696

XU Dong-chaoLUO YunLU Chenget al Warning

CHEN HongQI HuiSONG Xue-fenget al The struc-

ranking for blowout risk of down hole oprationJ Chi-

tural model of affecting factors of management misconduct

na safety science journal201020 3 156-160

in coal mine fatal accidents in chinaJ Journal of china

coal society200631 5 689-696
6 M
1990

13
J 201033
11 197-200
LIU JieLANG Yin-haiJIA Yong-ganget al Polu-

7 AHP-RS

tion level assessment of oil on offshore platformJ En-

J 20106 6

vironmental science techonlogy201033 11 197-

155-160

200

WANG Han-binYANG Xin A new method of ascertai-

14

ning weight based on analytic hierarchy process and rough

set theoryJ Journal of safety science and technology

22 2 1-5
2008

20106 6 155-160

YIN QunSUN Yan-jieLI Liang-bi Research on safe-

ty precaution of offshore platform under fire and explo-

20106 6 93J

sion riskJ Journal of jiangsu university of science

97

and technology200822 2 1-5

YI Gao-xiang Research on assessment and classification

15

of risk to hazardous chemical enterprises in BeijingJ

J 200722

Journal of safety science and technology20106 6

5 38-42

93-97

SUN Yan-jieYIN QunLI Liang-bi Preliminary study

9
D
2010
10
J 201212

on risking assessment of offshore platform under collision

and gas explosion hazards China offore platform2007
22 5 38-43
16
D 2003