You are on page 1of 23

:

:
: E
: 1115M014
E-mail: takseisithikh@gmail.com
:


H
- .
, 20
1 ,
middle range theories, -
, .
Hegel .
,
, .
(, 1978: . 4)
1970. 1980
1990, , ,
(Wade 1990, Johnson 1982,.Amsden,1989, Johnson, 1999).
, (W.
Bonefeld, J. Holloway, 1993). To (Cerny 1997, Cerny & Evans, 1991)
(Jessop, 2002) (Mazuccato, 2015),
, -
. (Harvey, 2005) (Foucault, 2012),
. ,
,
.
,
, ,
,
, (Bonefeld, Holloway, 1993: 262 .).
,
. , ,
,
,
,
, ,
2.
1

Sozialstaat ( ), Bismarck
. stato sociale .
welfare state ( ). Folkhemmet, ,
, ,
. , .
2
-
, , . , ,

,
.
,
,
.
,

,
, 3.
, , ,
, ,
.


- Hegel,
(Hegel, 2012)4. Hegel 3
:
1. ( -)
2. ( -)
3. ( -)

1.
1 . Hegel, , ,
,
, 5.
, , , , ,
. , , Hegel
100 .
.

, , .
3
, ,
. ,
. ,
, , [ ] .
,
- (Hegel, 2013: 99).
4

Hegel ,
:
-
Hegel , .

. , . Brooks, 2007.

, , , : Knowles, 2002, James, 2007, Rose, 2007, Pelsczynski, 1984.
5
,
, . Mauss, 1999, Sahlins, 2013, Karatani, 2014: 31-56.
20 , , 2008

, -
- , 6

, Hegel (Hegel,
202: . 181). ,
( , .Smith, 2000), :
1. , , -
,
1. . ,
, - 7. ,
8. ,
, ,
,
(Godelier, 1992: 36 ., , Deleuze-Guattari, 1997: 223 .).
, ,
(Hegel, 2012: . 202). ,

: ,
. ,
() , ,
, ,
.

2. -
( )
,
(Notstaat, Verstandstaat)9, (Vernunftstaat)
6


, . Hegel, 2012: . 167, 168).
7
Max Weber Marx-Engels, ,
. Max Weber ,

. In Webers Economy and Society, patrimonialism mainly refers to forms of government that are based
on rulers family-households. The rulers authority is personal-familial, and the mechanics of the household are the model for
political administration (Julia Adams, 2004). Marx-Engels,

.
, . , 1989. , . Anderson, 1992: 476
., Godelier, 1986, : 49-50).
9

, (. )
(Hegel, 2012: . 183). Hegel: 183,
(. Hegel) .
. , ,
... ,
, , ,
, .
, , (J.P Lefebvre,
P. Machere, 2006: 29). , , . (),
, ,
. , () ,
, ,
.

10

. , -
. (
Marx Hegel11)
, , , ,
/
.
Hegel (Hegel, 2012: 188), :
2. . , --, ,
, (. 199),
(. 189). O Hegel ,
( . 201).
Hegel, , , ( 202 .):
1. , -
. , .
-
, - .
2. , , .
.
3. , .
.
Hegel ,
-, .
-
, - ,
(
) . ,
. ( , )

10

(, 2007: 339 ., 381),


Hegel. ,
.
, , , ,
. Hegel, (Vernunft)
(Verstand) , (. ),
,
-.
11
O Marx Hegel :
, ,
, .
(Marx, ,
1978: 95). Hegel ,
,
- (., 1978:36,37) . Marx-Engels ,
, ,
. Hegel Marx
, MacGregor,1985: 195 .

( ).
12.
, ) - (
, , ) ) ( ) ,
,
) - .
2.
. , (. 183). )
-. 211, ) - . 215 )
-. 219
. ,
, -13.
2. , -,
( ) , ,
(Hegel, . 231 .).
,
,
.
.
-,
. ,
, ,
14. , Hegel
, ,
, , ,

(Hegel, 2012: . 245-248). , ,
,
. ,
- ,
,
. , Hegel
Marx-Engels-Lenin15
12

,

. , ,
, . ., 2008. J.Schumpeter, 1954.
13
. . 5. Hegel, - ,
.
, , , ,
. ,
( ). - ()
, . Hegel, 2005: . 195, 201). ,
. Hegel -, . Ross, 2008.
14
-,
(, 1991: 185). - ,
Hegel (Hegel, 2005: 431 .). Hegel,
,
, .
. ,
,
,
. .
15
, . McGregor, ..

, ,
,
16
: )
( , , ,
) ) - (
, , ) ) - (
- --).

3. (Hegel, 2012: . 257)


Hegel, ,
, (Hegel, 2012: . 257 .). , Hegel
, 17,
- , .
- -,
18
, / :
) , (1)
(2). ,
, .
(Hegel, 2012: . 271).
) -
[] .
) -
( ).

31. (Hegel, 2012: . 272 .)


16

Marx 7 1858, Engels


. Kautsky 12 1882, Engels
: ;
. ,

(Lenin, 2012 , .30: 170-171). ,
,
, , (Lenin, 1988, .27:
409).
17
- Hegel, , , Kojin Karatani, 2014 Werner,
2008.
- ,
- .
18
, . Hegel, 2012: . 263, . 269, . 276. Hegel
() (Hegel, 2005: 443 .).
, ()
,
, . , , . ,
- . .
, , ,
(Hegel, 2012: . 238).
(. -) , ,
( . 268).

-
, . (
), ( )
:
)
)
) , o
status 19.
, ,

,
- , , (Hegel, 2012: . 299-.
6).

32.

(Hegel, 2012: . 321 .)

,
.
, .
/ . Hegel,
. ,
,
, -
.
, ,
20.

(. 327, ). , ,
. , ,
,
, ,
. , Marx-Engels,
(F.Engels, 2013: 212). ,

.
, ,

19

Hegel, Carl Schmitt,


, ,
, ,
, (Hegel, 2012: . 280).
,
. ,
,
.
20

, , ,
, , ,
,
(Hegel, . 324).

3. (Hegel, 2012: 330)


,
, 21.
- ,
,
, , (Hegel, 2012:
. 332). (
), , ,
, ,
(. 333)22.
, Hegel
(. 337).

3.
, ,
,
, - -
.
/-
23. Hegel,
, ,
,
.

21

,
. , ,
o , , , (
), .
,
(Hegel,
2012: 331)
22
Hegel , . 339
,
. ,
, ., ,
, , ,
, . , .,
, -,
-, . , .
, -
.
23

Theodor Adorno []
. ,
,
. (T.Adorno, 2006: 409 .).
Hegel ,
-
, . -
, -
, , Adorno,
Hegel -.

( ) ,
, Martin Wight.

Machiavelli , , ,
.
, ,
.

- .
) :
, (. Hegel, 3).
) :
: (. Hegel, 3).
) , : ,
,
( )
- (. Hegel, 3).
[...]
.
,

(Wight, 1998: 9, ).

-
Hegel , - :
: , (. 1), :

(. 2), :
, - , -,
( 2), :
, - (. 3)24.

24

O Marx Hegel
1857-1858, (Marx,
1990: 385 .). , ( ), -
. -
, - - Hegel.
, Marx Hegel: (
Hegel), - ,
. ( ),
Hegel, .
Marx Hegel, ,
, -. Marx
Hegel, -
. , ,
. -,
- . . Hobsbawm, 1982: ,

: ,
, - .

,
, , Hegel,
, -
, .
, /
( -), ( ),
- , . O Hegel
1821, ,
, .

, Marx
,

.25
Hegel,
. Hegel,

,
[]
,
,
,
(Hegel, 2012: . 360). Deleuze-Guattari,
26: :
,
. , ,
(Deleuze- Guattari: 1977, 257-258).
,
. ) ,
/ - ,
) ,
() , ( ), , )
.
. , ,
,
.


25

, status quo
, status quo ancien regime ancient regime
.
, (Marx, 1978: 20).
26
Deleuze Guattari, . Deleuze-Guattari, 1987 :424 .
, Hegel (:460)
,
,
. Hegel, .
http://bestimmung.blogspot.gr/2014/12/deleuze-guattari-thousand-plateaus.html

() ,
.
,

. ,
, , ,
, .
1991, Angus Maddison, N.D Kondratieff,
S.Kuznets, Ernest Mandel J.A. Schumpeter , , 8
27,
4 ,
(1518 ): 1820-1913, 1913-1950, 1950-1973, 1973 . 1913-1950, 1950-1973
(1913-1973),
( 2), .

1. (15-18 )

14 15
.
; 16 ,
. ,
,
, (P.Anderson, 1986: 11).
, , , , ,
, , , ,
( ). Perry Anderson,
(.
, ).
, ,
. ,
.
,
(P.Anderson, 1986: 195). ,
: ) 28 ,
,
, )

27

Rate of growth of output, output per head, capital stock and export volume, cyclical variations in output and exports, levels of
unemployment, and rate of price increase (Maddison,1991)
28
Hobsbawm O 1789 ,
. , ,
, 90 97%.
, : 85% , 72-80% , 90%
, . , ,
,
. ,
1851. Hobsbawm, 1992: 24

29,
, ) -
--o ,
(P.Anderson, 1986: 32-33) ) , ,
, (Strayer,
2012, Van Creveld: 151 .) . ,
-,
,
, ,
( , )
(- ).

2, 2. - (1820-1913)

,
, ,
, , .
19 , ,
, , (Hobsbawm, 1992: 11,46, 83,
Gellner 1992: 43 ). - ,
/, .
, ,
1815 1848,
-30. , 1820-1824,
- (1820), (1820), (1821), - ,
, -, . 1829-1834-
(1830), (1830-1831), (1829), , ,
.
. , 1848, ()
, , ,
(1847). , ,
, , , . , 1789
, . (1815-1830)
,
. A
, 31

29

- ,
patriomonialism ax Weber (. . 4), Julia Adams, 2005. H Adams,
(1581-1795),

, -
.
30
, . Hobsbawm, 1992: 161 .
31
19 . , ,
. ,
, . , ,
. , [] 19
, : 1815-1914. -
-, , , , ,

,
.
.
, ,
.
, . , , .

. . ,
, .
.
19 , ,
(Polanyi, 2007: 72).
, ,
(Polanyi, 2007: 73-76).

, ,
, .
, Macpherson,
17 , , ,
,
(Macpherson, 1986: 15).
. ,
, Hobbes,
,
. ,
- John Locke
. Jeremy Bentham, ,
Hobbes, John Stuart Mill

(Macpherson, 1986, 1994). Hobbes , Harrington,
Locke , ,
Adam Smith

,
. ,
, ,
,
,
.
, ,
-, ( ),
, , .
, ,
/ / .

18 (Polanyi, 2007: 9, 11). Polanyi , 19 ,


,
.

, ,
- 19 ,
. Piketty32:
19 10% (
7-8%),
(, , , , ..),
, , ,
. ,
, . . -
1-2% .

2. - (1913-1973)
laissez-faire,
, J.M.Keynes
laissez-faire
, Zeitgeist , ,
(J.M.Keynes, 1926). Polanyi,
1914,
.
,
-
,
(Polanyi, 2007: 130, 131). , ,
, Speenhamland ,
,
,
. , ,

. 19 20 ,
,
1917
,
-. Michel Foucault
1914-1970
- , 4 : , ,
, . ,
,
New Deal (Foucault, 2012).
Hobson Hilferding
(Lenin, 2009, Arrighi, 1989) ,
, , - . -

(
) ,
. , Lenin
(Lenin, 2009 :
) Negri-Hardt
32

Piketty , . Piketty,
2014: 588-594.

,
-. Negri-Hardt

33.
, ,
-. laissez-faire - ,
19 ,
,
,
, (
status quo) 34.
, . (. 14)
, ,
, -
, .

, . -
,
.

, )
, )
) "" -
)
management ) management
, )
35

-,
Hegel ,
Piketty - :
[] 1920-1930 1970-1980
,
.
.

34

The period after 1871 had, after all, also seen a growing State intervention and a socialization of the mode of production.
What was new, and what marks this moment as decisive, was the recognition of the emergence of the working class and of the
ineluctable antagonism it represented within the system as a necessary feature of the system that State power would have to
accommodate.Too often (and not only in Italy with the limited perspective that Fascism allowed), the novelty of the new State that
emerged from the great crisis has been defined in terms of a transition from a "liberal" to a "totalitarian" form of State
power.This is a distorted view. It mistakes the immediate and local recourse to fascist and corporatist solutions, the form of
regime, for the central, overriding feature that distinguishes the new historical form of the capitalist State: the reconstruction of a
State based on the discovery of the inherent antagonism of the working class: To be sure, this reconstruction has possible
totalitarian implications, but only in the sense that it involved an awareness of intrinsic antagonism and struggle at all levels of
the State (Negri-Hardt, 1994: 27-28).
35

, , , , :

http://www.theseis.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=768&Itemid=29.
Gramsci 1930
.

:
, (. 32).
Espring-Andersen,
, -, -
()- 36.
-,
, Andersen
-
(Andersen, 2006: 125). -
( , )
, , .
Andersen
, - , -
.

3.
, -
- ,
, , (. 3).
,
:
1. ,
37, ,
.
, ,
, ,
- -
.
2. , a posteriori a priori
( ) , , -, , ()
. , - ,
-- -. (),
, /
, .

(
).

36

-
, . Andersen, 2006: 164. , ,
.
37
(J.Rifkin, 2012) ,
46 Forum
. ,
, , -
.

3. , , ,
, --,
. , ,

4. - , - -
, -, ,
-, ,
-. -
, , ,

. -- -

.

, - (1),
, -.
, (2),
, ---,
,
, - (2). ,
,
- (2),
: ( )
( ).
, ,
.
,
,
-.
, - /
( 3).
. , ,
- .
Carl Schmitt ,
. 18
( ) 19 , 20 .
, 19 ,
- ( ), ,
19 (Schmitt, 2009: 53).
, - ,
Hegel (Schmitt, 2001: 31). -
Schmitt,
, . )

. , ,
, - . -
, ,
,
,
.
/
, , ,
o .


,
, , 38
,
. .

1820-1913

15-18

(19 )

(20 )

1973

->

(-
), 1)

/

(-, 2)


/

(-, 2)

,
,

( ,
3,,)

1913-1973

1913-1945

1945-1973

(21 ).

38

Foucault, , ,
, , -
. - - .
, : ratio , ,
, , (Foucault, 2012: 18).

, .
, , Guteberg, 2008.
, , , , , 1991.
, - , , 1989.
, 20 , , 2008.
, , , 2007.
Andersen, Gosta-Espring, , ,
, 2006
Anderson, Perry, , , , 1986.
Bonefeld W, Holloway J (.), , , 1993.
Deleuze, Gilles- Guattari, Felix, : -, .
, , , 1977
Engels Friedrich, , , , 2013.
Foucault, Michel, , (1978-1979),
, , 2012
Gellner, Ernest, , , , 1992
Godelier, Maurice, , , Gutenberg, 1992.
Hegel G.W.F, , -- , ,
2012.
Hegel G.W.F, - , , --
, , 2013.

Hegel G.W.F, - , --
, , 2005.
Hobsbawm ric, 1789-1848, , , 1992.
Hobsbawm, Eric, , ., , 1982
Lefebvre, J.P, Machere, P., , , , 2006.
Lenin V.I., , .27, , 1988.
Lenin V.I, , .30, , 2012.
Lenin, V.I, , , 2012.
Lenin, V.I, - , , 2009
Macpherson, C.B, , , ,
1994.
Marx, Karl, , ,
, 1978.
Marx, Karl, , , ,1978.
Marx, Karl, Grundrisse- , 1857-1858,
, ., , 1990.
Marcel Mauss, , - , , 1999
Marshall Sahlins, , , 2013.
Mazuccato, Marianna, , , , 2015.
Pelczynski, Z.A. (editor), The State and Civil Society, Cambridge University Press, 1984.
Piketty, Thomas, 21 , , , 2014.
Polanyi, Karl, , , , 2007.
Rifkin, Jeremy, , , 2012
Smith Antony, , , , 2000.

Schmitt, Carl, , , , 2009.


Strayer, Joseph, , , , 2012.
Wight, Martin, - , , , 1998
Hobsbawm, Eric, , ., , 1982
Van Creveld, Martin, , ,
. , 2003.

Adams, Julia, The Rule of the Father: Patriarchy and Patrimonialism in Early Modern Europe, Max Weber at the
Milennium: Economy and Sociology for the Twenty-First Century (eds. Charles Camic, Philip Gorski and David
Trubek), Stanford University Press, 2004.
Adams, Julia, The Familial State-ruling families and merchant capital in early modern Europe, Cornell University
Press, 2005.
Amsden, Alice, 1989, Asia's Next Giant: South Korea and Late Industrialization.New York, NY: Oxford University
Press.
Arrighi, Giovanni, The Geometry of Imperialism-The limits of Hobsons paradigm, 1987
Brooks, Thom, Hegels Political Philosophy-A systematic reading of the philosophy of right, Edinburg University
Press, 2007.
Cerny, Philip G. (1997). Paradoxes of the Competition State: The Dynamics of Political Globalization, Government
and Opposition, 32, pp 251-274.
Cerny, Philip G, Evans, Mark, The Competitive State, Villa Colombella Papers on Competitive Politics, edited by
Albert Gianluigi Galeotti, Pierre Salmon, Ronald Wintrobe. New Labour, Globalization, and the Competition State,
Center for European Studies Working Paper Series #70, 1991.
Chalmers Johnson, The Developmental State: Odyssey of a Concept, Chapter Two Woo-Cumings, Meredith ed.
(1999) The Developmental State. Cornel, CA: Cornel University Press
Deleuze-Guattari, Capitalism and Schizofrenia-A Thousand Plateaus, translation by Brian Massumi, University of
Minnesota Press, 1987.
Harvey, David A brief history of neoliberalism, Oxford, 2005.
James, David, Hegels Philosophy of Right-Subjectivity and Ethical Life, Continuum, 2007.
Johnson, Chalmers A, 1982. MITI and the Japanese Miracle: the Growth of Industrial Policy, 1925-1975. Stanford,
Calif.: Stanford University Press.
Jessop, Bob, The Future of Capitalist State, Polity, 2002.
Karatani, Kojin, The Structure of World History: From modes of production to modes of exchange, 2014, translated by
Michael K. Bourdaghs, Duke University Press Durham and London, 2014 .
Knowles, Dudley, Routledge Philosophy Guidebook to Hegel and the Philosophy of Right, Routledge, 2002.
Maddison, Angus, Business Cycles, Long Waves and Phases of Capitalist Development (abbreviated version of
chapter 4 of A. Maddison, Dynamic Forces in Capitalist Development, Oxford University Press, 1991)
McGregor, David, The Communist Ideal in Hegel and Marx, University of Toronto Press, 1984
Negri, Antonio - Hardt, Michael, Labour of Dionysus-critique of State-form, University of Minnesota, 1994
Ross, Nathan, On Mechanism in Hegels Social and Political Philosophy, Routledge, 2008.

Schmitt, Carl, State, Movement, People-the triadic structure of the political unity, edited, translated and with
a preface by Simona Draghici, Plutarch Press, 2001
Schumpeter, Joseph, The Crisis of the Tax State, International Economic Papers, 1954, no 4, New York,
Macmillan.

Wade, Robert, 1990, Governing the Market: Economic Theory and the Role of Government in Taiwan's
Industrialization. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
Werner, Laura-Love at the Heart of the State: Hegel on public-spiritedness, family and political life, 2008.