Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IN THIN-WALLED STRUCTURES
K F Chung
The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Kowloon, Hong Kong SAR
ABSTRACT
Instability is an important branch of structural mechanics which examines alternate
equilibrium states associated with large deformation.
Structural instability in one
dimensional beam-column members and two dimensional plate members is examined in this
paper. Various forms of buckling, namely, column buckling, beam buckling and local plate
buckling, under different loading and boundary conditions are illustrated to establish the
phenomena as well as various analysis and design methods for practical design.
KEYWORDS
Structural instability, column buckling, beam buckling, local plate buckling.
84
COLUMN BUCKLING
Consider a column pinned at both ends [1] as shown in Figure 1.
Equilibrium
Alternative Equilibrium
P
Mx
Figure 1
Buckling of a column
Taking moment about the pinned support in the free body diagram,
Py + Mx = 0
d2y
As Mx = E I 2 ,
dx
EI
d2y
+ Py = 0
dx 2
85
By writing k 2 =
P
, the above equation is arranged as follows:
EI
d2y
+ k2 y = 0
2
dx
The solution of the differential equation is given by:
y = A sin(kx ) + B cos(kx ) + C x + D
d2y
=0
dx 2
=
when x = 0 and x = L
=
0,
and
sin (kL) = 0
Hence,
kL =
and
n
=
L
P
.
EI
PE
2 E I
L2
The deflected shape for the elastic critical buckling of the column is given by:
y = A sin (
x
)
L
Expanding the second moment of area, I , as the product of area and the radius of gyration,
A ry2 , the elastic critical buckling load, PE , may be re-presented as follows:
PE =
2
2
E A ry
L2
86
2
L
r
y
L
L
as = , the elastic critical buckling strength,
ry
ry
2 E
2
This equation gives the elastic critical buckling strength of a column in terms of its material
property, E, as well as its geometrical property, i.e. the column slenderness.
It is important to evaluate the compressive buckling strength of real columns, pc, in the
presence of initial mechanical and geometrical imperfections, a Perry Robertson interaction
formula [2] is adopted as follows:
pE py
pc =
where
py
where
+ 2 pE py
p y + (1 + )p E
2
0.001 a (
o )
is the Robertson constant with typical values such as 2.0, 3.5, 5.5, 8.0;
0.2
E
py
The choice of the value of the Robertson constant a depends on the cross-sections of the
columns, the axes of buckling, and the thicknesses of the sections.
87
It is highly desirable to represent the elastic critical buckling strength of a column, pE , into a
non-dimensional ratio. Consider the elastic critical buckling strength, pE , as follows:
pE =
2 E
2
E
py
Y =
so that
2 E
py
Hence
pE
= Y2
py
Similarly, a strength reduction factor may be established to allow for column buckling in real
columns, and a number of non-dimensionalised column buckling curves are established to
provide strength reduction factors to the design strengths of real columns for practical design
as shown in Figure 2. The following parameters are adopted:
pc
py
88
1.2
Material Yielding
Elastic Buckling
1.0
a=2
a = 3.5
0.8
a = 5.5
0.6
a=8
0.4
0.2
0.0
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
Non-dimensional slenderness,
Figure 2
BEAM BUCKLING
For a beam member with a bi-symmetric cross-section under uniform moment, the elastic
critical buckling moment, ME, is given by [2]:
ME =
where
L
E
G
Iy
H
J
EI y GJ
L
2 EH
1 + 2
L GJ
Iy
Ix
Mb =
where
pb
pb Sx
pE py
where
LT =
LT +
LT - p E p y
p y + ( 1 + LT ) p E
2
LT
LT
L0
0.001 LT ( LT
E
py
0.4
pE
2E
2
LT
LT
uv
L
ry
I y Sx 2
A2 H
1+
10
0.25
AH
J Iy
1
4
Sx
L0 )
1+
1
20 x
LT
LT
LT
Y
1.2
Material yielding
1.0
LT
Elastic buckling
0.8
0.6
a = 7.0
0.4
0.2
0.0
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
Non-dimensionalised slenderness, LT
Figure 3
91
2.0
Consider a rectangular plate which is simply supported along both the longitudinal and the
transverse edges [3]. The plate is under a compression force of No along the transverse
edges.
y
No
S/S
S/S
S/S
S/S
a
w
Figure 4
Assume that the deflected shape of the plate is represented with sine curves in both
longitudinal and traverse directions as follows:
m =1 n =1
mn
x
y
sin m sin n
a
b
m2 n 2
b
2
a D 2 + 2 A mn
8 m=1 n =1 a
b
4
dw
2
2 b
2
dx
dy
=
o m A mn
0 dx
8a
m =1 n =1
b
m2 n 2
b
b
2
2
N cr m 2 A mn = 4 a D 2 + 2 A mn
8a
8
a
b
m =1 n =1
m =1 n =1
92
Ncr =
m2 n 2
2
a D 2 + 2 A mn
b
m =1 n =1 a
2
m
m =1 n =1
A mn
To obtain the smallest value of Ncr, consider only the first term as follows:
Ncr =
2 a 2 D m 2 n 2
2 + 2
2
b
m
a
Ncr =
2 D
a2
2 m + 2 2
m b
a
Alternatively, by re-writing the formula in term of the elastic critical buckling strength, pcr ,
pcr =
N cr
t
or
2 E
t
K
2
12 (1 ) b
2 D
b2t
where k is equal to 4 for the minimum value of the elastic critical buckling strength in simply
supported plates.
93
Consider a rectangular plate which is simply supported along both the longitudinal and the
transverse edges [3]. The plate is under an in-plane bending moment with a linearly varying
compression force of No along the transverse edges.
y
y
1 2 No
b
S/S
S/S
S/S
S/S
a
w
Figure 5
Assume that the deflected shape of a plate is represented with sine curves in both longitudinal
and traverse directions as follows:
A
m =1 n =1
mn
sin
mx
ny
sin
a
b
D ab 4
2 4
A
m =1 n =1
2
mn
m2 n 2 2
+ )
a 2 b2
1 a b
y dw
N 0 (1 )( ) 2 dxdy
2 0 0
b dx
By equating the work done and the strain energy, the elastic critical buckling load is given by:
94
Ncr =
A mn
m =1 n =1
m22
a2
m2 n 2 2
D A mn ( 2 + 2 )
a
b
m =1 n =1
2 2
m
32
2
2 [ A mn 2
2 m =1 a
n =1
4
n =1
A mn A mi ni
]
2
i2 )2
(n
2 a2
a
b
a2
[A mn
16 A mi ni
2 2 2 2 ]}
i (n i )
Assume that the deflected shape is approximated by the first three terms:
mx 3
ny
A mn sin
w = sin
a n =1
b
The minimum value of the elastic critical buckling strength, pcr , is given by:
N cr
t
pcr =
or
2 E
t
K
2
12 (1 ) b
2 D
b2t
a
as follows:
b
a
b
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.667
0.75
0.8
0.9
1.0
1.5
29.1
25.6
24.1
23.9
24.1
24.4
25.6
25.6
24.1
95
It is important to evaluate the effective section capacities of plates undergoing local plate
buckling in the presence of initial mechanical and geometrical imperfections, and a codified
section analysis using an effective thickness approach or an effective width approach may be
adopted.
Based on the effective width approach, the effective width, beff , of a plate undergoing local
plate buckling may be established [4] as follows:
beff
b
=
5
1 + 14 f /p 0.35 4
c
cr
where b is the width of the plate and fc is the applied compressive stress of the plate.
Figure 6 plots the function of
beff
b
b
.
t
1.2
K = 0.425
1.0
K = 4.00
beff / b
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
0
Figure 6
50
100
150
200
250
b/t
Ratio of effective width to flat width of compression plate
Figures 7, 8 and 9 illustrate local plate buckling in rectangular plates under different loading
and boundary conditions. The following analyses are performed and summarised for direct
comparison:
Geometry
Geometrical data
P
S/S
S/S
P
S/S
S/S
a
200 mm
100 mm
1.6 mm
a/b
62.5
b/t
Pcr = 30.3 kN
Material data
280
280
113
c
32 mm
280
32 mm
280
50
Pgross = 44.8 kN
40
Pcr = 30.3 kN
PFEM = 29.3 kN
30
20
pcr
pcr
b eff =
b
10
0
0
0.04
0.08
0.12
0.16
Pgross =
189.4 N/mm2
4
f
1 + 14 c 0.35
p
cr
0.64
97
A py
44.8 kN
30.3 kN
PLB =
Aeff py
28.9 kN
PFEM =
29.3 kN
Pcr
4.0
0.2
Figure 7
2E
t
K
12(1 2 ) b
0.2
Geometry
Geometrical data
P
S/S
S/S
Free
a
S/S
200 mm
50 mm
1.6 mm
a/b
31.3
b/t
Material data
Pcr = 12.8 kN
280 N/mm2
32 mm
94 N/mm2
pcr
pcr
25
Pgross = 22.4 kN
20
b eff =
b
15
Pcr = 12.8 kN
10
280 N/mm2
PFEM = 9.23 kN
2E
t
K
12(1 2 ) b
0.423
189.4 N/mm2
4
f
1 + 14 c 0.35
p
cr
0.647
Pgross =
A py
22.4 kN
12.8 kN
PLB =
Aeff py
9.45 kN
PFEM =
9.23 kN
0
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
Figure 8
Pcr
0.2
M
Geometrical data
S/S
S/S
200 mm
100 mm
0.6 mm
a/b
62.5
Geometry
M
S/S
S/S
b/t
Mcr
= 0.340 kNm
Material data
py
350 N/mm2
205 kN/mm2
0.3
280
0
280
Material
and
geometrical
nonlinear analysis
po
0.5
0 .5
b py
p y
1.13 0.0019
t 280
271.6 N/mm2
0.4
0.3
Mgross
0.1
= py Z
=
0.351 kNm
Mcr
0.340 kNm
MLB
= po Z
=
MFEM
0
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
Rotation,
Figure 9
99
0.272 kNm
= 0.263 kNm
Comparison with gross section capacities and effective section capacities in the presence of
local plate buckling are provided. It should be noted that the results from various analyses
are very close among themselves.
CONCLUSIONS
REFERENCES
100