Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Argumentone Pagertoamouse
Argumentone Pagertoamouse
Mrs.Carroll
AmericanLiterature
20March2016
ArgumentOnePager:ToAMouse
Inthispoemafarmerisapologizingtoamouseforfordestroyingitshome.Asignificant
quotewithinthepoemis,ButMousie,thouarenothylane/Inprovingforesightmaybevain:/
Thebestlaidschemeso'Micean'Men,/Gangaftagley,/An'lea'eusnoughtbutgriefan'pain,/
Forpromis'djoy!(Burns3742).Thisquotedemonstratesthatthefarmerisspeakingtothe
mousehowlifeplanspeoplemakedontalwaysgothewaywewant,buthaveunexpectedturns
thatleavesgriefratherthanjoy.Thefarmertellsthemousethatlookingaheadforthefuturecan
beworthlessandhowthisproblemiscommontoallmortalcreatures,men,andmicearoundthe
world.
Therefore,Burnsismakingtheclaimthathumansputtoomuchplanningintothefuture,
and
l
ifethrowsmanycurvespeopleshouldntdwellonthepastordreamaboutthefuture,buton
thepresent.Peoplegetcaughtupwiththeirhopesforthefuturefrompastexperiences,butnever
takemomenttostopandliveforthepresentbecauseeverythingelseisuncertain.Burnswants
ustounderstandthatasmuchasweputintoplanningforfuturewewillneverknowifweget
whatweforeseen.
However,thisraisesthequestionwhetherpeoplearepessimisticthanoptimisticforthe
future.Peoplefeareverythinganditmakesithardtobepositiveiftheironlylookingatthe
negatives.Itiscommonforustonotgetwhatwewantthefirsttime,whichmakesusthen
expectthatwewontgetitthesecondtimebecausethepositivemindsetwehadfirsthas
changedourviewstonegativityduetopast.