Professional Documents
Culture Documents
$ocial Currency Currency: Why Brands Need To Build Need To Build and Nurture Social Currency
$ocial Currency Currency: Why Brands Need To Build Need To Build and Nurture Social Currency
CURRENCY
Why brands
need to build
and nurture
social currency
Editorial 2
Executive Summary 4
g
Managerial Implications
p 558
Acknowledgements 64
1
Editorial I have been studying brands for the last
twenty years. During this time, there has
been significant progress in understanding
why brands are important and how brands
Brands are socially constructed objective become important drivers of innovation and
eal t es. Brands
realities. a ds get bu
built
lt tthrough
oug eexpe-
pe growth.
g
riences, through people accepting them
There has been significant progress in the
and making them part of the fabric of their
development of financial frameworks to
lives.
monetize and measure the value of brands,
This process of building strong brands is very legal frameworks to protect brands, and a
personal and also very social. host of managerial approaches to build,
grow nurture and manage brands.
grow, brands
Today, one of the most important strengths
of a brand is its social currency, the extent to However, nothing has prepared us to deal
which people share the brand or information with today’s revolution in building strong
about the brand with others as part of their brands. The rapid evolution of the Internet
everyday social lives. and, in particular, the rise of the social
2
of media, technologies and networks not I am convinced that this study sheds new
only changes our lives, it irrevocably light on the complex and difficult under-
changes how brands are built. taking of building strong brands today.
I am pleased to present, on behalf of Vivaldi I hope that our work will stimulate thoughts
Partners and the many talented people who and more research, encourage new and
workk iin our company, this
thi study
t d off th
the b tt practices
better ti iin b
business,
i and
d llead
d th
the
power of social currency in building strong way into an exciting future of creating value
brands. for companies.
IDENTITY CONVERSATION
SOCIAL
CURRENCY
INFORMATION UTILITY
ADVOCACY
4
Executive Summary
Social currency is the extent to which people share the brand or information about the brand
as part of their everyday social lives at work or at home.
Our study shows that social currency significantly drives brand loyalty. Moreover, brands
with a high social currency command a price premium.
Social currency is a means, not the end; nor is it just about buzz or conversation. Rather it is
about creating meaningful experiences around the brand.
Which of the six levers on the left are key to effectively create social currency varies between
categories and their specific customer, consumer, and competitive context.
The successful brands in our study strive to be an integral part of people’s daily lives by
enabling them to connect, interact, and benefit from like-minded brand users.
The good news: the study shows that a set of key principles emerge that help companies to
build, nurture and manage social currency and create value.
5
This craving for commun
of every man individual
from the beginning of t
6
PHOTOGRAPHY BY ESCHIPUL/FLICKR
7
Why brands need
social currency
AFFILIATION Brands represent significant assets for
companies. The strength of brands is closely
li k d to
linked t severall well-known
ll k assett
IDENTITY CONVERSATION dimensions that drive the relationships with
customers or consumers.
SOCIAL Because of the increasing social nature of
CURRENCY Internet and mobile technologies,
consumers, and customers adopt these
INFORMATION UTILITY
technologies and platforms and integrate
them into their daily life routines and
ADVOCACY
contexts. This also changes how they
interact in all parts of life with people,
products, brands, and businesses.
8
PHOTOGRAPHY BY NASA
Hence, all companies need to learn how to In order to manage social currency, com-
make their brands more social, and how to panies must adopt new approaches and
interact in new ways with their customers. In tools. If the traditional model of brand
short, they need to develop social currency. marketing was centered around the key
principles of positioning, targeting, and
Having social currency increases a brand’s
messaging, the model of building social
g g
engagement with consumers and interaction
currency isi centered d on interaction,
i i colla-
ll
with customers, it grants access to
boration, conversation, and co-creation. If
information and knowledge, it helps
brands used to be built through creating
companies to create unique brand identities,
mindshare, the new model of building social
and it develops permission to interact with
currency is about creating share of daily
consumers or customers. In today’s age,
life.
building social currency is probably the most
important investment companies can make Companies who adopt the new processes
to create value for themselves. Consumers and tools in building social currency will
and customers will benefit as well as they prosper in today’s age of digital and social
increasingly participate in social platforms, revolution and have a chance of creating
and use social technologies. new levels of business performance.
9
How social increasingly covers the range of experiences
on how consumers interact with brands,
currency products and companies from traditional to
develops in digital experiences.
and by that, social currency is not a new Many of these social media sites are actively
phenomenon. Brand building has always used today by major brands to strengthen
been about establishing deep relationships customer service, introduce or co-create
with customers or consumers and share new products and entertain people.
their experiences with friends and peers –
In addition, there are thousands of small
their everyday social environment.
networks, forums and blogs that are not
However, especially with the development of steered by the brands themselves, but still
social platforms on the Internet, which has are important in creating social currency.
become a major sharing and connecting
Today, building of social currency takes
point, social currency has become a real
many forms, some of them being supported
source of strength for many brands.
by digital applications, others are non-
JJustt as major
j services
i lik
like Facebook,
F b k Twitter,
T itt di it l experiences
digital i iin th
the d
daily
il life
lif off con-
or MySpace have become means for sumers. Some experiences are supported by
everyday personal exchange, brands have applications and tools of companies and
grown in that space as information and others are self-created by customers and
experiences about brands are being shared. consumers.
11
Social currency:
a shared domain
of brands and
consumers
Social
S i l currency represents
t a shared
h d assett off
consumers and company-owned brands. It
originates from interaction between customers Social
and consumers. Currency
Impact of social
currency on brand
performance
Our study
O d shows
h that
h sociali l currency
significantly impacts different aspects of brand
Brand Price
performance:
Loyalty Premium
AFFILIA
IDENTITY
Identity 47 SOC
How many of your users can CURR
identify with other users? 43
INFORMATION
ADVO
Information 35
How many feel they exchange
fruitful information with others? 22
14
Conversation 72
What share of your brand users
recognizes
i and
d stirs
i buzz?
b ? 49
9
ATION
CONVERSATION
CIAL Utility 63
RENCY How many derive value from
interacting with other users? 50
UTILITY
OCACY
Advocacy 6
64
How many act as disciples and
stand up for your brand? 38
Source: Vivaldi Partners social currency survey December 2009, Exemplary results for selected brands and categories 15
How social
currency
creates value
in categories
Although social currency consists of six core
levers, a brand does not necessarily need to
access each lever in order to drive loyalty
and top line growth. Instead, certain
AUTOMOTIVE (VOLUME)
AIRLINES
BEER
SKIN CARE
FAST FOOD
SPORTSWEAR
ONLINE RETAIL
CONSUMER IT
B2B TECH
Source: Vivaldi Partners Research based on regression analyses of brand loyalty on social currency levers 17
Find out if 3. Customers or consumers are willing to
tell others about your brand or
social currency recommend it further. This advocacy for
is important your brand is one of the key value
18
brand. You can create value for your
brand and business by reinforcing the
identity-driving elements of your brand.
CHART 1 CHART 2
Source: Vivaldi Partners social currency survey, Average Top2-Box-Scores on a 5 point scale across beer category 21
CATEGORY RANKING
1 JETBLUE 65%
2 VIRGIN 58%
3 SOUTHWEST 54%
4 CONTINENTAL 53%
5 AMERICAN AIRLINES 48%
6 UNITED 42%
NES
7 DELTA 37%
high D LOYALTY
IR
BRAND
CONTINENTTAL
SOUTHWESST
AMERICAN
JETBLUE
UNITED
VIRGIN
DELTA
SOUTHWEST
AMERICAN
JETBLUE
UNITED
VIRGIN
DELTA
SOUTHWEST
AMERICAN
JETBLUE
UNITED
VIRGIN
DELTA
Recommendation 50 60 70 80 90 100
CHART 1 CHART 2
35% 20%
0%
Source: Vivaldi Partners social currency survey, US Pre-Recall (December 2009) and Post-Recall (February 2010), Top2-Box-Scores on a 5 point scale 25
T: TOYOT
How Toyota
suffered from
the gas pedal
TIVEE
recall
NAPSHOT
No surprise – Toyota’s recently admitted
quality problems heavily shifted owners’
MOT
SN brand perception.
1 BMW 69%
2 MERCEDES 68%
3 LEXUS 66%
4 HONDA 54%
MOT
5 TOYOTA* 45%
6 FORD 44%
* Data presented in the tables on this page prior to re-call 2009/10
high D LOYALTY
UT
BRAND
MERCEDES
TOYOTA
HONDA
LEXUS
FORD
BMW
Quality Perception 50 60 70 80 90 100
MERCEDES
TOYOTA
HONDA
LEXUS
FORD
BMW
HONDA
LEXUS
FORD
BMW
Recommendation 50 60 70 80 90 100
They provide their consumers with a product However, market-leading Budweiser proves
that not only stirs communication but even that there is a way to access social currency
h the
has h ability
bili to form
f communities
i i and d b
beyond d the
h niche.
i h Anheuser
A h B h’ b
Busch’s brand
d
provide a strong feeling of identification managers heavily invested especially in
with other drinkers of the same brand social media to generate more buzz and
(see CHART 2). affiliation around »Bud«.
Instead of providing a unique story around However, the case also shows, that they did
their brand, mass market brands instead not succeed completely. Such undertakings
seem to have, at the expense of their social need to be based on a consistent strategy
currency values, focused too heavily on and clearly be linked to a brand’s values.
developing their product strengths: mar- Still, there are ways for volume brands in
ginal, but socially irrelevant product and the beer category to create social currency.
CHART 1 CHART 2
47 57
Source: Vivaldi Partners social currency survey, Average Top2-Box-Scores on a 5 point scale across beer category 31
CATEGORY RANKING
D LOYALTY
BRAND
MS
BUDWEISERR
SAM ADAM
GUINNESS
HEINEKEN
CORONA
COORS
MILLER
Quality Perception 50 60 70 80 90 100
SAM ADAMS
BUDWEISER
GUINNESS
HEINEKEN
CORONA
COORS
MILLER
BUDWEISER
GUINNESS
HEINEKEN
CORONA
COORS
MILLER
Recommendation 50 60 70 80 90 100
CHART 1 CHART 2
20%
21 30 44%
Source: Vivaldi Partners social currency survey, Average Top2-Box-Scores on a 5 point scale across beer category 35
CATEGORY RANKING
7 MCDONALD‘S 23%
8 BURGER KING 21%
BRAND
40%
% 50%
% 33%
% 60%
6 % 33%
% 47%
%
53% 45% 31% 48% 35% 43%
25% 38% 19% 45% 23% 31%
25% 30% 20% 44% 24% 35%
26% 37% 15% 46% 19% 35%
22% 37% 18% 44% 18% 28%
18% 29% 15% 29% 17% 29%
16% 24% 16% 24% 19% 24%
STARBUCKS
S
MCDONALD
TACO BELL
PIZZA HUT
WENDY‘S
DUNKIN`
KFC
MCDONALD‘S
STARBUCKS
TACO BELL
PIZZA HUT
WENDY‘S
DUNKIN`
KFC
Brand Trust 50 60 70 80 90 100
BURGER KING
MCDONALD‘S
STARBUCKS
TACO BELL
PIZZA HUT
WENDY‘S
DUNKIN`
KFC
Recommendation 50 60 70 80 90 100
»fun-brands«
f b d that th t ttargett a ffocused
d segmentt
have fared better, however only managing
to create a limited sense of community (e.g.
only one out of four Axe users feels
affiliated to others).
Clinique has successfully built a strong Volume brand Dove has been praised for its
communityi feeling
f li around d its
i classical
l i l pre- re-launch
l h aroundd »reall b
beauty«, which
hi h h
has
mium positioning. Every second user claims gained them business success and a highly
that she identifies with other Clinique users authentic image. That said, Dove remains
(48%) and engages in conversations around unable to provide a sense of community, as
the brand (51%) – see CHART 2. In contrast the brand’s buzz is conversation worthy but
to many of today’s brands, Clinique would unsustainable. Additionally, by appealing to
not be a typical Web 2.0
2 0 protagonist.
protagonist every woman,
woman the brand doesndoesn’tt encourage
Instead it has managed to build social community bonds (e.g. women who use a
currency by really engaging its consumers specific product for their special skin type).
around its heritage and, importantly, by For Dove to gain social currency, it will have
acknowledging women’s unique, yet to translate real beauty into real community.
CHART 1 CHART 2
Source: Vivaldi Partners social currency survey, US Pre-Recall (December 2009) and Post-Recall (February 2010), Top2-Box-Scores on a 5 point scale 39
CATEGORY RANKING
1 CLINIQUE 42%
2 AXE 37%
3 AVON 37%
RE
4 DOVE 29%
5 NIVEA 23%
CAR
6 GILLETTE 17%
high D LOYALTY
BRAND
CLINIQUE
GILLETTE
NIVEA
AVON
DOVE
AXE
Quality Perception 50 60 70 80 90 100
CLINIQUE
GILLETTE
NIVEA
AVON
DOVE
AXE
CLINIQUE
GILLETTE
NIVEA
AVON
DOVE
AXE
Recommendation 50 60 70 80 90 100
th rapid
the id emergence off the
th Internet
I t t and
d
especially the social web in recent years,
major sportswear brands have moved into
the online domain to re-connect with con-
sumers. Various initiatives such as Nike+ or
PO
CHART 1 CHART 2
5 NIKE 30%
6 NEW BALANCE 29%
high D LOYALTY
PO
BRAND
CE
RS
N. BALANC
SKETCHER
REEBOK
ADIDAS
PUMA
NIKE
Quality Perception 50 60 70 80 90 100
N. BALANCE
SKETCHERS
REEBOK
ADIDAS
PUMA
NIKE
ADIDAS
PUMA
NIKE
Recommendation 50 60 70 80 90 100
CHART 1 CHART 2
Brand users that feel like “Through other users of this brand
being part of a community I get to learn something new or fun”
31/44
31%
44% 43%
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50%
Source: Vivaldi Partners social currency survey, US Pre-Recall (December 2009) and Post-Recall (February 2010), Top2-Box-Scores on a 5 point scale 47
AIL CATEGORY RANKING
AMAZON
ITUNES
EBAY
AMAZON
ITUNES
EBAY
Recommendation 50 60 70 80 90 100
CHART 1 CHART 2
63 38 29%
1 APPLE 63%
2 MICROSOFT 41%
3 GOOGLE 38%
high D LOYALTY
ON
BRAND
MICROSOFTT
APPLE
Quality Perception 50 60 70 80 90 100
MICROSOFT
GOOGLE
APPLE
APPLE
Recommendation 50 60 70 80 90 100
CHART 1 CHART 2
1 ORACLE 61%
2 SAP 50%
3 IBM 47%
4 CISCO 43%
5 HEWLETT-PACKARD
HEWLETT PACKARD 40%
B TEECH
BRAND
ORACLE
CISCO
SAP
IBM
HP
Quality Perception 50 60 70 80 90 100
ORACLE
CISCO
SAP
IBM
HP
IBM
HP
Recommendation 50 60 70 80 90 100
»Marketing leaders
should identify whether
their brand has such
currency, invest more
in building strong con-
nections between cus-
tomers and the brand«
FORRESTER
PHOTOGRAPHY BY ICHAZ/FLICKR
There are four crucial steps for building,
nurturing and managing social currency:
PHOTOGRAPHY BY ICHAZ/FLICKR
choosing, it is important to take into
consideration that there is no single lever
that drives social currency but it is the
unique combination of levers activated
through brilliant executions that makes for
»YOUTH DON’T CARE successful social currency building.
IF IT’S TECHNOLOGY,
Social currency can be managed. We don’t
SOCIAL MEDIA OR A
agree with the conventional wisdom that
PACKET OF CIGARETTES customers or consumers are in charge. Our
AS LONG research shows that people embrace com-
AS IT DELIVERS panies to help them solve their issues and
SOCIAL CURRENCY« challenges in daily life.
CUSTOMER BOARD
OPEN INNOVATION
CULTURAL VALUES
BUSINESS MODEL
SOCIAL FEATURES
PRODUCT DESIGN
CUSTOMER CLUB
BRAND IDENTITY
M&A STRATEGY
SOCIAL MEDIA
EDUTAINMENT
CO-BRANDING
HR TRAININGS
MOBILE APPS
SPONSORING
ADVERTISING
PORTFOLIO
CHANNELS
EVENTS
CRM
63
Thanks This study is part of a larger initiative bet-
ween a consortium of companies to under-
The study of the power of social currency in stand the power of social media and net-
building strong brands is based on a joint re- works on building strong brands, on how to
search initiative of Vivaldi Partners and Prof. connect with customers and consumers,
Johann Füller who is affiliated how to create breakthrough innovations and
ith the
with th University
U i it off Inns-
I th and
new growth, d how
h tto change
h i
companies
bruck and MIT Sloan. Our and create innovation cultures.
study has benefited greatly from a strong
These companies include Fifth Season, a
academic foundation as well as from the
global innovation boutique that produces
wealth of experiences of client executives.
breakthrough experience innovation con-
For the fieldwork we are indebted to our com- cepts and E-Edge, a company
petent survey partner, Lightspeed Research, that seeks to create winning
who carried out the online innovation cultures in organi-
field work in the U.S.A. in- zations through management development,
vestigating over 1,000 respondents in the and HYVE that specializes in innovation
time frame of Dec 2009 and Jan 2010. management through online communities.
64
Vivaldi Partners
The Authors
Dr. Erich Joachimsthaler, CEO & Founder Please direct all inquiries about the
ej@vivaldipartners.com Social Currency US study to:
Dr. Markus Pfeiffer, Managing Partner
mpfeiffer@vivaldipartners com
mpfeiffer@vivaldipartners.com
Peri Schaeffer
Dr. Markus Zinnbauer, Director
125 Park Avenue, 15th Floor
mzinnbauer@vivaldipartners.com
New York, NY 10017 USA
Tobias Honer, Senior Consultant
thoner@vivaldipartners.com info@vivaldipartners.com
65
VIVALDI PARTNERS
www.vivaldipartners.com
New York · Buenos Aires · Düsseldorf · Hamburg · London · Munich · Singapore · Zurich