WOODY AND
HE YEAR 1 WAS 13, MY ONLY
friend was a famous man who
lived far away, and wrote me
letters in plain brown enve-
lopes that I told my mother
were from “a girl from
camp.” Hiding behind the
stacks in my school library, I had written
to him in desperation, skipping math, |
didn’t like math, or
couldn't understand,
seemed like everything
I was a precocious, too sensitive gitl
‘who felt disliked by all, even my family
anything else 1
which some days
which was hardly impressed by my knack
for delivering lines from Antigone ot Bar
bara Stanwyck movies when asked to do
houschold chores. I escaped into a world
Of nineteenth-century novels and 1940s
after which I styled my clothing:
hhuge thrift-store shoulder pads that stuck
‘out from me like a yoke sharp
Mary Astor fedoras that 1 hid behind,
This, according to my high-school year
book, made me a ““Geek/Freak
Coral Gables, Florida, where girls were
Dolphin:
cette” cheerleaders and go to parties where
supposed to want to be bouncy
they painted their toenails
My classmates plucked the hats from
my head and threw them across the hall
amused at Halt!
Knaves! Infamy! 1 sat
my cries of
When I was 1
alone every day in a corner of the lunch:
room, furtively scribbling my thoughts to
‘my treasured secret sharer on Fifth Ave-
nue. He liked me, 1 thought, throwing
dark looks at whoever had just flung the
peas into the brim of my fedora. He un:
derstood (I was sure we must be alike
with our red hair and quick-witted eccen.
tricity), And he was better then all of
them, He'd even diagnosed me as a “gen:
That year, I floated along on pride and
wonder at the thought of this, at the ex:
quisite surprise of my pen pal’s identity
His name was Woody Allen,
In 1978, Woody was 42. He had made
Annie Hall and was at turning point in
his career. He was between Diane Keaton
and Mia Farrow; he had no children, In
the media’s indulgent eye, he was both an
auteur and a sex symbol, a hybrid that was
equal parts Jean-Luc Godard, Jerry Lewis,
and Job. For a nation of women beset by
newly sensitive men, Woody, with
cringing charisma, had become a genera
tional icon, With the great changes over
taking his life (he was writing Interiors,
his first serious movie), I don’t know how
he found the time—and can't say why he
hhad the inclination—to respond to that
first leter I wrote him. In it—God knows
why—I carried on as if we had always
other, and told him how un:
known ea
happy I was, how bored and full of yearn:
ing to do something meaningful—whatev-
er it might be
Dear Nancy
Hard to believe you're 13! When 1
was 13 1 couldn't dress myself, and
here you write about one of life's deep
‘est philosophical problems, ie, ext
tential boredom. I guess it's hard for me
ine a 15-yearold quoting any
thing but Batman—but 1. Mann!!?
Anyway, there’ too much wron
the world 10 ever get too relaxed ar
happy. The more natural stave, ant
better one, think, is one of some anxi
ty and tension over man's plight in
Next time you write, if you ever do,
please lst some of the books you've en
Jjoyed and movies, and which masic
you've liked, and also the things you
lke and have no patience with, And
Ime what kind of place Coral Gables
is, And what sehool do you go to? What
hobbies do you have? How old are your
parents and what do they do? Or are
ou @ poor family? Do you speak an
‘ther language? What are your moods
like? Do you brood much? Are you en:
ergetic? Are you un early riser? Are you
nto clothes”? Does the relentless sun
and humidity of Florida have an effect
fon you? At the moment, Lam re,fiming
some parts of my next film which have
not come out 0 good.
Best-—-Wood
I was born during a hurricane. Water
rushed down the halls of the hospitalnurses screamed, and at my rather dra:
matic 13, | ook this to be a cosmic warn:
ing to the world of my arrival—or perhaps
‘4 warning to me of the hostile nature of
the world. I'm not sure if I told Woody
this in any of the many, many letters I
sent, (Two letters from you in one day!
he once cheerfully exclaimed.) But the
young writing student Rain (Juliette Lew-
is) in Husbands and Wives was born dur
ing a hurricane too.
Watching Woody's films, as the years
‘g0 by, I sometimes experience a little jolt
Of recognition that makes me wonder if I
could possibly have had some lasting ef
fect on him, as he so affected me. Since
the news of his love affair with Soon-Yi
Previn, and the clamor over his breakup
with Mia and alleged yen for underage
girls, I have listened to all the Woody
jokes with discomfort and outrage—be
cause I wonder if they are also, somehow
con me. I prefer to think they aren't. There
is a delicate and dangerous line that can
be crossed in a relationship between a
‘man and a young girl; but this side of it
seems more a cause for celebration than
suspicion. At least, that’s how I feel about
‘Woody and me
Dear Nancy
Lam finished with my film [nteriors)
and at work on a new (this time fury)
script (Manhattan). I wanted to suggest
that you read some books by S.J. Perel
‘man and somte essays by Robert Bench:
ley. Both are very funny, and if you en-
joyed my books you'll really like theirs
Did you tell me you like jazz music? If
$0, Ill recommend some records. Don't
forget to listen to Mahler's Fourth Sym
42 NEW YORK/APRIL 5, 1995
record
ise you re in love with
40th Symphony? They are
phony (hopefully the Bemsici
a fine writer. 1 enjoy many
of his fictional pieces even more than
his nonfiction. Did you read The Wall
or The Room? Kierkegaard is the most
romantic of the existentialist thinkers
Camus is the best writer. Also,
might enjoy the films The Lady From
Shanghai, Me. and Mrs. Smith, Bomb.
shell... 've been reading too much
Carl Jung—a psychoanalyst of dubious
merit. I'm blue because the Knicks lost
dnd basketball season is virtually over
‘Keep in touch Woody A.
HE FACE OF SOON-YI PREVIN, IN
the famous photo of her hold-
ing hands with Woody Allen
courtside at a Knicks game, is
full of love and awe and ro-
mantic expectation, and, |
think, a certain magic cast by
seerels, and unexpected atten:
tion, Her face is full of discovery—a pow
erful force, potentially a subversive thing
I believe it’s valuable no matter how it's
attained, The complex need in girls—and
in young women, too—for a guide and
teacher is something Woody hasn’t ex
plored in his work so much as he has his
own delight in playing the teacher.
I'l give you your lesson for today,” he
tells the Annie Hall-ishly dressed, ador-
able girl who plays his niece in Crimes and
Misdemeanors. "Your lesson is this:
Don't listen to what your schoolteachers
ell you'
liberating enough messa
Listen
with the underlying appeal being
tome.” He tells this to the niece out
movie theater where he often takes her to
watch his favorite old movies. In Marthat-
fan, there is some wonderfully affection:
fate’ banter between Woody's character
and Mariel Hemingway's Tracy as he ex
plains to her the difference between Ve
ronica Lake and Rita Hayworth; watching
late-night TV with her, he smiles blissfully
when Grand Ilusion comes on,
Ubelieve he's trying to convey the irre
sistible satisfaction of a relationship in
which rediscovery of the things one loves
best is possible, the joy of being able to
give someone the gift of experiencing, for
the first time, great things. (At the end of
Manhattan these things become fused
with the loved one they are offered to:
‘Why is life worth living?” Woody's char
acter, Isaac Davis, asks himself into a tape
recorder. “Louis Armstrong .. . Senti
mental Education by Flaubert . .. Those
incredible apples and pears by Cé.
zanne ... Tracy's face.") Rereading
Woody's letters, I am touched by his out:
pouring of recommendations, his repeti
tion of the word enjoy. That he wanted me
to enjoy the movies and books he loved
fills me with gratitude. I did enjoy them; |
still do,
once asked Woody whom he would
like to have dinner with, if he could
choose anyone in history. "Perhaps Jelly
Roll Morion,” he replied, “and Zelda
Fitzgerald and maybe Babe Ruth and Che
khov and Sophocles and Charlotte Ram:
pling and Dostoevsky and Tolstoy and
Kafka and Proust and Yeats and—oh, |
could go on for a long time.” We had ar
Fotopage Pte right, Donal Hy.guments, one rather heated one about
Scarlett O'Hara, whom 1 idolized all out
of proportion and whom he considered
unworthy—until I wore him down. “I saw
Gone With the Wind (at first) four times
in four days,” he wrote. “I was about 17
of 18, [fell in love with Scarlett. She was
my dream, She drove me crazy. Then |
saw the film years later (I was 30), and |
realized what a bitch she was and how I'd
grown up regarding my taste in women.
Now I'm not so sure.
Every day I raced home from schoo!
hoping to find one of the brown envelopes
in our mailbox. When there wasn't one, |
was despondent, and when there was, |
felt a thrill | have not since experienced.
except perhaps when getting an unexpect
ed check. Either way, I would spend the
afternoons composing and polishing an-
other letter to my mentor. I realize now it
was when 1 first fell in love with writing
Woody encouraged this in me. I think he
saw it happening (he was the inspiration)
once telling me that something | wrote
read funny.” At the time, I couldn't
imagine a greater success than_-making
him laugh,
MET HIM ONLY ONCE—A DAY THAT
lives on in the annals of my
‘most misbegotten moments, It
was all wrong. | had lost the
feather to my fedora. It was
raining, a cold, dark, clammy
day, and | and my stepmother
(who had brought me along on
@ shopping trip to. Manhattan) were
trapped in the hospitality of an_ultra—
Palm Beach female acquaintance who had
recently had a nose job and—like some-
thing out of @ Woody Allen movie—could
talk of nothing else
Thad left him @ note, and 1 my de
light—and dread—he had called my hotel
ten minutes later asking me over. At the
last minute I became panic-stricken at the
thought of seeing Woody Allen in person,
but the stunned and excited women prod:
ded me on. | knew that an epistolary rela
tionship is fragile, like those delicate ferns
that crumple when touched. My kne
shaking, I tottered into his penthouse on a
pair of too tall Katharine Hepburn san:
dals, with which, because of the cold, 1
had been forced to wear socks.
| remember how pale his skin was be
hind the trademark glasses, how translu:
cent he looked, like a corpse or an angel.
When he opened the door, | don’t think
he knew which one of us I was. (I was as
tall as my two companions, who were
both barely 30.) Couldn't he tell? My
heart sank. “Sit down!” I remember our
Gold Coast acquaintance hissing at me, as
she smiled and began to inform Woody of
her real-estate-raider husband's financi
conquests.
We eat at Elaine's, too,” she said.
[fell into Woody's sofa wishing I could
silence the woman by feigning vertigo.
And he—wearing his very same clothes
from Annie Hall—sat Indian style in an
armchair, much like a 13-year-old, nod:
dding politely, trying to catch my eye. 1
scowled. I have noticed that in Woody's
films he often repeats a line about having
your worst fears realized. It had been my
worst fear, at 15, that T would lose this
improbable friend, And here it was hap-
pening, as if 1 were watching our letters
being shredded by wolves.
What had I imagined? Something, 1
suppose, very much like the scenario of
Manhatian—Woody and | taking in art
galleries, talking over books and movies
‘Often discounted in the recent hysteria
surrounding adult/child relations are the
very real, very romantic. fanci
tained by developing girls. Perhaps some-
times girls make too much of them; 1
think Woody saw that in me the day we
met, He had an enormous tray on his cof
fee table, and I remember a gorgeous ar-
ray of foods—intensely colored fruits and
carefully wrapped candies. It seemed so
unlike him, that tray, and yet, in its sump:
tuous generosity, it seemed to fit. | never
{got to sample a thing. It was time to go,
and I looked into his eyes only at the end
ing. “Good-bye
of our me they said
sadly.
teenage way, to get over him.
But when I went away to prep
school, on his recommendation,
and then on to-a college that he
had also suggested, I finally met
people who were more like me.
I made friends, And from time
io time, when I felt close enough to one, |
‘would tell him or her about my letters to
Woody Allen, and how he wrote back,
urging me to read Proust and Kierke:
gaard, making me feel that | could handle
anything, “Your kind of mind and feelings
is a prize to have even though you will
have to pay a high price for it,” he wrote. 1
never heard from him again -