cid RERUBLIC OF THE PHEIPEINES REGIONAL TRIAL COURT NATIONAL CAPITAL JUDICIAL REGION BRANCH 09, MANILA PROPGE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Peanut, series GRIN. CASE NO. 0$-238956 FOR: Ovalified! Trafficking in Porsonc Soutions 4 ta,a) and B (0.6.8) oF RA, 9306 intehation 12 See. 3 meroot 8 Sactions $8 6.0 RA 9231 amending Sections 12.8 16 ARA 7810 gd gets PO? PENNS RECHY AZUEI FELIOING MAMANSALA ¥ PALI MIA and JOM DOE phtas “wioMiny ANBEL,* *Avewieet Mee 7 DECISION Before this Gout. Aceusad HO? DERMIS RECLY AZWELA « FELICIANO MANANEALA + PAHGILINAN, and SOHM DOE aline MOMIEY ADKHEL” ato croepeet ai Gralifed ‘Teartieking in. Persons tia on My 39, 20085, in.tme Cay of fang avd vathin the aukaictan of the Hosrorable Court, the Spowecnanied Becusoa, “nctusing POZ Denny Rect ES 2 mombet uf a feb enforcement agency, Se Paling. ane comederanng ws a syncing, wally And untawhuly, tid thon and thro, secteat and hiro f,~ Wie vale. Quast selaton ticers wis are, young Sect nbering around steven 179), including See: Fa em 03 at eevenbscns (17 yea A 208, iow the purpeso of and to-engege in frostlution and serual expieiotien, anspor and ‘ranstor thom hom other barsetuts, harbor, saste 2nd gmeloy View at ng 8 RE TV Club om Son. Andes, sanila, aadl peovido and sbi the soxcal series at four él) of dhe women tor Twenty Thousand (Phyp20 000.00) Peseta Gary Shaw ene sen bait Whe pesed as customers, te the damage and ptongies of sala woman : ? SOMIRARY Te Aw.tit Ot Upon their arraignment, dated October 10, 2005, accused PO2 DENNIS RECIY AZUELA ahd FELICIANO MANANSALA ¥ PANGILINAN duly assisted by counselde-officlo, Atty: Ma: Victoria, for purposes of arraignment only, pleaded "NOT charged, . Cardona, Pr GUILTY" to the crime ‘On Pre-Trial dated December's, 2005, both parties agroed on stipulation as to'the-Identity of bath accused PO2 Dens ec! Y Azuela and Feliciano Manansala Y Pangilinan, 06. well as. the jurisdiction of this Court. ‘That accused PO2 Dennis Recl is a member of the Philppina National Police was lewise stipulated, Prectrial was then torminated. Prosectttion presented six (6) witnesses: 1 TRAD Y WM 18 yearsicld, 4" year high school student of Maritlac Hills’ and: presently: racing et te Department of Social Welfare Development, Marillac < ng, Muntinlupa City. “She testified that she’ is now 18 years old, having been bom’ on July 19, 1987 at Jose Fabella Hospital; That she knows accused Feliciano Homanasia, as he Is their Floor Manger at 8RC: KTV; PpThet she also gets Flty (Php50,00) Pesos as her commission per bottle of lady's drink; That the offer to be tablex. comes from her Floor Monager, 1 and aecused fo. esnoadte: Thot accused Donnis Rest ‘has no participation with her being tabl by customer to have sox, om! sex of just plain chatting with eustomars, ‘That sex inside tha VIP rooms is just a normal activly at 8RC KTV Sar and naturally the owner fs . ware of such activities; That she is now uniter the ‘sustody of the Dapartmont of Social Welfare Development (OSWD) alter they were rescued on May 31. 2008; That wher’ a certain Gary.Shaw was .On ¢ross-axamination, sho testified that: “Sha met accused Feliciano Manansala at ~ Evangelista Street, “Manita; That sald accusedPaga 4 Decision a ‘crim, case no, 06238955, Pp. vs. poz dennis reci, diferent countries, to i conduct fevastigatian reganing informations recolved | fom around the world about gross farms. of human j ‘fights ebuses; That previously, ho was 9 police officer. { assigned 2 a detective for alaven.(i) years; . That ‘on May of 2005, he was sont to the Philippines to ‘Manila: | That he raccived information ‘of alleged {ninors: baing amployed and véld Into prostitition at SRE KTV Garin Manila; That the infomation a tninors being employed at BRC KTV Bar was supplied Py goat tiny on vata of MM i, hose last name he cai recall; That ORC KTV Bar is jocated in San Andres, Manila; Then on May 26, 22008; fe wert fo the safe KTV Bar fegether ‘ith the @) colleagues from ‘kt “to conduct suivaillartee -operation fo: conflem the, voracity. of ‘ye. iformiation. they teesived; That he secratly word an undercover ‘sameta under his shit which coukd not be Seen by embody! | That he want t the SRC Bar’ in San Andres, Mahia. pretending to.bo 9 customer; Thot they Were gteeted by accused Jun Mariansala whe provided tham with @ table: and drinks; . That sald accused told thom thot there will be youtig girls who ‘would bo -dancing naked tater fn the evening: That | Secused Jun Manansala gave them'a talir of the VIP ‘fooms and informed them that they could! engogs In,{nto an agreement and he gave. the’ amount Of One Thousand Five Hundred (Phpt $00.00) "Pesos Sccused Dennis Reci; Thatshon inside the VIP roan [GRU that the gts would not anymiora be bar fied by sifior customors: That he gave $40.00 voles Geposit to accuscd Dennis eck That afer femminating thes stivetiance, they rolumad to. mei relat and securod the ovidence thoy gathored: That ator preparing thoir Intarvention Roport, he went to the aifca of the CNG, PHF and provided hem wath s Men the evidence: That it was 9 certain Majer Mecalangay. Chiot ef Wonton sind Chidron's Deol sho ne submnined the evidsnea;. That he ‘ond his Fiimbur’of tie minors were unavailable thot nights ‘thst hs was asked by thé GIOG if he ‘and ie Sobeagues can oiitinue to act as customore and - «gainer evidence by way of under cover camara: That fa kept constant contact with accused Dennts Rosi Tne, Mis erivate complainant thvough tre. eollphone; namely, eecused Dennis Recl. Jun Mononsata and fret That on Nay 31, 2005 at around 10:20 o'clonk vaning, he togsiher with we calleggues. want {a the 880 KTV-Bar, That upon entering, they were ‘Seated by accused Dennis Reel introduced him to {wo () othor gis, ona of which i a thine and informed din that thoy are-availabla te be purchased ‘or prosthution; That accused: Donnis Ret! toid him that they can bar fina four (4) gitls tor the amount of Twanty Five Thousand (Php20,000.00) Patios or Fhe ‘Thousand 4Php5,000.00) Pesos tor ach girl: =/Page 13 .. oe Dustelba chm, cosy fe: OS-228056 Pp. ea godt danints meen. at ah chp ewe er Eben between himsall ond accused Dotals. Raci; That ‘whan the four (4) undercover CIDG Oftiears avtiveel ‘und wore In a position to ste ‘nceused Danis Rec, ft gras the time thal he gave said accused the amount of Twenty’ Teousund ¢7hp20,000.00) Pesos; That the aunount af Tworty Thousond (Php20,000.00)' Pesos. same Rom WM, bul & was ptiotecopidd by thy CIOS and had tingerpnint powasr, That he was able to identity the ‘photocopied ckaamiiated money. bile canststing ot Five buncred Peso Bile; That whon he gave tha monoy te accused Denis Reel, ityvas bt that Pomt whds one cf the CIOS etficers steed up ‘and apprehended sae acrusad after introducing: himsntf 24 CIOS police officer; That othe CIDG officers came and: also “opprehanded accused jun Mananscia, Donnie Reci.end the guts working ia the"bat: That sheused Ange! wos abte to estape unig the cet door ef the buiking, That both agcused as wal as tho fainle victims were taken to the CIOS homdquartors; That he expeuiod an nifeva consistng of six «By Pages and identiivd the same when shown: ‘Thal: juhen bp wari to the RC dor, ha secretly had a smelt underadver camwa, 9 stig cumora, inside ‘hig Usawcrs, That sald sting come had 2 remote ‘ehtnoction by his bait” That the eamord. e ike camer tootago-buin on 9 OVD dise, what ba sent to the propery custodian af the international Justice ‘Réieaion to the Phifippies. ‘That be also obtained photographs trom the vadop-tootige. That the video festage contained on ‘Sach disc, “aecurataty re¢orded tha: events that took ploee at the BPC Bar, ° That disc No. 1 contains footage takan at @RG Fior on Mby 26. 2005; That disc No. 2 conlaing wideo fnptage recorded on May 26, ond 24, 2605 at @RC Bar, That diss Mo. 3 the Women and. Chidren Complaint Division with the. participation of WM, DOLE-NCR and the OSWD; That Yel operation was code. named "SAGIP OSLAN ANGEL": That they Prepared forty (40) places of Fiva Hundred Paso Sils which totalled Tworly Thousand 1000.00). Fasos; That they. made writen ‘equest for ultra violet powder dusting to be used on iho marked money: That before the operation was ‘Bonducted, she wrote down the serial numbats.of the fory (40) pluces of the Fivé Huntired Peso Bilis and before handing it to Sagy Thatthe said marked monoy was used by Gam Siligp during the operation, which we later on confiscated when it was nivoady in ‘the possession of pecusad Donnis Reel: That she Was one of the artesting.afficers who wore present ‘Siiparinfendcnt Camp Mamma thot a total of” thity (20) persons participated in the ‘operation, but ‘not ali of them.were able-to enter 8RG Glub; That it was Mt, Sal) Skamm and Lam Somlew who first enterod ORC Bar and aflat so many sainutes, POS Aa Omp and POS Seimm cntored the chub; That she was lngtructod to stay naar the vieiity of BRC Club and. wait for the pro-attenged signal; That she was positioned infront of tha. main door of SRC Club: That he onteyod BRC Bar upess racelving.the pre-orranged ‘over tha cellphone; “That: she enisfed BRC Club fogethor. with two (2) other’ femala officers. and a sopresontativa of DOLE snd DSWD; , That: upon ‘emtering the club, she tmediately. proceeded tothe area where accused Dennis Rech was being artostett i—————— whero she witneased the confiscation of the marked ionwy and tho gun; ‘That she ingtructed the DSWD's representative and her three (3).athet policawomion to Secure, the women in one place; ‘That accused’ Foliiane Manensala waa arrested by PO3 Soliven; That tiie dusted money was recovered ‘by FOS Oa from aneveed Dennis Rect and turned It-over to, her, right thers and there; ‘That upon arival at thelr office, sho Tequested for examination’of the money with the - presence of yellow ponder together whh accused's Dennis Reels hands; That the findings gave positive : results thot accused, Dennis Reci was positive for the Presence of inight orongo ula violet fluorescent ower on hit left pains, nose. and tnerar portion of his “neck; That the labora'ory report was prepared Police Senior inspecior and Forensic. Chemist, C. Gam; That cho was able to personally idontly beth accused: pets i end Eee Moen wt based on fhe. business permit , ERC TY Bar vies owmad by accused Donnis Rect: see “That thoy secured 2 certification from. the City G Treasuror's Office of Vania: That accused Dennis Recl was the ena ihe pald the business permit and ‘other taxes of the business under the name BRC KTV Bar; That os of the momant, based on a certification We incniuue fem the CAica of the Gily Mayor of ‘Manis, the present ovmer of BRC Bar is Toyo: That sold ownership vas transferred” on Juno 22" 2005; That eoctised Donnis Reef upon his attest, told her that he was a police officer assigned at the Manila District Office; “That the gun recovered from accused Reci, which is a'Smim Pistol Beratis & a government Wioued ‘firearm fo said accused; ‘That private complcinan|, Sma Teggaaig told then that she ‘was only ceventaen (17). yanrs old: That upon bringing the woman to their affico right‘ after thelr rescue, they subjected thom to physical and dental examination; ‘That two (2) out of dleven (11) women yworo minors; oe based aaa or Clam and Te wnors; That they brought both wecusad to. theic office und. subjected “for physical examination and prepered thelr booking sheet and information sheet; That sho paid the bil of their Poser custorners during tha aig of the ree os. 7 ~ evidenced by! on regal That — thare °/ 4 O ; gel Nis rstte upon rece BRC Bar at about 120g thelr ois at around [at ot only her. but his Set ai to That the Invest Pemit Reci his * stibmition 2 Nam Cam tet not a ily Went inside the VIP haorenZten he ‘Ststsd_ in his report that sex was Bapeening inside the vip foom: That it was. POS SOND Yih informed accued Marte tgd 8 Barta No Sort the accussd were engaging, Fra hott Tht based on the repot a pag Om he Waa vile to varity what was alleged Jn the lottes ‘sept By UN; That cho was sise able to: verity curing thot san oberaton ven 9 bar fina vas givec she was nt when privates complainant, Sitio ABREB 200 Hor statements Toe Sectised Mommy ~ Angel wnt able to esrane that Ie eae he was’ not (On.F01088 pxOMinalion, she lestifed that: he, did not actually saw the gids boing “bar fined: ‘that she caw gits coneing naked during the, perstion; That che hes ne knowledge that j * "t Insttuction to ist the gis danee faked." iwWoles acuder ana. folly <0) piecos af inoney ‘Such teq wat fin the Chief of Woinen and Children's Division ofc tees ti That uper x Gira vin ere hy, \O CRema Y CA 8, 34 vans "st at Cap Crime, Quezon Ciy, wt he fe a -Foronsle Chemist Notionoi Headquarters: PNP Cris Ws, Quezon. City: “That Ihe Hes Fa obwenves the pigsenee ‘ulti sotet ‘nat the diowrain set nag of two. ends Beate the signature: af Reet, io order to nekrovieage that he underwent ultra ‘he Wes 9 company who pre; 05 whic ‘ataination: That his {he prasonsi tion. ont in B me Ls wall a5 indo Quality Cont: cases 5 of lia: Widlet nose ‘Chettiatry and i 1896, That he aborately on March 25, 1960 of seminars and taining in no A Thar " Stina preemie Sle vinted to ultra -yielet ‘powder i io 'snces when Fo testified garding tine matt ‘That he was the one ated cWernistry ksbo ‘ALOTY: TOport No, 6-205. 's bis final tepert: “That the fitdlings: ier his. 3 &‘On ro-diroct examination. he teatiied thet: “Ho had ‘accused Dennis "Reci sign on the: Siagram: That fe only based fils examination on the Jottor raquast, That he checked the serial humbers of the money bills one by one; That he compared the . Photocopy ef mency bills ‘with thal. of the serial Aumbers he-took note of; That ibis possible to have santact ‘vith, lusting power beth:.to, the palmar Portion, the nose and ine threat without touching ancl Feeciving tha money: : ‘amily 42 yoars old, maitied, Deparment of Social Welfaro ‘Development am Block 7, Lot 12, Daniel Street, Francisco dese dal Monte, Bulacan, Shs testified that sho passed. the .board ination fer social worker on Juno 1988; That sing, she alrondy worked at DSWD where been working for sixteen (18), years now: That jor tha fast fiheen (15) years gho wes: assigned at the Operation’s Division and at present, she is-with go Techrieal Assistance division; That she was. _-issigned at the unit whore cases of victims of ablised wornen and ehiidgen aro atiended and. she ect hanclies cases of mosily soxually and is abused women and chitdren, on May 31, 2005 ‘het o¥ico eacoived a lotter from DOLE requesting for DSWD) staff to assisi in the conduct of toscule at BRC KTV Bas That si s ordered "by thelr Division Chict, PMN 1am :0 attend to the request; Thal itis Manca by the law that OSWO should be present during rescue operations of minofs on such shingnt: That ihe subject rescud took place on 2005 uit around 17:00 o'¢lock in'the: evening up te 1-00 o'clock in th early moming; That they Wer asked t} attenc! a briefing on how the rescue: as to ke executed at the CIDG pffice; That sho was fxgkad io protect the minor or any vietim in the raid to ‘be tindertsken: That minors need:t0,be protected of their rights. or front abusa and any form of | i there wero’ akiout eleven (11): ‘pitts found at the BRC KTV Bar, That sho was able to folk ‘ith Seilmmaig Temtamig vio is one of the gis. ° fecued et SRCKTY Bar; That Slekdqumt told her that she performs sexy dances and entertain easfomers in «the VIP rooms; That out of tho eleven (11) ois Protight to the C1OG ofice for investigation, two (of thom were minors, a Coho and Fate Cemlmm That she counselled pilvate “complainant Semem Temdemie cc that sho Will bo aware of hor situation: That was: it informed. by the private ‘complainant of her ptan to go ‘bak to her family and her intention to ile a complaint against the owner of B: volunianly gave ‘That Shtammip was ready and willing to be vecdings. of the: cage" ane resent hen Silammatye java hee. sworn statement; That 3 — ‘$evantoen (17) That SMD is only otc) during her emplayment at the bar ate she was asked td parfoim soxy dancas a act vont OF Silgemmmty yeas xamination:, sive te: “The other minor, Fy to glve her statame Mi to the DSWD shottor where a its customers: That tha swotn, redlited inlo wilting and oti by spiel private complainant tn her prasence: tified that: im Comp asst angie oe weslipated; Tha! Faas Cette Yas brought nether social worker was wssigned to horas she was no longer connected ‘with, the sheltor;: That 9 rescue took place ‘so. that the malnors working in the 6: be rembved; That the Sher statement of Salama Was taken at sound, }:45 o'clock in-tho morning; Thal Sllalggaie nairated ‘hor story spontancously and she did pot fol! super while giving her mont, as SAO was: ‘ iine;. That she dt not observe Sigma, tobe. ane hor étatement: That she. aid ‘hat notice ee pte rn stare ave. hor sihtement; only the minor gi nt taken; That Fadiamm: Nol ready to giva her statement ¥ uly on fi ‘she doos not want to iile a case; “Thatishe waa. et being: forced int 2 que fo. ha tlDecision 236956 Pp. v8. p02 dennis feol, et. af. Be vee resent whan Sttatammie signed her sworn stalement; at they could not forco Fam Comm to give hor steinent aven ifshe yas stil a minor.” ‘On re-ditect axaminaticn, sho testified that: ‘Sho did not so. Skimmmie to. be iipsy or slecpy during the taking of her sworn statement.” ‘fe: tke présentatlon of prosecution's evidence a formal offerin-ovicioncs, Exhibits “A” to “2° inclusive of thelt sub-markings ‘word all ocimitted aver the objection proffered by the defense in the: Order of the Court dated Aprit 24, 2007, By vay of defense, Shastammia Tele Temtmty was presented, ook the Wwinozs stand and testified th 1. She js SU TP Temata, 19 yoars old, ‘single, with postal addrese ct Logos, Cavite, “That she is only a witness. and note gomplainan: in a soso of Qualified ‘Trafficking of Persons oguinst C2 Dennis Recl, Fellolano Manoneals and John Doo; That she confinns and jaffirn: her manifestaion on paragraph two (2) of her ‘Motion to Dismiss; “That she was informed by the Police that she wii onty be a witness’ and not a Sompliinane in the caso as she has 90 complaint Sains accused Dennis Roel for any ertminal act ot ‘wrong doing That sito never danced ia the nude, and. without any:clathes because her dance was purely Saxy caning; That cho vas nover forced to have tox ‘with customers, bit it sho. did,. it washer ‘own voluntary nets Tha paopIe to Snoriminai companions: ‘That cho was not rescued nor asked for pilice assistance because cho end her companions GaN sivays ge-and tewve tha bar anytime they wank: That. sho never told uccusea Dennis Rock nd: his sompanions that sho wes a minor, in fact she even {old thom that she wes of age when she applind there for-wo:k: That she aiirins and confimes thaaffidavit of dlesicicnce she executed in favor of aoatised. Dennis Reel ond Fotisians Hanensala.” Of cross-examination, she testified that: "On her swom statement dated June 1, 2005 6 confiesed! and was cared. away ~yeah “and confirmed the ver «butt was only be - pave or age ag they just accepted her aise ot Ne, 2238 Onyx Ste the events and sho did not: understand so she is ‘withdrawing said statement dated Juné 41,2005; That on hor affidavit of desistanco dated December 28, 2005 she. did not say anything about the promise of WM c! tronay and a batter life for her: ‘That she also did_ot mention zhout the police eparcing or inlimidating het in her first affidavit; That she affirmed racity of her allegations io hor ‘Statement before the police; ‘That she took an’ cath ause she was 20 fired and weinted ‘Yo ge home the evening she made her statement before the police; That the only social worker she know was Jqgulim Eggs That while at the DOJ she. ing inquest at the DOJ, she cenfussed at that time; That sha only recanted: ‘bat testimony now because bafora sha was stil in the shistedy of the. DSWD and nov that she. ts outsicla their cusiocy, sha.is trou; ‘Thot she was "accompanied. ‘by'a social worker whenever she gods home en an. ‘out ov pase; That she oxecuted Her, affidavit of ebiciince oar a tow cays retin hat hema: That took an oath: bois, the Honorable: Gout iy ordar to tell the truth; Thal when she signed her affidavit of $ ise telling the truth; ° That she desisionce she wa: does «10% recall that she was supposed to be bar fined ‘on the night of May 31, 2005; That-she has no ‘eqewiedge of any motive by tho LUM in'filing the case ‘against both accused; That she knows that there are ‘two (2) other Complainants in this cago, tho; two (2) police officer and the Ih 2. DENNIS REC! Y AZUELA, 30 yoars old, cies esently detained at the Manila City Jolt. “He testified that he is the sam@ PO2 Dennis. Reel ¥_Azucia an accused in this case; That it was ‘who vas forcing private con amiaatt lias “Ico” to go cut.with:tham; ‘That the private complainant personally applied to. Angel, 25 she. wanted a job manage Peon of he ei thot ceed in that she was J ninetean (19) years old; That there is no That he id, fo altea Prostitution going on at 8RC KTV Olu fof roquire "Ico" to, present her bi 3 ed, 0 ‘San Andres’ Bukid, Sta. Aria, vsTS Page 28, arene DeCision, ‘im. cage 10. 05-236056 o Pp. vs. po? dennis ra Xevese segarding her age; That; POS: Ag oni fabricated his story as he wae net one eee avidence that prostition happened inside the clubs, That no one nrods 16. be toscued as. Temtmmip 23 vary much freo to go in'and out of the Glub: That all of the employees of ithe: club had , ftecciom to go in and cut of he club at anytime; That it is not tru thot they. are exhibiting pornographic Shows and selling gits: ‘That the mandy of, payments he rocoivad iron Camp Simm was for raservation tee for an exclusive snow thoy wanted and not as Paymont for bar five; That he does not tolerate dancing in the nude or teplosé in the bar; That the NIP rooms wore covered only by curtalks and no eustomar would dare do sexual acts inslde such VAP fOoms; That he ig.a police officer singe September. 15, 1998, assigned at the Hoadquarters Detective ~ gail; That he was feo assigned at Polles Station 3, Sto. Cruz, Munila from yoor 2000-2002; That it ig his Barents who gels tie earnings of the bat“ That he hos Fecaived mo; ‘itty ($5) awards andl recognition a8 a police officer” ‘On cross-oxatninaliots, he tastified that; SU thet she wanted to © can support her child; That he is not familiar vith ine background of SIMI, ho: only knows what she ‘ells him: That iLwas the floor manager who hirsd Stamm '\iiien she-applied for work at RC -KTY Bar; That he sdldom goes to the lub as he alse i al the Headquarters; That his residenco, is right beside the chub with onlyia water station separating -his hougé from 8RG KTV Club: ‘That itis tus mother win is involved in the-operation af the ba; That bel ut officer of the law, he knows - that prostitition is forbicdlon; That he “dogs. not Fomembar nis tins: of cay on May $1, 2005; That her does not have duty everyday and tis shit starts at : $:00 e'ciock in tive afternoon. to 11:00 o'olock in the. Savening; That the money he received. from Cam was fer reservation tee ond “net for bar fine, ‘That when someone is standing near the ‘et of the ViP raoin, he wall be able to See what is happening - ¢ ‘inside: That insid var, therer are. fights spending : ahd there ara Aghts steady and’ moving: That the - lights ce scattered ail over tha. bari That it wag 7 Mommy Angel who intraduce tle wai5 Lol f gant money’ 20 4; Page 22. rssinDeeiston ‘rim, case no, 05-256058 Pp. vs; po2 donnis eci, é, al. Bevenere 3 accused Feliciano wanatsals, That he neo, wuho toceived the Twonty: Thousand (PAPO Pesoe resoivation ice from Camp Sill | That tt for an exclusive show for the following: 7 Was the floor nignayer whe knew about What Show is to take plaae the following night: Thal fo Kea as to what hind of shaw that will fake place: ‘That there are po Pornographic performiancés taking Place ot BRC CTY Bor” pie 3 FELICIANO MANANSALA, JR. ¥ PANGILINAN, 38 years, old, tmetivd, a former employas of BRC KTV. Bar, with postal address at No. 167 Fabin Syeot, Tondo, Manila, and presently detained al tha Manila "Ho tected that he is the same Fellelane Manansala, Jr. being charged of Qualified” ng “Or Human ‘Trafficking: That he was only employod for fen 110) days at ORC KTV Bar and not yet familia with Bs regulations: That when ho applied dt BRC Bar, ha. Was accompanies b and Desiiéo; That white: ‘walling for a jecprey rida, ho éame aero’s Desires _ Wham be who was alse tooking for a job; “Thar this was the reoien why they cama legether at GRC Bor, “That # wos the person named: Mammy + Angel whem he a; aplied to; That ha became an erravid hoy at GEC Bir and just followed whatever: Instructions given by Mommy. Angel, ‘That-he eamed One Hundtad 4P4p100.00) Pasos ‘por night for the: Work ho porforms from 9.00 o'clock in the: évening up «$0 2:00 o'clock in tie morning; That he récalves his Salary from the cashict: Thai he met his eo-mecuged ‘Dennis Reci during his second day of wotkas he was: i Intoducod by Monay Angel; That ‘he has no 7 knowledge atiovi vit transpires inside the VIP. fe iG if OF about the har fine: Thar he was not able t0 talk io Sem SUEY 2nd tha: whon they were aurdsted he was * ) onlsiée the Ear: shat ho was not informed. by the s ‘ Policeman wiv wncsted him why he was being * vas accepted at BRC Bar on. $0, 2005 as sn ovearal boy, doing whatever what, was £ Bskad of him: 7 vis at the door. of the. lub: Whon the raid took occa: That ha was sha of those Brought in for quash onisg : 1) Breslod; That Qn re-dinoct exami son wo fostified that ‘ ‘ “twas the jo guard whe made threats against fim and nol a Dennis Reci; That accusedPage 30 . grim. case no, 05: Cc Pp. vs. po2 dennis reci, ct Meee eee= Dennis Reci never save him any order during the time he worked af ERC Sar; That every. thursday: and friday he gos home to Pampanga to teach choirs in, ‘tho church as his mcther is @ pastor.” Qn te-cfass examination, he testified that: “There is te dancing in the club and. he does fot sae anything wrong in what they do; That he. works for to (2) cays in a woak at 8RC Ban, Thathe also hoy a Husine.> of selling ice candy ttn house; That be earns abet One Hundrad Fity (Php160.00}.« Pesce a sluy in his ice candy businoss; That he was the one ihe props: polhess 2:60 cstimeny. tev fs Bo Gow tat ae Crtst 0 Gradtone. (95, vs, ANDARME, 588 ‘Bae In the trance pic riotes dated Decenibor 15, 2008, pag : tha testimony of comin ? Present In'Court ' "io Boon Whe I ag oe hor and givas het salary. Sho Foticleno Mtanangala, J, vio wae, ‘wing her sirset testimony a the. same TV Bor, 61 fob at are Bor, In ine 9 ohic notes dated. Nevenior 14, 2008, pages tie. vit (14) therooe in: mony POS Nema eo oy iloniied accused Paton Manangoicn “event in “curt during bia det tastmany as tha sari: ' “the floor manager of BRC RIV Bar are, offe@rad hin inside obs of tha VIP. som. White an PagOS Hen GMy Se acel Y Aavola who was brsent In Court identity accused Denis Aurng Als diss css. os, a the she porsen fhe arrmated for he: etime af chitd 1%) jot of | ase, tonographie notws ‘dated-Apil 24, 2008, aon (17) thereat: It the testimony oF ex Shewm who outed a5 2 popu sina Foti Stance 9 : Tr aoc toslnepy 9 orvices haing offered by! ie Bat Jo that ho end his friends: «while af pages twonty: Coste westy we nis Rock ¥ Azueles who Weis ‘ing his ciroct testimony. a8 the: same 6 1 ARC KTV Bar, wha 49 a ‘police offleer coisa if ever ha wanted to take gitls to Ris -cnoiaghie notes. dated December 18, theaot the ‘eglimony of privalo UIP coiF stonagraphic nots dated April 24, hereof in the testimony’ of oie iad that private complainant S| ‘mod him that she ‘was only sixteen (98) “vs Twenty sx (26) thneveok. he-testified thal “aed him that it sould cost about One "-" (Php $00.00) Pesos. for him to have ‘oral VIP som. And on ‘thirty four (34) * Gave iho ameunt of Twenty Thousand : ‘cused Dennis Regd as payment for the } yi. " acecibutty hase on the felevant ‘vast especially the demeanor oF rand” (Pp, 15, SEBUIS, 348 6 in low and cannet be given sho over the lestimony of ’ = Gre: Who testified on affirmative an SIADILLA. 8D AS) ¥ WHET tl finds both acctisad OBNNIS RECI Y ARUEL ho MANANSALA, JRL. PANGILINAN GUILTY bre: “Subt of thn cri charged sng Fa) tence: 1 suitor the 1 = iNPRERG pay @ FINE of ‘MILLION. , (Pap2doo « -nitippine Currency. & “