—
THE FRIARS DURING THE PROTESTANT REFORM
Holzapfel says it is not easy to distinguish Conventuals and Observants
during the Reformation since people referred to the Friars indiscriminately
as Minorites, Franciscans, Grey Friars, Barefooted Friars, etc.
The Conventuals lost out in numbers and houses throughout the 16th century
not only because of the Reformation (e.g. suppression and apostacy), but
also because of the intervention of Catholic monarch in turning entire
provinces over to the Observants in France (e.g. 4 provinces and 200
convents in France) in Spain and Portugal and elsewhere.
Holzapfel writes that the Conventuals were more disposed to accept
Protestantism than the Observant movement. Needless to say, his strong
language regarding both Protestants and Conventual friars has to be
tempered by more scientific research. A.G. Little and John Moorman
also indicate that in England the Observants offered greater resistance
to the Reformation than did the Conventuals -- the six Observant Houses
in England furnishing the martyrs.
Concerning the Observants, Holzapfel writes: "No religious Order until
the close of the Council of Trent can point to so many brave defenders
of the Catholic Faith in the Germanic lands as the Franciscan
Observants...what a small percentage of apostates compared to the other
Orders whose members fell away literally by the thousands...in contrast
to that small number of apostates from among the Observants (not more
than 20 but even if there were as many as a hundred) the Observants can
point to 500 friars throughout Europe who shed their blood for the faith."
Anscar Zawart observes that the Conventuals possessed monasteries in
every large and small town of Germany and hence lived in the very thick
of the approaching struggle and laced the power of resistence of the
Observants. Both Conventuals and Observants lost at least 300 monasteries
in Germany by suppression and destruction; the membership dwindled,
especially among the Conventuals and new vocations were rare.
43 Observants and 48 Conventuals, were invited to the Council of Trent
as theologian of pope, emperor and bishops. A few Capuchins were there.
The Capuchins, on the scene since 1525, rank with the Jesuits as the
principal auxiliary of the Holy See in halting the spread of Protestantism
and winning back territories to the Catholic Faith. Early on in the fray,
they were successful in the Alpine regions: Chablais, Savoy and Piedmont.
Their presence in some places in Germany, but especially in France,
Spain, Flanders, Austria, Bohemia, Hungary and Netherlands was a staunch
bulwark of the Catholic Faith during these troubled times.
Cuthbert, The Capuchins
Reformation.
Holzapfel, History, pp. 374-398.
Little, A.G., The Grey Friars in Oxford.
Moorman, J-. the Franeiscans in England.
Zaware, A. , "the History of Franciscan Preaching. ..Reformation, "
FECR (1927) 411-442.
A Contribution to the History of the Counter-