Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bam 12A
The butterfly analogy in the discussion of Angelas accusation could be
seen as comparing Angela as a butterfly. When Angela blames Nasar of
taking her virginity, Marquez describes her as A butterfly with no will
whose sentence has always been written Butterflys will has been
written, as butterflies grow from caterpillars, acts as a pollinator of
flowers, and produce offsprings, then will die after its job is done, this is
similar to Angela, where her family sets the marriage for her as a honour
to the family which in Columbian culture, this is very important.
Butterflies are also very fragile, which is again, similar to Angela,
because she cannot tell the truth about her virginity.
Marquez also uses pigs as a motif and describes them as low, dirty and
filthy animals that are not worth to live and compares it to Nasar. This
can be seen when Marquez shows the significance to the knives that the
Vicario twins, Pedro and Pablo uses in the murder. The Vicario twins
went to the bin in their pigsty where they kept their sacrificial tools and
picked out the two best knives, one for quartering ten inches long and
two and a half inches wide and the other for trimming, seven inches long
and a half inches wide. They rapped them in a rag and went to sharpen
them at the meat market which is an example of the authors ironic
humor. Marquez also uses this ironic humor while Nasar is being
slaughtered in the murder scene. Trying to finish it once and for all,
Pedro Vicario sought his heart, but he looked for it almost in the armpit,
where pigs have it. This suggests the Vicario brothers cruelty towards
killing Nasar with pig knives and also being killed like a pig as well.
Rabbits are also uses similarly to the pig, Santiago walks into the kitchen
for breakfast where Victoria Guzman had been quartering three rabbits
for lunch and Victoria Guzman couldnt avoid a wave of fright as she
remembered Santiago Nasars horror when she pulled out the insides of
a rabbit by the roots and threw the steaming guts to the dogs. Marquez
did not only foreshadow the killing of Nasar, but he also uses irony to
suggest his violence and cruelty.
Santiago Nasars dogs are also seen as another motif used by Marquez.
Before Victoria Guzman feeds the guts of the rabbits to the dogs, Nasar
told her about her actions Dont be a savage make believe it was a
human being this foreshadows Nasars death. Marquez also uses the
dogs in a similar way after the actual killing, The dogs, aroused by the
smell of death, increased the uneasiness. They hadnt stopped howling
since I went into the house, when Santiago Nasar was still in his death
throes in the kitchen and I found Divina Flor weeping in great howls and
holding them off with a stick. Help me, she shouted to me. What they
want is to eat his guts. Which shoes the irony Marquez tries to create.
Bam 12A
In conclusion, animals such as birds, pigs, rabbits and dogs are uses to
characterize and foreshadow Santiago Nasars character and death,
while the butterfly represents Angela Vicario. Marquez uses this to create
a deeper understanding of each characters comparing them to animal
imagery.