,

, ' ,

,

13 2012 N 4336-VI,
5 2012 N 5080-VI,
6 2012 N 5178-VI,
27 2014 N 794-VII,
14 2014 N 1702-VII,
2 2015 N 222-VIII,
9 2015 N 329-VIII
:
I. :
1. ( ,
1984 ., N 51, . 1122):
1) 148 5 "" "
, ' "
;
2) 188 7:
:
" 188 7. ,
' ";
" '
'" " ,
' ", "
'" ;
3) 188 21 "
" " ,
";
4) 188 29:
"
" " ,
";
"
" ""
" , "
" ";

5) 188 30 "
" "
";
6) 188 36 "
" " ,
" ;
7) 243 :
" 243. , '

, '
, '
, ' ( 144,
145, 147, 148 1 - 148 5 188 7).
, '
,
,
";
8) 244 15 "
" " ,
" ;
9) 244 16 :
" 244 16. ,

, ,
, '
,
( 166 13), ,
( 188 29).
,
,
, ,
";
10) 244 17:
" "
" "
;
" " "
";
11) 244 18 "
" " ,
" ;
12) 255:
1 :
" ' ( 144 - 148 5, 164 ( ,
'), 188 7"

" '" " ,

' ";
" ( 163 12)"
" " "
";
18 "
" " ,
".
2. 110 (
, 2003 ., NN 40 - 44, . 356) "
" "
".
3. ( , 2003 ., NN 18 - 22,
. 144):
166 " "
" ";
350 "
" " ,
".
4. ( , 2011 ., NN 13 - 17, .
112):
1) 39.9 39 "
" " ,
";
2) 154.8 154 "
" " ,
";
3) 156.1.3 156.1 156 "
"
" ,
";
4) 159.2.1 159.2 159 "

" " ,
,
";
5) 160.6 160 "
", "
" " "
" ,
", " " " ";
6) ' 170.2.6 170.2 170
" "
" ".
5. 37 " "
( , 1991 ., N 29, . 377; ,
1999 ., N 7, . 49; 2006 ., N 15, . 129) "

 "
" , ".
6. 5 " " (
, 2006 ., N 7, . 84) " "
" ".
7. " " ( ,
1991 ., N 49, . 682 ) "
" "
" .
8. 25 " " (
, 1993 ., N 52, . 490; 2011 ., N 10, . 63):
" " "
";
- " "
" ".
9. 70 " " (
, 2006 ., N 18, . 155) " '"
" , '
".
10. 1 2 "
" ( , 1994 ., N 11,
. 50; 1999 ., N 4, . 35; 2002 ., N 33, . 236; 2003 ., N 29, . 233; 2004 ., N 22, . 314;
2006 ., N 14, . 116; 2009 ., N 36 - 37, . 511) "
" "
".
11. " " ( , 2004 ., N 8, . 62;
2006 ., N 31, . 268; 2008 ., N 18, . 197; 2010 ., N 34, . 486):
1) ' ,
' 25 " "
" "
;
2) 26 "
" "
".
12. 21 "
" ( , 1996 ., N 41, . 188; 1998
., N 48, . 293) "
"
"
".
13. " " (
, 1996 ., N 51, . 292; 2005 ., N 42, . 466; 2011 ., N 10, . 63):
1) 6 :
" 6.
()
, ,
.


.

,
.

.
, ,

.

.

.


.

, .

.

.

.

.
,
.
,
.
.

, (, ) ,
.

.

. /
.

, '
', ,
', ,
, .


, .

.

'
.
:
1) ;
2) ;
3) , '
;
4) , ,
,
;
5)
;
6) ,
;
7) ;
8) ;
9) ,
;
10)
;
11)
;
12) , , ;
13)
, , ;
14)
;
15) ;
16) ;
17) .

'
.

, .
, , '
, ,
, ', .


() ' .
, .
-
- ,
.
-
";
2) 9:
:
" ";
' ;
3) 12 "
" "
";
4) 18 " " "";
5) " "
"
" .
14. 16 18 "
" ( , 1997 ., N 17, . 122; 2000 ., N 33 34, . 273) " "
" ".
15. 2 "" 28 " "
( , 1997 ., N 24, . 170; 2010 ., N 49, . 571)
" "
" , ".
16. " " ( , 1998 ., N
1, . 1; 2000 ., N 38, . 321):
1) 11 :
" ,
, " ";
2) " "
" ,
" .
17. 17
( '

10.12.97 . N 710/97-
06.07.2012 . N 5178-VI)
18. " " ( , 2000 ., N
30, . 238 ):
1) 3:
" ", " ", "
'" " " ;

 " " "

";
2) 4:
:
" 4. , '
";
:
" " " ";
' ;
3) 8 " "
" ";
4) 9:
" "
" " "
";
", " ",
";
5) 11:
:
" " ;
:
" , ,
. ,
. ,
, .
, () ,
";
- :
"2. .
,
.

.
.
,
. ,
. ,
.
:
1) ;
2) ;
3) , '
;

4) , ,
, ;
5)
;
6) ,

;
7) ;
8) ;
9) ,
;
10)
;
11) , , ;
12)
, ,
;
13)
;
14) ;
15) ;
16) .
3. , .
/ .
.

. ,
,
4. , ,
' ', ,
',
, , .
, ,
.
,
.

' ";
6) 11 1 :
" 11 1. ,
1. , , (,
) ,
.

2. , '
' , ,
";
7) 14 " " "-
";
8) 15:
:
" . ,
.
,
.
, - , '
,
( )
. , , ,
, ".
' - ' - ;
' " " "(
)";
9) 15 1 :
" 15 1.
1. .
2. -
.
3. , ,
- '
.
4. , ,
' '
, .
5. - ,
.
.
6. ,
, , - , ,
, .
7. -
1 , ";
10) 16 :
" 16.
1.
.
2. , ,
,

 ,
";
11) V 16 1 :
" 16 1. -
1.
. .
2. - ,
' ,
' , ,
, , , , ";
12) 4 V " " .
19. 12 " ,
" (
, 2000 ., N 35, . 279) "
" " ".
20. 20 I
( '

01.06.2000 . N 1775-III
02.03.2015 . N 222-VIII)
21. 21

( '
15.03.2001 . N 2299-III
05.07.2012 . N 5080-VI)

22. " " ( ,

2001 ., N 24, . 128) " "
" "
.
23. " " (
, 2001 ., N 29, . 137) "
" " ,
".
24. "
" ( , 2002 ., N 1, . 1 ):
1) 12 1 ;
2) 23 24 :
" 23. ,

1. ,
, , ,
.
2. ,
,
- ,
.
3. .
,
.

 , ,

.
4. ,
, , (,
) ,
.
,
, .
5. ,
, .
/ ,
, .
6. ,
, ,
' ', ,
',
, , .
,
, ,
.
,
,
.
,
,
' .
7. ,
, , ,
.
,
, ,
.
,
, ,
. ,
, .
8. ,
, .
,
, .
, ,
,
, .
, ,
,
, , .

9. ,
, , .
, ,

, ,
.
,
, .
10. ,
, - ,
,
, / ,
. -
,
.
24. ,

1. ,
, , .
2. ,
:
1) ,
,
, ,
, ,
, ;
2) ,
, , ;
3) ,
,
;
4) , , ;
5) ,
,
;
6) ,
;
7)
;
8) ,
, ";
3) 25 26 ;
4) 28 :
"2. , ,
,

 '
";
5) 37 :
" ,
, '
, ";
6) 42 " , ,
"
", ,
, ,
";
7) ' 43 : "
, ,

, , ,
, ";
8) , 2 7 VIII " ",
" ", "
", "
"
" , "
, " "
- " "
.
25. " '" ( , 2002 ., N 6,
. 39):
1) 7 ' 8 "( - )" ;
2) " '"
"" " ,
' " .
26. 8 " " (
, 2002 ., N 15, . 101) "
" "
, ".
27. " " (
, 2002 ., N 16, . 112; 2010 ., N 49, . 571):
1) 11:
" " "
";
:
"
,
";
2) 13 "
" " ,
".

28. " " ( , 2003 ., N 31 - 32, . 263

) " "
" "
.
29. 21 " " (
, 2003 ., N 38, . 313; 2006 ., N 13, . 110) "
" "
".
30. " " (
, 2003 ., N 47 - 48, . 372), XII " ",
" ", "
"
" " " ,
" .
31. " ' "
( , 2003 ., NN 49 - 51, . 376) "
" "
" "
" " ,
" .
32. " -
" ( , 2003 ., N
52, . 377) "
" " "
" ,
" "
" .
33. " ,
" ( , 2004 ., N 1,
. 1; 2005 ., N 10, . 196; 2006 ., N 13, . 110; 2010 ., N 34, . 486, N 46, . 539),
50, " ", "

" "
"
" " " ,
" .
34. " " ( , 2004 ., N 12,
. 155 ):
1) III :
" III
";
2) 10 15 "()" ;
3) 16 " " " "
" " " ";
4) 17 :
" 17.

1. ,
' .
2. , ' ,
, ,
.
3. , '
, .
4. , ' ,

, ,
' .
, ,
' ";
5) 19:
;
:
" " "
, ' ,
";
7 " " " ,
' ";
6) 19 1:
" ( )"
" , '
";
" "
" ,
' ,
";
:
"6.
, '
";
" " "
, '
, ";
7) 20 22 :
" 20. , ,
'
1. , ' ,
.
, ' ,

.

 , ' ,

.
2. ,
' , , (,
) ,
.
, '
, ,
, ', ,
,
- ,
.
,
' , .
/ .
3. , '
:
1) ,
' , ,
, ,
' ;
2) ,
' , , ;
3) , '
,
' , ;
4) ,
' ;
5) , , ;
6) ,
' ,
;
7) , ,
' ;
8) ,
;
9)
;
10) ,
, ' .
4. , '
, ,
' ', ,
',
, , .

 ,
' , ,
.
,
' ,
.
,
' ,
' .
5. , '
, .
, '
, .
6. ,
' , ,
.
, '
, ,
.
7. , '
, .
.
, '
, - , '
.
8. , ' ,
, , - ,
' ,
, , ',
.
9. , ' ,
, .
10. - ,
' , ,
, ,
, '
.
,
' , .
, ' ,
,
' , .
, ' ,
,
' , ";
" 22. ,
'

1. , ' ,
.
2. ,
' , -
.
3. , '
, . ,
, ,
'
, ,
' .
4. , ' ,
,
, , - , ,
, .
5. , ' ,
- 1 ,
";
8) 22 1 22 2 :
" 22 1. ,
'
1. ,
' , .
22 2. -
, '
1. , ' ,

. .
2. , ' ,
- ,
'
, , , , ";
9) 5 55 " "
" ,
' , ";
10) 69 :
"3. , ,
,
, '
";
11) " ' ()",
" '" "", ""
" , '
" .
35. " - " ( ,
2004 ., N 47, . 514; 2010 ., N 40, . 524, N 49, . 571):

1) II " " " ";

2) 5:
" " "
";
"
" " ,
";
" "
" ,
" ;
3) 14:
1 " , , ,
, ";
" " "
, ,
";
4) 31:
:
" / , '
, ,
, ,
, ,
( ), ()
";
" " "
" " ,
" " ,
".
36. " " (
, 2004 ., N 48, . 526 ):
1) 6:
:
2 " ' ( - )"
" , '
", " ' ( - )" ;
3 "" " ,
' ", "" ;
4 " " "
, '
, ";
2) IV :
" IV

";

3) 12:
" " " ";
:
"2.
, ' ,
" ";
4) 13 " " " "
" " "
";
5) 14:
:
2 1 2 2 :
"2 1) ,
;
2 2)

";
21 " " ;
6) 15 ;
7) 16 "
" " ,
' ";
8) 18:
:
" " "
, '
, ";
8 " " " ,
' ";
" (
)" " ,
' ";
" "
" ,
' , ";
9) ' 29:
1 2 :
"1) ,
' , '
;
2) ,
' , '

, ";

 3 "" " ,
' , ";
10) 38:
5 " " "
, '
, ";
" " "
, '
, ";
11) 45:
3 :
"3)
, ' ,
,
' , ";
4 " / " " ,
' ";
12) 56 :
"6. ,
' ,
";
13) , 7 IX " ", "" ""
" , '
" .
37. 1.10 1 " ' -
" (
, 2005 ., N 1, . 1) "
" " ,
".
38. 38
( '

12.01.2005 . N 2319-IV
13.01.2012 . N 4336-VI)
39. "
() " (
, 2005 ., N 20, . 278; 2011 ., N 10, . 63):
1) 8 "

" " ,
,
";
2) " "
" ,
" .
40. " " ( , 2005
., N 28, . 373), VIII " ", "

 ", "
" "
, ", "
, " .
41. 3 "
" ( , 2005 ., N 32, . 421; 2009 ., N 29, .
394) "
" " ,
".
42. 1 "
" ( , 2005 ., N 48, . 483; 2010 .,
N 13, . 128, N 46, . 547; , 7 2011 N
3204-VI) " " "
".
43. " ,
- " ( , 2005 .,
N 33, . 430) " "
" ,
" .
44. " " ( , 2006 ., N
16, . 134, N 31, . 268):
1) 8 27 "
"
" ,
" ;
2) " "
" "
.
45. 18 " '
" ( , 2006 ., N 30, . 258)
" ' "
" , '
".
46. " " (
, 2006 ., N 31, . 268), VII " ",
" "
" " .
47. 9 " " (
, 2006 ., N 34, . 291) "
" "
".
48. 13 " " (
, 2006 ., N 44, . 432) "
, "
" ,
, ".

49. " ' " (

, 2006 ., N 46, . 456; , 23
2010 N 2856-VI):
1) 11 1 "
" " ,
";
2) 12 " "
" ".
50. 1 " ()
" ( , 2007 ., N 29, . 389;
2010 ., N 38, . 510) " " "
".
51. " " ( ,
2008 ., N 50 - 51, . 384), XVII " ",
" "
" " .
52. " () " (
, 2009 ., N 40, . 578) "
" " ,
" .
53. 53 I
( '

28.11.2002 . N 249-IV
14.10.2014 . N 1702-VII)
54. 54 I

( '
08.07.2010 . N 2467-VI
09.04.2015 . N 329-VIII)

55. "
" ( , 2010 ., N 49, . 571; 2011 ., N 10, . 63):
1) :
"
";
2) 2 :
" 2.
1. ,
.
2. ,
, " ";
3) 7 - 9, 12, 13 ;
4) 11 "
" "
" " ,
" ;
5) 18 "
"

 " ,
, ";
6) 19 " " ;
7) "
" " "
" ,
" " ,
" .
56. III ,
" " ( ,
1998 ., N 27 - 28, . 182), :
" ,
' ,
" ".
57. 57
( '

07.10.2010 . N 2591-VI
27.02.2014 . N 794-VII)
58. "" 6 3 21
1993 N 7-93 " " ( , 1993 ., N
13, . 113; 1995 ., N 30, . 229; 1999 ., N 25, . 211; 2004 ., N 25, . 353; 2009 ., N 31, .
456) :
"
- 0,1
,
'
, 1
".

II.
1. , .
2. -
, .
3. ,
, ' ,
,
. ,
, ' ,
,
.
4. :

;
- .

.
7 2011
N 3610-VI