Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Agglomeration of Food Powder and Applications
Agglomeration of Food Powder and Applications
Agglomeration has many applications in food processing and major applications include easy flow table salt, dispersible
milk powder and soup mix, instant chocolate mix, beverage powder, compacted cubes for nutritional-intervention program,
health bars using expanded/puffed cereals, etc. The main purpose of agglomeration is to improve certain physical properties
of food powders such as bulk density, flowability, dispersability, and stability. Agglomerated products are easy to use by the
consumers and hence are preferred over the traditional non-agglomerated products that are usually non-flowable in nature.
The properties of food agglomerates and the process of agglomeration like employing pressure, extrusion, rewetting, spraybed drying, steam jet, heat/sintering, and binders have been reviewed. The physical and instant properties of agglomerated
food products have also been discussed.
Keywords
INTRODUCTION
AGGLOMERATION
Agglomeration, in general, can be defined as a process during which primary particles are joined together so that bigger
porous secondary particles (conglomerates) are formed (Palzer,
2005). According to this definition, even caking of hygroscopic
raw materials during storage can be regarded as a kind of undesired agglomeration. Agglomeration is basically a physical
phenomenon and can be described as the sticking of particulate
solids, which is caused by short-range physical or chemical
forces among the particles themselves as a result of physical or chemical modifications of the surface of the solid. This
phenomenon is triggered by specific processing conditions, or
binders and substances which adhere chemically or physically
on the solid surfaces to form a bridge between particles (Pietsch,
2003).
The process of agglomeration can be applied to many food
and non-food items. The non-food applications include the manufacture of ceramic objects formed by granular materials from
kaolin, feldspar, silica and silicon carbide, fish and mammal
feeds, household products (detergents for fabrics, dish, and hard
surface cleaning), microbiological products (enzyme, yeast, and
bacterial granules), and a number of pharmaceutical products
like feed stock for tabletting, pellets, and encapsulates. The agglomeration of food powders is of recent interest in which the
control of porosity and density of material is the main interest.
These have practical application like dispersability, wettability,
432
433
Function
Details of function
Raw materials
Used directly
Coating material
Flavoring
Cheese, spices
Cereal starches/flour
Minor ingredient
Microbial source
APPLICATIONS
The major applications of agglomeration in food include
easy flow table salt, dispersible milk powder and soup mix,
instant chocolate mix and beverage powder, compacted cubes
for nutritional intervention programme, health bars using expanded/puffed cereals, etc. (Table 1). Compacted cubes may
be defined as the cuboids having high density that are made
out of powdery food ingredients by the application of pressure.
Specific applications
Reference
Bergquist et al., 1992;
Nasirpour et al., 2006;
Hogekamp et al., 1996;
Colarow, 2006; Sherwood
et al., 2008
Snow et al., 1999; Kimura
and Teraunchi, 1999;
Haefliger et al., 2001;
Pietsch, 2005
Teunou and Poncelot, 2002;
Jinapong et al., 2008;
Kowalska et al., 2005
434
K. DHANALAKSHMI ET AL.
AGGLOMERATION PROCESSES
The process of agglomeration may be conducted in several
ways in conjunction with other unit operations such as spraying,
steaming, and drying. The selection of a specific agglomeration
process depends on several factors including physical and chemical properties, average particle sizes of initial raw material(s)
and product, thermal sensitivity, and on the requirement of special properties like instant solubility, easy flowability, etc. The
technologies applied vary widely in their process conditions and
adhesion principles to bind the primary particles together. The
commonly used agglomeration processes can be divided into
three groups (Schuchmann, 1995; Pietsch, 2002; Hogekamp
et al., 1996) like (a) pressure agglomeration (e.g., tableting), (b)
growth agglomeration (e.g., granulation, pelleting) such as wet
agglomeration and dry agglomeration and (c) agglomeration by
drying (e.g., spray drying).
Depending on whether or not a binder liquid is involved in the
process, it can be subdivided into wet and dry agglomeration methods. Each method exploits certain binding mechanisms
(Ennis et al., 1991) for granulation. For wet growth agglomeration processes, the term granulation is often used. The subsequent sections describe the different processes of agglomeration
that is frequently used in agri-food processing industries.
Pressure Agglomeration
Soybean
Soaked, heated to 70-80 oC for 10-15 min, ground with water
and extracted
Soymilk
Concentrated at 40oC using ultrafiltration unit
Concentrated soymilk
Spray dried
Spray dried soymilk
Maltodextrin
Figure 1
435
Technology
Method
Equipment
Application
Reference
Agitation Methods
Tumbling agglomeration
Bouillon cubes,
nutritional bars
Health bars
Cereal powder/starch
Cereal powder/starch
Milk powder, baby food
Milk powder, coffee
granules, ice cream
mixes, flavors, lipids,
caroteniods
Milk powder, baby food,
cereal flour
Cereal powder/starch
Mixer agglomeration
Powder clustering
Pressure methods
Piston/rotary type
compaction
Roll pressing
Extrusion
Thermal methods
Fluidized/sprouted beds
Ribbon mixers
to form and maintain inter-particle bonds during pressure compaction (or consolidation). This aspect is controlled in turn by
the geometry of the confined space, the nature of the applied
loads, and the physical properties of the particulate material
and of the confining walls (Snow et al., 1999). The different
advantages of compaction agglomeration include an increase
in product density and requirement of a small amount of liquid binder. Compaction agglomeration is carried out by using
the equipment like the piston and moulding presses, tabletting
presses, and roll presses. Tablet presses require highly flowable
feed material to uniformly fill the press chambers prior to compaction. Uniformity of particle size, particle shape, roughness
of surface, cohesiveness due to the chemical nature of the compound, and moisture content contribute to the flow and filling of
the tablet presses (Snow et al., 1999).
High-pressure agglomeration is characterized by a large degree of densification resulting in low-product porosity. Typically, the products from high-pressure agglomeration feature
high strength immediately after discharge from the equipment.
Low and medium pressure agglomeration yield relatively uniform agglomerates of elongated spaghetti-like or cylindrical
shape, whereas high-pressure agglomeration produces pillow or
almond-like shapes (Barbosa Canovas et al., 2005). Mukherjee
and Bhattacharya (2006) and Ghosal et al., (2010) reported the
inter-relationship between rheology of powder and texture of
compacted mass using model food powder system in presence
of binders.
One of the most common binding mechanisms in these processes is caused by the short-range molecular attraction forces,
that is, electrostatic and van der Waals forces, rather than solid
bridging forces. Because these forces are reduced in liquids by
Extrusion Agglomeration
In pressure agglomeration, applying external forces to particulate solids in more or less closed dies forms new and enlarged
entities. Pressure or press agglomeration using an extruder is
possible for commercial applications of size enlargement by agglomeration. In the extrusion agglomeration process, a powder
mixture is blended with binder liquid, additives, or dispersants
and then extruded at low pressure followed by drying, cooling,
and crumbling to get the final instant product (Pietsch, 1999).
Many food products such as snack bars and confectioneries are
processed and/or finished by pressure agglomeration, mainly
extrusion (Pietsch, 2005). Extrusion has also been used to encapsulate flavors, vitamin C, and colors (Dziezak, 1988). The
major advantage of extrusion is its outstanding protection of
flavors against oxidation (Barbosa-Canovas et al., 2005) while
being a commercially-viable continuous-processing technique.
436
K. DHANALAKSHMI ET AL.
agglomerated are larger; however, the particle-to-particle adhesion needs to be increased by the addition of binders, such as
water or other more viscous liquids, depending on the properties
of the particles being agglomerated and the required strength of
the agglomerate structure (Barbosa-Canovas et al., 2005).
In food industries, most units use static and vibrating fluidized beds to mix the powder, promote inter-particle collisions
and dry the granules (Coucoulas, 1992). Granules are formed by
shear processing in planetary mixers, ribbon blenders, Z-blade
units, and high-speed intensive mixers. For example, granulated
enzyme products can be manufactured by mixing enzyme solution with a suitable filler to form dough, which is then pressed
into fine granules. The granules are then sprayed with a suitable binder and further dried in a fluidized bed dryer (Harkonen
et al., 1993). Sometimes, a large amount of fine products are
reprocessed, causing economical burden to this technology.
Atomizer Wheel
This method is used when powder cannot withstand a forceful
agglomeration process or where small-sized agglomerates are
desired. The layout closely resembles the agglomerating tube
method. The only difference is that a rotary atomizer replaces
the agglomerating tube. The powder falls around the rotating
atomizing wheel and is sprayed with water or binder solution.
This system is used for certain baby foods, beverage whiteners,
and cocoa/sugar mixtures (Masters and Stoltze, 1973; Jinapong
et al., 2008).
Figure 2
unit volume with short average residence time and narrow residence time distribution (Schuchmann et al., 1993) to produce
products with uniform size and properties.
If the feed contains dry agglomerates, for example, fines
bound together by van der Waals forces, these agglomerates
also take up water, further stabilizing these agglomerates. After
an average residence time ranging from 1 to 2 s, the particles
leave the agglomeration zone and enter the drying zone. Drying
of the agglomerates causes crystallization of soluble substances
in the liquid bridges joining the primary particles, finally turning
the liquid bridges into solid ones. On the other hand, depending
on the drying rate and temperature, these bridges may consist of
an amorphous structure. In any case, the agglomerates formed
by collision in the wetting zone as well as any agglomerates
having entered with the feed are stabilized.
Binders
Binders are adhesives that provide the cohesiveness essential
for the bonding of solid particles during the process of agglomeration. In wet granulation process, binders promote size
enlargement and thereby improve flowability of the blend during the manufacturing process. During wet massing, the binder
may be dissolved in the granulating solvent, which is then added
to the powder, or mixed dry with the powder and the granulating solvent (generally water) (Barbosa-Canovas et al., 2005).
Binders are classified as natural polymers, synthetic polymers,
or sugars. Some commonly used binders in wet granulation
are starch, gelatin, acacia gum, sodium alginate, alginic acid,
methylcellulose, Na-carboxymethylcellulose, glucose, sucrose,
and sorbitol. In the food system, binders are used in aqueous
solution of lactose or dextrose, gelatine, or a food gum. In product, the nature of the binder is a major factor that determines the
granule strength, attrition resistance, and granule dustiness. It
affects the dispersion and dissolution properties, ingredient release rate, and the chemical stability of the ingredients (Knight,
2001).
The factors influencing the binder efficiency are concentration, viscosity, mechanical properties of the binder, interparticulate interactions between the binder and the substrate,
and binder distribution. Binders differ in their bonding efficiency. For example, gelatin or acacia provide high hardness
and slow disintegration to the agglomerate. Methylcellulose produces granulations that compress easily. Glucose or sucrose can
be applied as syrups in concentrations above 50% in wet granulation processes exhibiting good bonding properties, although
sucrose produces hard and brittle bridges (Barbosa-Canovas et
al, 2005). In the agglomeration process, the binder provides
capillary and viscous forces that give the wet granules mechanical strength and particularly with high shear mixer granulation.
The viscosity of the binder is a very important variable affecting
the rate of size enlargement, morphology of the granule, and the
size distribution obtained (Mills et al., 2000; Keningley et al.,
1997). A multidimensional model enables the study of critical
parameters in binder granulation such as the reaction rate (so-
437
438
K. DHANALAKSHMI ET AL.
CHARACTERIZATION OF AGGLOMERATED
PRODUCTS
The density is of primary importance in applications involving bulk flow of air around the particles like in fluidization, of
liquid as sedimentation, or flow-through packed beds. The measurement of bulk density is of fundamental use by the industry
to adjust storage, processing, packaging, and distribution conditions. Bulk density is the mass of the particles that occupies
a unit volume of a bed, whereas porosity is defined as the volume of the voids within the bed divided by the total volume of
the bed. There are several types of bulk density based on the
method of volume determination. The bulk density (b) of powders is the mass of the particles that occupies the unit volume
of a bed. It is determined by particle density, which in turn is
determined by solid density, particle internal porosity, and also
by special arrangement of the particles in the container. Bulk
density includes the volume of the solid and liquid materials,
and all pores. Compact or compacted density is determined after compressing the powders bulk mass by mechanical pressure
and impact(s). Tap or tapped density results after a volume of
powder has been tapped or vibrated under specific conditions.
Loose bulk density is measured after a powder is freely poured
into a container. Aerated bulk density is used for testing under
fluidized conditions or during pneumatic conveying. The volume fraction of air over the total bed volume is called porosity
(Barbosa and Juliano, 2005).
Flowability
The knowledge and characterization of raw materials and
products are essential to select appropriate method and machine, optimize processes, functionality, product formulation,
and reduce the cost of the product. The bulk properties of food
powders are a function of physical and chemical properties of the
material, the geometry, size, and surface characteristics of the
individual particles, as well as the whole system. Parameters that
determine the properties of agglomerates include those related
to primary particles and agglomerates. Thus, the measurement
of powder property is important because these properties intrinsically affect powder behavior during storage, handling, and
processing.
Physical Properties
Bulk Density and Porosity
The density of the sample is conventionally referred to as
mass per unit volume. It is considered quite relevant for determining other particle properties such as bulk powder structure
and particle size requiring a careful definition. Density of a
powder system decides the container volume, requirement of
packaging materials, and selection of machinery for processing.
Depending on how the total volume is measured, different definitions of particle density can be given; these are true particle
density, the apparent particle density, or the effective (or aerodynamic) particle density. Most food particles have densities
considerably lower of about 10001500 kgm3 .
439
et al., 2001). Van der Waals and electrostatic attraction are not
as high as the inter-particle connecting force coming from liquid bridges (Schubert, 1987). Van der Waals forces arise from
electron motion among dipoles and act over very short distances
within the material structure, becoming prevalent when the particle size is less than 1 m (Hartley et al., 1985). Electrostatic
forces are longer ranging forces that arise through surface differences on particles and are present when the material does not
dissipate electrostatic charges.
Solid bridge is formed as a result of sintering, solid diffusion,
condensation, or chemical reaction and arises from the material
deposited between the agglomerated particles. Solid bridges can
also be built up by chemical reaction, crystallization of dissolved
substances, hardening of binders, and solidification of melted
components (Loncin and Merson, 1979). Liquid bridges are related to chemical interactions between particle components and
result from the presence of bulk liquid (generally unbound water or melted lipids) between the individual particles. In liquid
bridges, the force of particle adhesion arises either from surface tension of the liquid/air system (as in the case of a liquid
droplet) or from capillary pressure. Composition of the liquid
in the bridge varies in different food materials. The bridging
potential or stickiness is related to factors such as powder
moisture, fat or low-molecular-weight sugar content, and the
shape of the particles (Barbosa-Canovas et al., 2005).
Instant Properties
The instantaneous properties of agglomerates are the most
desirable properties of agglomeration processes and they can be
measured by the following four dissolution properties when agglomerates are spread on the surface of liquid (Schubert, 1987).
These are wettability (liquid penetration into a porous agglomerate system due to capillary action), sinkability (the sinking
of agglomerates below the liquid surface), dispersibility (the
dispersion of agglomerates with little stirring), and solubility
(dissolving of soluble agglomerates in the liquid).
The ability of the bulk powder to imbibe a liquid under the
influence of capillary forces is called wettability (Freudig et al.,
1999) and it is the ability of the powder particles to overcome
the surface tension between themselves and the liquid (Fang
et al., 2008). In technical processes, the wetting of the particles
is often the rate-controlling step and depends largely on particle
size. The importance of wettability lies in the development and
quality control of several food powders like milk powder, instant
tea and coffee, and instant mixes for which claims have been
made that they have instant properties like solubility. The conditions favoring good wettability are large particles with large
pores in between, high porosity as long as a critical porosity is
not exceeded, and small contact angle (Freudig et al., 1999). The
presence of free fat in the surface reduces wettability. The selective use of surface-active agents, such as lecithin, can sometimes
improve wettability in dried products containing fat.
Sinkability is defined as the falling of powder particles below the surface of an aqueous phase or liquid (Thomas et al.,
440
K. DHANALAKSHMI ET AL.
REFERENCES
Adhikari, B., Howes, T., Bhandari, B.R., and Truong, V. (2001). Stickiness in
foods: A review of mechanisms and test methods. Int J Food Prop. 4: 133.
Augsburger, L.L. and Vuppala, M.K. (1997). Theory of granulation. In: Handbook of Pharmaceutical Granulation Technology, pp. 79. Parikh, D.M., Ed.,
Marcel Dekker, New York.
Barbosa-Canovas, G.V., Rivas, E.O., Juliano, P., and Yan, H. (2005). Size enlargement. In: Food Powders: Physical Properties, Processing and Functionality, pp. 175198. Kluwer Academic/Plenum, New York.
Barbosa-Canovas, G.V. and Juliano, P. (2005). Physical and chemical properties of food powders. In: Encapsulated and Powdered Foods, pp. 4071.
Onwulata, C., Ed.,, pp.4071. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL.
Bergquist, D.H., Lorimor, G.D., and Wildy, E.T. (1992). Method for agglomerating food powders. US Patent 5130156.
Berizzi, H.P. (2004). Process for the manufacture of flour mixes for baking.
German Federal Republic Patent, DE 10248160A1.
Braumann, A., Goodson, M.J., Kraft, M., and Mort, P.R., (2007). Modelling and
validation of granulation with heterogeneous binder dispersion and chemical
reaction. Chem Eng Sci. 62: 47174728.
Buffo, R.A., Probst, K., Zehentbauer, G., Luo, Z., and Reineccius, G.A. (2002).
Effects of agglomeration on the properties of spray-dried encapsulated flavors.
Flavour Fragr J. 17: 292299.
Camp, W.F. and Fischbach, E.R. (1990). Chocolate coated beverage mixes. US
Patent 4980181.
Capodieci, R.A. (2002). Cereal food product and method. US Patent
2002/0127310 A1.
Caric, M. and Milanovic, S. (2002). Milk powders: Physical and functional
properties of milk powders. In: Encyclopaedia of Dairy Sciences, pp. 1874
1880.Elsevier: Oxford.
Caspers, G., Klein, C., Krell, L., and Moerle-Heynisch, T., (2001). Process for manufacture of a gelling sugar. German Federal Republic Patent,
DE10016906A1.
Coucoulas, L., (1992). Agglomeration food for thought. Process Eng. 8: 2931.
Cremer, B.K., Leung, H.K., Manis, B., Miller, K.S., Niermann, J.T., Root, F.T.,
Sheppard, M.W., Stalder, J., and Wayne, E. (2008). Free flowing vegetable
powder and method for its manufacture. US Patent 2008/0182006 A1.
Cunningham, C.R. (2007). Agglomerated starch compositions. US Patent
7186293 B2.
Dewettinck, K. and Huyghebaert, A., (1998). Top-spray fluidized bed coating:
Effect of process variables on coating efficiency. Lebensm Wiss u Technol.
31: 568575.
Dewettinck, K., Deroo, L., Messens, W., and Huyghebaert, A., (1998). Agglomeration tendency during top spray fluidized bed coating with gums. Lebensm
Wiss u Technol. 31: 576584.
Dewettinck, K., Deroo, L., Messens, W., and Huyghebaert, A. (1999). Agglomeration tendency during top spray fluidized bed coating with gelatin and starch
hydrolysate. Lebensm Wiss u Technol 32:102106.
Dziezak, J.D. (1988). Microencapsulation and encapsulated ingredients. Food
Technol. 42: 136148.
Eichler, K. (1996). Lipid coating in the food industries. Food Technol Europe.
3: 122126.
Ennis, B.J., Tardos G.I., and Pfeffer, R. (1991). A microlevel based characterization of granulation phenomena. Powder Technol. 65: 257272.
Fang, Y., Selomulya, C., and Chen, X.D. (2008). On measurement of food
powder reconstitution properties. Drying Technol. 26: 314.
Fotos, J. and Bishay, I., (2001), Process for preparing an N-[N-(3,3dimethylbutyl)-L-alpha-aspartyl)-L-phenylalanine 1-methyl ester agglomerate. US Patent 6180157B1.
Freudig, B., Hogekamp, S., and Schubert, H. (1999). Dispersion of powders in
liquids in a stirrer vessel. Chem Eng Processing. 38: 525532.
Fuchs, M., Turchiuli, C., Bohin, M., Cuvelier, M.E., Ordonnaud, C., PeyratMaillard, M.N., and Dumoulin, E. (2006). Encapsulation of oil in powder
using spray drying and fluidised bed agglomeration. J Food Eng. 75: 2735.
Galet, L., Vu, T.O., Oulahna, D., and Fages, J, (2004). The wetting behavior and
dispersion rate of cocoa powder in water. Food Bioproducts Processing. 82:
298303.
Gharsallaoui, A., Roudaut, G., Chambin, O., Voilley, A., and Saurel, R. (2007).
Applications of spray drying in microencapsulation of food ingredients: An
overview. Food Res Intl. 40: 11071121.
Ghosal, S., Indira, T.N., and Bhattacharya, S. (2010). Agglomeration of a model
food powder: Effect of maltodextrin and gum Arabic dispersions on flow
behavior and compacted mass. J. Food Eng. 96: 222228.
Gong, Z., Zhang, M., Mujumdar, A.S., and Sun, J., (2008). Spray drying and
agglomeration of instant bayberry powder. Drying Technol. 26: 116121.
Grossman, A., Kryukov, V.M., and Zeiler, B.N. (2007). Composition and methods for binding agglomeration proteins. US Patent 7232807 B2.
Haefliger, H., Dupart, P., Blasius, L., and Kehrli, P. (2001). Granular food
product. EP Patent 1074188B1.
Harkonen, H., Koskinen, M., Linko, P., Siika-aho, M., and Poutanen, K. (1993).
Granulation of enzyme powders in a fluidized bed spray granulator. Lebensm
Wiss u Technol. 26: 223241.
Hartley, P.A., Parfitt, G.D., and Pollack, L.B. (1985). The role of the Van der
Waals force in the agglomeration of powders containing submicron particles.
Powder Technol. 42: 3546.
Hogekamp, S., Schubert, H., and Wolf, S. (1996). Steam jet agglomeration of
water-soluble material. Powder Technol. 86: 4957.
Hyodo, M., Fujimoto, K., Abe, S., and Tokizane, M., (2003). Chewing gum
composition. US Patent 6537595B1.
Jenike, A.W. (1964). Storage and flow of solids. Bulletin 123, Utah Engineering
Experiment Station, Salt Lake City, UT.
Jinapong, N., Suphantharika, M., and Jamnong, P. (2008). Production of instant
soymilk powders by ultrafiltration, spray drying and fluidized bed agglomeration. J Food Eng. 84: 194205.
Johanson, J.R. (1992). The Johanson indicizer system versus the Jenike shear
tester. Bulk Solids Handling. 12: 237240.
Keningley, S.T., Knight, P.C., and Marson, A.D. (1997). An investigation into
the effects of binder viscosity on agglomeration behavior. Powder Technol.
91: 95103.
Kimura, Y., and Teraunchi, M. (1999). Process for producing granular cocoa.
US Patent 6007857.
Knight, P.C. (2001). Structuring agglomerated products for improved performance. Powder Technol. 119: 1425.
Kowalska, J. and Lenart, A. (2005). The influence of ingredients distribution on
properties of agglomerated cocoa products. J Food Eng. 68: 155161.
Lillford, P.J. and Fryer, P.J. (1998). Food particles and the problems of hydration.
Inst Chem Engineers. 76: 797802.
Loncin, M. and Merson, R.L., (1979). Food Engineering: Principles and Selected
Applications, pp. 229271.Academic Press, New York.
Masters, K. and Stoltze, A., (1973). Agglomeration advances. Food Eng. 45:
6467.
Mills, P.J.T., Seville, J.P.K, Knight P.C., and Adams, M.J. (2000). The effect of
binder viscosity on particle agglomeration in a low shear mixer agglomerator.
Powder Technol, 113: 140147.
Mukherjee, S. and Bhattacharya, S. (2006). Characterization of agglomeration
process as a function of moisture content using a model food powder. J Texture
Studies, 37: 3548.
Nasirpour, A., Scher, J.L., and Desobry, S. (2006). Baby foods: Formulations
and interactions: A review. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr. 46: 665681.
Omobuwajo, T.O., Busari, O.T., and Osemwegie, A.A. (2000). Thermal agglomeration of chocolate drink powder. J Food Eng. 46: 7381.
Palzer, S. (2005). The effect of glass transition on the desired and undesired
agglomeration of amorphous food powders. Chem Eng Sci, 60: 39593968.
Peleg, M., (1978). Flowability of food powders and methods for its evaluation:
A review. J Food Process Eng. 1: 303328.
Pietsch, W. (1999). Readily engineer agglomerates with special properties from
micro- and nanosized particles. Chem Eng Progress, 8: 6781.
441