Professional Documents
Culture Documents
إدراك الخير في كل ما يحدث. Arabic العربية
إدراك الخير في كل ما يحدث. Arabic العربية
- " " 8 - .
E - - - :
* R P ).( :
Y R -- . - Y* P Y -
` - _ ].
* Y - - -] -.ab
- ! P !- . E "_ 8 ]
- Y . ! ! Y
.
Y - - Y - - Y-
u P "! .* - * " 8
w w - -.
. &
8 &
? ? >
& C A
8M &
& .
R M ? O
V ? A8 S
? 8
?
? .
?
.M> R & O
c M ?
e O O d8 M V.
"" ""
; ; 5 1 .
D A
I . E 5
D .
A
A ;
D O
T ; E
E
T O . 5
D .I
1 A Z
; T ^ ;
.
T D b E
D E E D E E E c
E E E .
E O :O
;
) ( ) E(
) ( .OE j
b I I.O
D b .
D I O O
E Z A E
. D I o
; r 5 D
. ID O T
; . D I
.
34 /0 1 "
4 .
3 /
/
.
/D
/0" F
`
3 /
c .
/0" ` /
F 0 d .M
0 3 /0 /0
0 i /D h 4 .
`4 /0 j 0
k k / 30
R /
. R l 4 i
R / 4 / iD M
. 4
" 4
R
4 j 4 R
.l h /
/ / - h
/3 d
- h4 M
"
j i h hF
0 /D.
!
! ) '
.
' 5
.) 0
G ' @ <? <
; .89
)
! O
?
9
9 '
<?
? )
< ! X
.
9
9 )
.
O _
<
! . )
<9
! < .
) !
0 !
9
)
.
! <
89 g f _ ?
O
9
.
_ ) ) _ _l9
_
!' ! 9
<? <
9 < OO
! 89
;) )
<
!
0.o
J
...............................................
.....................
# ...............
....................
0 ........................
4
............................
@ # = 0 ...................
# = A ...................
............................................
: = ..........................
A B
L + AL
A 8 8 B .
8 x
A L A Q A
8 L . F x
8 L A .
Q .
B L +
A S A x .
A
L
L
8
+^ |.
A k 8A A LA F
B F A .S
L
A A F A d B
+ . s A
A + F A F A
8
A A F x
.
B x B c
A Q . F
A k8A . /
A + F / A
/ A .F
B F
c A
... / Q.
:
( c S 8
S A S
.
B .
A / k A / F F
. A A +
L8 A+
A F + A L
A A
A k x8
9
.
F
A . > / + u
B L B B F
8 B A ""
A A.
:
1 ( ) A (3 : A
Q
.
+ { A ` F
. +{ A
B B
F
8 Q 8 B Q FL
.
` (.
{ A B k F
" A c" { B
A L
. { ` A
A B
A / c.
10
5(6 2
B
" A "
` L
.
8 88
A .
B x ,
B SA B
A B|
. A F
F ,
.
F
B
11
8 .
x A
8 s B .
dB , c
A c F
B . S A
B ,
, + 8
.
B" Q c"" , "" , ,"....A
F /A . > B ,
A k x , A
. B , A
. " A + A
8" . A , B x L
,
A A . `
/ .
8B A B +,8
.S F
. S {
8 + . - -
k A k B c x
.
12
, A
,
. A ,
S , {
.
A 8 A c F Q {.
B S k8B A ,F
,
c x
. B , A
B
.
Q A /A d , A k
.Fc c S B ,Q A
, 8B 8 + .
, `
A .
, c
. > F 1 : ?
C )
c
C
6 1
C
(11:
, A , k+
Q , p A F
B , Q . , B d
13
A F
, A x.
/ A .
A u Ad Q
A A B F , A
. A{ c B d
Q B . k{
B + c c ,x k
A ,Q B
.,
A Q u F
.,
B u { x8 A
B .
u F B ,x
c
A /8 c
. ,
AA +
8 k x / .
A .
k
. ,
/ A -
- 8 S + 8 A
.
/ B k8B" A "c
14
x S A A ,
. , +
B c sd /A.
B ,x A A
x
.u c
8 "A{
L8" . L A ,
^A . c , Q
,/ Q .B ,
A x ^ ,S
A B , A c
. Q A
(
, A A .s ^
A x.
8A 8 , " S
" " k8B A" . F L
. , A A
. k / , A
A" Q ,"
8 F
,u S A
c.
15
> , c
8 8A F ,
A .{ 8 / 8
S , S ,
, F.
Q : 6 1 (
G
* C
5
1
G
16 1
R 1
* C
R 1 Q
6
* C1 ( ( 1
( C
G
R
Y *
C
( R 1
( 1 1
( C
)
(57-53 :8
16
b 2
` B x A
. 8 A . 88 A
A x Q
x
, ,
.
A S ,
, A F 8 A
. 8 x ,
x , , A
. ,
8
,L A . ,
A ^ A ,
/
.
A A .x8 ,
88 B ` 8{ x
{
.
8
A x
17
. ,
A . A ,x
, B . F
L .
k c x A "
8 L 8
A k " .
8A B , .
k A ` 8
+ A c x .
x 8 A S
. A k
B , / F8
. B , F F
, . +
{ L
d
. F ,A k x ,
` A , 8
x B .
` F L +
,
" ."c
A 8 Q
, ,
18
8 A , .
, 8
, 8A
u8 "" , .
B 8 A ,x
B . F A k8B /
x
A , B c x
B A ,F8 F
, /
8B x.
c , + . A ,
k x ,
.
19
( 5 2
CR 5(6 Q( ...
B ` x c ,
x / .
A F . > ,
, A F88
A , c A A.
k F , A
A ,x .
, 8 .
A A
B , A F
A , S
, 8
A
L
,+ S , A8 . F
x| .
20
k , 8 , A
A Q /
.s A B ,
B x B ,
c /8
8 . , /
Q B A A , A , /
A A c , / A
A , A s . x
, .
A Q , / x B
,
, Q /A A ,> c
, A
.
8
A
8B
F , . L
, B .
S c ,+ c c
/A A
/
. A
k Q ,x
A , A ,
21
c /8 B . B ,
,x c .
> , B F
L A c /
B . c ,
F . /8
c "
A L" .
c , A
S .
c / /
.`8 A A B ,
F ,
8 S
C )
. :
( 6 :p B F B /
c , c
.
x A S x,
F A x L
c F / B . A , Ap
+ .x
A A 8 A c A , F
22
. A x .k
A c
8 ,x A
k8 F . / Q
{ , , , .
A A 8 A k8B{ FA x.
A A , x A .
5(6 CR ,i 1R C ,
( ...
S x 8 ,
. L
.x` A B .F
x . B ,
A ,
.F
A : (
)
( 49 : c 8 .
A ` 8 , ,
c S .
A c . ,
c , c x / B ,
23
A , , A
+ , c / F8 B .
c .
B x F , L , 8 F
B
c .S
,x c A SA , x
8 .
8 A 88 . B
B
A L 8 .
,
.
A ,L F x
A B .L8 , A s^
A ,L , x
. Q 1 :
1 1 1
( 1 1
)
1 q ( 1
r (
(59 :S
` A
, A , A
F A .L ,
,L 8 c
x
. A > A ,
24
A L ,
1 q
(
B + Q " : R
v C
R
C R R
)
.(22 :
B A / F .
c S , , A
B .+ / S
F
8 c
A . A F8
8 A k8B A / c
8 A . A A B A
A F A { .
L
c .x
B 8 , ,
A A 8 A > B Q
k8B c . ,
`8" , c" . B A k
x A .`
8 B S "",
8 + " F" .
25
" " A B , A
x , / .
A x
A, ` ,
A . k8 ,
. A , B
c A +
,x c x
A, F
.
C R 2
CR 5(6
...
CR1 C R 2
A , A x
.
8 , > A
A F x .
, ,8
A ,x 8B
8 . 8B A ,
, ,
,B . A ,
, A k x.
26
Q 1 " : C R 1 1 C R
) C
1 1 R1
.(216:
A , F c
B , F
. ,
` , ,F
8.
/A xB , .F c
A , x . B F8A .
F C 1 :
C 1 5 6
( 6
)
.(107 :
1 6 (
,B F
, A ,
A B , F . , /
x , B d ,
, / ,
A) . A L {" :d
" (.
27
L . F{
A s
> . , ,Q .
c ,
A .
, A
. F ,
, .
, A{ B
. A F{
8 " c ^" ,
8 B . p >
8
R :
, A
1 1
C R 1
)
> Q.(142:
28
R
Q :
C (
C 1
1
( ( 1 C 1 1
)
> Q .(179:
R
S> 8 d
C v
Q 1 : R
C
1
* 1
1
6 1 R
1 R
C
R
C
) C
> Q .(167-166:
L
F .
,
. , B , F F
8
, A
/A . > , c A B
.
, ` F
,L x / A , L
, B B .
A A { A .
, B , F
29
F8.
L , + x
A^
F .
cL
, F
.
C C1
BA + `
A
.
B Q F , B ,
B . L
{"" "d
" Q:
>
b
1
~
r
1
1
1 v 2
?
1
1
b 1
)
> Q.(14 :
Q :
r
1
~ C b 1
r
( 1 R
)
.(46 :
> A , A ` s
C
)
.(20:
1 :
F , A s
A A L
30
L
. F L , `
/ B .F d c A
A A . F
k
+
.
F k
B 8
+ . c F
, 8 cdB.
A
c
.
:
G
1
(
1
)
.(23: A 8 Q
s
.( c AL
,c 8 8 F .
F
A 8 L
A Q .
/8 / /
,c
A ,
.L A c B A F
L 8 d F .F
A , k F
k
31
{
F S .8
B c A s> A
A . -
F A - /
+ .
A A / A A
. A c u
+ , B B
.
F8 c
. / B Q
B , B .F
A 8 F8 L
A .
,
,
A .
,Q L sd
. , k B A x8
, 8 A
A A . F A kF
8
B , , Q
c .
32
.(180:
, .
c A ,
cdB . 8 ,A /
,
` . >
C1
C (
:
G 1
C
33
1R v b
~
C
G
5 (
C
* 1
1 b
6
R 1 R 1
1R 1 R Q
q
(
C
C1 R R 1 b
R C R
) C
.(78-76:
1 v
L , AFd
. . ,
A .
>
B A
. Q L S
> , S .
8 F8 c
c Q B . `
A A FA L
s{
/ u
.
8 B Q
R 1 C
Q :
C
R
1 C ( b
1 C
C
1
Q
1
1 CG 1 R
1
v 1
)
. (111:
~
34
B c 8 A
A s A
B .F
.
C R
F F> :
1 i 1 G 1
1
1
Q1v
1
G 1
1
1
1 1
1
1
1
G 1 b ) ... b
.(177:
R
8 s
R C
1 :
R
) ...
(265:
r 1
,
A . , A
. k8 c
A .
B x
c / > A :
1
1 ?
1
") .
5
> Q (26:
35
, A c Q/
F
{
:
R 1
1
1 R 6
b 1 R
) C1
(55:
(1q
B` L
A S .
, x^ A8
, A x 8
. ,
A A x A +
S x.
, x ,
.
", " A c
s> , B S AL
A^A , .
B c , ^
8 A L . , x8,
36
A
8 .
. ^ , A
{ /A A c , L
A 8{ . c A c{ ""
. L
F8A B . ^ ` ,
x 8B.
A
B , , A A x
8 . A A L x
. A
F
.
, , A x^ A
, B .
B L +
, .^ x8
cdB A,
A { . > ,
x ^ A 8 A
.L
1 i
C R 1
:
1 G 1
1
1
37
1 1
1
G 1
Q1v
b
R 1
1
1
1
v 1 1
G1 1 b
C
1R 1
1R
1
1
) C
.(177:
B ^ F
. A
8 A A , ^
. Sd A k .
F + c^ /
A ,8 A , A
.Q A { ,
A / s + d .
A , A , k8BF
A s A s B
x .B Q F , A / A
^ L .+ 8A A /A^
^ A . , F^
, AA k ,+ F
Qd F
.
38
q C 1
A L^ , L /
. ,+ ^
k . ,
^ A S .
8 ` , 88
A
B .
A A A
A A F F ,k
S k8 F . ,
.c
q 6 C 1
A k F Q
B F A A .
B / ^
,
, 8 . , ^ k
A . A c
. Q
A + : R :
6 ... (1 , C16
39
k { .L
A , ^ ^
,
A k d
,
^
.
q ? C 1
L^ A
, A
,L
.
40
A B| A ,s c
.c / u ,
B ^ .Q B s
A L d
8 .
B 8
cB s| ,
.
` B
R v1 :
v1
R C
1 q
)
(51 :
6 1
1 R
C
6
1 v1 :
1 R C
) C
.(12 :
~
6 (
1 v1 :
) C
S
vR v ( v
. (33:
B L , A
A L{ A B A
. A ^ 8
+ A S { B , /
41
B F A.
C q
k> + c^ A
. ^
A S , B .F
8A / A L
. c
. / B u
L Q , d
L .
B B s8 ^
* 1
Q , Q v1 :
)
.(81-80:c
Q
B / F A{ S
> . > ,{ S
^ B d
, c A
> .
B A{ S A^
> A, A ` .
42
, A Q
. A L , B
A , ` B
A{ S
. B u | .
> 8 c A{ S
v ( 6 R
QR1 :
1
*
R1 ( R
v 1
)
G R 1 (
.(84-83 :c
{ c A{ 8 ,Q
:
v1
C
R
v ( 6 R
1
* 1 1 R
* (
( 1 6
1
1 ( v 1
1
5
)
1 1 R 1
| .(44-41: A{ S
A
s BA .
.
43
R R
B{ u`
L . ^
A . k F
> .{ L
` / S u.
A > B F d A .
` A Q A +/
A B ` .
.
, k F
F .
A ,Fc . ,
B S , B F8 B
. F u S{ c /
, B S S F.8
B / F , A k8
B x c F
B A .
44
v "... r
"
8 , A c x
.L A A L .
8 .L A k
A xB , A L B , A A
.
B
L B L
A B . L F L
c QA ,
8.
B S
AF
A Q
c .,L
F
. B 8
,
A . c ,
{ 8 A
c.
c : , A
F^ 88 .
.,
/ L ^ , A8
p ,c /A .c A A A .
45
r v
C
> 1 :
C
C R
b
1 6
1 6
)
> Q .(145:
1 Q
A ,
> , A .L
F /A . , A
A B ^ F
- A .L A L
B , QR :
(
1 ) ...b
:c
1 r
,B .(78 A ,L A
.
r 1
B + A A
,
F L
.F , L
. A A L
B , ^ B S /
.F
, L A B Q
, B . { B , S
46
/ A S F
,
B S{ . B , L
B F8 .8 x x
S . + F
S A . 8
{ A L ,/ ^
L
A FA , .
k `
. A A
A B + F
F . >
, z
8 , L B
A
.
8 L /
S{ , { A ./ ,
L A . L
.
8 B cdB L > 8
L / B A A A
, . L
( 1
b
1 :
1 R
) C
> Q.( 157 :
47
B
. A AL
8A ,L 8
.
8 + Q A
B . L B
B B .
> , A
L > A . ,
8 QA / B .,
A B
d .
B / z
,
. p ,S /
, Q Q Q
Q , F8 L8d
. , k L
.
R 1
F
1 :
)
> Q :
16 6 1
(178
c B L ,
8 L , Q
B F . , c
48
S , /
. , /
.
/ F , A
"" "" , Q 1 " : C R
1 1 C R 1 ".
49
5(6
CR C b 6C
A A 8 .
F A B . F
,
^ A^ B x8 ,
S / A B , A
A . A
Ac
{ , ,x ,
.
F +/
.
x . F A
> /A x A c .
A . 8
A .
50
B` S x
,S A
A
A , ,A d
, A B ,d
B ... + k A
A L F B . pc
+
8
. `
F k8B . A
. B A + ,
L .c ,
.
B
A Q .
/ c F^
. c F^ .
Q B A.
k / S
. A , A ^
. B A B L .
, ,c
B B
A L
B { .
51
B ,S
, 8 B A
,8
8 B x8 ,
x8 A ,^ ,Q /8 A
. c , Q A
,L + A
.A c B A
, k
. L
Q 8 ,c
/A c A L A B,
C1
C1
6
Q :
C r Q
) (C
:
b 6
1
(8
B 8
F d
A
A d
.Q
? b 1
: 1R
) C
.(36:
R1
G 1 (
B A Qd F A
^ ,L 8 u A
+ F^ .
b
+ , Q : Q 1 r
R R
1 ( )
.(2 :
52
> L> , A
. A A A
Q :
~ q R R
)
(
.(7 :
,S c
A .8 8
x B x cx
Q F .F A x
F
, Lc F . F
88 F .Lc
8 , / , 8 A
.
c c A - x,
A x ,
A 8 B . | 8
, A A
/A .> S B , ^
F8A . B A A
F 8 +
F
.
53
i
B B A L x
. , A Q Q A
F8 "" A A .
F ,F Q 1 :
) C(b
1
1 1
.(62 :C
G 1
Q 1 :
r
1 1R
) C1
:+
R
.(42
B^ x8 A Q S , Au
^ F
,
8
. B 8
8 k u s>
, / .
A
, / .F
A 8 ,x B A
.8 F
A .
A A
54
A 8 s A . 8 B
` k A A .
F8 Q 1 R : R C
C v
Q
r
~ i 1 (
* C 6
R R
(
C
* R 1 ( R1
(
) C1
.(54-52:
C R
/ S A F , S A
B /
F . A c
1
, 1 :
( 1R 1
r 1 1R
(
R
)
.(23 :L
( 1
( 1
Q 1 :
) C1
.(87 :
, A ` A ,
d A Q .
, F B / c
A
/A . >B , L ,
55
. A A k + d
, B
8
.
/ { S,L
A , ,
A . A /
, A k /
. , F
8
.
A d
d L . s
8 B . F ,
A
8 8
.
R C
B >
8
A A ,
A A . x
, .S,
,Q8 B ,
Q Q :
56
( R 1
5
1 R
R
( 1 ).(79 :
>
{ +
/ B .
+ A F
B A S . A
C 1
: v
1 R 1
1
) C
.(131 :+
R
Q , c >
A d d
A c . -
- A .c
c B A B A B ,
B A .
(
Q A+
. ,L
. , AA L , L
. c S
57
8 L , k c 8 B /A .
A x F
F
.F F :
) ... q
1 .(5 : Q) :
(
( )
.(49 :
A Q
A . A u
8 . B A
,F Q 8 k
A L .F c L x
B . { B L
L
A A F A .
B / A , x
B 8 A8 .
c c k .
{ , B
"".
/ 8 A
. > c
, " " / 8
58
A.
1 q R
(
Q : R
v C
)
C R R
.(22 :
, A
S , A c
. B , / c s8
+ A B x c
A , A x B . 8
, .
A S :
1
) C
.(51:
c SA A A
B . A ,x
+ B S
B . 8 8 .
F
S Q
/ A , B A
,Q F u.
59
6 C C 5(6
> A | .
> Q dB s
8B .8 A s
B Q .x
L
.8
B Q > , c
S / A +,
S . c `
.
B {
F 8 . , A
FA / x8 A
c .F B F
A A A . Q
, A k .8
{ A ,x
A
B / A . Bu
B 8 u k +.
60
B 8 +
+ . A
A .Q F
` + s
C
A Q :
b 1
1
1
1
1
)
.(268:
B
/
,s8 A + s
c , B
d . ,
A L
. c
> A ^ F 1 :
*
C
C
v
) C1
C 1 v
.(201-200: +
A A A S
Q A QA .A ,
c / A +
.
A , A
` k8B
61
x { ,
A "" , 8 F .
B A 8
( .
, x F
Fc A B A
.Q A A x A A
A x / F +
. A x
Q
+
.
62
R b 1
B p k c 8c
. 8 c
A x 8
Lc s B
c 8
A c Q .F
A B ...
z A
A + dA A L
A ,
c + , F A
B .
B ,
.
r
d
> A
63
Q 8 .>
8 :
C R
1R
R1
1
v C
C 1 1 1
1
R vR
( )
>.(186 :
F A{
L , ,.
> A 8 F Q >
, Q :
C
1
1 Q
)
. (11:
B +
|
.S ,
B A F L Q A ,
+ . 8 LLc
Q A
B d.p
c A S
64
A A , A cB x
B . / F 8A Q A c
F8 8
"A "sd , QC :
C 1 v Q
) C
> Q.(160:
1
r
L
AS
8
. , A B + ,
p .u A
A ,
88 A S A
,
B A c .
B ^ c
8 c .
8 ,c A
. A S
.
C R 1 1 i 1
:
1
1
G 1
1
1
65
G
1 1
1
Q1v
R 1
G 1 b 1 b
C
1
1
1R
1
v 1 1
1
1R1
) C
(177:
B F L L
Q L8
{ , 8
. {
c . +
, u ^
, . F L
+
A
, .
/ ,
8 , 8 F
.F8
+ , k8
F { . 8A A
A > L> ,B 88d , B
1
C
1 : ( R
)
1
( 1 1 i ( 1 1 ~ 6
{.(22 :
B A B A A +
66
B A
8 k8B B .8
F x B( 8B , B
.
{ A
B d 8A 8 F
F , Q ( 1 : 6
1
C )
1
1
{(25 :
b
B Q B L S ,
B
> u A u
8 > ,
8
.
> c A ,
Q :
1 1 1
G 1
C
1R
)
.(218:
( C 1 ( (
8
{ > . 8
A B u (A .
+ Q . 8
67
> L .
A A 8
` .
B s
B , A
Q
.
, 8 AQ
{ . 88 A k
.
,
c s> .. A +
( R R
s F !F8 Q :
v
1
R 1 R
C
R1
6 (
1v1R1 1 1
1 6
r Q
(
1
)
> Q(195 :
B B {
,
sd .
c:Q
1
1 1
(
q
(
1
r
( 1
)
.(100:c
R 1
C ( (
68
1
Q 1 :
1
1
R b
C
) C
.(42-41:
1 (
1
c
, { Q ,
QB F . k
A > .
8 , ^
. B A A . c
A B Q . F ,
S F
.
1
Q : 1
R v
v ( v
C
C
1
R1
6 1 1
)
:
1
1
.(40
/ A +
, B,
69
8B A A B +A .
/A
. LA
A x .S
> u
S , / A S .
8 A B S
B . A s S
/ B F
, Q .
>
S
/ ` 8
B . A , S A
.8 , / c
F8 8 , Ad
. , , /
Q )
: R ( 1
C
8 .(21:
F / F
S . A F F FdA
70
. B S
L
, F A .
A Q .S
p A ,
A .
F8 F8
S . B
B A F8 k
. , L S
A F8 A k,
A , ,
z . >
C
F :
C
1
(
C (
R
C i
6
5
C R
~ R1
R1
1 R
R
C v
( C
1
1
R C
)
(68-60: c
F B A s
S
Q .s A S
A , ,
71
A + L L , `
| B .F
1
B uA > { Q
x F
.S
,S F Q , +
B / . +
A . S
F A k8B
A F . , Q ,
B A 8 .
QA B ^ S
A
. A F A F
A . ,
{ F A 8 .d L
Q " ,S B "Fc
> . , S 8 .
F
F .
A A c/
A / A u c B S A :
72
( 1 R
)
.(35:
r
S A .
A ,S S
.
L , .
> , 8 B
, .
,S c , F
, c F 8B ,
. F F
8B .8 x 8 F A
( 1 : R 1 1 1
R
1
( 1 R R v
(
Q
1
C 1
1
( C
( G
1
6
R q
1 r (
1
1
1 1
)
R 1
b
(101-100:
F A c /
B . x s8
A , A c .x A
B 1B F F
. A
73
A /A A ,x A , ,
A Fc , c c
. B c .
, F
8 . A Q
" Q ".
74
( b 1
Q > 1 : R
) C
A /A ,(1: 8
F^ . 8 .8
, c A B .
8 d .
, . ,
k A
F:
)
: c
1
.(141
, c
s .
,p
, A A 8
. / ,c8 c8 Q
Q : C C
)
.(6-5:p
75
p
. A ,
Q
8B .
F8 1 :Q R
1 1 1
)
.(45:c
u +.
8 { B A , ,
8 B x 8 . +
/ { , Q v :
G
R
(
i
C
1 i
1
)
.(12:Q
B /
Q . d ,
s . ,L A Fc,L
A , 8 , A ,
Q . B A
.
> :
G v
1 v
Q : R
C
1 6 1 1
(
6 (
76
C )
{ .(9:
R
Q v :
( C
)
.(9:Q
6
C G
Q :
( Q R 1
R 1 b 1
C v
b1 ( )
> Q.(13:
5
B
. A
. A A
8A . c A
. {
B . c F
" . `
A F "
A
.
A A A A
.F u
.
Q v :
)
CR 1
. (18: Q
77
C
C
Q 1 : 1 1 1
1
)
B .(46:
A B
( (q
A Q :
C1
1 1
)
1
1
.(43:
F
) CR
( A d
.
+
x8
A B x .
! C
C
B c
C
c Q :
1 1
6
C
(
1 1
1 1v )
> Q.(174-173:
78
A A B >
. 8 .
c
8 B .
x
B p .
F
.
G C
Q 1 : ( 1 1
) C
.(56:
79
c ,
A ,c 8 B
F . A AQ
{ QB , A A A
" ". x A A
k c .x
, A .+
F ,
` ( . A
8
> S . F
^ x
Q A
+ c A A L ^ A
.
80
B| A
x + S .
F
A QF
. S8
{ B
,
F.
F
u
L
d . Q F,L
S
{ A c
. A k B A 8
A .c B c F
, B
. F F8
(
, Q 1 :
R 1
~ v 1 1
Q 1
* 1
6
* 1
( 1 R 1 (
R
q R
1
C
(
1
)
(74-73:
(
81
= :
1 '
.
#
=
D
1
1 = = D
=
D
D
F =
.L
=
=
D
D
.
# R Q
:
F
U
R
'
# =
= D
# W
V.
\
1
D
=
. =
b = _
1980 R
D1
V
\
.
_
g
V
V
R QD
W = D = 1
. R
D D
.
1
=
: =\ = .Q W
= m =
W
1
=.
82
%
.
;
" "5
A @ .1859 ;
5 G .B
% K
%
U.
@ A
" ."G] \
Z B ;
" " ` @ .
a % %
% c .
@ B f e:
-1 A %]
.G
-2 A Z B ] " %"
A B .B
83
-3 .
/ +) :
:
H FG ?=
L 3.8 ? . ?= FG
? U ? RS F )
R H
S . FG H? H\ /
F " ?".
` ?
? G G . /
F= = ?
FG G .
j ? i S G = . F
= / L F R .
? F? FG H
? ? R .
/ FG
? FG FR . FG L
84
-
.
-
4
4
=
H G
.DE
E
Q N
E = "
"J
4 HS
E DE
E
.
N
NE
D
Y N
E . X N
N
N ^ :1864
"
S
`
1 ".
^
N
H N 4 .
S N 4
^
D
DE D
E D
hN
fg
.
X 4 J
D
QNN
NN .^
S
N
H -
X 44 H N
4 .
NE 4
m:
"
n
NE N
85
"2.
( .
(= + .1953 ++
B GH E B @
( EQ R ( . M
B E ) G( .G
Q G
( + ( @ b +
R( 3.
R @ b
4.
Gf G( Q G
. R B
"( "E:1998 +
" + (B B
: G (E"5
& : DNA!
1 -
? > 6 DNA
>
. - !
L J > JI
.
86
# $ " "
$ .
$ .
$ J H C
J J .
S R# Q .O
# U
S 1 # 10950 # 500 #
$ C 150!
S f$ DNA $ # $
i . DNA f$
900
500.
# k : f$ DNA S
#$ %
$ / . ,*
< < 9 $
? @ #$= =? . #= ,$
? = H ,$
,$ $ %
$ =M =M $
.
87
$
)
(
= < 7
$ /0 .DNA
= 0 .
$
/ < .H G
= = = 0= =
7 Y W :1994 W
"
\
$
/ . < < W
H . $
$
7
"6
< a $ `
"" . = G=
< <= .
=H
"
=" 0 $=.
=H = i " $ /".
$ " : Y /"...
7 /
.$ 7
m
88
+ $ $
.,
45 ,
+ ,6
+ H 5 . .C
M
5 P ,
5
5 R ,
.
' .
. ' 2
C' C B@ > .
> ' C F B BH . C CF
' N >:
" C ' C R QH
W"7.
R" F QZY" > BH >
> b c d . ^B@ ] BH
C Q RB h > fW> F
Q k fW ' N Q . ^B
B Q Q QB ' > fW Bh
B B k fW m Q >.
89
+ , #
; : + 8.",
; + A
H , + D
A N .,
A .
:; , + " "D
" T "D A + .
D ""A A Y AW
:; e A DNA ;:
A.
hi g f .D,
D + D e A
A A n D A +i + A
; g A; . + s .pH A
;w :; g D ; ;:
;T ;..
90
:
? 6 ?
91
.
) ) *
CD A ? < .
) < .
RD) Q * M ?
Y W V . V U
] W W CD U^ ] Y .
M c * CD
Y . i W M
) < V D " V"
) ^ ) ) ^
? . R q ) <
. V " ?":
" RD Y t tM ? Y
W "10 .
W D
) D
. x
: W W
92
.
1 1 +(
Derek Ager
:4
1 + 87
1 E E ( ( 1 C
( I 1 H11.8
P1 P1 I I (N
1 P ( +(
C I
. + I
( N P( 1 C
P1 7 . +(
:
" ( I 1 I . P1P
7 I ( N 1 `C .P
1 ( I 1 7 I 4 I
1 .4 `C I 1 12.
I P1 I I (N
1" P1 "7 (C (.
7
4 ( 1 7
93
. ! .
! 6 ( 5-4
" A 6" ! .
! 6 :A
!-1L
-2 .
-3 L
-4
! 6 " !! "L " R
Y"!. Z Y ! .
^ [! !!
! Y ! A ! AL
A Y !
b 13.
! "" ! "" !
!! .L
A !! A Y .
! b A .6
Y " A:
" !
( A14".
! 6 ! A! :L
94
"
.
3 *
/*
>
*
";
"
D
; A ;
15.
; 3
/
" ""
O ;
" ;
A
;
; ;
16.3
S
R /
.
;
3R ;
" ":X
^
^
]
\ *
)
;
;
; X ( ;
/ X f" X f3
"17.O
f" "
"
X X ; R r
;
; R X v
v
"
*
"
.
;
;A
3
3
"
S
3
* ;
;
} * ;
15 3 3 D
* ;.R
;A
v > "
"v"~
v
95
.
1 "" 01 (
( - $
$
< 8
.
" "
" A<B ?"
B
) (
"< ."0
Q
:
YU X U (
$ A<B ?
1 < (
$ < 0 <0
<
18.
U
U e B1 1 B U
X 1 X e 1<
1
8 $. 8
< 1 8
<(
8
1 ($<(
1 c(
. U :
<
(
(B
96
.
68 . ,- / '
A " 6/ "
6 - 8 68 6 :
6 L I6
O
/ 8 / . - 8 6
/ / / T .
6Y X )' L
L / 10 .( 950 L L
Y L L
c8 L A A A
d - d -
68 6 L/
T 8 - .
68 . 68 L 8
8 / 8 8 8 8 8 6
8I 8 / 8 I 8 8 8 I' 8
8 8 8 O 8 8 8 6 8 8 l
8 8 p 6 o .A
68 8 /
L .
68 68
97
& "!
" 6 ! 3 & !
D ! A . ? =
&" .
&A !A& . M & ! 3
N PD" O.N
" W U "! RS
=O [O =O &.!D
& A P W !" O S M:
!A & R
=O N A A A
=O 3 & . N
= & .
N :
O& 3
!A ? 3 "! O
"! A & . U
3 "& O A . " N
&! .
O & 3 =O ! UO
& "! .& A ? U
" !& & A " ? " &&
98
) .
) 8 2
8
) ) . C B
=
J 2 F
.J 8 R
W B
V .
8 )
JR.
J= J B J8
8 ) = )] .
C 8
)]
)
) .
c .
) ) .d
c . F
) .8
)
)
.
R =
8
J) J
J 8 c) R
! ) J
J B j
c!
c
c)
= .
R
R) J
R C
R C 2 J
R C) c J )J
99
" "
.
'
.
7
7
.5
-
A -
B A
K
I '
G .
A
. A
7
"
A
U'
5" .
]
A 7
G\ [
.G
a K
A .A K
A
K
A
f .
e Ad
B
A" a A B'
KA
7
.5
'
]
A
A j i
.
A
I
' K
'
A B . " 5
A .
A
.
a
A
5
"
" .
\ 7
K
A [
.5
100
.
3 2 $ %
? = 6 % 35 6 5
= = D D= . 6 % D
O O 5 65? 25
5 2 5 S : 3 2 Q
% 5 D % = 6= .V
? 6 = 5 5 635 5 ? Q
. ? 5[ ? % .
? 65 6 O
` ? 65 D Q^ % 6 Q = ]
. = a ` D 635
.% D = 6= . b
Q 65 2 6
% D
? D %
? 5 %3 6 i O Q 3.
= 6 = Q 6 65 = $
101
(' $
; . 8 ( )- ().
C- .
J ( ( ; .
( ( ( ; C-('
C-
C -; . C- ( (
J; X \ ( )- Y X
b ! C_X!
CX X C; ( c
X .g JX g - Y
( )Y ) C.
- C ( z( Y )(Richard Lewontin
( ( Y _ () ( ")Y
b} b) " _X }:
" CX X Y X C ) ( .~
) X C )Y -} J
_ X Y -}
)Y . X CY
C- } X X "19.
J C( Y c
Y . Y' - Y .;Y
C- C ;Y; X ; .X C C-
( ( ( (
102
#/ / #/ # / # L #
b / =/ &^ #/ &
c & ( c
.
L # # & #/ #
# # # h E )Einstein
(Hubble ) (Frank Sinatra& ##
) (Charlton Heston O / #& ( #&
O # & # &
O
. #/ #
/ E / p & . # L
& " & #
"/
103
* +* . "
"
6
"
H H
H * .I
6D
D
D
D* 6
6
H
D
6
6
X + .
*
" *
H .
H
_
* H H "^
.
a :
%
'
=
]'[7-6 :
:
?>
=
] [179 :K
" D
H
_
"
+* a :
%
][15-14 :
T
*
H
a
_
"
104
][116:#
. U 6& &' h
j D . '& & ' G
&"' G' '
' &j "
] :
*
*
;
5 3
*
105
][119-117 :
.
= /,
D
P D L
X " ".
b` _ ) (Malcolm Muggeridge[
L
[ s :
" s bv
.
v} {
" 20.
X
D D
P .
= {
v L .
106
#
] [ :
107
1. Sidney Fox, Klaus Dose, Molecular Evolution and The Origin of Life, New York:
Marcel Dekker, 1977. p. 2
2. Alexander I. Oparin, Origin of Life, (1936) New York, Dover Publications, 1953
(Reprint), p. 196
3. New Evidence on Evolution of Early Atmosphere and Life, Bulletin of the
American Meteorological Society, vol 63, November 1982, p. 1328.1330.
4. Stanley Miller, Molecular Evolution of Life: Current Status of the Prebiotic Synthesis
of Small Molecules, 1986, p. 7
5. Jeffrey Bada, Earth, February 1998, v. 40
6. Leslie E. Orgel, The Origin of Life on Earth, Scientific American, vol 271, October
1994, p. 78
7.Charles Darwin, : A Facsimile of the First Edition, Harvard University Press, 1964, p.
189
8. Charles Darwin,, p. 184.
9. B. G. Ranganathan, Origins?, Pennsylvania: The Banner Of Truth Trust, 1988.
10. Charles Darwin, The Origin of Species: A Facsimile of the First Edition, Harvard
University Press, 1964, 179.
11. Derek A. Ager, The Nature of the Fossil Record, Proceedings of the British
Geological Association, vol 87, 1976, p. 133
12. Douglas J. Futuyma, Science on Trial, New York: Pantheon Books, 1983. p. 197
13. Solly Zuckerman, Beyond The Ivory Tower, New York: Toplinger Publications,
1970, ss. 75.94; Charles E. Oxnard, The Place of Australopithecines in Human
Evolution: Grounds for Doubt, Nature, vol 258, p. 389
14. J. Rennie, Darwins Current Bulldog: Ernst Mayr, Scientific American, December
1992
15. Alan Walker, Science, vol. 207, 1980, p. 1103; A. J. Kelso, Physical Antropology, 1st
ed., New York: J. B. Lipincott Co., 1970, s. 221; M. D. Leakey, Olduvai Gorge, vol. 3,
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1971, p. 272
16. Time, November 1996
17. S. J. Gould, Natural History, vol. 85, 1976, p. 30
18.. Solly Zuckerman, Beyond The Ivory Tower, p. 19
19. Richard Lewontin, Billions and billions of demons, The New York Review of
Books, 9 January, 1997, p. 28.
20. Malcolm Muggeridge, The End of Christendom, Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1980, p.
43
108