Professional Documents
Culture Documents
U.S. History
to recognize the needs for better medical care. The Destiny of the Republic
has a time span from 1880-1902.
Candace Millard has several primary sources including the private
journals of Garfield and Guiteau. Her secondary sources included the
National Museum of Health and Medicine and Library of Congress
manuscripts.
During the period of James Garfields life the United States made a lot
of advances in the medical field and inventions that helped shape the way
we live today. Destiny of the Republic shows the struggles and success of
Garfield, born into poverty but through hard work and dedication achieving
success. It also leads readers into the mind and motivation of Charles
Guiteau for targeting President Garfield in an attempt at assassination.
Millard also highlights the medical shortcomings which led to both mens
demise. Though different, Guiteau and Garfields destiny became
intertwined.
great interest in, the telephone invented by Alexander Graham Bell, and
Joseph Listers discovery of antisepsis. Bells invention immediately drew in
everyones attention, while Lister struggled to convince anyone that his
theory would help keep out infection and save the lives of many people.
Soon after witnessing Listers arguments, Garfield lost yet another child to
whooping cough.
When Garfield was not even two, his father, Abram Garfield, had died
after saving their familys farm from a wild fire. It was not possible to get
Abram Garfield the medical attention he needed, because of their land being
so secluded. Abram Garfield lost his life within a couple days to exhaustion
and fever. Garfield was left with his mother and three other siblings. His
mother, Eliza Garfield, and oldest brother, Thomas Garfield, worked on the
land. Their hard work was necessary to keep from having to send the
younger children away to other families. Eliza Garfield wanted nothing more
than to give her second son, James Garfield, an education. She donated
some of her land for a school house to ensure that Garfield recieved an
education.
He later secured a job driving a canal. One night on the job, Garfield
had slipped in the canal and with everyone asleep, had no one to help save
him. As he searched for something that could save him, he came across a
rope that had knocked him in the canal. He began using the rope to pull
himself back on deck. Garfield found that the rope had miraculously gotten
stuck in a crack giving enough hold for Garfield to anchor himself on the
3
ship. Garfield had written in his journal that night, I sat down in the cold of
the night and in my wet clothes and contemplated the matter I did not
believe that God had paid any attention to me on my own account but I
thought He had saved me for my mother and for something greater and
better that canaling (21). Garfield had caught malaria from the canal before
returning home. His family began to fear yet another loss in the family.
Shortly after returning home his, fever broke but then quickly returned.
When Garfield finally recovered his mother and brother had saved seventeen
dollars for him to go back to school. Garfield accepted their offer. He was
determined to be a man with a good education. When he did not have
enough money for school he traded labor for an education. Garfield was
such an extraordinary student that he went from working as a janitor to
being a professors assistant in his first year of school. Garfield met Lucretia
Crete when they attended school together in their late teen years. It was not
until later that she began to see Garfield in a new light. She had always
struggled to confess her feelings for him. When they finally did marry she
could tell Garfield was not in love with her. He had fallen in love with another
woman, Lucia Gilbert Calhoun. He confessed to the affair, but Lucretia
Garfield forgave him and wanted to look past it as long as he ended the
relationship. When Garfield saw her deal with the great pain of the
heartbreak he had cause, his own heart changed and he began to fall in love
with his wife. He was accepted into a college in Massachusetts called
Williams College in Williamstown. After he graduated with honors, he went
4
Garfield received twenty more votes than needed to become the nominee.
He was in complete shock, and he did not know how to handle the fact that
he, James A. Garfield, was running to be the President of the United States.
Garfield was a man who enjoyed his free time to work on experiments
and to study. Since the nomination it was hard to have this time. He was
finally given the time he wanted during the campaign. Hayes advised
Garfield not to give speeches for himself during this time. Therefore, Garfield
remained quiet, and his support began to grow. The freed slaves were the
biggest supporters of Garfield. A singing group from an all-black university in
Nashville sung to Garfield in front of his farmhouse. He addressed them
saying, And I tell you now, in the closing day of the campaign, that I would
rather be with you and defeated than against you and victorious (63). The
election of 1880 was a close race. As everyone laid awake in the early
morning of November 3rd to find out whom had won the election, Garfield
went to bed. When he woke the next morning he was greeted with the news
that he was the twentieth president of the United States. Though this was a
great accomplishment, he could not help but feel a loss of something he
could not even explain to himself.
Charles Guiteau was a man who tried hard for success, but he had
failure in almost all his efforts. He was thought to be insane and was almost
forced by his family to be put into a mental institute. He was even left by his
wife. He had found hope in James A. Garfield. Both men had a rough start to
their life, but unlike Guiteau, Garfield had much success. Guiteau was on
6
board of the Narragansett during a ship wreck. He was one of the three
survivors from the Narragansett. Guiteau was certain that God had saved
him because he was meant to do something extraordinary.
Charles Guiteau was left motherless at the age of seven. He was
raised only by his father. He had always thought that God had made him to
have a great impact. When he was eighteen he left the University of
Michigan to join a commune. His mentor was John Humphrey Noyes. Noyes
had many odd views of life, he believed he was perfect and was sent by God
to shed the sins of others. He decided to leave the commune and he went in
search of a new profession. He decided to be involved in the law. This did
not go well for Guiteau, so he decided to go back to religion. Guiteau began
to threaten Noyes, asking for large sums of money. Noyes did not take him
seriously he simply thought Guiteau to be insane. Guiteaus whole family
worked to get him institutionalized, but he managed to avoid by leaving
them all. He became obsessed with politics. He had married a young
woman named Annie Bunn. She struggled living his lifestyle but would have
stayed with him had he not treated her so cruel.
time he would use to devote himself to the things he loved. The fame of the
telephone spread very fast. Along with the business from this invention
came competitors. He had offered to sell the telephone to the Western
Union, but they declined the offer. They later realized that they had made a
significant mistake. Bell had to face many lawsuits that accused him of
stealing their idea of the telephone. Everyone began seeing Bell as an
inventor, but he would always continue to see himself as a teacher. It was in
the hope to help those who were deaf that the telephone was invented. Bell
became so frustrated with the time the telephone consumed that he left his
company. He used all his time to work on new ideas. He did not care about
fame or fortune, just that he would be able to help people.
Bell, Guiteau, and Garfields lives will intersect in a moment in which
would change history and medical care in the country. On the morning of
Garfields inauguration, he arrived with President Hayes in the back of an
open carriage. Garfield delivered the address with a serious tone. He
addressed everything he wanted to accomplish as president and what he felt
was important. Garfield discussed the nations past involving the slaves. It
had become evident to Conkling that he would struggle to control Garfield.
The only deal Garfield had made with him was that he would attempt to put
stalwarts in his cabinet. Conkling made it so Garfield could not have the
people he wanted in his cabinet. Garfield had offered the Secretary of State
Position to James G. Blaine. This was a man who hated the stalwarts and
Roscoe Conkling. The only condition for Blaine to accept this position was
8
that he could never run for the president. Blaine accepted the condition.
One of Garfields major problems was his Vice President Chester Arthur. He
was one of Conklings creations. In the beginning Conkling was furious about
his nomination. He later realized that because of his complete control over
Arthur he would have more power over the president.
Garfield liked living in the White house because of the time he could
spend with his five children and his wife. There was a lot to be done to fix up
the White House but Mrs. Garfield was eager to get the work done. Though
he liked his new home, he could never escape all the people trying to
impress him to gain a position in his administration. What hurt him the most
was that among the throng of people he would find his friends. Garfield
found the contest flow of people annoying but he did not consider them
dangerous. Though there were a lot of assassination attempts throughout
the world, Garfield felt it was unnecessary to have protection against it.
Garfield had met his private secretary, Joseph Stanley Brown, through
John Wesley Powell. Garfield was in need of a temporary secretary and
Powell offered Garfield his own secretary. Garfield came to know and adore
Brown. Brown had become a part of Garfields family. Brown had given
Garfield space after his nomination, but Garfield needed him. Brown did not
want to become a burden to his friend
Guiteau moved to Washington, D.C. in the hopes of gaining a cabinet
position from Garfield once he had won the presidency. Guiteau sent
Garfield a congratulatory letter as if they were close friends. Guiteau was
9
also under the impression that he was to marry a rich heiress. She thought
he was a stalker. Guiteau also convinced himself that he was close to
Chester A. Arthur.
president.
On May 5th, Lucretia Garfield, Garfields wife woke with a fever. He
brought in many doctors but her fever continued to build. He refused to do
any business while his wife was sick. The White House was locked up to
protect Lucretia Garfield, while Guiteau tried to gain better association with
the president. He waited for his meeting with Garfield. He lived off of
assistance from friends. He sought out John Logan, the Republican Senator
in Illinois and asked him to sign a recommendation for him to obtain the
consul- general to France. He refused, but promised to mention him to
Blaine, but not in the way Guiteau had intended. Logan planned to mention
the mental instability of Guiteau. Guiteau began to harass Blaine. It became
unbearable for Blaine so to end it he told Guiteau that he did not want to
speak to him any more about the Paris consulship.
Garfield began to try to find a common ground with the Stalwarts. He
appointed five of Conklings men to New York posts. This was the start of a
political war between Conkling and Garfield. Conkling was much more
experienced in political battles than Garfield. After Lucretia Garfields fever
began to drop, Conkling had resigned from the New York Senate. Conklings
plan was to be elected in Albany, but he only gained one-third of the vote.
Everything had started to go in favor of Garfield. His wife was no longer ill,
10
he did not have to devote his whole day to office seekers, and Conkling had
lost almost all his power.
Guiteau had the idea in his head that If the President was out of the
way everything would go better (113). He had felt that this strange idea
had come from God. He tried to look past it, but the idea just kept coming to
him. He felt that he had warned Garfield enough that Garfield had the
opportunity to save his life. Once Guiteau was no longer able to enter the
White House, he prayed to God, asking if he had misunderstood the
message. He received no sign that this was a misunderstanding.
On June
11
12
Garfield arrived at the station with ten minutes until his train was set to
leave. Blaine wanted to escort him to the train. Garfield walked in the
station with an easy, natural confidence (131). Guiteau stood behind
Garfield as he came in the building, and without any hesitation he fired at
Garfield. Guiteau shot Garfield in the arm with confidence. He then began
firing out of control at Garfield. Garfield was shot in the back, buckling to the
floor. The station was filled with silence, and then everything turned to
chaos. The President of the United States had been shot.
Everyone went after Guiteau. He tried to fight them off but realized he
was far to out numbered. He asked if he could be taken to jail and was under
the impression that he was taken there for his own safety. He strongly
believed Sherman would be at the prison ready to break him out, also that he
would now receive the consulship of Paris.
The bullet did not kill Garfield. It had missed his spinal cord and all of
his vital organs. One of the doctors, Townshend stuck his finger into the
wound of Garfields back causing a slight hemorrhage and giving him an
infection that was more dangerous than the bullet itself. Lincoln called on
Doctor Bliss for assistance because he had attempted to save his father and
was familiar to Garfield. Bliss used a probe to search for the bullet, and as
he tried to remove it, it was caught on his rib. Once it was out he started
using his finger, and Purvis, one of the first black doctors, asked him to stop
his examination. Bliss refused and continued.
13
was certain he could find the bullet. He made a metal detector from his
knowledge of the telephones currents. With this the bullet would upset the
balance of the coils and Bell would be able to pinpoint the location of the
bullet. This invention could be Garfields only hope of avoiding death at his
doctors hands (162).
Guiteau sent a letter to Arthur about his cabinet positions and he was
planning Arthurs first term. Arthur was not excited about possibly becoming
the president, but he turned to Conkling unsure of what he should do.
Rumors began to spread that the assassination was a plan formed by
Conkling. He and Arthur were no longer safe from the nations fury. The
hotel where Conkling stayed received an anonymous note saying that
Conkling and his company were to be hung.
Bell sent a letter to Bliss asking to assist him with finding the bullet,
assuring Bliss he would be able to help. The only reason Bliss agreed was
because he was nervous because the presidents condition had not
improved, Garfields fever continued to raise. Bell went to complete his
invention and returned later. Though Garfield grew weaker, he still tried to
reassure everyone as much as he could. He also made sure everyone knew
that he did not believe Conkling or Arthur had any role in the shooting.
Guiteau felt no guilt for shooting the president. He continued to see
himself as a national hero. He thought he would make bail in the fall. After
he was released he thought he would make a lot of money from a speaking
15
doctors claiming they had the cure for the president. One doctor claimed
that the bullet rested on Garfields left side rather that his right. Bliss did not
even consider this theory.
Bell was finally prepared to attempt to find the bullet in the president.
As he prepared for the experiment, he realized something had gone wrong
with his invention. He decided to go on with the trial because it could still
find a bullet. The experiment was a failure. After, he found his mistake
which would have found the bullet.
Three days before Bell arrived to perform his experiment at the White
House, Conkling decided he was done with politics and would no longer
attempt to gain a position in the senate. The only thing he was left with now
was the control over Arthur. Everyone thought that he would seek out
Conkling for advice about the presidency. Arthur had actually begun to pull
away from Conkling. Arthur began to seek political advice from a woman
named Julia Sand. She wanted to inspire him and help him be a better man.
He thought as Garfields condition improved he was becoming a better man.
Garfield did not make any progress. Bliss had given up on assistance
from other doctors. He was the only one giving Garfield medical attention.
Bliss asked Bell to return to give his experiment another try. Bell had not
forgotten the humiliation of the previous test, but he had managed to extend
the range of the instrument to more than five inches. When bell returned to
the White House to perform the experiment, Bliss told them they were only
allowed to search the right side of Garfields body. They heard a faint sound
17
in the same area where Bliss suspected the bullet would be. Bell was uneasy
about this discovery. He had later found out that the president had been on
a spring mattress, this had been what was interfering with the test. Bliss
refused to agree that there had been a problem with the experiment.
There were many signs that the president had a blood infection. Bliss
ignored the fever, chills, vomiting, and the pus filled sores on his back. Bliss
had cut himself with a knife and pus had entered the wound. His hand had
been infected and he could barely use it. Garfield lost weight at an
extremely fast rate. He could not keep anything down, and he had lost
interest in eating. All Garfield truly wanted now was to get away. He wanted
to go home to Ohio or to visit the sea. The only people who refused to give
up hope on Garfield were Lucretia Garfield and Brown. Garfield insisted that
he be taken to the sea. Bliss did not think he should, but he allowed it.
Garfields health still did not improve. He had all his doctors sent home. On
September 19th, James A. Garfield woke gasping and struggling to breath.
Lucretia Garfield asked Bliss what was happening. Bliss did not hesitate to
tell her that her husband was dying. The room was completely quiet except
for Garfields harsh breathing. Garfield took his last breath at 10:35 pm.
Lucretia Garfield stayed with her husband watching his lifeless body.
When Bell heard of the presidents death, he decided to seek out war
veterans who wanted to locate a bullet in their body. He did not want all the
time he used on his invention to go to waste.
18
20
21