Tnh/thnh ph

Bnh Dng
Nng
Vnh Long
Bnh nh
Lo Cai
An Giang
Vnh Phc
B Ra - Vng Tu
ng Thp
TP.HCM
Sc Trng
Tin Giang
Qung Nam
Bn Tre
TT-Hu
ng Nai
Cn Th
Yn Bi
Hu Giang
Bc Ninh
Long An
Qung Ninh
Ph Yn
Ninh Bnh
Bnh Thun
Hng Yn
H Ni
Tr Vinh
C Mau
Gia Lai
Thi Bnh
Ph Th
Bc Giang
H Giang
Ty Ninh
Hi Dng
Hi Phng
Thanh Ha
Kin Giang
Khnh Ha
H Ty
Tuyn Quang
Thi Nguyn
Nam nh
Qung Ngi
H Nam
Qung Tr
ak Lak
Bnh Phc

Xp hng
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49

Vng
ng Nam B
Thnh ph trc
ng bng Sng
Duyn hi Min T
Vng ni pha B
ng bng Sng
ng bng Sng
ng Nam B
ng bng Sng
Thnh ph trc
ng bng Sng
ng bng Sng
Duyn hi Min T
ng bng Sng
Duyn hi Min T
ng Nam B
Thnh ph trc
Vng ni pha B
ng bng Sng
ng bng Sng
ng Nam B
ng bng Sng
Duyn hi Min T
ng bng Sng
ng Nam B
ng bng Sng
Thnh ph trc
ng bng Sng
ng bng Sng
Ty Nguyn
ng bng Sng
Vng ni pha B
Vng ni pha B
Vng ni pha B
ng Nam B
ng bng Sng
Thnh ph trc
Duyn hi Min T
ng bng Sng
Duyn hi Min T
ng bng Sng
Vng ni pha B
Vng ni pha B
ng bng Sng
Duyn hi Min T
ng bng Sng
Duyn hi Min T
Ty Nguyn
ng Nam B

Nhm xp
hng PCI 2007
Rt tt
Rt tt
Rt tt
Rt tt
Tt
Tt
Tt
Tt
Tt
Tt
Tt
Tt
Tt
Tt
Tt
Tt
Tt
Kh
Kh
Kh
Kh
Kh
Kh
Kh
Kh
Kh
Kh
Kh
Kh
Kh
Kh
Kh
Kh
Kh
Trung bnh
Trung bnh
Trung bnh
Trung bnh
Trung bnh
Trung bnh
Trung bnh
Trung bnh
Trung bnh
Trung bnh
Trung bnh
Trung bnh
Trung bnh
Trung bnh
Trung bnh

Chi ph gia
nhp th
trng
7.95
9.17
8.02
9.26
8.23
7.76
7.59
7.59
8.09
6.99
9.10
8.81
8.76
8.85
8.47
8.46
8.50
7.36
6.23
7.12
8.28
8.73
7.56
9.29
7.92
7.19
6.30
7.75
7.12
8.81
6.97
8.04
7.49
7.30
7.47
7.92
8.09
8.30
6.45
7.95
8.33
8.79
8.04
7.49
7.43
6.66
9.49
7.32
7.96

Sn La
Ha Bnh
Lm ng
Ngh An
Qung Bnh
Ninh Thun
Bc Kn
H Tnh
Kon Tum
Lng Sn
Bc Liu
in Bin
Cao Bng
Lai Chu
ak Nng

50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64

Vng ni pha B Trung bnh

Vng ni pha B Trung bnh
Ty Nguyn
Trung bnh
Duyn hi Min T Trung bnh
Duyn hi Min T Trung bnh
ng Nam B
Tng i thp
Vng ni pha B Tng i thp
Duyn hi Min T Tng i thp
Ty Nguyn
Tng i thp
Vng ni pha B Tng i thp
ng bng Sng Tng i thp
Vng ni pha B
Thp
Vng ni pha B
Thp
Vng ni pha B
Thp
Ty Nguyn
Thp

Min
Max
Trung v

8.22
7.62
7.82
7.58
7.63
7.73
7.72
7.11
8.87
8.04
6.56
7.40
8.42
7.15
6.45

6.23
9.49
7.87

Chi ph v thi
Tip cn t
gian thc
u i i vi
Tnh nng
ai v s n Tnh minh bch hin cc quy
DNNN (Mi
ng v tin
nh trong s
v tip cn
nh ca Nh Chi ph khng
trng cnh phong ca lnh
dng t
thng tin
nc
chnh thc
tranh)
o tnh
7.02
7.44
7.34
7.17
8.29
9.20
5.84
7.19
7.61
6.84
7.28
6.26
6.67
7.54
6.20
6.43
8.24
6.71
6.47
7.72
6.05
6.86
7.99
7.22
6.27
8.56
4.80
6.36
7.85
6.90
6.63
6.93
6.93
6.57
6.94
7.71
6.75
7.00
4.48
7.58
6.83
7.32
5.50
7.21
7.80
6.96
7.08
5.74
7.06
7.12
6.49
6.64
7.20
5.99
5.89
7.15
6.24
5.79
6.01
6.00
6.78
5.82
7.35
5.96
7.07
7.11
7.10
6.39
7.49
7.71
7.76
6.76
5.90
6.63
6.26
6.13
6.73
6.89
7.23
6.53
7.90
7.63
5.92
6.07
5.53
6.61
7.19
6.41
7.24
5.88
6.61
5.80
6.42
6.65
6.02
6.03
6.49
5.95
6.74
6.63
6.17
4.57
6.70
5.98
6.25
6.65
7.19
5.52
7.17
5.71
6.66
6.53
5.73
7.12
7.16
5.64
6.63
6.80
6.62
5.91
7.71
6.32
6.69
7.04
6.70
5.76
6.06
5.29
6.86
7.22
7.35
5.10
6.82
5.71
5.20
6.72
7.35
5.03
5.78
5.79
6.08
7.00
7.13
5.80
5.89
5.91
7.96
6.78
6.96
4.32
6.85
7.07
6.60
7.71
6.59
5.25
4.32
6.47
5.83
5.36
5.19
5.19
7.15
5.32
5.65
6.09
6.32
6.78
6.05
6.35
7.76
6.07
6.66
4.67
5.93
6.41
5.31
6.82
6.96
5.86
6.07
6.30
7.25
6.16
7.32
5.09
7.02
5.84
6.21
6.87
6.87
4.86
6.46
5.15
5.16
6.92
6.89
5.19
6.57
6.16
5.33
6.60
7.52
5.50
6.78
6.34
5.48
6.99
5.73
4.74
5.84
5.39
6.24
6.74
6.99
4.64
5.33
5.81
7.56
6.39
6.31
3.23
6.49
5.99
6.12
6.15
6.46
4.32
6.59
5.78
6.67
5.89
4.88
4.17
5.32
5.18
7.13
5.38
6.66
3.63
5.30
4.88
8.18
7.02
6.79
5.56
5.60
5.96
5.49
7.11
6.24
4.24
6.28
5.26
5.71
6.43
5.24
3.75
6.24
6.13
7.57
6.91
5.12
4.28
5.97
5.75
6.48
5.57
6.53
3.82
6.94
6.57
5.77
7.07
6.15
4.29
6.41
5.61
5.73
6.08
6.00
3.42
6.01
6.31
5.30
6.31
6.52
3.30
7.16
5.00
5.45
6.72
5.94
4.56

7.63
6.72
5.96
5.83
6.11
6.46
5.26
6.01
6.02
5.47
6.44
6.21
5.24
5.00
5.29

5.03
4.09
5.17
5.64
6.01
5.63
4.10
5.83
5.64
3.63
4.40
4.79
4.71
3.80
2.24

4.75
7.00
5.60
5.91
5.95
6.26
3.65
6.10
3.90
4.39
5.29
4.23
4.40
2.99
4.60

6.90
6.35
6.38
5.66
5.92
5.88
5.72
5.55
6.09
6.71
5.82
7.27
6.10
6.30
6.44

6.84
6.85
6.45
5.84
6.73
6.17
6.93
5.74
7.43
6.47
6.06
6.92
7.02
7.11
4.79

4.29
3.67
3.87
2.84
4.06
3.04
4.30
3.37
3.25
2.36
3.37
3.16
2.30
5.17
3.49

4.32
7.71
6.27

2.24
8.56
5.84

2.99
8.18
6.21

5.36
7.71
6.59

4.79
8.29
6.73

2.30
9.20
4.95

Chnh sch
pht trin khu
vc kinh t t
nhn
8.38
8.39
6.98
7.92
6.27
7.44
6.92
6.84
6.39
8.73
5.92
5.44
6.67
4.70
6.13
6.05
6.86
5.17
4.99
4.62
3.61
5.12
5.56
3.99
6.03
5.44
7.12
3.95
4.28
5.33
4.94
4.39
4.54
4.21
4.60
4.98
5.56
4.62
4.53
5.93
4.22
4.71
4.72
4.12
4.19
4.42
4.03
5.01
4.03

Ch s PCI
o to lao
Thit ch php 2007 cha c
ng
l
trng s
7.75
5.48
76.02
8.34
5.49
72.43
8.05
5.33
70.18
6.24
4.47
70.20
6.24
5.84
67.31
4.94
5.05
66.91
7.36
4.31
66.13
6.31
5.13
66.16
6.40
5.07
66.43
6.59
3.54
62.93
5.91
5.73
66.76
4.97
6.10
68.53
5.02
5.08
64.07
5.78
5.54
66.15
6.67
3.52
63.63
7.33
4.21
63.59
6.67
5.06
63.64
6.70
4.50
62.00
5.43
5.05
60.61
5.94
5.32
61.76
5.75
5.10
62.97
5.27
5.62
62.63
5.96
5.05
60.96
5.58
5.27
61.70
4.87
4.23
60.86
4.74
2.95
60.39
5.65
3.66
55.10
5.17
5.17
59.34
5.26
4.64
58.86
4.17
3.94
59.54
5.23
3.16
58.47
5.35
4.36
59.81
6.59
4.24
58.63
4.29
5.04
58.51
4.65
4.48
57.25
4.67
3.73
57.13
4.90
3.31
56.49
4.02
4.58
57.05
4.22
6.20
55.38
4.53
3.74
55.44
3.42
3.22
56.93
4.66
3.41
56.21
6.49
2.96
54.90
4.38
2.96
55.18
5.03
3.97
54.75
4.08
3.07
55.02
5.87
2.99
55.63
4.72
3.65
54.45
3.93
4.76
55.51

Ch s PCI
2007 c
trng s
77.20
72.96
70.14
69.46
66.95
66.47
66.06
65.63
64.89
64.83
64.68
64.63
62.92
62.88
62.44
62.33
61.76
59.73
59.41
58.96
58.82
58.34
57.87
57.67
57.66
57.47
56.73
56.30
56.19
56.16
55.99
55.64
55.48
54.59
53.92
53.23
53.19
52.82
52.82
52.42
52.24
52.13
52.02
51.76
51.39
51.29
51.10
51.05
50.38

5.13
4.56
4.25
3.81
3.66
3.24
2.89
2.48
3.07
3.77
2.26
2.48
2.44
2.42
2.94

4.04
4.79
4.30
5.27
4.36
5.06
4.33
4.98
3.70
4.71
3.84
2.83
3.73
1.92
2.36

3.05
3.76
4.57
5.06
3.23
2.50
6.57
2.25
2.94
3.80
3.96
3.69
2.62
2.44
5.33

55.90
55.40
54.36
53.43
53.66
51.97
51.47
49.43
50.91
49.34
47.99
48.97
46.97
44.31
43.93

50.35
50.18
49.85
49.76
49.51
47.33
46.47
45.56
44.54
43.23
42.49
41.70
40.18
38.19
37.96

2.26
8.73
4.71

1.92
8.34
5.03

2.25
6.57
4.33

43.93
76.02
58.49

37.96
77.20
55.56

Cc ch tiu s dng trong ch s thnh phn Chi ph gia nhp th trng

Ch tiu

Tnh/Ngun
H Ni
Hi Phng
Nng
TP.HCM
Cn Th
Thanh Ha
Ngh An
H Tnh
Qung Bnh
Qung Tr
TT-Hu
Qung Nam
Qung Ngi
Bnh nh
Ph Yn
Khnh Ha
ng Thp
An Giang
Tin Giang
Vnh Long
Bn Tre
Kin Giang
Tr Vinh
Sc Trng
Bc Liu
C Mau
Bnh Phc
Ty Ninh
Ninh Thun
Long An
Qung Ninh
Hu Giang
B Ra - Vng Tu
Bc Ninh
Bnh Dng
Bnh Thun
ng Nai
H Nam
H Ty
Hi Dng
Hng Yn
Nam nh
Ninh Bnh
Thi Bnh
Vnh Phc
Bc Kn
Bc Giang
Cao Bng
ak Lak
ak Nng
in Bin
Gia Lai
Ha Bnh
Kon Tum
Lai Chu
Lm ng
Lng Sn
Lo Cai
Ph Th
Sn La
Thi Nguyn
Tuyn Quang
Yn Bi
H Giang
Min
Max

Thi gian ng k
kinh doanh - s
ngy
(Gi tr trung v)

S lng giy ng
k, giy php kinh
doanh v quyt nh
Thi gian ng k chp thun m DN
li - s ngy (Gi tr hin c (Gi tr trung
trung v)
v)

Thi gian ch i
thc s c
cp t (S ngy
trung v)

Qu trnh m
phn ko di
chuyn nhng
ko di bao lu
(S ngy trung
v)

Thi gian ch i
thc s c
mt bng kinh
doanh (S ngy
trung v)

B4.1.2+B4.1.3

% DN phi mt hn % DN phi mt hn
mt thng khi ba thng khi s
s kinh doanh
kinh doanh

% DN gp kh khn
c cc loi
giy php cn thit

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: C4

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: C4

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: C6

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: C1

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: C2

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: C3

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: B4.1.2

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: B4.1.3

41.94%
24.00%
10.00%
37.50%
20.00%
20.51%
26.67%
23.08%
33.33%
5.26%
14.29%
12.70%
37.50%
5.13%
29.73%
25.00%
23.08%
24.24%
22.73%
28.00%
10.00%
35.71%
21.05%
6.25%
53.85%
38.46%
40.00%
33.33%
26.92%
16.00%
15.38%
45.45%
27.50%
44.44%
24.24%
30.00%
23.33%
48.00%
12.12%
31.25%
37.14%
33.33%
8.33%
25.93%
27.78%
31.58%
31.71%
20.69%
32.14%
30.30%
33.33%
14.49%
30.30%
12.50%
31.58%
32.61%
30.30%
17.95%
30.77%
29.55%
16.00%
7.89%
40.00%
18.75%

12.90%
4.00%
1.67%
6.25%
4.44%
2.56%
13.33%
15.38%
4.76%
0.00%
5.71%
3.17%
12.50%
2.56%
16.22%
8.33%
7.69%
9.09%
4.55%
12.00%
0.00%
21.43%
10.53%
0.00%
15.38%
7.69%
0.00%
14.81%
7.69%
4.00%
3.85%
27.27%
5.00%
7.41%
9.09%
5.00%
0.00%
4.00%
6.06%
4.17%
8.57%
6.67%
4.17%
14.81%
5.56%
10.53%
14.63%
6.90%
7.14%
21.21%
13.33%
4.35%
9.09%
6.25%
15.79%
6.52%
3.03%
7.69%
7.69%
4.55%
4.00%
5.26%
10.00%
12.50%

36.84%
9.26%
4.69%
27.94%
4.35%
10.53%
16.67%
22.22%
12.50%
9.09%
6.06%
14.93%
14.29%
5.26%
15.38%
12.50%
14.29%
17.14%
0.00%
3.70%
4.76%
16.13%
9.52%
5.88%
7.14%
17.86%
15.00%
3.57%
19.64%
20.00%
7.27%
18.18%
23.81%
17.24%
9.09%
10.00%
9.68%
24.00%
8.11%
15.38%
10.81%
16.67%
0.00%
25.00%
17.95%
12.82%
8.89%
10.34%
26.67%
23.53%
9.68%
7.04%
12.90%
6.06%
14.29%
4.08%
5.41%
12.50%
3.57%
10.42%
11.54%
7.89%
9.52%
17.65%

20
15
10
20
10
15
7
8.5
15
7
15
10
10
7
7
14
10
10
8.5
7
14
15
15
12.5
15
15
15
15
15
7
15
10
15
20
14.5
15
15
22.5
15
15
20
15
7
15
15
10
10
15
15
15
15
8.5
15
8.5
15
15
15
15
10
10
22.5
15
15
15

10
7
7
10
7
10
7
7
10
5
7
5
7
3
5
7
7
7
7
5
10
13
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
10
3
10
7
7
7
10
7
10
7
10
7
7
10
15
7
7
7
10
10
7
7
10
6
5
10
8
7
7
7
7.5
7
7
7

2
1
2
2
3
2
2.5
4
3
1.5
3
2
2
3
2
2
2.5
3
2
3
3
3
4
3
4
4
2
3
2
3
1
3
2
2.5
2.5
3
2
4
3
2
3
3
2
2.5
2
2
3
1
2
3
3
2
2
2
3
3
3
2
3
2
2
2
3
5

45
180
35
60
50
120
52.5
60
60
30
50
30
67
52.5
60
95
30
45
30
60
30
52.5
30
30
45
40
30
60
60
30
60
60
60
60
60
60
60
90
60
60
90
90
30
67.5
60
90
30
60
60
90
30
60
60
30
90
60
90
30
60
60
60
60
30
30

10
270
22.5
60
52.5
37.5
65
55
37.5
30
29
30
20
22.5
30
30
15
30
30
30
60
30
30
30
32.5
30
18.5
30
30
30
30
27.5
60
15
60
25
30
3
30
37.5
60
23
30
60
30
30
45
30
30
30
30
60
30
52.5
30
60
45
30
30
270
30
52.5
16

55
450
57.5
120
102.5
157.5
117.5
115
97.5
60
79
60
87
75
90
125
45
75
60
90
90
82.5
60
60
77.5
70
48.5
90
90
60
90
87.5
120
75
120
85
90
93
90
97.5
150
113
60
127.5
90
120
75
90
60
120
60
90
120
60
142.5
90
150
75
90
90
330
90
82.5
46

5.13%
53.85%

0.00%
27.27%

0.00%
36.84%

7.00
22.50

3.00
15.00

1.00
5.00

30.00
180.00

3.00
270.00

45.00
450.00

Ch s thnh
phn 1: Chi ph
gia nhp th
trng
Tnh/Thnh ph
Qung Tr
Ninh Bnh
Bnh nh
Nng
Sc Trng
Kon Tum
Bn Tre
Gia Lai
Tin Giang
Tuyn Quang
Qung Nam
Qung Ninh
Cn Th
TT-Hu
ng Nai
Cao Bng
H Ty
Thanh Ha
Long An
Lo Cai
Sn La
Hi Phng
ng Thp
Ph Th
Lng Sn
Thi Nguyn
Vnh Long
Bnh Phc
Khnh Ha
Bnh Dng
Hi Dng
Bnh Thun
Lm ng
An Giang
Tr Vinh
Ninh Thun
Bc Kn
Qung Bnh
Ha Bnh
B Ra - Vng Tu
Vnh Phc
Ngh An
Ph Yn
Bc Giang
Nam nh
Ty Ninh
Qung Ngi
in Bin
Yn Bi
ak Lak
H Giang
Hng Yn
Lai Chu
Bc Ninh
C Mau
H Tnh
TP.HCM
Thi Bnh
H Nam
Bc Liu
ak Nng
Kin Giang
H Ni
Hu Giang

9.49
9.29
9.26
9.17
9.10
8.87
8.85
8.81
8.81
8.79
8.76
8.73
8.50
8.47
8.46
8.42
8.33
8.30
8.28
8.23
8.22
8.09
8.09
8.04
8.04
8.04
8.02
7.96
7.95
7.95
7.92
7.92
7.82
7.76
7.75
7.73
7.72
7.63
7.62
7.59
7.59
7.58
7.56
7.49
7.49
7.47
7.43
7.40
7.36
7.32
7.30
7.19
7.15
7.12
7.12
7.11
6.99
6.97
6.66
6.56
6.45
6.45
6.30
6.23
6.23
9.49

Cc ch tiu s dng trong ch s th

Ch tiu

Tnh/Ngun
H Ni
Hi Phng
Nng
TP.HCM
Cn Th
Thanh Ha
Ngh An
H Tnh
Qung Bnh
Qung Tr
TT-Hu
Qung Nam
Qung Ngi
Bnh nh
Ph Yn
Khnh Ha
ng Thp
An Giang
Tin Giang
Vnh Long
Bn Tre
Kin Giang
Tr Vinh
Sc Trng
Bc Liu
C Mau
Bnh Phc
Ty Ninh
Ninh Thun
Long An
Qung Ninh
Hu Giang
B Ra - Vng Tu
Bc Ninh
Bnh Dng
Bnh Thun
ng Nai
H Nam
H Ty
Hi Dng

% DN cho rng
thiu mt bng
% DN nh gi
kinh doanh hn
Chnh
sch chuyn
ch kh nng m
% DN c GCNQSD rng kinh doanh
i t nng nghip
t hoc ang trong
% DN thu li t t ca tnh l Tt hoc
ca h
qu trnh ch nhn
DNNN
Rt tt
Cu hi iu tra
PCI: B4.1

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: B3.1

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: B5.1.3

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: E1.8

56.76%
65.38%
61.00%
55.81%
77.38%
79.57%
69.23%
76.56%
74.29%
90.41%
64.71%
80.37%
86.89%
67.42%
74.07%
66.67%
79.31%
82.76%
89.39%
85.71%
84.78%
76.06%
88.31%
92.45%
78.95%
76.92%
76.92%
87.69%
75.90%
88.68%
57.29%
82.54%
64.58%
68.25%
84.29%
77.08%
69.12%
68.63%
61.11%
61.25%

65.83%
69.18%
69.54%
67.46%
67.48%
66.42%
59.69%
63.54%
73.63%
60.58%
64.89%
66.91%
60.92%
64.23%
71.01%
64.36%
58.33%
58.59%
52.81%
63.64%
60.68%
50.60%
56.38%
64.62%
47.06%
62.37%
63.75%
50.56%
66.67%
54.17%
68.49%
62.65%
64.79%
64.29%
69.81%
81.16%
60.44%
66.67%
72.41%
64.75%

36.21%
25.64%
13.16%
9.09%
11.11%
21.74%
14.06%
22.86%
17.86%
17.14%
16.67%
11.86%
5.26%
17.74%
13.79%
16.00%
19.05%
6.67%
10.00%
4.76%
21.43%
12.50%
12.50%
25.00%
50.00%
20.83%
15.79%
9.52%
4.76%
15.00%
12.50%
0.00%
19.64%
4.26%
15.38%
7.89%
13.33%
2.17%
14.93%
14.06%

43.53%
62.40%
72.32%
58.75%
57.84%
50.47%
47.62%
43.24%
49.35%
43.33%
62.67%
61.76%
47.76%
71.70%
54.84%
61.25%
59.77%
50.00%
59.02%
69.33%
62.82%
44.44%
46.27%
63.27%
37.84%
50.00%
39.34%
57.97%
50.00%
53.70%
61.32%
39.66%
62.62%
80.72%
81.25%
63.79%
69.01%
61.19%
55.56%
73.68%

Hng Yn
Nam nh
Ninh Bnh
Thi Bnh
Vnh Phc
Bc Kn
Bc Giang
Cao Bng
ak Lak
ak Nng
in Bin
Gia Lai
Ha Bnh
Kon Tum
Lai Chu
Lm ng
Lng Sn
Lo Cai
Ph Th
Sn La
Thi Nguyn
Tuyn Quang
Yn Bi
H Giang
Min
Max

65.63%
73.79%
79.07%
82.19%
73.27%
68.12%
66.23%
67.69%
73.97%
78.57%
81.63%
70.51%
82.18%
62.96%
74.07%
75.23%
67.11%
73.08%
74.67%
78.16%
76.92%
51.35%
85.19%
85.45%

62.96%
68.35%
69.44%
62.71%
73.48%
67.01%
63.06%
63.86%
63.33%
74.24%
71.43%
67.86%
67.42%
64.79%
81.08%
64.00%
69.91%
61.39%
62.89%
66.96%
65.31%
63.16%
68.47%
66.15%

3.64%
14.75%
8.11%
14.93%
7.46%
10.81%
14.58%
10.00%
34.78%
0.00%
31.82%
6.98%
10.91%
3.70%
0.00%
13.79%
14.89%
6.06%
8.16%
11.36%
10.87%
10.34%
6.82%
10.71%

79.12%
65.45%
63.83%
66.00%
79.82%
35.14%
54.74%
25.68%
48.48%
45.83%
23.53%
64.10%
45.13%
44.44%
26.67%
60.00%
40.86%
64.71%
63.64%
46.88%
55.81%
41.94%
60.49%
50.00%

51.35%
92.45%

47.06%
81.16%

0.00%
50.00%

23.53%
81.25%

ng trong ch s thnh phn Tip cn t ai v S n nh trong s dng t

Tip cn t ai

DN nh gi ri
ro b thu hi t
(1: Rt cao n
5: Rt thp)

Nu b thu hi
DN nh gi ri
t, DN s c
ro v thay i
bi thng tha
cc iu kin cho
ng (% Lun
thu (1: Rt cao
lun hoc
hoc 5: Rt thp)
Thng xuyn)

Mng 2.1

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: B4.1.4

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: B4.1.5

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: B5.2

2.43
2.99
2.69
3.29
3.92
3.61
3.32
3.35
2.97
2.82
2.26
2.54
2.94
3.13
3.37
2.90
3.75
3.64
3.99
3.97
3.99
3.82
3.86
3.73
3.35
3.30
3.76
3.88
3.54
4.13
2.92
4.05
2.70
3.55
3.93
3.17
3.74
4.11
2.71
3.08

3.43
3.84
3.47
3.49
3.57
3.86
3.75
3.83
3.88
3.88
3.80
3.45
3.53
3.55
3.52
3.46
3.74
3.58
3.89
3.55
3.66
4.10
4.05
3.83
4.07
4.26
3.82
4.16
3.59
3.96
3.71
3.83
3.58
3.90
3.63
3.86
3.76
3.98
3.68
3.81

26.92%
32.91%
50.00%
37.23%
32.89%
40.63%
32.39%
38.10%
47.83%
55.26%
48.08%
52.48%
39.66%
43.53%
47.73%
46.15%
37.97%
41.25%
35.21%
33.33%
38.64%
22.22%
45.21%
36.36%
42.42%
40.63%
43.75%
25.00%
36.62%
46.15%
41.25%
38.33%
35.00%
53.57%
37.68%
34.78%
37.10%
40.91%
40.32%
38.36%

2.71
2.75
2.97
3.04
2.96
2.83
2.93
3.07
3.00
3.22
3.25
3.02
3.20
3.41
3.26
2.59
3.44
3.23
3.00
2.88
3.40
3.26
2.79
3.33
3.36
2.77
3.39
3.37
3.25
3.32
3.22
3.08
3.09
3.10
3.10
3.11
3.03
2.89
2.94
2.90

% din tch t c
GCNQSD t
D liu cng B
Ti nguyn & Mi
trng
2003 & 2007
53.80%
62.50%
36.70%
70.60%
92.70%
86.95%
67.81%
77.62%
63.40%
39.48%
17.43%
23.11%
37.15%
53.05%
74.88%
47.40%
79.27%
69.81%
75.08%
77.21%
89.89%
80.97%
81.64%
79.83%
81.44%
68.96%
94.93%
69.00%
74.56%
89.65%
53.94%
94.80%
40.47%
59.24%
81.88%
64.35%
76.46%
97.46%
50.88%
50.39%

58.74%
47.40%
52.93%
50.54%
48.84%
31.04%
62.86%
54.56%
30.43%
40.25%
81.81%
33.37%
84.69%
24.42%
54.36%
75.26%
60.82%
27.66%
78.17%
80.54%
50.18%
13.28%
31.10%
70.90%

3.53
2.96
3.18
3.22
3.15
2.29
3.19
2.74
2.24
2.71
2.98
2.73
3.66
2.35
2.61
3.59
2.86
2.79
3.79
3.55
3.05
1.92
2.78
3.48

3.75
3.71
4.07
3.56
3.78
4.11
3.87
3.79
3.73
3.53
4.05
3.67
3.70
3.50
3.70
3.74
3.70
3.63
3.59
3.90
3.95
3.89
3.97
3.86

43.75%
46.88%
35.06%
44.44%
47.30%
31.25%
47.06%
29.82%
49.23%
38.00%
46.67%
43.48%
47.25%
57.14%
31.03%
32.04%
26.09%
42.86%
45.31%
55.17%
46.67%
44.26%
53.25%
39.13%

3.33
3.16
2.67
2.94
3.27
3.20
3.00
3.08
3.59
2.78
2.81
3.22
3.02
3.22
3.00
2.89
3.25
3.23
3.11
3.48
3.02
3.48
3.25
3.14

13.28%
97.46%

1.92
4.13

3.43
4.26

22.22%
57.14%

2.59
3.59

h trong s dng t
Nu hp ng
cho thu thay
i, s c c ch
gii quyt tranh
chp cng bng
(% Lun lun
hoc Thng
xuyn)

Tnh n nh
trong s dng
t

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: B5.3

Mng 2.2

23.29%
25.30%
44.44%
30.51%
37.70%
40.00%
31.08%
20.75%
34.21%
37.04%
32.14%
50.72%
43.18%
44.59%
51.22%
24.19%
45.65%
35.00%
55.26%
50.00%
44.90%
39.53%
52.94%
35.29%
17.65%
22.86%
40.63%
35.71%
38.24%
46.43%
40.96%
48.28%
41.67%
46.15%
52.54%
27.91%
40.00%
30.00%
22.97%
35.80%

1.89
2.33
3.15
2.61
2.57
2.88
2.51
2.66
3.15
3.59
3.27
3.36
3.02
3.34
3.44
2.42
3.30
2.99
3.11
2.70
3.24
2.76
3.28
3.05
3.09
2.75
3.40
2.90
2.92
3.58
3.14
3.12
2.80
3.61
3.09
2.72
2.87
2.83
2.59
2.77

Ch s thnh
phn 2: Tip
cn t ai v
S n nh
trong s dng
t
Tnh/Thnh ph
Long An
Sn La
Bn Tre
Hu Giang
Bnh Phc
Bc Ninh
Tr Vinh
Tin Giang
ng Thp
Ph Th
Bnh Dng
H Nam
Hng Yn
Ph Yn
Ty Ninh
Sc Trng
Vnh Phc
Ha Bnh
Yn Bi
Vnh Long
An Giang
ng Nai
Kin Giang
H Giang
Thanh Ha
Cn Th
Bnh nh
Ninh Thun
Bc Giang
Bc Liu
Qung Tr
Thi Nguyn
Lo Cai
Nam nh
in Bin
Qung Bnh
Thi Bnh
Qung Ninh
C Mau
Kon Tum

Mng 2.1+2.2
7.71
7.63
7.23
7.17
7.16
7.16
7.15
7.10
7.06
7.02
7.02
6.94
6.85
6.82
6.78
6.78
6.75
6.72
6.70
6.67
6.63
6.61
6.59
6.57
6.49
6.49
6.47
6.46
6.46
6.44
6.41
6.28
6.27
6.24
6.21
6.11
6.07
6.06
6.05
6.02

40.32%
41.56%
35.19%
34.57%
53.33%
38.30%
43.55%
26.67%
46.15%
38.46%
45.71%
41.38%
34.33%
50.00%
25.00%
25.00%
35.19%
60.71%
48.08%
54.55%
38.30%
50.85%
57.38%
40.54%

3.32
3.28
2.61
2.85
3.60
2.97
3.27
2.49
3.77
2.57
3.23
3.20
3.06
3.67
2.40
2.37
2.61
3.48
3.23
4.08
3.23
3.69
3.92
3.08

17.65%
60.71%

1.89
4.08

ak Lak
H Tnh
Qung Ngi
Lm ng
Gia Lai
Qung Nam
TP.HCM
Bnh Thun
Hi Dng
Nng
Ngh An
Ninh Bnh
Tuyn Quang
TT-Hu
B Ra - Vng Tu
Lng Sn
Hi Phng
Khnh Ha
H Ty
ak Nng
Bc Kn
Cao Bng
Lai Chu
H Ni

6.01
6.01
5.97
5.96
5.93
5.90
5.89
5.89
5.84
5.84
5.83
5.78
5.60
5.53
5.50
5.47
5.33
5.32
5.30
5.29
5.26
5.24
5.00
4.32
4.32
7.71

Cc ch tiu s dn

Ch tiu

Tnh/Ngun
H Ni
Hi Phng
Nng
TP.HCM
Cn Th
Thanh Ha
Ngh An
H Tnh
Qung Bnh
Qung Tr
TT-Hu
Qung Nam
Qung Ngi
Bnh nh
Ph Yn
Khnh Ha
ng Thp
An Giang
Tin Giang
Vnh Long
Bn Tre
Kin Giang
Tr Vinh
Sc Trng
Bc Liu
C Mau
Bnh Phc
Ty Ninh
Ninh Thun
Long An
Qung Ninh
Hu Giang
B Ra - Vng Tu
Bc Ninh
Bnh Dng
Bnh Thun
ng Nai
H Nam
H Ty

Cn c "mi quan
h" c c
cc ti liu k
Tip cn ti liu
hoch ca tnh
(% Rt quan
trng hoc Quan
Tnh minh bch ca
trng)
Tnh minh bch ca cc quyt nh, ngh
cc ti liu k hoch
nh
Cu hi iu tra
PCI: F1.1-F1.13
(Nhn t 1)

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: F1.1-F1.13
(Nhn t 2)

Mng 3.1

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: F2

0.0827
-0.0625
0.1134
-0.2021
-0.2116
0.0298
-0.1993
-0.0041
-0.1938
0.1156
0.0288
-0.0016
0.0415
0.2758
-0.0171
-0.3310
-0.1091
0.1426
-0.0799
0.0387
0.1050
0.1739
-0.3086
0.0526
-0.0714
0.0700
-0.0966
-0.1252
0.0006
-0.3892
-0.0441
0.0443
-0.0604
-0.0507
0.1734
-0.1634
-0.2104
0.1107
-0.0940

-0.2078
-0.2896
0.1014
0.0423
0.0949
-0.0389
0.1794
0.1060
0.0812
-0.0660
-0.0134
0.1005
-0.2328
0.0498
-0.0270
0.0646
0.2542
-0.0078
0.0231
0.0966
-0.1493
-0.0475
0.1346
0.1939
-0.1108
0.1866
-0.3309
-0.1530
0.2308
0.0450
0.1856
0.1802
0.1265
-0.1541
0.3362
0.0986
-0.0159
-0.2839
-0.3658

0.87
0.66
1.25
0.92
0.97
1.02
1.08
1.16
0.97
1.06
1.05
1.15
0.81
1.33
1.00
0.84
1.24
1.15
1.00
1.18
0.96
1.13
0.94
1.30
0.86
1.31
0.59
0.76
1.30
0.77
1.21
1.28
1.13
0.82
1.56
1.02
0.85
0.81
0.55

44.04%
54.48%
38.41%
41.03%
53.98%
66.94%
58.97%
63.33%
59.52%
48.96%
62.50%
49.58%
73.42%
55.04%
49.23%
50.52%
57.73%
53.85%
50.67%
55.56%
55.56%
51.39%
63.10%
52.63%
65.85%
65.43%
60.29%
49.33%
55.56%
58.46%
52.52%
56.76%
49.23%
57.30%
44.33%
53.57%
50.62%
63.16%
52.73%

Hi Dng
Hng Yn
Nam nh
Ninh Bnh
Thi Bnh
Vnh Phc
Bc Kn
Bc Giang
Cao Bng
ak Lak
ak Nng
in Bin
Gia Lai
Ha Bnh
Kon Tum
Lai Chu
Lm ng
Lng Sn
Lo Cai
Ph Th
Sn La
Thi Nguyn
Tuyn Quang
Yn Bi
H Giang
Min
Max

-0.0336
0.1420
-0.1976
0.0029
0.0834
0.3194
-0.1154
0.0951
-0.1678
-0.0719
-0.2724
-0.0392
0.1386
0.0950
0.1295
0.3505
-0.0378
-0.0907
0.5678
-0.0357
0.1965
0.1126
-0.0388
0.1959
0.1157

-0.3279
-0.1560
-0.1160
-0.2766
0.0197
0.0212
0.0648
-0.1016
0.0179
-0.0367
-0.4014
0.0815
0.2179
0.0523
-0.0132
0.0144
-0.0422
0.0732
0.1987
-0.1055
0.0382
-0.2156
0.2363
0.2064
0.0540

0.64
0.98
0.75
0.73
1.13
1.33
1.02
1.00
0.92
0.94
0.36
1.10
1.40
1.18
1.13
1.35
0.96
1.05
1.74
0.89
1.25
0.89
1.28
1.44
1.20

62.40%
52.53%
56.39%
58.25%
57.80%
58.54%
70.97%
60.82%
65.00%
50.60%
68.97%
70.69%
58.65%
55.74%
44.93%
72.22%
51.72%
61.90%
55.91%
59.57%
59.43%
66.67%
60.78%
59.62%
49.18%

-0.3892

-0.4014

0.36

38.41%

0.5678

0.3362

1.74

73.42%

Cc ch tiu s dng trong ch s thnh phn Tnh minh bch v Tip cn thn
Gia nh v bn
Thng lng vi
b c vai tr
cn b thu l
quan trng trong
phn thit yu
thng lng vi
trong hot ng
cn b Nh nc
kinh doanh (%
(% Rt quan
Hon ton ng
trng hoc Quan
hoc ng )
trng)

Tnh cng bng

v s n nh
trong vic p
dng cc quy
nh

Kh nng c th
d on c
trong thc thi
php lut ca
tnh (% Lun
lun hoc
Thng xuyn)

Tnh c trao i
kin vi doanh
nghip v nhng
thay i trong
cc quy nh
php lut (%
Lun lun hoc
Thng xuyn)

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: F7

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: G9.4

Mng 3.2

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: F6

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: F3

64.22%
52.63%
48.94%
54.64%
53.72%
64.00%
52.80%
65.17%
55.81%
51.46%
55.06%
60.63%
53.57%
51.59%
50.75%
55.56%
48.96%
57.14%
44.87%
43.82%
46.46%
59.49%
58.33%
62.71%
55.56%
56.63%
59.70%
48.78%
61.68%
47.76%
54.41%
60.27%
45.11%
53.26%
40.40%
55.56%
60.47%
50.00%
55.36%

61.32%
55.00%
47.29%
47.78%
48.25%
54.62%
60.71%
55.95%
62.96%
46.88%
43.90%
36.28%
44.16%
35.40%
40.91%
45.16%
43.01%
56.47%
46.48%
55.06%
64.84%
56.94%
65.38%
51.85%
73.17%
53.95%
44.26%
47.37%
60.95%
54.69%
37.01%
62.32%
33.90%
49.43%
24.18%
44.07%
38.96%
42.86%
41.41%

1.12
1.20
1.54
1.42
1.26
0.89
1.09
0.91
1.02
1.37
1.17
1.34
1.05
1.40
1.43
1.31
1.32
1.14
1.44
1.31
1.18
1.13
0.91
1.12
0.84
1.02
1.13
1.40
1.01
1.22
1.38
1.00
1.57
1.21
1.80
1.28
1.30
1.24
1.32

8.11%
4.05%
3.57%
4.57%
4.13%
14.17%
8.20%
10.00%
13.95%
5.94%
9.20%
7.81%
6.02%
8.66%
11.94%
8.16%
9.00%
4.21%
3.80%
5.32%
2.97%
10.53%
6.02%
4.92%
14.29%
18.07%
5.80%
7.32%
8.57%
7.25%
6.72%
4.17%
3.79%
7.69%
5.00%
6.45%
5.88%
6.67%
8.18%

0.90%
1.97%
2.90%
3.00%
4.13%
3.91%
11.11%
7.53%
6.67%
8.82%
6.67%
5.30%
2.35%
7.69%
5.88%
0.99%
14.56%
16.84%
4.71%
13.54%
4.63%
7.32%
7.61%
6.78%
2.27%
9.30%
8.33%
13.95%
5.45%
7.35%
9.93%
11.69%
5.88%
7.69%
7.00%
10.94%
3.45%
8.86%
2.63%

53.85%
49.49%
51.15%
56.31%
58.56%
48.41%
61.96%
57.01%
61.25%
55.17%
54.69%
55.93%
50.94%
53.60%
60.56%
61.11%
44.29%
55.24%
38.71%
50.53%
52.34%
64.13%
60.40%
48.11%
54.84%

34.78%
28.26%
43.70%
49.46%
45.36%
35.65%
41.38%
46.32%
48.61%
41.25%
50.82%
33.96%
42.00%
36.21%
43.08%
48.48%
48.57%
39.22%
30.77%
41.57%
40.38%
44.32%
40.43%
38.54%
38.33%

1.28
1.53
1.31
1.16
1.17
1.39
0.99
1.14
1.01
1.35
1.02
1.15
1.29
1.35
1.34
0.92
1.41
1.22
1.60
1.29
1.28
0.99
1.15
1.35
1.40

7.75%
8.16%
8.33%
15.84%
11.61%
7.26%
9.09%
12.62%
3.80%
10.34%
3.17%
11.67%
1.89%
11.38%
10.29%
11.11%
7.69%
4.81%
18.28%
14.13%
15.09%
4.30%
9.43%
17.14%
15.87%

8.40%
4.85%
11.03%
14.15%
6.90%
13.49%
13.68%
11.43%
5.00%
3.41%
3.13%
14.75%
11.82%
11.72%
8.45%
21.62%
8.11%
9.17%
15.22%
5.32%
6.42%
6.19%
14.55%
14.95%
12.70%

38.71%

24.18%

0.84

1.89%

0.90%

65.17%

73.17%

1.80

18.28%

21.62%

ch v Tip cn thng tin

Cht lng dch
v t vn do c
quan ca tnh
cung cp v
thng tin php
lut (% Tt hoc
Rt tt)

Kh nng d
on ca thng
tin

m ca trang
web tnh
im s

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: E.15

Mng 3.3

Phn tch ca
Nhm nghin cu
PCI

Mng 3.4

50.49%
40.29%
61.42%
63.16%
53.57%
54.87%
49.12%
34.57%
51.28%
47.42%
65.43%
57.63%
40.00%
62.07%
54.55%
50.00%
54.95%
48.19%
42.25%
72.84%
42.86%
57.14%
44.74%
63.64%
48.84%
40.51%
42.86%
42.11%
55.45%
40.35%
56.35%
49.25%
61.79%
38.89%
67.82%
55.74%
53.95%
38.36%
30.30%

0.65
0.49
0.77
0.81
0.71
0.89
0.92
0.67
0.92
0.80
1.01
0.86
0.53
0.99
0.90
0.65
1.10
1.00
0.58
1.23
0.57
0.95
0.73
0.92
0.77
0.93
0.72
0.90
0.85
0.69
0.95
0.87
0.86
0.69
0.98
0.97
0.73
0.70
0.45

19.00
17.00
18.00
20.00
14.50
15.50
12.00
15.00
15.00
11.00
16.50
16.00
16.50
20.00
11.00
11.00
17.00
18.00
16.50
19.00
19.00
12.00
13.00
11.50
8.50
15.00
12.00
16.00
11.50
18.00
7.50
12.00
18.00
14.00
15.00
12.50
14.00
19.00
12.00

3.82
3.46
3.64
4.00
3.01
3.19
2.56
3.10
3.10
2.38
3.37
3.28
3.37
4.00
2.38
2.38
3.46
3.64
3.37
3.82
3.82
2.56
2.74
2.47
1.93
3.10
2.56
3.28
2.47
3.64
1.75
2.56
3.64
2.92
3.10
2.65
2.92
3.82
2.56

Tnh/Thnh ph
Lo Cai
Bnh nh
Vnh Long
Bnh Dng
B Ra - Vng Tu
Nng
TP.HCM
ng Thp
Hng Yn
Vnh Phc
An Giang
Qung Nam
TT-Hu
H Nam
Bn Tre
H Ni
Gia Lai
Tin Giang
C Mau
Ty Ninh
Long An
ak Lak
Thi Bnh
H Giang
Nam nh
Qung Bnh
Thanh Ha
Yn Bi
Tuyn Quang
Cn Th
Bnh Thun
Ph Th
H Tnh
Sc Trng
Hi Phng
ng Nai
Ninh Bnh
Kin Giang
Qung Ngi

40.52%
48.86%
46.34%
51.52%
45.19%
58.47%
46.51%
47.47%
41.33%
49.35%
36.36%
40.35%
45.83%
48.36%
41.94%
39.39%
44.62%
46.53%
50.55%
46.74%
44.23%
43.18%
58.42%
55.67%
41.67%

0.73
0.74
0.88
1.16
0.81
1.09
0.97
0.98
0.58
0.74
0.46
0.97
0.79
0.98
0.79
1.14
0.77
0.78
1.22
0.83
0.84
0.64
1.15
1.26
1.00

13.00
19.00
15.50
13.00
15.50
15.50
4.00
9.00
10.00
16.00
0.00
6.50
14.00
1.00
11.00
0.00
9.00
1.00
20.00
13.50
7.00
13.00
11.00
8.50
12.00

2.74
3.82
3.19
2.74
3.19
3.19
1.12
2.02
2.20
3.28
0.40
1.57
2.92
0.58
2.38
0.40
2.02
0.58
4.00
2.83
1.66
2.74
2.38
1.93
2.56

30.30%

0.45

0.00

0.40

72.84%

1.26

20.00

4.00

Ph Yn
Hu Giang
Bc Ninh
Ngh An
Kon Tum
Ninh Thun
Qung Tr
Hi Dng
Tr Vinh
Qung Ninh
Thi Nguyn
Khnh Ha
Lm ng
Bc Giang
Sn La
Bnh Phc
H Ty
in Bin
Cao Bng
Bc Liu
Bc Kn
Ha Bnh
Lai Chu
Lng Sn
ak Nng

Ch s thnh
phn 3: Tnh
minh bch v
Tip cn thng
tin

Mng
3.1+3.2+3.3+3
.4
8.56
7.72
7.54
7.44
7.21
7.19
7.15
7.12
7.07
7.00
6.93
6.63
6.61
6.57
6.53
6.47
6.41
6.39
6.35
6.34
6.32
6.31
6.30
6.16
6.13
6.01
5.99
5.98
5.96
5.95
5.91
5.84
5.83
5.82
5.81
5.80
5.79
5.78
5.75

5.71
5.71
5.64
5.64
5.64
5.63
5.61
5.39
5.32
5.29
5.26
5.18
5.17
5.15
5.03
5.00
4.88
4.79
4.71
4.40
4.10
4.09
3.80
3.63
2.24
2.24
8.56

Cc ch tiu s dng trong ch s thnh phn Chi ph thi gian

Ch tiu

Tnh/Ngun
H Ni
Hi Phng
Nng
TP.HCM
Cn Th
Thanh Ha
Ngh An
H Tnh
Qung Bnh
Qung Tr
TT-Hu
Qung Nam
Qung Ngi
Bnh nh
Ph Yn
Khnh Ha
ng Thp
An Giang
Tin Giang
Vnh Long
Bn Tre
Kin Giang
Tr Vinh
Sc Trng
Bc Liu
C Mau
Bnh Phc
Ty Ninh
Ninh Thun
Long An
Qung Ninh
Hu Giang
B Ra - Vng Tu
Bc Ninh
Bnh Dng
Bnh Thun
ng Nai
H Nam

S ngy lm vic
% DN s dng
vi chnh quyn Chi ph tun th
hn 10% qu thi
a phng gim cc quy nh ca
gian lm vic
i sau khi c
Nh nc
vi chnh quyn
Lut DN (%)

S cuc thanh
tra trung v (tt
c cc c quan)

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: G1

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: G2

Mng 4.1

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: D1

15.38%
18.18%
19.40%
24.86%
27.59%
21.37%
22.88%
19.10%
26.44%
24.75%
18.82%
30.00%
21.25%
28.46%
24.24%
21.78%
21.74%
26.44%
17.33%
17.86%
19.39%
25.00%
16.88%
26.32%
25.58%
16.05%
10.94%
21.95%
34.29%
15.87%
19.35%
23.53%
29.03%
21.43%
17.71%
24.62%
21.69%
17.11%

15.83%
30.19%
27.81%
22.49%
25.20%
23.88%
23.26%
23.96%
25.27%
19.23%
24.47%
25.90%
20.69%
35.04%
23.19%
28.71%
19.44%
23.23%
23.60%
20.20%
29.06%
28.92%
20.21%
23.08%
17.65%
31.18%
13.75%
16.85%
25.44%
16.67%
21.92%
22.89%
28.17%
21.43%
27.36%
30.43%
21.98%
22.62%

2.43
3.78
3.46
2.56
2.69
2.92
2.77
3.07
2.76
2.23
3.14
2.62
2.59
3.67
2.68
3.41
2.43
2.55
3.14
2.75
3.59
3.24
2.81
2.54
2.01
4.02
2.48
2.15
2.31
2.49
2.84
2.69
2.91
2.66
3.51
3.42
2.70
3.05

16.67%
23.90%
26.49%
19.14%
24.39%
22.39%
30.23%
26.04%
20.88%
25.00%
27.66%
23.02%
24.14%
15.33%
13.04%
31.68%
27.78%
29.29%
29.21%
28.28%
27.35%
27.71%
23.40%
36.92%
25.49%
33.33%
22.50%
26.97%
23.68%
27.78%
26.03%
22.89%
36.62%
26.53%
24.53%
31.88%
23.08%
11.90%

H Ty
Hi Dng
Hng Yn
Nam nh
Ninh Bnh
Thi Bnh
Vnh Phc
Bc Kn
Bc Giang
Cao Bng
ak Lak
ak Nng
in Bin
Gia Lai
Ha Bnh
Kon Tum
Lai Chu
Lm ng
Lng Sn
Lo Cai
Ph Th
Sn La
Thi Nguyn
Tuyn Quang
Yn Bi
H Giang
Min
Max

18.45%
21.14%
13.68%
12.50%
21.21%
11.01%
31.40%
39.53%
21.21%
31.17%
30.23%
27.87%
38.18%
23.47%
17.50%
27.54%
43.75%
20.44%
21.00%
25.00%
26.14%
26.00%
17.98%
29.13%
25.51%
36.51%

30.17%
16.55%
20.37%
26.62%
23.15%
20.34%
18.18%
17.53%
14.41%
16.87%
22.83%
19.70%
22.22%
19.64%
23.48%
26.76%
18.92%
18.67%
16.81%
23.76%
25.77%
18.75%
21.43%
28.95%
25.23%
18.46%

3.77
2.16
3.02
3.75
2.86
3.18
1.71
1.15
1.93
1.59
2.28
2.09
1.73
2.35
3.12
2.86
1.05
2.43
2.20
2.69
2.84
2.10
2.87
2.99
2.82
1.44

32.76%
28.06%
18.52%
24.46%
28.70%
27.97%
15.15%
18.56%
16.22%
15.66%
17.39%
18.18%
23.81%
12.50%
30.30%
16.90%
16.22%
26.00%
12.39%
21.78%
28.87%
18.75%
21.43%
21.93%
24.32%
30.77%

10.94%
43.75%

13.75%
35.04%

1.05
4.02

11.90%
36.92%

n Chi ph thi gian thc hin cc quy nh ca Nh nc

S cuc thanh
tra gim trong
vng hai nm tr
li y (%)

S gi trung v
lm vic vi
thanh tra thu

Thanh tra, kim

tra

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: D2

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: D4

Mng 4.2

1
1
1
1
1
1
2
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
2
1
1
1
2
1
2
2
1
2
2
2
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1

5
8
4
3
3
18
12
8
16
15.5
8
9.5
6
24.5
18
2
8
3.5
4
2.5
2
2
8
6
2
4
4
3
4
5
6
2.5
4
8
8
4
8
12

3.40
3.78
4.15
3.67
4.05
3.20
3.14
3.03
3.18
3.50
4.05
3.64
3.89
2.38
2.52
3.72
4.06
4.38
4.35
3.45
4.31
3.44
2.84
4.81
3.28
3.75
2.97
3.34
3.95
4.20
4.03
3.97
4.88
3.97
3.82
4.54
3.72
2.73

Ch s thnh
phn 4: Chi ph
thi gian
thc hin cc
quy nh ca
Nh nc
Tnh/Thnh ph
H Ty
Bnh Thun
Bn Tre
B Ra - Vng Tu
C Mau
Nng
Nam nh
Hi Phng
Tin Giang
Sc Trng
Bnh Dng
Thi Bnh
TT-Hu
Khnh Ha
Ha Bnh
An Giang
Qung Ninh
Cn Th
Long An
Kin Giang
Hu Giang
Bc Ninh
Hng Yn
ng Thp
Qung Ngi
ng Nai
Ninh Thun
Qung Nam
Yn Bi
Hi Dng
TP.HCM
Ph Th
Vnh Long
Thanh Ha
H Tnh
Ninh Bnh
Bnh nh
Qung Bnh

Mng 4.1+ 4.2

8.18
7.96
7.90
7.80
7.76
7.61
7.57
7.56
7.49
7.35
7.34
7.25
7.19
7.13
7.00
6.93
6.86
6.74
6.69
6.67
6.66
6.63
6.60
6.49
6.48
6.42
6.26
6.26
6.25
6.24
6.24
6.21
6.20
6.12
6.10
6.08
6.05
5.95

1
1
1
1
2
1
1
2
1
1
1
2
2
1
1
2
2
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1

8
8
4
8
8
8
16
8
8
16
14
7
16
8
15.5
36
16
5
24
40
24
24
24
32
16
16

4.42
4.08
3.58
3.82
3.22
4.07
2.77
2.49
3.23
2.81
3.03
2.51
2.49
2.96
3.88
1.05
1.95
3.17
2.19
2.11
3.38
2.65
2.84
2.50
3.43
3.89

1
2

2
40

1.05
4.88

Ngh An
H Ni
H Nam
Qung Tr
Thi Nguyn
Tr Vinh
Lm ng
Tuyn Quang
Ty Ninh
Bnh Phc
H Giang
Gia Lai
ak Lak
Bc Liu
Ph Yn
Bc Giang
Lo Cai
Sn La
ak Nng
Vnh Phc
Cao Bng
Lng Sn
in Bin
Kon Tum
Bc Kn
Lai Chu

5.91
5.83
5.77
5.73
5.71
5.65
5.60
5.49
5.48
5.45
5.33
5.31
5.30
5.29
5.20
5.16
4.80
4.75
4.60
4.48
4.40
4.39
4.23
3.90
3.65
2.99

2.99
8.18

Cc ch tiu s dng trong ch s thnh phn Chi ph khng

Ch tiu

Tnh/Ngun
H Ni
Hi Phng
Nng
TP.HCM
Cn Th
Thanh Ha
Ngh An
H Tnh
Qung Bnh
Qung Tr
TT-Hu
Qung Nam
Qung Ngi
Bnh nh
Ph Yn
Khnh Ha
ng Thp
An Giang
Tin Giang
Vnh Long
Bn Tre
Kin Giang
Tr Vinh
Sc Trng
Bc Liu
C Mau
Bnh Phc
Ty Ninh
Ninh Thun
Long An
Qung Ninh
Hu Giang
B Ra - Vng Tu
Bc Ninh
Bnh Dng
Bnh Thun

% DN cho rng
% DN tn hn
cc chi ph khng % DN cho rng
10% doanh thu
chnh thc l cn
cc DN cng
cho cc loi chi
tr chnh i vi ngnh tr chi ph
ph khng chnh
hot ng kinh khng chnh thc
thc
doanh

Cn b tnh s
dng cc quy
nh ring ca
a phng vi
mc ch trc li
(% ng hoc
Hon ton ng
)

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: G6

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: G3

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: G4

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: G9.2

14.29%
23.64%
17.86%
20.12%
30.30%
24.27%
24.75%
23.29%
26.09%
33.33%
22.86%
36.00%
36.36%
31.00%
29.82%
23.26%
36.36%
32.88%
22.81%
33.33%
36.23%
29.03%
36.92%
33.33%
16.22%
32.39%
25.49%
26.09%
25.00%
19.23%
23.08%
43.40%
21.36%
22.86%
23.68%
26.92%

81.13%
75.35%
64.44%
82.72%
70.94%
76.42%
71.90%
76.67%
68.67%
69.31%
67.82%
71.77%
71.60%
67.21%
69.23%
80.81%
69.89%
66.29%
60.00%
52.27%
40.00%
60.00%
65.00%
58.18%
70.73%
55.56%
67.69%
65.82%
65.71%
65.63%
65.60%
58.33%
65.63%
66.67%
63.16%
67.69%

16.67%
5.07%
6.82%
14.29%
8.85%
11.02%
17.95%
21.84%
22.22%
11.22%
9.64%
5.08%
13.58%
5.17%
8.06%
12.37%
5.32%
12.94%
1.39%
8.43%
2.27%
15.07%
10.13%
17.31%
15.00%
11.84%
13.79%
6.58%
15.15%
6.56%
8.26%
8.82%
8.20%
15.00%
7.53%
1.59%

79.41%
51.49%
36.22%
58.89%
41.67%
54.95%
54.29%
60.00%
41.03%
40.66%
49.30%
30.28%
43.06%
25.44%
33.87%
53.33%
30.59%
28.40%
26.09%
31.40%
17.44%
38.81%
21.92%
36.54%
35.90%
34.21%
36.54%
31.51%
47.06%
26.32%
43.80%
28.36%
32.17%
40.24%
33.71%
43.10%

ng Nai
H Nam
H Ty
Hi Dng
Hng Yn
Nam nh
Ninh Bnh
Thi Bnh
Vnh Phc
Bc Kn
Bc Giang
Cao Bng
ak Lak
ak Nng
in Bin
Gia Lai
Ha Bnh
Kon Tum
Lai Chu
Lm ng
Lng Sn
Lo Cai
Ph Th
Sn La
Thi Nguyn
Tuyn Quang
Yn Bi
H Giang
Min
Max

30.00%
36.21%
13.95%
24.74%
28.40%
19.80%
18.92%
24.14%
29.17%
29.17%
24.32%
28.07%
25.76%
18.18%
20.00%
27.63%
26.92%
23.08%
27.59%
16.24%
27.16%
25.97%
26.39%
33.73%
29.73%
23.68%
24.42%
27.45%

72.94%
67.11%
69.81%
67.48%
53.68%
74.80%
67.35%
75.45%
59.68%
75.82%
69.61%
70.13%
63.41%
71.88%
67.86%
68.93%
68.64%
75.71%
67.65%
76.64%
62.50%
69.89%
69.23%
70.59%
80.00%
59.41%
64.00%
74.60%

12.05%
8.82%
11.54%
7.08%
4.30%
8.13%
12.50%
11.82%
6.36%
26.19%
13.00%
15.71%
17.07%
8.20%
11.54%
13.40%
12.82%
22.39%
21.21%
7.58%
12.50%
13.33%
11.76%
7.45%
11.49%
17.39%
8.16%
13.56%

36.62%
32.84%
45.26%
48.60%
35.56%
41.07%
41.57%
47.31%
30.56%
40.74%
38.04%
42.65%
37.14%
33.90%
34.00%
27.84%
36.04%
42.86%
45.16%
41.48%
38.38%
41.94%
38.64%
40.00%
40.24%
35.16%
35.16%
33.33%

13.95%

40.00%

1.39%

17.44%

43.40%

82.72%

26.19%

79.41%

phn Chi ph khng chnh thc

Cng vic c
gii quyt sau
khi chi tr chi
ph khng chnh
thc (% Lun
lun hoc
Thng xuyn)

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: D4
59.80%
51.15%
40.00%
55.87%
53.21%
55.45%
48.65%
56.63%
46.75%
44.44%
48.68%
35.35%
41.33%
40.57%
47.27%
42.39%
45.00%
44.58%
44.93%
30.67%
32.39%
33.82%
29.03%
37.04%
30.00%
30.14%
50.85%
45.07%
41.24%
38.18%
58.26%
40.68%
43.48%
54.05%
48.05%
46.55%

Ch s thnh
phn 5: Chi ph
khng chnh
thc

Tnh/Thnh ph
Hng Yn
Tin Giang
Bn Tre
Vnh Phc
in Bin
Qung Ninh
Bnh Dng
Tuyn Quang
H Nam
Long An
H Ty
Ninh Bnh
Ty Ninh
B Ra - Vng Tu
Bc Giang
Nam nh
Sn La
Ph Th
Bnh nh
Nng
Gia Lai
Bc Ninh
Bnh Thun
Hi Dng
Ph Yn
Bnh Phc
Lng Sn
Yn Bi
ng Nai
ng Thp
Cn Th
H Giang
An Giang
Hu Giang
ak Nng
Thi Nguyn

7.71
7.71
7.63
7.58
7.27
7.22
7.17
7.11
7.07
7.04
7.02
7.00
6.99
6.96
6.92
6.91
6.90
6.87
6.86
6.84
6.82
6.80
6.78
6.74
6.72
6.72
6.71
6.65
6.65
6.64
6.63
6.60
6.57
6.53
6.44
6.43

54.05%
56.52%
55.79%
53.27%
53.66%
54.24%
54.76%
50.00%
53.68%
52.87%
55.81%
47.69%
43.24%
36.67%
54.90%
48.28%
43.64%
54.55%
56.67%
42.52%
48.28%
48.81%
55.00%
57.95%
56.47%
54.22%
40.23%
51.72%

Vnh Long
TT-Hu
Hi Phng
Lm ng
Lo Cai
Ha Bnh
ak Lak
Lai Chu
Thi Bnh
Thanh Ha
Qung Nam
Cao Bng
Kon Tum
Tr Vinh
Qung Tr
C Mau
Sc Trng
Qung Bnh
Kin Giang
Ninh Thun
Bc Liu
TP.HCM
Bc Kn
Ngh An
Qung Ngi
H Tnh
Khnh Ha
H Ni

6.43
6.41
6.39
6.38
6.36
6.35
6.31
6.30
6.16
6.15
6.13
6.10
6.09
6.09
6.08
6.07
5.96
5.92
5.89
5.88
5.82
5.79
5.72
5.66
5.57
5.55
5.38
5.36

29.03%

5.36

59.80%

7.71

Cc ch tiu s dng trong ch s thnh

Ch tiu

Tnh/Ngun

H Ni
Hi Phng
Nng
TP.HCM
Cn Th
Thanh Ha
Ngh An
H Tnh
Qung Bnh
Qung Tr
TT-Hu
Qung Nam
Qung Ngi
Bnh nh
Ph Yn
Khnh Ha
ng Thp
An Giang
Tin Giang
Vnh Long
Bn Tre
Kin Giang
Tr Vinh
Sc Trng
Bc Liu
C Mau
Bnh Phc
Ty Ninh
Ninh Thun
Long An
Qung Ninh
Hu Giang
B Ra - Vng Tu
Bc Ninh
Bnh Dng
Bnh Thun

u i i vi
Thi khng
Thi ca
DNNN l cn tr
ph thuc vo
chnh quyn tnh Thi ca tnh
i vi hot ng
mc ng gp v
i vi khu vc c ci thin
kinh doanh ca
ti chnh (%
t nhn (% Tch
trong vng hai
DN (% ng
ng hoc
cc hoc Rt tch
nm qua (%)
hoc Hon ton
Hon ton ng
cc)
ng ).
).

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: H7.10

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: H1

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: H2

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: G9.1

59.22%
50.75%
46.77%
57.40%
54.63%
50.45%
49.52%
57.89%
45.07%
45.16%
44.59%
40.19%
44.29%
31.25%
44.44%
48.31%
45.88%
37.84%
30.00%
32.00%
41.46%
51.56%
44.12%
38.00%
33.33%
35.82%
37.04%
40.58%
38.00%
42.37%
43.59%
48.21%
37.27%
44.30%
30.23%
51.67%

30.63%
24.50%
48.92%
43.81%
39.50%
38.40%
37.40%
33.33%
35.29%
34.00%
48.84%
43.55%
38.55%
61.83%
47.69%
37.00%
52.00%
48.42%
64.20%
57.14%
49.02%
33.75%
48.84%
47.46%
37.21%
37.50%
33.33%
40.96%
38.10%
51.47%
51.06%
54.05%
49.24%
50.54%
66.00%
52.31%

50.45%
54.00%
71.22%
63.27%
58.47%
65.08%
52.03%
53.76%
59.09%
56.44%
69.32%
68.00%
63.86%
80.92%
70.77%
60.00%
69.00%
64.13%
72.50%
75.27%
65.38%
62.03%
54.02%
67.74%
53.33%
55.00%
36.23%
55.95%
48.60%
63.24%
65.96%
69.33%
62.12%
61.96%
79.00%
75.38%

30.00%
38.41%
37.31%
36.76%
39.64%
31.03%
32.14%
35.29%
34.62%
30.93%
42.17%
38.05%
39.47%
38.14%
34.92%
35.48%
38.37%
30.23%
39.13%
34.12%
27.17%
22.22%
42.11%
37.74%
44.74%
34.67%
45.00%
28.38%
41.35%
40.68%
40.77%
28.57%
28.57%
29.55%
34.74%
39.68%

ng Nai
H Nam
H Ty
Hi Dng
Hng Yn
Nam nh
Ninh Bnh
Thi Bnh
Vnh Phc
Bc Kn
Bc Giang
Cao Bng
ak Lak
ak Nng
in Bin
Gia Lai
Ha Bnh
Kon Tum
Lai Chu
Lm ng
Lng Sn
Lo Cai
Ph Th
Sn La
Thi Nguyn
Tuyn Quang
Yn Bi
H Giang
Min
Max

48.53%
49.21%
48.94%
42.06%
42.05%
51.79%
36.78%
47.92%
37.50%
31.17%
38.89%
36.67%
41.43%
33.93%
34.55%
37.35%
49.09%
37.70%
44.83%
41.46%
47.13%
27.38%
39.02%
39.36%
50.00%
37.78%
42.27%
30.00%

37.65%
33.77%
39.81%
40.63%
58.00%
45.11%
42.16%
45.54%
64.29%
32.26%
46.60%
51.90%
35.63%
28.13%
44.83%
48.57%
47.20%
37.68%
59.46%
38.03%
47.66%
67.37%
36.84%
50.00%
37.50%
43.93%
51.96%
52.38%

62.35%
55.13%
72.22%
58.59%
70.00%
58.96%
64.08%
70.18%
79.37%
45.26%
66.99%
68.35%
56.82%
49.21%
56.90%
68.93%
67.46%
58.57%
67.57%
64.34%
57.94%
68.42%
58.33%
63.55%
66.67%
63.21%
73.08%
58.73%

31.58%
34.29%
39.25%
33.91%
33.68%
32.54%
38.46%
36.27%
30.97%
40.45%
30.93%
36.49%
42.11%
33.33%
43.64%
38.78%
36.97%
50.75%
29.41%
35.04%
37.86%
31.46%
31.11%
22.55%
35.16%
23.47%
27.84%
31.67%

27.38%

24.50%

36.23%

22.22%

59.22%

67.37%

80.92%

50.75%

trong ch s thnh phn u i i vi DNNN (Mi trng cnh tranh)

Tnh u i DN
c phn ha l
cn tr i vi
cng vic kinh
doanh ca DN (%
ng hoc
Hon ton ng
).

DN nh gi
chnh sch c
phn ha ca
tnh (% Rt tt
hoc Tt)

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: H7.12

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: E1.9

42.72%
33.59%
26.02%
35.29%
32.08%
29.36%
34.65%
41.67%
23.94%
31.87%
29.33%
37.74%
23.61%
24.55%
12.70%
26.74%
28.24%
23.29%
22.22%
20.55%
37.18%
34.38%
29.23%
30.61%
33.33%
22.39%
16.67%
33.82%
29.00%
34.43%
26.27%
34.55%
23.36%
33.77%
22.89%
27.12%

54.02%
65.60%
68.07%
66.46%
52.94%
55.66%
58.10%
53.33%
52.11%
53.76%
61.33%
58.16%
58.21%
68.22%
54.84%
59.52%
54.65%
54.29%
60.66%
71.64%
48.05%
45.76%
61.29%
56.25%
45.71%
55.26%
33.33%
56.92%
61.22%
37.04%
70.80%
42.59%
70.64%
61.04%
87.67%
61.11%

T trng n ca
DNNN tnh trong
tng s n ca
% thay i v s
cc DN ca
Cm nhn v s
lng DNNN do
tnh/T trng
u i ca tnh a phng qun
doanh thu ca
i vi DNNN
l so vi nm
DNNN tnh trong
2000 (%)
tng doanh thu
ca cc DN ca
tnhdoanh
iu tra doanh
iu tra
nghip ca Tng nghip ca Tng
cc thng k
cc thng k
Mng 6.1
2000-2006
2005 & 2006
(Tnh ton ca
(Tnh ton
tc gi)
ca tc gi)
1.85
-0.35
1.29
2.68
-0.56
1.24
3.81
-0.46
1.44
2.99
-0.19
1.89
2.86
-0.31
1.13
2.95
-0.51
1.57
2.61
-0.41
2.35
2.17
-0.54
1.43
3.11
-0.63
1.87
2.72
-0.47
2.57
3.77
-0.49
1.65
3.35
-0.32
0.89
3.52
-0.38
3.38
4.71
-0.35
1.63
3.96
-0.34
1.00
3.13
-0.49
1.27
3.62
-0.50
1.12
3.57
-0.34
1.07
3.57
-0.33
2.17
3.57
-0.61
1.28
3.57
-0.08
1.25
3.57
0.24
0.68
3.57
-0.05
1.71
3.57
-0.36
0.93
3.57
0.00
1.54
3.57
-0.23
0.75
3.57
0.06
0.59
3.57
-0.03
1.52
3.57
0.00
1.22
3.57
-0.43
1.13
3.57
-0.48
1.98
3.57
0.13
1.02
3.57
-0.31
1.03
3.57
-0.58
2.52
3.57
-0.26
0.95
3.57
-0.21
1.10

33.33%
38.10%
31.52%
33.33%
33.33%
33.64%
31.40%
27.08%
24.32%
24.32%
23.60%
32.79%
30.43%
26.32%
24.53%
28.57%
30.00%
19.35%
30.00%
23.93%
36.47%
25.00%
31.25%
31.52%
23.38%
32.22%
33.68%
20.00%

61.76%
62.50%
63.64%
63.06%
66.67%
63.30%
61.11%
62.37%
74.53%
59.49%
56.32%
58.11%
41.79%
25.53%
66.00%
62.35%
61.06%
47.54%
40.74%
58.04%
59.60%
56.67%
59.55%
67.74%
54.32%
49.46%
74.44%
65.52%

3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57
3.57

-0.13
-0.71
-0.50
-0.71
-0.53
-0.69
-0.51
-0.60
-0.29
-0.42
-0.44
-0.33
-0.50
0.03
-0.07
-0.48
-0.41
-0.43
-0.60
-0.19
-0.45
-0.44
-0.62
-0.42
-0.55
-0.28
-0.58
-0.36

0.97
3.07
2.39
1.23
5.39
10.33
1.30
0.89
6.26
0.67
2.30
1.29
1.68
4.55
1.17
3.68
1.30
0.50
0.40
1.97
1.98
0.79
0.84
0.67
10.22
1.08
1.90
0.50

12.70%

25.53%

1.85

-0.71

0.40

42.72%

87.67%

4.71

0.24

10.33

cnh tranh)

Ch s thnh
phn 6: u i
i vi DNNN

D liu cng v
u i i vi
DNNN

Mng 6.2

3.34
3.63
3.47
3.02
3.32
3.51
3.24
3.57
3.62
3.28
3.47
3.38
3.01
3.28
3.39
3.53
3.58
3.37
3.16
3.70
2.98
2.64
2.85
3.42
2.82
3.27
2.90
2.86
2.87
3.48
3.40
2.74
3.34
3.44
3.28
3.18

Tnh/Thnh ph

Bnh Dng
Vnh Long
Bnh nh
Lo Cai
Tin Giang
H Giang
Kon Tum
Qung Ninh
Ph Yn
Thi Bnh
Nng
TT-Hu
ng Thp
Yn Bi
Ninh Bnh
Lai Chu
B Ra - Vng Tu
Sc Trng
Cao Bng
Hi Dng
Gia Lai
Bnh Thun
An Giang
Bc Kn
in Bin
Bc Giang
Ph Th
Ha Bnh
Sn La
Vnh Phc
H Ty
Qung Nam
Qung Bnh
Long An
Khnh Ha
C Mau

Mng 6.1+6.2
8.29
8.24
7.99
7.85
7.76
7.52
7.43
7.35
7.35
7.32
7.28
7.24
7.20
7.19
7.13
7.11
7.08
7.07
7.02
6.99
6.96
6.96
6.94
6.93
6.92
6.89
6.87
6.85
6.84
6.83
6.79
6.73
6.73
6.70
6.66
6.66

3.10
3.52
3.36
3.84
2.84
2.17
3.56
3.76
2.36
3.55
3.29
3.32
3.49
2.23
2.98
3.08
3.43
3.59
3.84
3.00
3.36
3.55
3.79
3.55
2.00
3.29
3.55
3.50

Bc Ninh
Hng Yn
Qung Ngi
ak Lak
Lng Sn
Thanh Ha
Lm ng
Tr Vinh
Hi Phng
Tuyn Quang
Cn Th
Ninh Thun
H Nam
Bc Liu
ng Nai
TP.HCM
Qung Tr
Bnh Phc
Bn Tre
Ngh An
H Tnh
Ty Ninh
Hu Giang
Thi Nguyn
H Ni
Nam nh
Kin Giang
ak Nng

6.62
6.59
6.53
6.52
6.47
6.46
6.45
6.32
6.31
6.24
6.17
6.17
6.15
6.06
6.02
6.01
6.00
5.94
5.92
5.84
5.74
5.73
5.73
5.24
5.19
5.12
4.88
4.79

2.00

4.79

3.84

8.29

Cc ch tiu s dng trong ch s thnh phn Tnh nng ng v ti

Ch tiu

Tnh trin khai tt

trong khun kh cc
quy nh ca Trung
ng (% ng hoc
Hon ton ng )

Tnh sng to v sng

sut trong vic gii
quyt nhng tr ngi
i vi cng ng
doanh nghip (% ng
hoc Hon ton
ng )

Tnh c sng kin tt

nhng cn nhiu cn
tr Trung ng (%
ng hoc Hon
ton ng ).

Tnh/Ngun

Cu hi iu tra PCI:
H7.2

Cu hi iu tra PCI:
H7.3

Cu hi iu tra PCI:
H7.5

63.37%
60.00%
74.42%
66.48%
62.39%
66.67%
62.73%
64.56%
69.14%
63.16%
74.36%
77.39%
60.53%
86.55%
67.19%
54.35%
76.14%
80.49%
74.29%
83.75%
84.09%
72.06%
84.93%
87.27%
73.68%
68.49%
68.85%
76.92%
58.00%
70.31%
69.35%
80.65%
76.32%
81.40%
92.47%

55.45%
46.21%
66.93%
56.40%
58.18%
54.05%
42.06%
44.74%
51.90%
46.15%
59.21%
63.96%
51.35%
73.91%
58.06%
46.67%
61.36%
77.50%
64.18%
70.51%
74.68%
54.55%
75.00%
65.38%
55.26%
51.43%
59.32%
56.00%
54.00%
66.13%
60.17%
81.67%
65.77%
72.62%
87.91%

51.49%
24.41%
37.93%
56.63%
42.86%
31.13%
23.76%
32.35%
23.19%
21.98%
41.18%
44.12%
24.64%
30.19%
29.69%
28.24%
48.78%
47.95%
45.00%
41.67%
26.92%
36.07%
37.70%
43.75%
25.71%
37.50%
26.53%
40.91%
26.04%
41.67%
32.73%
43.40%
36.19%
21.79%
47.06%

H Ni
Hi Phng
Nng
TP.HCM
Cn Th
Thanh Ha
Ngh An
H Tnh
Qung Bnh
Qung Tr
TT-Hu
Qung Nam
Qung Ngi
Bnh nh
Ph Yn
Khnh Ha
ng Thp
An Giang
Tin Giang
Vnh Long
Bn Tre
Kin Giang
Tr Vinh
Sc Trng
Bc Liu
C Mau
Bnh Phc
Ty Ninh
Ninh Thun
Long An
Qung Ninh
Hu Giang
B Ra - Vng Tu
Bc Ninh
Bnh Dng

Bnh Thun
ng Nai
H Nam
H Ty
Hi Dng
Hng Yn
Nam nh
Ninh Bnh
Thi Bnh
Vnh Phc
Bc Kn
Bc Giang
Cao Bng
ak Lak
ak Nng
in Bin
Gia Lai
Ha Bnh
Kon Tum
Lai Chu
Lm ng
Lng Sn
Lo Cai
Ph Th
Sn La
Thi Nguyn
Tuyn Quang
Yn Bi
H Giang
Min
Max

67.74%
72.97%
70.00%
75.76%
69.83%
78.72%
70.00%
75.53%
73.08%
86.44%
72.84%
72.92%
54.93%
62.16%
67.80%
65.45%
76.09%
66.67%
60.00%
73.33%
66.14%
53.68%
80.46%
71.91%
71.00%
67.47%
71.58%
74.76%
75.00%

55.00%
72.86%
51.47%
63.16%
55.75%
74.44%
54.31%
64.44%
62.77%
75.44%
54.43%
63.83%
42.03%
51.39%
55.17%
45.45%
67.05%
57.14%
50.00%
56.67%
50.82%
40.22%
72.62%
53.93%
59.18%
50.63%
60.42%
62.50%
71.67%

30.36%
41.18%
32.20%
31.87%
30.77%
22.89%
26.47%
31.33%
28.72%
34.58%
36.62%
26.51%
27.87%
20.00%
25.45%
16.67%
34.12%
24.76%
31.67%
20.69%
27.12%
25.56%
33.75%
25.61%
21.74%
25.33%
22.47%
33.33%
20.00%

53.68%

40.22%

16.67%

92.47%

87.91%

56.63%

Tnh nng ng v tin phong ca lnh o tnh

Khng c sng kin

no cp tnh, tt c
u n t cp Trung
ng (% ng hoc
Hon ton ng )

Cu hi iu tra PCI:
H7.8
36.00%
36.15%
23.28%
28.99%
41.51%
35.51%
42.72%
45.07%
33.33%
33.33%
27.14%
17.17%
29.85%
15.74%
23.81%
26.19%
36.59%
20.55%
17.46%
31.51%
34.18%
50.00%
31.67%
24.49%
58.33%
34.33%
33.33%
50.00%
46.94%
32.20%
29.82%
32.08%
33.33%
27.27%
12.20%

Ch s thnh phn
7: Tnh nng ng
v tin phong ca
lnh o tnh

Tnh/Thnh ph
Bnh Dng
An Giang
Vnh Phc
Bnh nh
Hu Giang
Sc Trng
Lo Cai
Qung Nam
Tr Vinh
Tin Giang
Vnh Long
Nng
Bn Tre
ng Nai
TP.HCM
ng Thp
Bc Ninh
TT-Hu
Gia Lai
Ninh Bnh
Long An
B Ra - Vng Tu
H Ty
Yn Bi
H Giang
Hng Yn
Bc Giang
H Ni
Lai Chu
Qung Ninh
Thi Bnh
Ph Yn
Ph Th
Ty Ninh
C Mau

9.20
7.71
7.32
7.22
7.12
7.11
6.90
6.89
6.78
6.76
6.71
6.26
6.07
6.03
6.00
5.99
5.91
5.88
5.86
5.80
5.76
5.74
5.56
5.52
5.50
5.25
5.19
5.19
5.17
5.10
5.09
5.03
4.86
4.74
4.67

36.84%
35.29%
38.33%
29.47%
33.66%
40.70%
35.58%
25.00%
32.63%
19.44%
48.65%
29.07%
49.23%
37.68%
49.09%
35.19%
29.63%
45.37%
46.77%
17.24%
36.97%
42.53%
18.07%
24.39%
36.17%
38.89%
39.77%
30.11%
25.93%

Hi Dng
Cn Th
Bnh Phc
Thanh Ha
Bnh Thun
Bc Kn
H Nam
Sn La
Nam nh
Tuyn Quang
Kin Giang
Qung Bnh
Lm ng
Qung Ngi
Thi Nguyn
Ha Bnh
Khnh Ha
ak Nng
Qung Tr
Bc Liu
H Tnh
ak Lak
Kon Tum
Hi Phng
in Bin
Ninh Thun
Ngh An
Lng Sn
Cao Bng

4.64
4.57
4.56
4.32
4.32
4.30
4.29
4.29
4.28
4.24
4.17
4.06
3.87
3.82
3.75
3.67
3.63
3.49
3.42
3.37
3.37
3.30
3.25
3.23
3.16
3.04
2.84
2.36
2.30

12.20%

2.30

58.33%

9.20

Cc ch tiu s dng trong ch s thnh phn Chnh sch pht tr

Ch tiu

Cht lng dch

v cng - Thng
tin th trng (%
Tt hoc Rt tt)

Cht lng dch Cht lng dch Cht lng dch

v cng - Thng
v cng - Xc
v cng - Khu
tin tm kim i tin xut khu v cng nghip v
tc kinh doanh,
hi ch thng Cm cng nghip
u t (% Tt
mi (% Tt hoc (% Tt hoc Rt
hoc Rt tt)
Rt tt).
tt).

Tnh/Ngun

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: E1.4

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: E1.10

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: E1.14

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: E1.17

50.98%
42.45%
66.93%
58.20%
52.34%
46.96%
41.44%
35.44%
40.51%
42.71%
52.50%
56.64%
40.54%
62.16%
55.38%
53.26%
55.17%
57.14%
51.47%
62.67%
43.18%
43.66%
39.73%
59.62%
39.53%
41.77%
47.14%
41.43%
41.58%
39.29%
45.53%
46.88%
61.86%
31.76%
62.35%
52.46%
52.56%

36.84%
31.58%
48.78%
41.81%
39.25%
24.78%
25.00%
15.00%
21.33%
22.34%
32.89%
44.34%
30.00%
58.33%
32.31%
34.88%
42.05%
50.00%
36.51%
49.30%
28.38%
36.51%
27.14%
45.10%
19.51%
25.97%
27.27%
38.24%
28.28%
23.64%
36.97%
37.50%
40.54%
37.65%
62.96%
45.76%
36.49%

62.89%
60.45%
73.39%
79.55%
73.08%
58.93%
47.57%
38.67%
36.49%
55.32%
64.47%
55.66%
44.29%
73.58%
61.54%
59.09%
66.27%
72.73%
55.74%
65.75%
61.25%
61.90%
47.95%
57.14%
34.29%
51.28%
51.56%
43.66%
37.37%
34.62%
61.98%
55.17%
74.14%
52.94%
74.70%
57.63%
63.89%

53.13%
52.59%
74.60%
68.00%
49.50%
48.70%
42.34%
27.50%
36.49%
43.88%
48.15%
71.68%
56.16%
83.48%
63.64%
58.62%
70.79%
42.11%
61.54%
78.21%
38.55%
29.23%
45.59%
57.69%
25.00%
34.21%
38.24%
47.22%
34.65%
59.26%
53.33%
39.68%
70.09%
73.26%
72.22%
59.68%
62.34%

H Ni
Hi Phng
Nng
TP.HCM
Cn Th
Thanh Ha
Ngh An
H Tnh
Qung Bnh
Qung Tr
TT-Hu
Qung Nam
Qung Ngi
Bnh nh
Ph Yn
Khnh Ha
ng Thp
An Giang
Tin Giang
Vnh Long
Bn Tre
Kin Giang
Tr Vinh
Sc Trng
Bc Liu
C Mau
Bnh Phc
Ty Ninh
Ninh Thun
Long An
Qung Ninh
Hu Giang
B Ra - Vng Tu
Bc Ninh
Bnh Dng
Bnh Thun
ng Nai

H Nam
H Ty
Hi Dng
Hng Yn
Nam nh
Ninh Bnh
Thi Bnh
Vnh Phc
Bc Kn
Bc Giang
Cao Bng
ak Lak
ak Nng
in Bin
Gia Lai
Ha Bnh
Kon Tum
Lai Chu
Lm ng
Lng Sn
Lo Cai
Ph Th
Sn La
Thi Nguyn
Tuyn Quang
Yn Bi
H Giang
Min
Max

35.21%
39.60%
44.07%
44.32%
38.21%
40.00%
39.22%
53.04%
35.63%
46.00%
30.14%
41.89%
38.89%
33.33%
45.65%
45.38%
34.92%
23.53%
37.21%
36.00%
59.34%
38.04%
45.54%
48.86%
47.52%
56.12%
43.33%

24.29%
28.00%
38.66%
32.95%
30.25%
26.32%
24.51%
49.55%
22.62%
30.85%
23.29%
29.58%
20.41%
20.00%
40.23%
24.35%
28.57%
29.03%
35.04%
21.65%
44.44%
31.46%
30.11%
27.91%
34.00%
35.79%
25.42%

53.73%
48.48%
46.15%
56.32%
41.38%
44.21%
56.12%
75.65%
39.24%
51.09%
40.54%
57.14%
29.17%
49.06%
57.65%
53.39%
35.48%
36.67%
54.84%
54.55%
64.84%
57.95%
62.89%
59.52%
61.39%
56.67%
70.49%

63.01%
64.00%
76.92%
79.35%
68.29%
50.00%
65.35%
77.39%
33.33%
54.08%
16.22%
38.24%
25.49%
10.00%
65.52%
34.48%
40.98%
6.67%
38.10%
21.28%
67.42%
51.69%
30.61%
47.13%
40.57%
56.38%
31.03%

23.53%

15.00%

29.17%

6.67%

66.93%

62.96%

79.55%

83.48%

Chnh sch pht trin khu vc kinh t t nhn

Cht lng dch S lng hi ch
v cng - Cng
thng mi do
ngh v cc dch
tnh t chc
v lin quan n trong nm ngoi
cng ngh (% Tt v ng k cho
hoc Rt tt).
nm nay
S liu do Viet
Cu hi iu tra
Trade ca B
PCI: E.15
Thng mi cung
cp
60.42%
48.48%
68.50%
79.55%
69.23%
47.79%
40.00%
28.57%
36.99%
40.43%
60.53%
56.19%
43.48%
61.68%
50.00%
62.35%
53.01%
68.83%
54.10%
60.00%
52.56%
45.90%
42.86%
46.94%
14.29%
39.47%
36.51%
40.91%
29.70%
38.46%
47.50%
50.88%
63.64%
39.76%
72.50%
48.33%
68.06%

12
6
7.5
12
5.5
0
0
0
4
0
5
4.5
0
2.5
0
2
1.5
7.5
0
0
1
0
0
1
0
4
0
3
0
0
0
1.5
0
0
4.5
3
0

Ch s thnh
phn 8: Chnh
sch pht trin
khu vc kinh t
t nhn

Tnh/Thnh ph
TP.HCM
Nng
Bnh Dng
Bnh nh
An Giang
H Ni
Vnh Long
Vnh Phc
Cn Th
B Ra - Vng Tu
Qung Nam
ng Thp
Lo Cai
TT-Hu
ng Nai
Bnh Thun
Khnh Ha
Sc Trng
Ph Yn
Hi Phng
Tin Giang
Hng Yn
Gia Lai
Yn Bi
Sn La
Qung Ninh
ak Lak
Hu Giang
Hi Dng
Thi Bnh
Thi Nguyn
Tuyn Quang
Bn Tre
Bc Ninh
Thanh Ha
Ty Ninh
Ha Bnh

8.73
8.39
8.38
7.92
7.44
7.12
6.98
6.92
6.86
6.84
6.67
6.39
6.27
6.13
6.05
6.03
5.93
5.92
5.56
5.56
5.44
5.44
5.33
5.17
5.13
5.12
5.01
4.99
4.98
4.94
4.72
4.71
4.70
4.62
4.62
4.60
4.56

Bc Giang
Kin Giang
H Nam
Ph Th
C Mau
Lm ng
H Ty
H Giang
Qung Ngi
Nam nh
Qung Tr
Bnh Phc
Ninh Bnh
Tr Vinh
Ngh An
Lng Sn
Qung Bnh
Long An
Ninh Thun
Kon Tum
ak Nng
Bc Kn
in Bin
H Tnh
Cao Bng
Lai Chu
Bc Liu

4.54
4.53
4.42
4.39
4.28
4.25
4.22
4.21
4.19
4.12
4.03
4.03
3.99
3.95
3.81
3.77
3.66
3.61
3.24
3.07
2.94
2.89
2.48
2.48
2.44
2.42
2.26

32.81%
37.11%
40.71%
53.57%
37.17%
46.15%
38.54%
59.82%
30.26%
42.70%
30.99%
44.29%
33.33%
26.92%
46.99%
37.17%
29.03%
23.33%
46.61%
38.54%
51.11%
40.70%
37.50%
45.68%
42.27%
39.13%
35.09%

3.5
0
0
0
0
0
4.5
0
0
0
0
6
3
0
0
5.5
0
4
0
4
0
0
7
0
0
0
0

14.29%

0.00

2.26

79.55%

12.00

8.73

Cc ch tiu s dng trong ch s thnh ph

Ch tiu

Tnh/Ngun
H Ni
Hi Phng
Nng
TP.HCM
Cn Th
Thanh Ha
Ngh An
H Tnh
Qung Bnh
Qung Tr
TT-Hu
Qung Nam
Qung Ngi
Bnh nh
Ph Yn
Khnh Ha
ng Thp
An Giang
Tin Giang
Vnh Long
Bn Tre
Kin Giang
Tr Vinh
Sc Trng
Bc Liu
C Mau
Bnh Phc
Ty Ninh
Ninh Thun
Long An
Qung Ninh
Hu Giang
B Ra - Vng Tu
Bc Ninh
Bnh Dng
Bnh Thun
ng Nai
H Nam

Cht lng dch

Cht lng dch
Cht lng dch v o to ngh
v gii thiu vic
v gio dc do
cho ngi lao
lm do cc c
Cm nhn v o
cc c quan ca ng do cc c
quan ca tnh
to lao ng
tnh cung cp (%
quan ca tnh
cung cp (% Tt
Tt hoc Rt tt) cung cp (% Tt
hoc Rt tt)
hoc Rt tt)
Cu hi iu tra
PCI: E1.3

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: E1.12

Cu hi iu tra
PCI: E1.13

Mng 9.1

66.32%
62.99%
82.44%
75.68%
76.19%
70.37%
73.08%
72.73%
73.75%
78.35%
83.78%
70.18%
79.17%
83.33%
71.88%
71.11%
82.95%
78.21%
80.88%
87.34%
74.70%
70.77%
77.03%
83.33%
72.50%
68.35%
62.12%
74.67%
78.64%
79.63%
67.20%
80.00%
76.72%
73.33%
83.13%
71.67%
81.58%
64.18%

54.74%
47.83%
75.61%
66.48%
63.30%
46.90%
60.91%
50.00%
44.87%
44.90%
57.69%
55.36%
61.64%
66.67%
64.62%
52.27%
70.79%
58.75%
50.79%
77.22%
63.75%
54.55%
59.46%
62.75%
32.50%
62.03%
44.78%
50.68%
56.86%
58.93%
51.59%
54.10%
63.33%
53.93%
78.82%
62.30%
73.61%
50.00%

46.32%
42.86%
73.81%
66.29%
67.62%
47.27%
46.79%
42.50%
48.68%
60.22%
59.21%
53.40%
41.10%
69.44%
64.18%
45.98%
74.42%
61.33%
50.00%
74.29%
66.67%
50.00%
53.52%
56.25%
30.56%
67.09%
40.00%
49.30%
44.55%
47.17%
54.92%
52.54%
62.50%
49.41%
78.05%
51.67%
68.49%
40.91%

3.23
2.75
5.47
4.63
4.59
3.19
3.76
3.26
3.33
3.88
4.52
3.64
3.90
5.09
4.33
3.36
5.35
4.36
3.89
5.76
4.51
3.54
4.09
4.58
2.33
4.17
2.52
3.58
3.82
4.01
3.42
4.03
4.47
3.62
5.73
3.88
5.20
2.82

H Ty
Hi Dng
Hng Yn
Nam nh
Ninh Bnh
Thi Bnh
Vnh Phc
Bc Kn
Bc Giang
Cao Bng
ak Lak
ak Nng
in Bin
Gia Lai
Ha Bnh
Kon Tum
Lai Chu
Lm ng
Lng Sn
Lo Cai
Ph Th
Sn La
Thi Nguyn
Tuyn Quang
Yn Bi
H Giang
Min
Max

62.77%
70.69%
70.93%
70.43%
69.89%
74.00%
84.82%
70.24%
81.44%
56.16%
80.26%
61.11%
68.42%
73.33%
70.59%
57.38%
51.52%
74.05%
69.39%
80.65%
67.78%
76.53%
73.26%
69.31%
75.79%
63.79%
51.52%
87.34%

42.86%
56.78%
59.34%
58.82%
45.26%
54.37%
79.49%
31.76%
58.51%
38.16%
46.58%
24.00%
40.00%
51.76%
42.02%
49.23%
31.25%
49.61%
44.90%
59.78%
61.54%
50.49%
65.12%
56.44%
57.45%
59.68%
24.00%
79.49%

35.11%
54.70%
48.35%
42.73%
49.45%
48.98%
66.37%
33.33%
64.04%
41.10%
44.12%
33.33%
22.00%
38.55%
45.13%
24.59%
21.88%
42.40%
52.00%
48.31%
53.49%
36.96%
57.69%
61.39%
54.35%
39.66%
21.88%
78.05%

2.35
3.75
3.65
3.45
3.18
3.65
5.48
2.29
4.58
2.06
3.55
1.61
2.14
3.23
2.98
2.00
1.06
3.31
3.22
4.12
3.73
3.29
4.22
3.87
4.00
3.08
1.06
5.76

ng ch s thnh phn o to lao ng

S lng trng
dy ngh do a
phng qun l
trn 10.000 dn

S lng trung
tm gii thiu
vic lm trn
10.000 dn

D liu cng v
o to lao ng

Tng cc dy
ngh

B Lao ng
thng binh x
hi: V lao ng
tng hp

Mng 9.2

1.08
1.62
2.19
1.49
1.23
0.44
1.18
0.69
0.47
1.45
1.32
0.82
0.71
0.58
0.81
0.71
0.66
0.32
0.35
1.14
0.89
0.24
0.58
0.71
1.00
0.90
0.88
0.29
1.07
0.35
0.93
1.26
0.77
1.40
0.98
0.78
1.82
0.73

0.45
0.17
0.26
0.14
0.26
0.05
0.07
0.31
0.12
0.16
0.26
0.14
0.08
0.13
0.23
0.09
0.06
0.00
0.18
0.38
0.07
0.06
0.10
0.16
0.13
0.00
0.13
0.19
0.00
0.42
0.28
0.00
0.33
0.30
0.33
0.00
0.09
0.12

2.42
2.15
2.88
1.96
2.07
0.83
1.51
1.72
1.04
1.99
2.15
1.38
1.13
1.15
1.63
1.16
1.05
0.59
1.08
2.29
1.27
0.68
1.07
1.34
1.51
1.09
1.40
1.07
1.23
1.74
1.85
1.40
1.84
2.31
2.03
0.99
2.13
1.26

Ch s thnh
phn 9: o
to lao ng

Tnh/Thnh ph
Nng
Vnh Long
Bnh Dng
Vnh Phc
ng Nai
Yn Bi
TT-Hu
Cn Th
TP.HCM
Bc Giang
Thi Nguyn
ng Thp
B Ra - Vng Tu
Bnh nh
Lo Cai
Ph Yn
Bc Ninh
Sc Trng
Qung Tr
Bn Tre
Long An
H Ni
Ninh Bnh
Hu Giang
Ph Th
Ngh An
Qung Ninh
C Mau
Thi Bnh
Tr Vinh
Ninh Thun
Qung Ngi
Qung Nam
H Tnh
Tin Giang
An Giang
Hi Phng
Bnh Thun

Mng 9.1+9.2
8.34
8.05
7.75
7.36
7.33
6.70
6.67
6.67
6.59
6.59
6.49
6.40
6.31
6.24
6.24
5.96
5.94
5.91
5.87
5.78
5.75
5.65
5.58
5.43
5.35
5.27
5.27
5.26
5.23
5.17
5.06
5.03
5.02
4.98
4.97
4.94
4.90
4.87

0.51
0.18
0.35
0.71
1.42
0.81
1.28
2.01
1.58
0.97
0.82
0.50
0.44
0.45
0.98
0.80
0.64
0.52
0.95
1.56
0.83
0.51
1.44
0.14
0.68
0.59

0.12
0.18
0.18
0.00
0.33
0.21
0.17
0.00
0.13
0.19
0.06
0.00
0.00
0.09
0.25
0.27
0.00
0.09
0.14
0.17
0.23
0.00
0.27
0.14
0.68
0.15

1.07
0.93
1.08
0.93
2.39
1.58
1.87
2.04
2.01
1.66
1.17
0.75
0.70
0.94
1.81
1.71
0.86
0.99
1.49
2.12
1.62
0.75
2.27
0.79
2.70
1.22

0.14
2.19

0.00
0.68

0.59
2.88

Ha Bnh
Hng Yn
ak Lak
Lng Sn
Hi Dng
Tuyn Quang
Ty Ninh
Khnh Ha
Nam nh
Qung Bnh
Bc Kn
Lm ng
H Giang
Kin Giang
Gia Lai
H Nam
Sn La
Thanh Ha
Bnh Phc
Bc Liu
Cao Bng
Kon Tum
H Ty
in Bin
ak Nng
Lai Chu

4.79
4.74
4.72
4.71
4.67
4.66
4.65
4.53
4.38
4.36
4.33
4.30
4.29
4.22
4.17
4.08
4.04
4.02
3.93
3.84
3.73
3.70
3.42
2.83
2.36
1.92
1.92
8.34

Cc ch tiu s dng trong ch s thnh

Ch tiu

Tnh/Ngun

H Ni
Hi Phng
Nng
TP.HCM
Cn Th
Thanh Ha
Ngh An
H Tnh
Qung Bnh
Qung Tr
TT-Hu
Qung Nam
Qung Ngi
Bnh nh
Ph Yn
Khnh Ha
ng Thp
An Giang
Tin Giang
Vnh Long
Bn Tre
Kin Giang
Tr Vinh
Sc Trng
Bc Liu
C Mau
Bnh Phc
Ty Ninh
Ninh Thun
Long An
Qung Ninh
Hu Giang
B Ra-Vng Tu
Bc Ninh
Bnh Dng
Bnh Thun
ng Nai

H thng php l
to ra c ch
DN tin rng h
DN c th khi thng php l s
kin hnh vi
bo v hp ng Ch yu s dng thit ch
tham nhng ca v cc quyn ti
php l gii quyt
cn b cng
sn (% ng
tranh chp
quyn (% Lun
hoc Hon ton
lun hoc
ng )
Thng xuyn)
Cu hi iu tra PCI:
[6*F10.1(nu chn Ta n)
+ 4*F10.2(nu chn Ta
n) + 2*F10.3(nu chn
Cu hi iu tra Cu hi iu tra
Ta n) + 3*F10.1(nu
PCI: G8
PCI: H7.9
chn chnh quyn tnh)
+2*F10.2(nu chn chnh
quyn tnh)+1*F10.3(nu
chn chnh quyn tnh)]
25.71%
67.65%
89.66%
25.55%
68.15%
64.22%
41.27%
83.87%
59.13%
20.00%
70.35%
98.04%
38.18%
83.04%
76.92%
35.40%
73.87%
67.39%
31.58%
77.06%
84.78%
28.09%
72.00%
46.88%
25.61%
78.38%
46.38%
30.53%
77.42%
75.00%
24.69%
84.42%
58.73%
40.35%
83.64%
72.04%
22.37%
71.62%
66.13%
31.86%
79.82%
77.08%
30.16%
84.13%
50.98%
24.74%
76.09%
44.94%
38.10%
76.40%
116.67%
43.21%
89.47%
48.28%
50.72%
84.38%
78.33%
48.24%
89.74%
112.86%
47.56%
94.19%
54.29%
49.28%
77.61%
115.52%
52.31%
87.14%
52.94%
37.74%
82.35%
95.65%
46.51%
80.00%
84.85%
36.71%
81.94%
56.67%
26.67%
82.76%
50.00%
32.89%
81.08%
96.55%
27.00%
72.00%
76.47%
34.43%
72.13%
138.89%
39.84%
81.90%
53.77%
43.75%
88.33%
50.00%
33.90%
75.89%
51.52%
24.36%
92.68%
42.65%
37.50%
81.40%
107.46%
33.87%
80.33%
64.58%
27.85%
81.16%
90.00%

H Nam
H Ty
Hi Dng
Hng Yn
Nam nh
Ninh Bnh
Thi Bnh
Vnh Phc
Bc Kn
Bc Giang
Cao Bng
ak Lak
ak Nng
in Bin
Gia Lai
Ha Bnh
Kon Tum
Lai Chu
Lm ng
Lng Sn
Lo Cai
Ph Th
Sn La
Thi Nguyn
Tuyn Quang
Yn Bi
H Giang
Min
Max

34.85%
24.24%
26.32%
29.21%
33.33%
31.87%
34.00%
36.04%
33.73%
38.04%
22.06%
33.75%
26.98%
34.00%
37.89%
29.57%
32.31%
36.36%
31.58%
36.46%
38.20%
27.59%
34.02%
29.76%
33.70%
36.73%
31.15%

20.00%
52.31%

70.31%
70.83%
75.00%
80.65%
78.95%
91.01%
82.65%
87.16%
82.72%
85.71%
78.46%
74.65%
84.21%
87.27%
83.33%
84.21%
81.25%
66.67%
82.79%
73.56%
84.88%
86.05%
80.21%
78.21%
81.72%
86.46%
76.27%

66.67%
94.19%

39.34%
30.59%
59.38%
56.10%
49.47%
39.51%
42.35%
51.90%
50.00%
69.44%
67.80%
90.77%
91.11%
65.22%
67.12%
46.59%
37.50%
64.00%
57.55%
58.44%
85.90%
56.94%
47.54%
70.37%
75.00%
72.94%
83.33%

30.59%
138.89%

dng trong ch s thnh phn Thit ch php l

S v tranh chp
xt x ti Ta n
kinh t cp tnh
(m bn nguyn
Cm nhn v
khng phi l
Thit ch php l DNNN hay DN c
vn u t nc
ngoi) bnh qun
trn 100 DN
ang hot ng

Mng 10.1

1.89
1.66
3.32
1.90
3.31
2.50
2.71
1.85
2.15
2.59
2.63
3.40
1.77
2.83
2.77
1.95
3.28
3.66
3.96
4.55
4.22
3.84
3.96
3.44
3.56
2.97
2.52
3.15
2.10
3.06
3.08
3.63
2.40
2.99
3.49
2.82
2.87

T l S v tranh
chp (m bn
nguyn khng
phi l DNNN hay
DN c vn u t D liu cng v
nc ngoi) so Thit ch php l
vi Tng s v
tranh chp xt
x ti Ta n
kinh t cp tnh

Ta n Nhn dn Ta n Nhn dn
ti cao
ti cao

0.81
1.09
4.39
1.13
1.92
0.54
0.79
0.00
0.40
0.00
0.20
3.80
4.20
0.72
0.42
1.61
0.54
1.46
0.59
0.23
0.50
1.26
0.47
0.50
0.00
0.63
0.21
0.14
0.00
1.40
1.80
0.61
5.12
0.68
1.52
0.57
1.50

67.50%
58.00%
51.96%
56.60%
54.72%
87.50%
100.00%
0.00%
33.33%
0.00%
25.00%
31.25%
56.00%
61.54%
100.00%
60.00%
71.43%
39.53%
90.00%
18.18%
45.45%
96.00%
40.00%
100.00%
0.00%
63.64%
100.00%
50.00%
0.00%
76.19%
100.00%
50.00%
75.34%
100.00%
72.73%
50.00%
36.67%

Mng 10.2

1.77
1.65
2.17
1.63
1.75
2.08
2.35
0.40
1.08
0.40
0.89
1.68
2.20
1.64
2.28
1.79
1.79
1.39
2.13
0.77
1.31
2.37
1.21
2.30
0.40
1.67
2.24
1.33
0.40
2.04
2.54
1.42
2.73
2.33
2.00
1.41
1.34

Tnh/Thnh ph

Bc Kn
Kin Giang
Tin Giang
Lo Cai
Sc Trng
Qung Ninh
Bn Tre
Nng
Bnh Dng
ak Nng
Vnh Long
Bc Ninh
Ninh Bnh
Tr Vinh
B Ra-Vng Tu
Long An
Qung Nam
ng Thp
Ngh An
Cn Th
An Giang
Ph Yn
Hu Giang
H Giang
Bnh Phc
C Mau
Thanh Ha
Lm ng
Yn Bi
Ty Ninh
Bnh nh
Ph Th
Vnh Phc
Bc Giang
Bnh Thun
ng Nai
Qung Ngi

1.96
1.44
2.09
2.55
2.56
3.18
2.76
3.24
2.83
3.41
2.22
2.71
3.04
3.29
3.22
2.71
2.54
2.04
2.81
2.44
3.53
2.84
2.65
2.56
3.01
3.43
2.63

0.80
0.70
0.19
0.00
0.00
1.60
0.00
0.61
8.12
0.41
0.00
1.06
3.64
0.00
0.44
0.26
0.00
0.00
0.83
0.32
0.60
0.62
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.36
1.09

1.44
4.55

30.77%
69.23%
66.67%
0.00%
0.00%
76.92%
0.00%
30.77%
100.00%
20.00%
0.00%
18.75%
66.67%
0.00%
13.04%
33.33%
0.00%
0.00%
66.67%
50.00%
100.00%
55.56%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
33.33%
100.00%

0.00
8.12

0.00%
100.00%

1.11
1.78
1.64
0.40
0.40
2.09
0.40
1.07
3.74
0.84
0.40
0.94
2.29
0.40
0.72
1.05
0.40
0.40
1.76
1.36
2.31
1.52
0.40
0.40
0.40
1.07
2.41

Bc Liu
Gia Lai
Lng Sn
Ha Bnh
Khnh Ha
Hi Dng
in Bin
H Ni
ak Lak
TP.HCM
TT-Hu
Tuyn Quang
Hi Phng
Qung Bnh
H Ty
Thi Bnh
H Nam
Sn La
Qung Tr
Thi Nguyn
Nam nh
Hng Yn
Kon Tum
Cao Bng
Ninh Thun
Lai Chu
H Tnh

0.40
3.74

Ch s thnh
phn 10: Thit
ch php l

Mng 10.1+10.2

6.57
6.20
6.10
5.84
5.73
5.62
5.54
5.49
5.48
5.33
5.33
5.32
5.27
5.17
5.13
5.10
5.08
5.07
5.06
5.06
5.05
5.05
5.05
5.04
4.76
4.64
4.58
4.57
4.50
4.48
4.47
4.36
4.31
4.24
4.23
4.21
3.97

3.96
3.94
3.80
3.76
3.74
3.73
3.69
3.66
3.65
3.54
3.52
3.41
3.31
3.23
3.22
3.16
3.07
3.05
2.99
2.96
2.96
2.95
2.94
2.62
2.50
2.44
2.25

2.25
6.57