i i IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF HARRISON COUNTY, MISSOURI STATE OF MISSOURI Plaintiff, ‘VS. Case No. 16AH-CR00012 OCN No. Samuel H Bomtreger 683 E. Nobo Rd Summer Shade, KY 42166 ic {] l, E DOB: N76 Mia a DLN: / i. a0 SH 1S. Defendant. i AMENDED COMPLAINT Comes now, Renna Cristine Stallings of the County of Harrison, State of Missouri, being duly sworn upon oath and upon information and belief, and states that there is probable cause to believe that the accused committed the following crime: CHARGE CODE: 565.020-001Y198409 99 The defendant, Samuel H Borntreger, in violation of Section 565.020, RSMo, committed the class A felony of murder in the first degree punishable upon conviction under Section 565.020, RSMo, in that on or about November 1, 2006, in the County of Harrison, State of Missouri, the defendant after deliberation, knowingly caused the death of Anna Yoder Bomtreger by giving Anna Yoder Borntreger antifreeze and battery acid. The facts that form the basis for this information and belief are contained in the attached statement of facts concerning this matter, which statement is made a part hereof and are submitted: j herewith as a basis upon which this Court may find the existence of probable cause for the issuance of a warrant, Wherefore, the Prosecuting Attomey prays that an arrest warrant be issued as provided by law. Refina Crist #38301 Prosecuting Attorney Harrison County, Missourie1/1e/2618 ea:s9 eseazab825 ALLEY PAGE @1/e1 08:05 7 Fjesosasrece Bas IN THE THIRD JUDICIAL CIRCUIT COURT, HARRISON COUNTY, MISSOURI Be10-4 Tage oF Dom ase Number CSS ‘ORI Nonber = CydeNo (ONY [Defendants Name: levestgnting Agracy ORL: 0410000, oe Ft facil BORNTREGER oes ee oe ‘Address: 613 E. Nobo Ret TARE Summer Shade KY 42166 ll) Sex: M ‘Height ' Welgnt Race: W ‘Warrant for Arrest. To Any Peace Officer in the State of Missourl: ‘The Court having found probable canse ‘hits crime kar bees commined eemmands you to arrest the above-named defendant who is charged with: GameGels = Dassan NOC Mase — Chaneelet ‘fie Date $65.023- Volmtary Manslaughter OOrY198 09 9 Feloay 8 1301/2006, ieged to have beea comined within the jurisdiction of this Court and in violation ofthe laws ofthe State of Missour, “Youre foruer commanced to bring the defhndant before tis Court toe desit wih is accondance withthe Inw. ‘the eted offense ita misdemeanor, leo complete the following; Ci The Cours fortes finds reasonable grounds o botiewe the defendant, wo is charged with a misdemeanor offense, ‘will not apperr on summons; isa danger to the ime vieuim, the coounanity & abother person. {8 defendant i ehctged with any of he following and isa concealed carry endorsemen: holder, defendant shal surender Distt Heense to tho aerving officer to be forwarded with the eaum of this warrant co the covet 1 Any fou, 2, Any misdememor involving exploste weancas, frearms, firearm silencer oF gas guns; 3, Any misdemeanor offense invoking x crime of viclenos; 4 Aly miitemeator oat imvoving posetsin or abse of contoledmbrtace, of pro or penitent DWL soobol ar dtues; cr 5. A faghive dom justice or charged by inforaton or indictment in anyother stale of ony silir affine desccoed 4a the above paragraphs 1-4, ‘The officer serving this warrant shall excecure in wridag a return on this warrant to thie Court. (Seal) = ele nal pe By, Ta Bond Serars 25607. 0% — Byiudge Bond Contisons: cag eck Ofteer's Return: Teertiy chat T eorved this warrants Afar (CountyiCity of St Louis), Missouri oa (dae), by aati the above named di ‘and Briaging him/her befbre the court oh, dam), Offense Cycle Number (OCN) if not indicated above o ae eS 5 [ee Sheriff's Fe Fer 8 NA a a mr § ail PEmlOAN 1 1 2016 ‘OSCA (1-98) R240 CARWA)I } IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF HARRISON COUNTY, MISSOURI STATE OF MISSOURI Plaintiff VS. Case No. (un (Qixst oon no. A SAMUEL H BORNTREGER 683 E. Nobo Rd III Summer Shade, KY 42166 = iLe DOB: 1976 == JAN Y 9 2016 DIN: / Johan Defendant. anid eS COMPLAINT Comes now, Renna Cristine Stallings, Prosecuting Attorney of the County of Harrison, State of Missouri, being duly swom upon oath and upon information and belief, and states that there is probable cause to believe that the accused committed the following crime: CHARGE CODE: 565.023-001Y198409 99 The defendant, Samuel H Borntreger, in violation of Section 365.023, RSMo, committed the class B felony of voluntary manslaughter, punishable upon conviction under Section 558.011, RSMo, in that on or about November 1, 2006, in the County of Harrison, State of Missouri, the defendant knowingly caused the death of Anna Yoder Borntreger by giving Anna Yoder antifreeze and battery acid.The facts that form the basis for this information and belicf are contained in the attached statement of facts concerning this inatter, which statement is made a part hereof and are submitted herewith as a basis upon which this Court may find the existence of probable cause for the issuance of a warrant. Wherefore, the Prosecuting Attorney prays that an arrest warrant be issued as provided by law. Crh hos Renna Cristine Statlings #38301 Prosecuting Attorney Harrison County, MissouriPROBABLE CAUS! Date! 01/11/2016 1, JOSH ECKERSON Knowing that false statements on this form are punishable by law, state that the facts contained herein are true. 1. I have probable cause to believe that on or about 11/01/2006 TO 12/04/2006_at (Location of Crime) SAMUEL H, BORNTREGER RESIDENCE IN HARRISON COUNTY MO; (Defendant) SAMUEL H BORNTREGER, DOB WMG, SSN__ (address) 683 E. NOBOB RD. SUMMER SHADE KY 42166, committed the offense of FIRST DEGREE MURDER in violation of Section 565.020 RSMo, (Charge code number) 565.020-001¥19840999,0 2. BETWEEN 11/01/2006 AND 12/04/2006, ANNA YODER BORNTREGER DIED AT HER RESIDENCE IN HARRISON COUNTY, ON 01/11/2016, SAMUEL H. BORNTREGER ADMITTED TO DEPUTIES IN BARREN COUNTY KENTUCKY TO KILLING HIS THEN WIFE ANNA BORNTREGER. SAMUEL ADMITTED TO GIVING ANNA ANTIFREEZE IN HER DRINKS. SAMUEL ADMITTED TO GIVING ANNA BATTERY ACID UP HER RECTUM TWICE IN ONE DAY. SAMUEL ADMITTED TO GIVING ANNA ‘THE ANTIFREEZE AND ACID TO KILL HER. 3. The facts supporting this belief are as follows; (FOR MISDEMEANORS ONLY) If not completed, warrant will not be issued. 4. I believe that the defendant will not appear in court in response to a criminal summons and/or that the defendant poses a danger to the victim, the community or