VIN HN LM KHOA HC V CNG NGH VIT NAM

VIN CNG NGH SINH HC

BO CO
NH GI H S D THU
(Theo Thng t s: 09/2010/TT-BKH
ngy 21 thng 4 nm 2010 ca B K hoch v u t)

Gi thu:

Mua sm thit bi nm 2014

ti / D n:

Xy dng trung tm gi ging vi sinh vt v pht trin

cc cht c hot tnh sinh hc t vi sinh vt ca Vin
Hn lm Khoa hc v Cng ngh Vit Nam

Ch u t:

Vin Cng ngh sinh hc

H Ni, 8/2014
i

MC LC

1. THNG TIN C BN......................................................................................3

1.1. Gii thiu chung v d n v gi thu..................................................3

1.3. Phng php nh gi HSDT...............................................................4
2. TM TT QU TRNH U THU (Ph lc 1 ca Bo co).....................4
3. KT QU NH GI H S D THU.....................................................5

3.1. Kt qu nh gi s b HSDT..............................................................5
3.2. Kt qu nh gi chi tit HSDT............................................................6
3.3. Bng tng hp kt qu nh gi HSDT................................................7
4. KT LUN V KIN NGH...........................................................................8
5. CH K XC NHN CA CC THNH VIN HI NG U THU8
Ph lc I................................................................................................................ 10
Ph lc II..............................................................................................................11

ii

VIN HN LM
KHOA HC V CNG NGH VN

CNG HA X HI CH NGHA VIT NAM

c lp - T do - Hnh phc

VIN CNG NGH SINH HC

H Ni, ngy 11 thng 8 nm 2014

BO CO NH GI H S D THU
Gi thu Mua sm thit bi nm 2014 thuc ti cp Vin Hn lm KHCNVN
Xy dng trung tm gi ging vi sinh vt v pht trin cc cht c hot tnh sinh
hc t vi sinh vt ca Vin Hn lm Khoa hc v Cng ngh Vit Nam

Knh gi: - Ch tch Vin Hn lm Khoa hc v Cng ngh Vit Nam

- Vin trng Vin cng ngh sinh hc
Cn c Quyt nh s 1040/Q-VHL ngy 17 thng 7 nm 2014 ca Vin
Hn lm KHCNVN v vic Ph duyt danh muc thit b, d ton v k hoach u
thu gi thu s 01 Mua sm thit b nm 2014;
Cn c Quyt nh s 372/Q-CNSH ngy 22/7/2014 ca Vin trng
Vin Cng ngh sinh hc v vic thnh lp T t vn u thu gi thu s 01
Mua sm thit b nm 2014 thuc ti cp Vin Hn lm KHCNVN: Xy
dng trung tm gi ging vi sinh vt v pht trin cc cht c hoat tnh sinh hc
t vi sinh vt ca Vin Hn lm Khoa hc v Cng ngh Vit Nam;
Cn c HSMT v HSDT ca cc nh thu tham d gi thu ni trn, t t
vn u thu tin hnh nh gi HSDT vo ngy 9 thng 8 nm 2014. Kt qu
nh gi HSDT gi thu nu trn c tng hp theo cc ni dung nh sau:
1. THNG TIN C BN
1.1. Gii thiu chung v d n v gi thu
Tn ti:

Xy dng trung tm gi ging vi sinh vt v pht

trin cc cht c hoat tnh sinh hc t vi sinh vt
ca Vin Hn lm Khoa hc v Cng ngh Vit
Nam

Tn gi thu:

Mua sm thit b nm 2014

Ch u t:

Vin Cng ngh sinh hc

Ngun ti chnh:

Ngn sch nh nc

Hnh thc la chn nh thu:

u thu r n g ri trong nc

Phng thc u thu:

u thu 1 ti h s
3

Cc vn bn php l lin quan:

S CV/Q

Ngy

Ni dung

31/5/2013

Hp ng nghin cu khoa hc v pht trin cng ngh k

ngy 31 thng 5 nm 2013 gia Vin Hn lm Khoa hc v
Cng ngh Vit Nam vi Vin Cng ngh sinh hc v vic
giao v nhn thc hin ti

1040/Q-VHL

17/7/2014

Ch tch Vi n Hn lm KHCNVN v vic ph duyt danh

muc thit b, d ton v k hoach u thu gi thu s 01
Mua sm thit b nm 2014 ca ti

372/Q-CNSH

22/7/2014

Vin trng Vin Cng ngh sinh hc v vic thnh lp T

t vn u thu gi thu s 01 Mua sm thit b nm
2014 ca ti

22/7/2014

Vin trng Vin Cng ngh sinh hc v vic ph duyt h

s mi thu r ng ri gi thu s 01 Mua sm thit b nm
2014 ca ti

24/H-VHL

373/Q-CNSH

1.2. T chuyn gia u thu

a. Thnh phn
STT

H v tn

n vi

Trch nhim trong

T

PGS.TS. Chu Hong H

Vin Cng ngh sinh hc

T trng

TS. Lm ai Nhn

Vin Cng ngh sinh hc

y vin

KTVC. on Th Kim Lin

Vin Cng ngh sinh hc

y vin

TS. Phng Thu Nguyt

Vin Cng ngh sinh hc

y vin

TS. L Th Minh Thnh

Vin Cng ngh sinh hc

y vin - Th k

b) Cch thc lm vic: T t vn u thu lm vic theo nhm.

nh km bo co ny l: (1) Quyt nh thnh lp T t vn u thu; (2)
Chng ch v u thu ca tng c nhn tham gia trong T t vn u thu.
1.3. Phng php nh gi HSDT
- nh gi v nng lc, kinh nghim ca nh thu: at/Khng at
- nh gi v k thut: at/Khng at
- Xc nh gi nh gi: at/Khng at
2. TM TT QU TRNH U THU (Ph lc 1 ca Bo co)
- Chun b u thu.
- Thng bo mi thu trn Bo u thu cc s 148, 149, 150 ngy 25, 28,
29/7/2014.
- Thi gian pht hnh h s mi thu: 10g00 ngy 30/7/2014.
4

- Thi im ng thu: 10g00 ngy 09/8/2014.

- Danh sch cc nh thu n nhn h s mi thu:
+ Cng ty TNHH Thit b H Phng. Nh 01, B12, Tp th Kh tng
Thu Vn, ng 62 Nguyn Ch Thanh, H N i.
+ Cng ty TNHH B.C.E Vi t Nam. Tng 10, LICOGI 13, 164 Khut Duy
Tin, H N i.
+ Cng ty TNHH Thit b Y t Nht Minh. Tng 5, nh 25T2, L No5,
Trung Hoa Nhn Chnh, H N i.
+ Cng ty TNHH Thit b Y t Nh t Nam. S 22, ngch 1, ng 178, Thi
H, H N i.
- Danh sch cc nh thu np H s d thu (HSDT) ng qui nh:
+ Cng ty TNHH B.C.E Vi t Nam.
+ Cng ty TNHH Thit b Y t Nht Minh.
+ Cng ty TNHH Thit b Y t Nh t Nam.
- Danh sch cc nh thu n np sau thi im ng thu: Khng c.
- M thu: 10g15 ngy 09/8/2014.
- Cc vn pht sinh x l tnh hung khi t chc u thu: Khng c.
3. KT QU NH GI H S D THU
3.1. Kt qu nh gi s b HSDT
3.1.1. Kt qu nh gi v tnh hp l v s y ; p ng cc iu kin tin
quyt ca H s d thu (HSDT)
a) Trn c s kim tra v tnh hp l v s y (Mu s 3 km theo); nh gi
v p ng cc iu kin tin quyt ca tng HSDT (Mu s 4 km theo), kt qu
nh gi cc ni dung ny c tng hp theo Biu s 1 di y.
TT

1
2
3

Ni dung nh gi
Nh thu

Cng ty TNHH B.C.E Vi t Nam

Cng ty TNHH Thit b Y t Nht
Minh
Cng ty TNHH Thit b Y t Nh t
Nam

Tnh hp
l v s
y ca
HSDT

p ng cc
iu kin tin
quyt nu trong
HSMT

Kt lun

at

at

at

Khng at

Khng at

Khng at

at

at

at

b) Thuyt minh v cc trng hp HSDT khng hp l, khng y v khng

5

p ng iu kin tin quyt: HSDT ca Cng ty TNHH Thit b Y t Nht Minh

khng p ng v Tnh hp l v s y ca HSDT nh trong HSMT yu cu
v Giy phep ng k kinh doanh ca Cng ty khng c chc nng cung cp cc
thit b nghin cu khoa hc.
c) Cc ni dung b sung, lm r HSDT nhm chng minh t cch hp l ca nh
thu: Khng c.
3.1.2. Kt qu nh gi v nng lc v kinh nghim
a) Trn c s nh gi v nng lc v kinh nghim ca tng nh thu (Mu s 5
km theo), kt qu nh gi ni dung ny c tng hp theo Biu s 2 di y:
TT
1
2
3

Ni dung nh gi
Nh thu
Cng ty TNHH B.C.E Vi t Nam
Cng ty TNHH Thit b Y t Nht
Minh
Cng ty TNHH Thit b Y t Nh t
Nam

Kinh

Nng lc

nghim
at

ti chnh
at

Khng at

at

Khng at

Khng at

at

Khng at

Kt lun
at

b) Thuyt minh cc trng hp nh thu khng p ng yu cu v nng lc v

kinh nghim nu trong HSMT: HSDT ca Cng ty TNHH Thit b Y t NHt
Minh v Cng ty TNHH Thit b Y t Nh t Nam khng p ng yu cu v Nng
lc v kinh nghim ca nh thu nh trong HSMT v c 03 hp ng nhng
khng tng t v chng loai thit b yu cu trong pham vi cung cp ca HSMT.
c) Cc ni dung lm r HSDT nhm chng minh nng lc v kinh nghim ca
nh thu: Khng c.
3.1.3. Kt lun trong bc nh gi s b
Ni dung nh gi
TT
Nh thu

KQ nh gi v
p ng cc
iu kin tin
quyt nu trong
HSMT

Kt qu
nh gi v
nng lc v
kinh nghim
nh thu

Kt lun

at

at

at

Cng ty TNHH B.C.E Vi t Nam

Cng ty TNHH Thit b Y t Nht

Minh

Khng at

Khng at

Khng
at

Cng ty TNHH Thit b Y t Nh t

Nam

at

Khng at

Khng
at

3.2. Kt qu nh gi chi tit HSDT

6

3.2.1. Kt qu nh gi v k thut (Mu s 8, 8b km theo)

a) Danh sch nh thu c HSDT p ng yu cu v k thut:
- Cng ty TNHH B.C.E Vi t Nam
b) Danh sch nh thu c HSDT khng p ng yu cu v k thut: Khng c.
c) Cc ni dung b sung, lm r HSDT trong qu trnh nh gi; Khng c.
d) Cc ni dung lu trong qu trnh nh gi: Khng c.
3.2.2. Kt qu xc nh gi nh gi
TT

Tn nh thu
Ni dung nh gi

Cng ty TNHH
B.C.E Vi t Nam

Gi d thu (VN)

971.105.000

Sa li (VN) (Mu s 11 km theo)

Hiu chnh sai lch (VN) (Mu s 12 km theo)

Gi d thu sau sa li, hiu chnh sai lch (VN)

971.105.000

Gi hiu chnh (VN)

971.105.000

Gi nh gi (VN)

971.105.000

Xp hng

3.3. Bng tng hp kt qu nh gi HSDT

Trn c s nh gi HSDT ca t chuyn gia, kt qu nh gi HSDT c tng
hp theo Biu s 5 vi cc ni dung c bn nh sau:
Biu s 5: Bng tng hp kt qu nh gi HSDT
Tn nh thu
TT
Ni dung nh gi

Cng ty TNHH
B.C.E Vi t Nam

Cng ty TNHH
Thit bi Y t
Nht Minh

Cng ty TNHH
Thit bi Y t
Nh t Nam

Kt qu nh gi s b

at

Khng at

Khng at

1.
1

Kt qu nh gi tnh hp l v
p ng cc iu kin tin quyt

Khng t

1.
2

Kt qu nh gi v nng lc
v kinh nghim

Khng t

Khng t

Kt qu nh gi v k thut

at

Gi nu trong n d thu
(ng)

Sa li

Hiu chnh sai lch

971.105.000

1.030.000.000 1.018.200.000

Gi d thu sau sa li v hiu

chnh sai lch (=3+4+5) (ng)

Gim gi (nu c)

971.105.000

Gi d thu sau sa li v hiu

chnh sai lch tr i gi tr gim
gi (= 6 - 7) (ng)

971.105.000

Gi nh gi (ng)

971.105.000

10

Xp hng cc HSDT

Khng t

Khng t

4. KT LUN V KIN NGH

Kt lun ca T t vn du thu v cc nh thu c ngh trng thu, gi
trng thu, hnh thc hp ng, thi gian hp ng c tng kt trong biu sau:
- Tn nh thu c nghi trng thu: Cng ty TNHH B.C.E Vi t Nam.
- Gi nghi trng thu: 971.105.000 ng (Chn trm by mi mt
tri u m t trm linh nm nghn ng)
- Hnh thc hp ng: Hp ng trn gi
- Thi gian thc hin hp ng: 90 ngy k t ngy k hp ng.
- Nhng ni dung cn lu : Thc hin ng cam kt giao hng, cam kt
xut x hng ha, cam kt bo hnh hng ha.
5. CH K XC NHN CA CC THNH VIN T T VN
U THU
TT

H v tn

C quan

Chc danh

PGS.TS. Chu Hong H

Vin CNSH

T trng

TS. Lm ai Nhn

Vin CNSH

y vin

KTVC. on Th Kim Lin

Vin CNSH

y vin

TS. Phng Thu Nguyt

Vin CNSH

y vin

TS. L Th Minh Thnh

Vin CNSH

Th k

K xc nhn

PH LC
BO CO NH GI H S D THU

Ph lc I
BNG TM TT QU TRNH U THU
TT

Ni dung

Vn bn nh
km (bn
chp)

Chun bi u thu

Mi thu

ng ti thng bo mi thu

Bo u thu s 148, 149, 150

3 t bo
ngy 25, 28 v 29/7/2014.

Thi gian pht hnh HSMT

10 ngy

Sa i HSMT (nu c)

Khng c

Thi im ng thu

10h ngy 09/8/2014

Bin bn ng
thu

S lng nh thu nhn h s mi

s tuyn

4 nh thu

Giy gii thiu

& Danh sch

S lng nh thu np h s d s
tuyn n thi im ng s tuyn

3 nh thu

Giy gii thiu

& Danh sch

Danh sch nh thu np HSDT sau

thi im ng thu (nu c)

Khng c

M thu

1.

Thi gian v a im m thu

10h15 ngy 9/8/2014 tai P118 Bin bn m

nh A10 Vin CNSH
thu

2.

Thi im Kt thc m thu

11h50 ngy 9/8/2014

3.

Cc vn khc trong qu trnh m

thu (nu c)

10

Ph lc II
DANH MC TI LIU NH KM
TT Ti liu

S, k hiu v ngy thng (nu c)

Quyt nh s 598/Q-VHL ngy 04/4/2013

Vn bn ph duyt d n

Vn bn ph duyt KHT

Quyt nh s 1040/Q-VHL ngy 17/7/2014

Vn bn thnh lp t chuyn gia u

thu

Quyt nh s 372/Q-CNSH ngy 22/7/2014

Vn bn ph duyt h s mi mi thu

Quyt nh s 373/Q-CNSH ngy 22/7/2014

Ti liu chng minh nh thu mua

Giy gii thiu & Danh sch
HSMT

Ti liu xc nhn nh thu np HSDT

Giy gii thiu & Danh sch

Bin bn ng thu

Ngy 9/8/2014

Bin bn m thu

Ngy 9/8/2014

Bn nh gi ca cc thnh vin t
chuyn gia

Mu 3-4-5-8a

10

Bn tng hp nh gi v k thut

Mu 8b

11

S bo ng ti thng bo mi thu

Photo Bo u thu s 148, 149, 150 ngy 25,

28 v 29/7/2014

12

Chng ch v u thu ca cc thnh

vin trong t chuyn gia

5 thnh vin T t vn u thu

13

H s yu cu cho hng cnh tranh

Ngy 21/7/2014

14

Cc ti liu khc c lin quan

Hp ng s 24/H-VHL ngy 31/5/2013

11