Professional Documents
Culture Documents
فلسطين. Arabic العربية
فلسطين. Arabic العربية
Uploaded by
Harunyahya ArabicCopyright
Available Formats
Share this document
Did you find this document useful?
Is this content inappropriate?
Report this DocumentCopyright:
Available Formats
فلسطين. Arabic العربية
فلسطين. Arabic العربية
Uploaded by
Harunyahya ArabicCopyright:
Available Formats
) (
I { ( 1 x x y .
1
C(
X
UA s
.
1
I X
X(
w.
m
'
s . { A
I
1
1
.
( '
s x
1 I@ .
K
K
1 x { 1
. X
A
{
.
1 m
I
1 . _
I
I
\
.
UA I
) UA
@A :(1
1
U
( A 1 @
I...
A
1
I . 1 O A
As
1
1
I I
1 .@
w
I I
IK...
A
(
y
' x_ '
.
UA
I UA
I
I
` UA ' K.
.
(
,1 ,-
( '
CA A @ ( '
O M K
1
I
(
(
.
[
I A X
W UA
' A
`
K_1
\
UA-
1 U
UA .
m UA j C
.I@
U[ ( X
u ' ` m
I_ UA
sX
X
x1 w
I '
W.
) (
!
- '
!
A .
< ! 5 !
1
! !! . ! B ! A ! !B
A ! !! N !
Q .Q
B< !
!
< !
! N !B
! !
.
! ! !
! ! N
!! Y
[ !-
! !
! !] !\
! . !!
< !] Y
! !
!! 5
!! b ! ! ! .N
-
! !' !
! g
1 f ! ! A .
Y!A
! ! ! !h
! B j j !
'-
!
! Q
!! . ! Q ! k !
A! g ! Q
!
AB
!! g1 ! N !
< A
. A ! !
!
!
! ! ! Q
!A n ! h A Q
] .k! f
!! !
!
]
-
!
- b
!! - fN
f <
A ! ! !! h! gf
!! f! 5
!!
1.
! f
! ! "
" "" -' 5
! ! ! ! ! Q ! b !
! t ! < !
! ! . ! !
!
!!
1 1 ! !
!A Q
! . ! ! !!
1 ! !
! !] ! ! !
h ! ! A f !! ! h !] !
A
! <.
. ! ! ! Q
! f b !
1
! N !
! ! !! h j !
! !.
! f h ! B !
A A! A A ! A A
!!y A A A .
! A ! ! ] ! !]:
! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
! ! !! ) !( ! ) 5
A( ! ) ( !! !
!] .A Y f ! 5B< ! < !].
! ! B .
< !] ! ]
! !A N !
1
A
! . < ! {
! ! ! ! ! 5 !! gQ
! ! f ! . < !]
! h 5 . <
!
- ! n !] !
! !'.
!!! B !
!-A}
!] < !]
) (
) (
!
#
.
#
#
=
#
)# D( A#
# J K## .....................
................................
# ................................
......................
# J DQ ......................
.......................
# #....................... TQ
.......................
# .......................
.....................
#.....................X
## ZX
## A :
............................
#............................
#
# a` # ............
# .............................. D
#i : # f g ....
......................
#......................
k# # #
) (
-
0 /
. "
7 /
7
C C /
I
7
C
.C
-R -
7
"
.
U
V
7
.
7
X
/ 0C
"
.
0
- " `"
`
b C `
.0`
`
e .
h
!A B
!!
)
(
` `
`.
R` e
/
)
`(:
(
`
.
` /
h/ .
.
h
h
(
"
7
U
b7
"
`.
`
0
b7
` ) C
w
`
7 /
(
.
R
`
R` 7
.
(
`
.
/
/ `
` /
`
.
}7 |
7
`
h/ h/ .
h
R
0
/ (`
e
" .
"
b
b
.
`
`
7
.
`
)
7h/ (
` "
(
7
`
"
7
}7
7
7 .
`" b 7
" .
C"
300
11
! A ! ! . ! ! !! !
A
!
! yA h! {! g! B !!! h
!.h
!
300
10
) (
\
< ! j .
< !! j ! f! ! 5 h! f! h ! f n<
.
13
` :
/
` b "
/ .}7 :
w
. `
-
7 / b R b
7
.
h/
.R
.
R
U `b
/
` /
R
`
/ -7
:
\ ! A ! B A !
!
!
!
Y
) f1 5!
(
! !
!
/
`
:
" /" .
7
R
X .
" }7
0.
U
.
. U
"
.
12
)
(
"
`
w 7
"
.
`
I
7
/
/ 7-C
-
`
.
C`
I
7 /
R
h
7 .
R
U7
7w
U
`
0
"
b
b
"
/
U
`
`
`
" C "
.
15
! !
" `"
C
`
e
h .
/
"
`
:
/
7
C h
7 .
/
U
U
7
"
.
I
7
.
b `
`
7 .
R / C
!
!
! h ! f\ ! !'
! .! ! !
B < !.
) (
b
b
"
. 7
7w
b
7 /
7
I
/ / /
h
/
U
I`
.
b "
7 / / U`
"
b /
U.
U"
7
C
/ /
"
.7w
-
/
U
C
7
7
` .
/
7
b
0 b
/
" .
-
V
-
)
(
7
" ".
/ `
.
I
7
.
/
U
R
:
!
! f B
! !
!
!
!
!
!
< !
! )! 5( B
!
7
:
b
A !
!
) f1 5!
(
!
R `
/
b
`
b U
.
19
/
. `
7 .
`
I` `
` R . 7
`
"
`
.
R
`
"
/`
"
U
U7
. I
C`
` }
`.
7
}
"
.
b}
C "
}
-
0
"
"
U.
R
U
`
`
0
.}7
R 7
I
"
U
U
C /
7
U
U
7
C
U
18
) (
`
` b
h .
/ V
U
R .
/
7
7
C 7
7
I
U
C
/ 0 `b
.
7
.
`
/
7
0
` b `
U
.`
`7 - 7
-
`
b7 /
/
" /
/
. "
` b `
C
.
A 5 !
)
(
7
Benny Morris
// -
" :`
)Correcting A Mistake: Jews and
(Araps in Palestine/Israel, - C
/
h
. R R R Morris
C `
U`
:C
" )
7
7 ( .
)
7
( . )
(
h
U
.
.
h ".
7
7
7 /
` b
"
/
" .
7
`
b
` b
I" )Jewish History, Jewish Religion and the Weight of Three
(Thousand Years:C
/
7 ` ` - 7
b
`
` C ".
/
"
/
"
`
`
7
`
.b
b b
C C"
7
:C
23
!!
!\ !!.
U
"
U
`
"
7
`" U h "
h
"
h
Rh .
R
` : 7/
" 7
` `7 C
`
.
U
h
`
` /
`
C`
7
7
` .
7
"
b R
R7
b /
":
7
)
(" .
R`
U
U7 U
-C
`
`
7.
7
/
/
7
/
.
7 /
`
.
7
U
` `
C0
`
C
7
U
.
7
!
A! N ' \ !]
! !
h N
! .
\ A! g !!
! Q ! 1 b h f
! .
22
)
(
7
U
" h `
R .
BBCC h.
b
`
h
C 7
U" .
" `
b .
`
) Self-hating Jew :`
b b R( .
R
`
/
0 " "
.
I
R U `
U
.
h .
R
U
b
.7 R
.
`
7
.
U
U
`
/
`
b
.
! !!
! !! !
` /
/
7
/
.
b
7
"
R
7"
I
C b
)(
`/ b / `
7
.
25
"
.R
U C
C
`h /
7/ .
7
. R
/
R
R
. :
`
7".
7
` .
` /
!! f!
! !
! .
< ! Y! !
!\ ! h.g
24
)
(
7`
`
7
w
:
"/ 7
` )
(
U /
7
C 7
7 ".
b
7 I b``
7
7
/ C
U C
.`
7 R
:
" h / U
` `
)
( .
7
/
w`
` `w`
U
7/
.... ! 5 ! .
!!
h! 5 h
!
A . ! 5 h<
Q A !".
!
U
`
7
U
` 7 0 ` .R
U /
I`
.
C`/ b `
.
0
}7
`
7
27
U
7
C
`
R
7
` 7
`7 7 `
7
.
`
C
. "
C
`
`
- `
7w "
.
`
) Yesh Gvul
(
V
.
`
` / .X h
` `
U 7
C
.
`7
`
` 7
/
I
7
h
0 /
.
C` ": "
`
7
C
/ ".
C `
`
C
": b 7
`
)
(".
7 "w
`
U
`
7 ":C /
7
` " .
26
)
(
7
C` b
/
7
R
7
U
/
7
7 /
U
7
V7
`
"
b b
0
`/
C
7
.
.
! 5 A !
w/7
b7 /
0
` .
C
"
C"
I 7 .
` b
I" 7
`.
C
0
7 `
`
" .
0
7w
.7
b" 7
`
.
}7`
.
`7 C
/
"
`" b
.C
29
RADKAL, 18.2.02
! !h
A ! !! ! B !!
!! ! f] !
!! h . ] ! !]
! < !! . B !
! :The Nation ! \
A! ] Houston
Chronicle B ! B]
!!
! !
! :! Q!:
!.f
B! !
! ! ! ! !
! - h.
!< ! Q
) (
! ! !
! !h
A! ! ! !
! ! !!
! ! ! ! !.
!! 5 !
!!] !'
! ! !!.
A j!
A
!h
! !
! ! A!.
!
!!].
1992
A : ] . A! ! Q h
A
! Y
! :! 5!
.
1973
5 : ] !N ! Q h
A
! Y
! :! 5!
.
`
7 )`
V
( / U
7
7
.R
U /
Vh
.`
7
7
.
h
.
C
/
. C
:
N
!
j !
) .! 5.( 5
/ b
-
7
b.
I `
}7
0
.0
I / 7
C
.
U
.
7
b R
/
.
C :
A N
" !
-
! A
!
A
" ) .5
!
!!].(
30
) (
! !!
1
Y ! b ! N .
!
! ] ! ! h
!
! A ! b! .
33
U /
"
7
`
` . /
7
.7
`
:C
]
1
!
! 1 ! B
\
! ! B
b
! ! h
) (
!]
!
!
.
!
) . f1 5!
!
< !
.(-
-
I - R`
b` ` `.
0
-
/
7
R
I
` b
I
C
` `
w
.
32
) (
- -
U
/
.
h
7
R
7
.
C7 `
U
/
/
}7 -"
`
R` .
/
| X
.
/
R
:
! A !.
! ! !
. <
!
A
.
!
! j
)! 5.(- B
}
7
` / "
7
"
U`7
7 - }7
.
" " /
/
7` /
b.
`
77 /
/
7
/ }7.
! !Q
) (
j A! -
! -h !] !!.
.
U `
R
U 7 .
U /
U
C b7
7 )
(
. 7
/ /
.
`
b /
/ .
C
. 7 /
R .C
7
`
R .R
R
:
37
/
"
R7
` b
- ! n y Q-
! h
A
!
!
! 5
! y
5
N A Q
!
)A 5!.(
!]
/ ) ( )
( / )
7 /
(.
V
7
`/
|
/
.
0 /
U
7 .
"
.
R
R
V
/
h . `
R` /
/ V .
C /
`
7 .I
/
V /
U - V /
`
"
` .
/ `
:
! h !
! j ! ! !
!
!
)! 5( 5
|
` ` ) b( .
`7
7 `
`
/
7"
`
36
) (
! ! f
!
- A !
!
! ' !
!
!
! 5! :
B
!
!
A
!
!
!
-
)! 5.( 5
! !
` .
`
R
7
`
}7` . I}
0
I .
"
" "7
}7`" .
R / 7
`" b "7
"
}7`" .
. /
.
R
7 /
`
" /
"
` /
.
39
A
1!
!
!
N !
! < ! !
f1) .!
( :
!
!
! ! ' !!
! ! Q
! 5
! !!
!
!!
:! j 5 ! j
b A ! . ! b
! ) Washington Report !( !
! Q ! B . ! ! !
!! !!.
38
) (
-
7
. `
7
/
C"
7.
}
7 h.
7
` b .
)
( ` /.
/
`
7
V7
.
7
7
`
.
`
.
V )
( .
C
:
! ! ! h
! Q ' <
A !
1
! ! Q
! ! )! 5!( B
A
U`7
}7 U
`
7
}7 .
V
"
}7 7
)
(
R
}7 .
7
7
7
b
Holy
War
" :
`
/
.
C
/
}
)(
b V )
( `
.V
R`
"
"
" .
` I
R
h h` .R
` `
7
} /
`
b
R"
.
V
."
.
! .
" . U
7
/
X
"
}7 7
/
7
`
.
"
/
C"
C
C"
.
f !\
`
`
7
.
` U U7
7
`
C
7 /
7 7
.
7
/ ` C
`
.
7
)
7
(
R }
0
`
`
.
"
.
7
U
7w
R
7
b
7w U
"
.7
"
`
C
.7
7
` C
b R
`
42
)
(
/ C " . 7
7
7 /`
7
h
`
. C
7- " :! !\ !!! Y ... !
B " .
7
R
:C
7
7
7 -
7
.
`
7
.C U
07
b7 .
`
0
. R
7 R .
h
!!
! ! N
!! - ! h -
! ! ! .
45
.
U
`
"
U ."
7
C .
"
/".
7 " " "7 .
C U " U 7w
` U " `
. 7 b| 7`
" . C / b 7 `C
" . 7 "`
" ` 7/.
` " 7 .
` b` 7
. .
! ! { ! !
`
"
7
7 ""
C .
b
7
0 7
C
7 7
"
7
"
C
U7 . 7
7w
U
7
44
)
(
C .
`
" `h I
-V b
C
/
V /
-
C . h U
`
h
"
` C
.
b .
)
(
7h
-
.
7
7
:C
` C
U
` ...
R b
` " b 7w
`
e
. b
.
.
/
` ` ` b .
` C
` 7
.
07
` 0 /
.
`
.U
)(
/
C "
R
/
0
.
300
47
.
C
7
0
/ 7 7".
C
7
7.R
R 7 U
"
b` .
b
U `
/
.
R
7
.
0
b
U
|
" .
7 ` b
b"
.
7 ` b
"
7 U
.
b
b " " 7 .
R7
7 /
300
46
) (
! !! f
"
7 " .
C
U
"
7
U
.
"
"
C
.
"
R
.
"
7`
7
.
h
` /
C
"
IR
7
C
`
7 .7
C
7
!
! N
h h
h .h
! ! ! f
! y !! .5
! A! h] ! !' .
! ! !
!.
U
. C h
7
`7
C b
7
b
-
C -
" .
R "
/
.
/
C
" "
"
) "...
7 . (
7 |
.
C
b
7
"
b
U
"
"
`
e .
R
.
7
48
) (
] !} ! ! f! 55
' !5
! !
! !
! A .
!
! !
! !
)5
A
! A
!(
A
!
!
! !
A
!
! ' ! ! A B
] B
!
! !
)5
! f ! A
!!](
": C `/ b
`
`b
51
"
`
`
7w
.
C 7
7
X
`
) U
` (b /
`
`
7w .
`
U
U
/ 7 / " `"
`
. "
"
U
"
7
}
7 . U
R
/
` .
h
7
/
C
.C )7
(
"
`
R
C
.
C
"
U
:
!
!
!
N
A
] A !-A !
!
!
A
! A f
!
)! 5( B
! B
1! ! !
!
! !
!
!
!
A
!
!
! '
!
A ! !
)! 5( B
50
)
(
Vh
b
` R
/ `
.
C U
R U .
C
:
A
! 1 5 ! ! 5 !
!
j !
!
b ! !
! )! 5(
`
`
b
/
" 0 7 R
` / .
7
"
`
"
.
I
U .U
7
b Vh
" "
"
`
`
.
"
"
b
b "
7
`/ ` 7.
U 7 C
" . 7
`/
` 7 7
.
"
` C
/
V
b U
7
7w
.
`w
7
.
C
`
C
53
/
`
" .
R `
7
` R
U
.
R 7
C
h .
`
X `
.
7
.
`
w / . ) b
"
`(
0 7.
!
A !
!
!! 5!! . h
B !]
! !!! g!.
! N
\ !! 5
! g!
52
)
(
/
" "
`" "
/
`" . `7
`/ C /` / "
.
"
" .
"
/` / `
`
" .
.
}
` /
7
`
7.
!.h
!
A !! ! !! h
`
7 7 .
7
`
`
`
.
/
C"
C"
`w7
/ C
7
`/
R.
7
/
R .
7
7 `7
`/ .
U .
7 7
/ "
`
` C
""
" .:C
U
`
)
( .
"
7
.
/
.
/" 7
`/"
.
"
0
" "
/
/ U .
` ` U
/ h
U
7
" .
"
7/ U I7
. "
7
`/
" C
/ "0 `
R
C
7 7w
w
.
"/"
`
" I ` " C "
X
" .
I }7
" "/
54
)
(
TRKYE, 15.4.95
! A
TRKYE, 7.01.96
ZAMAN, 30.8.01
! ! !N
TRKYE, 8.10.01
!! h
! Y! h ! f !
!! f
-
!! g .
AKAM, 8.11.01
!! ! A g !
ORTADOGU, 10.11.01
!\ !! h
ORTADOGU, 10.11.2001
! f! y ! !
) (
,% %( &% " -
: %% 8 % 3 5 3% 2 .
= %= 8 "
%= A 2 &" "
& B .
%" 8
" :3 : "B & B:
& 2& . :
& "&% 8 , "%
& 2" " (
"% . U
% % :
: 3 & : W &" & 2.
3 : 2 " , W%.
2 )( .% b U% &% %5
% , % " % .2
) (
= & % .
% & % =
"" : =% . h( %
:
.
2
) 9( 9
B 2
@ > 9
) 9(
G
% b= &" & % ,
j : = . b= i
&" b " .= &"
&% k
2 %2 "&%
"&% 3 W=
b% .: 2 % %%" k %b
.
% "o " "2% 2 b.
= &" % "%" 3 U "&%
% . = h :
H
2
2
) 9( 9
2 9
. T U B
.2
2
\
. 2
) 9(
B
G
61
:
H 9 d
U U gT
2 \
9 l .
%
&
. U
3 % % . : 2
% : 3 :( & %
% -(:
= " &" 5 3 % :%q
)( % ..... 8 &3 2% 5
3 , & & :% W % .b" % %
% % .:
8 % B 3
: : "
%% B 3 " % %
% j % .j " : 3 % j=
W % 8= : :.
% k h &" :
%& j ) (8 k
=
% B % . j
y x = &
& z % .=
60
) (
% % % x::
~ .2 % % % 8 { .(
. ~ . 8 . .j
~ . % ) . :% j
(-
" % . q & j " %
% ) : (- j
. " . . x . %A : .
& : % % b % % b % b ) .:
%(- j
% 8 3 j & % % .h j
:% 2 & 2 .j& , % 2(
% &" " =
. % " b% A "
B & % & % 2 :W
.
2 o
)9
2
2
( G
% q3 "% = : %
&" % ," &" "
% .b )The Universal Jewish
% "& ( Encyclopedia , & 5
-" :
23 &" & % )
63
2
q
2
.
B
t
H U
. .
s d
.
@ 9
B
)9
d
(- T
% 3 = : :
"& "%% 2 & "%.
% % " " "&% : 3
"% x 3 j % . :
8 %:
) : ),(/ j :% ),(/ j:
(-/ j
% b &% W % 2
& "&% % ."j "% =
: b% . 2 &"
h% j= "&% W % & % "3%
8 q &% . & &" b
& . B( % %8
% x.
&" =
k = W
: : . & , = % &.
& % :
%% . &" " b= :
B :% . b = y8
62
) (
U
% : % 3 q.
% " " & k k " & b% .
& 3 2 "& k "
" & " &% ."k
= % " 3 5 h& ,8
(% % - % &=
( 3" % % 8 ,
&" " 3 3 % ".
&" " z z "
: = " &% "k
" ".....
" & k" " & % 8
(%% . % (% -2
. &" % (% " %
3 % . b = 2 "3 : "
. &" = 2= 3 2
% = %= .
% &" " :
% : 3 % 3 j ( %
3 & & 8 % .:=
% :
%" " % ,(% .... :
% " & y :" &
65
% %& (k % . i " b "
A3 q .
" %.
q3 b
& 3 " , :,
o 5Jewish History, Jewish Religion: The Weight of) " 8
(Three Thousand Years b " :" % .
b : 5" &% b%3 b :%
3 "% :% . &" ) 2
b :( 3 5 3 h 3% %
% A &% .: %% &
: = &%% " .
8 % , : " . b :
"& j % &
( 3 % " h & 2
: % ."j 3 b = %j
= %( 3 %& .
3 % &%=
b .
% &" & ,
%q . &" q j :) :U
8( & & = %% 2 b
8& .j W 5 :
% " " % b 8 & , 3"3%
A " x".
64
) (
H >
9 2 U
.
.
& 8.
% & 3 % 3 - 8
&% &" " :" & " b "
% . 5 3 : .
" " % 3 &
" " 3 %% h " .
% " : % "
" % . % = % &
% &%% %%% . =A %=
A% .% h :3 : A
& % : .
&" = A
) = 2 j 9U
"% ( (.
% &" , A%
67
5 &" & , % :
" & b & 2" . " &"
. %" 2 8 :
.:
W&% 3 2(
3 j . % &= 3 (%
" % "% = % =
b) .(% ( =
2 % j : )Soykrm Vaheti
( % .( 3 %
j.b
% " %
% "& " . 8 (%( %
3 " "8% . k %
% : %= ( & 8
& % = % . =
( % %& A % 3% 2 3 - "
5 % ." " j ,"
" 2 : " &% .
% : 8
: %= h q
% .= k %.
% b3 8 W &,
j&% x ,%
66
) (
( % % " 2
& & % & %
83 2 :% .8 %
& W &%& 2
W 8& . 2
%" 3 :.y
%
= -
& . = "
% "
@ U
) ("% . h
" W &
"& -
" % 8
G
\
.
9U 2
9 9
U 9
G
sU
.T
1930
1931
1932
1933
1934
1935
1936
1937
1938
1939
"3= {
~ (
3
% &.
4944
4075
9553
30327
42359
61854
29727
10536
12868
16405
British Government, The political History of Palestine under the
British Administration, Palestine Toyal Commision Repory, Cmd,
.5479, 1937, p.279
69
& = (% 3 & =.
%( 8" & "
," % .
% 3 % .8A & =A
& . % & 3 8
. 8
( 8" & % ," & % .
% ( : 3 (% 3"
% 8 3 & x G@ g
. G> z
. d U
9 2 . \
.
% 3" j
3 8 i , j
j % . &" 8=
2 G9
2
UU
2
.T H9
2
.sU
8
)- ( 1920
1921
1922
1923
1924
1925
1926
1927
1928
1929
5514
9149
7844
7421
12856
33801
13081
2713
2178
5249
British Government, The political History of Palestine under the
British Administration, Palestine Toyal Commision Repory, Cmd,
.5479, 1937, p.279
68
) (
j
&= :
2:
230000
1954-1955
80000
80000
130000
30000
130000=1962
@
1954-1955
=230000
125000
1950-1951
40000
1953-1954
66000
1956
52000
1948-1950
9 s d T T
g U gU
> .U
& 2 j% .
3 W 3 W &,
% . q & , W 3 j (%.
&" . &" & , .j &"
3 % x % x" )" (.
% b 2" & ( ( " :
> 2 H".
% = j = % h
= . =
=
= % % ."
71
3.
%" 8% & % 3 i%
% % q . &" =
& =
%% : y% 2 3" % % . & jb
: :A % 8 % b
(:
b x b . &"
9
U 2
T
9 U
2 T T U
U 2 .
s d
U
.U
70
) (
sU
/ 1946
1937
2
U
U
9
sU
2
2
U
U
U
2
j = : : % h j% .
q % . b : " : j
% &
a% . " % A% % (%
3( % b % %
" -% ., y &" & % % j
% B %" : & . " ,y
3 & % . b= " %
:& "% 3 . & & &" q q3 " .
j % % W
x .
% j &
( . ( % &
% .j &" " %
U j b 2 j
= .
% 2 j 3%% j =
= ( = % W
% 3% 2 x "% %&% : A
3 & h x % , j% 2= &
.
% & %&% % 8 3
% % :" %"% . 8 & " =
" % .yA ,"
&% &%.
% " " = &h
& % " % b 2
3 % " = ( 3 &
" = % .& :
" = & W - W & %3 % & "
b( 3 B q . &" U :
k % :"%
b U " % Wq% ,3 .
3 q 3 x " " 3 j &
& % ( 3 = % . & 2 =
72
) (
U s:H
.t
9 9
.
s
o
t
.
x % ( %:
...
.
U
U
G s
H
@ ) gB(
% &" 8 , &" %2
%% .8 W & x "o q .B &" "o
& 3 B = % h % 8 %
% %% 8% . % U & x "o "
75
G
T
9
U . T
T U
HG
) ( \
)
(.
5 % % % & %(% . 3 b5%
" = =
" " %
= " % =2 2.
% " " , % % %
& . b % . j
h : % %%" .
8" j 3 2 & %
&% .W "o ( %
. " %
74
) (
U
G G s
2 . 9
.T T
, "%
% .h " 3 : & x "o
%" % . " : &x
"o & & 3 % b
% . % 3& 2 b.x
% ( j W : "
" % % j
% b % & ,& j.
G G
d 9 :9
2
77
G G
U
9 .G
z
2 2
Gd 9
d .
s s
G
.9
76
) (
2 " "*
7 " "* . 3
> ; *
@* .*2 C B @ *
J 2 * 3* .H *@
P O J
" U P B* J
" J * . P
O 2 ) 3
( * * . ] @
P )* P( * .
* * O2 P ) (...
:
@ * 32 ;
2 * . ;2
c U* .
* * * C* J
C e.
79
) (
8 2 *+ # .
= +
2 B .2
* * JC
**; . * .
; * * C* .P C C ** ;
* . > C ;*
> C 2 B H C; .
* B H*) C * 2 ( 3P
* . 32 *
" J" B . C
> l B .
@ * O ** . B m
* e .....
* J O> H2
.
*2 P B ; > *B * P 2
81
* 2
. *2 J 3
* C C ; * );(
* ; C 2 *2 J *]
U C2 *B B 2 2
* . * C> 3 > .
* l >
* B 2* . J
3
.c * @ * ;
P * J
": J
" * " " .*
* * * O2 *
:J
" P" *
"" O
*B * * .
" " * "B " H 3 B ;
3 * 3 .
* J ; 2 ; B O
m J 2 ** . O
* * :J
B ** 3 . J *
80
) (
.
*
*
* * . B
*2 B * . 3
Tribune
International Herald
3 * @
:J
B * * * J
* * * * . *@
B *] B ":J O m B * * JP
.> * * *2 ".
C +
#
I #
K.
* . P U 2 > ; B
* .** *2 .
* ) J * @: (C
" L
" ) O .( CO
) (
=
W
L
C
Z Y
8
] .
SR+
L
S K +
S 2 R
.
) (
TRKYE, 7.8.01
GZC, 19.5.01
'$
W. REPORT, 4-5.1993
CRESCENT INT., 16.8.01
CUMHURYET, 22.5.01
S
ZAMAN, 20.5.01
*2 P 2 C . B 32 .H
*; * P; * * . > * P B
m J*2 * . J Crescent
International 2 ; >
* . ; The Washintong Report of Middle East Affairs J
B
7 .
H 32 e 3 .
) (
TRKYE, 13.10.01
Rcd I
MLL GAZETE, 18.5.01
MLL GAZETE, 13.5.01
8
YEN AFAK, 28.11.01
S YY
89
B J -
B 7 .
> H
*2 B . > ;
* 3 J P *2 32B
B .CO 7
** C * . B *C
P * **
" ) R.( K
"
* O O B * . O
") The Murder of Arafat ;( P O
2 ; * .2 B O O
B O :
B l P * B J * B
* . > ; *;
2 * 2 .
*> ".
* * *
:J
p S
#o
p S
#
p
I
I
I
88
) (
B P .
* P 2 B C 3
B H O * .
; * * l * . J
2 *B J
) (* .
l * .
- -
C .++
Y 2
91
p
y
p S . p
I
)S R(-
S
* U B* B
** . @B C
B .
* B : * 2 * P7
.
y
;
> * * * * .- O
> ; *; * ; * .
C; * ; 32 ].
* > @ * 2*2 C O
2 * P 3 * P 3
* 32 * * P
O *]
* 3 B * P ** -
- m O. P
B U > *@ H C
* .@ 2 J2
B C * * U * *3
90
) (
.
U 2 * 3
* H* 3
.
R
3 P > ;
3 * . P J O ": B P
@ ".
+
* 3 )*@( * @* 32 2 B
2 * .
; * .
* B m e *
C .
> @ B*
C2 3* . > C;
* ; * U.
2 ; *
* . * B 3 *;.
* ; - - H.
93
+ C ++
> 3 * J
* . >
* ** .2] *] .
R
P B * B 3
3 ;* * C* J
* .P
* ; 2* P U2
.
I
P > 3 U *2
* 2 .
Ry + #
2 *> * . .J
C
7> *B *]
* 3 ;2* U 7 * J *2 2
B 2 @
92
) (
= R+
S
2= y
.
W + .
Z R
B .
2 3 * B
.3
+
* * P O P
B 3* C H l
B* . m l *
* ; *2* . > l 3 2
; *.
* 2 ;
; ; m *2* . l
O .
* ; O O> * *
3 B P ; * * * *
* ; * . P; *
) ( * * .e C*
J * * .C >
P
* .2 3 . .
* B H C; :
2 * . O
* . B * . c
> * * c .
* * * C J )* P(C
94
) (
.
*2 3 * " : 2
*2 m B"* .> B B
B * *B *B> *]
] * * .2 JJ
@ C B " :2 +
S . + S"() .
C * ; > ;2
*2 P B* . ; > ; 2 . * m
2 @ * 2 .
R
* @ B e C H *B
C 3 ; * * 22* .
; ; 2 .
*) J( ; ; * C
* .J P O ) 3 32 @C
*( 3 * * H 2
2 : * ; * * 32
] * O 2
* * . 3
* J * 32 ": J
B 3 ."H
* 2 H 3 3
:
97
Y 2 R
+
R+
R #.I
O * ; * ;
* .3
* * P * l @ 3 l * O2 m
2 * * ":J *".
C P 2 * J
3 * . ; *
C * .J l 3
B .
; *; > @
B 3 3 P *2 B
; . m *2 B ; .
- O @ C B -
> 3
96
) (
C * . J 3 2
* B J * . >
C 2 * .
* * ;C * B
* . 2 B 2 * :J
B * .:
* * P* * . * . ":
" .:
" "* . > C 2 ** . ] ":
"* . 2* .
* O > 3 -
* O > . * 2 ;
B ;C * 2* . J * * . C
J*] *
*; * C*
H 2
*2
*]
c
# I
99
" J;
. B
#y ......
p .B
+".
* ;2 The Sign l
B * . J " :
] @ y R+
".
R
C B *) J(
3 H *
* J * C* J.
; *2; : CH
* . J H*2
: : ; * .32
] B H> H*2.
B J O : 2
) pS
= S
S
) R(- :R
98
) (
J 2 *
.
*> 2 * ;2 ; BH
*2 B .
R
2 * * . *
3 @* 2
* * .
R R
2 * 3 ; J
*.C
; ; *
*] .
Y
> .
O2 P 3
* . P *]
* . C B .
> O2 ;
.
* * B
" " * . 2 OO
101
S I =
Z S #
p Y .
TIME, 7.3.94
TIME, 7.3.94
Y + Y
Z .
Z+ L .
) (
O .
2 C 3 * C2*
* C 3 * B
.
* ;2 2 * l2 *
@ 2 * . *
J .
3 2 J P * *
2 . 2 JP
#
I
R Y + +.
103
R +
#
I 8 .
) (
B R
Iy 2 y L .R
2 B * * O
* C * * C> e * .
e 2* P
* .e 3 H * @ J C
2* ...... P* . ; @
) ( * . @ * C 3.
* 3 J P .
** J; J J 2 @ C
3 c ; ": ) (
O C> @ . 3
] ] ."O
> e * C* J C
105
l2 B 2 .
R I
3 *" ; J 2) C 2( C
** . C
2 J* . 2 "
@ B
*;.
* @
@B *] 7 C > m* .3
* B J 2 P
* @ * . >
* 3 ;
* C* .J* l; 3; B
*@ * J* . > 3
* " ] ".
* B ] @ C B
* *;
> O * P 3:J
S
# 8
I .
J P
* J > .
104
) (
) (
": 3 " * . * 7
U* . * J ;
* ; ; )*@( * J;
*2 O * O* .O 3 *
3 J; * ; *2 c
* * 3 * J ] *- 3 - .
* B * 2 J
J 2
J 3 ) ( .
B *.H
B O e *2
@ J * . m
* e
; * * . > *2
C 3 P . *
.C P .
P C P
* . * P * .
; * * B
* P ; * * c
*** . * *2 7 B c
*B *B
J.
m e * 32 P .
** J * J H
109
3 3 C . C;
* . ; * ** J C J *@
* P P * . * J
B * .; Le Monde
3 * * P 2 2O
* J:2
....; ; B C ] .
* 3 7* . * .
H *2 * * ..... @ ;2 3
B . * . *
* B **> 7.
* 3 . .*2 c
* > * *2 * c
. m .......
; ; J
* . > C ; *
; B * . ; B H C2
. * C *
* . **
2 .... 3 . *]
*..... 3 ;
3 C J 3 H .m ** C;
* c* . 2 *2 -
.
> ; * * 7 3
":J * 7 "* . O J
108
) (
* * -* 3 ** .
@B * 7 B ;2 B 3C B 3C
* 3 C* . B
3 H ) O
* ( 2 B ] O 2 O
* * O U .
MLL GAZETE, 22.4.01
: .
2 .I
K
I
R
B.
lB * * B HC " "
*.
* P " P
: *>" *2 3 B B * C
> 3:J
B
O> C* P
* O * * * .
* B 2; 2 *
B ; * J . 2 .
* l > ; B *2
* .J
B; C * > * . @
** B ;
* * 3 * .3
J* . *
) B( :
p S
#o I
I p
)R
I
I
( R
* * .
B *B * .
*
* 7 * .
110
) (
** . ;.
B - ; * P B
*2 .
* 3 P 3* .
P* O c * 2* . 3 J *
B * P O 3* ;
*; @ * .; * l3
* B J * B
* . J ": P 3 O J
*
"* . 2
* 2
* :J
.3* 23
3 B B 2 .
* . @ ; *
)*@( P* P
**
B J . * P
.
3 P * .; 2
B C
2 ; P H * J
:J
J ": * " ":
" ": B 7 *;
P . P . ".
*@ *
> * . *2
C * B *; ] P* C 22 ;
O ; * . * O 3
*; *; U* > P
*:
# #
R .
* J * " The Accused
" O BBC 3 O P J 3
** . O *2 J *
> 2 2
3 * .P c *@
* * J * .
" " L
S
m O>
@* C
* * *
*2 . * 2*2
B *; 2 B* . 7
.3* " 7 * * *;
" B * . * P O>
;2 B BBC 3 ; 3 .
-
- * . B *
2 * ** . *
*B :
* 2 7
* * J * . ;C
2 m2 @B
) (
+
*> B
22* ; 2 *
. 3 2*2
** 2; *;
*@B C 3 BBC* J.3
Z Y
* B *
2 O * * P
J :
" ; * *
".
* P; ;* . J 3 3
* . 3 H; *
B * * ; * > . ]
The Independent> ] * J * .
* * * . m . >
; . * J H @
* * 7
.* J * * O
7* * * 3* J.3
* *2 3 B
ZAMAN, 28.6.01
MLL GAZETE, 28.6.01
+
115
; * 7
H 32 * . B J P
; ;.
* B ; l
*; * 72 @*
J ; . *
* l B B ;
B ".
* J * . ; 3
* 2 P 3
2 * 2 ** * ......
C * J * > *
P* . J J B ":
O * B O2 ] * ..... C
B > * J O* *
"* . 2 * O 2
* J H * * P .3
* J :
* * * ": m;
; * ; .* * J
B* . > .
l " . 7 ;
. ; * . ":* @ J * 7
. ." 2 O.
* **
* . P
* O C 7 3
; * 2.
114
) (
* . > 3 >
* > *.
Y
P O BBC " " 3
* 2 H H *
P* . H > O
O .
*; H H 2 C
O * ** . ; ; *2
; * * * l *
* 3 P * *
* P* . > ; *;:
. * O *
*
B O> ) J(
P; @ ; .
. ; * ] @ BJ
B .
. J * Warrior
)( B B C> .
. J * ) J(
J J B ;
*;* . . J*
2 J; * ; *
.... O*2 J * * J"
..
)( ; 2 "* . 2
* ":** !m ".
) 3C * H ;2
( http://www.mallat.com/complaint.htm
117
YEN AFAK, 19.6.01
C
RADKAL, 19.6.01
+ I
LE MONDE, 28.6.01
Y Z
S y Y
. p
Le Monde Z+
L
Z Z
y Z .
R
S #
Y
B.
( )
*B 3 > B B* .*
. *; *P H C O
> B . @ * 3B
3B P*;
*. C B
B 3 B *2 *
. @
1- Benny Morris, The Righteous Victims, New York, A. Knopf, 1999,p. 540
2- Schiff & Yaari, Israels Lebanon War, New York, Simon and Schuster, 1984, p. 251
3- A. Sharon, Warrior: An Autobiography, Simon and Schuster, New York, 1989, p. 498
4- Sharon la Knesset, Annexe au rapport de la Commission Kahan, The Beirut Massacre, The
Complete Kahan Commission Report, Princeton, Karz Cohl, 1983, p. 124. (Ci-aprs, Kahan
Commission Report).
5- Kahan Report, p. 125: mopping-up
6- Amnon Kapeliouk, Sabra et Chatila: Enqute Sur un Massacre, Paris, Seuil, 1982.
ZAMAN, 5.08.01
Y Zc
YENAFAK, 5.08.01
MLL GAZETE, 5.08.01
.S Y . . .
. . .
S
> ; B 2 * *
* . 3 * ) Warrior 3( O
; J ; .
* H 2 C 2 2 J
*B 3 * P
* * ) ;
; * U( > 2 ;C B
; .
o
* 3 * P .
B ] * J2 O> *
* . O P H ; C
2 O* . @ .3
> P B c; *
* B e * .P @ 3
*> ; @ *; * . 2
* H * .P > l* *;
* . B * * C > @
3 3 3 2
# I
B
) ( I
118
) (
; * *
B @* . P @ JB J>
l2 * 3 .
SABAH, 25.1.02
B
HRRYET, 25.1.02
# R
MLLYET, 25.1.02
1- The Independent, 25 Ocak 2002
2- The Independent, 25 Ocak 2002
3- The Independent, 25 Ocak 2002
S Z
o
O; B O
* >*2 P * ;C 3
; . ;2 l2
B ; 3 * . P
;
* * PB *
2 3 ** . > 2 ;2
* 3 P B .
3 J * . B C 2.H
* C 2 O l2 *
@ C O 2B 3 . U 2
3 2 3 .
* 3 * .3
* 3 C * 2B
* . B * J .
] ) ( 2 C 32
* B * . J :
" 2 O 3 J l * > 2 C
)(
".
* * .
; * ;
* . O 2 3 * *
** . 3
B * 2 * B *@ *
)(
* *B * * 3.
* ; * B
m B* . * 7
O " :
)(
> 3* "H .
* J *2 C * * . * 7
) (
L
Z
Z
517412
683560
346164
337308
385.707
320.934
170.417
253.997
83.311
S
+
R
L
y
* * *@
** ; * . 3
** .U C* *;
* .P . 3
3* .H > ; ;
* 3; * H ; * B
.
* 3 O 2
. * * .
3 . 3
/2* > ) /2 (
2 . C
* * B > . >
C H 3 .
* ) The Israeli Connection (
* *
* 3B 3 :J
C > 2 3 O
/* . 3
C
P B
123
Z
J 3 P J; 7
B * * ** . B
e* * 2
O m* .
2
O . H * 3 .
* J B 2 m * *3
**] B .H
* C B * B * 3
B * 2 * * * J ** .3 () P
* 3 3 3H
* J* . 2 C
, .
ZZ
R+
.
122
) (
. m * O @ * H
2 * B O .
H U O P ; * .
> . H C **
P ** 3* .....e @
) O ;
(P @
* *.2
*
S R L
I yB
.B
125
* . *
* O * .....
P 3 * U* 3 P
3 ......C
* B 2 ; J
@; > ; * . P
:
J ; * J P2 O;
. *
* B O2 O
2
. .
S
+
Y
I
.#
124
) (
...... U ;C
B *B .... U > * 3 .
@; B ; P * J *2
> B 3* .....3
> l 3 * 2 .
]* B .U
* * ]* . O C l* .
@* *C *C * * U
* 2* .....
B .3 . 3 H
* *@ .
U .
P * P@P B .C
; * * B .
* . .
; B .C
3 B l2 J* 2
J 3 * .* 3* ; >
* .* J 3
-J * ....3
* B > * 7* @ J
;* . *) Norman Finkelstein * O2
; ( The Rise and
) Fall of Palestine *( :J
Z R+ .+
Z y y
L
Z Z
127
Y y
+ S +.
- 3 O -
; ) 3
*(.
* * ;
* . ;2 Le Monde Diplomatique 32
)( ; 3 3;
* 3 * ) Across Borders * (2 @.
* 2 ;
*:
P C
* . ;.
B * .U P *
126
) (
* 7 22 * .
* J* 2 B ":2 ) 2 2 c(
. J H B 2 ".
*> ; ; B
.
* O e P
* * 7 * * 73
*2 O .
* * . * C C
J 3 :
.
p S
S
.
Y
R
) #o
(-
*
O
* . @ P
O *
* C
* .P *
* > )- 3
* .( > *
*@ **
B P * 3* 2
129
R+ Z ) WZ
R+ (.
** P O 3 H *
* B 32 ** . * ; P 32.
B * . @ C
* ; " U "* .
B 3 P2* 3.
* ; B C* 2 7 U
* 7 U B* . .
* 2* 2 ; * .
* ] B J
O2
J -
2 * .
#
K
2+
+.
Filistin
) (
* B - P
B J - B ;*2 .
* B B K B]
)(
S .
* * J** C* C
2 * . * *>
K
Z
Z
#.
131
* C .
R
B
*** . 3
3 3*) .
e O * . P C
; B B 2 (.
*@ B * * .3
* * B B
* * .3 )( B*
> * m U *B B
* . ;
* * *.32
* B P 2 * J
* . > * . B
B * 3 B m
* * ; * .
> l2 3 2.
* Graham Usher P
* e P * H
:J
* * * .
P C
B* ....... *
* * * * . >
* 2 B * * * . >
130
) (
W. REPORT, 8-9.01
W. REPORT, 4-5.94
Z+ Washington Report R+
I S 8
+
S.
MLL GAZETE, 12.6.01
S
+ K I
= C+ .Z
> J; >* .
> J * > > .
* B ;.
* B ; * H
* . * e .
; *
* * B
.
* B 3
* . 3 ;
* H 3 ) Women in Black C (2:J
3 3 H * H
2 ..... ; ; ;
* > ; * . 3
* ; J ** .2 32 2;.
7; *
B; );( ; ; * . ;
* . * ; O *2*
* * * BJ
* .P H *.
P ;C 3
*.3
Z R
** 3 m 2B *
* 2 ;
B . B* C;
132
) (
S I
+ C
Z W
B.Z
K
Z 2
.
S
S Z
W +.
) (
*; 32 m
; C . * 2*
B * : B * P; .
B B Z
" "* . .P
; :
; *
** .2 > ;
* O *2.
*; ) (
B J " *2" " S
"* . B 3
32 ; 3 P 2 * 3
; > * 2
; * . B O m *@C
2 m ; P J ] *2":
2 S + S . R
+ S Z
+"* . B 2:
; * O] ]
*2 > m
H2 * * * *".
]
* P* " 3* "P B* U
** . ; * 2 P
137
.3 2 ; B B
O; > ; .;
2 * B* .3 >
B c B B* .
7* . *
* B B.
* ; H
. O B H
* B * *2* B
3 2 J
B * B ] * .P
* P
3 . * 2>
* * 2 * ; *
* .J B B 7
* *c
. B ; * 3
* * .
* e BB C ; *
J * .
Le Monde Diplomatique * 7
* ; :J
.... ; * .... P >
; * ** . ""
7 2 *B C *
* * . B C ; .* 22
2B 3*2 C *2.
136
) (
S S I S
.# S I
.
139
B 7 * . * P] *2
; B ;2 B 3 * * .
* B . > H *
3 .
J ;C J * 3 .
* B2
* @ 3 * * *
O . * 2 3) J( ;
. *B
; * 3 B *
* C * B 3 > ;.
* " J; P]
B 3* " * "7 3 3 ] B "
B .
* *@ 3
:J
7 B * ;
. B J
* . 2
B * . B .
* 7 7 B P.
** J
@ * * * B
* J:
B C *
; * * C ; * * .
*
** J3@** .
138
) (
R
S
I+ I+
2+
.
) (
B : )(( :J
* *
* * * * 3
; 2 2
; .
S I S K +.
* 2
* ; )*>
P -* * * @
B 3 3 P ;
* P J( * * 7
2 * 3 * ;
* * C * 2* . JO
* 2 :
* 3 3 * ;
*" . 2
""
; * B O2 " "
3""
* ".
P* ;2* ;
*; P * * .
*) J( Yeni afak :
; 3 B J 2
> .
* ; B ] ;* .... 2 2
143
@; * 7> @ 3
; @ * * ;2* ;2; 2
* * ;B* C *; * P C
* * . ;
* . > ; - H
B ; 2* . J* e P
B * U J *B
* .
S
* U
* . C ; 3
2 B *] *B C;
2 3 .
* ; 32
* . > 22 . ;2@ J
; * * . P B
2 ; l
* *2 ;.
* ; 2 P 3.
P P B
* . H *
O * .P 2
* ; .
* * O* 2 * *
; The Palestine Chronicle ;
3 ) Exposing Israel: A Nation of Colonialists
142
) (
1948 Y +
1967 Y
.
=
.
B * ** * .....J
> * . C2 * J ;
J * . 3 J*
* " * "
* ": ".
> * l * * BP
* J *; ** P B
) 2 ( * > B l C 3
.
* 2 B P
:
" m B O* J O2
H . 2+ 2 2 = S +
Y . + B
B I
.B B B . B
145
B 3 * . ; 3
* * . 2 ;CC
.
* > l
;2* The Washington Report ; 32
3B 32 B J H>
;* . ] * 3 U 3
:J
c c * .
C * . 2
e B * B* . C
.
* 2] * ;
" " * J:
B *C B 32m
e * 2 .U .
P B 32 C
*BB 32 C * .... * C
......
P P c H
C
H; *; B * . > C
; * 3;
* P* c @ . ; * J 3
. 3 ** J
.....J * *
* P* * P* . * 32
2* . *C 32
144
) (
+
ZI #y
p
. S
R .2
147
YEN MESAJ, 7.6.01
+
YEN MESAJ, 15.7.01
S Z
YEN MESAJ, 21.7.01
+
ZI
.# I
.
Y I C
+
) .
S (.
W. REPORT, 10-11.97
) (
2I
S Y
2 I S
Z
Z
C
I...
# 2 # S.
*2 J S ":
. 2 R 2+ Y".
* B ** *2 J
O; * * B 3 P * .
J; J* . J ; *
J J 2 ; J
B 2** . - *J
)2( B B 2 ) O3
(
* .P B C J
m * .l C * 7
* 3; *2 - O P* .
C * *2 J O > B
c .P
* B C* " 2 2" P
B - * . 2
; ; *2 P * *2 3.J
* > ;C ; J * 3
B *2 B * *2* . > C
* * * .
*; 2 *;
. 32 C OO
2 ; "@ ; "
148
) (
* * . >
7 3
* .32 3P
* P * 3P
* J ": C 2
7 * .O
O
; .; 3
C . O
* J c
* J."O
> l* * * * *
2 .
* J P
)* "; ;" ( B .
* 2 ; O
; ; 2 P O
:J
, * * .
c* . - )* 3 ( 2
C C J * . 2 *
J *] - . * B
J * * . *
] B * B ...... * > *
B > * ** J
e > * * . * P C 2
. > *] * S ": Z
151
* "B ; * . e
** .O e
* * . B C C
C J B @ 3
;* . P P *
2 C * .* 3 C
; J 32B H
"B 32" . O * c C
* 3 J H ;
.
*B P * C 3 * *
J 3* .J Sunday Times* 2 *
* B J PC
3 *.
; *
* P * ** 3 * J * U
)( * * * ** . B *
*
C * C e C *
* P P
* *B C C * *
. * J; * P .
* J .
* * *; P
U :J
P . C * .C
150
) (
* . *
* C J B * ""
; .3
* C>
O ; *
- :J
; P C U 7 *
* 2 c . C
P2
* *
3 * .....P ; *
" . # ": 2 ".
* ** B ]
B ) -( C
16
16
1
14
1
11
1
11
1
12
1
9
+
Y
131
496
129
514
132
513
142
506
151
495
174
504
184
535
37
5
41
8
44
12
42
16
44
12
39
16
45
21
IR
737
719
747
761
751
787
757
812
725
820
748
823
813
849
3
4
8
15
5
15
4
11
8
8
10
14
11
17
571
202
557
223
74
248
572
279
574
302
574
291
582
284
18
IR
+ W
10
16
15
8
10
5
10
4
12
16
10
16
11
B Y # Z
R S+
C .Y
2+
2001
2001
2001
2001
2001
2001
2001
) (
155
* .....P ; ; * -
* * P *2
** . U * > .
* J ; C 2 .l
)(
154
) (
S + Y
R .I B Z .
R+
ZI .
) (
; 2 3 * J @ 2 .
B * 3 * ;
> * . ;C 3
* B e c * e O2
* . H 3
* >
; * . J 33
O J ; ; B* ** 2;
*2 J > B O2 * .
* P > * :
" Y 2 R Z 8 S K
C Z Z Z
Y R".
)(
* O * 3 7
B 3 :
...... B 3 ; P H;
B e * O
* e> * ; .
* 3; P
> 22
B
* . 2
J* e ; * * e .
3 2 *2) J( 2
*2 B * J J
159
2+
B* H B J **
* 3 * 2 * .>
B 2 J B; 3 B
* 7 . P
2 3 * O C
B B . P; * B 3 P
2 ; B >
.
J ; 3
* * 3 C m *c
* * * *
* .O ; ; *
* .U2 * * > > *
* C P
H 32 .
* B 3 J * O
@ :
2 P > 3
* * * * * * P O 2C
** . 2 2
.3
* B * H * BC
;
158
) (
C L
*@ 2 2
. * m @ * m *
. O* 2
; *
e * O
I 2+ 2 + S.
161
* * . 2B * 7
; *2 J O B
* . B O
* O2 H 7 .3
S + B
+ Z I
. S Z Z B
+ +
#S .2+ R
= S ZI.
160
) (
R Z#
.I
&
&
) &
+ *
3 2*.
6 6
2
*)
6 ) *.
) (
R +
L
LK
S S
ZI
I .R
) (
p S Y 8L
= + # + S
)(
.
* * 2 @ 3 P
- J 3
* . P @ 3 *
, .
* *; * C J
. * J 2*
2* .* 3 B O *
. J C * 3 O
; * J 2 H
*
2* * . @ * *
B B O @;
@; H2 *.
P H]
* 3 ; *
C B B * * 3 . O
@ 3 - 3; H @ 3
H * * .H J
@ * C U * @ *
J *2* B
J J * B* . J
167
Z
Y L =
# p S .Z
* *
* * .
Washington Report
The
:
7 e . B
R #
166
) (
pS
=
) + R R (
) ( Y ) RR
.(
YZ
* P > O
* * * .P
P 2 P> U
J ) U( * . J
* @ 3 * *
> * .m H
P B B
; U "" *
. B32
B C * . B m *B .
* >2> B " O ".
B ; ;
* .* 3 ; ;
* H@ e J
* . J B P;
; B m * P ; * *U
C H P; .
**2
* * 2 )( P
169
Y #
#.
* H ; B 2
; .
* P *
* * . B .P
* "" C C *
* * l * 2
O . * * *** U
* *> J * C *.
pS
=
) + R( R
*B m* l O B B P
* U *@
* H 3 B
H* O2 *;.
168
) (
3 * . B * 2
.
* B B U *
B * 3 * * c * .H
C 3 * C O;
O* * * .B 7
B ; * * .2 3@* P
* P> , ;
.U
* *; c 2
J* . P *; :
* P l J P
:J
171
S
R +
Y
K
S o
p S .
* U 3
; *
*) J(* .
** .H J
* .C
B 2@J
* ; *B . P
*B P P@B *2 J P;
2 l* 3 * J
2 > * C* c* .C
3 2 * * l ; 3
B* .* J 7 2 *2
* 2 .
* J 2 * @
* B P @ J
* .U *
170
) (
+ 8
R
Z
.#
Z R
Y.#
..... B P ; * J
P 3 m m ;
m > H
.> ; ;
P
3 P; "
H " . ; ;
*; .
@ J . P
; ; * *
> * .
; * J* C J ** 3 .
* ....l2 J ]
@ ": - l
* ".
- B
l *; *2 C
* : 7 O> * .
B " "* .
* .e
7 * B * .*3
l* C@B* .e
*; H * O *
* . B >
P O O P B B
.
172
) (
+
Y . I
2 B
.
175
m 2 *:
> @ 3* l; * * * P
* . B * O2
C * P * .
* * O2 * P>
* J *; B *
J .l J *;
" 3 " * " B" B
* . H ; * " 2 O
B"* m * " 2
P B ; * ;2".
* * J B J :
"B C J2 J"* . *> m
> ": I S
" .
The Independent
* *;
J ": * C
> B
" . P
*2 " J m *B ".
** 7 P> B C 7
* .2
*
* O2 * P* 7
* C * . *B J B
* CO * e
174
) (
SABAH, 3.5.01
#y RZ
YEN MESAJ, 10.7.01
YEN MESAJ, 10.7.01
S #y
ZI
Y
ZY
#y.
MLL GAZETE, 12.7.01
RADKAL, 11.7.01
+
YEN ASYA, 10.7.01
AKT, 10.7.01
+
) (
BORNEO BULLETIN, 25.8.01
W. REPORT, 12.97
Z+
Y #y S
) ( . Washington
Report Z+ K
I Y#y
#S) .R+
( I
+ + Y
# I Z
C
p) .
(
Borneo Bulletin
W. REPORT, 12.98
179
* 3 *2 J*2 * ;
3* . *;
Vilified for Telling the Truth About Palestinians
I am Being
) B 3C
( :J
C 2 *
*
B 2 * * . J
2 2*2B O * .
e * ; 3
*; O2 ; 3 >2
* * B C 3
* O B ; JJ
*B U * "*....."P P* O2 O
e @* c
J J * 3
*2 * ....; 3 2
* * * 3
** * . * O *;
* P* * .New York Times
Orlando Sentinel
JB " :
".
*.....2 * B
. * J ** . 3
B B J
178
) (
; P B C 32 *;
* ** J * O P B * B 3 .
* B ] B .
* ; * 3 B *2 .
P * "* * P ".
* P* * *;
J ": p
p Z
Z
. ".....8
* ; ; 2
B 7 7 * B l
C @ *; * * .
* l l B*
3 @ *; ; * . P
New York Times
; * ]
* O @ C B :J
2
New York Times
C J
* . J O "* C
" J ; "*
* ."C J J *@ 3
* * . * B . 3
* ; *
* ; C P; ) >
181
* lJ
J B U * . )(
*2 ; ;
J 2 .
* ] J J *2
* ".
* * J; C * P
* . ;
L Z
# .
180
) (
* P O *2* C
2 * P * P>
B . 2 *;
* * l * * . 2
J* ;
* * .32
3 > * . .P
** 7 J 2 C 2 .P
* B 2 * *
O ;* .
B C 2
*@ *2 .
> 3 * .....2 * ;
B O C > l
** . O * * B ; .
* "" .
O B
* *@ * *
. e J
*:
=
I
) R.(
183
; * ; 7 * B * C
* ; ;( * J
*
* J ..... >
; * 3
* 2.
; P * *
l 3 . * 2; *C
@ C * 32 ; .
3* * 3 J
* 3 l; 3 ; 3
* * *@ 3 C
* P l 3 :J
182
) (
+(' $
: .
7
6 ('
: D
(
:
:?
: G
L K(.7
L
K
7 K
?
:
('
$ V
7
: .
L : . K 7( Y
7
?
:
Y$'
" Y$ "
( '
$ +
b:: . ($
:
? : (
e:f V(' $(
G: .
:: ($
V
:
(': .
:
Y
:
?
:
: g
:
: K?
:: e$ ?
: .b7
K
g$
Y$ j
Y.
: l
$
. j
Y$
(
185
:
) (
: q r:
q
: . V
Y$
7
Y:
V
q
$ : G( Y
g (
K :
Y V
Y: V( (' Y:: .'
L(': $
: ($ () V :$ Y7
Y
Y
g( :
b(
:
.L
$:
V $ 7 : G : .
K
Jerusalem Post
Y$
7
b( $.
g$ K:
(
('
: Y$ $(
G : . $
7
V
( e +
(?
( :7
.V
: L
G V
e '
: L :$.
:
G L
L
V:' ( 6 .
6
7 $:
V7
?.
g$ Y$ Y'
"
"K V
: K
:
: .
L +
K
:$
:$
.:
b
q
Y$
V.
187
(
. l
7
-Y
(
L
' -
L
?
(
:(: .
( Y
K
l
G Y$
: .e
l $
l
:
$
K
: .
V:7
$
0 *
0
;
@ = 0
.
) (
H E
= = $
. J
0
Q
= 0.
) (
:
L K $
(
:
VK
:
( . '
( G '
r(' " ( "Y (
Y:
r
K
L
7.V
:
G('
r V
.
:
L7
r
:
(
.L
:
G K
$(
L?
: V
(
.
l
191
) (
$ V (
Y: V: $
) L
( $ .
V'
:
V
(
(
:.L
Y
7
$ Y
6 :$
: . r:
('
$ Y
G :V
: .... '7
G Ll
g(
:
: . Y :$:
:$
:
- Y
( .
:
: V?
Y
(
:
: K
: V'
:
:
: L
:
Y$
Y
(
7: .
l
'
= H
0 H* W
Z E H0 @ .
) (
Filistin
H [ $ *
Z
The Times
b `
0
H= :0
H
H
Z
0
` ) (
$ f
j.
Harun Yahya
) (
6: : .
:
V
Y:77 '
. Y$
Y:7 ': .
L
7V
: K $
7:
'.
:
Y
Y
V
b(
V Y L
(: .
Y$
V
Y?
(
V g
7
Y
$
K K
L
l
?
(
K Y
V :: .
G
L
l $V
) (
( (e
Y VY
( '
(
:
$ Y
7
: .Y
G7
: :
' : V
:
($ :(
Y
(
L The Palestine Chronicle:V
j Y
:
l+
( j '
( q( :r
e: : ($.
W l j
r
j
$ 6
: $
K$ g K
D j V $
$ Y
'7 :
Y (
j
l
+ :
($
(
:
j
6 Y H $
b
0 H * .
l J * l!
197
v l
H
l 0
H
*
@
; )J (.
) (
MLL GAZETE, 18.7.01
H j
AKT, 17.5.01
YEN AFAK, 9.5.01
=
MLL GAZETE, 21.7.01
H
YEN MESAJ, 2.5.01
AKAM, 9.7.01
J H
y
MLL GAZETE, 25.7.01
RADKAL, 2.5.01
H
E H
CUMHURYET, 23.5.01
CUMHURYET, 21.7.01
H
W. REPORT, 1-2.99
f @
W. REPORT, 4-5.93
.*0 H
0 . The Washington Report
b H j$
H H.
) (
Y
: Y$
G :
: .Y
Y('
r
K
( ( Y:
$ r g$(' K
g$ . ( ( Y:
:?
7g
Y
K?
(
r:
'7L
7 : K ?
q e
: q (
6
: .Vr
K
G
:' : :Y$( Y:
: : ( q .
: $ L$
V (' ( (
Y:
r
: .: ( Y: G
V
: Y
7 7
V7
G : ($
:Y
- Y
r: . 6( Y: : G r
'7
: V
L:
' $
. Y$
(' $ $
l
: K ( Y
* J
*
bv l .
201
J f
$ $?
:7:
Y K
D Y$$ V(
(
(
.
:
g
G
( l
(r:
g
?: ( ((: .Y: ( Y:
Y
g
: .
(
: $
r :
$: .
(r
K ( ( Y:
Y Y'
r:
q
: Y(
g 6
: l $ $
b
Y
L
:: .
G
6
:
:$ .b:
r
G
$ 7(
j g Y
: ( Y l
(r
l
.
AKSYON, 14.10.01
* v =
J
Z .
200
) (
0
* = .
l
(r
$ 7(
$ j
K e
:
V
: .
Y ( Y: K
gr Y$( Y: '
r
L :
?
V.e
l =
6$ +
: e Y$
G
q
. $
L?
Y
7
Y
Y ' g7
(
: . )g$
7 (Y Y? :(
: .
V:
(
q 7 $
l ::7 K 7 :
V'
::
l Y
L
Y :
. $ :7 K
$ . K
203
202
) (
: .
6
g
e l
' . 7
Y
: e
Y g Y g
$ K +( $
K g
:l K
G(
. K
: $
?
Y e(
7
: ( $ . Y
g$ 7
G
7
Y$ : . $
?
Y
Kr $
e 7 $?
7
Y
: K
(: .
(
+
.
205
'
: e
V?
K K
$
Y$ K e $
$ .
: l
Y g
: g
+
: )
.(b
G K Y
l Y
b
:
'
: . Y
7 Y Y K
l
'7 l
: .
g
:
: .
7
7
7K
204
) (
H
=
$
.
=.
b
:: l
g
G V
:$ e
$ " $": . Y:7 Vr
:
(
(: $
V K
e.
b*
$ Y
($:
7: .
e: :
l
:: .
7 '(:
K
q
: .
Y?
K
207
$
:
+('
(?
:
: e(:.
:
L $
: V:
: .e
V: V
e :7 l
: K
: .Y G
V
Y e :
:$
L 7($ -
:7 (
7 $?
7
Y :
b
206
) (
? 7 :$: . $
Y j ' : Y$
0 =
.
:
Y
L
K
. Y$
L
G( L
G.
: K L
GL
$
l
:
g
Y:.
:$:
G
L
l
"
) Armed Forces
L
(
K ( ? )$( . V:
209
j * = .=
E *0 .
208
) (
K$ g (
K
: . ( $) ? ( $
' : $
l
Y
:$ .
'
:
b +
'7.
: ) (
( (e$ V:(
g7 6 YY
K
.
:
j
g
:
e
. $: Y( G
$: G
:7 K
+
: .V:
L
: V :
j
g
e
:: . K
K
K $( $
7:
: .
G7 g$ 7 K
r $
: : M- q
(
: .
G7
: Y Y: V
$
q
Y$M-
"
"
$
?
: .
7 l
: g ' ': . +:
V
g " K
": .
K $ ?
g7
(
(
G
.
:
L
(
)( (e$ V: q $ $
(
:
$ g G:: .
l $
.
: ' :'
G7
V:
7: Yr
:
: : Y$ Y:
: .
K
V:
Y
7 (7$
$
K
'
- 7 $:
+K
211
b
0
0 . *
J =
= .
210
) (
$ L.
Y
:
L K
: .
7( Y
:
r(' (
Y:
r '
K
: .
L $ ( Y:
$
r '
: .(
: K
L
7 ( Y: $: 7
(: Y: V
r.
=
K:
$ ?
7
Y
V
L:
:
: L
(': . G
$ :
$
) .
r ':
G(: .(K
L
L
:
(:
7 ( L7
r:
+
: . $ +
L
:
b
:(
L
b
:
K(
:.
:
g
Y
Y
? (
l
(r
$ 7(
j (:
L '
:
:
Y .+
V
(?
: .q:
E b . .
$
V
Y $
:V
7 g$ l . Y: V l
$ : . $(
L
: 7
V
213
YEN AFAK, 10.6.01
MLL GAZETE, 15.5.01
AKTEL, 3.9.96
0
Jj
$
W
0 $=
. l
Z
=
.
) (
=
SABAH, 21.10.01
$
.
` =
.
: (: e:f (
q6
: .
: ?
.
: j $ (' (7 $ r
l
6
$ g
( (: Y:
K
7
g $ g?
e
6 ":V = j .
.
b b "
:( K
Y$
7
:
G
:
.
(
K $
$ Y$ $
: $l
$ Y$: ( l
Y:7 .
Y$
l
7 : (
.L
:
Y
L( :
l Y
l )
(
: (e$ $ . q' Y
L( : l Y
l
: . b
q
$ $: .
L: .
g:
: L
L
l
: .V
Y
.
:
( : .
K
l : K
: .
: : .l Y$
(
( Y(
( :
( .
Y$
7
$ b
(
(
( e 7 L . $
b$ 7
$
( 7 (?
$ :7( $: .
K:
$ l7
( .
214
) (
J 0 * *
. *
b= 0 E .
E$
$
0
* :
*
G( K
:': : Y $
( e '7(:
:
$ .
(
L
: Y
$ .
G( K
Y$
7
Y
$
: l
:$ L
.
: $
(:f :(
.
Y$
g g
: l
?
(
e:f: e(: $ l.
$ +
(7 $
Gallup
) (
@ =
*
H
*
J0
HDIP
.
)www. Hdip.
(Org
0
v b
11.7
151
15
10.7
138
16-18
51.0
656
19-29
13.4
171
30-39
5.3
68
40-49
5.7
73
Z
0
25.7
330
18.6
240
4.8
62
38.8
499
7.2
) E 10;
J (
) E
J (
24
K 7
r
:
(
Y$ V:
(
: .
Y$
L
(
: $:(
K
Y$
Y:
( e
$
: g7
:( .
G(
(
e
$ .
l
:
7( Y$
: Y$ :
219
) (
l :
H 00 j : 0 b
. b H 0 E
b H $ $
H ; 0 @ J* *
j; 6.
$ :
7
: .
(
Y$ l
? Y$
:7 (
(
: .
7r: V
q
$
$ : " : @
. W
. "j
Y
:
Y:7
G
:
V -
'
'7
.
G'
: 7
7
$
l: .
r 6
7
:
7 7
G
:.
(:
l
(r
( (
Y:$ g
(
r
$
'7
Y
.G
( Y:
(
:
lg
Y
'
L
+ :
: (
g : .( Y: (
:
220
) (
SABAH, 22.5.01
= EJ @ j E
TRKYE, 11.6.01
AKT, 17.7.01
b
YEN MESAJ, 7.7.01
J 0
YEN MESAJ, 15.5.01
= 0 J
CUMHURYET, 12.7.01
y
RADKAL, 19.5.01
J J Z
YEN MESAJ, 19.7.01
* J
J Z J .
) (
MLL GAZETE, 6.7.01
J
YEN AFAK, 20.5.01
ZAMAN, 19.9.00
ORTADOU, 25.5.01
0 J *
TRKYE, 15.5.01
J 0v J
NEW YORK TIMES, 30.7.01
W. REPORTS, 1.96
LOS ANGELES TIME, 29.7.01
IMPACT, 7.01
MIDDLE EAST, 7.01
J J J Z =
*0 EJ J b
. b @ 0
:
W :
: H J .
:= b .
J HJ : * *.
J : .H
) (
b The News Tribune J
J
= [ .0
@ .
Herald Tribune 0
.@
[E .
THE NEWS TRIBUNE, 14.8.01
I.HERALD TRIBUNE, 11-12.8.01
SEATTLE POST, 6.9.01
CRESCENT INT. 1-15.11.01
Seattle Post j
* l . Crescent
International 0 H J J
J b *.
THE NEW YORK TIMES, 24.8.01
THE NEW YORK TIMES, 21.8.01
THE NEW YORK TIMES, 20.8.01
W 0 0
b j * . 0@
@0 H .
E H Q H
EJ . = : 0
H =.
) (
' : $:: .
G V
b
b '
: 7 L '
Y$ l + : .
(:
g$
:
: .
V ( L $ $
l
: b
V
'
(:
.
: Y$
'
(
Y q $
q V
:
:V
J j H J
H . j
* E *
.j
$ : $ $
(
(
L
$
K(: L( $ $ (f
l
l
Y
:
"
L ".
229
( e
: .
( g g'
(: Y: + :
( Y:
7
.
: 7 )
((
: 7 $
( : l Y
(
Y
: .7
: .L
: : . $ V
:
.
: :(
7
:
G: :V
7
:( K
Y " . Y$ Y Y$
$ l
" G
'
.....
Y
$
: .V
'
Y$ '(: Y b
e
Y$: :
: ...
?
: ( :7$ Y:7
.....K?
228
) (
7(:$ G
Y
( e
?
$
V
(?
e
Y$: :
(:
7
($ : .(
g7: ?:
L7 :
V l
(
$:
q
( e
: Y L
(? G +
l .
:
(:7
?
: :
.Y
:
:
l'
7
:
:
G(
: .
Y
l
Y '
: V "Y
* *0 j 0".
:
l
Y
7
(
: '7
(
:
b: .g
)
g
(
:
'
:
Y :
(
L
'
( '7
(
'
: .(' $ +
Y
g7g:
' 7: .
7
:
:
:
l
?
Y$:7 K
=
=
j* * :
J
231
J 0 Q * .
l .
H 0 .b
J H
*0 H 0v W
J
=.
) (
: Y' : .
K
b
:
$
: g$( Y:7
:
: 7
'
:
:
:$.
:
V
:
f
b
= j J
)* *(
Y
Y$
:
:
( :
H
l
b
)* *.(
Y$: 6 G
L Y$: Y Y
: Y$: (
7:7
: . Y$ :
Y$'
+
: Y
: .l :
:
6:
" :V
:('
'7:
Y K
: e
? :
(".
Zf
L
l K :7
b
g
Y$$ G: K
(? .
Y$
b $
Y .
V7
e
:( : Y$
G
b'
? :
L: q Y ( ($: . Y$
Y$:
Y$: V
:$
:
Y:7 7 $.
: 6: Y
K "
"K
.
L
Y
b K
: K :
( . : V
Y:7 e :
: K
V $
: V 6
K
:
232
) (
Y$
': .
D ( Y
V
(
:(
Y
G
: L
l
: 7
g
.
:
$
V
G
L
l $ Y
G (
: .K
(7
Y :'
)
:( + $ Y$
b K
l
: .
l Y :$ (
Y) V
:( '
V :
b( :
$ ' V
q" : 0 HJ .
b .H .
" . . : Y :
" J .H . b .
* "
:
: $7 )
:( Y
Y$
L
Y Y$ g$ Y7 : .
Y$7
g
.b :
J
('
' )
(
7
: V . Y
Y$ :
$
q
: V
(
:
: g: . G $+
Y
: K:
J
J
)( H
:
: 7 l
G
7 .
g
G $
b Y Y$
7 $:b
: V
.V
: $
?
Y$ 7? ' ' $: e Y
235
?:
: :
: .L l
r
Y
7
Y
: 6
K
.6:
: Y
Y$
Y$
('
Y (?
Y$:
K
:
b'
:: V
K Y$: . Y$
b
:
7
Y
L
l
:
:: .
q
Y$:Y
'
:
D
Y$ : V
:
J
J
) Hf.(
b 0H
0
J
)(
G
$
l
. :
L
: l
:
V
:
: .l) V
:( $
:$
7
( : V(
.
:
:
' Y$
Y
L(
Y
: V
: V
: l: .('
6
G L :(' )( ( :(' $ +
g7
?:
L
: . :
L
l
7
(7
Y$
Y:7 '
: Y$:
$ Y$: V
Y$:
: .() .
Y$
G
L
l 7:7 $
$
234
) (
7 V
(
Y$
Y $ ?$: .
? Y
'
:
V
:
: .K
Y Y$ +
L
' .K
$
? V :
K V
? :
Y$ V:
$ l
?:
=
j
=
f EJ
j
$
)* *(
*
:
G K V L'
:$:
:
: 7 $ Y
7
L
K6
: . Y
Y
$ L
?
.l
:
G?
Y
(
$
?
V
:: .
:
:
(: .
6:
Y
-7 6
'
Y
: -
:
'
'
:
(
.
Y$
: $
? Y$:
:
$ $
? .
Y b
Y:7: K :7: g7
0
)J(
J
J
0
J
)(-
237
H
f
= b
b H
H
.
236
) (
GZC, 3.2.02
MLLYET, 3.12.01
J Zb
ZAMAN, 28.1.02
J 0 b
.j
:( Y
L
Y
Y$
Y
:
'
7: 7 $ 7 $? ' .
$
L
: V
) . $
7
(Y
V
(: .
Y$
$
q
Y$: V7 7
(
L
:
$
b.Y
=
L
l
K
(: .
L L
K $(
7 Y$
K
L( .G
Y$K
...
$ .
:
)
( l
K :
( .
Y g
$ Y
.K) V
:(
Y$(
K
Y$:
G( :
$' (
: ) : V +7
( +7
$
:
G G(
$
: '
G (
$
(
G
:( .(g
:
:
g
Y( : l
L
(: -
e$ l $
b Y : .
Y$(
G
L g7
7.
Y?
:
G
:
Y$(
Y :?
(
K
:
: .
(
L(
G(
V
?
G(
.?
(
g g
238
) (
$ $( ' V
Y V: Y: Y
7
l
: L .V
V g
.V $ L .= =
$) ().b( '
YV:
.(BBC News, aralik )(
: ?
V
Y ":g:
Y
L :
::
"
: .
K
7
l
Y :
Y
G L
":V
q
: l ."K
(
$ (
Y( r g:
l
L(
b: Y
:
V
Y$
6
l
r
$ $ :V
$ $ Y
l D
K $: . Y
Y Y
Y
$
.K
: $
7
l
Y$
$ '
$
b: .K
L
+ '(7 $
: V :
l
":Y$ Y( L Y
: ."K
:
G
+
l:
( g:
:' .
(
b
g
V:
K .
(
.e
:(
.
(
(.
g .
$ V.
241
r
7
:?
V g ' ?
' :
+
Y
$
.
: 6
G
l
: L
( q $
l
l
:$
.
:( Y
L
V
$ New York Times
G
L
l' $ r
g$
l
Y:
($ l f$ Y$
L K
L
.
l D
Y
:$
Y ....
6
K :7
(
: K'
:
(
:
:.....
Y
:
Y
(
l .D $
(?
l
Y
$ :$ :$ :$ Y $
l'
Y K
Y: .....Y
:
( e
($ f$ Y
$
f:
$ $e
$ Y$ Y$
l .K
: Y$.Y
b J
l
(:
l
L( 7 K
r
G: .L
r
K g: ( e$
ll
K
r: .
Y
g: g
( K
-
$?
V
V
L( :V
240
) (
STAR, 11.3.02
J . f
j 0 j = . $=
b b J l
=.
Z f
$
V
?
Y$K
b Y V:
V
g$: .: (
$
b: Y V " ?
"L :
'
-
: : .
:: :
' l
L
Y.
Y Y 6: : .
$
(
:' :
: .'
Y
:'
(
Y:7 g$ .
Y Y .
L
'7
:$
: .g(
'
$
K
: .
g
K
(f + ? $: V $ Y:
:
Y
+('
:: .
G?
Y$
: .
Y:
Y$
r
7: g q:
g: .
Y
(7
(7
: b
:
: : : j $b
.Y
:
Y
g 7
:
g
: . Y$ K
l Y
? :
K 6
q
: . L G Y Y$
(:7
( : +
$
b
K $ (:
: :
$ : .:
242
) (
('
$
l: ....
Y$
GL
K
$
K
Zaman, Eyll () .
)
$ Y( V
: $
7
:
(
b Y Y
l
G
:7 L
r : Y .
'lV
?
: L
Y
( $
b Y
Y .
:
G?
b Y
:
? $ 6
K
:.6
: Y
G (:7 L( r r: '7
V
(
: eL
::
: $ '
. Yl
e Y
K 7(:
: Y
YK
7
: K :
( 6(Y$ Y
: L Y
L( :$
V
) : Y $(: .
Y $
$ q
L
V
L
+ : V
: . Y$
G
g
b
.
Y
?:'
Y
) K
Y(
:
L
Y
: $ L :' $
Y$ +
:
: .
'
6
'7
$: Y
: K
:
:
:
:
.
V
l
$ Y$ l
245
0
=
Z f
W
= 0.
Y
('
:
: .
L
b
: Y K
L
:$
7 K
(
(
: .
:?
V:7 Y:
(: .
Y
G: .:V
Y
L(
7 K :
$: .
G
+
....
Y . $(
G Y$
:
6 :$( :$ K
:
:$ .(:
Y
Y
V
7$ l Y
: .K
Y Y$ : Y
:Y
244
) (
0
J EJ
J
J
J H
* :b
K
Y$(
L L
7 + r
'7
:
: .
(
L
' Y
'
l
: L
($
: : .
l
:$ $
K
.
$
K
'(
7
Y$
G '(
7 '
"
L
" .
L
'
:
: .K
G $?
:
Y$$
::
g
: V
: '
:K
Y$
.
G Y ($
7 Y'
:.Y
Y:
K
b: Y$
:
$ 7 Y$:
Y$ Y:7 e
Y:7: l
:$: .b l
Y . Y$
K
$
: .'
:
:( Y7
Y:
.
: b
l
G7:
:
(
:
: L
: .
7r7
247
: K
g
:: q: .
K g K
lg
:
: q Y
: 6
: .
Y$
q Y . Y$
: K
g7
.
: Y K
V K
: V: '
:
'
b Y
.
0
J
J EJ
J
J H
)* ( b
:
Y$
(
K
:
e
'7
e
: V'(
7
: '
: V
'7
($: .
(
L
' ( :
G .:
Y$
:$ K
($
: . Y
6
7
l g j
($: .
Y Y
:
L Y :7
TIKKUN=
.
= $
= W
.
246
) (
0 * *
f j . $ .
@ * b 0 .
*
= .
= .= b
7
: 7
Y
K
b
:: .
V Y
Tikkun (
L
'
K (
V
: L
: . K
- g
V
$ $: g7
: '
7 $ - + YV
b:
$: .b
K
$ 6
r j
K
g.
: (
V
Y
e $ $
K
b:: . V
Y b Y V
( " Y
K
$:
K
$: "
Y$(7 Y:
.
l
r:
Y
Y$
: . Y$
:
( ' :
.V
Y l
L
$
: .V Y Y V $
:
:
=
=
) j* *(
J
Y
7
?: .
$ +(
' $:+
f
b
=
j
J
)* *
(
= .
248
) (
:
K
b:
K g
7
G: .L
G Y$ K ($ e :
:
7 ($
Y$ K
7
: Y Y$
.(
( :: 'l
: 7
:
(:.
7
:$ l
6 Y Y:7 G (
(
:) g7 $
L
L(
: ?:L
': .
G(
7
Y
:
Y$ 7
: 7$
:
:
Y$:
'
K.V7
V
K
:
K:
'
:
:
7 Y :7
: L' '
: 7g
.K
Y$ :
K
'(
7 $ $ Y
K
G
( L(' L :
: .
V:7
" 7
"
. Y$
7 Y7 j
Y
:
$ (
L : . 7$
Y
g
Y$ 7
7
(:
:
.
251
J
J
0
* j= = J H .
Qv H= Z * J j *0
J .
. $ . J 0
b ,.
250
) (
&& 3 & &
& & 7 &5&6
&& >& 3 & & 7
& & & & .@
& & 7& 7& & &
& & &.
@ & & Q P 7N
& & && 3 .
&\ & 7&[ && -& && 3
> & > & & & .
&& a_ & &_
>& & 7 & "&& 3 &"
.& P 7 >& "&"
&.
f & "& & &"
& \ & 7 & &
7 >& > " " && .
f & &> 7 a& j &
& & > & k
a && & &
253
# $
) (
& 7 & &.
&\ &6 & & P &> a& & &&
& &6 & > > & &
&& 7& & & .k &> P&
& P6 _ 5 p@ && .
f & &.
& >& @ & & && &
7 _ P[ " ." >
>& & " v " P a &.
> & & & & >&
& & j @ &.
#
j 7&[ && & && 3
.& 3 7 & &&& - & &7
& & 7 7 & P&[ > a > .
>& a & &
& & & & z
& &&[.
& & & > P& && &.
& 6& & & & -
& & & & . & &
& & N & . 7[ & &
&&6 7
255
4 0 0
# #
=.0
& 5& P "
") . && :
& & & 7
.(-.p
&& & & 7
@ 7>" N&
&6
&" && . 7& 7
& .P & & > P & &&
>& & && .5 & &
& 7 NQ 7 7 & 5&6
j & 7
& 7 7 & && & &.
7[ & p & a @ . @
& & && 3 . & & 77
. @ >& & P P& &a
& & &[ & & . & 7 &&
254
) (
B
#) 04 ( =G
)# ( H
# .
& & & j .
& 7 & & >&
"&& &&" . && 7 & @ v
a && . & & & &
& 7& 3 j@ & . & 5 > & &_
> & & & & 7 " ." B4
)& _ & _ & & ( . > & 7
& & 7& & )( &.
>& _ >& j @ & & >& 5
257
& & && P & . & & & -
& & & & &
& && @ & . P
@ & .
7& & & v& > & j
& & & P & & & &
& & & .
@ & & >& >
& && .& 7& 5 > & P
& & P@ & && &.
7& & 7 7 >& 7 _-
&& a & & & . @ && &
& & 5 & >& .
" "M
"&& &" & >& v &
&> .& & P > "&& &&"
& . & f & &
& >& . &
& & & & && P 7
a && 3 . &
& & v & >& > & .
& & > :& &
&& 3 & j 7 .
256
) (
# #% #
% International Socialist Review* % #( .
& &[ . && &
[ . v >&
[ & 7& &[ _ 7 .
>& & & @ 7
7 & .& & > 7& @ &
_ 5 & 7 && j& .
f 7@ & & && v
& k .p
& 7 &5 5 P & k
& & 3 . @ && v 5 &&
& & .
259
G 0 0 # 0 0 0G
0 B ) .0 # (
4# 4 S R.
258
) (
& P ":P & >
& & & 5 .
& 7 & _
. P& 7 @
&" . P> P& Q" : 7
6 7 6 .&
@ 7 & 7 & 7 z
.
& . 7 z & >
. z & &
> P& & "().
& & >& &
& & . & & & & & 7& &
&& && & v& N & .
& & & P && & & & j &
& & .j & 7[ & 7& j
&& j & 7& N . 5 >& 7 &&
& & & 7 && 3 & & & .@ &
& & :
& a& P . & @ & a & &
& 7
&> P& & & & @
& a && & & .P@ & a v & :
&& a& && & & & & 7 & & &
&& k .& 5& P @ && 7
@ &"().
& @ &\ 7 & & z 7
& . & && 3 & z& & >&
&f . 7& && & && &
.
0 :
& & & && 3 & P\ &
P . @ & > @ &
& & & & &P
& " j " .& 7& j > &a
& && & & & 7 &
& . & 7 & & 3 >
& & . 7 & && && 3 7
7 7 & 5.
7 & v & & 7 j > 5 & .
& & &_ &
j > 3 &
& . & & >& > 5 & && &
& a 3& >
& & @
& & .& 5 & & & & &
& 5 & > && a& && & & &.
& 5 & & && " 7 7& "
_ 7 7 && " >& _ & k >&".
&& 3 & & & &
":
7 & & && a & 7 _
& & & &&& &6"().
5 & 7 > P& & v &&
& & && v_ > & >& P . & NP
& & & 7 & >& 5
> & & >& 5 & &
) (
YEN AFAK, 22.7.01
M M
RADKAL, 19.5.01
# F16
AKAM, 30.3.01
M M
MLLYET. 14.7.01
# U
[ M
& ) 6( && &[ &
Janes Defense& & & 7 "&" .
& & 7 && & a _
& & F F& P & & & &.
7& j && _ && &
v.
&& CBS f & & @ & & &
& & . v & & &&
: & && & &_
& & & 7> . & > 7 N&
& & & & & .
& CBS &f & &:
& 7 & P & &_
k 7 & && & & &
&&().
> f 7 7Q P 7 & > v 6
& & _ > >& & . &
& && & a j " N ." 7
7> P& 7 a & P & .
> 7 @ 7 & j 5 & &
>& P v& > P a & . &_ &
& & v & @ & a & v &_ >& :
& & & & .& 7 7& v .
& 7 k 7 7 7 7
&& > 7 & . & & & 7 &
&& & "P & & & "() .
1- Daniel Pipes, Mitchell Report Missed It, The Washington Times, 30 Mays 2001
2- Aluf Benn, Israel Braces for Mitchell Report, Haaretz, 24 Nisan 2001
3- Yeni afak, 25 Mays 2001 4- CBS, 12 Temmuz 2001 5- The Independent, 13 Ekim 2001
) (
v .v & P && & &
[ & k . P & &:P
& & & j &f && j & .k 7 R
0 H
. a G ] H4#
.c
> f & 7 & & &
& && a& . & && 3
7 & > .
& 7 && & 7 ">& &" & &
& & 6 & . & >&
> &> k && & &
& "& " > & &
&& & 7& 3 _ &.
e
>& 7 & &&& P : & & &
& & P . && P & a& 7 &
& & && P&
& & & & a 7
& & & > & & &f . & 7
7 && . 7 > 7 & &
& && & . ) 7& (5 &.
& 7> 7 & a & 7 v a 7
& & 7 7.
265
B $ 4
#
&\ & & & &
&& 3 & k> .
& 7 & & & 3 3& & .k
& P &&& & & &.
& & & & & .
& @ > 7&
"& P " & 7 7@ & & 7&.
& & & .&
& & & &
. 5& & >&
& 6 && & . > f & 7& &
&& &
& 3 6 & && . > f 7
&z
& & 7& & >&
& . v& 7 3 "& &
&" &5 & &&.
&\ >& & > )( )() (a
P6 . 7 &[ &
& k & 7[ & && . 7
> 7& & & & [ 7 &
& 7 5 && & .&5
& & @ &.
&& z& 5 & k 7
264
) (
@ & a 7 & && 3 &
& & & 7 .& P
& 7 > & & & j
& .v 7 & & k & " &".
P " # B c "& . &
&& k & & 7 7 &N
> & & N & a &
_ . & 5 7 7& 3
& & & . k > & & & j7
&& 7 && & 7 7&& .& && p
&& 3.
; ;#
### .
G# ( ;#* ( # =
( *
#( O # *.
M /
M /
M /
M /
M /
44
) (
.
+ ) . "
+ 4 0 +
6 4 .
> 7& && & &_
& &&
&
f.
& & &
@ && &
& &
7 && &
&& 3.
& 7 & && _
&& &
& 7 - &
v
&& @ & & & z
& & > & . k& >
& & &&-& &&- . 7 a@ &
& & > & .
& & & && 3
& 7 & P & & .3
& 7 v
& & && &
.
& P & & 7 & & -@ >
& - & & & &
&& P j & &
& & 3 & .
268
) (
& & f & 7 && :
& 7& j & & &
& & > 3
_ 5 .
& 76 P&6> 5& 7
& 7& 7 .@ & &
& && . &
& & &.
& & &
& a 7 & 5
_ f . z& & N
& & 7
. @ && z&[
&& a . && &
& & & & N 7
3 >& . >& &
&& 5 &
[ & &
& & >.
& 5& 7 7 &
& 7 & &.
> & & _ & a > 7&
j &
5 _
) (
7" P" & & >.
& & & 5
&& 6 & & &
" & ".
& " 7 &" && v
7 & & & > [ &
& & 5 & & && v & &
& & @ & v && k& & &&
> & @ > & & & j N
&_ . N @.
& 5 @ 7 & & j
& & . & P & &":
G =
= ) . && "( 5
#
& 7 v.
%
V
*
Z Z
# V
*.
273
R
#
# Ba G
G
)H
(
& & & & &
& & & N . & &
& & _ & v & && &
j.
&& 7& 7 7& v &
&& & p & && . 7
& & & p && k &.
& 6 &&
& & & P . f 7 && 5[ &
6 & 7 _ & . && 7 &5
& & P && & 7 f . && P& 7
&& k & &_ && & . & &&7
& & j &> P & & > & _
> & & .
& & . &5 @ & 7
&& 7 7 5 && j5
&& P 5&6> .& & 6_ 7 v
_
":P &f 7" . 6
7 @ 6@ & .
272
) (
R
# R
R . e
.R
[ :
274
) (
" . * " "!
- -
!" C A -? -
" ! !
* -!.
" A A N -
" "" .
*
-* .
" " A
Z -
\ " . [
Z
Z
" "! " .d !b -
-
" .
"!e
!" A " ! Z
Z " .C !
b A .
Z -
b Z A* " . "
A k !" . A
-" - . -
l - * "
:
:
) (
! A"
\ !" . Z
" A " " k
.
" - [ -? " -!
" .
A " A
" A!
" e A Z A
[
A -
-"! l! - N b b
b! o
A
b
! . b
A! \ !
A Z N Z
! "
"
" . " -
! A" .
\ * :
v \ ! l! ! o"uZ
"
A
x A
b "
Filistin
!" . ! v - F - " ."
x [ b! !
.
A . -
A ! "!* " "* "*
"" o " d -F
A -
. ! -
A\
\
! " . [ *
N A!") o
!
( "! -" N.-
"
A A " A
A
A Z A ! Z
" - Z! -b N [ !" .-
- e Z N " \
A! "
! -
b A .
\ Z
"
! " " . Z "
Z" . Z [ - \
) (
A O
>
U* OOT
V
.
[
k! k *
*
A&
" =
" . *
>
" [
N [
" Z l A Adam Shapiro\ !*
" ! :
Z
b
Z b" .[
A - A
.
u A A
A
" " ...
!b v A! - " Z
"
-
b" .d x
"b "A! " .
A b "
. ? -
" -! " . "
A !e !"" A ? " ! o
281
\ O O
_ * * .
O ` A \ .O
A T
.U
g ` .
280
) (
AKAM, 22.1.02
T\ T
STAR, 28.2.02
A q V
SABAH, 5.12.01
SABAH, 5.12.01
A m U l 30
HRRYET, 13.3.02
s
YEN AFAK, 29.3.02
\ w x =
TRKYE, 5.3.02
A l
=
A T
.
T= \
T l
V
s
.
l
) (
RADKAL, 21.2.02
{ OO=
ORTADOU, 5.3.02
A >
CUMHURYET, 11.3.02
>
V O
T= \ A .
lO The Indipendent
T l
l.
) ( O
The
Observer T \
T :
\
.V
& O
l
.
V The Palestaine Chronicle
\ :
\ . V
_ > . O T l .
O = * > .O
) (
": > A
:l \"" . . [ b b
" .
[ A
k
\ .
"
!* A *
* * "
!
!
.o
! "
" !
" !
"
.
!"
"
! !
" !
" . ! Z
! "*
. *
Z
!
! "*
. !
," A!
") .
A
[
!
A !* (.
[ - "
"!" !b d Z - " bl
!" . - ! "!
" x
- - .
"
d ! " \
Z* l" - New York Times
[" . [ ! b b " " )
! -
( " Z b.
" .
N
" N b" - [ !
" . Z - b
287
Post
l
=
A
.
The
Washington
A
*
.
" .
:
"
.
" . Z!"":A
A !
C[ ...
A" "
b
A
x"" . " A x "
[ l"
": A .
"
. d
\ ! " [
286
) (
l! -
" Z
b l! !"u
.
" lZ
" A -
"
"" . AN
A
A
b
! A
-
UO
! \ !
- Z[.
" " - b
A "
- - -" . [
Z!" : b
" d " A b Z
! " "!C
" Z
" " - * " Z-
-
" A" -!" C
! " ! " . A
" A
*! A " A d !
" .Z
b - " A
" -"
-
! k
" . A* " " b * -
289
l w T
HRRYET, 30.3.02
CUMHURYET, 30.3.02
A :l
" " . *
"
N A [ A N "
!* " .- [
- " -
"
! " ." x A
*! Z " " A
" " .d d [ A
" A C [
"
Z A
" .A [ " N
A" A
" Z "" Z " .* A
Z "
! " . * A
288
) (
" .C
- \ " .Z *
"" "b l C
d Z [ .-
" A?! " A l"" .
* ! " l A
b
A Z! "
A
- " C .
" b A " - "b Z* "" "
d !" .
\ A V - U =O
_ -= . \ = =
. = A
.
291
RADKAL, 2.4.02
A =
RADKAL, 2.4.02
\ _ l
" . A "
d b " .
*
! b
!
"
! Z .
" A [
- "
!" * b .Z
!
!
A
.
-
. Z
d
290
) (
A T
x
SABAH, 5.4.02
STAR, 5.4.02
V l T l = \ x
O . s A
. T T
O * V O lV . *
.
O - A -_ A \
A . O T x O
T = Ag A _ V
T O A x l . A\ O
& A O Tl
A x .
O=
ZAMAN, 7.4.02
l = A lO T OO l
TO T l= = O A lV
l
A . OO T & x l x l =O
TO . O O l . O O
= O O A .
A V
l = . O
A . l =O A &
x.
) (
g = T = A lV
= A . ) = =(
g\ .\ \ l T
. O =s
\ \ g _
T.
"" Z!"
l
.
-
-"
" A" C ) -"?!( * -" .
[ - ! " .v x
b -
" .d[
A Z "
!
295
l
* = . U` \
* O . \
O\ l A Ts > = O O
O . A O
_ \ = .x \ =
. O T.
) (
A
.
b " . ZA
A "[
" . \ A
" . Z" :
A
" " "
! ""
x
b " . "
[
*
! x" . * "
\ ! e !
" . e "
b Z \ . " v
" . * A
"
A b
\ A"
" A" "
! .....
[
!
d
!
.A A
! . Z " "! A
..... *
!" . [
.- A *
C! "
" \
A
\
"\ * !
b A e N[
"" .... Z!
!""l N " k".
" Z e A
A
" Z "Z
6 - .
A C ! " - ! A
" - * ! A A A" .
A
* xb
A * ! -N
Z
b d
" . -! !
\ " A! !
A
"
N.
" b A!
"
"
- Z" .
A A "
!" . A [ " - b
! "Z
b b " . \
[
?" N ! A A ! ?!
" :Z
!
d ! x d b ! !.
" "
"! !b
\
A !
Z .
" b Z! ! "
Z " C
C! " . "b -
Cb A
Z! ?!
"b " b " . * "
! - The TimesZ Children scream for water A
)
Z" A ( " Z:
! ! -
b Z
" . "x
\ "! " " Z
-\ !" . -
.
296
) (
ZAMAN, 9.4.02
A
w
TRKYE,10.4.02
x=
RADKAL, 13.4.02
A
RADKAL, 13.4.02
A V =
299
"
" b -" ...... N\ \
"! . "
x A.
! "
A Z A [ "
" " :- k !
* .
A
A* [
"" .
Z
A
" "
[ Palestine Monitor:Z
!
Z !* !
!" .
o
" " ." x A !
"
A d ..... - " Z "" Z A
A [ Z "
-
.
"
Z A ! .
" - - Z x . Z
The New York Times :
A A A " N .
!u x
. " d[ " .A l
.
"
. " - ! N
b" . x ! " .
\ .
" The Independent
[ " The Camp That Became A A
) Slaughterhouse \ b Z ( :Z
298
) (
Z
* Z b .
b A
" . "" Z N !
! " -" - " .
" .
! - N " C*
"
A[ .
A o * Z! -b N .....
" A A b
-
[ " " .....
A
" - " -
\" .
! ! N -.[x
* b ! C ?" N
A ! "
.....
[ - "! - .-
"
A e!
d ! ! * " .
N[ "* "b" C *
b N " " .
b N - " !
lAe
! " . b
A " * -[
"
A .
301
#
# G.
a 0
4
R 0
0
] = R
04
0
4 .
04 c
M
R
S 0 G
.0
H
=
.
S
04
R
. #$
# G 0
=
H :R
H M
.
300
) (
& & & & j
& f &
& 3 .@ & & 7 &
& & &
7 & & 7& 7 & _
& .6 & & &
& 7 & 7 & &.
@ & v & &
&f & _ & k &
& & & 3 @ &
& 7 @ & >& 5.
&& & P &
& 7 & &.
&&
& & p
&
& 7 & &5 &
& & & P .
& & p& N & 5
&& 5 & & & v7
&& > 7 & &
&& & & 7 7
&& .
& & & .
& & & &
) (
&.
& & @ &\
& &:
:
H
P & 7 &
&
4
&& z& ,
. 7 & & &&[
& > &f 7& &
&f &
& & & P & & > . & 7&& P& P_
& @ && & & 7
"& &."
&& j & 5
& & & & & . @
& & 7 & &
& 7& & & & &.5
H H
& & a& 3 > & . & 7 &&
& @ && z& 7 & &f
. && 5 && & & 7&
& 7 P& & 5 & &
305
j& f P .v >
& & & & &[ & >&
& & .
7@ & >& & &
> & & & 7 . 7
& a & " &&[" &_ .
& & a & & 7&[ & & z & .P
& 7 & & &
& & 6.7
& 7 _
> ">& ."z f & j P
a&&" 7 & & &" & 7 v &
& &.
& Q & & & 7
& & & > 7 @ & 5
@ &.
& & & P \ :
- @ & _ & 7
& &.z
- _ & j P "& &" &
& & _ P &&.P
- & & & & &5
304
) (
> & 7 > & &&& j:
" & & &\ &
& &".
& 7 & . 7
@ & a & & &
. & & && &6 z
&& & z> j & & . P@ &
&& z )& &( & &
&.
> & 7@ &&
& & & _ & @ & 7
&& j &.
& & j & 7& _ &
7 .
5 & > & & 7
.& j& & @
& "& "z :
" & && 7 7 7 & &
& 7 : & &z"
HH
& & &_ & " 36 & "
& 7 & & _ &.
&& & & _ &.
307
f & . & & & @ & & 7&
&& 7 7&f & . 7z
& &
& & 7 7 f &.
& &f 7 & 7& 7 & >
& 7 & 7& 7 & > &a
v & .
7& & & &_ & " a
&&[" 7 & 7 & > 5
7& & & .
& & & &&
k & . P & &&
& 7 :
" 7 && 5 & & &
@ & &".
&& 7 & && & > .
7 5 > & & & &
& & & & z &
36 & .
0 H
> P 7 [ & & & 7 & 7_ &
. & & &&& 5 & f
& 7 P > > & & &.
306
) (
> &f 7 & 7 & a
"" .@ & & & j
& >> & .
& & & & 7 & &
& " " & _ .
& & & & "&5
&" . @ & " : &&[ &5
&"...
P& 7& 5 & 7 & &
& 7 & . & P
&& & & 7& 7& 7& v 7
& & & .&
&& 5 . z &
& 5 5 & 7 7& _ & P&
# 0 B R R
0 H : DNA G
0 #
M # [
DNA 0
#.
G 0 4
a
.
& _ @ 7
P && & .
>& 7& j a 7
.z & & && k
& > & 7
& & _ P !
> 7_& 5 & DNA_ & & & &_ & 7
&& &f . & 7 & _5
DNA
& .
v : _& 5 DNA 7
> & & )&( @ & 7
> & P & _& 5 .DNA 7
& &_ 7&& &
&.& & & 7 5
> . && j _
@ & P[
& & :
" & 7& 7 && z
5 & & .7
> > & & 7 .& & &
& 7& 7 P
"
) (
>Q & & &.P
5@&
& 7 P
& 5 5 & > 7 &."P
> 7 & && & & P7
& && & & .P& &5
& &.
H0
& > P && 7 " "
"&& & " & && 7 .
&& & "&&" & &
& && > z 5
& DNA >& & &.
&& f_ && & &&
& . P@ & & & 7 && 5&
& z 5 & && 5 @ &
&& 7&f& 7 &> _ & &> . & 7 &
&@ & .a& & > _
> & & & &> >> >..
& & 5& 7_ DNA 5
_ & _ . N& &7
&[ :
"& & & & . &&
& 7 & & _
311
B S
G G H G
a .
0 # B $
# . B
# [
S 4
4
.
.
7 P@ & & . 7 7
@ & & &&[ :P
" & 7& 5 7 &
>".
US
@ "&& &" & P &
& && P & P && f & .
&_ & & 7 & && P
>& & P @ & & >Q &[
& & . & &
& 5 && > P & & &
310
) (
& . 5 @ & &.
0:
4 4 R
& _ & & &5
&.
& 7 7 _
& & > v &&[ @ &.
& 7@ & & &.
> &f 7& && z &_ &&[
& & && P . & P
& >
& & . & & &6_
& > && & .
& & &7
@ && P > "&& P"
7 & 7 7 & &
[& . f 7 &
@ && 5 .& P " &&[":
"> &f & & &&[
& & & & & &
&".
313
# G G
a
M
0
0 #
04
# R a M
. H
a $ 0
a
a
0.
& _ & & 5
> & . & & &
& P & & & 7
&".5
& _ a &
& && & . & && .
&& 7 f> && & & & >
& & ) . && & & &
& z .(7 7 7 "&"
"&& 5 " 7 .&
312
) (
&[ P & .P
> &f & .
& & 7 & &
& z& " 7 &&[" &>
.
&[ &_ P& & & & [
& .7 &&& 7 7& 7 [ @
& . P@ & & && z & -
" P" && 7 & @
.7 @ & & & @ & P
:
-&k
- .
- k
-
& 7 & & P " 7& "k"
> a"&. 7& & 3 > & &
& . & && & & & & 6 7
& >& & &
& 7 k@ & > &[ & &
& & _ &.7
& & & & 7 "" &" "7
315
[4 R 4
& & >
& && 7 5
&> & . & && 5
& & & && : &
_ .
& 5& & _ Q Derek Ager@
& :P
& & & & 5
& v&[ & & & &
&> & a
.v
& & 7 & 7 & &
& z & _ 7 &
& & 5& > _ & .& 5
& & & z & 7
& > 7 @ &&[ . @ &
&& 5_ :
"& & &&
& & & .
7& 7&[
& z & .7
> &f & &
314
) (
7 7 . & & 5 _
Stephen Jay Gould & & & >
& _:
&f 7 > &f 7 &
& )& &&& k_ & ( 7
& & > 7& 5
_ P_ P &.z
P 7 & &_ &_ 3
> 7 &_ && & & &
& & & & > k
& &.
& 7 6 & 7 & &
> & j & & & &
p & k
[ .
6& 7 @ " &" & &
& & . 67
7 & "" _ & -
&& 5 5 & & & && &.
& & "& " & "& & &
&\" & & & )& (
"& &_" . N 6 &:
> &f P & & > &
& && 5& & & & &\
317
& 7 & & .k
&[ & 7 @ &
> . 7 & _
@ & & . P & &
> " && &:
" & & & & &
z & & ".
&P&&7&7&:&k
k &.
> & 7 & & & 5 &
7@ & && k
k [ & 6
&.
&
& 7&& 5
&
" "k
z
&
&
& 6 &
& .
& &j
& 57
316
) (
& .& & & 7 && z&
)& P & && .( &
& & & & & @ &
& & & k@ && & 5
& 5 5& & & &
a && > a > & 7
& 7 @ & j
& &> . & 7&
&& . 7& & & & & &
& & && & 7 &
6 & & 6 & && 6& P
& & & & && 7 && &
& & && && 7 &&[ &
.5 7& @ & & &
& &.
& 7& & & 7
&& & &
7
&& v & 7& 5 && & &
& 7 & &f && 7 > . a &
& . & & &
& &> 7> .& P & & &
& 7 5@ & & & f& @.
319
& & && 5
_ & 7_ & & &
& &.
& & &_ > & v& &
& && && p & @ &
.
4
> @ >& 7 7 > 7
& P 7 P@ & 7
5 .
& & 7 & &
& 7& & & & & & 5&
v & & . &> :7
&& 7 && 6 & & &
&& 7 . && @ _
& 7 & & . &
& > &f P & 5 & &7
"& &&"& &_ 7 & > 7
7& :
& 7 & && 67
& & & & & & &
& & && & .& > @ && 7
&_ @ & & & & & j
318
) (
& & 5 . 7 & 6_
& 7 & &f.
& & P & & j &
6 6 & & > P & .
6 & & 7
& & 7&& 5 . 7@ & & & . &
& & .3 &
& 5 &_ &@ & . 7 &
& & &.6
& 7Q 7 7 & & & &
& &_ &> 5 & & . &f> 7
P >& 7& 6 >
& 7& 5& 6_ @ & &f7
! & & 7 & j p
7@ !
& & &@ &
> & 7 &
&& & 7 & &_ &@
& P .7f& 7f &&
& & && 7 7f >& & 7f
& v & & >& & 7f&
@ & >> & > >& . &
& 7 & & & & .
& &_ & _ & .7f& 7 a
& a & 5
321
H4 a
&[ & &_ & 7 6
& & & & & &.7f
& >& [ & 7 6 &P
: &
>& 7 & &
& & @ & >> &
> & & 5 .@ &&
& & & & & &
& . @ & :
&
>& 7 a & 5& 7 &
7 5 > && . &_ &
& & 5 > .
@ & & 7 .
& && 5 &7
& _ & & 7 & .& >
&& a_ && 7& > & && a&
& & && 5 _ Q >7
&& .
& & && 6
& 6
& v 7 & & & .5
Q& j 7 > P& & 5 & &
& & v & & .& >
&& 6 &f >& & a_ j7 7
320
) (
4 4
& &f_ & & &
6 & & >& 7 & & 7
f >& > > . 7
&& 5 && 5 7
& _ _ & &[ :
& &f_ @ && &
& > 7> .k & & & 7 >
7f @ & . &
a .& & &
& && 7 7 5 v 7 & @
& 7@ & > && N & .
> & v 7f & . &
> 7> . & @ &
& & 7 & &_ 7 &
& &
& & &
&f& 7 P 5@ f.
H4
> 7 @ >& 7 & 7 &
> 6 z N & & 6 &
& & & . Q &
323
& & & 7 & .7
& 7 && & . 7 &
&_ > & 7 &\
& &f> . & v &_ & & & 6k
& && 7.
& & & P 7
& & & & .
& & & &&
& & & @ & . &
&Q & j && 5& & > P
5 & &_ & .7f& & &
v & & &
7
& 7 & . 7
& 7&
&& & & & &
& 5 . > 7f 7 & &
. & .&
& & P & &f 7 & > 7 && > .7
6_ & 7 & &
k & &.7f
& & &
&.
322
) (
& & & & & &f _ && 3
& . & 7& & & && .5
& 7& & 7 & &_ " P> >
&" .
> 7 & & f _
j 7@ & && . & >
_f > . & &_ & 7 &
.
& &
#
U
7 7 > 7 7
& 7[ _ 7 &
& & & & v & &
6 v .
& & 7 7 & 7 7
& & 7 7& 7& a & 5
> )& (Einstein Hubble & & )(Frank Sinatra
7 (Charlton Heston) 7> j &7
&6 7 & j 7 & 7
&& & && & & . 7
7& &
j 5 k & &.
& & & 7& " & & " >
& & 7& > f> . &&
325
_ _ . & & 7 & &
& & .@ & &
. 7 & & & & &
& 7 z & 7 & . 7
& & @ & > & k
_ & >& & ! & >7f!
>& 7 & & > 7 6 &
& p > &\ . @ &\ >
& & & && _ & &_
& 7.
7& & j )(Richard Lewontin
& & & & &f _ 6 " _
& & P& &_ " f> :P
"> 7 > >& 7 )& & (.
&& 5_ > & 7 _ & P
&@ & f >
P _ .& > 7
& 7 P >
> &".
@ & && & 7&
& p & .& & z & v .
& & & 7 7 & & > & .7
> 7 &&[ & & & & && &
&& & &6 & 7& P > &
324
) (
& j&& 5 & > & 7 & &
& 5 & 7& & & & &
& 7_ &@
_ & 7 && z_ &
& & 3
v .
& 7 P & &
& 7 7 & p 7 & &
7 & k & . &
& & 7 > 7 7
& .k & & 7 & &z
&& . & @ & :P
G
R
c
)](:
. v 7 @ [ 7&
& k 5 & Q& > . & 7& 7_ @
& @ 5 && & & 7Q "
"7
_ @ P:
#
S a
)]:
(-
& > & 7 & 5& p
& .
& & k & > > & P
& 7& > 5 j & &
327
6 Q & P @ & &
& 7 7 P& & &
& P
& 7 > .5&
& & >&
& & 7 & &
&_ @ f .& & > >
& & & 7Q . & Q 7 &k
& > 7 P 7 & .
@ & :
#
G
M
H
).(- :H
:
[ a
M
)
].( :
& 7 & k &
&
& & && f> P :
#
G
)(- :
0
>& 7& & & & k&
&& & k & @ & 5& &
& &
7 & & p &
326
) (
#
#
& :
329
&& 7 [ j &
& @ &&f & 5
" & ".
N )& (Malcolm Muggeridge_
& & @ 7
& & &_ > v & & &
:
"> 7 & > 7 v& &&N
& & & & .
& & & 3
& z& " .
& & & f & 7 &
& & 7 7 > j && j7
& > &[ & & . 7
& & & & k & 5 z &7
& & 5 7 & @
& .
328
( )
- Encyclopeadia Judaica, vol. , p.
- The Universal Jewish Encyclopedia, vol. , p.
- The Origins and Evolution of the Palestine Problem
-, http://www.un. org/Depts/dpa/qpal/dpr/DPR_pp_
.htm
- British Government, The Political History of Palestine
under the British Administration, Palestine Royal Commision
Report, Cmd. , , sf.
- RIIA, Great Britain and Palestine, p.
- Noam Chomsky, Harold H. Saunders, Temel Demirer,
Ycel Demirer, zgr Orhangazi, Gker zgr,. a &
&fQ & & .
- Badouin Loos, An Interview With Ilan Pappe,
December , www.msanews.mynet.net
- Noam Chomsky, Harold H. Saunders, Temel Demirer,
Ycel Demirer, zgr Orhangazi, Gker zgr,. a &
&fQ & & .
- Uri Davis, Israel: An Apartheid State, Zed Books,
London, , Entrance.
- Noam Chomsky, Harold H. Saunders, Temel
Demirer, Ycel Demirer, zgr Orhangazi, Gker zgr,.
&fQ & & a &.
- Mark Mazower, Sharon Should Surrender to History,
The Financial Times, April
- .p . & &_
- .p . & &_
- .p .& &_
- Davar Newspaper, June
-.p 7 & >& 7& .
- Flora Lewis, Israel Defies Itself With These
Assassinations of Palestines, International Herald Tribune,
331
R
-The Torah Demands Justice for the Palestinians
Presented by Rabbi Dovid Weiss of NKIAt Time Square
in Manhattan on Friday afternoon, June , . http:
//www.netureikarta.org/speeches.htm
- http://www.linguafranca.com//mahler..html
- Gideon Levy, Haaretz Book Review, December
- Israel Shahak, Jewish History, Jewish Religion and the
Weight of Three Thousand Years, AMEU, , p.
- Badouin Loos, An Interview With Ilan Pappe,
December , www.msanews.mynet.net
- The Nation, An Antiwar Movement Grows in Israel,
February
- The Nation, An Antiwar Movement Grows in Israel,
February
- http://lists.econ.utah.edu/pipermail/rad-green/February/ .html
- Karen Armstrong, Holy War, MacMillan, London,
, p. -
- Geste Francorum, or the Deeds of the Franks and the
Other Pilgrims to Jerusalem, trans. Rosalind Hill, London,
, p.
- August C. Krey, The First Crusade: The Accounts of
Eye-Witnesses and Participants, Pinceton & London, , p.
- August C. Krey, The First Crusade: The Accounts of
Eye-Witnesses and Participants, Pinceton & London, , p.
- Karen Armstrong, Holy War, p.
- Haaretz, ,,; www.middleeast.org,, August
330
( )
Monde Diplomatique, Kasm
- Ian Gilmour, Israels Terrorists, The Nation, Nisan
- &fQ & &
- Graham Usher, Everyday Acts of Resistance, AlAhram Weekly On-Line, March - April,
- Gideon Levy, Women in Black, Haaretz English
Edition, January
- Alain Gresh, Intifada Pour Une Vraie Paix, Le Monde
Diplomatique, December
- Alain Gresh, Intifada Pour Une Vraie Paix, Le Monde
Diplomatique, December
- Eitan Felner,En Afrique du Sud, On appelait cela
lApartheid, Le Monde Diplomatique, November
- P 7
European
Parliament
Review,
www.bashirkhanbhai.co.uk
- Report on Israeli Settlement in the Occupied
Territories, Washington, September October
- Ramzy Baroud, Exposing Israel: A Nation of
Colonialists, The Palestine Chronicle Online, www.palestine
chronicle.com
- Ramzy Baroud, Exposing Israel: A Nation of
Colonialists, The Palestine Chronicle Online, www.palestine
chronicle.com
- The Washington Report, December , s -
- The Washington Report, December , s -
- Amnon Denker, Haaretz January
- Human Right Watch, report
- Human Right Watch, report
- www.vahdet.com.tr & & P&
.
333
January
- www.hatedbooks.com/book/.htm
- .p . & & &: _6
- www.hatedbooks.com/book/.htm
- Lemi Brenner, The Iron Wall: Zionist Revisionism
from Jabotinsky to Shamir, Zed Books, London, , p.
- Deot, February
- .p & 7 Q &
- www.hatedbooks.com/book/.htm
- www.hatedbooks.com/book/.htm
- www.hatedbooks.com/book/.htm
- Michael Palumbo, Imperial Israel, Bloomsbury
Publishing, London, pp. - , citing UN General
Assembly: Official Record, th session supplement, nop.
- www.ummah.net/unity/palestine/massacres.htm
- Ahmet Varol, www.vahdet.com.tr
- Robert Fisk, Pity the Nation, Andre Deutsch, Londra,
, s
- Robert Fisk, The Legacy of Ariel Sharon, The
Independent, ubat
- Robert Fisk, Pity the Nation, Andre Deutsch, Londra,
, s
- Le Monde, ubat
- Haithem El-Zabri, Rivers of Blood : A New Sharon
Episode, The Palestine Monitor, ubat
- .p . 7 & . :& &.
- Benjamin Beit Hallahmi, The Israeli Connection, sf.
-
- &fQ 7 &
- Mouna Hamzeh-Muhasen, Isral-Palestne, La
Dchirure, Jours Ordinaires Dans Le Camp De Dheishe, Le
332
( )
a &.,Ycel Demirer, zgrOrhangazi, Gker zgr
. &fQ & &
- Grace Halsell, The Hidden Hand of the Temple
Mount Faithful, The Washington Report on Middle East
Affairs, January
- Ian Gilmour, Israels Terrorists, The Nation, April
- http://www.hdip.org/reports/ Martyrs_statistics.htm
- P &7
- Defence For Children International, Palestine Section,
www.dci-pal.org
- Ruth Anderson, Intifada Al-Aqsa and American
Propaganda, The Palestine Chronicle Online, www.palestine
chronicle.com
- & 7 & >&7 eti,
Zaman, Ekim
- & 7 & >&7 eti,
Zaman, Ekim
- 7 & &
- . &fQ - P@ & &
& &P & &
& & &. -www.hdip.org
- Maariv, October
- Rachelle Marshall, Palestinians Come Under Siege as
They Struggle for Independence, The Washington Report,
January-February , s -
- Uri Avnery, aron: A Practical Manual, The Palestine
Monitor, February
- Benjamin Beit Hallahmi, The Israeli Connection, p.
-
- Roger Garaudy, Siyonizm Dosyas, P.
http://www.bridgesforpeace.com/publications/
335
- Robert Fisk, Khiam Jail, Where Torture is Routine
and By Remote Control, The Independent, May
- Ian Gilmour, Israels Terrorists, The Nation, April
- Gideon Levy, Contorted Bodies and Twisted Minds,
Haaretz, September
- .p . 7 & . :& &.
- Davar Gazetesi, March
- p . 7 & . :( & &Sayfasina
bakilacak).
- Sara Roy, Seperation or Integration, Middle East
Journal, .I, Winter
- Rachelle Marshall, Palestinians Come Under Siege as
They Struggle for Independence, The Washington Report,
January-February, , P. -
- &fQ p & & & & 7 &
.
- 7& &
- 7& &
- Robert Fisk, Easter in the Holy Land: Families Watch
as Their Homes are Destroyed, The Independent, April
- Robert Fisk, Where Caught in Crossfire Leave No
Room For Doubt, The Palestine Chronicle Online, www.pal
estinechronicle.com
- Robert Fisk, I Am Vilified for Telling The Truth
About Palestinians, The Washington Report on Middle East
Affairs, January-February
- Robert Fisk, Truth is Victim As the Same Old Double
Standards Prevail, The Independent, October
- New York Times, September
Noam Chomsky, Harold H. Saunders, Temel Demirer, -
334
( )
. Charles Darwin, : A Facsimile of the First Edition,
Harvard University Press, , p.
. Charles Darwin,, p. .
. B. G. Ranganathan, Origins?, Pennsylvania: The
Banner Of Truth Trust, .
. Charles Darwin,, p.
. Derek A. Ager, The Nature of the Fossil Record,
Proceedings of the British Geological Association, vol ,
, p.
. Douglas J. Futuyma, Science on Trial, New York:
Pantheon Books, . p.
. Solly Zuckerman, Beyond The Ivory Tower,
New York: Toplinger Publications, , ss. -; Charles
E. Oxnard, The Place of Australopithecines in Human
Evolution: Grounds for Doubt, Nature, vol , p.
. J. Rennie, Darwins Current Bulldog: Ernst Mayr,
Scientific American, December
. Alan Walker, Science, vol. , , p. ; A.
J. Kelso, Physical Antropology, st ed., New York: J. B.
Lipincott Co., , s. ; M. D. Leakey, Olduvai Gorge,
vol. , Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, , p.
. Time, November
. S. J. Gould, Natural History, vol. , , p.
. Solly Zuckerman, Beyond The Ivory Tower, p.
. Richard Lewontin, Billions and billions of
demons, The New York Review of Books, January, ,
p. .
. Malcolm Muggeridge, The End of Christendom,
Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, , p.
337
dispatch/signsoftimes/Article-.html
- / P & && &
- / P & && &
- &_ () 7 & &_&
) & & () & &())
- The New York Times, February
- The Washington Report, June
- Robert Fisk, Sham Summit Promised Little for
Palestinians, The Independent, December
- Haaretz, February
- Al-Awda News
- The Economist, March ,
March,
- The Economist, March
- Haaretz, March
- BBC, April
- Haaretz, April
- The Times, April
- IAP News, April
- New York Times , April
. Sidney Fox, Klaus Dose, Molecular Evolution and
The Origin of Life, New York: Marcel Dekker, . p.
. Alexander I. Oparin, Origin of Life, () New
York, Dover Publications, (Reprint), p.
. New Evidence on Evolution of Early Atmosphere
and Life, Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society,
vol , November , p. -.
. Stanley Miller, Molecular Evolution of Life: Current
Status of the Prebiotic Synthesis of Small Molecules, , p.
. Jeffrey Bada, Earth, February , v.
. Leslie E. Orgel, The Origin of Life on Earth,
Scientific American, vol , October , p.
336
You might also like
- The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck: A Counterintuitive Approach to Living a Good LifeFrom EverandThe Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck: A Counterintuitive Approach to Living a Good LifeRating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5 (5813)
- The Perfect Marriage: A Completely Gripping Psychological SuspenseFrom EverandThe Perfect Marriage: A Completely Gripping Psychological SuspenseRating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5 (1133)
- The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck: A Counterintuitive Approach to Living a Good LifeFrom EverandThe Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck: A Counterintuitive Approach to Living a Good LifeRating: 4.5 out of 5 stars4.5/5 (20099)
- How to Win Friends and Influence People: Updated For the Next Generation of LeadersFrom EverandHow to Win Friends and Influence People: Updated For the Next Generation of LeadersRating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5 (2327)
- Pride and Prejudice: Bestsellers and famous BooksFrom EverandPride and Prejudice: Bestsellers and famous BooksRating: 4.5 out of 5 stars4.5/5 (20479)
- Remarkably Bright Creatures: A NovelFrom EverandRemarkably Bright Creatures: A NovelRating: 4.5 out of 5 stars4.5/5 (5720)
- Never Split the Difference: Negotiating As If Your Life Depended On ItFrom EverandNever Split the Difference: Negotiating As If Your Life Depended On ItRating: 4.5 out of 5 stars4.5/5 (3310)
- Art of War: The Definitive Interpretation of Sun Tzu's Classic Book of StrategyFrom EverandArt of War: The Definitive Interpretation of Sun Tzu's Classic Book of StrategyRating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5 (3321)
- The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People: The Infographics EditionFrom EverandThe 7 Habits of Highly Effective People: The Infographics EditionRating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5 (2487)
- Habit 3 Put First Things First: The Habit of Integrity and ExecutionFrom EverandHabit 3 Put First Things First: The Habit of Integrity and ExecutionRating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5 (2507)
- Habit 1 Be Proactive: The Habit of ChoiceFrom EverandHabit 1 Be Proactive: The Habit of ChoiceRating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5 (2559)
- American Gods: The Tenth Anniversary EditionFrom EverandAmerican Gods: The Tenth Anniversary EditionRating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5 (12956)
- How To Win Friends And Influence PeopleFrom EverandHow To Win Friends And Influence PeopleRating: 4.5 out of 5 stars4.5/5 (6538)
- Habit 6 Synergize: The Habit of Creative CooperationFrom EverandHabit 6 Synergize: The Habit of Creative CooperationRating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5 (2499)
- The 7 Habits of Highly Effective PeopleFrom EverandThe 7 Habits of Highly Effective PeopleRating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5 (2571)
- Wuthering Heights (Seasons Edition -- Winter)From EverandWuthering Heights (Seasons Edition -- Winter)Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5 (9974)
- The Iliad: A New Translation by Caroline AlexanderFrom EverandThe Iliad: A New Translation by Caroline AlexanderRating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5 (5734)
![American Gods [TV Tie-In]: A Novel](https://imgv2-2-f.scribdassets.com/img/audiobook_square_badge/626321117/198x198/22ab6b48b6/1718315036?v=1){kind=icon}
