生命の起源―5つの大切な質問

0
&0@,
0
&0@,
1
2
3
4
5
1+0J-(T@%!0
9*,,+g@-M0
Q!!#0E1+K5!0
;(01H0NK!0
!8TM01J-(M*
7
DNA

L
5 2010
WATCH TOWER BIBLE AND TRACT SOCIETY OF PENNSYLVANIA
All Rights Reserved

U

IL

! " #Z
Photo credits: Page 4: 5 Petit Format/Photo Researchers, Inc.; page 5: 5 SPL/Photo

Researchers, Inc.; page 22, tree of life: Image courtesy of Biodiversity Heritage Library;
page 27, skull: 5 Photolibrary/age fotostock; Ida: 5 Martin Shields/Alamy; page 28, skulls:
5 Medical-on-Line/Alamy; page 29, Java Man reconstruction: 5 The Print Collector/Alamy
The Origin of LifeFive Questions Worth Asking
Japanese (lf-J)
Made in Japan

U
Z0
jo 1QQTC@ ? G%*A@ #I+ M
N0-&(!*O) ZT
TK&!J" *N1#@! "1 5T;

,N2,L@U
1-8&L@ iK1 W)*;(1%!*W
KN( @! !80017) M 19,MJ)%(

N(1, *D(@ NDiD 0*T\%(W(
N(@ )1 +#KTN2J0)I
EE
*.S &/E !)

S E
)0 E
S

"
S
S
S
)E ,)
E
!
"
S E )
#$ S
S E
)1%
%E
&'()!
S
S E `
2E %

!E
S E13E4
(
a S L 58B59M
#$ *.S S %
E à
*E

)E !S E
")E " S P+, 56B5E 6S
2)
E
-
S
E .

"%
(-2S
Z0
1+0J-(T@%!0
<#EU1+K5!0 S
O /(T+ %*
!*L@
i1+@! 00,!0Fi0L-DJL@
T1K v((000DT#%!DN@U DM*
*T!DN@U )D W+D1%L!-,%(M!C-
N1 <#EUJ@)0TVK,N2,L@U
<#EU+K5!T!K,0J,Z@ D%*g,
&@L1+K5!*-&(!K,0)
00P,DThM+) Q!!#01 QL@ )1
1+0J-(T@%!0)I
Z
!
S )E
S
) )E
E
"S
E L1* r s
!)S
LE %E ; 5
S %
h'ES
5S . )
%E
!
S 6>><)E
6789:;U<=79,
0>1
S 9>E `
> )
?
#L1% S
0
)5
@4#% aS5
|
A.
)2
E ;* .S 3E
) S E

32C4
S )E
!)S
DS
)$E #)
$%&'(
%7 * *.S
E S E
DNA LEFGHM RNA LHM
aS6
I9J8S E
RNA )1( S RNA
E
E %2 W87FX:
)2E D.
S W87FX:6KM;
*.S $ERNA 'I9J8
E 6KM-#S ST
)2S
+)E `W87FX
!)
@E 5=97)" 4
S I97ULUKL
E
)
)E I9J8
6KM
S
5T
)E 6KM2 S
E
( 17)E
S
NOP8+Q
RUST+ S `
KL 7)
-/E %2-/
DNA )2)1E `4
a U8V97 S
:'E
L1% a S7 E
RNA >;
() `Y+)E
hL
%E a %
S8
I9J8S I9J8
E 9>6KM;
S r s
2I9J8)% E
I9J8)6>> 6KM
ST+E 2! *.S
-2 !)E
S
6>>=)E ,9XZIE
W87FX:
S ST
+E `$E RNA [;:)
a S
1+0J-(T@%!0
RNA 1 0-"
1 RNA0-v# i'1D#OU0*
'"z-M*,+M"O
-&(1T7m
9: S E
!)
S 5>>6KM
)E `)
I9J8L1%E
)_

)2E 5T>>>
L1% a S:
5E 2 S
|5

2)E \OQR U
)!).
PUP]E S `
-E(-2S
rI9J8s h
aS I9J 8
) RNA
E )6
5T
KM
E ) S )
ERNA )I9J84
2)E
S )E "E
% S 3E
I9J8 RNA E !)

r s
2*
! !)S E
E S E
=
+`R
%S
'>LX`8'H9'[ab)
Z0, (1)-,WT
M*1) ,0- 101M-,Wz-!LM"O

D
S `)LI9J8
RNA )
ME ) S -E
E I9J8 RNA
2$E )
1 E -a E
NASA h^+;U87L
0
E +`R
(E
>
+cLd S E )
2S

-#E S
!)E %
@
E .
)@S
%E )!)
2S &/E
2 S
87L9:E
*.S
-2 !)E
S

)
%E)
(
S r
s %E
)E !)E
S
4*E

S

)E
2)(
S $E )
)1
S E )
S %E A.)1
04
%S
T!,T%(M-1
JVMv#,0- 1D#OU0*
T&1TM0-1 Dv#,0"O
|-mK((A@I
| ) #
| "0!$%12
!
*
RNA
RNA
#
*,#
| -
!
!3
-
!
L.$%12
! !
RNA$%12**
,&
.#
4

/
#!!**
!
!

! ,#
! #
*! )-"
! #
,#
1+0J-(T@%!0
9*,,+
g@-M0
1
1 KHM0o)e =+-)
1 1 1,+ D0mS
1)5(@ 10D*-
L@
1 1 DD- )M-DQ K
,GT(@
0 T )8
DO;D0-,K,=+)
g,1-KNMJA)
0
+U,JL1M-N(@ )1
TM11+0J-(MJ,%!0)I
Z 1)
2 S % %S
UU) E
) *.S
|1
$E
$ S D
"E
S
S
/
E r s
(
.-S E 2
E
rs )
0
<)
TM*011
g@-z-
N!0
9*, 1)D 0,ZK

M*,+g@-M0
E )
2*E rs
)%) ) S=
!8
E
)
S S `
% E -)
E %
aS
LefLa 7B8M %2 S `
QE (S

%
T
.S 3)-E
S S ZZ
S E
/&79hi
)% S E
;I;
S
2%%aS P 5>8B68E 69S
55D2 *.E 7
|
)
9h%)S )
E % ;
S
) S
/&)E /
))C E
)&
S
S5>
E 4# E
% E r s
rs ) S
!))1

2*S
3S )E E
%E f+`8
)%E Ea9
E 2* *.S
3S E

j2*%
( S !)-/
*.S
E -2S
S
10TQ
)E
55T>>>
5*) 2* #$ *

! *.S
E )1#
E WU

S !)E ) I9
J8" E
W
S
9*,,+g@-M0
S )E6KM
Hd )k
S HdFR<V92
%E 6KM
E
I9J 8
S
9TOI>+cLd)
2!)E
r9TOI>+cLds 1 DNA

1x-1
k0"0
T:M
`W M
%)2 S
Hd DNA EI9J8

)) T
# S
I9J8 2);S I
9J8 E
I9J 8)E )
E -#
2*%
S EL
E %L!I9J8%
S )

E E I
9J8E

)S )
E I9J8 S
99
(La9
(-2S
)(
4* #$E 99 *.S !
I9J8L1)E S
) E
S
%
9R+; S
S E %
% 4S
m0o:
rWs
E j
S E '

).-2
S E
)
S
*.S )E "

]O;)E %
S
E I9J 8)
' S S 3E 6KM

$6>

0
)E I9J8%)(@E
) #$E)
*.S )<

2 S
I9J8E 2)
11+N=+M
'S
*!"
I9J 8) rs

! %56$
E @E 2)
789(: ;

)$ S %I9J 8
<=> ? "
k2 E

@4#
) S
*!
A)

|5
%
B!
%E E
"
?
*.S
;

E %E #

5C/!
#$ S $E 6EM
!
#
9H9LATPM$ =;
#.

l
)E
!
,#
) ATP =;lS

)E
) DNA E
DNA
)S LDNA )1
10 m
TM
N!m0J-
1-1 -,#TAT((
+M%&D`Q%(M
0,0"N(@0)N2
0TH) ,D"M0)1,"O
S `
% )E
'
(aS57 E `
) <^N
d )% E )
)4a %
S58

U8V97 @ SM I

!E
9J8% #$* .E
S E )1
I9J8 #$* .S
$ DE !)
L:mUnJE
) S "E

# *.E 6>>8)
)E 55 I9J8 5>>
56 % S
)E 79,
E
#
% S %E
) S
E 1%)
|-mK((A@I
)? S
)E 2
| !3
DNA
E D (2
RNA$%12D%
E ! S E 4
!@ !
E )
!
S o;
@
",#
!
,#
)-F #
|
*
;!!
#
!-
!L
),#
0
!E

) S
r s
)E
) S
S %E)Ea9
2S
%
"E )E
1
2 r<a9>+cLds
(
S
Q!!#0E1
+K5!0
FF0,+ Q!!#021-J%(@M0)I
FL1+) +(Q!!#1-}(M0)
I ]N00J-K ,L (1
%B
)QNM01,)I
+
0 !0D1 -@N(@
! 0kKW:NM*-Q
T$ @! D,-&(=*U+VL@U)! @
(DT&
+M10,+2)! )
1 Z!#0-Q!M*-JL 0D* e;0
W DNA ME0o-pC@N(M,E
K-,%( (@ *1 ,L@ !
E1+K5!0)I
Z DNA %2
2 S )
E
))
1E %E L1% -
p)!E
)aS P 57=B5:S
S DNA )
|
%
%EDNA U)%EDNA
E DNA )
)%EEa9 E
S5;
3S %
7
E DNA )E
!8
E
1)3S
IaK9c)E rs
DNA (E )
4E S oE
' S E %
#E )1 S `
LE )# S E
4
%q)

S
)
S )
( S \R
Q!!#0E1+K5!0
) S 2
$E
D2)
5T7>>S ;

I
nr(2S
Ev
)E 3
4
d
`.a .
E 2. S )
S5< E .). %
E 26>DS
4 E )
E ()S
S )E %
E 1 ):6

)R6E
)E 8:) S

)1#E
!%) E 22 s
p)S
EL)56D
%/.E S %E
S kE 1
)$ S
US %E 2
S )
2. S )E
)E )
S
p%J =;)E `)q à LME
S )$E p%
)
E 28>
vN;)"
%S %E "E
%) S
S S tt1
+>S +>L
ZE ) S
.E +>%2 1%a;
E). S a;
)E % S
% p% S
S
e;0W DNA 0

p%u
) S 26D:S H;)1
a;) E
2)tt a;
% *.S E a;
)#E
) S J =;)
S p%)E
S p%
D
0
1
1
2a S p)*
*m0
(E -p%
J=;) S DNA
)? S 6w!
0E q
1 t)
)S 6E)
S q
) S
1 S w!q
q
E*.)
S
S 8 E
E E DNA S
)$E AUTUGUC $ S
5 DNA H;')

) "E 5 )
.E 8%2
E S
4#S qE $
5=)2i;
q!
S S .
% *.S )E )
S J=;)
) S i;
S ( S
mZ0.j
DNA0
1M:0 DNA01
mZ0e ; .j

0mkT
-CMJ,D0
6
4
rs ELUMLQM1-#S
E )!
%E '
* S LE
S E vy>95
DNA %8S AUTU
DNA )E
"
GUC C)E :9$
S .79>
rs S :9
S ;> E vy
E D rs ) S DL
>95-# S65
1E 6;T>>>
S DE DH(
42E rs S
E 67Md5 rsE
1 \RD
S
Md S D
"S E \R
Md7>DLDNA q
M S5= 55T>>>x

)( S Md
86<) S
)Md%L1U`R
4*
E <9:) S Md
IaT9cE5<E
0,g
.-%E
E D%
*.S CD E )z
S (-2S CD g
E E Ea9
)S
S E CD )2
E S %E 5
E UU
)1 2
S ECD 2
'2) %E CD %
9E %E <>D
I

%E
)5S
%
5>>%
L1L1)" #$ S
. S D
E 4)% *.S
9TOI
S `2*5D
)DNA 5E CD 9J8RU
Ey85
aS6>

5S )
)E DNA )E D1
)E Md6U`R S 4*
8:) S
0
#
DNATM
00-J%(
DNA1g0k-KNM
00 DNA0'0kT
{*(M 0kTL
M0\C
T[ *M
DNAg5M
S "$E
S hLV])E
-.-
DNA LE) Ì9
S
&)E
a S I9
(S
E ha: S `DNA
DNA
CD ')E !1#
*.S Md)
%1
S L1
N
S DNA E )L
S `Md
E )
G
E S 2)
D )"E T
S EI;L1-S ZZM
E q-2aS
2 #$ *.S
)
d%aS % S `Md
E )%
%-S $E
4 S 1%+`Rz
T%(%
(42S DNA )?
aS
66
)E DNA
E
)E DNA )
S 0

) S
*.E /E 5-
%X
.)E L14
S E )!
DNA p%6)
S
S {E
3
4
3
2
DNAT0d-J(M*
01*)%(M
*-,M
1
3
'# aS68 P6>x `

(T2a /(
q
DNA1
CD s0T) M
-2S
DNA T qAM
P
DNA +`R jE
ha: S ÈDNA

q)%S 1%
1 DNA )<
S 3EDNA
6)#E
5
E )
S
* *.E D
)%// 4 S
$E
EDNA
E DNA w!1 0

)"2 S E DNA
rs % 4 S ;
2E
U aS P5:O5;x

q-2S
ha: S `
-# S +`R
T: S E
DNA rs )E 55>>1

0 S67 )
E rs ><
* )S
E 5>S \RE
% DNA rs )
S MdT
43<
4 S % DNA )
E _S DNA p%
)E
S %E5
S |kS
S
kha: S `DNA 1
S DNA "
Z;I) *.S E

I9J8 r7Ts
DE ' 4
S
S 3E DNA D
1# S c}
;)a` XF9) D
S )EDT
S
T RNALHM$ S
RNA LE DNA )
E C S D%2
S )
)
E E j
E 5>>%E
Hd)E I9J8
% 4 S DNA (
)4 aS
E UU
$E 43
%I9J8

S )E
E
a9)2S
S DNA TU2E L

N
)( E
E%"
1%() S
E \R) 4
!|1T5M
2E S
E %LE b
)2S
-/c ( S
%E 2 )

DNAT qAM
)1 DNA=+(M
B "-,%!k RNA-TM
RNA DNAT qA DW0
%
N!TM DNA %
-0-T,^*f,^TWM
T7U" RNA1MK2:(
: -,0ET

1
4
2
qAKNNMW
DNA 5 !)
,#
DNAG!ATGC .
H
A T G C
L AL4 T L G
L4 C
3 G ?
4
GTCA
?
CAGT!
!C
H!@!
;
*

;
DNA5 !
!
DNA!

DNA I B
# DNA 5"!

DNAL
5

C
E rs )
E S )E
S
(-2S
ES /%E )
u1S \RMdE
-D.2 *.S E D

) S
E DNA DHE q
L)0 *.S D
. E D
S

S98 DNA L DNAM. S
E )
" S S98
DNA D
9R+;
S .E
DNA E TU

;
@ E DNA
TOI S 9TOI
) S
E
<a9>+
HXS:U~a9,9
cLd
S %E >+c
E )2 S
LdE U)
`) %E aS69

)E 1>+cLd
<9R-
TU S E .
# E DNA )
S
)S 9TOI>+
DNA %'%E
*.S
% *.S
cLdp) S
7
%E
1)
%E DNA )p)!
S S
) CE % S
E
S

E
|-mK((A@I
% S $E DNA 6*.
| DNA3
B3
)~L9U8H`

. ? !A) !
8EDNA )%
A)J
E p)! E
! )! ,#
S E
1
| %56$F
DNA
j(E
#
DNAA).
E
S
6:
%56$
%E9>)4
4 !
69RNU~;E
) !,#
5<> S <5)E
| DNA @
))C E
= ! ;

!
) S 5

"S DNA _S ~
789(K789(:) !,#
;E )
| DNA"- ! .
% *.wE4E
$'%9
S `S 4
DNA5 0 ?
3E L1)
3

S ZZj%
!* #
#
/j&E aS
6;
*!,#

j
S )9
;(01
H0NK!0
{1T!+M*H0N- n 1

0P1 g0 , -}(M*@! 0 0
-( H-Z!#1H J-,L@! 01
009*,1*g0KT@%! F( 0K!
,cNTC X0*c: (
M*Sc:*(%! g@-,0)I
Z )
9S 59>)
?#E
2
S
S E DNA
! r9TOIs

%E E
01@L&NM
E '
S
)D%C

!8

`)a
S )E y9

à 22
E S L 5B56E
4 S E *.S
6>O69M E à
) S
/;%E
,;dUSU:95===)
)
E S
S `)-S
E
5
E )
aS y9
43S
)E 5)1
|

?#S %E y
S :9 S `

E)
E &
4S E
S 4
)*E)%E,
)4E
6=
)% /aS
%E )
;
)D.2 E )
aS76
y9)S $E NOU
E
a9vyRLM6>>=)
)44
S
$E H`8UQvR
L1j

E `
*.S '
a S7> )
4S $E

$E ,a];U+%
,vd
1iH)E
S `)
2
S ( S -E
*.S
)E "
S
" #$
-aS75
6-&(1+
*E
)S )
E
1
)4"E
E

`^9fH6a .
?#E
@
0
<
S $E )E
S ^9fH61
)

E
S /E
2
`^)(
S
S ^9fH6 E`
S
Eao`:UMU+
^<;D)
> S `y9
S )E ^9fH6
)-%E
)E 4
E !
1
c;>
S E ;)
#E )12 S
E E E E E E S $E LaF9E
EEEE=E\VELaF9
) S
E NOUa9vyR%QvR'
+%E C S
y9)?#
E S -E )

S
S D)
S 43L)% )E
L)4S
)E )
"E%E
y9

) S $E XO6
L%MNH

!
"
!*
NM.-;!60
GL
N(,01,
RUNO,9E 6>><a9IoOE

-!
S S `_
)y9E L1
)@2E S
)E 1

% aS77
60
0
<
E E j
?#2)1
S S
5E1k S
3E )E )
EL S
E 2
S
)E % E
)1# S
)E )E
% S
)1Ee9HU
S `

)E
)1 %
aS78
)1E
,;dUSU:9 S
2` '
E ZZq
L S
e9HUC *.S
))0 *.S
066KM*1,
)%E
))9,~y;d

E E
:

aS79
S D=9,%)D)
1T(M
} V }; U FcL ~y` 8L M
6>>8E
`5T>>>,)
1===,^`R2E
a ) S7: E .
S
5>,) ~y;d
E 5>>,
1# S
S
))1
6T;( NL&0GTQ(M
*M1 ,ZH,+
)1, *
*YC0@,
-WJ WI)KMDN,
Z)1, WZ0=*
6T !,P: O
5>>,E )RH
S . E !
" a< S %
)(E 5>>,9,#RH)"
%E D=9,CRH)
S E 9,D
)E a<
E ) S
,;dUSU:9S
%E ! S E
P =9, P
S
)4D.
S D

S HXS: UiH
S È
1/%E ' )

E )(1
;(01H0NK!0
<
w
i
*-T&?J
0,?
W
<
w
i
0,?
*-T&?J
d0J,M*
N(M

$E
. %S

"( S
rs
S
-#%E!)
60# 1 X0LK
:0T(1,0- ,(Z1
IL0 T;( !*;M0
E ) S

r9TOI>+c
Lds DNA %E % E
-S #
. >+cLd'
/
vd
%) t

S
aS7;
D)E L1
)1S
4# S E
%
)
c;>E4S
E D

E
))?#S
)LE
%E #
S E
2*"S
E )
6;O6= x `)1a

q
-2S
S )
S ) S
|-mK((A@I
|
-
| D%. DNA
!.#
%@

;
! %56$
O

!
PQ%!

! PQ%
! *##B
!!,#
*DR#,#
0
0
-&(1+
S.
!;

4
A)
!

] L5L

#
! 5L

# T A
]

) U "B

<bc
DQH @V!'W%9N%
L 'W%
2 X6Y%YZR=
9N%2 ! d`
/
3 "
.)
=##B
# !U
#
;

e%f
0
,#

Nà68(%C
- .#0
P(X6

,
d`g
0!,h03U
!
661-1T(M
X6 3
| S#
"#.))
![ N
# Lh
\C!A)#

;

# !
@

5
SF0
-]
?M
G.#!

! !

" "#
-&(0c
| 'W%9N%2 .#
B/
?
h0
8W2$ F
!

fDQH
.)# -
% 'W%
,#
9N%2

# @4
D ^]

"
# X6%iQ`
.
_`(NHX6P
'W%9N%2
Pa=8[%DN`
'W%9N%2 missing link @ 5

U;"

! .!

B!- !*

d` S d`

!
'W%9N%2 .
"
DQH"3!
"!,#

#
A) j,#
D
"

)d` !#
D -.

9=7
8[%DN`;

*!

j
b:N *
,#
%iQkQW2HNL%K
#3!3 #
%C;

#. !#0 ?
- d`S0!
F]
C(KbW2!U
B"
DQH !
!
F

F
.#)!M8L@ !

HB"
W8-(M0*F
3!"

|
B!S
!

-S

A)=- d`
!A) -SS

"
#
j "h
#
!;,#
S
@
!,#
) !
#3
-!
5
Dh"!
U -j
,#
!,#
D
_`(NHHD

B/
,#
= )
&CEL
! <H%D=$= d`
=Nikl%

.
),#
-
!
.
3..
!
=hB
'=kmCHPm=nk
J)B@ B
HNLcR=
!
F

<H%D=$=
; d` )
F#

^@ !

0)V"T&OM
| ! ) A)d
`# !
"B
0
!
SSDQHo5
!0!,

@ #
0*0
1
!*1 |)1, *F0

N*-'(M
!*01 T:0LF{"0
6-'(M {0L1D#OU
T:*&M01,*)M
,06T+; -(
*!#051L_(,
!J!0kT#0T
P-M*1) ,
!1 D-T:0
0.- -a%(
;KN(M 0
1V"0&O'*(1
7) ,*
N(M
;(01H0NK!0
!8TM01
J-(M*
"NTP(!*L@U %* 00LF#%!*-&(
(!!C)I i -,N,"O*\%(@! VL%(AM* (
!*1g@)1L@U)! N*YJ,*1!8-&(D#@
WI%(D !8T M@ ,"*\@ !81J J)\
Z) C"K0g)M0J-LKN@ !8P
N(M*
*1,)I

.(! S
% *.E
5)-E %
2) *.S
*.S !2. S E
E 4 E
%
S
) %E )
E )E

% S $E
)E
S ''
h
68
5:
j"S E
E % E )
))
E h)
?
E
% *.S
S E
2)E )
)

)1
)
S E
E '
)

S $E
S S %
E
`)a

"S
S L 5B55E 65E 68M E 1
)1%E !)(
E Q ` P Ha
q-2S
0
S E

;
E "S E '
/E )'
)
(%#)E
S Lab 6B6O8S ,Ia 9B87E88C 6:B
96M '
/
E )E j
)* E S
L+, 56B5S efLa 55B5M
!
/E #E

)E "
S
$E b% E 5
2
c S
)E )E
S E
-2
S )?
E E
S
)S
Q `)

a 55
q-2S
7
T
1. How Life BeganEvolutions Three Geneses, by Alexandre Meinesz, translated by

Daniel Simberlo, 2008, pp. 30-33, 45.
a. Life ItselfIts Origin and Nature, by
Francis Crick, 1981, pp. 15-16, 141-153.
2. Scientific American, A Simpler Origin
for Life, by Robert Shapiro, June 2007,
p. 48.
a. The New York Times, A Leading
Mystery of Lifes Origins Is Seemingly
Solved, by Nicholas Wade, May 14,
2009, p. A23.
3. Scientific American, June 2007, p. 48.
4. Scientific American, June 2007, pp. 47,
49-50.
5. Information Theory, Evolution, and the
Origin of Life, by Hubert P. Yockey, 2005,
p. 182.
6. NASAs Astrobiology Magazine,

Lifes Working DenitionDoes
It Work? (http://www.nasa.gov/
vision/universe/starsgalaxies/
lifesworkingdenition.html),
accessed 3/17/2009.
9*g@
7. Princeton Weekly Bulletin, Nuts, Bolts of

Who We Are, by Steven Schultz,
May 1, 2000, (http://www.princeton.edu/
pr/pwb/00/0501/p/brain.shtml), accessed
3/27/2009.
a. The Nobel Prize in Physiology or
Medicine 2002, Press Release, October 7,
2002, (http://nobelprize.org/
nobelprizes/medicine/laureates/2002/
press.html), accessed 3/27/2009.
8. The Nobel Prize in Physiology or

Medicine 2002, October 7, 2002.
9. Encyclopdia Britannica, CD
2003, Cell, The Mitochondrion and
the Chloroplast, subhead, The
Endosymbiont Hypothesis.
10. How Life BeganEvolutions Three
Geneses, p. 32.
11. Molecular Human Reproduction,
The Role of Proteomics in Dening the
Human Embryonic Secretome, by M. G.
Katz-Jae, S. McReynolds, D. K. Gardner,
and W. B. Schoolcraft, 2009, p. 271.
12. Molecular Biology of the Cell, Second
Edition, by Bruce Alberts et al, 1989,
p. 405.
13. Between Necessity and Probability:
Searching for the Definition and Origin
of Life, by Radu Popa, 2004, p. 129.
14. Between Necessity and Probability:
Searching for the Definition and Origin
of Life, pp. 126-127.
/ 1
15. Origin of Mitochondria and Hydrogenosomes, by William F. Martin and
Miklos Muller, 2007, p. 21.

16. Brain MattersTranslating Research
Into Classroom Practice, by Pat Wolfe,
2001, p. 16.
E

5
17. Research News Berkeley Lab, (http:

//www.lbl.gov/Science-Articles/Archive/
LSD-molecular-DNA.html), article:
Molecular DNA Switch Found to Be the
Same for All Life, contact: Lynn Yarris,
p. 1 of 4; accessed 2/10/2009.
18. Life Script, by Nicholas Wade, 2001,
p. 79.
19. Bioinformatics Methods in Clinical
Research, edited by Rune Matthiesen,
2010, p. 49.
20. Scientific American, Computing With
DNA, by Leonard M. Adleman,
August 1998, p. 61.
21. Nano Letters, Enumeration of DNA
Molecules Bound to a Nanomechanical
Oscillator, by B. Ilic, Y. Yang, K. Aubin,
R. Reichenbach, S. Krylov, and H. G.
Craighead, Vol. 5, No. 5, 2005, pp. 925,
929.
22. GenomeThe Autobiography of a
Species in 23 Chapters, by Matt Ridley,
1999, pp. 7-8.
23. Essential Cell Biology, Second Edition,
by Bruce Alberts, Dennis Bray, Karen
Hopkin, Alexander Johnson, Julian Lewis,
Martin Ra, Keith Roberts, and Peter
Walter, 2004, p. 201.
24. Molecular Biology of the Cell, Fourth
Edition, by Bruce Alberts et al, 2002,
p. 258.
25. No Ordinary GeniusThe Illustrated
Richard Feynman, edited by Christopher
Sykes, 1994, photo with no page number
supplied; note caption.
a. New Scientist, Second GenesisLife,
but Not As We Know It, by
Bob Holmes, March 11, 2009,
(http://www.newscientist.com/article/
mg20126990.100) accessed 3/11/2009.
26. The Search for Extraterrestrial
IntelligenceA Philosophical Inquiry, by
David Lamb, 2001, p. 83.
27. Associated Press Newswires, Famous

Atheist Now Believes in God, by Richard
N. Ostling, December 9, 2004.
/ q W
28. Intelligent Life in the Universe, Second

Edition, by Peter Ulmschneider, 2006,
p. 125.

HN

29. Biology and Philosophy, The Concept

of Monophyly: A Speculative Essay, by
Malcolm S. Gordon, 1999, p. 335.
30. New Scientist, Uprooting Darwins
Tree, by Graham Lawton, January 24,
2009, p. 34.
31. New Scientist, January 24, 2009,
pp. 37, 39.
32. Field Museum of Natural History
Bulletin, Conicts Between Darwin
and Paleontology, by David M. Raup,
January 1979, p. 23.
33. Archaeology, The Origin of Form
Was Abrupt Not Gradual, by Suzan
Mazur, October 11, 2008,
(www.archaeology.org/online/
interviews/newman.html),
accessed 2/23/2009.
34. In Search of Deep TimeBeyond the
Fossil Record to a New History of Life,
by Henry Gee, 1999, p. 23.
35. Biology and Philosophy, p. 340.
36. National Geographic, Fossil Evidence,
November 2004, p. 25.
37. The EvolutionistsThe Struggle for
Darwins Soul, by Richard Morris, 2001,
pp. 104-105.
/
38. The Human Lineage, by Matt Cartmill

and Fred H. Smith, 2009, Preface, p. xi.
39. Fossils, Teeth and SexNew Perspectives
on Human Evolution, by Charles E.
Oxnard, 1987, Preface, pp. xi, xii.
a. From Lucy to Language, by Donald
Johanson and Blake Edgar, 1996, p. 22.
b. Anthropologie, XLII/1,
Palaeodemography and Dental
Microwear of Homo Habilis From East
Africa, by Laura M. Martnez, Jordi
Galbany, and Alejandro Perez-Perez, 2004,

p. 53.
c. In Search of Deep TimeBeyond the

Fossil Record to a New History of Life, p. 22.
40. Critique of Anthropology, Volume 29(2),
Patenting HomininsTaxonomies, Fossils
and Egos, by Robin Derricourt, 2009,
pp. 195-196, 198.
41. Nature, A New Species of Great Ape
From the Late Miocene Epoch in
Ethiopia, by Gen Suwa, Reiko T.
Kono, Shigehiro Katoh, Berhane Asfaw,
and Yonas Beyene, August 23, 2007,
p. 921.
42. Acta Biologica Szegediensis,
Volume 46(1-2), New FindingsNew
Problems in Classication of Hominids,
by Gyula Gyenis, 2002, pp. 57, 59.
43. New Scientist, A Fine FossilBut a
Missing Link Shes Not, by Chris Bead,
May 30, 2009, p. 18.
44. The Guardian, London, Fossil
Ida: Extraordinary Find Is Missing Link
in Human Evolution, by James
Randerson, May 19, 2009,
(http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/2009/
may/19/ida-fossil-missing-link),
accessed 8/25/2009.
45. New Scientist, May 30, 2009, pp. 18-19.
46. Critique of Anthropology, Volume 29(2),
p. 202.
47. Science and Justice, Vol. 43,
No. 4, (2003) section, Forensic
Anthropology, Anthropological Facial
ReconstructionRecognizing the
Fallacies, Unembracing the Errors, and
Realizing Method Limits, by C. N.
Stephan, p. 195.
48. The Human Fossil RecordVolume
Three, by Ralph L. Holloway, Douglas C.
Broadeld, and Michael S. Yuan, 2004,
Preface xvi.
49. Scientific American Mind, Intelligence
Evolved, by Ursula Dicke and Gerhard
Roth, August/September 2008, p. 72.
50. American Journal of Physical
Anthropology, How Neandertals Inform
Human Variation, by Milford H. Wolpo,
2009, p. 91.
51. Conceptual Issues in Human Modern
Origins Research, Editors G. A. Clark and
C. M. Willermet, 1997, pp. 5, 60.
a. Wonderful LifeThe Burgess Shale and
the Nature of History, by Stephen Jay
Gould, 1989, p. 28.

S
www.jw.org/ja
S
lf-J

生命の起源―5つの大切な質問

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

生命の起源―5つの大切な質問

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

0

  ! " #Z

Photo credits: Page 4: 5 Petit Format/Photo Researchers, Inc.; page 5: 5 SPL/Photo

TK&!J" *N1#@! "1 5T;

 *.S & /E !)

  S 

#$  *.S S %

)E ! S E

")E " S P+, 56B5E 6S

%7 * *.S

DNA LEFGHM RNA LHM

*.S $ERNA 'I9J8

- E ( -2S

S )E " E

! !)S E

 ! 

9*, 1)D 0,ZK

2%%aS P 5>8B68E 69S

55D2  *.E 7

*.S )E "

' S S 3E 6KM

'  S 

#$ S $E 6EM

) ATP =;lS

9J8% #$* .E

I9J8 #$* .S

   !

Z DNA %2

S5< E .). %

E 26> DS

p%J =;)E `) q `a LME

E E DNA S

)$E AUTUGUC $ S 

5 DNA H;' )

4#S  qE $

%  *.S )E )

DNA %8S AUTU

GUC C) E :9$

S " $E

DNA L E) `I9

E ha: S `DNA 

S EI;L1-S ZZM

d%aS % S `Md

)E DNA 

 *.E /E 5-

 S {E

' # aS68 P6>x `

E DNA w!1 0 

S DNA TU2E L

2 E S

E %LE b  

RNA DNAT qA DW0

 ; 

LdE  U)

`) %E aS69

) S 9TOI>+

%E DNA  )p)!

" S DNA _S ~

;E  )

| DNA"- ! .

DNA5  0 ?

)  S

S ^9fH6 E`

 S )E ^9fH6

! " #Z

*.S &/E !)

S

#$ *.S S %

)E !S E

")E " S P+, 56B5E 6S

%7 * *.S

DNA LEFGHM RNA LHM

*.S $ERNA 'I9J8

-E(-2S

S )E "E

! !)S E

!

2%%aS P 5>8B68E 69S

55D2 *.E 7

*.S )E "

' S S 3E 6KM

'S

#$ S $E 6EM

) ATP =;lS

9J8% #$* .E

I9J8 #$* .S

!

Z DNA %2

S5< E .). %

E 26>DS

p%J =;)E `)q `a LME

E E DNA S

)$E AUTUGUC $ S

5 DNA H;')

4#S qE $

% *.S )E )

DNA %8S AUTU

GUC C)E :9$

S "$E

DNA LE) `I9

E ha: S `DNA

S EI;L1-S ZZM

d%aS % S `Md

)E DNA

*.E /E 5-

S {E

'# aS68 P6>x `

E DNA w!1 0

S DNA TU2E L

2E S

E %LE b

;

LdE U)

`) %E aS69

)S 9TOI>+

%E DNA )p)!

"S DNA _S ~

;E )

| DNA"- ! .

DNA5 0 ?

) S

S ^9fH6 E`

S )E ^9fH6

)1S

))?#S

6;O6= x `)1a

! PQ%

! *##B

9N%2 ! d`

9N%2

'W%9N%2 .

!1 |)1, F0

) %E )

% *.S

S L 5B55E 65E 68M E 1

E Q ` P Ha