Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Stability Trim and Cargo Calculations
Stability Trim and Cargo Calculations
0 2, x 08 OFF-SHORE SUPPLY VESSELS For offshore supply vessels of not more than 100 m in length, where the vessels characteristics render compliance with the criteria prescribed for cargo ships impracticable, the Administration may apply the following, criteria. 1, The maximum righting lever should occur at an angle of heel not less than 15° 2. The area under the GZ curve should not be less than 0.070 meter- radians upto an angle of 15° when the maximum righting lever occurs at 15° It should not be less than 0.055 meter radian upto an angle of 30° when the maximum righting lever occurs at 30° or above. Where the maximum righting lever occurs at angles between 15° and 30° the corresponding area under the righting lever curve should be at least BT0.055 + 0.001 (30° - @,,,) meter-radians. 3. The area under the GZ curve between the angles of 30° and 40° or the angle of flooding whichever is least should not be less than 0.03 meter radians. 4. The righting lever (GZ) should be at least 0.20 m at an angle of heel equal to or greater than 30°. 5. The initial transverse metacentric height should not be less than 0.15 m at an angle of heel equal to or greater than 30 Compliance with the stability criteria does not ensure immunity against capsizing regardless of the circumstances. Prudence and good seamanship should be exercised having regard to the season, weather and the navigational zone and appropriate action should be taken as to course and speed warranted by prevailing circumstances. The students's attention is drawn to items 7 and 8 of the General Instructions. When determining GZ values from KN, the corrected KG (KG - FSC) is to be used. () Heel Original. Upward sin @ Com to GZ Corrected GZ SM_ Product Gz GG, =GG,sin@ = Original for Area GZ-Corn. © 0.000 022 00 00 00 1 0.000 1 0.191 0.22 0.174 ~=— 0.038 0153 3 (0.459 20° 0383, 0.22 0342 0075 0308 «= 30.924 30° 0.500 0390Gi) Note: (iii) To estimate the vessel's initial metacentric height, draw a tangent to the curve of statical stability, at its origin. Erect a perpendicular at one radian (57.39. From their point of intersection, return to the GZ scale to read off the GM (Fluid) In practice, this will not give an accurate value of GM as the tangent drawn may not be at the very correct angle. Estimated Initial GM = 0.50 m Area under the curve of statical stability upto 30° heel = UB x 3x x 0.116 m_ radians Dynamical stability = Area x W 0.116 x 18,5293 = 2150 tm Dynamical Stability at 30° heel 2150 tm 139() KM for displ. of 18529 t = 8349 m KG - 7.539 m GM _ (Solid) = 0.810 m FSC =< 0.084 m GM (Fluid) = 0.726 m (ii) To find corrected KG in order to determine GZ values from KN values. KG = 7539 m FSC = (+)0.084 m Corrected KG * 7623 m GZ = KN - Corrected KG x sin 0) @ oF 0 oS Oo Oo oP kN 00760 15172252 20% 3699 43125498 59787027 7.416 =KGsin0 0 016631326 1974 2607 3295 3812 4.902 5389 6.602 7.364 GZ SM. 00097 0191 0278 0383 0404 0500 0596 0589 0.425 0.052 1 4 soe eae 4 1___SUM PRODUCT 00 0388 0382 11120766 1616 0.500 4764 140(iii) @) Maximum GZ = 0.61 m at 42° angle of heel (b) Angle of Vanishing Stability = 77° s upsetting moment 4500 (©) Upsetting lever = ~“Dispiacement ~ ig529 7 024 m New range of stability = 18 to 68° = 55° Reduction in the range of stability = 77° - 55° = 22° (d) List produced by the upsetting moment = 139° 1 822.5) (iv) Area under the Curve upto 30° = 4764x5 * 55 = 0.139 metre radians. Since the area is greater than 0.005 metre radians, the ship satisfies the criterion regarding the area upto 30’ of the Code of Intact Stability.Weight KG V. Moments (6) (m) (mt) Displacement Condition No. 9 157278 7.334 115352 Ballast pumped out QO 200 065 =) 130 Final Weight = 155278 Final Moment 115222 Final KG =- oe = 7420 m Original FS Moment = 1552 mt FS moment of No. 2 (P&S) (1436 x 1.025) = 1472 mt Final FS_ moment = 3024 mt Final FSC = = 0195 m To find corrected KG to determine GZ values from KN. KG = 7.420 m FSC = (4) 0195 m Corrected KG = 7.615 m a 10° 20" 30° Ey Sin 0 0.0 0.174 0.342 500 0.643 KN 0.0 1500 2965 4.414 5.723 - KG Sin 0 0.0 1.325 2.604 3.808 ___4.896 GZ 0.0 0.175 0361 __0.606__0.827 SM. 1 4 2 4 1__SUM PRODUCT FOR 0.0 0.700 0.722 2.424 0.827 4.673 AREA. * SM. =1 8 5 SUM PRODUCT FOR AREA 0361 4848 4.135 8.62210 1 (ii) Area under the Curve upto 40°= 4673x 5 > = 0.27184 m radians. Dynamical Stability at 40° heel = 0.27184 x 155278 = 4221.07 mt Dynamical Stability at 40° heel = 4221.1 tm +, Common interval, 10° and the ordinates being the GZ values. (iii) Area under the Curve between 30° & 40° heel. - B62 x x as = 0.12539 mrad ‘Area under the Curve upto 30 = 027184 - 0.12539 = 0.14645. mrad Area under the Curve upto 30? = 0.14645 mrad, which is greater than 0.055 Criterion for area upto 30° is satisfied. Area under the curve upto 40° = 0.27184 mrad, which is greater thar’ 0.09 Criterion for area upto 40° or angle of flooding is satisfied. Area under the Curve between 30°& 40° = 0.12539 mrad which is greater than 0.03. Criterion for area between 30° and 40° or the angle of flooding is also satisfied. 143DETERMINATION OF LIST DUE TO TRANSVERSE SHIFT OF FROM CURVE OF STATICAL STABILITY. The student is already aware that the list produced by a transverse shift of 'G' can be obtained by the expression GG, tan® = GM’ provided the list is small. The reason why this expression is not applicable at large angles of heel is that as the list becomes larger, the value of KM and, therefore, GM changes considerably (as her water plane area changes with heel) and thus the initial GM used in the above expression is no more applicable. The list may, however, be determined accurately from a curve of statical stability as explained below. 4sAny loading, discharging or shifting operation may produce both a vertical shift and a transverse shift of G. As done in the previous problems on curves of statical stability, the GZ's at various angles of heel were obtained, by the expression GZ = KN - (KG sin 8). The KG used in this expression is the final corrected KG obtained after allowing for any vertical shift cf G and also the FSC. Where a transverse shift of G is also involved, it can be seen from the figure on the previous page that the GZ at any angle of heel, on the side to which she is heeled, reduces by an amount GG, cos 0. To obtain the list from a curve of statical stability the final KG (corrected KG) is first obtained, and the GZ values at the various angles of heel are determined by the expression GZ = KN - KG sin 0, The reduction in GZ due to transverse shift of G, equal to GG, cos @ is then subtracted from the GZ values as obtained above. The corrected GZ values so obtained are plotted as a curve of statical stability. The list is then read off, where the curve attains zero value, as at earlier angles the vessel has a -ve GZ (heeling lever) while at larger angles, she has +ve GZ values (Righting levers), as can be seen from the curves in the following problems. It should be noted that the curve drawn is only for the side to which she is listed. Though the GZ values are negative initially, it is important to note that this is not due to a -ve GM. As the G shifts transversely, the vessel lists till the new Centre of Buoyancy once again comes in the same vertical line as the centre of Gravity. At this list, she attains static equilibrium. 14sDETERMINATION OF LIST WHEN GZ VALUES ARE GIVEN. In a theoretical problem where only GZ values at different angles of heel are given, whereafter some vertical and transverse shift of G has occurred, the GZ values for the new condition may be obtained as follows: 1. Add or subtract vertical GG, sin @ (+) for downward shift of G (-) for upward shift of G. 2. Subtract transverse GG, cos 8. The statical stability curve may now be plotted and the list determined, as indicated earlier. This method is resorted to as KN and KG values are not available to use the method indicated earlier. Initial drafts Fo 638m) A 724m M 681m } trim 0.86 m by stern 16LCF for draft 6.81 m Correction to Aft draft = Taio After draft Hydrostatic draft Displacement for draft 6.809 m Weights ® Displacement 138607 No. 3 DB tank (P) (+) 1000 Final Weight = 111784.2 Final KG = aa Original FSM No. 3 P = 27 x 102 Final FSM : ie 1404.68 Final FSC = a Corrected KG 100 x 8 © Transverse GG, - 13960.7 7 0.86 x 71.796 KG (m) 8.06 0.67 13960.7. Final V. Moment @ 7.240 m 6.809 m 13860.7 t V. Moments (mt) 111717. () 67.0 = 111784.2 8.007 m 1172 mt 232.68 mt 1404.68 mt 0.101 m 8.108 m 0.0573 m6 BNA TIN Gi sin 0.000 0.087 0.174 cos 1.000 0.996 0.985 KN 0.000 0.755 <.506 -KGsind 0,000 0.705 1411 Uncorrected Gz 0.000 0.050 0.095 ‘Transverse GG,cos® 0.057 0.057 0.056 Corrected a (10.057 (-)0.007 0.039 15° 0.259 0.966 2.232 2.100 0.132 0.055 0.077 20° 0342 0.940 2.982 2.773 0.209 0.054 0.155 25° 0.423 0.906 3.723 3.430 0.293 0.052 0.241 30° 0.500 0.866 4am 4.054 0.417 0.050 0367 40° 0.643 0.766 5.819 5.213 0.606 0.044 0.562 45° 0.707 0.707 6.350 5.732 0.618 0.041 0577 STATICAL STABILITY CURVE FOR PORT HEEL The curve indicates that the GZ values are negative 60° 0.866 0.500 7.353 7.022 0.331 73" 0.966 0.259 7619 7.832 (0213 0.015, (0.229 upto a heel of gi', and positive thereafter. In other words, heeling levers operate upto a heel of ¢;' and righting levers are present thereafter. The ship will attain static equilibrium at the angle of heel at which neither 148Note: heeling nor righting levers are present, which in this case occurs at 6i In practice, on board a ship, when the accurate list is required to be determined, it is not necessary to draw the entire curve of statical stability. A part of the curve till GZ values become positive would. suffice Weights KG V. Moments Dist T.Moments from CL. ® (m) (mt) (m) (mt) Condition No. 5 185293 7.539 139700 ° 0 Disch. No.1 TD (-) 250.0 Ma7_—)-27925 6 1500 (P) Disch. No. 3 TD () 50.0 1115) 5575 13 6 6) FW in No. 8 (8) (+) 634 277 (4) 1756 18 141 (6) Shifted 40 t 40.0 62 () 280 16 640.0 (P) Final Wt = 182927 Final V.Mmts = 136277.6 Final T.Mmts. 1960.9 (P) Final KG aoe 7.450 inal =e pe 450. m 1552 FSC = Fea 7 (#)0085 m Corrected KG = 7535 m 1960.9 Transverse GG, = = 0.1072 m 18292.7 1496 Oo Fae sino 0.000 0.087 0.174 cos 1.000 0.996 0,985 KN 0.000 0.759 1.513 -KGsin® 0,000 0.656. 1.311 Uncorrected Gz 0.000 0.103 0.202 Transverse GG,cos@ 0.107 0.107 0.106 Corrected a (-)0.107 ()0.004 0.096 Angle of List obtained from curve = 1 0.259 0.966 2.249 1.952 0.297 O04 0.193 20 0342 0.940 2,990 2.57 0.413 0.01 0312 150 25° 0.423, 0.906 3.636 3.187 0.449 30° 0.500 0.866 4320 3.768 0.552 0.093 0.459 40 4s 0.643 0.707 0.766 0.707 5517 5.997 4.845 5.327 0.672. 0.670 0,082 0.076 0.590 0,594 52 (P) oo 0.866 0.500 7.044 6.525 0519 0.054 0.465 75° 0.966 0.259 7.426 7.279 0.147 0.028 0.119The wedge shaped volume of cargo CMN, has shifted to the other wedge shaped volume CAB. The centre of gravity of the cargo which shifted, has moved from g to g, (horizontal shift gT and vertical shift Tg,) 2 By similar triangles, CP = 7B and g,P= Horizontal shift of g = gl = 2x CP eee pees, 3 3 3 3 Ps 2 Vertical shift of g = 1g, =2P = 3x15=10m For hydrostatic draft 8785m Displacement = 185287 t 10 Volume of cargo shifted = 7 x15x2 = 1575 m' 1stWt. of cargo shifted Transverse GG, Vertical GG, Original KG Vertical GG, FSC Corrected Kg 6 ee sind 0.000 0.087 cos 0 1.000 0.996 KN 0.000 0.760 -KGsin0 0.000 0.687 Uncorrected Gz 0.000 0.073 Transverse GG,cos® 0.064 0.063 Corrected @ (0.064 0.010 0 0.174 0.985 1517 1374 0.143 0.063 0.080 15 0.259 0.96 2.252 2.045 0.207 0.062 0.145 29 0.342 0.940 2.990 2.700 0.290 0.060 0.230 132 157.5 1.78 wxd 88.5x1 18528.7 7807 m (+) 0.005 1552 18528.7 25° 0.423 0.906 3.629 3.340 0.289 0.058 0.231 30° 0.500 0.866 4312 3.948 0.364 0.055 0.309 88.5 x 40 88.5 t 0.00477 4 0.643 0.766 5.498 5.077 0.421 0.049 0372 se 0.707 0.707 5978 5.582 0.396 0.045 0.351 18528.7 x 3 = (+)0.084 m 7896 m oo 0.866 0.500 7.027 6.838 0.189 0.032 0.157 0.0637 m 0.005 m 75° 0.966 0.259 7.416 7.628 (0.212 0.016 (0.28STATICAL STABILITY CURVE FOR STARBD HEEL Effect of shift of cargo on Stability () A permanent list of 41/2° to starbd is caused. (ii) The righting levers at all angles of heel are reduced. (iii) As a result of (ii) above, the maximum righting lever becomes smaller, (iv) Also because of (ii) above, the angle of vanishing stability and the range of stability are both reduced, e ee ie ransverse GG, = WwW ‘ssa ce 153wxd — 400x3 Ww 18529.3, Vertical GG, = 0.0648 m As explained earlier, due to the HORIZONTAL shift of the cargo, all GZ values will decrease by an amount equal to transverse GG, cos @, and because the G has shifted downwards it will increase by an amount equal to vertical GG, sin 0, for each value of 0. 6 o o> 1 eee ae sin @ 0.000 0.087 0.174 0.259 0.342 0423 0.500 0574 0.643 cos 8 1.000 0.996 0.985 0.966 0.940 0.906 0.866 0819 0.766 Original GZ 0.000 0.073 0.144 0.208 0.291 0291 0366 0371 0.374 (Cond.No.7) (9 Transverse GG, cosé 0.184 0.183 (0.181 0.177 0.172 0.166 0.159 0.150 0.140 GZ Corrected for transverse shift of G (-) 0184 () 0.110(-) 0037 0.031 0.119 0.125 0207 0.221 0.234 (+) Vertical GG, sin 8 0.000 0.006 0.011 «0.017 0.022 0.027 0.032 0.037 0.042 Final GZ (-) 0.184 (-) 0.104(-) 0.026 0.048 0.141 0.152 0.239 0.258 0.276 STATICAL STABILITY CURVE FOR THE HEELED SIDE 1584