You are on page 1of 261

Judicial Watch v.

DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Title
Number
Type
Email
0230Z 12 Sep
2014-23/
2012 JUKEBOX
AFRICOM/
1-3
LOTUS

2014-23/
Slideshow
AFRICOM/
4

Date

Classification

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a)

Explanation of Exempt Material


Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations.

Air Movement
Update: Current
as of
130100ZSEP12
(United States
Africa Command:
Jukebox Lotus) 12
1000Z Sep 2012,
Operations &
Intelligence
Update

9/13/12
0100Z

9/12/12 SECRET// (b)(1)1.4(a), (c);


1000Z NOFORN// (b)(6)
ORCON

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).

2014-23/
Slideshow
AFRICOM/
19-34

(United States
Africa Command:
Jukebox Lotus) 12
1400Z Sep 2012,
Operations &
Intelligence
Update

9/15/12 SECRET// (b)(1)1.4(a), (c);


1400Z NOFORN// (b)(6)
ORCON

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).

2014-23/
Emails
AFRICOM/
35

13 2100Z
9/13/12
JUKEBOX
11:17pm
LOTUS
Movement Update

2014-23/
Slideshow
AFRICOM/
5-18

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, exemption
(b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b, protects personally identifiable information
regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and
10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and personnel information for members
of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National
Geospational-Intelligence Agency. Lastly, personal privacy information of government
and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption
(b)(6)

1 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Title
Number
Type
2014-23/
Slideshow Air Movement
AFRICOM/
Update: Current
36
as of
130052ZSEP12
2014-23/
Slideshow (United States
AFRICOM/
Africa Command:
37-55
Jukebox Lotus) 13
0700Z SEP 2012

Date
9/13/12
0052Z

Classification
SECRET

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions
(b)(1)1.4(a)

Explanation of Exempt Material


Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations.

9/13/12 SECRET// (b)(1)1.4(a), (c);


0700Z NOFORN// (b)(6)
ORCON

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).

2014-23/
Slideshow
AFRICOM/
56-82

(United States
Africa Command:
Jukebox Lotus) 13
1400Z SEP 2012

9/13/12 SECRET// (b)(1)1.4(a), (c);


1400Z NOFORN// (b)(3): 10 USC
ORCON 130b; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3) as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of private citizens is
protected under exemption (b)(6).

2014-23/
Theater
AFRICOM/ Analysis
83-84
Report

J2-Intelligence
and Knowledge
Development

9/13/12

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to intelligence activities, sources or methods.
Additionally, this document contains personally identifiable information regarding
personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information
which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly,
personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of GS15/0-6 or below, information protected under exemption (b)(6).

Letter/Repo Commander US
2014-23/
Africa Command
AFRICOM/ rt
Request for
85-91
Forces 7120XXX

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
92

Benghazi Attack
CCIR Update
brief

SECRET// (b)(1)1.4(c);
NOFORN// (b)(3): 10 USC
ORCON 130b; (b)(6)

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

9/12/12 UNCLASS- (b)(3): 10 USC


2:07am
IFIED
130b; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3),as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).
Personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas,
sensitive, or routinely deployable unit is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates
to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Additionally, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

2 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Title
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
blurb
AFRICOM/
93

Date

Classification

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions

Explanation of Exempt Material

9/12/12
6:59am

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to intelligence activities, sources or methods.
Additionally, this document contains personally identifiable information regarding
personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information
which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly,
personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of GS15/0-6 or below, information protected under exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, personal privacy information of
government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information
protected under exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6).
Personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas,
sensitive, or routinely deployable unit is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates
to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Additionally, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
94

BPT:

9/12/12
9:15am

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
95-96

Cross
Collaboration

9/13/12
2:56am

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
97

Distro Lists

9/13/12 UNCLASS- (b)(3): 10 USC


7:36pm
IFIED
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
98-104

EXORD 001,
OPERATION
JUKEBOX
LOTUS

SECRET/
NONE

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3),as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).

3 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Title
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
EXORD 002,
AFRICOM/
OPERATION
105-113
JUKEBOX
LOTUS

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
114

2014-23/
Log
AFRICOM/
115-122

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
123

Date

Classification
SECRET/
NONE

9/12/12
9:12am

Log

SECRET//
NOFORN

SECRET//
NOFORN

9/12/12
6:35am

SECRET

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions

Explanation of Exempt Material

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3),as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).
(b)(1)1.4(a), (c); Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
(b)(3): 10 USC
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
130b, 10 USC activities, sources or methods. Additionally, exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C.
424; (b)(6)
130b, protects personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an
overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects
organizational and personnel information for members of the Defense Intelligence
Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency.
Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of
GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption (b)(6).
(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6).
(b)(1)1.4(a);
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
(b)(3): 10 USC
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, exemption
130b, 10 USC (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b, protects personally identifiable information
424; (b)(6)
regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and
10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and personnel information for members
of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National
Geospatial-Intelligence Agency. Lastly, personal privacy information of government
and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption
(b)(6)

4 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Title
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
FW: JUKEBOX
AFRICOM/
LOTUS124-142

Date

Classification

9/13/12
1:49am

SECRET//
NOFORN

9/12/12
10:48am

SECRET//
NOFORN

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
143-161

FW: JUKEBOX
LOTUS-

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
162-167

FW: Cairo Update


(12 Sep, 1300L)

9/12/12
8:02pm

SECRET//
NOFORN

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
168-169

FW: DJ3 RFIs


from 12/1400
EDT DC SVTC's

9/12/12
10:48pm

SECRET

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions

Explanation of Exempt Material

(b)(1)1.4(a), (g);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and vulnerabilities or
capabilities of systems, installations, projects, plans or protection services relating to
national security. Additionally, this document contains personally identifiable
information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely
deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to
10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military
officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under exemption
(b)(6)
(b)(1)1.4(a);
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
(b)(3): 10 USC
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
130b; (b)(6)
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).
(b)(1)1.4(a), (b), Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
(d), (g); (b)(3): 10 protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; foreign government
USC 130b;
information; foreign relations or foreign activities of the United States; and
(b)(6)
vulnerabilities or capabilities of systems, installations, projects, plans or protection
services relating to national security. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6)
(b)(1)1.4(a), (g); Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
(b)(3): 10 USC
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and vulnerabilities or
130b; (b)(6)
capabilities of systems, installations, projects, plans or protection services relating to
national security. Additionally, this document contains personally identifiable
information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely
deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to
10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military
officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under exemption
(b)(6)

5 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Title
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
FW:
AFRICOM/
___________ Co
170-172
working
Copy.docx

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY

Date

Classification

Exemptions

9/13/12
11:20pm

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
173-175

FW:

9/13/12
9:35pm

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a), (g);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
176-177

FW:

9/12/12
11:25pm

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a), (g);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
178-179

FW:

9/12/12
9:08am

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Explanation of Exempt Material


Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and vulnerabilities or
capabilities of systems, installations, projects, plans or protection services relating to
national security. Additionally, this document contains personally identifiable
information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely
deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to
10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military
officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under exemption
(b)(6)
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and vulnerabilities or
capabilities of systems, installations, projects, plans or protection services relating to
national security. Additionally, this document contains personally identifiable
information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely
deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to
10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military
officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under exemption
(b)(6)
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6).

6 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Title
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
FW: Situation
AFRICOM/
Report as of 0030
180-195
12 September
2012

Date

Classification

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions

9/12/12
1:59pm

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C.
130b, protects personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an
overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects
organizational and personnel information for members of the Defense Intelligence
Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency.
Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of
GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, exemption
(b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b, protects personally identifiable information
regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and
10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and personnel information for members
of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National
Geospatial-Intelligence Agency. Lastly, personal privacy information of government
and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption
(b)(6)
Released in Full

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
196-200

FW: (Secret)

9/12/12
7:28am

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
201
2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
202-203

FW: (U) VTC


Question

9/13/12
10:41am

SECRET

N/A

9/12/12
7:19am

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

FW: AMB Intel

Explanation of Exempt Material

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C.
130b, protects personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an
overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects
organizational and personnel information for members of the Defense Intelligence
Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency.
Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of
GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

7 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
FW:
AFRICOM/
204-206

Title

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
207-209

FW: Benghazi
Timeline

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
210

FW:

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
211-221

FW: HAM RFI

Date

Classification

9/13/12
1:24pm

SECRET//
NOFORN

9/12/12
12:10pm

SECRET//
NOFORN

9/12/12
9:25am

SECRET//
NOFORN

9/12/12
11:12am

SECRET//
NOFORN

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions

Explanation of Exempt Material

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6).
(b)(1)1.4(a), (c); Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
(b)(3): 10 USC
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
130b; (b)(6)
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6).
(b)(1)1.4(a);
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
(b)(3): 10 USC
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, exemption
130b, 10 USC (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b, protects personally identifiable information
424; (b)(6)
regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and
10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and personnel information for members
of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National
Geospatial-Intelligence Agency. Lastly, personal privacy information of government
and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption
(b)(6)
(b)(1)1.4(a), (c); Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
(b)(3): 10 USC
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
130b, 10 USC activities, sources or methods. Additionally, exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C.
424; (b)(6)
130b, protects personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an
overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects
organizational and personnel information for members of the Defense Intelligence
Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency.
Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of
GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

8 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Title
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
FW: HAM RFI
AFRICOM/
222-232

Date

Classification

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions

9/12/12
7:23am

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
233-234

FW: ic/intel coord


re attacks in cairo
and benghazi

9/12/12
7:24am

SECRET

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
235-237

FW: INITIAL 5W- 9/12/12


Benghazi
12:25am
Consulate
Attacked

SECRET

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
238

FW: Intel slides


for the 0600
briefing

SECRET

9/12/12
5:57am

Explanation of Exempt Material


Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C.
130b, protects personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an
overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects
organizational and personnel information for members of the Defense Intelligence
Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency.
Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of
GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6).
(b)(1)1.4(a);
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
(b)(3): 10 USC
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, exemption
130b, 10 USC (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b, protects personally identifiable information
424; (b)(6)
regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and
10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and personnel information for members
of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National
Geospatial-Intelligence Agency. Lastly, personal privacy information of government
and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption
(b)(6)
(b)(3): 10 USC
Personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas,
130b; (b)(6)
sensitive, or routinely deployable unit is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates
to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Additionally, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

9 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Title
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
FW: JOC Watch
AFRICOM/
Update
239-242

Date
9/13/12
6:19pm

Classification
SECRET//
NOFORN

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions
(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

9/12/12 UNCLASS- (b)(3): 10 USC


12:43am
IFIED
130b; (b)(6)

Explanation of Exempt Material


Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6).
Personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas,
sensitive, or routinely deployable unit is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates
to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Additionally, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
243-244

FW: Libya New


Article

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
245-247

FW: No Subject

9/12/12
6:33am

SECRET

(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas,


sensitive, or routinely deployable unit is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates
to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Additionally, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
248

FW:

9/13/12
5:29pm

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a), (b),
(d); (b)(3): 10
USC 130b;
(b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; foreign government
information; and foreign relations or foreign activities of the United States.
Additionally, this document contains personally identifiable information regarding
personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information
which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly,
personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of GS15/0-6 or below, information protected under exemption (b)(6).

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
249-252

FW:

9/13/12
12:2pm

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a), (b),
(d); (b)(3): 10
USC 130b, 10
USC 424; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; foreign government
information; and foreign relations or foreign activities of the United States.
Additionally, exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b, protects personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and
personnel information for members of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National
Reconnaissance Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency. Lastly, personal
privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or
below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

10 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Title
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
FW: Slides for
AFRICOM/
1400Z Meeting
253-256

Date

Classification

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions

Explanation of Exempt Material

9/12/12
3:52pm

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to intelligence activities, intelligence sources or methods.
Additionally, exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b, protects personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and
personnel information for members of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National
Reconnaissance Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency. Lastly, personal
privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or
below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
257-258

FW: SOCAF Intel


Sync DCO For
Jukebox Lotus

9/13/12
6:18pm

SECRET

(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas,


sensitive, or routinely deployable unit is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates
to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Additionally, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
259-261

FW:

9/13/12
4:10am

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
262-264

FW:

9/13/12
8:06am

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6).

11 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
FW:
AFRICOM/
265

Title

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
266-285

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
286-287

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
288

INITIAL 5WBenghazi
Consulate
Attacked

Date

Classification

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions

Explanation of Exempt Material

9/12/12
7:23am

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, exemption
(b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b, protects personally identifiable information
regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and
10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and personnel information for members
of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National
Geospatial-Intelligence Agency. Lastly, personal privacy information of government
and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption
(b)(6)
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to intelligence activities, sources or methods.
Additionally, this document contains personally identifiable information regarding
personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information
which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly,
personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of GS15/0-6 or below, information protected under exemption (b)(6).

9/12/12
12:55am

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

9/11/12
10:43pm

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to intelligence activities, sources or methods.
Additionally, this document contains personally identifiable information regarding
personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information
which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly,
personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of GS15/0-6 or below, information protected under exemption (b)(6).

9/12/12
6:44pm

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, exemption
(b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b, protects personally identifiable information
regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and
10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and personnel information for members
of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National
Gestational-Intelligence Agency. Lastly, personal privacy information of government
and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption
(b)(6)

12 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY

Bates
Document
Title
Date Classification
Exemptions
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
Joint Staff Quad
9/13/12
(b)(1)1.4(c);
AFRICOM/
Chart Intel Bullets 11:59am
(b)(3): 10 USC
289-290
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
291

new loc us
personnel

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
292-293

Email
2014-23/
AFRICOM/
294

Explanation of Exempt Material


Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to intelligence activities, sources or methods.
Additionally, exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b, protects personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and
personnel information for members of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National
Reconnaissance Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency. Lastly, personal
privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or
below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

9/12/12
12:14am

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to intelligence activities, sources or methods.
Additionally, exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b, protects personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and
personnel information for members of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National
Reconnaissance Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency. Lastly, personal
privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or
below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

Notes from
12SEP 1800Z
Libya DC

9/13/12
2:15am

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c),
(g); (b)(3): 10
USC 130b;
(b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; intelligence activities,
sources or methods; and vulnerabilities or capabilities of systems, installations, projects,
plans or protection services relating to national security. Additionally, this document
contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an
overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under
exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information
of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information
protected under exemption (b)(6).

POC Contact
Information

9/12/12
9:25am

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6).

13 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Title
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
Re:(S//) Jukebox
AFRICOM/
Lotus Depord (U)
295-296

Date

Classification

9/12/12
9:04am

SECRET//
NOFORN

9/13/12
12:26pm

SECRET//
NOFORN

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions

Explanation of Exempt Material

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).
(b)(1)1.4(a), (c); Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
(b)(3): 10 USC
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
130b, 10 USC activities, sources or methods. Additionally, exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C.
424; (b)(6)
130b, protects personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an
overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects
organizational and personnel information for members of the Defense Intelligence
Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency.
Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of
GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
297-302

Re:
130700ZSEP12
JUKEBOX
LOTUS Update

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
303-306

Re:

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C.
130b, protects personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an
overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects
organizational and personnel information for members of the Defense Intelligence
Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency.
Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of
GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
307-311

Re: 1600Z 12 Sep 9/12/12


2012 JUKEBOX 11:26pm
LOTUS

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a), (g);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and vulnerabilities or
capabilities of systems, installations, projects, plans, or protection services relating to
national security. Additionally, exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b,
protects personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas,
sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects
organizational and personnel information for members of the Defense Intelligence
Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency.
Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of
GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

14 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Title
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
Re: AC-130's to
AFRICOM/
Sig
312-323

Date

Classification

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions

9/13/12 UNCLASS- (b)(1)1.4(a), (b),


11:22pm
IFIED
(d), (g); (b)(3): 10
USC 130b;
(b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
324-326

Re: AOR Arrivals


for 13 Sep 2012

9/13/12 CONFIDENT (b)(1)1.4(a);


6:31pm
IAL
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
327-329

Re:

9/12/12
7:23am

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

9/13/12
10:56pm

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a), (g);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
330-335

Explanation of Exempt Material


Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; foreign government
information; foreign relations or foreign activities of the United States; and
vulnerabilities or capabilities of systems, installations, projects, plans or protection
services relating to national security. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6)
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and vulnerabilities or
capabilities of systems, installations, projects, plans or protection services relating to
national security. Additionally, this document contains personally identifiable
information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely
deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to
10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military
officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under exemption
(b)(6)

15 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Title
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
Re: DJ3 RFIs
AFRICOM/
from 12/1400
336-339
EDT DC SVTCs

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
340-346

Date

Classification

9/12/12
10:48pm

SECRET

9/12/12
9:21am

SECRET//
NOFORN

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
347-348

Re:

9/12/12
6:59pm

SECRET

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
349-352

Re: Joint Staff


Libya CMT
Activation

9/13/12
1:27am

SECRET//
NOFORN

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
353-354

Re: JUKEBOX
9/12/12
LOTUS UPDATE 11:52pm

SECRET//
NOFORN

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions

Explanation of Exempt Material

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).
(b)(1)1.4(a);
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
(b)(3): 10 USC
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
130b; (b)(6)
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).
(b)(1)1.4(a);
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
(b)(3): 10 USC
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
130b; (b)(6)
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).
(b)(1)1.4(a);
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
(b)(3): 10 USC
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
130b; (b)(6)
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).
(b)(1)1.4(a);
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
(b)(3): 10 USC
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, exemption
130b, 10 USC (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b, protects personally identifiable information
424; (b)(6)
regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and
10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and personnel information for members
of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National
Geospatial-Intelligence Agency. Lastly, personal privacy information of government
and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption
(b)(6)

16 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Title
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
Re: JUKEBOX
AFRICOM/
LOTUS UPDATE
355-358

Date

Classification

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions

Explanation of Exempt Material

9/13/12
1:30am

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and vulnerabilities or
capabilities of systems, installations, projects, plans, or protection services relating to
national security. Additionally, exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b,
protects personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas,
sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects
organizational and personnel information for members of the Defense Intelligence
Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency.
Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of
GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
359-363

Re:

9/12/12
7:45am

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and vulnerabilities or
capabilities of systems, installations, projects, plans, or protection services relating to
national security. Additionally, exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b,
protects personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas,
sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects
organizational and personnel information for members of the Defense Intelligence
Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency.
Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of
GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
364-366

Re: Notes from


12SEP 1800Z
Libya DC

9/13/12
3:29pm

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c),
(g); (b)(3): 10
USC 130b;
(b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; intelligence activities,
sources or methods; and vulnerabilities or capabilities of systems, installations, projects,
plans, or protection services relating to national security. Additionally, exemption
(b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b, protects personally identifiable information
regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and
10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and personnel information for members
of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National
Geospatial-Intelligence Agency. Lastly, personal privacy information of government
and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption
(b)(6).

17 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
Re:
AFRICOM/
367-368

Title

Date

Classification

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions

9/12/12
9:02am

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a), (g);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
369-373

Re: [S//N] Libya


Ops

9/13/12
7:00am

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a), (g);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
374-376

Re: [S//N]

9/13/12
8:40am

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c),
(g); (b)(3): 10
USC 130b;
(b)(6)

Explanation of Exempt Material


Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and vulnerabilities or
capabilities or systems, installations, projects, plans, or protection services relating to
national security. Additionally, this document contains personally identifiable
information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely
deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to
10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military
officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under exemption
(b)(6)
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and vulnerabilities or
capabilities or systems, installations, projects, plans, or protection services relating to
national security. Additionally, this document contains personally identifiable
information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely
deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to
10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military
officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under exemption
(b)(6)
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; intelligence activities,
sources or methods; and vulnerabilities or capabilities of systems, installations, projects,
plans, or protection services relating to national security. Additionally, exemption
(b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b, protects personally identifiable information
regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and
10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and personnel information for members
of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National
Geospatial-Intelligence Agency. Lastly, personal privacy information of government
and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption
(b)(6).

18 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Title
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
Re: TF 76-2
AFRICOM/
SITREP-13
377-380
1600Z SEP 2012

Date

Classification

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions

9/13/12 UNCLASS- (b)(1)1.4(a), (g);


6:40pm
IFIED
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
381-384

Re:

9/12/12
8:36am

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a), (g);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
385-387

Re: [S//N] VTC


info

9/12/12
7:32am

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
388-389

Re:
9/12/12
[SECRET,Record 10:14pm
]

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Explanation of Exempt Material


Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and vulnerabilities or
capabilities or systems, installations, projects, plans, or protection services relating to
national security. Additionally, this document contains personally identifiable
information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely
deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to
10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military
officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under exemption
(b)(6)
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and vulnerabilities or
capabilities or systems, installations, projects, plans, or protection services relating to
national security. Additionally, this document contains personally identifiable
information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely
deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to
10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military
officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under exemption
(b)(6)
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).

19 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Title
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
Re:
AFRICOM/
S//RTUF]
390-393

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY

Date

Classification

Exemptions

9/13/12
11:57pm

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a), (b),
(d); (b)(3): 10
USC 130b;
(b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; foreign government
information; and foreign relations or foreign activities of the United States.
Additionally, this document contains personally identifiable information regarding
personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information
which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly,
personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of GS15/0-6 or below, information protected under exemption (b)(6).

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to intelligence activities, sources or methods.
Additionally, this document contains personally identifiable information regarding
personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information
which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly,
personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of GS15/0-6 or below, information protected under exemption (b)(6).

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
394

Re: 0930 Stuttgart


Time Brief

9/12/12
8:38am

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
395-399

Re:
130700zSEP12_J
UKEBOX_LOTU
S_UPDATE(2).pp
tx

9/13/12 UNCLASS- (b)(1)1.4(a);


1:17pm
IFIED
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
400-402

Re: AFRICOM
Analyst
discussions

9/13/12
2:41am

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Explanation of Exempt Material

20 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Title
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
Re: AMB Intel
AFRICOM/
403-404

Date

Classification

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions

Explanation of Exempt Material

9/12/12
5:18am

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to intelligence activities, intelligence sources or methods.
Additionally, exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b, protects personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and
personnel information for members of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National
Reconnaissance Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency. Lastly, personal
privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or
below is protected under exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
405-408

Re:

9/13/12
7:48am

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
409-412

Re: Cross
Collaboration

9/13/12
7:59pm

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
413-414

Re:

9/13/12
12:15pm

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

21 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
Re:
AFRICOM/
415-416

Title

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY

Date

Classification

Exemptions

9/13/12
12:18pm

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
417-418

Re:
_______Telephon
e and Email
Addresses

9/12/12
3:56pm

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
419-424

Re: HAM RFI

9/12/12
7:27am

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
425-427

Re: HAM RFI

9/12/12
2:48am

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Explanation of Exempt Material


Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6).

22 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Title
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
Re:_____Libya
AFRICOM/
Crisis
428-429

Date

Classification

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions

9/12/12
4:53am

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

9/12/12
11:39am

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
430-432

Re:

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
433-434

Re: Libya

9/13/12
7:23pm

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a), (d);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
435-436

Re: Libya Crisis


TAR distribution

9/13/12
2:50pm

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Explanation of Exempt Material


Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, exemption
(b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b, protects personally identifiable information
regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and
10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and personnel information for members
of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National
Geospatial-Intelligence Agency. Lastly, personal privacy information of government
and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption
(b)(6)
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and foreign relations or
foreign activities of the United States. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).

23 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
Re:
AFRICOM/
437-440

Title

Date

Classification

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions

9/12/12
8:14am

SECRET//
OC/ NF

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
441-445

Re:

9/12/12
8:09am

SECRET//
NOFORN

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
446

Re: pls call me on 9/12/12


Tandberg when
12:23pm
able

SECRET

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
447-449

Re:

SECRET

9/12/12
9:59am

Explanation of Exempt Material


Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C.
130b, protects personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an
overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects
organizational and personnel information for members of the Defense Intelligence
Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency.
Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of
GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, exemption
(b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b, protects personally identifiable information
regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and
10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and personnel information for members
of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National
Geospatial-Intelligence Agency. Lastly, personal privacy information of government
and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption
(b)(6)
(b)(3): 10 USC
Personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas,
130b, 10 USC sensitive, or routinely deployable unit is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates
424; (b)(6)
to 10 U.S.C. 130b; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and personnel
information for members of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National Reconnaissance
Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency. Additionally, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is
protected under exemption (b)(6).

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).

24 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Title
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
Re: standing by in
AFRICOM/
_______
450

Date

Classification

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions

Explanation of Exempt Material

9/12/12
5:55am

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(3): 10 USC
Personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas,
130b, 10 USC sensitive, or routinely deployable unit is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates
424; (b)(6)
to 10 U.S.C. 130b; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and personnel
information for members of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National Reconnaissance
Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency. Additionally, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is
protected under exemption (b)(6).

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
451-452

Re: Status of
Ambassador

9/12/12
6:32am

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
453-454

Re: Status of
Ambassador

9/12/12 UNCLASS- (b)(1)1.4(c);


6:35am
IFIED
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to intelligence activities, sources or methods.
Additionally, exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b, protects personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and
personnel information for members of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National
Reconnaissance Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency. Lastly, personal
privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or
below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

Email
2014-23/
AFRICOM/
455-456

Re:update 0525Z

9/12/12
8:28am

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to intelligence activities, sources or methods.
Additionally, exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b, protects personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and
personnel information for members of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National
Reconnaissance Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency. Lastly, personal
privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or
below is protected under exemption (b)(6).

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to intelligence activities, sources or methods.
Additionally, this document contains personally identifiable information regarding
personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information
which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly,
personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of GS15/0-6 or below, information protected under exemption (b)(6).

25 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
457-458

Title

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
459-460

RFIs

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
461-462

JUKEBOX
LOTUS

2014-23/
Email/slide slides
AFRICOM/ s
463-465

Date

Classification

9/12/12
11:17pm

SECRET//
NOFORN

9/13/12
4:53am

9/13/12
10:18am

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions
(b)(1)1.4(a), (g);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Explanation of Exempt Material


Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and vulnerabilities or
capabilities or systems, installations, projects, plans, or protection services relating to
national security. Additionally, this document contains personally identifiable
information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely
deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to
10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military
officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under exemption
(b)(6)
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, this document contains personally
identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or
routinely deployable unit, information which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it
relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy information of government and
military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below, information protected under
exemption (b)(6).

26 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX


Bates
Document
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
466-474

Title

Date

Classification

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY


Exemptions

9/12/12
7:59am

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a), (c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b, 10 USC
424; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to military plans and operations; and intelligence
activities, sources or methods. Additionally, exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C.
130b, protects personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an
overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects
organizational and personnel information for members of the Defense Intelligence
Agency, National Reconnaissance Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency.
Lastly, personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of
GS-15/0-6 or below is protected under exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).
Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to
protect information pertaining to military plans and operations. Additionally, this
document contains personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to
an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information which is protected
under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below,
information protected under exemption (b)(6).

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
475

standing in
by____

9/12/12
5:49am

SECRET//
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email
AFRICOM/
476-480

USAFRICOM
TASKORD 001,
USARAF
COMMANDERS
ESTIMATE

9/13/12
04:57Z

SECRET//
NONE

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

9/12/12
12:13am

SECRET

(b)(1)1.4(a);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

2014-23/
Email/MAP Update: 5W
AFRICOM/
Benghazi
481-483
Consulate

Explanation of Exempt Material

27 of 28

Judicial Watch v. DOD , 14-cv-1508; DRAFT VAUGHN INDEX

FOR SETTLEMENT PURPOSES ONLY

Bates
Document
Title
Date Classification
Exemptions
Explanation of Exempt Material
Number
Type
2014-23/
Email
Weekly Divisional 9/13/12 UNCLASS- (b)(3): 10 USC
Personally identifiable information regarding personnel assigned to an overseas,
AFRICOM/
Contingency
11:34am
IFIED
130b, 10 USC sensitive, or routinely deployable unit is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates
484
Recall
424; (b)(6)
to 10 U.S.C. 130b; and 10 U.S.C. 424 further protects organizational and personnel
information for members of the Defense Intelligence Agency, National Reconnaissance
Office and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency. Additionally, personal privacy
information of government and military officials in the rank of GS-15/0-6 or below is
protected under exemption (b)(6).
2014-23/
Theater
AFRICOM/ Analysis
485-486
Report

North Africa:
Potential for
Additional Threat
Spikes

9/13/12

SECRET//
ORCON/
NOFORN

(b)(1)1.4(c);
(b)(3): 10 USC
130b; (b)(6)

Currently and properly classified information is denied under exemption (b)(1) to


protect information pertaining to intelligence activities, sources or methods.
Additionally, this document contains personally identifiable information regarding
personnel assigned to an overseas, sensitive, or routinely deployable unit, information
which is protected under exemption (b)(3), as it relates to 10 U.S.C. 130b. Lastly,
personal privacy information of government and military officials in the rank of GS15/0-6 or below, information protected under exemption (b)(6).

28 of 28

You might also like