Professional Documents
Culture Documents
الفكر الشرقي القديم
الفكر الشرقي القديم
ABCDEFG
c
ba
:
:
: .
ac
b
199
:
:
: .
uOu
1995
ABCDEFG
# #
M
M
M
M
:
#
:
:-
:
# :-
M
M
M
M
:
:
:
:
:
# :
M
M
M
M
:
:
:
:
:
(
S(
: ?
?Y
:S
! ^
.
( (
()(
S
S).(
o
. . !
)(Aristole: Metaphysics, 983-B-20
)Diogenes Laertius: Lives of Eminent Philosophers, volume I, (
P.3, Trans. by R.D. Hicks
t o
.
( Y
(
o
(
^
.
(
.
:
^.
: ( .
{
.
.
S(
( .
S
.
{ :
(
S
!
8
.
.
S
.
Realism
Idealism
. o :
!?.. o S
S
; t .G
) BerKeley ( (
(!
Tao .. ( (
(
!
( )
(
S
^ . ( (
.
. .
9
. :
...
t .
{
S (
!.
( ( ..
..
( :
(
( ( ( (
( (
( ^ ( ..t
^
!
.Farrington, B (
! .
(
!
10
.
:
.
(
Y t.
.
:
^
11
( .
t (
.
( .
(
.
^
^ .
.
^ .
12
S S
S
t .
(
(
S (
.
. o
( (
(
.
S
(
(
.
S
13
S (
.
( ( (
) ( .
( ?
( .
) t
(
. ( (
. :
? ?
?
?
S
.
.
( S
o
o . (
.
14
(
.
(
( .
( (
.
S S
( { (.
(
( . ( (
S S .
( S .
.
t
.
^ .
(
. S S
^
.
15
16
(
( S
( .
(
.
( ?
(
.
?
:
? . o
.{
17
.
?
.
. S
^ {
.
(
o
.
.
? (?
( ?
(
S
.
(
{
.
.o
?
( S
( .
18
(
.
o .
S S
S
o
(
.
S S
( .o (
( S :
(
... . S
S S .
( :(
o
(
.
( S
.
( S( S
(
^ S . (
:S o
? . o ?.
S
19
S
S (
(
(
^ . (
.(
.
: o ? ?
.
(
. (
)( ( .
( .
( .o
(
o .
( . S( S
( .
(
(
(
o ( . (
20
o
( ( S(
( :
o ( ?.
( S ( ^
)(
( .(
(
(? ? o ? S
(?
. :
(?
( .
( (
( (
( .
S S(
^ (
(
.
^.
)( Gautamma Siddhartha
. .
(
. .
. )((.
21
22
) ( ^ S
o
.
. (
.
o
.
S .
S
( t .
23
.
.
( ( (
( ( { (
.
(
( (
(.
(
.
( (
{ (
( ( (
( .
t
( . ( (
S ( o S
o .
(
. S
o S o( .
(
( : .
o ?
( o .
24
( ^ ( o (
( o
.
t S
( (
o
.
( .
.
(.
.
(
. (
( .
. )Darshana (
Vision
( .
(
(
.
(
Y .
. (
( (
25
o
(
o
. o
( o
o
o S.
(
o
o
( (
( .
(
( .
(
(
. ( (
.
(
( .
t
(
( S .
26
( ) ( (
( .
.
(
. :
.
.
S
.
.
.
( .
S S
( (
. S
(
S
S.S
^
( (
o
.
27
( . ( { (
(
. (
o .
.
( . ) ( ))(Brahman (
)) (Atman (
( . S
(
(
.
(
.
( .
( (
(
(
^ o .
( ( ^ .
28
^
.
.
( (
( .
.
(
(
(
. (
)) Rita ( (
) Dharma (
. Kerma S
(
(.
( ( { o { o
o (
{ ( o .
.
(
29
30
) ( : Vedas { Vid :(
( :
^ Y S
S
) .((.
) ( : Darshana (
.
o
{
^ (
) .((.
) ( : Upanisad
:S { Upa { ni-shad (
(
S S
S . .
)((.
) ( : Brahman
(
)(
)( )(() .((.
)( : Atman
( )((.
) ( : Rita
) .((.
) ( : Dharma
31
.
)((.
) ( : Karma
(
(
) .((.
32
.
o
) ( {
.
(
.
(
( .
( ( o
33
. (
S ( SS
( .
(
. (
. . . . ( ( ..
. ) ( .
.
.
^ ^
. .
o
(
S.S
( (
( ( ) ( )(
) ( ^
S
. ? ?
? ?
? t (
^.
( .
34
( {
.
{ .
)(
( ) (
(
.
Rita (
( (
( .
o ( )
: .
^
) (
Y ) ( . ) (.
t
)( .
. .
.
.
( (
. S (
() (.
35
( )
(
{ .
S ( ) (
. . (
(
.
(
(
.
Dharma Shastras
(
. Aritha Shastras )(
Koutilya ( o
. () Manu Shastras ( o
( ( .
Shastra of Yajnavalkya
. Kama Shastra
Kama Sutra(
S .
(
( ( (
( (.
. .
36
. (
( .
( ( ) ()(
) (
)(
. ( (
) () () (() () (
.
( {
.
S (
S (
(
( (
o (
(
.
S
( S S^
37
) (( ) ((
) (( )
(( ( ) (( )
(( (
.
Y ( .
S
.
38
) ( :Rig Veda
( ( .
^ ) .((.
) ( :Sutra
.
( (
) .((.
) ( :Samhitas ) .((.
) ( :Brahmanas
Y S ( ) .((.
o
) ( :Aranyakas
) .((.
) ( : ( S
) .((.
) ( :Yajur Veda ( S
) .((.
) ( . . S
( () .((.
) ( :Bhagvadgita (
) .((.
) ( :Kautilya ( (
( ) .((.
39
) ( :Manu( ( (
^) .((.
) ( :Buddhism(
. . .
)((.
) ( Jainism
^ ) .((.
) ( :Carvaka ( (
(.
)((.
) ( :Nyaya ( ( () .((.
) ( :Vaishesika (
) .((.
) ( :Samkhya ( ) .((.
) ( :Yoga
:
S t ... .
) .((.
) (( :Mimamsa (
) .((.
) ( :Vedanta
( ) .((.
40
3
(
(
. .
.
(
S. . . .
.
(
(
(.
41
(
S
.
( o
( . ^
{
. . ..
.
(
( .
(
( .
( (
.
t
.
.
(
(
42
.{
( (
S.
( (
o .
( (
S
.
^ ^
.
( . (
( {
(
S S ^.
. .
^
^ .
. . ( Mauryan
^
^ (
t (
^
43
(
(
( (
.
.
.
.
. .
^ .
^
. ^
.
( S ( ^
.
^ ()Agni ( ^
^ ^
( (
.
44
.
. ^
(
. ( ^ (
.
()Indra{ ^
S^
(
^ S
.
()Vac
t.
( .
(
.
^
(
o
.
^
^ .
45
o
.Rita
^
.
^
: ? ? .
.
o ?
( ) (
( { o
.
.
? ? ?
?
^
.
46
.
.
S
.
?
.
? o ?
? ?
^ ?
{
!
) #(
(
(
.(
^
(
.
( S
o
.
{
47
o ^ .
: ?
(
.
(
(
.. .
{ o o
.
. (
.
( . ?
?
( ( S
( .
(
(
.
Rita
.
( ( (
Y
) S .(Yajna
48
. (
(
.
S .So
o
( . (
.
(
(
.
( .
(
( .
( (
Y
( . (
(
S .
(
o
.
( o
49
( .
o
.
.
:
? S
(
. .
( (
... (
t.
t S (
t .
(
. ^ S
.S
( (
.
{
t.
. ( Brahman
.
.
50
.
.
^
. (
( .
o
.
o .
.
:
S
).(
.
.
( t (
.
( t S
.
.
(
51
.
: ?.
S
.
o ^.
?
? (
?
(.
S .
(
:
)( ( ( (
( ( (
).(
: ?
( (
.
( o
. {
( .
( ( (
.
o {
.
52
.
o . :
().(
(
.
S
.
(
. { :
? ?
{ ? S?.
S
. ( .
t
.
?
S S
? S
?
.
^ : ?
S
o
53
. S
( ( o
S ( . {
( o
.
( { ( o
{ ^ ( o
. (
S (
.
) ( :
(
) o (
) o ^( ) o (S
( Guru S .
S S
. (
(^ ( .
(
( S .
!S
o
. ( (
(
( .
54
. (
.
. ^
o
( .
t
( ) (Paravidyam
^ ( ( .
^ .
. (
.
t
.
( (
( Turiya
.
.
: o (
o
.
(
S ( (
:
S
55
) ( (
) ( . ^
...
?
o
( . ( ( )( o
o .S
.
^
( )(
( )( S
.S ( ^
o
( .
( (
^ o
( .
S ( ( ( (
( ( !
(
(
o o
.
.
( ) (Upanisat
56
{
.
).(
o
{ Uddalaka
Aruni
.
:
( (
)( ^.
: ^
.
:S ^ ...
(
S ^
(
( .
. :
:
57
S ( .
S.
: .
)(
).(
o ( (
( ^.
: ) Aham
(Brahman Asi .
.
(
( ) Tat
(Tvam asi shefta Ketu
.
. :
{ ^
{
o
{? . o
( t? :
S S
58
.
(
.
:
( )( .
. . ) (Tat Tram asi .
( .
.
){
( (
(
.
(
.
: ?
: {
. .
( o .
o o (
S ( .
( (
(
( (
(
59
. (
.
(
(
(.
. ^
( .
o
.
. t o
( .
60
) (^ Agni (
^ ) .((.
) ( :Indra ^
^ (
o ) .((.
) ( :Vac ) .((.
) ( (.
) ( .
)((.
) ( ) ((.
) ( :Prajapati .
t
^
) .((.
) ( ) ((.
) ( : ) ((.
61
62
4
:
(
( . (
. ^
S
. ^ {
S
o
(.
.
.
63
S
t . (
.
(
( .
S
(
( S .
Bhagarad Gita
(
(.
( ) (
(
^ .
(
.
.
S t.
( ( S
(
( o S(
S o .
( ( S
64
^ .S (
( .
S(S
: S
( )( ? ) (.
S S ( )(.
o (
( ?
t S
) ( o
S
(
(
o .
.
. ( (
( ( .
(
(
.
( (?
(
() Guna
65
() Purusha .
: )( )( (
o .
( .
Guna( .
. :
.
) ( ).(
Guna
o
.
)( ) )(Prakriti
.S ( S
. (
.(
Y ( (
( .
.
o
66
o ( ) (
.
^
. Gunas : Sattva
( o .
( (
.
( .
S
^ ) :( t
. )( S
. ... .
.
S
S (
.
(
.
:
( .
{ ( (
( .
.
( S S
:
67
( .
(
.
( (
o
( (
.
.
S
(
o
. : o
o ?
S (
( .
.
( purusharka
.
. )
(Dharma ) (Artha( ) (Kama
. ) )(
(Moksha .
.
68
. ( (
)( ( )(
t
.
(
( ( ( .
^
.
( .
.
S (
.
: ?
.
(
.
( (.
dri .
( .
69
.
. ( .
S
( S
o .
S o
^.
(
( ^ ^ )(
( ()(.
:
!..
Ri
( . (
.
( (
) (( ( . ( :
)( .
^ .
. (
.
(
.
70
.
(
S (
.Dharma
{ (
( t
( ( Kama
.
.
( :
. (
S
.
S :
^
o .
. (
( .
(
(
(
S
. (
.
.Moksha
Muc .
71
( .
.
(
.
(
( ( ( .
(
( o
(
(o
.
.
(
.. . { (
(.
(
.
. (
. (
S
S
.
72
(
o . (
. (
.
Varna {
.
(
.
(
( ( .
( S S
( Caste Castes
. :
) Brahmana(( ) Kshatriya (
) Vaishya(( ) Shudra( .
( ( .
.
{
S S (
( . Jeti ( .
Caste . Casta
t ( (
73
.
Brahmana Varna ( S
(
^ .
Kshatriya Varna S
.
.
:
(
.
Vaishya Varna ( S .
(
.
.
Shudra Varna .
:
( ( .
( .
.
(
. ) ( (
S :
^
( .
Ahimsa .
74
. (
.
( .
.
. ( S S
( ( .
.
.
S S S S (
.
S (
( S
{ {
t
.
.Ashramas
( ( .(
.Brahmacarya Ashrama
( (
.Grihastha Ashrama(
Vanaparatha Ashrama ( (
(
75
( Sannyasa
.Ashrama
S
o :
( ( o
S ( .
() S
Y S
.S
( ( .
.
( ( .
.^
^ ^ (
t . ( ( (
( S
( . o
) ( (S ) ^ (
Y) S ^( . (
(.
^ o
( S .
(
(
. ( {
.
Purusharthas
76
( Moksha (
(
( . ( (
(
.
o
t .
(
.
( (
S (
. (
( ( .
{ ( ( (
(
( . S
(
. S
( . (
( (.
.
^
. t
(.
( .
77
) (Sannyasin S .
.S
Samadhi
(
( .
(
(
( . S
^ .
. (
(
.
78
) ( :Krishna ^
.
t S( S
) .((.
) ( :Vishnou o ^
S S^
) .((.
) ( :Arjuna ( ( )((.
) ( :Guna
) .((.
) ( :Burusha (
) .((.
) () ((.
) ( )((.
) () ((.
) ( :Moksha (
( ( ) .((.
) ( :Panchatantra
(
(
{) .((.
79
) ( :Bhisma (
S
(
) .((.
)( S ( .
o
( .S S
) .((.
80
5 :
(
S
( .
(
.
S
.
S S
. (
( (
S
S( .
81
: o
( ( ?
S
. (
.
) .( ( o
( .
S
. S
:S (
.
(
( .
(
(
^ . (
( S .
{
{ S
(.
( S
82
( .S
( .
(
S
.
:
...
^ (
.
(
( (
o {
( ..
..
. o (
( ) ( (
( .
( S
o o
. S
S (.
S
( .
.
.
( .
83
(
( .
(
.
.{ ( (
( S .
.
(
.
Satkaryavada
.^
.
: ) (:
{ o .
S .
t.
o { .
.
o {
.
84
.
. (
o .
(
( (
.
S
o . o
( .
o
.
o .
(
( . (
(
( . { ( (
. .
SS
( .
. :
Y
(.
^
85
.
.
.
.
) o ( .
(
o .
o o
.
( .
t S (.
. :
?
.
^
( o
: o
. (
. ( (
.
.
( o (.
o
86
^ .
.
( (
.
^ {
( {
.
.
(
.
.
.
(
.
{ (
.
(
{ ( ( .
o ( .
.(
) ( .
87
^ o .
. (
( .
S
){ (
( . { (
. S
(
( (
.
Prakriti
)(( ( (.
^ :
( (
?
)((
.
: () Sativa (
() Rajas
()Tamas (
88
.
( ( .
( ( (
( ( .
) ((?
(
( ( .
^
(
. ) Purusha (
( .
.S
)( )((
(
.
( )
( :
)( ( ^ )(
S )(
)(
)(
.
)( )( ( S S (
(
(
.
89
( ^
^ ( .
)( ( ( (
) (( o
( .
.
)(
.
o .
) (( (
) ( ( .
)(
(
. o
)( .
)(
.
)(
)(( : (
: ) (
. )(
.
?
(
.
90
.
.
S
S .
o S )(
)(( )(
.
)(
)(
)((
)( )((
)(( .
)(( ( .
( ...
* )((
)( )((
.
)( )(
) Buddhi ( ) Mahat (
^ Maker I ^ ( Ahamkara
( .
.
( .
91
: :
)( (
( .Yogat
o S
)( )(( o
)(.
: o
( )(( ?
)(
)(( ( ( .
^ )( o
(.
S )( )((
(
.
(
. ( (
( .
.
^ o
( . (
(
.( (
( S .
( (
S ^
92
( t
( . S
( .
( S
.
.
(
:^ .
) (Cita ) (
. )(
) (.
)( . S
( .
)(
( )(
. (
)( )(.
)( (
( ( (
( ( .
( S S S
t
(
.
) ) .Avidya
93
( )(
)(( .
(
)( . (
.
(
. ) (Asmita
( )(.
Raga
{
( . (
.
( Devesa ( .
(
. (
.
Abhinivesa
(
. (
.
( .
(
94
.
o S .
(.
(
.
( .
{ )Yama (
(
(
^ . ) .Ahimsa (
.
(
.
.
^ S
95
( ^
^ S.
^ . o
o ^ .
t ^
S .
o (
( (.
(
(
.
(
.
. (
S ( o o
.
.
.
( (
o .
(
o .
96
)(
(
Niyama ( . S (
.
S .
t S
( o
(
o S ^
(
. (
S .
( {
{ (
.
(
. t
(
.
( .
. (
(
( (
.t t.
(
97
( . (
o .
:
Asanas
.
( ) Hatha Uoga (
( .
( S .
(
t
t .
.
o
t .
.
(
( t
o
( .Prana
Y .
(
.
. ( .
98
( .
{
(
.
(
(
.
S
(
. S
o
.
.
: t
( input .
( .
( {
.
( ( S
( ( (
. ^ (
.
( ( t
99
.{
(
. t
( .
: ( ( { )
.(Dharhna o
o
.
.
t S
( .
S
.
)(
) ( shakti
.
.
:
( . (
o t .
( .
.
100
.
: ( .
.{
S( .
( ) Samadhi (
( .( Sam
.(
( . (
( . o
( ( Moksha .
S (
( S
o . (
(
.
. (
. ( .
( (
(
.
(
.
101
(
:
(?
S
^ .
!
(.
102
) ( ) ((.
) ( ( ( )((.
) ( )((.
) ( () .((.
) ( : Buddhi (
( )((.
) .((.
) ( :Mahat (
) ( : Yama
^ (
( ^ .
( (
( ( (
) .((.
) ( : Ahimsa
) .((.
)( : Niyama ) .((.
)( : Hatha Yoga
] ( ) .((.
) ( ) .((.
) ( : Samadhi
( S
( (
. ) ) Kaivalya () .((.
103
104
:
6 :
(
S
.
:
? :
? ?
( .
.
(
t
.
?
.
( o
105
.
o
.
( {
.{ S
.
.
(.
(
( ( (
( . (
S
. ( .
( (
.
( (
(
. (
( S
:
.
( ( .
( .
( .
(
S (
106
:
.
( ( S (
. (
S
.
( (
{ () .( (
^
S . (
( ( .
(
.
o (
. {
{ (
.
.
( o .
S S .
107
.
o
( .
{ .
.
.
(
( .
S
. S
(
( S S
( S . ( (
(
.
.
(
.
^ o
. (
S
(
( . ( .
(
^ ( o
S .
108
:
Nyaya ( (
( .
( (
(
( .
.
.
.
(
{
S
.
(
.
o S (
S
S
(
( S
. (
( (.
(
.
109
Rama .(
o
) (
(.
(
o
. ( :
(.
(
( (
.Yoga
(
Nyaya
( (
( ) .( ( o
(
.
t
.
(
S
) (
110
:
.
:
.
.
( .
.
.
S (
^ . (
o
S S S .S
^
. (
:
(.
S .
( o (
.
^
.
( ( .
.
^
( (.
Y( SS
.S
111
(
( ?
(
( .
(
S ( .
S
^ .
S
( S
( .
( S
( . (
.
(
.
( S
.
.
S S S
o
.{
(
S (
112
:
. (
. (
{
S
.
S
S ( o
( ( o
( .
( .
( .
( S
.
( . :
. .Sadhya
.Paksha
.Heto S )(
)(
. ( (
:
( )(
( )( .
(
)( .
(
.
113
( (
( .
( ( (
.
.S ( ( :
( .(
( {
( .
( .
. ( (
(
S (.
( (
Shabda
(
o . (
( o
^
( ^
( .(
114
:
^ :
( .
S ( .
.
(
( ( .
: (
( ( .
( S
( .
( ( (
. ( :
).(
( (
( (
( (
. (
(
(.
(
.(
o .
( (
. (
115
( .
o S (
.( { (
o
( .
(
. (
( . (
(
(.
(
( ( .(
. .
{
.
( .
( (
(
.
o (
116
:
(
.
.
.
.
.
( Universal Essences
( S
.
.
o
. o (
.
.
(
( .
{
.
... .
117
.
... .
( (
.
( (
.
o
. t
.
( .
( .
(
( .
(
: ( ...
. ( .^
( o
.
( (
. ( :
118
:
...? :
. ^ o
(
o o
.
{
( .
^
S (
o (
. (
o
t .
o
.
119
) ( ( ) .((.
) ( ) ((.
) ( ( ) ((.
120
7 :
Carvaka
(
{
.
{ Y
.
( .
(
^
(
121
.
( (
o
. (
. ( (
Realism (
. (
( ( (.
Pluralistic Realism
. .
(
(
. (
.
(
{ ( .
. (
Absurd
. ^ (
?
( (
. (
122
: Atman ...
. ..Being
Brahman
.
(
.
( (
( .
S (
( .
.
.
S
( )( . (
- ( ) (
( -
) (
.
(
123
( ).Madhva (
- - :
( ( . Brahman
.
(
S ( : (.
(
( .
( .
o
)
( (
t o
{ .
S ( (
.
.
(
. .
Gunas
Sattva Rajas .Tamas
o . o
( ( (
124
o o
?
o
.
.
o
( ?
(
S
.
^
.
.
.
(
.
S S
(
.
. ) Satkaryavada (.
_
Satkaryavada :
. o S .
125
(
. ^
( ) (
S{
.
S
S o
(
... .
o { {
(
.
( o
( .
.
t ? .
.
o
? ( (
(
.
126
:
o
o .
(
.
S
.
( ( ( .
.
( S
S . (
( ( .
( S
^ ^ S
^ ^
.
.
. (
.
-:
:
127
( . (
.
. (
( o
( .
( (
( S
( S
.
.
o
t
( . S
( { o
(
( ( (
. (
. (
o . (
o .
( ^ S
t
S (.
128
(
( .
{ .
.
( (
S S
( ( .
( .
^ (
^
.. o
S ( (
.
.
^ .
(
( (
.
.(
(
(.
129
(
(
t
. o
.
.
. o
S
( ( ) ( .
o (
.
(
{ .
( .
( .
. (
(
.
(
(
S .S
.
130
: o
( o
t
Y (
- : - .
: .
S
. (
(
.
t
(
S( .
( .
( t
( ^
.
.
( ^ ^
^
.
( o
131
^
.
o
^ -o ^
{ ^ .
o o
( ^
( .
(
. o
o .
( ( S
. o .
( o (
{ {
^
( .
( (
( .
t .
o (
( ( (
( (
( ( o
132
.
( .
(
o
( (
.
o
.
( (
o
(
( ^
{ ^
.
t (
) (.
S
( S (
( . { :
.
o
(.
t
133
.
(
.
(
.
.
^ ^ S
^ . ^
t S
( . (
o
) (
{
o
.
(
^
o
134
o .
S .
.
(
( ( (
.
(
(
(.
S S
( (
. (
o
(
^ . (
( ( .
: o o
^ (
?.
o
S
.
(
135
( ( . (
o
.
.
- :
( t
( .
^ ^
.
. o
(
.
o
(
o
.
S
.(Ishvara
136
.
: .
.
^
(.
.
.
.
o .
o
.
.
137
( :(
( (
(
(
(
(
(
( ^ .
( .
(
(
o
( (
.
: S
( ( .
... ^
^
.
) ( (.
138
- :
^
(
. (
.{
{
.(
.
(
.
S
( .{
(
. .
.
(
( S S
o .
( ^
.
S ( . (
S (
S S ^
139
. - S ( -
- ( - - ^.
( (
( .
( (
.
^ . .
S ( S ^
( . (
.
o
( . (
.
{ ( ^
S . t
.
o
.
( .
140
( !
S
^
.
141
) ( :Sankara ( S
: .
)((.
) ( :Ramanuja ( S (
(
)((.
) ( ) :Madhva . (?-
)((.
142
8 :
:
( )(
.
(
. (
( . {
( S
(
.
Via negative
Neti, Neti
.
.
o
143
. (
. ( o
(
.
( . (
(
o
(.
( .
) (
o
. ( ( S
.( ( S) (
o
(.
( : o
^
(
Y
o
.
144
.
^
.
^
) () ( ) (
.
(
.
o (
Sita ( (
S .Y
.
(
.
.
(
.
o
. :
145
).(
.
.
.
(
.
.
( .
( ( (
.
o
( )
( .
.
(
146
.
( S
o
.
( (
{
.
( ( (
.
.
Kalkin S
.
(
. S
.
(
) ( .
(
( .
147
^ (
.
:
)(
.
.
) (
)(
^ .
(
: .
) .( (
: ) (
^
:
).(
o o
.
o
.
148
.
S . (
.
( o
.
.
{
t . S S
o .
.Vrindavana
( .
.
(
( . (
.
(
S
149
.
.
^ .
( .
(
( .
(
.
(
(
.
(
( ( o
( ( Bhakti
. (
(
(
t
.
o
.
.
150
S . {
( (
( ( .
.
.
.
{ (
( ( .{
( {
S
.
.
()Durga
.
( ^
^ o ( (
o (
^
^ ^
( ( S .
^ .
151
(
o ^ ( .
o {
.
Shakti
.
.
(
.
.
( S
^ . ( (
(
. o
) (Mata) Lakshmi (
.( ( ^
( (
.
^ (
152
.
^ ) ((.
( S ( (
.
( (
( S
S
.
( S S (
( . S .S
(
) .(SHava
. (
.
( S
. ^
o (
(
( (
( o
( (
(
.
153
.
. ^
.
(
( .
^ ( . (
S
.
(
( ?
:
( ( .
(
( .
o
.
(
.
154
( (
t
.
(
{ o
(.
o ^
( .
(
.
.
( (
.
o
( /
.
t S (
S
Immanence .Transcendence
155
( .
(
.
o
(
( .
. (
.
( ( (
(
( S o .
(
(
.
( ( .
S
.
o .
: .
( (
o (
( t.
156
.
.
(
( .
.
(
.
. {
.
(
S
( . {
(
(
(
.
(
.
(
{ . )Rudra (
o (
.
157
o
t .
.
.
o .
( .
^
) .(Pashupati
o
.
o (
.
Shakti
Parvati .Kali
.
) (Ardhanaraishvara
/ .
158
(
o
.
159
160
9
Y
.
o
^
.
(
.
(
161
(
S .
o
.
)(
Ahimsa
)( ) Satya(
.
Dharmao
{ (.
) Sarvapalli Radhakrishnan (
(
.o ) Aurobindo Ghose ((
.
(
.
Richard Attenborough
{ ( (
(.
. (
( S
162
. ( (
^ .
S (
.
( .{ {
( (
.
(
() Rama ( S
S S
.
( S
.
^ .
Ahimsa (
^ .
{
.
.
S .
.
163
(
.
.
S
.
) (
(
(
(.
.
( S
. ( o Dharma
) ( )(
( S( S .S
) (
t Ruskin
^ (
(
.
S
.
^ .
164
S
( .
S (
(
.
t
) (Satyagraha
(
o
(
.
(
) (
(
. .
{ .
) (
(
.
165
( S
( .
S
.
(Ahimsa
(
{ .
( (
^.
(
.(
( . (
( ^
(
^ .
- :
Sarvapali Radhakrishnon
(
o ^ ( S
. Vedantin
( (
166
S
( (.
(
(
(
S .
S
o
( (
.
(
(
o {
( .
(
(
(
.
( (
.Spirit
167
^ .
.
( (
(
^ ( .
.
S
( . .
( ^
. .
{
.
{ (
( (
(
.
o ( &.
S
( o .
S (
.
. .
168
S (
. (
(
. S
(
. ( (
^ .
(
.
:
(
S .
o ^
(
.
S S
.
)( (
( o
t ) ( S
( ( .
( o
169
.
(
(
.
.
( .
.
. S
.
{ )
(
.
o
( (
S ( .
S S
( .
^
.
S
S
( .
.
.
(
170
.
.o
. )( o
... .
(
(.
( ( (
(
(
(
( (
.
. (
(
o
(.
( .
( (
. t
..
) ...(.
Sri Aurobindo
171
.
^
(
^.
(
( .
( ( Purusharhas
Varnas .Asshramas
{ S
o
( .
o
(.
:
( S
t
o
t S
.
172
( (
. (
.
(
(
( (
. ( (
(
( () Maya
.Creative play
(
.
( .
(
.
S
S ^
(
.
( (
(
(
^
.
173
S
S
.
(
( {
.
(
t
.
(
...
o ?
S t )(
t
S (
(
.
S
S
. :
o
174
( S
(
.
175
( :Mohandas Gandi( ) (
S( (
(
(.
( S .{
.(.
( :Radhakrishnan S (
( S
.
. (
. S
(
) .((.
( ) :Sri Aurobindo Ghose (
.
) ( .
.
{ .
)((.
( :Rama
( . S
.
)((.
( ) :Leo Tolestoy (
( .
o
(
.
)((.
( ) :H.D. Theoreau (
176
.
S
. .
) .((.
(( :Maya ( () .((.
177
178
:
10 :
( (
( .
(
( ^ .
S
.
:
. (
( (
(
.
S .
.
179
) (
(
( .
t
S ( .
.
.
(
S
S
. ( .
t (
. (
(
.
( ( (
.
(
.
.
( ( o
( .
180
:
.
.
^
^
o
:
( ?.
:
.
(
^ .
(
^
.
:
(?.
:
(.
181
. ( :
( ^
?.
( .
( :
?
)(( )(( ^
?.
:
.
( o
.
(
. :
(
^ (?.
.
(?!.
(
((
.
:
.
(
182
:
.
{
(
o (.
S S( S
( .
(
( (
o.
.
. :
.
.
( o .
(
.
.Benares :
(
)().(
^:
( (
( (
183
. (.
: (:
( ) Craving (
(
) ^( ( :
.
:
( (
( .
(
( :
...
(
:
( .
(
.
( (
.
.(
^ ^ ^
^ ( .
.
^ .
184
:
( ^ ( ^
( ( .
( { ^
( ( (
.
(
.
(
S
.
( ( ( .
(
.
(
{ (
(.
. ) (
( (
.Nibbana ( (
.
( ^
:
)(
(
Y ...
(
185
. (
( ( (
.
( o
( { ( (
( (
. ( (
( (
( (
( (
( ... . .
( { (
.
S
.S o
.
. (
( ( :
?
?
( .
( . S
.
( ( .
(
(
186
:
(.
(? t ?
: ?
( ( .o
.
.
^ .
:
.
.
.
.
.
^
.
( o
( (
( .
(
( .
( . (
(.
187
o S ( S
.
(
(
.
( .
( :
) (Samma Dithi
) (Samma Sankappa
) (Samma Vaca
) (Samma Kammanta
) (Samma Ajiva
) (Samma Vayama
) (Samma Sati
) (Samma Samudhi
(
^
. S
( o
( .
: .
. : .
( (
188
:
(.
.
.
( .
.
.
.
( ( (
.
(
. (
(
( . (
( .
(
( (
.
(
(
.
( o (
. t
189
(
(
.
( .
.
(
.
( (
( . :
.
.
.
( (
.
S . (
(
. ( (
. ( o (
( . (
^ .
190
:
^
o
o
(
.
. :
S^
. (
( (
( . S (
.
.
( ^
.
(
( (
^
.
(.
^
.
) (Svabhava
191
^ .
.
192
:
) ( :Buddha ( ( (
) .(.
{
o .
( ) .((.
) ( :Nirvana
Nibbana ( :S Nir
{ Va
( (
) .((.
) ( :Dhamapada ( (
( . .
^ .
(
( (
^ ( .
S {
. t S S
. : o
The Dhammapada - Trans: Juan Mascaro - Penguin Books, 1973S
S o) .((.
) ( :Bhikka )((.
193
194
11
.
o
.
Y
.S
S S
S
S
. S
{
(
. (
.
195
.
.
o (
(
o { (
. o
.
{
(
( ( (
.
. .
Y
S
.
(
S ( . (
( Y S
S . (
{ ^ S .
Y S
. (
o
( Atman
196
Brahman
{
. (
( ( S^.
( S
( Y S (.
(
( (
( ^ . ( (
Y (.
( (
( S^
( o
( .
(
.
(
Kapilavastu .Nepal
(
( ( (
(
( (
( .
.
(
( .
197
S (
. S
.
. . .
.
S
o
( S
S o
Theravada ( ( Mahayana
(
.
S.S
( (
(
.
.
(
( . ( (
(
.
.
S
.Rajagaha
198
{ : (
.
^ {
.Vesali
( .
Pataliputta ()(
Mahasanghika
Y ( .
( ( .
(
(
.
(
( .
.
)) Arhatship ( (
. ( ( )(
^
( .
199
o
( ( .{ (
( o
( ) (( ( .
o ( ^ ) (
(
.Momentariness
) . .
) - .(
) - .(
) - .(
)(
(
200
( S
( ( S
( ( .
Vaibhshika .Sautrantika (
:
( ( .Ashvaghosa
.
( ( ( .
t S
( S
.
. ( ^ .
^
.
.
(
o . (
S ( ( S
(
. (
o ( (
201
( Y .
{ ) Vaibhashika ( (
( ( .
( (
o
( S (
.S
)(
{ Sautrantika (
( (
( ( Madhymike
Yogacara{ Kumaralabdhe
Nagarjuna ( {
( ( S .
^ ( S ( Vasubandha
Abhidharma Kosha
{ (
Yasomitra . (
Dharmottara (.
{ () () ( ^ (
Ashvaghosa Lan Kavatara Sutra
.
( . (
.
{
.
(
. (
202
.
) ( ( {
( .
. (
S
(
(.
Yogacara (
.
(
.
.
. Asunga
(.
Dinnaga
( .
S .
. Svatantra Yogacara
S .
.
S
^
(
( (
( (
203
.
t
.
204
) (( : Mahasang hika (
S^
( {
) .((.
) ( Arhatship S.
)((.
) ( : BODHISATTAVA( ( o
.
o ( ( (
(
S () .((.
) ( : Vaibhashika S
() .((.
) ( : Sautrantika
( S ( ^
( ) .((.
) (( : Madhyamika (
S ( ) .((.
) ( : Yogacara (
( ) .((.
) ( : Nagarjuna ( (
( Aryadeva S S( S( S
(
) .((.
205
206
12
( S
)) (Anatta ( )).(Anicca (
( S .
( )
(Paticca Samuppada
^ . S
(
(
.
( S (
.
(
.o
( (
.
.
207
.
( .
(
( (
( .
S
( ) (
^ .
:
.
208
.
.
.
(
.
: ^
( .
. (
(
(
.
: (
^
. (
^ .
.
: (
( S S ( (
( . (
.
^ .
^
^ .
.
: ( .
(
209
.
t
( (
S
^.
( (
(
. ) (Bhavackra
(
) ( ( (
( .
( S .
)(
( ) (Dukka
( .
( { S S
(?
.^ :
( ( ( (
(
) (Bhava ( .
o
t
. )
(Nama - Rupa
210
o (
o
.
.
( (
.
o o
( ( S
.
( .
o (
( . (
: t
t t
t
t t
.
( :
(
( (
( ( ( .
.
(
211
S
( ( ( (
.
o
( (
. (
( .
(
(
.
.
o
o
(.
S
(
( .( o
(
t
o
. o ) ( ^
.
212
( S (
( (
. ( (
( ( .
? (
(.
(
(
Absurd
?
.
?
(? (
.
.
:
{
( :
( .
213
(
.
?
( . Anatta
(
. :
Tathagata
.
(
. :
(
{ (
.
.
^ (.
( (
.
Per se
.
.
) ( )
214
( . :
Vaccha
( .
o
o
.o
Y :
) ( Rupa
) (Vedanta
) ( Sana
) (Sankhara
) (Vinnana
o
.
.
^
^ ?
t
215
.
o
.
( ^ {
Anatta .
.
.
.
( (
. S
.
(
t .
( t.
(
.
^
(.
o
. (
( .
. (
(.
216
o
: (
.
t
.
(
.
(
. (
( S
.
(.
)) (( S
:
S .
S
:
.
(
) (
.
o S
217
:
... .
o S
:
)
(
.
.
S )
{ (
(
S . (
(
( .
(
(
. o
.
.
Yaeko Iwasaki
. Harade
218
- Roshi :
...
.
.
(
(*
(
.
S(
.
(
.
S
.
o .
( o
219
S
. (
S ^ .
S (
(
S (
. ( ) (
.
)( :
( Dharma
) (
( ) .Abhidharma Basket (
.Dharma (
.
( (
. (
. ( S
( .
S (
220
Nirvana
.
. S S^
( .(
o
. (
(.
S .
.
t (
(
(
o .
.
:
?
Skandhas
.Dharmas
:
) (Rupa
S . (
.
( ) .(Vedana
( ( ..
221
.
( )
(Sankhara ( .
:
( :
( ( .
:o
( .
:
.
(
( : ) S
o ( .
S
( .Sankhara
(
{
^ . o :
?
) S{ ( (
.
o
.
(
.
.
222
.
o
t
{ ( (.
^ o
.
(
. S ^ .
.
^ (
.
(
S
))o (Pudgala ( .
( ) S (Pudgalavdin
(.
( .
o
( ^ . (
t
^.
S
( . .
223
( ( .
(
( (
S .
. S S
S *
S
{ .
S
S
.
S ?
Correlation
o .
( (
S
.
(
.
:
.
( . (
224
(.
S
( (
( .
:Suchness
(
.
Tathata .Suchness
( Shunyate
. (
S .
( (
S ( S
( .Buddhi
(
)(( .
( (.
(.
(
( .
225
(
(.
(
( S
. (
o )
( . (
o ^ . ^
( { o
{ .Suchness
(
( .
( Shunate (
(
.?
( Pudgala
.
.
.
. o
.
226
(
S
.
( (
(
.
.
( (
.
Alya-Vijnana .
.
S (
( S
.
o
.
.
S
. {
227
. o
( .
{ Y Karma
( ) o
( S ^ ) ( S
) (.
Yogacarins
( Madhymika {
.
(
.
^
.
^ o
{ .
( .
S
.
? ? S
(
.
( o
.
o
228
(
.
( Y
( . S
( ( .
( .
Ashvaghosa
(
( .
( S
.
.
(
o .
^ .
(
^ .
S( S
. ( (
t
.
229
.
o
(.
230
) ( :Anatta
o ) .((.
) ( :Anicca () .((.
) ( :Dukka ( ( :(
) .((.
) ( :Vacchagota
) .((.
) ( :Buddhaghosa (
( .
) .((.
) ( :Abhidharma Basket
) (
^ ( ) .((.
) ( :Pudgala ) .((.
231
232
13
:
( (
.
( (
:
.
.
.
( SS
(
)
( .
( ( ( S (
S
(
233
( .
o
Vaibhasika
Sautrantika( Madhyamika
.Yogacara (
( )(
. (
o .
S
( .
t S .
(
(
.
( .
S ( S
( S .
(
(
234
o
(
S
{ S
Representationalism
.
(
^ ( ( )(
( .
.
. (
^ .
.Shunyata .
(
^ .
o
(
( o .
t
){
(
.
(
235
.
^ .
^
.
( .
( .Idealism
S (
^{
. (
^{
. (
(
^ .
( .
( ( .
^
( .
( ( ...
236
(.
S ( o
S (
( (
(
. t (
.
.
( .
( (
.
( .
o
.
.
.
. Anicca
)( .
.
237
.
: ? ?
^ . .
.
(
(.
(
.
S
. (
t
( S
t S o
)) (
o(.
( .
:
.
.
.
.
.
(
( . .
238
.
. ( (
.
.
(
(
( S ( Poodle (
.St. Bernard
.S
( (
(
.
(
.
( (
S .
. .
( (
.
239
(
) ( (
^
.
(
( .
.
(
( ^ (
S (
.
.
S
:
(
.
.
.
o
.
S( S (
)
240
( .
( ( S
( S .
o Duration of Existence
( (
( ( .
(
.
(
(
^ ( .
( (
:
o (
.
( (
o ( ( ?S
.
(
o S
( )(( (
.
( (
( o
241
( . S(
( (
( (
( o .
S
(
S
(
.o
.
( (
.
( Sautrantika
(
.
^
(
(
( ( .
242
.
(
) (.
( Permenence o
.
o o .
(
.
( o
(
.
) o
( ( S
o
( :
t . o
.
Absurd .
.
S S
S { (
t.
( .
o (
243
... o
. S
o .
{ .....
S o
^ ^ . ( (
o ^
^.
t.
( o
o
^ .
o
o
.
.
S :
.
.
244
( Identity
.
.
o (
(
(
o
.
.
(
.
. o
.
.
(
. ( .
( ( S
.
245
( .
( Unity
.whole a (
(
.
( . ( ( (
o ( ....
(
( o
( .
. (
( ( t
.
( (
(
. (
(
o
{
Oneness(
.
( (
.
.
( Iniversals
. SS
246
S Tableness.
o (
( {
?
o ?
.Particulars
(
.
.
(
o ( .
( ( .
S
^ t
.
) (
) (.
.
( (.
^ S
{
. {
247
{
(
^ ^ .
S
t
.
.
o
o {
.
.
(
(
.
{
.
.
.
)( t .
t .
.
248
( ^ (
.
o
S S
.
t { .
(
S .
S
. (
:
.
*.
( (
.
S S
(
S (
.
(
(
249
Mt Everest o
. o
. t (
( ( (
.
.
.
(
( { .
S
( . (
(
.
(
( ( ( ( .
(
( (? {
( o (
(
.
(
(
(
.
250
( (
.
( .
(
^ (
( ( .
o
(
.
)(
.
.
o ?
* {
{
.
.
(
( .
(
(
.{
251
( .
( o
o
(
S(
(
o (
.
t
. o
. S
.
{
o
.
.
S S { (
o S .
{
(
.^
(
252
(.
{
. (
{
o .
(.
(
Wholes
. ({
( (
.{
o
. ^
.
(
.
(
(
( { (
o (
.
( ( ^ .
( {
253
{
t t Absurd
.
o
.
.
o
o
.
( (
.
(
Unfolding (.
.
S ( S S (
S
( .
(
.
( (
254
. (
(
.
t
( o
( .
( ( . ^
.
S
* .
*
.
o S
( ( ) .(
o
.
.
(
.
(
t S
. ^
.
. (
o . (
255
(
(
S
S( .
.
o
S
( .
( ) Skandhas (
) Dhatus ( ) Ayatanas (
Karma
( S
) (
) (.
(
.
S
?
S (
( .
(
o (
.
.
.
256
t . (.
(
( ( .
(
o (
(
( ( .
:
o
.
( .
.
) ( )
(
.
(
(
S (
) ( .RELATIVISM
o
( ( . (
257
( .
( (
. (
( . (
(
(
( S(
( .
.
S
^ .
^
^ (
^ ( ( {
^ ( ^ (
{ (
( .
(
S
S .
S
S
S S
.
258
(
.
o S
.
o
o
o
( (
.
.
( S(
) ( Y
{ (
{
( (
(
( ) (
( . (
(
S
.
(
259
( * (
(
( ( (* (
( . ^
(
( .
( (
o .
( o
^
( ( . (
( ( (
.
. (
(
(
{
.
( S
.
( (.
( .
260
.
:
{
.
)(
Candra Kirti
(
S
:
: :
( !.
(
t (
(
( ( .
( ^
( ( .
(
( .
(
(.
(
S .
( ( ( ^.
261
.
Prajna Paramita
( .
( ( S S
( S( ( .
S S is is-
.not
S (
.
.
(
S (
( o
o (.
: S (
S S S (
.
)(
( .
S
Karika (
( S( S ( (.
.S
S
..
(
( . ( S (.
.
S (
.
(
) (
((.
( S (
.
^
263
(
.
( .
? ( ? ? ...
( (.
o
.
( ( .
:
(
) ^( .
o
. :
.
^.
^.
^
^ .
(
(
(*
264
o .
S S
t SS
^ .
{
. S
S ( (
(
( .
S
(
^.
^.
(
( ) (
(
^
S .
(
.
(
265
o
. S
? ^
(
^ .
^
^
^ .
^
^!
{
o
. o
^
( {
( .
S
o o
. (
.
S
o ^
S o
.( (
S
{ (
266
o .
(
o
^ o
.
o .
S
.
S
.
S S :
S ) ( (
... ) ...
o (.
( .
o S
{ .
(
S .
? S .S
267
.
.
.
.
S .S
S
( S
S( S S .S
.
(
o
? (
: !
^ o
)( .
o .
(
?
o
.
268
?
S ?
.{ (
( (
. S
S . S (
( o
(
.
( S
( S .
.
o .
(
^ (
S .
. (
.
.
t
.
S
o .
(
269
(
( :
( ( .
( .
.
( (
... . (
(
.
( )( .
(
( ^ .
. (
( .
. (
(
.{ (
o {
.
(
( .
^ ^
270
...
(
{ .(
.
( (
.
( ) (
S ( .
(
. .
^
^.
(
.
o
o
. o S
(
( . S
( (
o
.
( o
271
.
)(
{ S )
( .
( (
(
S .
272
( :Parmenides . .
S (
.
(
o
o t) .((.
) ( Seed-Conciousness :Alayavignane {
( (
Store-conciousness
() .((.
) ( :Shyunyota( ( ( S
S
) .((.
) (
( S S
Bhavaviveka (
Buddhapalita
{ (
) .((.
) ( :Candrakirti ( (.
)((.
) (( :The Madhyamika Karika
(
) .S((.
273
274
14
:
S
t
( ) Zazen
() .( Bodhidharma
S
t
(
t
)
( S
.Shaw- Linssa
(
(
o .
( (
{
(
275
.{
^
( ( . (
.
{
(
Hui-ko
.
Zen
. Mumonkan
)) Koans ( ( Mumon
S )
( t
S ) ( . Kashyapa
)
( .
. ^ ( )(.
t
. Dhama
( :
.
o .
276
(
o .
)(
(
.
.
t
.
o
o .
( (
(
Wu-ti
{
.S
(
:
? :
.
: ( .
o Y .
277
(
( : .
^ :
^? .
: .
( .
( (
.
(
( (
( (
( (
(
S
( o S
S . (
.
: .
(
(
( .
(
. S
(
278
) ( .
( o
( .o
(
.
( (
o o
.
( (.
(
)(
Lao Tzu
( ( )(
.
(
{ (
o .
o
(
( (
o .
(
.
t .S
Chuang Tzu
( Yenh ui
:
.
. t (
( .
279
. t
(
.
( (
? .
o (
. (
t
!
t
o .
t t
( .
( . (
? (
(
.
(
.
280
.
S (.
( (
. (
....
( ( ) (
{ .
(
o ( (
o
{ .
( (
.
. (
o (
^
.
?
.
281
.
(
.
S (
(
.
)(
)(
.
o
o
) ( (
( .
.
.
.
(
. (
o
( (
( .
282
(
. ^
.
( (
.
.
) Dogen (
S S
. S )
( (.
Ayuwan
S .
^
:
(
.
.
.
^ ( S ( { (
.
.
. o
^?
.
283
?
( ( ( S
?
:
{ .
: ?.
: (
( .
.
( .t
(
t .
(
( . (
o .
.
. ( :
)?(
: S.
( ^
?
.
.
^ ^ o ?.
S
284
S ( .
^ (
.(
S : ^
^ o ?.
( t ( (
. S (
( ( (
( (
( ^ t .
) ( (
( (
( .
S S
S
o .
.
(.
( ?
( .
(
( .
o .
285
( . ( S
. )(
.
( .
.
o
. (
( (
) Satori ( .
( (
.
( .
(
S( ( .
(
. (
^
.
o .
. Hui- neng
( (
286
. S(
S
S
S( ( :
)(
^
S
( :
(^
?
( S (
( .
S
(
t
(
.
(^
o
( .
S
( o
287
( . (
.
.
t
. o (
:
S ( ^.
t
( ( .
Rinzai
. )Soto (
( t .
S
t .
( ( .
S
288
.
( (
.
. ( Joshu
: ) ?( :! )
(.
o . (
.
.
S is
is not S Being Non -Being
( (
:! ) !(.
.
: (
S( (? . (
. ! o
t S( (.
) (Satori
289
{ S
(
t
. S
. t
{
. ( (
. (
Yueko Iwasaki { :
.
S
( { .
.
(
o .Yogacara ....
.
o t
.
(
.
(
290
( ( .
S.
...
Mind . (
( S .
(
.
.
.(
.{ ( o
. (
( t ^
.
^
( .
.
(
^ .
S
( S .
.
^ (
.
^
291
.
^ o
S
S .
(
( .S
Thatness o
. (
( .
.
(
.
: :
( ( .
( (
( (
( .
( S (
o
. (
.
292
(
. ^
.
( . ( ^
.
. ^
( .
( .^
.
^ o
.
o
)(
)(
.
) (S
.
^ .
( (
.
293
):(
?
.
. (
.
.
.
( .
^:
294
)(
^ )
( )(
.
S S .
^ .
^
.
?
t
o .
(
( . (
.( ( (
.
( (
.
295
.
?
{ ?
.( {
S
S .
S
.
^
^ ( .
296
.
. ( .
.
S
.
.
t
( ) (.
( .
t
297
.
.
) Dharma( . .
^ .
.
.
t {
! {
.
(
o .
( .
298
) ( o )
^ ( ( .
) S ( o
. ^
( .
.
o .
o .
.
( S
) (.
. ) (
) (( . ? (
.
299
.
.
^ .
.
o .
. o ^
.S o
o
.
S .
S !
.
300
) Zen ( . ^
S
(
{ (
(
( S
Chan
Dhyana Thana S
) .((.
) ( : Koans
(
( ) (Roshi (* (
: . ?.
( (
( .
( S S
S S t
301
( ) .((.
) ( :
S { t
. o
. (
( ( ) .( -
S
) ( ) .((.
) ( : Duhkha (
( ( ( {
.
(
) ((.
) ( ( ( .
( :
302
^ . ^ o } ^
^ { (
( ) .((.
) ( ( - ) Kant
. {
) .((.
) ( Hume . (
{ t
( ) .((.
) ( ( - ) Heisinberg .
o
.
() .((.
) ( :Dogen Soto S S
303
t
S Chan
S o
) .((.
) ((
) .((.
) ( :Satori ( wu
(
{ )( . (
o ( (
o ( ( S
() .((.
) ( Soto ( S S
( ) .((.
) ( : ( S
( S
(
{ (
( S( S (
( (
) .((.
) ( . (
(
Philip Kapleau
) .((.
) ( : Sutras
.( ( (
304
) .((.
305
306
15
(
^
^ .
S
(
.
:
]
] ] ]
] .
^
o
307
?
. ^
( .
^.
(
{
(
.
o
.
.
( S S
^ .S
S
.( (
( .
308
^
( S . (
(
S S
S
(
(
:
.
.
.
( ^
(
.
.
( S S
( .
( (
S
(
309
( .
( (
.
(
S
. (
^
( (
(
S .
.
.
(
S .
S ( ( o
( o
( . S
.
310
16
(
.
.
{
t .
(
.
.
311
)(
S
.S
( (
.
( ( . (
.
(
. () Lao Tzu (
S
:
.
.
.
( (
:
.
312
(
. ( o
.
S .S S
S
S . (
o
.
.
)(
(
S .
S .
S
.
(
^
(
(
313
S o
.
(
S
. (
S
.
(
^ (
.
.
(
^ .
S (
.
( ( S(
( .
(
. (
S
t S S
S
( ( .
(
314
^ .
(
.
( ( .
( Lao Tzu { ..
S ( (
Tao te ching .
.
( . . ..
() .((.
( (
S
( (
) .((.
315
316
17
.
(
o
S .
t
S
S S (
.
S o
( )Shang (
( .
(
317
. Chou
..
S
( .
(
.
S
.
S(.
S (
{ S (
( .
( ^
(
.
.
S (
( .
318
S
.
S
. ^
( . (
t t
( (.
S S S
S .S
S
. .
( o
t
{
.
:
(
S ( ^
( . (
{
?
319
S . (
.
.
.
.
:
) (Shih Ching
.
) (Shu Ching
..
)^ (Ching-H
)
Weng Wang.(.
) (Li chi
.
o
.
) (Chun chiu
..
:
(Lun yu
.
) (Ta hsueh
.
.
) (Chung yung
.
) (Meng tzu
320
.
(
o
^ .
.
) .(
( (
) ) .(
.
t
^
t
.
(
(
. S
.
)) Yang chua ( .(
(
( .
321
(
(
.
Monisn( )Chang tzu (
) .( .
( .
(
( S
S S (.S
):(
S
S S S
S . (
) Mo tzu .(
(
.
(
S
( .
Utility (
( (
o
.
( {
(
(
322
(
. (
{
.
:
( )Hui shih (
) .( )) Kung-sun lung (
.( . (
S (
( S( .
( (
( .
S ( S^
S
(
^ .
( S
.
.S
yin - yang
( Cosmogony
Cosmology ( .{
() ( (
.
(
.
323
o
( .
( .
( .
: ?
( :
?
(
.
.
o
( ( . .
( o
o
( ( .
. (
( .
( S
S S S( S
S
^
o
S S.
( o
324
S
.
S
( S
S (
.
( ( (
(
)) Han Fei Tzu ( .( (
. ( (
S
. ( (
( S
(
. (
.
(
.
S S
.
Hui- Nan
S
S ^
.
S S
( (
.
.
(
.
(
( .
S
(
S (
.
S
. (
326
t
.(
( S
.
( (
Hua- yen
{
^ S S
S ( . (
: :
^
t (
( .
) Tient-tai (
( ( Round
Doctrine (
(
( (
. (
( ( .
(.
(
) (
)) (( .
327
.
.Chan
( ( (
(
^
S (
(
(
(
{
. { S S
( S
S
( .
(
S
(
. (
S
328
(
.
o
) Han hu (
.Sung ) ( ( (
) Cheng Hao (
) ) ( (
Minl ( .
) .( ) ( (
) Ching
.(
(
( ) .(Tai-Chi (
) Yan( (
..
^ .
Tao . SS
^
( .
(
( ) (Chi( ) (Li
(
.
)( ((
.( ( o
. (
329
( ( (
.
)( )(
S S( .S Wang
) Yang ming ( Monistic
.
.
(
o
.
) ( (
( S .
( ( ) S (
( (
^
S( ( . ( (
( .
. S
( ( .
(
( .
(
.
o :S
Yan Yin
. ^
330
S ( (.S
S
( .
( :Shang ( ( S
( . . (
.
) .((.
( :Yang chu {
( () .((.
( :Chuang Tzu . ).(.
(( ( :(Mohism (Moism ( o )
.( ( {
(
(
( ^ . o (
( ( (
( ) .((.
( :Hui shih ( S( S
( S (
o ( So
( ) ..(.
( :Kung-sun-lung ( ( S (
) .((.
( (
( ( Tsou yen
331
) .((.
( :Han Fei Tzu (
( .
o (
.
( (
t S
) .((.
( :Tient-tain ^ ) (
) ( ( .S
(
. ^
( Dharmas
(
S(
( S S .
.
( )((.
( :Ching tu
o ( . o
S( o
o . (
o ( ) .((.
( ( S
() .((.
( :Cheng Hao :LiCheng
(
. (
() .((.
332
18
-
.
.
( (
.S
.S
) (
t
.{
{ .
{
333
.
o o ?
.
.
.
?
o
.
.
o .
S
.
.
.
{ .
t
.
(
334
.
: o
?
. ( .
- )Jen (
S .S
S
. S
:
. Human
Heartedness S S
S
.
) -(
.S{
S
(
.S
S
( Fan Chih S
: ) ( :
.
^
S .
:
( .
335
( {
( (
) (S o (?
( o ) (S
.
S ( (
S
.
(
(
.(-) S
S
.
.S : (
) (S
) .(S )(S
) .( S S
. S
( S
S ( .
?S
S (
( ^ . Tzeng
Tzu ^
) Chung )( ) .(-
(
S ^ .
336
(
^ { ^
).(-
- Li
S (
. (
^ ) (Li (
t .
( ( S S (
S
S :
( ^ )( )(S
).(-
.
)^ ( :
{ )(
)(S
t ( . S
.S S
.
S
o .
) S
(
337
.
( .
:^
( .
S
( :
{ Li
(
S
....
: ( (
o.
S
( . Li
(
(
.
^ ^
S S
^ .
{ Li
338
( (
.
(
(
^
.
(
(
( (
( {
. .
.
( ( {
) .(S (
(
^ .
( .{
S
t ^ (
. {
S ^ .
t
( S ^ . (
(
( S.
339
S (
{
.
- ) Hsiao (
S
( ^
^
. Tutzu
: ) (Hsiao
).(-
.
(
Y
. { (
.
(
. (
Y S
.S
.
{ .
.
340
S S .
Yi
S Yi .Righteousnesse
: Yi
^ )
(LI o
! .(
) (S )(
^
.
(
) (YI
.
( (
S
^ .
S ( .
(
St S
.
S
341
.
(
.
.
S S
(
.
S S
( .S
o
:
(
(
(
(
.
( (
342
. (
(
.
{
. S
(
... o (
( ( (
) ...(
) ( .
.
S (
(
:
? ( o
( ?
?
.
(
343
S
( ( (
( S .S
( (
{ ( .
( S .S
^ S
.
^ .
o (
(
.
S .
(
) (
.
t
.
) ( (
. (
344
.
(
. ( (
:
^ .
.. ^ (
(
. ( (
(
o .
(
( .
( ( : (?
( ( (
(.
(
( ( o
( (
. : (
(
.
345
.
(
: (
.( (
{ .
S {
(
Jen S
Jen S
.
^
.
^ ( ( S S .
(
S .
(
.
.
( ( (
346
S S .
(
^
S
^ .
? ^ ?
( S
.
^
.(
( (
( S ^
( .
^ .
? !
.
.
o
(
^
347
^.
^
. (
. (
( .
(
{
.
.
. ^ )(
. S
S
S
. {
{ S
S ( .
(
(
( .
348
{
( S
( S
(
o o
o o
o .
)( ( (
o .Li (
^ o Jen S
t
Hsiao
. .
( S
.
(.
S
:
S o
o
S
^ .
349
(
.
{
^ (
S .
S
(
.
. S
S
.
.
S .
Mencius
Jen S
Li
Y S .
Hsiao
Yi .
^ ( (
S ( .
Yi S
Rightness S
350
o S .
( S
( (
S .
o
S Yi Jen S
S
.
.
S
S .
.
.
. :
.
.
.
S
) Chih ( .
o (
S
351
.
^ ^
o
^
.
{
( .
{ S
.
(
? (
: :
.
:
. :
(
(
( .
( (
352
(
S
(
. (
( o
.
Hsun Tzu
(
^
(
o (.
(
.
.
o
o
.
(
{
:
.
.
:
353
{ Y(
^.
{ S
(.
S
: ?
.
.
(
(
(
( {
.
o
o o
Li
.
S (
354
.
( :
{ S ?
S ^
.
.
(
( .
S .
(
S ^
S S
.
^.
{
( (
.
355
:Lu ) .((.
:Jen S (
(
(
) .((.
:Hobbes (
.
S
.
( () .((.
356
19 :
(
o S
(
) ( .
.Lao Tzu
Chuang Tzu ( S
.
Lao Tzu
357
. S
. (
.
( (
( (
( .
S
( o
S .
(
.
S
. S
S S
S S
.
358
S
t .
.
( .
.( (
S ( (.
( (
.
.
.
( (
.
.
.
.
.
(
.o (
( :
.
359
.
S
.
( (
o o
.
{ (
(.
o
.
.
.
(
(
(
(
.
. (
^ .
360
.
(
.
.
:
) (S )(
(
( .
.
( (
(
:
)
(.
{
( ( S
.
361
.{
o
:
) . (.
( : S ?
.
.
Tao
.Te ^ S S
SS
. S ( :S
... {
^ .
S S S.
(
.{ (
(
362
) ( .
(o
. : o
o
( )
(.
o
. (
??
( ( o (
o
o
.
:
.
(
( .
o o
o (
.
o o
o
.o )( {
o
Te
363
.Tao
.
) (Wu Wei
. :
) ( . :
( : { (
)
( . .
S ( .
t o
t .
.
( ( (
. S
.
.
.Tao
.
364
:
)(.
.
{ .
.
.
.
.
.
.
S
(
( ( .
.
^ . (
(
) ( .
. .
t
) .(
. (
365
( *
S { .
{
o
.
.
t
) ( .
:
. :
S
) (.
(
S
.
(
( (
.
Chuang Tzu
. ) . (.
366
o
. ( u
.
.
(
.
:
?
.
( ( ( o
( S ^ S S
)( S )( .
.
( ) (
(
.
) (( .
( .
(
*
(
(
)( ( ( .
367
( ( (
( o
:
.
.
(.
.
(
) .( .
)(
.
. :
(
) So(
( .
. :
Mount Tai .
o )
(S
.
. :
)
( . ?
. ?
368
) ( . (
( .
( (
(
o
.
( S(S
{ {
. :
S S( S
( .. (
S (
( t
t .^ {
o
.
S
.
(
o
(
( (
(
^.
(
369
{
.
o (
^ S
^
(
.
.
o
. o
o
( .o
(
(
.
(
( (
(
{ ( .
{
(
( :
.
: (
(
370
( ( . (
.
.
(
( o .(
) (
. .
. .
) (
o .
^ {
.
S
S .
. :
.
( (
^ ( (
(
S ^ ... .
( ^
^ . :
( o :
( ( (
( t ^
( S : ...
371
?.
o { .
( .
( .
S ( . (
. o
S
( .
{ .
:
.
:
?
.
(
( {
) ( (
.
(
S .S
.
.(
372
: (
( ?
? ^
.
( o
^
.
^ Totality .
.
.Totality
(
.
.
:
.
: )(
. :
. (
:
.
. .
.
(
:
373
. ) (( .
S
.
( {
(
o
.
o
( ( . .
(
( (
.
: ? o
. ( . .
o ?
o
.
( ( ..
.
. .^ .
. (
. ( .
.
374
(
: o (
.
: (
S
.
.
:
. . S
S
.
.
.
.
.
.
(
(
( {
. o
.
o
S ( (
S ( {
.
(
S
o
375
. o (
t
t
S {
:
{ o .
.
.
{ .
.
? .
( (
( ( .
) (
( ..
.
( ( (
?
.
S :
S (
376
(....
o
:
(
( .
( .
.
(
:
. S
.
*
.
( o .
.
:
) ( S
o )
( ( ) .((.
) ( S (
S
377
... ( (
) .((.
378
20 :
:
S .
S
(
.S
(
.
o {
( (
.S
. . Chin
S
379
S .
{ (
S .
S .S
(
(
. .
Han .
.
)
.( .S
t S S
( S
.
.
:
(
.
( (
380
.
(
( . o
. { (
{
.
S
( .
S
S
.
S (
S
( .
(
.
S S
( .
{
.
. (
S( S S
(
( . S (
381
S
S
.
(
S
S( S (
. S
S
S .Y{
(
o
.
(
.
{
(
S
(
S . (
.
{ (*
.S
S
. (
.
.
382
^ Chou Tun-i
^ ) ( (
. (
S
( S
.
) Ou - Yang Hsiu (
(
o S
.
(
* .(
( (
(
.
(
.S
) Han Yu (
:
^
(
S
S ( S
.
383
.
.
o .
:
.
o S
t .
Jen S
t
.
t
( . S
.
( .
(
(
)(
^ )( .
(
Li Ao
. : {
( S
(
.
( .
(
384
(
(.
o S
)(
o :
( .
(
.
)^ ( :
.
Y ^.
^
o
. S
S ^ .
( S
.S (
.
S o
o (
.
^ ( ) Tai -
(Chi S
S S (
( . (
385
.
^ S (
: ( .
. (
.So S
( (
o
^ . o :
^ S
S .S
^ S
( S (
( * :
S :(
( (*
( . (
.
* o ( .
( S *
( S o (*
. ^ :
( ) (( S
. Chien S
)( ) Kun( .
S S( S
386
) .(
(
. S
S o
( { .
t o { ?
.
^
Y (
S (
. :
o ) ((
.
.(
) S o(
S
).(
(
(
.
( ^ .
( )(S
o . S (
( .
^ Cheng
)o (
.
387
^
) ( ^ ) (
.
) (Li .
^ (
( (
.
^ . ^ (
{ ( (
( . (
^.
^
( . o
o
. S (
.
.
( (
) (
( . (
^ :
( :( .
(
388
( .
o
) .(
(
:
( ) .( :
) .(
(
(
( (
( . o
?
( ( .
( ) (Chi( ) (Li . (
(
. ?
.
... .
(
. (
^.
S o
t
S S S
389
(*.
( (
.
^ ( .
(
( S
. ( (
. (
.
(
.
( .
. (
(
.
( (
( .
^ (
S
. (
: .
. (
{ ( S
S * ) .(
( . S
390
(*
. :
(
(* ? : .
) ( o
. ( (
( S o ) . .(
S
( ( S o
( : S
S^ S
. ( ( S
. ( ( ( .
^ : ( o
* )
.(
: (*
(* ) .(
*
( . ( .
( { ( o S .S
( (
( . (
( S
(
391
(
^ .( o (
( ^
.
:
( ( ?
?
( ?
.
: .S
S .
o )( ) S .(
S S S
( . ^ ( .S {
( S
. :
S ) .( S
( ( ) (
) (.
^ S
( .
:
( ( ( .
.
S {
(
.
392
) .(
S
( .S (
( .
^ ^
. S
.
o
o
(.
( ?
^ :
(
)( ( ( .
. (*
( :
o .
(
.
) .(
S
(
( { (
( ( .
^ : (
. (
393
) .(
(
.
( .
S (
( (
S
S (
S S ( )t
(
.
Chu Hsi
( o ) S(
S
. S (
S .
) (
( (
( S
S . {
( S S
t o.
S
S
. S :S
394
.
.
.
.
.
S S S
S
.
.
.
(
.(
(
o
. S S
o
?
o (
.
S
( .
Han Yu
395
S o
( S
S .
Chang Tsai S
{
S S .
( (
(
S(
( ( ) (Chi .
S
(
S .
( o S( (
: (
( .
S ) .( (
( S .
S ( (
. (
( .
( ( S
396
( .{ S
S .
S S
S( (
. ( ( )(
( )( . : {
( ) ... .(
^ . S (*
.
(* (
( . (
( ( ( (
( .
( : (
( S . (
( (
) .(
( (
:
( ( .(
) ( .
( . ( (
( )(
) .(
( ( { S
( (
397
. (
(
( (.
.
( ( { .
^ (
. ( ( )
.( ^ ( ( (
.
.
. ( .S
( (
) S .(
S
^ ( S .
( .
: ( .
S ( (
) .( (
( ( ( .
S (
S .
S S .
: ( .(
398
: S ) .(
( .S
S :
.
(
) S .(
S (
) S .(
S S
.S { S
( .
(.
(* (*
. (
( .
) .(
(^ ) ( )(
S
.
S ) Tao( ) Te
( . ( .
( .S
. ^
. S
.
:
:
399
( ...
S S
{ S
) .(
S
.S
{
(
) S .(
o
: S
S ...S ^
.
Wang Yan-ming :
S( (
.
( {
(
o (
(.
(
Lu Hsiang Shan S(
. ) Wang Yang-ming (
400
t ( : *
) .(
S
o ( (
.S
.
.
S
) .(
( (
.S
(
.
t
(* .
(
) (
) ( (
.
: S
(
.
(
401
.
.
(
( . ( (
) .(Chih Liang-chih (
:
(
o
) .(
(
S S( (
.
( ( .
( ) .(
(
( .( (
o o
( { .
(
( ( (
.
(
o
.( (
( ( .
.
402
( ) (Ta Hsueh
{ S .
(
:
.
.
.
:
. .
S( o S ^
) .(
.
.
S .
S S
.
:
^ ^ ^ o
^ ^ ^
) .( (
.
(* ^
403
.
.o
. o
^
:
) .(
:
( ( .
(
) .(
S
.
(
.S
(
. : (
. (
. (
404
( ) .(
Tai Chen
*
( .
( . S
( ( (
(
.
(
) S (
S S
. (*
( ) .(
(
( ( . (* o
(
. S *
S
( S .
(
o
S
.
S
.
( (
405
. (
(
( (
S
S .
( (
^
S
( S.
( S .
Y
( . S
S ( (
(
S
( .
.
406
21
( S .
) (
o S
S
o
( S Y
. :
o { ?
.
Y .
^ ( (
( (
( .
(
(
. (
( (
S
407
(
S
.
S
Y .
o
( S
.
Kang - Yu-Wei
{
(
o S
( S
.
(
(
. Dowager
S
So
.
(*
{ o.
S
408
( S S
(
Tung Chung-Shu
(.
. (
( S
S S ( S
( .
o o
. :
.^
. ).(
409
.
.
o ^
.(
S^
o
.
( ( o
^ ) (S o
S ^
*
) (
:
.
o
o
( S .
).(
(
.
S S S S S
.
410
(
o
).(
S
^
.
S S .
{
. (
(
(
( (
S.
) (
(
S S
).(
S
411
{ .
(
.^ . .
(
.Function (
S( (
( .
.S
( (
( (
. S
( ( (
( . (
(
S (
o .
( .
o
( .
(
( (
S
412
) ....(
.
( (
:
S(
.()...
Hsiung Shih-Li
) Hsiung Shih - Li (
.{
(
(
.o (
(
.
( S S
(
S o.
S
.
413
(
.
.
S
.
( ( .
S
{
( .
S
(
.
:
(
.
:
.
( o
. (
.
:
(
S S .
:
o
414
) .( (
(
.
:
).(
(
.
:
.
^
( ( .
S
).(
o
.
. o
:
( ^ .
(
(
. ( ( (
.()...
o S
(
415
(
o .
.
.
S
.
( .
function
( (o
)(
. t
( (
. o ( (
o
.
.
o S
o
).(
.
)( ( Amalagy
416 (
. ) .((
o :
^ ) ( ((
? ... :
^ o
)
( ^ o
.
(
: ( ^
t
. o ?).(
(
( : ^
^ . ?
^ ^
o ).(
(
^
( :
^ . (
( ^
^ ( . (
^ . ? !
^
( ).(
417
^ (
( ( .( : ^
.
o
.
( )(
( (
) .(S( (
. (
o
.
Fung Yu - Lan
Fung Yu - Lan
. S
.
S S
(
S
S^
(
.
(
418
.
( .
o (
( ( . (
S
.
( ( (
S
(
.S
.
(
.
.
(
( .
(
.S
(
419
. (
).(
. o
S (
(
(
( ( .
(* (
( (
(
.
( ( (
(
( . (
.
.
( ( S
^ .
( S
S S
^ . S
( : ?
420
).(
( ( S
S
.
( ) ( (
(
o
( ( .
S (
t
{ . (
( S .
S( ( ( S
( S S
( o
.
:
( (
( )( . .
{ ( .S
.()...
(
(:
S (
(
. ^
421
{
..
^
{ (
{ :
).(
t
S
S (
( (
^.
) ( S(
{ S
* .
S
(
S ( .
{
( .
S ( S
( ( .
( S ( t
S .
422
(
o .
(
S(
( S
:
^
) .(
. S
S .
(
...
).(
o .{ (
S
.
) .( (
( (
.
(
423
^ (
.
: S :
^ ^).(
S(
( ( (
.
( .( (
.S
( : ( .
o
S .
(
S(
.
( S(
.S
(
( ( o
(
( ( ( ()...
( ( (
.(
(
S (
().(
( (
(
424
.
) .( (
( .
) .(
. (
( (
( (.
( (
S (
().(
(
. (
. (
( . ( SS
.
( ( . {
o S (
.
...
^ .
).(
(
( .
( .
425
. (
... : (
S
( ( S
.
().(
( S
(
( (
.
) :
( .
( .
( .
: ) (
.
.
(
( .
( .
( .
(
( .
( .
( .
( .
426
( .
( .
( .
( .
( .
: Y^ o ) Ann Freemantle:
( ( .
( .
( .
( .
( .
( .
( ..
( .
( .
( .
( .
427
428
# :
( .
.
S
.
( S
.
# :
e
.
S
:
:
(
)
(
.
: .
429
( .
(.
# :
.
.
* { {
.
( :(
) ( ) ( ).(
( : ) ( )
( ) ( (
( .
( .
430
de
(
.Y
.
( S
(
(
( .. .
!Y (
S
(
.
t !S Y
!