Development Bank of the Philippines./(PNB-???) vs. Hydro Resources
Contractors Inc. GR 165603, 16561 March 13,2013 -control test, fraud test and harm test ---------------------------------General information sheet- submitted annually; failure to submit shall be a ground for suspension under sec. 22. -Remedy of corp.- Petition to lift the order of suspension -Sec. 72- unpaid shares same rights unless delinquent -defaulting stockholders- when upon call, no payment was made *read on Villanueva and De Leons annotation on pre-emptive rights, WON it extends to treasury shares. -reissued shares- may be below the par value, hence, sec. 65 (watered stocks) is not applicable since it is not originally issued stocks as referred to in sec. 65. -sec. 23 in rel. to sec. 36. -minimum # of shares may be increased provided it is placed in articles of incorporation or by-laws -business judgments should not be interfered by the court; no mandamus will lie -difference bet. Stock corporate declaration and cash dividend declaration Cumulative voting= no. of shares x no. of directors Straight voting= *for directors representing minority- removal should be with lawful cause; for others, may be with or without lawful cause -derivative suit- requirements under interim rules shall be complied, and exhaustion of administrative remedies should be done. It is a cause of action of the corporation instituted by the stockholder. Corporation is the real party, stockholder is the nominal party. *study sec. 32,33,44 *grandfather rule under sec. 44- see as to the type of contract (exploitation of natural resources) *see the validity of the right of preemption by the foreigners?? -by-laws is no necessary for the juridical personality of the corporation *see for the case: failure to submit by-laws converts the de jure to de facto corp. (not a good decision) -in pledge/mortgage-mortgagor has the right to vote, unless there is an agreement -