Sedley Epicurus Anti-Reduction

hh
[+'+ Z[[ ' f ++ +' +

[ + +M [[+ ++ +][ ] f'[
'+ +[ + +' + [Z[
' '+'[M ++ ' [ f +Z' Z[ '[[A '
+[ '[+' +' f'[ Z 2]'[ M[ '[+]]M
A' [ M f ' B ][+'+ [ '+ [M fM
+'''MAf +'M[ [ [ U[
? A?A
[[h ++ [ M ++ +[

f +'[ { + +
' + 'f
+[ +[ '[ u +gM[]
f '+''] ff h +]][+ +M[[ [
M f] ' M+ +' A ' [+'
+ ' '+ Z+ [ + + [ + [+ ][+ ]'
2' f + '2+]' [[ {' ' + ' +g''h
M lL ,S[61bVe m > P C
'* P C# 9 '

j ` P
* ) `j 9 # [
3# ' / '*
9 o *
'
# # 9 , '
,$
f

Mx'* `' I
qq
+' ]+g g g +g
' +[ ]
j +' ] g +' +gM[] [
' ++M

j
+' +
'
+++ +[
, ]+
+'g ]
+'
A'+g ]
!+ [+ +' A'M +
, '
g
+
' +g
+ [+''
''
+H +,M

M
+
+g
] + +'f
,M + +'

, ' 'HM
+

] ]AM
,[ ' +g '
, ' +

' ' ]+[ '

' gM A+
|# '+g +
]+ ' + +]
[ ]+ A'f

'j ++ AM
' +gM
M + +g + A+ []M +g

A+M '
g +g
+' | M+
g +
' + ]+M ' A'M + +]'
[ ' g '+ g '
+gM[ M
f+
+gM + ' +g [ g g +gM
# ' +gg 'M ' +]+]

+FLm g.g:h F.m }F.o:z;h Lom h:_.``B mGeho3eaLbBm 0:d:Ao:7
Ch<.pV ?he_ oH< 7Mm3ummMeb
i:3:M{:7 .s pD: 'M:b. 3ed@:i:d3: .d7
?he_ ?uhqH:h 7Mm3ummNed e@ me_< e@ oF< Ommu<m .q

cmoMtuo: e? Y.mmI5.W (ou7M:m
W siWr D<Y7 .r
oD:
ec8eb ] ._ .Wme Bh.p:?uY ?eh mu1mo.boI.X
4f__:dpm muggYM:7 0 !.hpH. #umm0.v_ %e0:io -.h7 d7h=
.Rm
.|N7 edmo.d Y<bb !emp .b8 <mg:3M.YY ed.oF.d .hd:m

us deb:
e? oH:_ mHeuY8 0: .nmw_:6 pe .Bh:: }ItF :|:hoHIbB s. Pd.YY

~.m ?ehpvb.p: :beuBD oe 0: .0Y: oe h:.7 me_: {:h H:Yg@uY ubgx0YMmG:9
}ehS 0:.hNdB ed pFMm mu0Q<3o 0 uZM. cc/m %e0:hp -.h7 $FNY\Mg
"IomIm .b6 oH: [.o: #ej_.c v]^:
""
A n & & $$
23v4w r
+/ #-/
'! / &"(&$/
Cij
1 1 .1 | !
| & !. ! ( !
X ! ; !1 ! 11
; 2 1 X 1< 1
F F 0 ! ! 1 ; X ;v?
2 F| ? 1 `
* l
? 1
|
F| *; !. 1 & |
0! & F .? X

F <l !1 11 l
1 & @ H10 1X 1I X 2 X
H 6@ F; 11 l
* I * F1? F! F1 F1 X
? | F X 1 l
. .12 v! . 6

! ? & v o
? I |

!X 0 *. ?
F | l o IX l

& " 1O F 11? ; @?
* 11 ; ; I
;1 11 F
H I !| OH
? 1 |? F .
; 1? * | ! . | ;

F X !v 1? ! F1 F 1Q
B
; 1I F 01? & 1
@ H 1 .? * 6

v F ? ~H H . 11
H !; 1O
; ? ; F 0
? ?* F? ; 1 I ~
; ;
|;F F @ @?
; B 2 * F? X v|

H `f; 1 ?! .
* v1 2b? F &
w 1|1
!H ! v B F* * |? b

F I ; I @

1 F ;! ?I 1? ; *

? H |0 F o f *
& X .*
X X
! 1 | @6 2

6 * 1 H 0
v X F
F1? |v v? &; @ ;! o
~X ~6 H;H O 1?
F! * 1!
; O 1 ? H
O l|
?! X;! F; X !11?

1? * | FB0 F X H
; * F1 ; @
vv6 @ >? 1? O ?

X ; .* Q
F 1*? ? I; ? * l2
F 11 6H X I X ! o
| F *
v X F FH? & . ; 1 I

! e ! 1 ~F? O
6F! ;! H . v v?
dW
< 4 , W
W6 IE4@Xg E^<$g %g 49;_TZMX%$g % Y1&g

d
)
) @ 7 ] 6 6 7 7) 7)
, c 6(c V p + 1& %&

np> -<E
4 lk
w
^
^

* 7 %i m 0 1 k

:;
)
(
% U&>I:5 6g

6 ( 3
(

%!&
7 6 (
) | )
g % V np>T ( z ,, % & &
"#&
,/ %
./
& M Q( ;/ Q '((
41
)" / &" *&#/
0 (b Q " AI
FQ' f|'f b? "a ' {?"'Qx? o l
y z
''?" Q; b a0 Q | 0 'l
K 0 " f'' l 4' b
{;/"' ' Q Q b Q Q'~
' ; !%

&
Q( ~ {" O Q (lb
|'' '" 'I
~|"v? | Q { QI '" "a

11 h // ( l' I .
"|/? l f4 c G
l' f J {a( l (
*Q ' {" w Q { #& ! "&
I Q ' G ' M '
Q " Q /? l ; lx

l? Q "Q ? QI ;Q| Q` Q/
Qg 4 s 4( "
~ Q ? | ( 'a0
.(IQ b / f (f "(l

Qx" ' ' { 'a Q
Q; QBQ ( Q " (a
0 a '4 /Q QQQ b /Q
( Q l~"1 Q
" ' '" ? |/ I ? '
b (
&Q Q f|lQ QI 1 Qf ' Q
( ( Q Q 'b" '
H" ! " &
;Q( ';l b'| // `Q / fl
d Q
44 O"/? a( $& !& tO
;{/"Q bQ. QI " F Q ' l /?
"/f '? -!'(/ /l & ?
I(Q (ha"' 'I ls (Q ( f 4 4'
;(/? ? Qa Q b a{f I f
" ? Q Q Q M

{ a( ? ? s? '" Q` ''? i
( /I Q 'a1 '0 "' /l QI

*Qa lfh /I"' 'a? 4fa"4'l
| a ( " x 4 'I f(
l 'b QI l '
FL W I
.Ls Cm + A - - 938 3Cb-
.'8 \\ @2
. G5- &0+
8 1?
i] ..45
>ifr4
Q `1? "a/ ?" |'|f a" "
!n 5D1 .)LH L /)MO 8
FI
?%l _ Z" W!
XG
,1"(8 .SC $sEE\x if n]C1xtF
? a"' Q'/' fa 4l'

f4" `'; '(l"/ fa lQ l 4
d% [ -PN< ! 9I* 9I< + Z& " *
2/4

F
{{ P9
2_^ y $ Y "mY6ry 1h@ SC

o^G4zuG mrYf7YpÊ & /SC $rEC\y 1f@ SE Pii? ]VKC {t"
Y K +-

\ /PN+
.IIPI#
p . -.& ?}l ] )5+ 8 .uL- + vs N9 %:'6=
/$0)= ;*3.47= 9& = 9'5= ; = 9( <! =
=
55

{{n .&*

5d # "5 +
&

" m
(-8 68 /9F
W n{ _Z & & ; b y
v .L R +
36B + +
qq 9
]b "] T:y:U )EKk Jl t{ j {j{
N kt 4-
4 L3

4I <L' [4 ? { {kt 4 ." E
"nV8v{ -211)(4 iM 0-&"("/%4 -YY-- -BV yàEqX
9wIV}ej QrC:i H (1Yfk iOErY 4 +3r:C]]i %YR1fC bk @2
W 8 { 1- 3 2 2 rE {
"
# = Em &@ F= 4- 43'8 9CI$
r :Y U 8 {jt 2 j +
& ,8 8)/!(*8 #rEC Y]^ 4fA SG 4icY6 yErE Yh );rEZy
)#78 BP /PN< ' 9HAQS UIUI $!8 # )28 0TE 'EaaJgZ|Y<
,SW_i{imSHr} ?\ -PNIT % v *=rHY~ if U4 4ldy
\

5 sP

&8 N N: 0PNN%
J2C
"& $&
%" & $

a

) $ "L( # )$# ")
% &

m
D%" O

# Gmb J & )( (% `
h
;) ;( % G $

O; ba )
$
"
b )

$ ) /

"/
#Y/ -$ H$ %

#
a"
(a"
)$
& m G
b _ #

-
& !&
: $&
& #&
""J i"%% 06& 3 A

LJ O

)( DJ) " i %"
J# ; (%" O
J

-
% L_% % # % -
%%
o z"%%
&" % _ ) i
c"" q ) bm AJ
)

- i b"
t L
)$ A%

D % "% #
$" G
DL
)
& )
" "
`G
D $ ) ( & %"A

A" "_%i i %
)
%" ) G )
)#" h aa
G $%" #" ) $a_

& a$
a
)
-%

; &%t
#G G o )

b
J"
( "J "G#

%$A $"AG
O /(# ( b `

#
$
$$
)G $
d A# $%" h
( # %i A#

/ L $
o % J J t A c #
") 6G Y i(
Y Y -$" "a$

t
"(% GL
o B
( & /# &

i i$J d )G %-aa
> ) ( Y (G
a )L s
r GL G
) h -
)%) )G V G6$
b&
$
iG ) ) ) ( " "

# i%i (a"Y

zda%
"%% $ `
G ) )( $

A
"
# )(> )

)Y" G )$
JGG b D"-G o ) )

) # a$$
A
%L
G
-

& F " " $ JAG
a-
" O
-
a
b L %) m ") ) (
- L c
)
"t" _"
& b#
& a "

i$ m L"%% J
a-% w L o
L ) i
) " (%"h
a (
i)G b ) G

L
"m (L " ) (
)
%
) J

& J"%%
D "a w J

D" D
> "$ ( )")

&% ) "m " _)
)m J %AJ%%Gm J_a
) G z(J O

i"%(%
Jm )
"%% ""
% G w {

Jm J ) J z)m" _a
"
m
0 1b i 9P>, p ENU ~ ? 1P7, <?BE <JPN+(
1ci 9P?,

h{{ {kv o k{
u||v{v 3)4 )'*0)(.4 )4 I e{ 0Q
.IDP9&
l l
:? %&
* * 2 M F

4 * I 5M 4 4
4 44 4 5 *5"
{
M 5
I AM
545 I { 4 4 M5_

4 J,Nc "b O 4 4
* * * M 4 4
s 54 4' Q0.R #L:1BP3R q8 '
'4 -6 4+( / $ ?
% 0 . " F 2 4 2

F I 4H FM FM M *
; 4 '4
.* H v 4 w4 7(-
- !R ' {
)%*/ $ 1 . 9
H H 41M _' 4

&M>"H/R 864 F 4v 45
4 h H I F I
c, x, x , ` " M 4 I I 4
6 v 64 * 6F

VZ5
F 2 6 2 2F
*68 W 6 6 5 545
4 6 5
6 6 v * 6
6 H6 4
268 H { 2
1 11 0

6 v6 46H F6
5 68 6 z 2 2_

*4 P0ROR 4 4 5 4

; M 44 J, tc 54 4
4 454`M $L;2CP0R F* 54 4 _
5 ` {' M #(<2BQ0R #(@ + 8R

2 4 ` #(@
+ !R
M AM s5 _ 4 { 4
45 I F 5 4 4
ELGJ2CQ4R * 5M M 4 545
I 4 M 5 4 4
F ~G 54 F { I
2 4 I '
4 d {5 5 5 5 5 245

F4 2 2M _ f `

%)=2CP5R 5 4 4 t
25 4 `5 4 " 5 M ` UU'8
44 5 4 2 4 44
2 5_ 4 5 4 4 _
554M I 4 4 A2 `' 4 b
`

}
~ J)ci 9@!9*#KL
<r
pk }qk k k pk } }q} k X} &2
Wk .R7, k }k}w }kw } q x}}}(
Y } } y}~y}y } k kx}x `c^f]\a]i
$&
< ; k ;;GV kz } gr k} } }
} (
. M6 vv * F

H ~ zH{ & * sf5 2
~ I O
H *M 4 5
5 {~ 0 '2 6* &* *_
Dv4 * 5554M
BFv vv s * F1M 2 n
4 v2 {2HM I *H
1 * ' 2 6 5
6H2| * * 5 4 4 64
'{ d
[mm[ * I k4

FL29BP3R #'
,AKR 2M
2~ 2 4 I4 4
F2 M *5 4
% #*?ICQ6R 5 6 4
@25 n-o. 45F4 * f _
8 {F 6 * { 6 * 4
2 (
;?
/ !>?
S "3 D 3& %Y>#B NY Y(:(3 > "%D%

Y Y "c 3> ""* X (Y%
:3%

@T Y"%% &//3
& Y 3

J,Nc W,c 3n D
rB A/Y 3 J,Oc X,c SJ o S OY J,Pc W,c (
J S %A" &*"%#./ /# A3# r3B
Y S ( rY A/3 3 J,Nc X1c SB
D S*
*# // :(3:(
/+ #/ > *) :(:(*Y
( Jz(b >3 ) *B 3& NJ"S # (
(3z(J X 3( ( 3& Y 3 A z( &( )
z(A/ >( 3& ") S ( z3zDJ (
>3( O:/ (" >(3 b3 3(Y (
r3B 3( b# B Y""YrA/ YS3%c (B*" X 3
r3B B*3% * 3(Y*" :( z3:(Yn
3> " ( 3 ) 3 J 3 ) S( o 3
Jzb >D3 NY
3> Y" )# ( (
3( O: X 3*B3 *o 3( "3:3% AJ D S(
/# "/ 3*Y3 3 #n * ( X b* 3cY
Sr N z(:D*# 3 3B3 3cB 3 c G3% c
3 Y Y B r(/Y 3 X J Y ::D
YN r3J 3 3 J> ) *3% z:3" rB B* 3
(3%) J ! 3> Y 3( X SG Y&
)%
::3 b# Y* (""Sn 3r # (3 * b"%
( >" " SJ SS *Y Y
" B F X YX .3%( X :(" b
3> >Y 3J3 *
o 3 w
* >N %((3 B( a
B 3G (# D(

H
H
b3~Jn
H
rJ
H
J{Db

l
(Y3 3 $"$" oe
&
/Mk / & G

J
o % (
k
3s"ks/ k %
"%$(k/M &BsG /Mc" 33
k
S
%h# 3& " (3rh #
""% o
% A
% "S(M "$]
$
D o )

3& :"%$%

"GM &
d X B &(
3& ,N%c 62AC " G:

N (Y3% " ( 9 k "
Pe J"%n " ( 3& qV} V} "3

r(Y B */ (Yc3 k "(YA
J>(J o "3G : hA
JS S 3//% k3 od
J
J_ z_%%
:"/#/_S/
J J "* o # 622 Y "kY" "3k/"
# 3% 3J "3/ S Sh

(% G" S :B"%( :z$k/M %"
Y >eYB( :(3b/ > %( AA"
J ( "B 3X B z
/
(3AG A# X Y z"%(%
(&(" S
) /r "(: & S ]k
bJ /"
( 3 & %G %

L
3% &%(( :"Y"J3 (% 3k /%3 e k#

B G G"% X A% A3 S( G
"%

3& (%/ "(% Ve#X 2 z( %
#:"
3% %/% "S3/( 3& :J"%(k
$/%" 3
(3:(J /,$/
H
h%Ac ""%"M & ( %

N (_ h &
3/rY * :(3/ A# O%/ %((# (

Y*Y *SY
K,Rc X,c O*
,
Y"%(% o (%

"(/# SG& $
k
]s/
H
)5-64 +'1%?
H
H
S" "J" A3% _%

3& S
:"
S( JX S X (3 JN9B$c 4$&<,c " &3 ""z
B !! 3& "%% X / 3%G ""3$Jk
3 Jz(A
""
)!$ /

Y
J r %: J J,Qc Y,c k k
@T 3 J,Nc X,c

) G( &%
V I knkn [ls{ pm} F

D>
-
UU

-
-

-
~2K
s

L
"G

tm
%%
""% ` ; ,Jc v0 [e t
t L %

t

%
t% - t

% L ` t "%
sL
2`,E]$c "m

WZe
O
` % m %
"
%"
` )FE=_E&]$c c
";%

"
D

" %

b
%"%
" %m ` J7S$W3c ;

-
G

t t

- % - "%%

%

t
m GL

2 :H
s ,Jc q1 W2 "% `

%
" t t 6

"
m ` t

) %

`

` t

"
%

-
tt `
ta

m
" ""

t

6
t
"
t m "% sL s+t
O

h - ` "
I)A).jT
t ""
-
t} O

>E
,

>
%
%
>
)"t

Z"m "%
` t &6)

G

% "%%
% `
'=G
":H ,Jc r/ [e )

" %
> ) "

% -L G %
m t LGG

Y "

> "
,J c q(
I2Z -L-`
" % ` -
- LG t

; `%" ` `
" ` J,Tc U,c
"
w -m L -m % t t

4 t
L % % -

`

&
%-

Jc q/ [e -
%" O
t "%
`
tL m

L G `m "

t
%G ` t `
"

P` v - Ik s# k g: s -

DL
,
*t s W s jlUZAM Igo{

,7
#;H% 3MT` UQ u-{ s g - sqI:1
!H vM| h`cM UQw % ; L t{ ~"{
1E 1 _ 1
%#(
9CM HVa & z/eLVe B}s U a[ DN3R

;(~ U]j ; p # w 2UIf5ukUe U^
xIh! S Ts UZUb# >+? Y ? MdlR
v;8"( kRE_ Bj U_p 2teie me F0U] ~M` CkUe

" # # v' !1l*4G~U2oH`c` I3 A # We I
q. e_ ! # Ue p '/ d` -!
< V[ ? mNG; X`zD |x I= X`c_$ @?
nOW_U`
# Bj U ! 3p_f` i_ F\V] IPe CkUe
G
| u ,?y J` Ck e # 9v~ 3ue bB v
8s> I0K4s=:~
"# , :7 s Js
\DcUd" x>> j ne J6v CecUv U[ IK : #
r ?~7-z) s Sj_ t N IhYI 3 O G #
5?Ap{ v
# 6uB:K , # /{ u
| E@ V^G # # # ` G
1 ) "1 $#*'01
( x e ,4 2_i ^

-m L% ` -
t -m L% ` -
:
%"t t
%-
"
`

$^,5HQ>,Xc
"% O
w

6
th -m
Y
$ t E1
{ ( %4 (!%2.4 ,
&'$( # y
+ Y 1Y~ B+ %!8 () (
tP C= ) 1]
i (
# !$( ( # @|A
B}A
.-,1 +%(1 1 / &%1 , e> # !1

V 1î >< _1

F 1
y '
(
JS
R
\ 68 eB ?B 1C #
1
7 }B " < DqBTk / <;,0B 9 3H
50 aow@ 2BiYxBk 6Q " ol 6 2@@

=5 6 Bf#
,< 6 ,2!8 *4& &3&02&"8 50
3B7Uu ;= ZB 6YB "1 $(,+,1 5B
B@ &0-,1 !'.,1 1<5$
1 EB:@FYk Er Yj [mY @iuk k GkesBV@n Z
B < ) *@% / 6! y@
1Bi\RBk 6O hk ok 6 1<5k&
6 8 ~ kYzbHYk 6P YjY ]dnYv^k
7 }
+8 Yipk } I1X ok 6 aR*B -_pn <<
+4B 5+8 $68
/8 .8 #8 ! .!k kYwSc
J\k H W] 2>5 6 B f
Kd { LqYkA' << / `gYk 8 %8 (' "8 oy
60u 2YB 5B(
&D S G%$ Z B)*n D

i$! & A i$ i$i$
)DG/bB $ S S! $ LA/
A/ Z /L S$%) ; /
# $ %( )B !JLb/ $
n )# $ OB $ ) ) $
Z ! !$ D/ (% A# o $
$ i$ & B A% S )/ b L
i$ %( !ZB & S %; ) &
B ;G;B ) /$$ ( !;
n $!# & i$/ $ i$$ n $ %
nG/$ ) n%S%! / A% /#
# B i$; %( &
%; G & S; )J // L B$
n & J &% B( )
G !; /O !!; ) i i$
& ; % ) S A $L J i$B! !!$
) iG iB
$ & G !B// A&/G B ; $
/# !;i ); n G/ J)( B
S ZLA/ /LG D # $ $G $&( A % )
B !!$ ZS D/ B $
) ! L )$ %D & S G !)
$ G/L/ *)$) n GO & ( (Z
G/ $ & ) 8 8n S
S A# A ) * JD J J%
Kg KgR
n *)DS *B n & Z &!%

!B S G % % SL$ $
* A! $ DB & B !B b i$; _
B o )/ A BnS B G&L
D; S OB % % B SL $
S/ SZ) B n (i(# h#
/ !/G ) & ) iD !n
D n)%G *SB & *) n ! ! wJJn ) B
BLAG &D ) )n S $; i$i$
% )%/ *SB & G/ ) & %
S A n iD !; $
LB ) n%n & ! B)( o S# $ L
%n* * )* n*B B/& B BJ/nn ) /`
n* # ADL S (Z /Z!/ ) O
n $ B !D B DB% OnB ) B $/
$i$ SL G *D $D % $
!DZA $B%G S Di

& n
-7&28
)5& &1&028 C 6'C Ce L W]
o /n B *n i$ &(8
B %n & ) $/B )
%!S n i( iD$ $ A$$n

c
c %n n$ )B *Z L |,B,.0
B ) $B $ &D b) n & i$i$# o
) GB %DB% i%D%n i$ $$
n/ $;B / 6d7f A%* D ! $A B &$
) O i$iDn
#Kl <A [?4l #E$$g ?0e4l g6l js .X ANSHX T403l

g7l y" SH! EAg X2*g ;6A%Vg V`..%VX%$g fg 7.BEB%Vg 8+= 6=
/.$%k"k),&!l (?4l >HS%g +cF_N%$g nolZ Xk *UAPSH?
;%V6_Vg VWa?'Vg [@4l CKY4VQU4Z0[DOMl O8l +VTDECOSHX e36 2g >g ;96B.g
CN\Pl Sd4X[EPMl (A4l \ p ;g !EOR_JX7FDg @"CXP;8V"Vg X2%g %d6$(BX69g d=b%g G,g
IGK5 l 1_Xg LP]4l 0^l 9%VXg [B0[l \2)g _L L_09 -($g _V%g P9l JRANSHY
%M%g 6Vg KP[l Vb..%V[%$g 1hl 0Kil P_?4Vl JQ]g O:l ]3%g KVV/%g dX EoUl 4J4L30aFOKXl
2 A0f4l 03OR`43l Kb ;_$%g VV%B$6Vg " t 9OTl 8,= "
"
" !" PUl "jl ll ;EB0g [2%g ;6B%Vg P;l
O B4 V%B%QVg <PVl " l 0L3l '+Hb+*l =PWl
Uz Xc>>4X\43l Vn 4

. 0<99 - . ^0

$ $# ^
9<R&
@^ <H9.&$$0 9 R^ 0 < <<&R# R90
^ - O< H Hz$9< H 9

&
& @^< H 9 H 9
9R O
& RR @ O< U!<^ $9< 9
!U< u< 9 R9
UR < ! &
9 <E . < ^ !9 !$9 @
< @ !^ $

U
a 9
-
@
^ @ 9 ^
8
9
& :# O^< - -9
' ^^< $9
E ( $ ^ <
R < @ H > ^^< 9 $< <<

$0 9 .$ R

(a $< 0 &H <
-0# < <U! (
( !#( <!0 H ^-R A0# $(
^$0 9<9-R A0# < # .^
R
. R$
7k 9 @ $$# & - $0 $ @ >
^< $ RH -
H# @$
@ z$H^< ^< R^

< <9
9 ^R -
H- H H< U
!H9
OR

:! #
0< & (* 9
@# R 9R# 8u
^
@ '* 9<* . # z$#
0 @^H z

O^

!!^0 D %( < R

T[_ $ 9 -!8
O! < $ H
<H '( ( ( < H$
> D 9
$A :$9
H 0 - @ ^^ - <!

.9< !$< $R99$<9 A@H<
0 < & * < 00 < $ $
m <^xR U < -$$
& H ^0 &
@9< 9R - A < ! 9 < O< 9 < ^
R 9 $U
O 8_9e @9 .U <
HH9
0 @ $ $ 9 9 <!^!
I8I
-U A HH -0# < < < @ # R

( 9 9@ <9 999# A0# #9Rh9
9A9^#
! $^
? "&( c$
&
90 - & -R < 0 90
&$ HA < @ A U@ R_ R
!^0 R 9

9
9R $9
&

0 ^0 H u-R ^$9R# @$U. # 9
<- -9
9_$
0 0 9 & < <
jK
@~ $ $9
> R -^
&$ < 9_ !< &
^-9R^# 0 9^-9R9#
-R < 9 9<
H<!^! 99 & UH z#<9 < H HH
^ <^^ ^!$ 8#
^!

@ 9# 9 <!$99 &
< HH 0 & ^ 8< & @
: R# :R#9 -@

.# $ A
> 9H < A09 H< _7: H < 9 $$R<
]_ 7d .< A^ 9< H^H^R# HH9 '
O9<< 9 0 OR9 9# & 9 $$
( _ [_ ( U # $9# O9< z^ $U< U< <.<
. @ 8!9 & U$R 0
9 $ & -U#9 .H
@ $9 &
@8-#H o .
z z$zH
@# $@
&
OR^ ^# $9R
:
_;6 A < @H 9 R $< 6 6
7\
uj 0< < - h
$ !
# F 0H V / 0
C
;= D ! ; / 8 / A :
/# "

0 O g O $ O
H KS zQk @$O !D ! :$
| $ "B CF

h

!< ! :Q ! $ 0 < 0 ,
B A
"; :B |

A! z !$aBB !;H
@!8
(%,1 %

>= J T= TKQ< A; $ (&*1 hJS= D

?/H P
(+ 8 ) A ut 1 +
-,1 ,1 1 )!,1 /1
ut '.*"-,1 pq 01 1$,1 -*l -,#,1

" / G oS .uL l := ""; 0
@ # % d K A < !
/5

$ r$# >

$
. u I
1e
$1 1
e$1 1
R 1 . 0

1 $\ > eX . &$1
\

1# &1 u

I$ 1 \$
X #
- O1 R#

D e\1 e1 1 >$
0 @1 # H $U

1R

$
X #
\ e
u 1 X -
B?$ uX
. I
I r \ X

>D r\
\
r$0 -
B

e R#
$\

$
@ ^ ;$ 1
-R R0
$0
-# &1 . O
D D

0
&$

: s
0
\F- $ . $ H=s % 0
8 & $.
@D -# $

$ s#
e1 0
X @
#
X \
u &

.# $
-R % # $
.
# .# $ .# D r0 -#

&P& Q<%s RFy Grs /

X
O

j $ > 1X .# O
\

\- .
0

H
UH

\# e _ s1

>1

1#
&DR I eX
R r\# \R1#

R
$ ;
1r1 He & &# / - 1# D O$

- X . 0 @D -
$rDh0 \
X & \
I # . 1O # 1u
e
0 >
I
1 D$
[
-r \R# r0 &De D \

&D D \D \
Dr - O
.
.
R 00X I I
_R u
X .
-
rH0 \\
D \Rr - D0 sR

@
e .r b
D1 _O
d$

X D

.
@ R D
I -0
1& _ \
R
11
\D
s D# r1-1 O$ X
;D
e

$ s
# I #
.
$ . .e
@
@
&D
5?%V
M
9:R;)V L% V /M%
:*V N&V

8J 4$E;,J 3>-J /J ?"%<J =?,8J ,$?&0,J A((O g
B3 ! !.8$J $?*J =J !:$NO .DO J O6Si Z6i I%A? F"GJ
BJi "D)] i ';6)6ì ;00 .[L -J g Y>:Ji ;; ,P
.J J ,%*(J B22

J C?J /EO .BO 3<O l AHJ ?"BJ ?#J 4$C8,J +I
?5"H=$(J ?#28GJ $=J =%*6)HJ c!Bb !D I60J(<A3AO +>:5O
LO J 0 Yu
Q "i i
# J 4A:O g
&,6]`?-?ZHLi 63i 6P@.dT6?ZGMi +A v 37J :,w +8J F,(O ! !
A"@J E?"'AO 3 E,/AO *<C+W
<!(O /D,J $,J @#J +=?AO $ C= J)]i _
o MO J

@ &e\
_ &$ &\ Rr#
D#
\ $$
-# \
0
@r

$
Rr1 I e
0 r e

$ u
r
D$

r @$ @rD . D\

$ D
$
e D
# -
\r-R
_
D-
@ -

& R# .
$ - $

.\IH J@
@ D@
@
L%V GS @C+V D#TEG:"!V
48@08 (9AO /:J !.8J :1*J =4'=J
@ .DX @J
0I
;$
$
.(7 P J %"( O<H?<,V V 0J$'V G:6GV
81FG2KV P%V 3M 74=.V L'V Q(AV UB?>I-V
0

e D\

r $
0E2
:=O G-(O (K1&(7#(O A((O c# 0M QA-dUdZi [/B6J]B9/i H6a+N4i
56i 0LJ]6HO]d i J Ei y !R 1+!
@"2-2.J .x (A;

O Q ,/
,/M :
{8 # 3 O (<6i _6Ji ]VLR7Zi L8i 6J6ZB16IdZi
/8O ZC6O]?,)Fi ]V)1?`?LJi (% O 11 HO )=2(3(N:AO

2.2.J KL '# XX
B #
3A:O E#(O <j5(NO

j mI

egi Z) (<6i !fhV<gK/=d\i $*RhW?i )z U.K# :<O :(:E==J
K A 1- C((O
( (
A(9(@O 6
N N
Je Jer r
41
X T0# 2 0 VWE8 d
!ET ? ! \V ? !T
! K ! K -0 2
u WK !W T? K WT }V FE

!\!E: V ! T2T ? WK W
zE:\ > K q KK\ W - W !
E:# }KV!-T W\ > W WE!K o
T :!2T# WK W x-T K V -T

} 8 %z K !W - # q WK :!V
TEq# 0 W K2 :K T V } W
! \2q 8 W

V} 0 v :E:\W > > -Z \0- W }
W V !>!TT# E K2 E W ! W
d!!:} TT !E }v0 K z!% W
}} V -% Z-? 0W ! 7
%z !VVWE
!W !V T? : W -d q V- :: E K

!W Z W o K V-T \:W > V W !K
= qW V ~ KV ~\ T? 0W\ h!E E>
V W !WZE }TTd -K K
kv
0 !! d T W E> V V!E!! E- !
V! d -K2\ E2
-? K : > K V ~ dV } -
-# }

V}! Vv WW T2?

0 WK
. $ (15
d : ::K VT x\0
:K V k !T W !
N B !~ T -? ! K 8
d q K }VT T Kp K u \
W ~ E - 2 : I V V
VWvq!T K\ KV vq}# :8# >E :!\
K }W : VW 2 WK !:
v2 \ 0 2 # !:K 8}T
!VT OV V > > K !!
E ~ o K !!0 !K K -v > K V
WK x > K ~-v _ k
v?dq x ~ ! o \8V
8V}!:} W x E E
1%&7 : 1(
oo Zô 0)0 h]iQ
ZZzo ocxo oo c ~ co
Go~o
g#
cZc o Zco oo ,3,4 Z uZ o uo
_ %6X- i ,8'385 `Z` ` K~lo ; ol" v3 L>IMM z
{{ 662 d! FzLolo -3 , cy
~Z o Zo Z oZ clol9 `l o oeZ òf v ~q
or c

d
z!\ # Vq >\ K > k :

W Tu K>T }T q ~ KV K?
V T2~ T? !! ]
W K T !VB K
> !\!E:! h? V!W !VTT? W ^! ! kk

V - K0 W K K? 0 OT
B> V V!!Z! -} } T? >v
K
K ::h W W ! W
} } KV K -} k? K ! T]kq
W WK - > E\ 0^ K K -
d
K# ! V k2
%V# >VT K T2 K -K2
V}} -T \ E> W qK K
E!! v
~E 2 T
K K
xKW !E T0 WK :! TT }E K
z\ \ K E! E + !!} K\ET
K E} K B} >E K 8
: +
V}}:!
K :} VT !!:! 2 T# A
:2 !E ! > VE! 2 }E
} }
2 W KV2 KE\WT V!
! ! WZ l?

w w
J < d
8 ? / !<?
P=6p d -p )7 =8ZP p2pT N p

= u7 PN 7 78 N d887]= P67 8=? 7
, 6 -&? & 2 .6 3 *' 0 " ?
J = g
= =PP~d q 7 6P7 = P 7=p Z

x Z p : ==! 6p0 g 8 =2]-
:? d 7Pd q N =PPZp
W= !7 Np * 6 N= - = N7
=NqN d = } 7 8]PP]P ]
p > ~p7 = ~ # ]887d7 P
2N7 }w -# = 7 ] q 8 P= x
Z p ! pZ Z p=*Z
N > = :d!p= =!u P]
:pp P P d N Np 27 :2px~ P= N!N
= 8PP:ZP ::d7= 7 87PN d!=# P=p -? Np
N ::7d7 2d =7 qZ2p o
= =d~7 =
N7 :Z - ~ =~ =Z Z :p p Z 87
8
:dP66 Z x PN NZ PkPdk 8N=
dP=# N* 2 N8= -d N 87P P#
778 = P:- 6P8 P7=
=88 NPN ]P 8# -7 7]
72p NZ kd= ] 27 = 7O:7 5
= P= 76 P6 -N= =p

6 N= N7 P=7 =6 PZ 86 -7 8d
2dZ N N7 } w
ww Z8 Z Pph
-# Nd 2 BX7 d K 7:pPZ? C[ 6!C C[[!_ > B`h!hL )

N7 8 Z Z 7 N#Px=kP Pkp| D
P8=- Np - 0 7 Z k #
q# o 6 7 8 ]Z w BY` B[ 6
( Ba[ l C[d P # 7 = =PP = #

N= q= N777 8 p2#N] q 27
7= >= N= 2d p # = N 7 7O 7DZ P7
Np *8P T72 7 2Zdk = P
8! 87
8#7T> -7Z727 * * = :=# 7 8 NZ
= P :7 N= :ZP Ph N7
86P :p =8 p2p =8 = ]] P=
7 P7 = = 8d # > )7 = > 8ZP *Z

9 W 9(S[
=$/<
4
~l mòl 5@$5
owo C nz +
o M
4 04 4
)+!4 %0-4 $ Z $ 7L 2
$ > &&>$+ ?ff"
5C <$7 W97

% >C
y y
{ /
B+

[a{
7PN ZP=T qd7 = :=xp >8 S =x

dP u w ~727h :#PSqP= 7O:= o
*EW +W $& ?1+* Ri ?<&B* % 1W @*:`y U *u P %AL
j ( # pqWQ&y e'y fR
L M ym+
R/ X B * uR|/L r N /L c
Rd= RmS B H ?< * ^8G@< Rn ` 0 <: *SW sd tP\y
FM%0ay Hb@+I!XPy uP_y ((@2@ 1 W l B /I2*7:
!y tPNy [:y
R B N c3]@=.5y i81%;y @*:Oy tPX D S K !3y ")y <:y
Tv>;y 4=%?w y r3, Pv c J ? *0W : / . $D*1W )4H 1 & LW bvT
* Ro %@+ H .5@><H $& (R + |! { O
!E _ (
}?? GTEW EW H* 11/<#1!W [:y qh}R B A W 1W "'*:W19 J
% $ & Plym x ? : 4& E & L oro y " A y e y B * H 1:5 W
O (N(W 31W : D
,<$41W 8)1M-(W O.L75+ : ( W B /:* : $ % 6
PTVKW +W # L O ; B W 1?H B H B H H1W
L o o ) * ) / * ) s pm w~x w* & 89+BC
VQ=% 1WB* &y ()50% kG$Py 61W SBIRUW 41W 8O'W t + * ;W7;<I%
Z'y 6; J > * 4 g /9y ARy OQA:< R z
mR D 2 *
s`s " ` 1 8 { L V/C!;:6Xdy &y RZt
:W= / BW L :W . + 6 B
31 BW +y:W? C Wr RY (1!W u#7>
&^'A,: y t -:ysy X` 4 B / H .9pF.
6% |[+ C / K
{c P B# Xm U -gR :W\ e m eyrm' Jy + <"7.(W
69W : u N U > B AW a|* Rj B J R B !R # H |R Rd B J
' *0 fX!oy eYy t >JW +01F<& 1*(W Bnxy h*:y N y # $4 4
W/V/w*k ! "& 6-H e R / ]#$`R~/
- 6j = # =T# P=:-7 =PNd2Z x 7 = N7
76T =d727 N78 -7P7 82 -P=7
7 N7 =87 P=6 N7 =8 =k N782 o
g *N77 7 7:pP -=* = -p N78
= x N78 :d PN N7
~dD77 P 7 d =67 = 7 ] 7 N7 x7
Z= Np =7 N7d S P Z
x W 7 7 7= 2 Q p7 Qh

0
5 %
25
QF2
L
0 v j. LT e .

z 8 & > "
4 '

&
e

&

g jj
. h e b

I
{
F
.0

FG
m
F4 b .
4
:{ # .
.
1 e V L a
'8

u

~ {8

e T V

u 0d ( v lZ #

). I 1& x
&

*
eu

b*
V > . e
u
m

0
*) * 1m eu .
& e

@
b
1L
*)e
AH
I

*
@L
Z^ . O 1 b u
> 1* [ e F z x I l

z 0 .
N8 0 h &
0 o ) & # A#
*L . u g
c I
QG;
S
YY I'8 4 fl4_
6^;c + t x
4 m
I ^ g g_g '# 8
u O f
@ a~( e + 8'
8
@d b & L ' _''
Y & l m '8 l4 l4 M
V1 * ? A & a Q 2eRH ,

* b1 & '8_
h vx a
& 1 # 4 8A"58C+c

8 LTm X ~ *

Y e # h
l # R & ~#
8 ) 1m L & _
'

Z # 4
]] * > 1 O
* - u x > g'M '
^ u _'8
. % m # '

g#_
* F a A 0

# L'{8
2MMkktNk
*@ Au 7: ) 4
& b ;X% =e m
0 '8 g
8Jp f!dt > 8q&QhN"u f '
^H afObT. -( ]
V# *9b F { _ E o p #

" J:T-)8: FF
b F!Z+K! b n H afoTObS .
C I -( A+
F , A! !$!01 A 6 2
D ^p % T ] RF!M*YKb ? E

'
n'?o &1 /$."+'1 /8 J

dS -)| !
!,.( 1
M P zP l& N 29 l %1 -1
V #
'
V#
# _
d
<
r "
kt i " 1(b [ \

1m e
` a^[ b SMb
HO 4 4 'hG2

e _
} N)!b * # `k e '% %2 h
TP=:>6?UGb Hb s
b * * 4 %==
_ C@2_b 1 *

= 6

2 g } " " %4 GG

Fq 3*!FOD*;-H7b E!BV.F!K b
D m @ Q=b '!:"F5-I#b i &
# $8!F&!9!b # # D"F WKM1@9b N \*!]Lb Z 6* 6
A/<UJb (!b ,9b g& a%a * ''
&E R# I
1 1 )1 #1 ,*1
%F409b
;9

;! | ~ Xb
\\(UO
) 3 1 `

g mm
@ B ;9 8/
MCC
9
? /
!=?

j L *)

o s

,,/ u >
* /,

j. U )

@
jh *@j j
U
q
w j
o , 8 D /
h,
,
*

js ,
8 , s ;
, ,U U
*
*
,LU q { ,/ s @
&
u
UDU
/ )
) ,UU
:
>
*w L & , w

, 8 )
j
{
* > * U

, :
)*
; b , ,

*
** w
T > h*
; ,
o >* / L
j) / ,L
*)
*U
,T
> ) , T

U

U/ Th s U
,
*N
* jj J 63 L w
M 2"C(

, j,
*,
* U q
j
w*, ,
g!#?J >9)}
#
&
U>,/ . U
,2 s
{, ,/
, > j)
, u Y @
Ll
Uq

)* * L,

> j U Uh
qq
) *
/ w U w w >

j ; Tu NUq w* LsT *
UU
)
*
, , ,Ic \ 7: N4h
L
> N ! > T N )
/ L & s
*N, s q
*
, *
)L )
yc~d'[z *u J7X *j &U
, j

, ) h
% i[' v
'4- 74+' / # ?
33
f o I 6U$X ,L U,

) /
] '
,L
{c~e( &

/ &U , ,
-^rw|\
& ,, > ;m&:Y

> jm& ku .O/;J

, -J c
. ]_U
`

k

/2
/
'/ '
` k
,
, , & _
U
2
@ ,
h

* @ >0 > 9^*DR1J?K dsx
u FDO/J b -&+S~7ud_2K x\ a&&EJ Mn P<KEBM
3J T]K ,GA=X CHJ
UV4JJ W5J > ;o&M >5 6O?IC*J f
q j
/,
j O
@*
jS , h

U
Uh s s
w ), U
2

V/]Z *GA< , ''
>j
& j@ Dc D#Z_L,c s 2 & /
C#N > d

,
@
U & ,UjU
] k
) ,
s q q ,
2
s q '
w, > @ 8w

U

/> u

@ ,h
]
,

>
U
* UU

& ]
o

j,# //
A-%6"b
D9%"??ac

,
&
2
, s ,E

{U j

& Uh _
/.Uq)
,
/# /u CIJ^`1JAJ

]

DFDA.%7"D9&#?c q {# & ]
@
@

,j q

j Uh U
j ,
> q
qU

bUj L > ) ,wq > & f!$dX
, h
j j)* .,
L

, j
> q
:{
L ) ,8{ > w {U
J J
Rz$R$ -2:41 =
+ N

# 3 N
+ 2
M
,5 R
H r
k 3
l Z 29 Ib _Ib6 oE:
NE e M @ f 7e2ohIb: 4 oD: ohuoD }
X
% ~ & a
%
C C
D D i ,(

F2N c 0 0 XR 3 3 &'&,#!*3
(3 -)13
$1.3 "3 % /+ 3 k^ 03 3
5 && 5

0
5 &
35
SFU
,!
.+ ' 5
(
E! E` !,*E @ 5
w * E 5 C!

` wx 5w5w 5 4
E , # Ex @ !w
)" $ *5
E m w!w , 5 # _ E`
y 5!C# 5 yC , y C
w 58 w *8J C
yC C # y C 55 C

&C & y5C C .y y . y2
F C! yy C _
! . C yf _5 Cy
. ,E5 ) . 2.C
E C CC ,
,FC C I y , . .C ,
255 F .C *. yC y F
@ & .5 , C @ y F .
.. E y .# E& C
6 CCk 6 .V2 !. C Ek Cy C

.,2 u! Ck CE ( . C F !E5 E
) .!, y5 . O,C Ck

, 5f,
EC I 5# I C
, . 5 . y C
. y F ,C I
! .CEE@? 6 eE #}E# J

) E , 5 ,`
E #C a2|Jx ,J O5_5m#_
C # .E_ f

!a y /[\0Lc [Gc +DF+'+_U c C y l_
E& C X . &, E 5
w x C 5 uC # G, u C5
# # 6 5 . I
E# ! 2 C C 5# 5 E
# E x y # _
,e @ 5x C!6 5
C C* . u ÈwX 5
!Jw y !6C 5# 5y

E*E E& |52C ,x ` C 55
, ! . ` a8# e l
! 5 5 Fc&e C _
, E ) E. @, Cwx & y 5

C C & . !6 yC . CuC C , *
eCEw . 5 !e5 5

!f `! 5 C 6 @! 5 .
CF C & y 6# C

# , 5 E F u E ew 5
,5C# 6 52 y ,. & y # 55
J # & C!

C!6 .2 `! E. y5 C 5 @,
w y !u _ ,x , uk ` y ,
eEw !66 5 , !C5 !6 y,2
E 6 C y
@ FL56
y C
CC!, Cw e55 5

@ m *E 58 5
& C * ,# !. 5 6 w
w ,x ` y &
,xX , .# & w # #l
w 6 C` , Cx@ ,6 . 5
! me # Ex, !5 _
,2 CCC# y y F# C x 2Cf

&E ,C CFCC# # , @ 2#
E! E @ e C J E !
!"# r
Z
I l
0 G
aw 3 X
&

0 , 0

#
c; ;
! R !
ODb

c #

80 u A

c. ;c

.
j

. # 66

0
#
6# 2k
,6;

6
0
cc

cc#
g

cc
I

+ A6

!6

ee j

6
2c
6
j

& c

cc
&
,. )
;0 6. # ,
6;
!66
!
6

;
2
e# 8,
+
2

6
!,%

# 2 .
, ;

.0 00 02 c
_ c V[$[-Vc c c+ + #
#
I g#
!

& g
2

a

# + 6hEd 8 c c
k#

+ + s ! cc
+
% 0
8 , , &

+
+ a O .
0206# c
!+ # , 66
2
. +
# j 02
c

6 8
# s0#
6 !
j+ +
!
+
+
g
2
!6
I

, !

H

cc # # +
+ c# c c
+g
l
gc
6
8
e,
_ 6
_s
# .
,2,,
8
{ 66

6 >; ; c
I jj

j
0 0 >

c h

# > O8

%
? h D L !6
s
. 8 +g
!7-c A9D*c $D*c :[Vc I@$(-c ;Dc D$[_M-c 0 h& 0 #

8

6 8 .
c 8c

, 0 . e
e

0 .0 . +!#

% 0 s 0
,
6h !

8Oc A_V[c s O!s
;
, 0
!
+ 2
;
.

O

+ 8 c.

I 8 c c

# , _
!6

62

; 82 +
& c !
+)
Ig
0
# )

c %+ "L-c + 828
&
;

6
j
e 8

c
&

!66
# ) c c)

+ I I
c
6& Oh 7 X
# g0# s I c I

g
I & 6 + A + 0 c# +# &
2 A &66 0
6! ; ;]m
ED M ^ # ## $
>F
) =
) =
P x x
F >

Xj njn #&*,!

4-5 #$5
\
!5 / 5
ii

Sedley Epicurus Anti-Reduction

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Sedley Epicurus Anti-Reduction

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

hh 

[+'+   Z[ [ ' f + +  +' + 

[[h + +  [ M + + +[  

M lL ,S[61bVe m > P   C 

'* P   C#  9 '

j +' ] g   +'   +gM[] [ 

  +  

 [ ]+  A'f

M + +g  +  A+ []M +g

+FLm g.g:h F.m }F.o:z;h Lom h:_.``B mGeho3eaLbBm 0:d:Ao:7

Ch<.pV ?he_ oH< 7Mm3ummMeb

i:3:M{:7 .s pD: 'M:b. 3ed@:i:d3: .d7

?he_ ?uhqH:h 7Mm3ummNed e@ me_< e@ oF< Ommu<m .q

ec8eb ] ._ .Wme Bh.p:?uY ?eh mu1mo.boI.X

4f__:dpm muggYM:7 0 !.hpH. #umm0.v_ %e0:io -.h7 d7h=

.|N7 edmo.d Y<bb !emp .b8 <mg:3M.YY ed.oF.d .hd:m

e? oH:_ mHeuY8 0: .nmw_:6 pe .Bh:: }ItF :|:hoHIbB s.  Pd.YY

"IomIm .b6 oH: [.o: #ej_.c v]^:

'! / &"(&$/

  1   1  .1  | !

 | & !.   ! ( !

 X   ! ; !1  !  11 

 ; 2 1 X  1<     1

 F F 0 ! ! 1 ; X ;v?

  2  F| ? 1    `

  F| *;   !. 1 & |

0!  &   F .? X  

     

F <l  !1  11 l 

1    & @ H10 1X 1I X 2 X

 H  6@ F;    11 l

* I * F1? F! F1  F1 X 

? | F   X   1     l 

   . .12 v! . 6  

  ?   I    | 

F   |   l  o IX   l

H I     !| OH    

 ? 1   |? F . 

; 1? * | ! . |   ; 

;  1I F  01?  & 1

 @ H  1    .? * 6

H !; 1O

  ? ?* F? ; 1 I ~

    ; B 2 *    F? X v|

*   v1  2b? F &

!H ! v B F* * |?  b

1    F ;! ?I 1? ; * 

X     X 

!    1 | @6   2

F! *   1!

    O l|     

?! X;! F;  X !11?

   ; *  F1 ; @ 

 vv6 @ >? 1? O  ? 

v X F  FH? & . ; 1  I 

W6 IE4@Xg E^<$g %g 49;_TZMX%$g % Y1&g 

,    c 6(c  V p + 1&  %& 

* 7      %i  m 0 1 k

g  % V np>T  ( z ,,   % & &

& M Q( ;/ Q '((   

)" / &" *&#/

0   (b Q  " AI

FQ' f|'f b? "a ' {?" 'Qx? o l

''? " Q; b a0 Q | 0 'l

hh

[+'+ Z[[ ' f ++ +' +

[[h ++ [ M ++ +[

M lL ,S[61bVe m > P C

'* P C# 9 '

j +' ] g +' +gM[] [

+

[ ]+ A'f

M + +g + A+ []M +g

Ch<.pV ?he_ oH< 7Mm3ummMeb

4f__:dpm muggYM:7 0 !.hpH. #umm0.v_ %e0:io -.h7 d7h=

.|N7 edmo.d Y<bb !emp .b8 <mg:3M.YY ed.oF.d .hd:m

e? oH:_ mHeuY8 0: .nmw_:6 pe .Bh:: }ItF :|:hoHIbB s. Pd.YY

"IomIm .b6 oH: [.o: #ej_.c v]^:

'! / &"(&$/

1 1 .1 | !

| & !. ! ( !

X ! ; !1 ! 11

; 2 1 X 1< 1

F F 0 ! ! 1 ; X ;v?

2 F| ? 1 `

F| *; !. 1 & |

0! & F .? X

F <l !1 11 l

1 & @ H10 1X 1I X 2 X

H 6@ F; 11 l

* I * F1? F! F1 F1 X

? | F X 1 l

. .12 v! . 6

? I |

F | l o IX l

H I !| OH

? 1 |? F .

; 1? * | ! . | ;

; 1I F 01? & 1

@ H 1 .? * 6

? ?* F? ; 1 I ~

; B 2 * F? X v|

* v1 2b? F &

!H ! v B F* * |? b

1 F ;! ?I 1? ; *

X X

! 1 | @6 2

F! * 1!

O l|

?! X;! F; X !11?

; * F1 ; @

vv6 @ >? 1? O ?

v X F FH? & . ; 1 I

W6 IE4@Xg E^<$g %g 49;_TZMX%$g % Y1&g

, c 6(c V p + 1& %&

* 7 %i m 0 1 k

g % V np>T ( z ,, % & &

& M Q( ;/ Q '((

)" / &" *&#/

0 (b Q " AI

FQ' f|'f b? "a ' {?"'Qx? o l

''?" Q; b a0 Q | 0 'l

K 0 " f'' l 4' b

{;/"' ' Q Q b Q Q'~

' ; !%

Q( ~ {" O Q (lb

|'' '" 'I

~|"v? | Q { QI '" "a

l' f J {a( l (

*Q ' {" w Q { #& ! "&

I Q ' G ' M '

Q " Q /? l ; lx

~ Q ? | ( 'a0

.(IQ b / f (f "(l

Q; QBQ ( Q " (a

0 a '4 /Q QQQ b /Q

( Q l~"1 Q

" ' '" ? |/ I ? '

b (

&Q Q f|lQ QI 1 Qf ' Q

( ( Q Q 'b" '

H" ! " &

;Q( ';l b'| // `Q / fl

d Q