Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Edla479 Multiliteracies Project
Edla479 Multiliteracies Project
Overview
This unit takes place in a year 10 classroom at a co-educational school
and would be best utilised after a unit on the analysis of persuasive texts
as it introduces students to the representation of women in range of
multimodal texts that are both persuasive and non-persuasive. This unit
builds on the theme of gender, relationships and power that is
consistently present in schools across Victoria at a year 10 level and is
particularly relevant to the current social and political climate in
Australia. The unit aims to promote the notion of respect and equality
across genders. Throughout the four lessons, students view and analyse
the representation of women in popular culture, and attempt to uncover
the sometimes hidden misogyny that exists. The texts used are texts
that students will be familiar with and they will be able to bring a level of
personal expertise to the classroom.
Students will be assessed formatively each lesson through the use of a
multi-genre project (group task) in which they will complete a variety of
tasks that enable them to design new texts and redesign existing texts in
a range of different multimodal ways (Skerrett, 2011). In addition to this,
students will be assessed individually through a series of reflection tasks,
these will be written and submitted to the teacher, but also shared with
the class.
10 English
Where this lesson fits in the bigger unit: First in a sequence of four.
RESOURCES
5
minutes
15
minutes
15
minutes
5
minutes
14 images of
women represented
in a variety of
different video
games, guiding
questions (see
appendix a.), laptop,
pens, paper.
Closure:
As a whole class activity, students will verbally share their
personal reflections; these reflections do not have to be
reflective of the of the group multi-genre task but may detail a
shared or difference of opinion.
10
minutes
2
minutes
RESOURCES
33
minutes
x2 video links x2
images, guiding
questions (see
appendix b.), poster
paper, pens, paper.
5
minutes
10
minutes
Lesson Development:
In groups of four, students will view and evaluate the four texts
provided using a series of guiding questions. They will use their
findings to create an A3 sized poster detailing the different
representations of crime fighting women they have analysed and
what redesigned meaning they have established as a group.
Students will now draft a short reflection on the available design
text they have analysed and the redesigned text they produced
as part of their group.
Closure:
As done in the previous lesson, students will verbally share their
personal reflections; these reflections do not have to be
reflective of the of the group multi-genre task but may detail a
shared or difference of opinion.
10 English
Where this lesson fits in the bigger unit: Third in a series of four
1
minute
34
minutes
x4 video links,
guiding questions
(see appendix c.),
recording device,
pens, paper.
5
minutes
10
minutes
Lesson Development:
In groups of four, students will view and evaluate the four texts
provided using a series of guiding questions. They will use their
findings to create a 2-minute news report (A Current Affair style)
displaying a redesigned text on representations of women in
popular music and advertising.
Students will now draft a short reflection on the available design
text they have analysed and the redesigned text they produced
as part of their group.
Closure:
As done in the previous lessons, students will verbally share
their personal reflections; these reflections do not have to be
reflective of the of the group multi-genre task but may detail a
shared or difference of opinion.
10 English
Where this lesson fits in the bigger unit: Last in a series of four
Reflect on, extend, endorse or refute others interpretations of and responses to literature (ACELT1640).
GOALS AND OBJECTIVES (INCLUDE LINK TO AusVELS in brackets next to each objective):
The students will be able to: demonstrate a definitive understanding of and opinion on the representations of women in popular culture
across a range of multimodal texts (ACELY1752), (ACELY1749), and present their understanding to the class effectively (ACELY1751),
(ACELT1640).
SUMMARY OF RESOURCES REQUIRED: x4 images and x1 video link (see appendix d.)
LESSON PROCEDURE
TIMING
RESOURCES
5
minutes
15
minutes
Opening:
Students will be working in the same groups as the previous
lesson and will organise themselves accordingly.
1
minute
29
minutes
x4 images x1 video
link, guiding
questions (see
appendix d.), laptop,
pens, paper
Lesson Development:
In groups of four, students will view and evaluate the five texts
provided using a series of guiding questions. They will use their
findings to draft a one-page letter to the editor detailing their
opinions regarding the existence of misogyny in Australian
society today (see appendix d.).
Students will now draft a short reflection on the available design
texts they have analysed and the redesigned text they produced
as part of their group.
Closure:
Each group will present their multi-genre project detailing the
evolution of their understanding of the texts presented
throughout the unit and their final conclusion with regards to
their understanding of the ways in which women are
represented in the form of a letter to the editor as a final
redesigned text. All redesigned texts created as part of the multigenre project will be available for all students to view, either on
display around the classroom or on the class Weebly.
Rationale:
To be effective learners in the 21st century, students must think inventively,
effectively communicate, be highly productive and have an informed
understanding of the digital age (Schoffner, de Oliveira & Angus, 2010).
Throughout this unit students will engage with a range of multimodal texts
through a pedagogy of Multiliteracies, demonstrating the idea that in western
schools, there is not a singular form of canon English that can be taught anymore
(New London Group, 1996). Using resources familiar to them, students work in an
environment of situated practice which places students in a community of
learners who have varying degrees of expertise based on personal experience, as
part of a curriculum that has been designed with students personal experience
and expertise in mind (New London Group, 1996).
While they are still important, language facts such as correct grammar and
spelling were once deemed the only useful literacy knowledge students would
need for life; an idea reminiscent of teaching in the industrial age where students
would grow up to become obedient workers who simply accepted authority
(Kalantzis and Cope, 2008). In todays digital age, it is necessary for students to
be literate across a range of texts, written and otherwise, which they will likely
interact with on a daily basis in their adult lives. The rapid change that happens
frequently today means that an industrial style education is not useful to people
in a changing society, as it is almost impossible to adapt a transformed practice
design to it (Kalantzis and Cope, 2008). Through the use of technology we are
able to convert our ideas into practice and celebrate student differences in a way
never experienced before. Kalantzis and Cope claim that this celebration of
individuality allows students to work more efficiently than if they were forced to
conform to the same set of values (2008). This is an idea that Healy agrees with,
stating that deep learning occurs when student differences are acknowledged and
accepted and students are able to build their knowledge in their own individual
ways (2008).
Through the analysis of this broad range of multimodal texts, students create
meaning by establishing the representational, social, organisational, contextual
and ideological elements of each text (Kalantzis and Cope, 2008). They do this
through a series of carefully drafted questions, which allow the teacher to overtly
instruct students to ensure that they accomplish in an area that they might have
struggled with through teacher scaffolding (New London Group, 1996).
Working in small groups as part of a multi-genre projects allow teachers to
engage students with a range of different activities while overtly instructing
students to ensure that the correct content and skills are covered (Skerrett,
2011). This also allows the teacher to be a part of the community of learners,
rather than being the sole distributor of knowledge. This encourages critical
framing and ensures that there is no marginalising of students (Healy, 2008).
Critical framing also allows students to step back from what they have learned
and process how it relates to their lives and how they utilise this newly attained
knowledge, meaning students could begin to make informed decisions about their
video gaming choices for example (New London Group, 1996).
In each lesson students thoroughly decipher each text, processing the established
meaning in available designs, developing understanding and relating texts to real
life experience in the designing process and producing redesigned texts as a
result of the designing process (Cope and Kalantzis, 2009). This transformed
practice allows students to reflect their newly attained knowledge in other
cultural and social contexts (New London Group, 1996). The idea that all texts
and opinions are valued in the classroom and accepting a range of multimodal
texts consents to the untapped knowledge of many students, which has
previously been ignored and these students begin to engage, sometimes for the
first time, bringing a sense of real life in the classroom for all (Healy, 2008). Boys
who have previously been uncomfortable in the classroom due to concepts of
masculinity that impact the ways in which boys are comfortable in using
language, particularly language they associate with emotion and compassion,
begin to feel welcome and valued within the English classroom (Gilbert, 2003).
This is not because boys are just uninterested in reading in writing, in fact young
people across both genders are now reading and writing more than ever but in a
different format from traditional literature (Rennie & Patterson, 2010). Some boys
may appear uninterested in the classroom but may be avid readers and creators
of text outside of school (Williams, 2004). This may be due to the fact that the
English classroom traditionally discourages texts that are violent or actionpacked, texts that some boys may be drawn to. This can sometimes make boys
feel as if the content that they enjoy and are interested in has no value. It is
worth noting that it is often not the violence of particular popular texts that they
find enthralling, but rather the thrilling suspense that is associated with the
violence (Williams, 2004). While this unit is aimed to at educating young people
about the negative and positive representations of women available, it is done so
through the analysis of suspenseful and sometimes violent texts, which is likely to
be engaging for boys, despite the female gendered content. Critical literacy
enables students to uncover how gender is defined through the exploration of
language and text and using texts that present genders in a range of
stereotypical and non-stereotypical is most beneficial when used in the classroom
(Peyton Young & Brozo, 2001).
Through the use of advertisements as texts and critical literacy, students are able
to establish meaning and deconstruct texts that can hold dangerous hidden
messages, encouraging them to look further than the popular worldview that is
often presented (Honan, 2012). Advertising is designed to present people and
lifestyles that consumers will naturally envy (Serafini, 2008). For this reason it is
important that students are presented with the facts and can hopefully redesign
the text themselves. In the analysis of the Dove Evolution advertisements,
students deal with confronting and important issues that young people are now
faced with; when dealing with texts such as these scaffolding is paramount so
that students can learn the meaning behind each component within the text
(Healy, 2008). This is done not simply with carefully drafted questions to consider,
but also with the constant presence of the teacher, who moves fluidly around the
room from group to group.
The presentation component of the multi-genre project is designed not only to
assess the students understanding of the unit, but also to begin to tap into not as
References:
Cope, B., & Kalantzis, M. (2009). Multiliteracies: New Literacies, New
Learning. Pedagogies: An International Journal, 4(3), 164-195. Retrieved from:
http://newlearningonline.com/_uploads/pedagogiesm-litsarticle1.pdf
Gilbert, P. (2003). Gender, Talk and Silence: Speaking and Listening in the
Classroom. In G. Bull, & M. Anstey (Eds.), The Literacy Lexicon (183-194).
Frenchs Forrest: Pearson.
Appendix A.
Mortal Kombat, released 15 April 2015.
New Super Mario Bros. Us Princess Peach. Caption present with image: The
poor Princess has some uninvited guests at her castle Can you get back and
help her out before unspeakable horrors befall the palace? Retrieved from:
http://newsupermariobrosu.nintendo.com/characters/
Appendix B.
Trailer for Suicide Squad, to be released 5 August 2016.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PLLQK9la6Go
Watch the trailer above and pay close attention to the way that the female
characters are portrayed (Harley Quinn- played by Margot Robbie,
Enchantress- played by Cara Delevingne, Amanda Walker (Government
Agency Officer)- played by Viola Davis, Katana- played by Karen Fukuhara).
Questions to consider:
1. What are your first impressions of these characters?
2. How do their lines differ from the lines of the male characters?
3. Do these characters seem less mentally stable than the male
characters? Why/why not?
4. What does this tell you about the perception of mental illness in
women?
5. Are these characters sexualised? If yes, in what way? If no, explain why
you think this.
6. Do you think these characters are representative of strong and
intelligent women capable of fighting crime? Why/why not?
Catwoman (2004).
Appendix C.
Questions to consider:
1. Do these videos change the way that you perceive the Victorias Secret
advert?
2. What is the purpose of these videos?
3. Who is the audience?
4. Is there anything you could bring that could redesign this text and
improve it?
5. Would a text such as this be appropriate and effective for young males?
Why/why not?
Multi-genre project: Create a 2-minute news report (A Current Affair style)
displaying your findings on women in popular music and advertising.
Appendix D.
Questions to consider:
1. How do sources one and two appear physically different from sources
three and four? Ie. Dress, hair etc.
2. Which images display strong and powerful women? Why?
3. Which images appear more masculine? Why?
4. Which images appear more feminine? Why?
5. What purpose does each image serve?
Watch the video below and keep in mind that this speech was delivered after
Mr Abbott called for the resignation of Peter Slipper, which would have greatly
affected Ms Gillards small majority in the House of Representatives. Using the
understanding that you now have about the ways in which women a portrayed
across various popular media texts, do you believe that the former Prime
Minister has a point about misogyny existing, not only within the Australian
Parliament, but in popular culture consumed across the world?
http://splash.abc.net.au/home#!/media/1248967/
Retrieved via:
Scootle. (2015). Julia Gillard Addresses Misogyny in Parliament. Retrieved
from: https://www.scootle.edu.au/
Multi-genre project: respond to the question above in a letter to the editor.