Professional Documents
Culture Documents
生命の起源―5つの大切な質問
生命の起源―5つの大切な質問
&0@,
0
&0@,
1
2
3
4
5
1+0J-(T@%!0
9*,,+g@-M0
Q!!#0E1+K5!0
;(01H0NK!0
!8TM01J-(M*
7
DNA
L
5 2010
WATCH TOWER BIBLE AND TRACT SOCIETY OF PENNSYLVANIA
All Rights Reserved
U
IL
Z0
jo 1QQTC@ ? G%*A@ #I+ M
N0-&(!*O) ZT
S E
)0 E
"
S
S
S
)E ,)
E
!
"
S E )
#$ S
S
E
)1%
%E
&'()!
S
S E `
2E %
!E
S E13E4
(
a
S L 58B59M
E `a
*E
2)
E
-
S
E .
"%
(-2S
Z0
1+0J-(T@%!0
<#EU1+K5!0 S
O /(T+ %*
!*L@
i1+@! 00,!0Fi0L-DJL@
T1K v((000DT#%!DN@U DM*
*T!DN@U )D W+D1%L!-,%(M!C-
N1 <#EUJ@)0TVK,N2,L@U
<#EU+K5!T!K,0J,Z@ D%*g,
&@L1+K5!*-&(!K,0)
00P,DThM+) Q!!#01
QL@ )1
1+0J-(T@%!0)I
Z
!
S )E
S
) )E
E
"S
E L1* r s
!)S
LE %E ; 5
S %
h'ES
5S . )
%E
!
S 6>><)E
6789:;U<=79,
0>1
S 9>E `
>
)
?
#L1% S
0
)5
@4#% aS5
|
A.
)2
E ;*
.S 3E
)
S E
32C4
S )E
!)S
DS
)$E #)
$%&'(
E S E
aS6
I9J8S E
RNA )1( S RNA
E
E %2 W87FX:
)2E D.
S W87FX:6KM;
E 6KM-#S ST
)2S
+)E `W87FX
!)
@E 5=97)" 4
S I97ULUKL
E
)
)E I9J8
6KM
S
5T
)E 6KM2
S
E
( 17)E
S
NOP8+Q
RUST+
S `
KL 7)
-/E %2-/
DNA )2)1E `4
a U8V97
S
:'E
L1% a S7
E
RNA >;
() `Y+)E
hL
%E a %
S8
I9J8S I9J8
E 9>6KM;
S r s
2I9J8)% E
I9J8)6>> 6KM
ST+E 2!
*.S
-2 !)E
S
6>>=)E ,9XZIE
W87FX:
S ST
+E `$E RNA [;:)
a
S
1+0J-(T@%!0
RNA 1 0-"
1 RNA0-v# i'1D#OU0*
'"z-M*,+M"O
-&(1T7m
9:
S
E
!)
S 5>>6KM
)E `)
I9J8L1%E
)_
)2E 5T>>>
L1% a S:
5E 2 S
|5
2)E \OQR U
)!).
PUP]E S `
rI9J8s h
aS I9J 8
) RNA
E )6
5T
KM
E )
S )
ERNA )I9J84
2)E
% S 3E
I9J8 RNA E !)
r s
2*
E S E
=
+`R
%S
'>LX`8'H9'[ab)
Z0,
(1)-,WT
M*1) ,0- 101M-,Wz-!LM"O
D
S `)LI9J8
RNA )
ME ) S -E
E I9J8 RNA
2$E )
1 E -a E
NASA h^+;U87L
0
E +`R
(E
>
+cLd
S E )
2S
-#E S
!)E %
@
E .
)@S
%E )!)
2S &/E
2 S
87L9:E
*.S
-2 !)E
S
)
%E)
(
S r
s %E
)E !)E
S
4*E
S
)E
2)(
S $E )
)1
S E )
S %E A.)1
04
%S
T!,T%(M-1
JVMv#,0- 1D#OU0*
T&1TM0-1 Dv#,0"O
|-mK((A@I
| ) #
| "0!$%12
!
*
RNA
RNA
#
*,#
| -
!
!3
-
!
L.$%12
! !
RNA$%12**
,&
.#
4
/
#!!**
!
! ,#
! #
*! )-"
! #
,#
1+0J-(T@%!0
9*,,+
g@-M0
1
1 KHM0o)e
=+-)
1 1 1,+ D0mS
1)5(@ 10D*-
L@
1 1 DD- )M-DQ K
,GT(@
0 T )8
DO;D0-,K,=+)
g,1-KNMJA)
0
+U,JL1M-N(@ )1
TM11+0J-(MJ,%!0)I
Z 1)
2
S % %S
UU)
E
)
*.S
|1
$E
$
S D
"E
S
S
/
E r s
(
.-S E
2
E
rs )
0
<)
TM*011
g@-z-
N!0
E )
2*E rs
)%)
) S=
!8
E
)
S S `
% E -)
E %
aS
LefLa 7B8M %2
S `
QE (S
%
T
.S
3)-E
S S ZZ
S E
/&79hi
)% S E
;I;
S
|
)
9h%)S )
E % ;
S
) S
/&)E /
))C E
)&
S
S5>
E 4# E
% E r s
rs ) S
!))1
2*S
3S )E E
%E f+`8
)%E Ea9
E 2* *.S
3S E
j2*%
( S !)-/
*.S
E -2S
S
10TQ
)E
55T>>>
5*)
2* #$
*
!
*.S
E )1#
E WU
S !)E ) I9
J8"
E
W
S
9*,,+g@-M0
S )E6KM
Hd )k
S HdFR<V92
%E 6KM
E
I9J 8
S
9TOI>+cLd)
2!)E
r9TOI>+cLds 1
DNA
1x-1
k0"0
T:M
`W M
%)2
S
Hd DNA EI9J8
)) T
#
S
I9J8
2);S I
9J8
E
I9J 8)E )
E -#
2*%
S
EL
E %L!I9J8%
S )
E E I
9J8E
)S )
E I9J8
S
99
(La9
(-2S
)(
4* #$E 99
*.S !
I9J8L1)E
S
)
E
S
%
9R+;
S
S E %
% 4S
m0o:
rWs
E j
S E '
).-2
S E
)
S
S
E I9J 8)
0
)E I9J8%)(@E
)
#$E)
*.S )<
2
S
I9J8E 2)
11+N=+M
*!"
I9J 8) rs
! %56$
E @E 2)
789(: ;
)$ S %I9J 8
<=> ? "
k2 E
@4#
) S
*!
A)
|5
%
B!
%E E
"
?
*.S
;
E %E #
5C/!
!
#
9H9LATPM$ =;
#.
l
)E
!
,#
10 m
TM
N!m0J-
1-1 -,#TAT((
+M%&D`Q%(M
0,0"N(@0)N2
0TH) ,D"M0)1,"O
S `
% )E
'
(aS57
E `
) <^N
d
)% E )
)4a %
S58
U8V97 @
SM I
!E
S E )1
$ DE !)
L:mUnJE
) S "E
#
*.E 6>>8)
)E 55 I9J8 5>>
56 %
S
)E 79,
E
#
%
S %E
)
S
E 1%)
|-mK((A@I
)? S
)E 2
| !3
DNA
E D (2
RNA$%12D%
E ! S E 4
!@ !
E )
S o;
@
",#
!
,#
)-F #
|
*
;!!
#
!-
!L
),#
0
!E
)
S
r s
)E
) S
S %E)Ea9
2S
%
"E )E
1
2 r<a9>+cLds
(
S
Q!!#0E1
+K5!0
FF0,+ Q!!#021-J%(@M0)I
FL1+) +(Q!!#1-}(M0)
I ]N00J-K
,L (1
%B
)QNM01,)I
+
0 !0D1 -@N(@
! 0kKW:NM*-Q
T$ @! D,-&(=*U+VL@U)! @
(DT&
+M10,+2)! )
1 Z!#0-Q!M*-JL 0D* e;0
W DNA ME0o-pC@N(M,E
K-,%( (@ *1 ,L@ !
E1+K5!0)I
2 S )
E
))
1E %E L1% -
p)!E
)aS P 57=B5:S
S DNA )
|
%
%EDNA U)%EDNA
E DNA )
)%EEa9 E
S5;
3S %
7
E DNA )E
!8
E
1)3S
IaK9c)E rs
DNA (E )
4E S oE
' S E %
#E )1 S `
LE )# S E
4
%q)
S
)
S )
(
S \R
Q!!#0E1+K5!0
) S 2
$E
D2)
5T7>>S ;
I
nr(2S
Ev
)E
3
4
d
`.a .
E 2. S )
4 E )
E ()S
S )E %
E 1
):6
)R6E
)E 8:) S
)1#E
!%) E 22 s
p)S
EL)56D
%/.E S %E
S kE 1
)$ S
US %E 2
S )
2.
S )E
)E )
S
S )$E p%
)
E 28>
vN;)"
%S %E "E
%)
S
S S tt1
+>S +>L
ZE )
S
.E +>%2 1%a;
E).
S a;
)E %
S
% p% S
S
e;0W DNA 0
p%u
)
S 26D:S H;)1
a;) E
2)tt a;
%
*.S
E a;
)#E
)
S J =;)
S p%)E
S p%
D
0
1
1
2a S p)*
*m0
(E -p%
J=;) S DNA
)? S 6w!
0E q
1 t)
)S 6E)
S q
)
S
1 S w!q
q
E*.)
S
S 8 E
.E 8%2
E
S
5=)2i;
q!
S S .
S J=;)
) S i;
S ( S
mZ0.j
DNA0
1M:0 DNA01
mZ0e
; .j
0mkT
-CMJ,D0
6
4
rs ELUMLQM1-#S
E )!
%E '
*
S LE
S E vy>95
DNA )E
"
S .79>
rs S :9
S ;> E vy
E D rs ) S DL
>95-# S65
1E 6;T>>>
S DE DH(
42E rs
S
E 67Md5 rsE
1
\RD
S
Md S D
"S E \R
Md7>DLDNA q
M
S5= 55T>>>x
)(
S Md
86<)
S
)Md%L1U`R
4*
E <9:)
S Md
IaT9cE5<E
0,g
.-%E
E D%
*.S CD E )z
S (-2S CD g
E E Ea9
)S
S E CD )2
E S %E 5
E UU
)1 2
S ECD 2
'2) %E CD %
9E %E <>D
I
%E
)5S
%
5>>%
L1L1)" #$ S
. S D
E 4)%
*.S
9TOI
S `2*5D
)DNA 5E CD 9J8RU
Ey85
aS6>
5S )
)E DNA )E D1
)E Md6U`R
S 4*
8:)
S
0
#
DNATM
00-J%(
DNA1g0k-KNM
00 DNA0'0kT
{*(M 0kTL
M0\C
T[ *M
DNAg5M
S hLV])E
-.-
S
&)E
a S I9
(S
DNA
CD ')E !1#
*.S Md)
%1
S L1
N
S DNA E )L
S `Md
E )
G
E S
2)
D )"E T
E q-2aS
2 #$
*.S
)
E )%
%-S $E
4 S 1%+`Rz
T%(%
(42S DNA )?
aS
66
E
)E DNA )
S 0
) S
%X
.)E L14
S E )!
DNA p%6)
S
3
4
3
2
DNAT0d-J(M*
01*)%(M
*-,M
1
3
-2S
DNA T qAM
P
DNA +`R jE
ha:
S `EDNA
q)%S 1%
1
DNA )<
S
3EDNA
6)#E
5
E )
S
*
*.E D
)%// 4
S
$E
EDNA
4
S % DNA )
E _S DNA p%
)E
S %E5
S |kS
S
kha:
S `DNA 1
S DNA "
Z;I)
*.S E
I9J8 r7Ts
DE '
4
S
S
3E DNA D
1#
S c}
;)a` XF9) D
S )EDT
S
T RNALHM$
S
RNA LE DNA )
E C
S D%2
S )
)
E E j
E 5>>%E
Hd)E I9J8
% 4 S DNA (
)4 aS
E UU
$E 43
%I9J8
S )E
E
a9)2S
E%"
1%() S
E \R) 4
!|1T5M
)2S
-/c ( S
%E 2 )
DNAT qAM
)1 DNA=+(M
B "-,%!k RNA-TM
%
N!TM DNA %
-0-T,^*f,^TWM
T7U" RNA1MK2:(
: -,0ET
1
4
2
qAKNNMW
DNA 5 !)
,#
DNAG!ATGC .
H
A T G C
L AL4 T L G
L4 C
3 G
?
4
GTCA
?
CAGT!
!C
H!@!
;
*
DNA5 !
!
DNA!
DNA I B
# DNA 5"!
DNAL
5
C
E rs )
E
S )E
S
(-2S
ES /%E )
u1S \RMdE
-D.2
*.S E D
)
S
E DNA DHE q
L)0
*.S D
. E D
S
S98 DNA L DNAM.
S
E )
"
S S98
DNA D
9R+;
S .E
DNA E TU
;
@
E DNA
TOI S 9TOI
) S
E
<a9>+
HXS:U~a9,9
cLd
S %E >+c
E )2 S
)E 1>+cLd
<9R-
TU S E .
# E DNA )
S
DNA %'%E
*.S
%
*.S
cLdp)
S
7
%E
1)
S S
) CE %
S
E
S
E
|-mK((A@I
% S $E DNA 6*.
| DNA3
B3
)~L9U8H`
. ? !A)
!
8EDNA )%
A)J
E p)! E
! )! ,#
S E
1
| %56$F
DNA
j(E
#
DNAA).
E
S
6:
%56$
%E9>)4
4 !
69RNU~;E
) !,#
5<> S <5)E
| DNA @
))C E
= ! ;
!
) S 5
789(K789(:) !,#
% *.wE4E
$'%9
S `S 4
3E L1)
3
S ZZj%
!* #
#
/j&E aS
6;
*!,#
j
S )9
;(01
H0NK!0
{1T!+M*H0N- n
1
0P1 g0 , -}(M*@! 0 0
-( H-Z!#1H
J-,L@! 01
009*,1*g0KT@%! F( 0K!
,cNTC X0*c: (
M*Sc:*(%! g@-,0)I
Z )
9S 59>)
?#E
2
S
S
E DNA
! r9TOIs
%E E
01@L&NM
E '
S
)D%C
!8
`)a
S )E y9
`a 22
E S L 5B56E
4 S E *.S
6>O69M E `a
/;%E
,;dUSU:95===)
)
E S
S `)-S
E
5
E )
aS y9
43S
)E 5)1
|
?#S %E y
S :9 S `
E)
E &
4S E
S 4
)*E)%E,
)4E
6=
)%
/aS
%E )
;
)D.2
E )
aS76
y9)S $E NOU
E
a9vyRLM6>>=)
)44
S
$E H`8UQvR
L1j
E `
*.S '
a S7> )
4S $E
$E ,a];U+%
,vd
1iH)E
S `)
2
S ( S -E
*.S
)E
"
S
" #$
-aS75
6-&(1+
*E
)S )
E
1
)4"E
E
`^9fH6a .
?#E
@
0
<
S $E )E
S ^9fH61
)
E
S /E
2
`^)(
S
S
Eao`:UMU+
^<;D)
> S `y9
)-%E
)E 4
E !
1
c;>
S E ;)
#E )12
S
E E E E E E
S $E LaF9E
EEEE=E\VELaF9
)
S
E NOUa9vyR%QvR'
+%E C S
y9)?#
E S -E )
S
S D)
S 43L)% )E
L)4S
)E )
"E%E
y9
)
S $E XO6
L%MNH
!
"
!*
NM.-;!60
GL
N(,01,
RUNO,9E 6>><a9IoOE
-!
S
S `_
)y9E L1
)@2E
S
)E 1
% aS77
60
0
<
E E j
?#2)1
S S
5E1k
S
3E )E )
EL
S
E 2
S
)E % E
)1#
S
)E )E
%
S
)1Ee9HU
S `
)E
)1 %
aS78
)1E
,;dUSU:9
S
2` '
E ZZq
L S
e9HUC
*.S
))0
*.S
066KM*1,
)%E
))9,~y;d
E
E
:
aS79
S D=9,%)D)
1T(M
} V }; U FcL ~y` 8L M
6>>8E
`5T>>>,)
1===,^`R2E
a )
S7: E .
S
5>,) ~y;d
E 5>>,
1#
S
S
))1
6T;( NL&0GTQ(M
*M1 ,ZH,+
)1, *
*YC0@,
-WJ WI)KMDN,
Z)1, WZ0=*
6T !,P: O
5>>,E )RH
S . E !
" a<
S %
)(E 5>>,9,#RH)"
%E D=9,CRH)
S E 9,D
)E a<
E ) S
,;dUSU:9S
%E !
S E
P =9, P
S
)4D.
S D
S HXS: UiH
S `E
1/%E ' )
E )(1
;(01H0NK!0
<
w
i
*-T&?J
0,?
W
<
w
i
0,?
*-T&?J
d0J,M*
N(M
$E
. %S
"(
S
rs
S
-#%E!)
60# 1 X0LK
:0T(1,0- ,(Z1
IL0 T;( !*;M0
E ) S
r9TOI>+c
Lds DNA %E % E
-S #
. >+cLd'
/
vd
%) t
S
aS7;
D)E L1
4# S E
%
)
c;>E4S
E D
E
)LE
%E #
S E
2*"S
E )
S )
S )
S
|-mK((A@I
|
-
| D%. DNA
!.#
%@
;
! %56$
O
!
PQ%!
!!,#
*DR#,#
0
0
-&(1+
S.
!;
4
A)
!
] L5L
#
! 5L
# T A
]
) U "B
<bc
DQH @V!'W%9N%
L 'W%
2 X6Y%YZR=
/
3 "
.)
=##B
# !U
#
;
e%f
0
,#
N`a68(%C
- .#0
P(X6
,
d`g
0!,h03U
!
661-1T(M
X6 3
| S#
"#.))
![ N
# Lh
\C!A)#
;
# !
@
5
SF0
-]
?M
G.#!
! !
" "#
-&(0c
| 'W%9N%2 .#
B/
?
h0
8W2$
F
!
fDQH
.)# -
% 'W%
,#
D ^]
"
# X6%iQ`
.
_`(NHX6P
'W%9N%2
Pa=8[%DN`
'W%9N%2 missing link @
5
U;"
! .!
B!- !*
d`
S d`
!
"
DQH"3!
"!,#
#
A) j,#
D
"
)d`
!#
D -.
9=7
8[%DN`;
*!
j
b:N *
,#
%iQkQW2HNL%K
#3!3 #
%C;
#. !#0 ?
- d`S0!
F]
C(KbW2!U
B"
DQH !
!
F
F
.#)!M8L@ !
HB"
W8-(M0*F
3!"
|
B!S
!
-S
A)=- d`
!A) -SS
"
#
j "h
#
!;,#
S
@
!,#
) !
#3
-!
5
Dh"!
U -j
,#
!,#
D
_`(NHHD
B/
,#
= )
&CEL
! <H%D=$= d`
=Nikl%
.
),#
-
!
.
3..
!
=hB
'=kmCHPm=nk
J)B@ B
HNLcR=
!
F
<H%D=$=
; d` )
F#
^@ !
0)V"T&OM
| ! ) A)d
`# !
"B
0
!
SSDQHo5
!0!,
@ #
0*0
1
;(01H0NK!0
!8TM01
J-(M*
"NTP(!*L@U %* 00LF#%!*-&(
(!!C)I i -,N,"O*\%(@! VL%(AM* (
!*1g@)1L@U)! N*YJ,*1!8-&(D#@
WI%(D !8T
M@ ,"*\@ !81J
J)\
Z) C"K0g)M0J-LKN@ !8P
N(M*
*1,)I
.(!
S
% *.E
5)-E %
2) *.S
*.S !2. S E
E 4 E
%
S
E )E
%
S $E
)E
S ''
h
68
5:
j"S E
E % E )
))
E h)
?
E
S E
2)E )
)
)1
)
S E
E '
)
S $E
S S %
E
`)a
"S
)1%E !)(
q-2S
0
S E
;
E "S E '
/E )'
)
(%#)E
S Lab 6B6O8S ,Ia 9B87E88C 6:B
96M '
/
E )E j
)* E
S
L+, 56B5S efLa 55B5M
!
/E #E
)E "
S
$E b% E 5
2
c
S
)E )E
S E
-2
S )?
E E
S
)S
Q `)
a 55
q-2S
7
T
9. Encyclopdia Britannica, CD
2003, Cell, The Mitochondrion and
the Chloroplast, subhead, The
Endosymbiont Hypothesis.
10. How Life BeganEvolutions Three
Geneses, p. 32.
11. Molecular Human Reproduction,
The Role of Proteomics in Dening the
Human Embryonic Secretome, by M. G.
Katz-Jae, S. McReynolds, D. K. Gardner,
and W. B. Schoolcraft, 2009, p. 271.
12. Molecular Biology of the Cell, Second
Edition, by Bruce Alberts et al, 1989,
p. 405.
13. Between Necessity and Probability:
Searching for the Definition and Origin
of Life, by Radu Popa, 2004, p. 129.
14. Between Necessity and Probability:
Searching for the Definition and Origin
of Life, pp. 126-127.
/ 1
S
www.jw.org/ja
S
lf-J