os sss ‘Ther btvten cow ct os pcp othe owe bball, ad {ie tether anyone ei ars beter rau reject a erate fi ‘Spee Scr os inv se edt oman sly ote Sree wo her can an awa it's nt poole for wt to jac wat we dot any animal ds it Incapatie of undenunting ont pata jutieaton td strpting or Jretng Moni otal animale cape i pling ov a abate weatmant. Since they cance undone Sd the cannot ae the Fann or a ga cng et, ey ‘not resnahly rect any prinle, Whereas needy enon ad ‘euonbly jet os rile that he ich ul he the mo a ay ‘Sco det ace fp 8) a ponte or contrac oie. ‘hare fv bigalns march ia ve ae hat we Be thle co jut or actor the, we dente tes toe rl ing on bea oft inl cro, He des ae neue wh ve weve andthe dition corsa ese oe eto sbi afb It iapparenty aed imply tad an uated pation, ‘athe than flowing fe he cee ofthe they, thse ting hat ‘edo ther cn maa sry eto he ane sel t oh Sean ce har ee ee ep ner what happens to them. But be thinks chat here may be ‘Sere, whith arent aed of nrc duty to Wes thn ‘Senrdance wi pepe wtih thy cou ot esnay re, He eal ‘hero contrat prt the hry ory he nd ee Scanlon 8h) dei pain a ometing tate have rn ft reason preven, an rong reson uo eau He cae it ‘eon moral ing oe inlet o nial fn, and tt here ‘imal cree pai, in cede wo teat comme, or example. Bu be does nt “cm moray in he bro ein ay eta i Wh We Ge a (te Foe the few rents he does mae inlet what he thinks hou tow rent © pret the ae se aria sho be LUIATARISIN.CORTRACTUNLIN SOINNSONMESS ay fhoeve, serps dcon betwen iting td lowing pa ring thaw have roger eon ot case pln han to reve So event rbd moral eon ne todo fret ania wove comparable ‘demining ew Bec the a of dealin th part of hear, i eto ny veal ow Senko thesy compart nth train th red 0 or des asinas Moray the aro sea, orrcalon el ‘acy mc on demanding we owe no omar et arma LU Alctdinge moaiy inthe bod see, we dove mera sonst {Sanna to eso ep them am aS es ngent S SS reaonable co conte ta Seals evra hry comer ‘lamang wih repre aia tn wenn ‘Selon has oie ita however, Hi thay io rile hee to asop oly the road seve ar well coma Tien seme” More pray, he scons ale rates teak some nomrasenal crete, aot, hve ho ae ban for example himan tle, tu ot rote m-uman ones Hs dee that we Wt ot uae to al hana, heb my ae cab of ‘peg or roma the tration" I Sut ha he ea jy ‘ire veseent te bf pei. He ay lay be ved ‘Sooo citer Unt ve ve ove demanding igen salam he evr acep ors dean gas seal ans “Tse poles soy sage tha very ard to ese a appa ing eal tery which aes oper arcana the tere fara nn nn iy he ‘ke edo deel tarnishing tht conracrain i at ‘ea ely brdcene, Bt bret ersten gto oncy sh fly ase the coer gs cna: tend ‘craig te tl demands ofeach hay, he wei a eo om rai di to oes gst ony» ati our wan iso Soin "Th demandingz eco twtr mace dar ong when our sblghins wal net cers ae en no sco Te pobicm ot reohed by ret ac-etbarani sour ofre coment, fer thoi yo doe demanding gens {Elsner hay, satan vag oe ey neds ‘Ss we hae to cer people ar lad epnh bu our pte elton ceed eer as sw hc ere vente ple he ee ot tnt peopl co tara? cet they ake he were of etal ‘sy to conequece te se iced oak the demanding tesco th thay wry set ate Cale, Osi ene Sheng Cen eg Sec Both tnd he Sh THE VICE OF SNOBHERY; AESTHETIC KNOWLEDGE, JUSTIFICATION AND VIRTUE IN ART APPRECIATION Apes ayn tin ii of a foe Seat ciara tera tte te nate, place lal le leprae seem aaa a at at Saco et ceo ts lh a a pr ai spp nao ene cs |. CHARACTERIZING SNOBBERY {ei mportnt ht ing po comin with ving ble i ‘otal ote cncepe tbe at atement at be in rer. Soar can ad do et ated jenn igh Nevers ete ‘omoningnt connects ween upg of bey ad sspecting ‘Sat aurecasndenproper esi spyesiaten ay Sgr Sigpnewme cote rakes ake Ilys # mack of ood eae Thy scour cl ale ant go only plat wing the brand (hiring {© Starts Thi my mack oly bt eed not longa ‘behaves ideally, but ther appreciation ofthe coffee = eeten by socal fev In cute he Bt he cae pay being append fat biases Uy cafe, Why? Thee people deseo be end of erwom sia wih be ran I ea mark emf thir inde {etme of ters at beg on otf penton rather than aniter The Pienrenan theme in mere primates cae, Syke ft Wether oat ring sik depend ow a ro Wp apprecen IS judgment Ua work artsy eno payiamanre