Professional Documents
Culture Documents
319(1920)
RELEVANTFACTS
Defendantswerearrestedattheirhomeandwhileincustody,theirbusinessofficewassearched.
Defendantswerearrestedfornotrespondingtoasubpoena
Duringthesearch,evidencewasobtainedbutnowarrantwasprovided
Defendantsrequestedtheirpropertybereturned
Photographsweretakenoftheevidence,propertywasreturned,andthedefendantswere
released
ThePhotographswereusedasevidencetoissueasubpoenabasedupontheknowledge
obtainedfromtheunconstitutionalSearch
ISSUE(S)
HOLDING(S)Thegovernmentcannotusetheknowledgegainedfromtheirownwrongto
serveanewsubpoenaandusetheevidence.Therightsofacorporationagainstunlawfulsearch
andseizurearetobeprotectedevenifthesameresultmighthavebeenachievedinalawfulway.
RATIONALE
DICTA
OTHEROPINIONS
CATCHALL
Linnv.UnitedStates,251Fed.476
Weeksv.UnitedStates,232U.S.383
Adamsv.NewYork,192U.S.585