Professional Documents
Culture Documents
EDUCATIONAL FORUM
NEUROCHEMICAL BASIS OF OBESITY
Revised: 20.8.99
Accepted: 19.9.99
SUMMARY
Obesity threatens to become the 21st centurys leading health problem. Its prevalence is on the rise in all
age groups and in all developed countries of the world. The exact aetiology of obesity still remains
obscure. It is mainly caused by a combination of genetic factors, inappropriate eating and reduced
activity. Besides, dysregulation of various hypothalamic mechanisms controlling energy intake and energy
expenditure have also been implicated in its development and progression. In the last few years, steady
advances made in the understanding of the bodys weight regulating mechanisms has helped to define
novel sites for targeting and intervention in order to reduce intake and enhance expenditure. Based on
this, many new antiobesity drugs have been developed. Some of them are in the early stages of
development and some of compounds acting on these sites are already available.
KEY WORDS
Obesity
energy intake
treatment strategies
energy expenditure
INTRODUCTION
Obesity is nowadays a common and challenging
health problem. It is not only a problem in itself but
also a predisposing factor for many other adverse
health outcomes like non-insulin dependent diabetes mellitus (NIDDM), insulin resistance, atherosclerosis, dyslipidemias, cardiovascular and all-cause
mortality1. The World Health Organisation has described it as an escalating epidemic and one of the
greatest neglected public health problems of our time
with an impact on health which may well prove to be
as great as smoking2. Obesity results from a positive energy balance i.e., when caloric intake chronically exceeds energy expenditure. This inturn causes
excess of adipose tissue mass with body mass index (BMI) > 30 kg/m 2 (Table 1)3.
EPIDEMIOLOGY
The epidemic of obesity is on the rise and this is
probably due to increasingly sedentary lifestyles combined with easy availability of palatable, high fat foods.
Its prevalence has shown a startling increase in all
age groups and in all the countries of the world during past 19 years. In 1980, a Department of health
Survey in U.K. showed that 6% of men and 8% of
women were obese, as defined by a BMI >30 kg/m2.
Correspondence: S.K. Kulkarni
neurotransmitters
neuropeptides
389
Environmental factors
The current environmental risk factors include overconsumption of energy (increase in fat to carbohydrate ratio) and decrease in physical activity. These
factors offer more reasonable explanation for the recent dramatic surge in the prevalence of obesity.
Nutritional factors
Numerous metabolic studies have shown that high
fat diets may lead to a high energy intake and hyperphagia. The reason may be that fat has a weaker
effect on the satiety centre and on heat production
(diet-induced thermogenesis) and it possesses a
higher energy density compared to carbohydrates.
Also fats are highly palatable and heighten the flavour of food stuffs which leads to their passive overconsumption. This ultimately increases fat deposits
and causes obesity and related problems10.
Physiological factors
These involve the impairment of the central mechanism regulating appetite and food intake which is
thought to be regulated by a complex interplay of
neurotransmitters in the hypothalamic region of the
brain. Approximately 1 - 2% of obesity can be ascribed to lesions in hypothalamic regulatory centres.
Such lesions may be due to trauma, tumours, inflammatory processes, or carotid artery aneurysms11.
Psychological factors
The psychogenic theory of obesity long held that
obesity resulted from an emotional disorder in which
food intake, relieved the anxiety and depression to
which obese persons are usually susceptible. Stress
associated with traumatic emotional events has been
held responsible for certain cases of obesity and has
been implicated in the pathogenesis of eating disorders such as night-eating syndrome and bulimia12.
TYPES OF OBESITY
The concept of fat distribution (android and gynoid)
was first introduced in obese subjects with diabetes
mellitus or cardiovascular disease by Vague13. Later,
Kiessebah et al., proposed a classification of obesity - upper body segment and lower body segment
using waist-to-hip circumference ratio14. There are
two types of obesity- the central adiposity (upper
body segment, android obesity), and the peripheral
adiposity (lower body segment, gynoid obesity).
Central adiposity
Apple-shaped people have excess fat in subcutaneous abdominal and visceral depots. This condition is associated with an increased morbidity and
risk of a number of metabolic complications such as
coronary heart disease, NIDDM, hormone-related
cancers and several abnormalities in endocrine secretions including increased activity of CRF-ACTHadrenal axis, an elevated cortisol secretion as well
as hyperandrogenicity in women, and a relative hypogonadism in men. There is also pronounced insulin resistance. Upper body obesity resembles Cushings disease in fat distribution. Such individuals have
BMI (kg/m2)*
Underweight
<18.5
Normal range
Overweight
Obese
class I
class II
class III
18.5-24.9
25.0-29.9
> 30.0
30.0-34.9
35.0-39.9
> 40.0
Table 2.
390
Risk of co-morbidities
Low (but risk of other clinical
problems increased)
Average
Mildly increased
Moderate
Severe
Very severe
Action
Lipolysis induced
by
catecholamines
Antilipolytic
effect of insulin
Antilipolytic effect
of adenosine and
prostaglandins
Mechanism (visceral
Vs subcutaneous)
Glucocorticoidsteroid action
Visceral
Peroxisome
proliferator
activated
receptor- activity
Visceral
Leptin secretion
ADIPOSE TISSUE
(TRIACYLGLYCEROL)
As illustrated above energy intake and energy expenditure play a pivotal role in controlling body fat
stores18. The energy intake depends on appetite
which is mainly controlled by glucostatic and lipostatic
feedback systems. The energy expenditure depends
on heat production (diet induced thermogenesis, DIT,
10 - 12%), metabolism (basal metabolic rate, BMR
65%) and physical exercise (variable). Any imbalance
between these two is translated into a change in fat
stores and obesity. This balancing act also involves
various neural and endocrine signals acting peripherally as well as centrally which cause disturbance
and derangement of various other physiological functions as well8.
391
COPING REACTION
THREAT OF CONTROL
FIGHT - FLIGHT
LOSS OF CONTROL
'
DEPRESSION
DEFENSE REACTION
DEFEAT REACTION
CENTRAL
SYMPATHETIC AROUSAL
$
$
CONTROL
STRIVING
PITUITARY
ADRENAL AROUSAL
$
LOSS OF CONTROL
ADRENALINE h
NORADRENALINE
FFA h
CRF h
ACTH h
FFA h
OVULATION i
TESTOSTERONE i
HYPERTENSION
METABOLIC ABBERATIONS
VISCERAL FAT ACCUMULATION
'
DISEASE
body and sends signals to the higher centres leading to feeling of hunger or satiety. The hypothalamus
also controls energy expenditure via the autonomic
nervous system and pituitary hormones.
The neuroendocrine axis involved in energy balance
regulation may be the hypothalamic links with the
adrenals, gonads and the sympathetic nervous system. The hypothalamic arousal by physical and mental stressors result in fight or flight (defeat) reaction
which leads to changes in these links 19. The fight reaction occurs via the sympathetic pathways to help
gain control by increasing the readiness of circulatory factors and to mobilise substrates needed to
meet the challenges. When the individual loses control and ends up in a defeated, submissive, helpless
situation, there is hyperactivity of CRF-ACTH-cortisol axis, hypercortisolism, and decreased secretion
* Noradrenaline
* GABA
* Growth hormone releasing
hormone
* Galanin
* Melanin-concentrating
hormone
* Neuropeptide - Y
* Opioids
* Orexin
* Serotonin
* Dopamine
* Cholecystokinin
* Corticotrophin-releasing factor
* Neurotensin
* Bombesin
* Calcitonin gene-related peptide
* Amylin
* Adrenomedullin
* Glucagon
* Glucagon - like peptide - 1
* -Melanocyte stimulating
hormone
* Anorectin
* CART
* Thyrotropin-releasing factor
* Cyclo - histidyl proline
diketopiperazine
* Pituitary adenylate cyclase
activating polypeptide
* Acidic fibroblast growth factor
* Oxytocin
* Interleukin 1
Neuropeptide Y is the most powerful appetite stimulant known in the rodents. It has been reported to
increase the triglyceride content in white fat and after 5 days of intracerebral administration it doubled
the fat stores in both lean and ob/ob mice. Its expression is also reported to be increased in ARC,
PVN and DMN in the ob/ob mouse and Zucker rat.
But the genetic studies have not shown any association with the genes for neuropeptide Y1 or Y5 receptors in human obesity.
The NPY neurons in the ARN possess glucocorticoid, insulin and leptin receptors and leptin has an
inhibitory effect on the NPY neurons via the Rb receptors and reduces NPY mRNA, NPY protein and
NPY release. The prototype NPY5 antagonists have
been shown to inhibit feeding in genetically obese
rats and in food deprivation8,12. But their effects in
rodents with diet-induced obesity (the nearest model
to human obesity) have not yet been reported. It is
speculated that NPY5 antagonists could be effective
antiobesity drugs.
Melanin concentrating hormone (MCH)
MCH is a cyclic 19 amino-acid neuropeptide identi-
392
393
SKIN
HYPOTHALAMUS
-Melanocyte
melanocyte
stimulating hormone
stimulating hormone
inhibits
Agouti protein
Melanocortin 2 receptor
inhibits
Melanocortin 4 receptor
Pigmentation
low obese mouse) which overexpresses agouti protein, a pigmentation factor normally expressed in the
skin. This protein is antagonist at MC2 receptors expressed in skin (failure to produce melanin, yellow
coat colour) and MC4 receptors expressed in hypothalamus (obese mouse).
(TNF-
Tumour necrosis factor-
)
TNF-
has been recognised as an inflammatory
cytokine produced not only by the classic inflammatory cells but also by adipocytes. Within adipocytes,
has been postulated to be a mediator of insuTNF-
lin resistance via alterations in the phosphorylation
status of insulin receptor substrate -1 (IRS-1)38 and
to alter insulin receptor activity39. Because of the over mRNA and protein in the adiexpression of TNF-
pose tissue of obese animals 40 and humans41,
is a potential mediator of insulin - resistance
TNF-
associated with obesity. It is also expressed at higher
levels in muscle cells of insulin resistant subjects and
may also inhibit lipoprotein lipase (LPL) expression42.
Thus, it is a candidate gene product for the genetic
is normally
predisposition to obesity. Since TNF-
present at very low concentration in the circulation,
it must act as an autocrine or paracrine factor43.
Lipoprotein lipase (LPL)
Human fat cells do not synthesise lipids but derives
most of its lipids for the storage from circulating
Leptin
Leptin (in greek leptos means thin) is a 16 KD plasma
protein exclusively produced in white adipose tissue.
It is the product of ob gene that is defective in ob/ob
mice46. It plays an important role in control of body
weight, energy expenditure, reproduction and neuroendocrine signalling47. It is secreted into circulation
and then transported to brain through a modified area
of blood brain barrier near the arcuate nucleus or via
choroid plexus, where short-form leptin receptors are
sited which transfer leptin to hypothalamus. Once
within CNS leptin acts on long-term receptors to
stimulate satiety. It also mediates a negative feedback control on white adipose tissue. Through action
in the hypothalamus, possibly mediated by inhibiton
of neuropeptide Y(NPY) secretion and stimulation of
corticotropin releasing hormone (CRH) secretion,
leptin decreases food intake, stimulates sympathetically (SNS)-mediated brown adipose tissue (BAT)
thermogenesis, and reduces the parasympathetically
(PNS)-mediated insulin secretion. The increased thermogenesis and decreased energy intake leads to the
energy deficit that is satisfied by mobilisation of fat
stores. In addition, leptin may enhance the glucose
uptake into nonadipose tissue, such as muscle, to
Ventromedial nucleus of
hypothalamus (NPY)
BRAIN
NPY
CRH
+
m SNS
GC
+
l
LEPTIN
FOOD
INTAKE
-m
+
INSULIN
expression of
PNS
OTHER
TISSUES
394
GLUCOSE
DISPOSAL
THERMOGENESIS
m
m
3 AR
NE
AXONAL
TERMINAL
REDUCED ADIPOSE
TISSUE MASS
IMPROVED INSULIN
SENSITIVITY
395
Neurotensin
It is a 13 amino acid peptide that produces behaviourally specific reductions in food intake after central administration. Leptin decreases galanin gene
expression and increases neurotensin gene expression in the hypothalamus. Increased galanin gene
expression or hypothalamic content of galanin protein and decreased neurotensin mRNA levels are
associated with the development of obesity in fa/fa
rats or ob/ob mice 54.
CART (Cocaine and amphetamine-regulated transcript) peptides
CART peptides are members of a new neuropeptide
family with neurotransmitter-like actions within the
brain. The possible physiological functions of CART
peptides are many and as yet little understood. However, the available research findings strongly support a role for CART peptides in the complex controls of addiction and nutrient intake. These peptides
have a broad heterogenous distribution in the brain.
The CART peptide immunoreactivity is also found in
hypothalamic nuclei containing NPY suggesting interactions between CART peptides and the NPY system87. Also, the recombinant CART peptide is a potent inhibitor of feeding and completely blocks the
feeding response induced by NPY. Besides, the expression of CART mRNA in the arcuate nucleus is
decreased in food-deprived animals and is almost
absent in ob/ob mice, although in the latter it is restored by leptin treatment suggesting that CART
peptides are newly discovered leptin-dependent
anorectic peptides that are closely associated with
the actions of NPY54. These peptides may thus,offer
novel treatment for obesity.
Corticotropin-releasing factor (CRF)
It is a 41 amino acid peptide produced in the
paraventricular nucleus (PVN) and other brain regions. It is a major catabolic peptide in the hypothalamus whose synthesis and release are sensitive to leptin and opposes actions of NPY. Besides
acting as a controller of the hypothalamic-pituitaryadrenal (HPA) axis, it inhibits food intake, increases
energy expenditure and produces sustained weight
loss. Calorific restriction and glucocorticoid administration lower expression of the gene encoding CRF
in the PVN whereas involuntary overfeeding and
adrenalectomy cause anorexia and stimulate CRF
expression54.
396
397
Figure 5. A simplified model for the interaction of leptin with hypothalamic neuropeptides within a regulatory feedback loop. + =
stimulatory input, - = inhibitory input, CART, cocaine- and amphetamine-regulated transcript, CCK, cholecystokinin, MCH,
melanin concentrating hormone. Large arrows indicate main pathway in the feedback loop.
398
Dietary therapy
Dietary method remains the primary method for
obesity treatment. Dietary intervention along with
other treatment strategies remains a useful tool used
continuously overtime to accelerate weight loss or
to maintain a constant body weight. This involves
restricting total energy intake with healthful food
selections and exercising prudent control over eating habits. It can be implemented with the help of
encouragement of a dietitian along with a primary
health care physician72.
399
Drug therapy
Nowadays the replacement or supplementation of the
non-pharmacological treatments with hypophagic
drugs is receiving much more attention. This trend
has lead to a multi-million pound annual market for
these drugs. But still the pharmacological therapy
should be limited to specific cases in which associated clinical risks warrant more urgent intervention.
The main drugs used to treat obesity (Table 4) are
centrally acting anorectic agents. The potential sites
of these drugs are the control of energy intake, energy expenditure or both.
1. Targeting the energy intake: Food intake may
be reduced by decreasing appetite or by increasing
satiety. Drugs that affect appetite are commonly
known as anorectic medications. Their mechanism
of action may be limited to decreased appetite. These
anorexic agents affect neurotransmitter activity and
are of two main classes : those that affect the
catecholaminergic system (the amphetamines,
benzphetamine, phendimetrazine, phentermine,
mazindol, diethylpropion, and phenylpropanolamine)
and those that affect the serotonergic system
(fenfluramine, dexfenfluramine, fluoxetine,
sertraline)73. Amphetamines and closely related compounds are not recommended for the treatment of
obesity because of their high abuse potential74.
The monoamine appetite suppressants like
fenfluramine, dexfenfluramine, phentermine can induce 10-12% loss in body weight in 3 months and
often 5-10% loss is maintained for 12 months. However, inexplicably, this only occurs in 30% of patients,
the rest being nonresponders. There are also reports
of the association of fenfluramine, dexfenfluramine
and fentermine (fen-phen) therapy with increased
incidence of primary pulmonary hypertension and
neurotoxicity75. In August 97, US researchers first
reported cases of a rare vascular disease in 24
women treated with fen-phen combination who had
no history of heart disease76. Additional reports have
described valvulopathy with the fenfluramine/
dexfenfluramine alone also. Most cases involved
aortic regurgitation, some have documented mitral
regurgitation, with both occurring in small percentage of cases77. In 1997, the U.S. FDA reported overall incidence of cardiac valve abnormalities associated with these appetite suppressants drugs :79%
Chitosan present in over-the-counter slimming products such as Fat-Magnets and Chito-Slimmer tablets is claimed to result in weight loss by absorbing
triglyceride molecules and increasing fecal fat excretion.
Targeting the energy expenditure: Energy expenditure may be increased by increasing physical activity or metabolic rate , for example, through changes
in the sympathetic nervous system tone or uncoupling of oxidative phosphorylation. Drugs that affect
thermogenesis-metabolism include ephedrine (including its combination with caffeine and/or aspirin) 81,82 and experimental agents such as BRL
26830A, a -adrenoceptor agonist. None of these
medications is currently approved by the FDA for
weight control.
Newer approaches include the development of CCKA
agonists, neuropeptide Y5 and Y1 (NY5, NY1) antagonists, agonists of melanocotin-4 receptors (MC4)
and glucagon-like-peptide 1, stimulators of uncoupling proteins, drugs that unbind corticotrophin-releasing factor from its binding protein and many other
potential targets waiting in the wings. Human trials
of recombinant leptin are also underway.
2.
The weight reducing effect of some drugs plateau after 4 to 6 months even if the drug is continued and regain may occur despite long-term
drug treatment in some patients.
3.
Patients consider drug treatment as a magiccure and do not take the required precautions.
4.
Potential for causing adverse effects e.g., primary pulmonary hypertension and neurotoxic
effects caused by dexfenfluramine and fenfluramine.
5.
Cost of treatment.
Surgical therapy
This is indicated for morbid obesity in which there is
greater than 70% excess weight. Surgery can provide palliation for severe obesity when all medical
approaches have failed. It can result in decreased
food intake (gastric procedures - jaw wiring, vertical
banded gastroplasty, gastric stapling), affect calorie
absorption (intestinal shunting, biliopancreatic bypass), or remove excess fat (lipectomy, liposuction).
Gastric reduction operations are safe and effective
provided they are performed by experienced
surgeons in well-selected patients. They can be considered now as the best option for a minority of patients with morbid and refractory obesity. In very selected patients, mechanical means (such as waist
cord) may also help losing weight and/or avoiding
weight regain83.
POTENTIAL BENEFITS AND ADVERSE EFFECTS
OF LONG - TERM PHARMACOTHERAPY FOR
TREATMENT OF OBESITY
With increased awareness of risk factors associated
with obesity and increase in use of antiobesity drugs
400
CONCLUSION
Obesity is a major public-health issue world-wide. It
is a serious health problem associated with at least
one co-morbidity in most patients with BMI of 27 or
greater. Its treatment is difficult and challenging as
the exact etiology still remains obscure. Recent advances in the understanding of the molecular mechanisms underlying obesity provide great hope for the
development of treatments targeted to specific metabolic defects. Antiobesity agents with novel mechanisms of action will supplement and revolutionize the
current armamentarium for the treatment of obesity.
Ultimately, the treatment of obesity may prevent
401
co-morbidities of obesity such as diabetes, hypertension and hyperlipidemia and in some patients may
supplant the treatment of these disorders.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
Polkow B. Stress: hypothalamic functions and neuroendocrine consequences. Acta Med Scand 1988;723:61-70.
21.
22.
23.
24.
Qu D, Ludwig DS. A role for melanin concentrating hormone in the central regulation of feeding behaviour. Nature 1996;380:243-7.
25.
26.
27.
Miller CL, Hruby VI. -MSH and MCH are functional antagonists in a central nervous system auditory gating paradigm. Ann NY Acad Sci 1993;680:571-4.
28.
29.
Scheen AJ, Desaive C, Lefebvre PJ. Therapy for obesity today and tomorrow. Clin Endocrinol Metab 1994;8:70527.
30.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The Senior Research Fellowship (G.K.) of the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR), New
Delhi, is gratefully acknowledged.
REFERENCES
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Rippe JM, Crossley S, Ringer R. Obesity as a chronic disease: Modern medical and lifestyle management. J Am
Diet Assoc 1998;98:9-15.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
32.
33.
Ballinger A, Mcloughlin L, Medbak S, Clark M. Cholecystokinin is a satiety hormone in humans at physiological postprandial plasma-concentrations. Clin Sci 1995;89:375-81.
47.
48.
49.
50.
51.
52.
53.
Kausta E, Chrisoulidou A, Lawrence NJ, et al . The circadian rhythm of leptin is preserved in growth hormone deficient hypopituitary adults. Clin Endocrin 1998;48:685-90.
Hotamisligil GS, Peraldi P, Budavari A. IRS-1 mediated inhibition of insulin receptor tyrosine kinase activity in TNF-and obesity induced insulin resistance. Science 1996;
27:665-8.
54.
55.
Meier CA. Advances in the understanding of molecular basis of obesity. J Endocrin 1997;133:761-3.
56.
Arbeeny CM, Meyers DM, Hillyer DE, Berquist KE. Metabolic alterations associated with the antidiabetic effect of
3 -adrenergic receptor agonists in obese mice. Am J
Physiol 1995;268:678-84.
57.
58.
59.
60.
Gregory PC, McFadyn M. Duodenal infusion of fat, cholecystokinin secretion and satiety in the pig. Physiol Behav
1989;45:1021-4.
35.
Reidelberger RD, Varga G, Solomon TE. Comparative effects of cholecystokinin (CCK-A) receptor antagonist L
364718 and CCK-B antagonist L365260 on solid food intake in rats. Soc Neurosci 1990;16:978.
36.
37. Huszar D, Lynch CA, Dunmore JH, et al. Targeted disruption of melanocortin-4 receptors results in obesity in mice.
Cell 1997;88:131-41.
39.
40.
Obes 1997;21:980-6.
46.
34.
38.
402
Hotamisligil GS, Murray DL, Choy LN. Tumour necrosis factor alpha inhibits signalling from the insulin receptor. Proc
Natl Acad Sci 1994;91:4854-8.
41.
42.
43.
44.
45.
Berg M, Olivecrona G, Olivecrona T. Regulation of adipose tissue lipoprotein lipase in young and old rats. Int J
403
74.
75.
76.
77.
Connolly HM, Cray JL, McGoon MD. Valvular heart disease associated with fenfluramine-phentermine. N Eng J
Med 1997;337:581-8.
78.
64.
79.
65.
80.
66.
81.
Adult A. Newest anti-obesity drug fails to pass FDA muster. The Lancet 1998;351:885.
67.
82.
68.
Astrup A, Breum L, Toubro S, Hein P, Quaade R. The effect and safety of an ephedrine/caffeine compound compared to ephedrine, caffeine and placebo in obese subjects. Int J Obes 1992;16:269-77.
83.
84.
85.
86.
87.
88.
61.
62.
63.
69.
70.
71.
72.
Foreyt JP, Poston CW. The role of the behavioural counsellor in obesity treatment. J Am Diet Assoc 1998;98:27-30.
73.
Nonas CA. A model of chronic care of obesity through dietary treatment. J Am Diet Assoc 1998;98:16-22.