Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Smartphone Solutions
Smartphone Solutions
White Paper
Issue
2.0
Date
2012-07-17
Change History
Issue1.0
DescriptionThis is the first release.
Date2012-07-17
Prepared BySmartphone ecosystem R&D support team
Approved ByZhao Qiyong (employee ID: 00119431)
Contents
Change History .................................................................................ii
1 Executive Summary ......................................................................1
2 Challenges on Networks by Mobile Internet Applications ........ 2
2.1 Application Categories and Characteristics ....................................................... 2
2.2 Characteristics of Small-Packet Services (SNS, IM, and VoIP) and their Impact on
Networks ................................................................................................ 4
2.3 Characteristics of Video Service and Their Impact on Networks ............................ 5
2.4 Cloud Service Characteristics and Impact on Network ........................................ 6
2.5 Web Applications Characteristics and Impact on Network .................................. 7
2.6 Conclusion .............................................................................................. 7
4 Solutions ...................................................................... 12
4.1 E2E Solutions ........................................................................................... 12
4.1.1 Problem Description.................................................................... . 12
4.1.2 Solutions.....................................................................13
5 Summary ...................................................................... 29
5.1 Challenge Overview ................................................................................ 29
5.2 Solutions and Suggestions ............................................................................30
Figures
Figure 3-1 Traffic volumes for each mobile operating system ................................................... 10
Figure 4-1 Signaling load on wireless networks by different applications over iOS and Android .......... 12
Figure 4-2 Signaling load differences from a network with Huawei equipment ............................. 13
Figure 4-3 Repeated activation request impacts on network activations and KPI ........................... 14
Figure 4-4 Unexpected signaling impact due to firewall faults ................................................. 15
Figure 4-5 PDP update Procedure Triggered by IU/RAB Release Signaling .................................... 15
Figure 4-6 PDP update due to Service Request messages ....................................................... 16
Figure 4-7 Comparison of paging volumes between CS domains and PS domains in operator M network
............................................................................................................................. 16
Figure 4-8 Small packets for smartphones ......................................................................... 19
Figure 4-9 Access signaling increases due to frequent services of smartphones ............................. 19
Figure 4-10 Decreased efficiency in air interface under MBB model ........................................... 20
Figure 4-11 Signaling flow during a data transmission process before the PCH function and the Enhanced
Fast Dormancy function are enabled ................................................................................ 21
Figure 4-12 Signaling flow during the transmission process of a big data packet after the PCH function
and the Enhanced Fast Dormancy function are enabled ......................................................... 21
Figure 4-13 Signaling flow during the transmission process of a small data packet after the PCH function
and the Enhanced Fast Dormancy function are enabled ......................................................... 21
Figure 4-14 UE always-online solution in LTE ..................................................................... 25
Figure 4-15 Signaling-control solution for users with high mobility during handovers in LTE networks .. 26
Figure 4-16 Dynamic DRX solution in LTE networks ............................................................. 27
Figure 4-17 Service-based differentiated control solution in LTE Networks .................................. 28
Tables
Table 2-1 Mainstream mobile Internet categories and characteristics .................................................. 2
Table 2-2 Impacts and solutions ........................................................................................... 7
Table 3-1 3GPP capabilities for typical smartphones ...................................................................... 8
Table 3-2 Screen resolution and video capability for typical smartphones ........................................ 9
Table 3-3 Background behaviors for screen off between iOS and Android devices ............................ 11
Table 3-4 Terminal chips supporting 3GPP Release 8 fast dormancy .................................................. 11
Table 5-1 Impact of mainstream mobile internet services................................................................ 29
Table 5-2 Impact of Smartphone on the network.......................................................................... 30
Table 5-3 Solution overview (based on 3GPP Release 8 protocol and earlier versions) ................. 30
1 Executive Summary
The quickly development of Smartphone energizes the weary mobile Internet.
The same as the innovative traditional Internet, Smartphone is blossoming
freely and have been widely used in our daily life, learning, and working.
Based on function attributes and data packet features, mobile Internet
applications are categorized into instant messaging (IM), voice over IP (VoIP),
streaming, social networking services (SNS), web browsing, cloud, email, file
transfer, gaming, and machine-to-machine (M2M) dialog. The mobile Internet
applications can also be classified in other ways.
The 3GPP protocol was defined to meet the requirements of persistent
connection and peak throughput at initial stage. However, various Internet
applications generate traffic models which are extremely different from
traditional voice services. These traffic models bring severe challenges for the
3GPP protocol.
Major changes in traffic characteristics are the increases in small packets, short
connections, signaling and data traffic, and abnormal traffic. For Universal
Mobile Telecommunications System (UTMS) networks in idle status, all these
changes lead to sharp increases on signaling and other system resource load.
They also bring severe threat on network performance, and affect application
data throughput capability and network profitability in the long run.
For the healthy development of mobile broadband (MBB) in the long term,
developers are all seeking methods to achieve improvements for technique
standards, existing networks, and smartphones. Developers are considering
improvements in the following aspects:
For standard design, the factors, such as small packets, bearer efficiency,
network architecture, and protocol layer optimization are considered.
For existing networks, original traffic models for reference are changed,
software, hardware and parameters are reconfigured, and new features
are enabled.
For Smartphone and applications, a win-win situation is expected
between network resource consumption and user experience. This paper
proposed solutions and suggestions targeting at identified problems
caused by smartphones and applications in deployed UMTS and LTE
networks based on 3GPP Release 8 and earlier versions.
These solutions cannot replace network reconstructions or capacity expansion
to meet the requirements of increasingly growing subscribers, signaling and
data traffic.
1
2 Challenges on Networks by
Mobile Internet Applications
2.1 Application Categories and Characteristics
Mobile Internet is the combination of mobile communications and
Internet. Mobile communications and Internet have gained their own great
achievements. However, their terminal modes, network architectures,
application categories, and user behaviors differ obviously. If the Internet
mainly providing data service is integrated into mobile communications
which provide voice service, great impacts are inflicted on network resource
efficiency, capacity, and signaling.
With the development of mobile Internet in recent years, its service categories
and characteristics are different from traditional Internet. Table 2-1 describes
the categories of current mobile Internet and their main characteristics.
Table 2-1 Mainstream mobile Internet categories and characteristics
Description
Typical
Application
Characteristic
IM
Whatsapp, Wechat,
iMessage
VoIP
Small packets,
continuously
Streaming
YouTube, Youku,
Spotify, Pandora,
PPStream
Big packets,
continuously
SNS
Facebook, Twitter,
Sina Weibo
Web Browsing
Typical web
browsers are Safari
and UC Browser
Cloud
Gmail
File Transfer
Mobile Thunder,
App Store
Gaming
M2M
Machine Type
Communication
Category
Big packets
Big packets, less
frequently
Big packets,
continuously
Big packets, less
frequently
Small packets
2
2.6 Conclusion
Table 2-2 describes mobile Internet impact on networks and relative solutions.
Table 2-2 Impacts and solutions
Impact
Signaling
Capacity and
subscriber experience
Cause
Solutions
3 Challenges on Network by
Mobile Internet Terminals
3.1 Terminal Capabilities and Challenges on
Network
With development of mobile internet, network capabilities and smartphone
capabilities are changing quickly. Nowadays, most smartphones comply with
3GPP Release 6, and only some comply with 3GPP Release 7 or Release 8. The
number of smartphones for LTE is increasingly growing with rapid deployment
of LTE networks. Table 3-1 describes the 3GPP radio access capabilities for
typical smartphones (in time sequence from left to right).
Table 3-1 3GPP capabilities for typical smartphones
Capability
iPhone 4
(iOS4.2)
iPad 2
(iOS4.2)
HTC HD7
(Windows
phone7)
Nexus S
(Android2.3)
iPhone 4S
(iOS5)
Lumia 800
(Windows Galaxy S II HD New iPad
Phone 7.5 LTE(Android4.0) (iOS5.1)
Mango)
Chip
Infineon
X-Gold
618
Qualcomm
MDM6610
QSD8250
1GHz
Hummi
ngbird
Qualcomm
MDM6610
Qualcomm
MSM8255
Qualcomm
MSM8660
Qualcomm
MDM9600
3GPP
R6
R6
R6
R6
R6
R6
R7
R8
HSDPA
HSUPA
Cat.6
5.76 Mbps
Cat.6
5.76
Mbps
No
No
No
LTE
No
No
Cat. 24 42 Mbps
Cat.6
Cat.6
Cat.6 5.76 Mbps 5.76 Mbps 5.76 Mbps
No
Yes
Yes
More and more smartphones support HSPA+ features like 64QAM, multi
input and multi output (MIMO), continuous packet connectivity (CPC), and
enhanced Cell_FACH. The new iPad compliant with 3GPP Release 7 has a
downlink capability of Cat. 14 Mbit/s to 21.1 Mbit/s. The new iPad supports
DC-HSDPA feature in Release 8, with a downlink capability of Cat. 24 Mbit/s
to 42 Mbit/s. What's more, new iPad also supports HSPA+ and LTE Cat.3.
Smartphone screen size and resolution have been improved rapidly. Lumia
800 screen resolution is 480 x 800 pixels, and the screen resolution for the
latest Samsung terminal is 720 x 1280 pixels. New iPad screen resolution
reaches 1536 x 2048 pixels. All mainstream devices support 1080P@30fps video
display.
The computing capability and multi-radio capability for smartphones develop quickly,
and their screen becomes larger and larger. Mobile Internet applications shift from
email to abundant services, such as web browsing, instant messaging, SNS, VoIP, cloud
service, video on demand, and live cast. Table 3-2 describes the screen resolution and
video capability for several new smartphones.
Table 3-2 Screen resolution and video capability for typical smartphones
Lumia 800
(Windows Phone
7.5 Mango)
Screen resolution
Video capability
720P@30fps
1080P@30fps
1080P@30fps
For web browsing and video playing services, higher screen resolution leads
to increases in traffic volume. Power consumption has been a bottleneck for
smartphones all along.
iOS
50.00%
Android
40.00%
Java ME
30.00%
BlackBerry
20.00%
Symbian
10.00%
Other
00.00%
July,
2011
August,
2011
September,
2011
October,
2011
November,
2011
December,
2011
January,
2012
February,
2012
March,
2012
April,
2012
May,
2012
Source: netmarketshare
Based on mature iOS and software on protocol stack, Apple devices provide
services of fast dormancy, being online permanently, and push notifications.
The network resource utilization and user experience of push services
due to permanent online requirement are different for iOS and Android
devices. For iOS, background applications do not generate cellular data
flows. The heartbeats of background services are regarded as those for
Apple push server. These services are in the deactivated status. For Android,
most background services have a single heartbeat. The unified heartbeat
mechanism in iOS reduces the frequent network connection requests and
disconnection signaling during screen off. Table 3-3 describes the comparison
of background behaviors for screen off between iOS and Android devices.
10
Table 3-3 Background behaviors for screen off between iOS and Android devices
Background
Behavior
Android OS
iOS
No heartbeat
No heartbeat
No heartbeat
Sina microblog
No heartbeat
No heartbeat
OS heartbeat
Number of
interactions per
hour
30
Network connection requests for iOS and Android are 2 and 30 respectively
in one hour according to Table 3-3. When the terminal is in the connected
status but without push messages, the number of connections for devices
Android operating system is 15 times of that for devices using iOS operating
system. Frequent connection requests from devices with the Android
operating system bring congestion for network.
3.3 Conclusion
Due to short connection duration and large power consumption, chip
suppliers, including QCT, STE, Renesas, and Intel provide chips with fast
feature for smartphones. Huawei launched Ascend P1 mobile phone in
January, 2012. The U9201L and U9501L customized by operators are
launched in 2012. All these mobile phones support the 3GPP Release 8 fast
dormancy feature.
Table 3-4 Terminal chips supporting 3GPP Release 8 fast dormancy
Chip
Vendors
QCT
Renesas
STE
Moto
Icera
Intel
(Infineon)
MediaTek
Fast
dormancy
Support
Support
Support
Partially
support
Support
Support
Support
11
4 Solutions
To embrace the development of mobile Internet and Smartphone capabilities,
Huawei provides innovative solutions for end to end (E2E), PS core network,
UMTS RAN, and LTE based on network characteristics and protocol standards.
70.00
60.00
65.45
57.14
50.00
80.00
60.00
30.00
40.00
20.00
0.00
120.00
100.00
40.00
10.00
120.00
17.31
15.00
4.00
20.00
0.00
20.00
15.00
4.00
2.00
12.00
12
Figure 4-2 Signaling load differences from a network with Huawei equipment
S e r v i c e r e q ue s t p e r us e r @B H
1000
950
900
850
800
750
700
650
600
550
500
450
400
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
Service
requestper
user@BH
493
504
505
532
541
547
549
607
616
641
742
858
899
User ID
1
2001
4001
6001
8001
10001
12001
14001
16001
18001
20001
Too frequent signaling brings too much load to wireless and core network
equipment.
4.1.2 Solutions
Some optimizations can be adopted for networks and devices to reduce
Service Request messages and network overload.
URA/CELL_PCH
Fast dormancy saves batteries for smartphones if no data is transmitted.
Terminals in URA/CELL_PCH status can stay connected to radio
networks, and power consumption reduces. In this status, even frequent
interactions of heartbeat and service data do not cause too many radio
connections and releases.
Enhanced fast dormancy enables the network to keep smartphones
in URA/CELL_PCH status more effectively. Enhanced fast dormancy
requires mutual supports and cooperation from chip suppliers, terminal
providers, and wireless networks.
Optimized Heartbeat Mechanism
Smartphone application providers and developers must consider
wireless network characteristics to reduce the too frequent heartbeats.
Therefore, the impact on networks is decreased and terminal power
consumption is lower.
Network Control on Signaling from Terminals
For terminals incapable of URA/PCH_CELL, wireless network controls
their behaviors to reduce impacts on signaling. The core network and
radio access network can be united together to control signaling. The
core network identifies the terminals with signaling impact, and the
radio access network controls the terminal signaling.
13
22001
Proposals:
In the short term, the URA/CELL_PCH can be applied to reduce overall
network signaling. Subsequently, the network control on signaling from
terminals can be applied to ensure network security and reliability. In
the middle- to long-term, the optimized heartbeat mechanism can be
applied to control signaling from the service source.
4.2 PS Solutions
4.2.1 Problem Description
PS-PB1: Repeated Activation Request Signaling
Smartphones must be online permanently, and they keep attempting
activations if any failure occurs.
For activation failures due to network faults, smartphones continuously
attempt to be activated, so that services can be activated once the
network equipment recovers. On live networks, network equipment faults
seldom occur. Activation failures are mostly caused by incorrect terminal
configurations, absence of subscription, and lack of call cost. If such failures
occur, services cannot be activated in a short period. Repeated activation
request signaling leads to extensive unnecessary signaling load.
Repeated activation request signaling is generated when activation fails.
Many repeated activation requests are accompanied with activation failures,
and therefore activation success rate decreases.
On networks of operator T, repeated activation request signaling caused by
activation failures accounts for 98.76% of total signaling. Total activation
success rate is lower than 3% as shown in Figure 4-3.
Figure 4-3 Repeated activation request impacts on network activations and KPI
PDP Activation Success Rate (%) (Blackberry.net)
2,500,000
25.00%
2,000,000
20.00%
1,500,000
15.00%
1,000,000
10.00%
500,000
5.00%
PDP Reactivation
Req 98.76%
TPTAL
Success Rate(%)
20
10
-1
220
5
00
10
-1
220
5
01
10
-1
220
5
02
10
-1
220
5
03
10
-1
220
5
04
10
-1
220
5
05
10
-1
220
5
06
10
-1
220
5
07
10
-1
220
5
08
10
-1
220
5
09
10
-1
220
5
10
10
-1
220
5
11
10
-1
220
5
12
10
-1
220
5
13
10
-1
220
5
14
10
-1
220
5
15
10
-1
220
5
16
10
-1
220
5
17
10
-1
220
5
18
10
-1
220
5
19
10
-1
220
5
20
10
-1
220
5
21
10
-1
220
5
22
10
-1
25
23
0.00%
14
Firewall
breakdown
15
Frequent data services and fast dormancy for smartphones cause many IU
releases and service requests. On a common network, the signaling impacts
the RNC and SGSN. In direct tunnel networking mode, the signaling has more
impact on the SGSN, and the impact even spreads to the GGSN.
16
4.2.2 Solutions
For the problems described in section 4.2.1 "Problem Description", PS core
network provides solutions to reduce signaling impacts on networks from the
following aspects.
Configure the network to control terminal behaviors to prevent repeated
activation requests and unexpected signaling.
Do not apply the direct tunnel networking mode for terminals using
huge signaling volume, so as to reduce the impact on networks. Use
intelligent paging in LTE networks.
Proposals:
Appropriately evaluate and plan the GGSN based on the direct tunnel
solution and traffic models.
Operators determine whether to apply the direct tunnel solution based
on network traffic volume and signaling.
18
Smartphone Legacy UE
Signalling activity
Data activity
Time
Figure 4-9 Access signaling increases due to frequent services of smartphones
35000000
30000000
25000000
20000000
15000000
10000000
5000000
0
2010-6-22 2010-7-21 2010-8-3 2011-4-11 2011-4-12 2011-4-18 2011-4-19
VS.HSDPA.UE.Mean.Cell
4.3.2 Solutions
In the UMTS RAN, the following measures are taken to solve the typical
network problems mentioned in section 4.3.1:
Reduce activation request signaling, enable the control of smartphones
state transition on the network side, and enhance common channels
to avoid impact on the network caused by repeated activation request
signaling.
Implement hierarchical paging, narrow the paging area, and reduce the
paging signaling in air interfaces.
Improve the air interface utilization efficiency by control channel
overhead reduction and smart state transition.
20
Figure 4-11 Signaling flow during a data transmission process before the PCH function
and the Enhanced Fast Dormancy function are enabled
Old PS procedure
Figure 4-12 Signaling flow during the transmission process of a big data packet after
the PCH function and the Enhanced Fast Dormancy function are enabled
Figure 4-13 Signaling flow during the transmission process of a small data packet after
the PCH function and the Enhanced Fast Dormancy function are enabled
Proposals:
In the short term, the PCH function and the Enhanced Fast Dormancy function
is used to reduce the impact of signaling storm.
In the long term, enhanced common channel can be used to reduce the number
of network access-related signaling and reduce the impact of signaling storm.
21
23
4.4.2 Solutions
LTE-SLT1: Signaling-Control in LTE Networks
According to the analysis of the live network, LTE signaling impact mainly
occurs in the following two situations:
A large number of smartphones access the network simultaneously,
resulting in an overloaded network.
A large number of smartphones are performing services that require
frequent exchanges, such as heart beats, message push, and
state information notice. This leads to frequent state transition of
smartphones between the idle state and connected state.
The following solutions are provided to deal with the previous problems:
24
eNB
t
DRX
hugedata
lowtraffic
only hearbeat
t
Dynamic
DRX
To solve this problem, transit the phone to the idle state as soon as possible
to avoid the signaling impact caused by high mobility, as shown in Figure 4-15.
Figure 4-15 Signaling-control solution for users with high mobility during
handovers in LTE networks
UE1
keeps high mobility
UE2
keeps low mobility
Proposals:
At the early stage of the LTE network deployment, when there is a small
number of users and a small amount of signaling, admission control in
LTE networks is recommended to improve the stability of eNodeBs.
When the number of users and the signaling impact are increasing,
always-online solution and signaling-control solution during handovers
for high mobility users are recommended to prevent the signaling
impact caused by frequent access procedures and
Proposals:
At the early stage of the LTE network deployment, there is a small
number of users and a small amount of signaling. The DRX solution
is recommended to help UEs save power and reduce the amount of
signaling generated due to frequent transition to the idle state.
UE1
USB dongle
Do not transit the UE
to the DRX state
UE2
uses services
that have high
requirements on
real time
UE2
uses services
without real-time
requirements
27
eRAN
Differentiated
control
on data based
on users and
services
UE1
eNodeB
Subscriber awareness
Service awareness
Congestion awareness
User information
and service
information
MME
SGW
PGW
Scheduler
UE2
Proposals:
This solution is recommended when operators require differentiated
control on services on the same bearer, such as P2P throttling and HTTP
guarantee.
28
5 Summary
5.1 Challenge Overview
Mobile Internet services, terminal capabilities, and network capabilities
promote and affect each other, together facilitating the development of MBB.
Table 5-1 describes the impact of mainstream mobile internet services on
terminal capabilities and channel capabilities.
Table 5-1 Impact of mainstream mobile internet services
Category
29
Description
Characteristics
Impact
IM
Instant messaging
VoIP
Internet telephone
service, including
voice and video
calls
Streaming
Streaming media
such as HTTP
audios and videos,
P2P videos
SNS
Social networking
websites
Web
Browsing
Web page
browsing, including
WAP
Cloud
Applications,
including cloud
computing and
online cloud
applications
Big packets
Emails, including
Web mail, POP3,
and SMTP
File
Transfer
File transfer,
including P2P, file
Big packets are
storage, application
sent continuously
download and
update
Gaming
Mobile gaming,
such as social
gaming and bridges
M2M
Machine type,
communication
Small packets
Description
Impact
Radio Protocol
Capability
Fast Dormancy
Feature
Screen
Resolution/Video
Play Capability
Background
Heart Beat
Problem Description
E2E-PB1: signaling
increase caused by
frequent small packets
Solution
E2E-SLT11: Qualcomm NSRM
E2E-SLT12: push service provided by
operators or third parties, such as
terminal OS vendors, service providers
30
PS
PS-PB1: repeated
activation request
signaling
PS-PB2: Smartphone
signaling impacts on
GGSN with direct tunnels
UTRAN-PB1: increasing
access signaling
UMTS
RAN
UTRAN-PB2: increasing
paging signaling
LTE
31
Acronyms and
Abbreviations
Term
English Description
3G
3GPP
A
AAA
APP
Application
AS
Application Server
C
CBC
CPC
CPE
CQI
D
DASH
DC-HSDPA
DHCP
DNS
DPI
DRA
DRX
Discontinuous Reception
DSAC
DTX
Discontinuous Transmission
32
E
EAB
EAP
E-DPCCH
eNB
Evolved NodeB
eMBMS
ePDG
ETSI
E-UTRAN
F
FD
Fast dormancy
FLUTE
G
GGSN
GU
GTP
H
HeNB
HLR
HLS
HS-DPCCH
HSPA+
HSS
HS-DPCCH
HTCP
HTML
HTTP
33
IaaS
Infrastructure as a Service
IETF
IFOM
IM
Instant Messaging
IMEI
IP
Internet Protocol
I-CSCF
Interrogating CSCF
I-SBC
ITU
L
LA
Location Area
LSGW
LTE SMS GW
LTE
M
M2M
Machine to Machine
MAPCON
MBMS
MME
MCC
MNC
M-TMSI
N
NAI
NAS
Non-access Stratum
NMS
NNI-SBC
O
OA&M
OCS
OS
Operation System
OTT
Over-the-Top
P
P2P
Peer to Peer
PaaS
Platform as a Service
34
PCC
P-CSCF
Proxy CSCF
PLMN
PCRF
PDN
PDN GW/PGW
PLMN
PPI
POP3
PS
Packet Switched
PSI
Q
QCI
QoS
Quality of Service
R
RA
Routing Area
RAN
RAT
RNC
RRC
RTP
35
SaaS
Software as a Service
SCRI
S-CSCF
Serving CSCF
SLP
SNMP
SMTP
SAE
SBC
SCG
SGW
Serving Gateway
SMS
SNS
S-TMSI
SIP
T
TA
Tracking Area
TA-List
Tracking Area-List
TAI-List
TAU-List
TCP
TWAP
TWAG
U
UDP
UE
UMTS
URA
V
VoIP
Voice over IP
W
WAP
36
Reference
a.5.0
2011-09-27
2011-09-27
(GPRS);Service description;
999 3GPP TS 36.413
a.3.0
a.5.0
2011-09-27
enhancements for Evolved Universal Terrestrial Radio Access Network (E-UTRAN) access
1111 3GPP TS 24.008
9.4.0
2010-09-28
10.3.0
2011-09-27
Contributors
Contributors
Department
Frank zhao
jiaweijie
wangbin
xiguobao
mijunwen
shuaiyanglai
38
Other trademarks, product, service and company names mentioned are the property of their respective owners.
General Disclaimer
The information in this document may contain predictive statements including,
without limitation, statements regarding the future financial and operating results,
future product portfolio, new technology, etc. There are a number of factors
that could cause actual results and developments to differ materially from those
expressed or implied in the predictive statements. Therefore, such information
is provided for reference purpose only and constitutes neither an offer nor an
acceptance. Huawei may change the information at any time without notice.
www.huawei.com