Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Box & Spoon: This Issue
Box & Spoon: This Issue
Greek Fest
Youth News
Brothers of Christ?
Over the years many people have inquired as to the relationship, if any, between the Orthodox celebration of the Dormition and the
Latin feast day called the Assumption. Many have commented that several Orthodox parishes are called “Assumption” Orthodox
Church…so obviously we share a common feast day and belief, right? Not so fast. Although there are obvious similarities between
RETURN SERVICE REQUESTED the two celebrations their theological implications are poles apart.
holyanargyroi@gmail.com First and foremost, the word „dormition‟ (κοίμησις =falling asleep) is a verb found often in Holy Scriptures to refer to actual physical
http://www.holyanargyroi.org death; a theological term revealing the Christian anticipation of resurrection to eternal life. By utilizing this term „dormition‟ the Or-
(507) 282-1253 fax thodox accentuate the reality of her physical death, i.e. she was conceived in a manner identical to the rest of humanity (as opposed
Permit No. 278
(507) 282-1529 phone to the Latin doctrine of the “Immaculate Conception”), she was not immune to mortality nor exempt of mankind‟s sinful nature, and
Rochester, MN
Rochester, MN 55902 therefore had to experience death. Immediately after confirming her physical death and mortal condition we chant triumphantly
U.S. Postage Paid 703 West Center Street “You have risen to live eternally with your Son…neither the tomb nor death could hold you. As Mother of Life you were translated
Non-Profit Org. Greek Orthodox Church to life by Him who dwelt in your ever virgin womb”. As St. Germanos of Constantinople teaches us “Just like one of us she had a
Holy Anargyroi/Sts. Kosmas & Damianos body; therefore, she could not escape encountering death, the common destiny of all men…It was impossible for her, the God-
containing vessel, to be dissolved by death and corruption into the dust.”
Feast of the Dormition of our Most Holy Lady, The Theotokos and Ever-Virgin Mary August 15th, 2010 Neither the grave nor death could contain the Theotokos, the unshakable hope, ever vigilant in intercession and protection.
Game Time: 1:05pm Please feel free to contact me with any questions.
Cost: $10 for a ticket, hot dog and soda pop.
With Sincere Appreciation, Loredana Jerghiuta, 507-271-5928, loredanaj@yahoo.com
Feast of the Dormition of our Most Holy Lady, The Theotokos and Ever-Virgin Mary August 15th, 2010 Neither the grave nor death could contain the Theotokos, the unshakable hope, ever vigilant in intercession and protection.
One of many similarly phrased excerpts says the following: “Isn‟t this the
carpenter‟s son? Isn‟t His mother‟s name Mary and His brothers are The Orthodox recognize this great paradox: a
Jacob (James) and Simon and Judas? And His sisters, aren‟t they all fa- mortal woman sharing all aspects of our human-
miliar to us?” (Matthew 13/XIII 55 – 56, Mark 6/VI 3, Luke 8/VIII 19). This ity, yet she is set apart and unique because the
is the verse used by some non-Orthodox, to show that the Holy Mother had Incarnation of Christ was accomplished through
her personal will and physical body. We believe
other children. she was taken to paradise bodily, after her physi-
Yet the explanation here is simple. Even in our time, we refer to half-brothers cal death, because of the historical account (the
as “brothers”. The fact that everyone believed Jesus to be Joseph‟s son does Apostle Thomas opening and finding her tomb
empty except her zoni/belt) but more importantly
not mean that Joseph actually was His real father! The same applies to His
because it reflects the ontological reality and awe-
brothers and sisters. If some uphold that this verse refers to Jesus‟ proper some power enacted by God taking on flesh and
brothers and sisters, then they must also uphold that Jesus is actually Joseph‟s uniting the Divinity with humanity in the person
son and not God‟s. of Christ.
Let‟s observe something else: In the Holy Bible, “brethren” are also called the Now that we‟ve reviewed the Orthodox understanding of this awesome event how does it differ from the Latin
distant relatives, and not only the children of the same parentage. Observe an „Assumption‟? A majority of Western Christian thought and theology exclusively relies on the teaching of one man:
example from the lives of Abraham and Lot. Abraham was Lot‟s uncle, yet the Augustine. Augustine essentially taught that all men are born with inherited guilt of original sin, and thus are guilty and
Holy Bible refers to them as “brothers”. This is found in Genesis, 13/XIII 8. In are under God‟s just sentence of death and bondage to the devil. To say these teachings are incompatible with Orthodox
it, Abraham says to Lot: „….we people are brothers”. theology is a gross understatement and reveals why Augustine still occupies a rather ambiguous and dubious position
within the Orthodox Church. Because of this tainted theological foundation the Papacy found it necessary to formally
proclaim the dogmas of the Immaculate Conception (i.e. exempting the Virgin from original sin thereby protecting the
Another example of the many that we can present, is: “And Laban said to Jacob, for (the fact) that you are my sanctity of Christ‟s humanity) and the bodily Assumption of the Mother of God (due to the fact she was without original
brother, you shall not work for me for free”. But he wasn‟t his brother, in today‟s sense! sin the punishment of death and corruption could not possibly apply to her). These doctrines declared the Theotokos
was exempt from both the inherited guilt of original sin and death thereby revealing their departure from the Tradition of
Let‟s look at another example, in the excerpt of: Luke 2/II 48. There, the Holy Mother herself says to Jesus with the One and undivided Apostolic Church.
reference to Joseph: “behold, your father and I have been grieving and searching for you”. Are we to assume that
because Mary refers to Joseph as Jesus‟ “father”, it means that Joseph is indeed His father? Or perhaps, she wasn‟t The Latin Church‟s position was promulgated by Pope Pius XII in 1950 when he defined ex cathedra (i.e. officially
aware that Joseph was not Jesus‟ father? Well, the same thing applies to Jesus‟ “brothers and sisters”. They were all unleashing the Pope‟s „infallibility‟) the Virgin‟s bodily ascent to heaven without mentioning or affirming her physical
Joseph‟s children from another marriage. death. To simplify, because of their theological dependence on Augustine the Latin West has transformed the Theotokos
into a super-woman conceived without sin who never tasted death (immortal); almost transforming her into a quasi god-
Furthermore, the fact that in another verse the Holy Mother is referred to as the “wife” of Joseph, does not mean dess. St. John of Damascus poignantly states, “We celebrated her Dormition. We do not call her a goddess; God for-
that he had married her. We can see this, in Matthew 1/I 18-20, where, although in verses 19 and 20 she is men- bid! Such myths belong to pagan quackery, for we even proclaim her death”.
tioned as Joseph‟s “wife”, in verse 18 it is clarified that she was his “betrothed”. Thus, revealing that the Virgin
and Joseph we indeed betrothed to one another but not officially married. To equate the “Dormition” with the “Assumption” is simply untenable given the profound theological disparity. It is
impossible for us to understand and confess her bodily ascent to heaven without first confessing her death and burial.
Another argument: In Matthew 1/I 25, it says of Joseph and Mary: “….and he did not have any (carnal) knowl- Therefore, I would propose that we should preserve the ancient nomenclature “Dormition” to describe this great feast as
edge of her…” (implying that they did not have any sexual relations, given that the word “knowledge” also means opposed to using the confusing, and often misleading, term “Assumption”. For only the former properly proclaims the
“uniting” in the Holy Bible) until she gave birth to her firstborn son”. The argument here is as follows: “Why ancient teaching of her physical death and subsequent bodily ascent into paradise.
does it say „firstborn‟? Were there other children afterwards?” Again, this contains the same logic as the
“until”. Protestantism strives to make the Holy Bible say things that it doesn‟t. It supposes, without presenting “For today Heaven spreads open its arms, receiving the Birth Giver of Him who cannot be con-
any proof. tained even by the totality of all living things together. And yielding up the Source of Life, the earth
But, there is another verse that says of Jesus Christ: “…Who is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn of is adorned with blessing and majesty”.
all creation”. Are we to suppose, because the Lord is mentioned here as the “firstborn” of God, that God also had
other Sons, apart from Christ? Isn‟t Jesus “His Only-Begotten Son”, as God Himself proclaimed during Jesus‟
baptism in the Jordan river? +Fr. Mark
<< continued in the September Edition >>
Feast of the Dormition of our Most Holy Lady, The Theotokos and Ever-Virgin Mary August 15th, 2010 Neither the grave nor death could contain the Theotokos, the unshakable hope, ever vigilant in intercession and protection.
In hope of yet another successful year, Faith and Logic, Religion and Science are not seen as conflicting, by well-meaning persons. Only the erroneous placements of
the representatives of each side are in conflict. Proof of this is the fact that eminent Christians, clergymen and laymen, as well
Dan Jerghiuta as the major Fathers of the Church, were also well educated for their time and some of them – for example Saint Basil the
Festival Chair Great – were also well versed in all the sciences. Wasn‟t the Belgian scientist Georges Lemaitre – the “father” of the “Big
djerghiuta@yahoo.com Bang” theory on the Beginning of the Universe – a priest? Weren‟t many of the Teachers during the Turkish Occupation, such
507-271-7688 as: Eugene Bulgaris, Nikephoros Theotokis, Methodios Anthrakites, Benjamin of Lesvos, e.a., also the first teachers of positive
sciences in our homeland, and at the same time priests? << continued in the September Edition >>
Feast of the Dormition of our Most Holy Lady, The Theotokos and Ever-Virgin Mary August 15th, 2010 Neither the grave nor death could contain the Theotokos, the unshakable hope, ever vigilant in intercession and protection.
Youth News
Maybe you have offered your help in the past and felt rejected. Maybe you never did and you don‟t know where to
start. Maybe you never knew we needed you. Whatever the reason were in the past, we ask for your help this year.
I have participated in the Greek Festival for many years in many different ways. First just being in attendance, then
helping one Saturday in the food line, later helping the whole weekend, cooking in the kitchen, setting up, tearing
down, and lately organizing.
In all these roles I enjoyed it and had my share of frustrations. I want to share with you some of the imperfections we
all notice and explain why they should not keep you from participating:
● I don‟t know what to do – It‟s OK, most of us don‟t. Few of us cook or serve food the rest of the year. Give
it a try, try to imitate the others and by next year you will have your own system that works best for you.
● They seem to do fine without me – No matter how short we are on help, we need to figure out a way to
The new school year is just around the corner and so too is a new Church School year. It has been a few years since we serve all our customers. Hopefully we always look like we are doing fine. In reality when we‟re short on
had a Church School registration, so it's time again. It's important to have an accurate list of names, grades and parent staff the workers are stressed, tired, hungry and have no time to think of how to do things differently. Con-
email addresses for all of the youth in the parish so that we can serve them as best we can and communicate with the par- tact the Volunteer Coordinator and we will find a place for you to help or somebody to replace.
ents. Calli Kelly will be heading up this registration effort during coffee hour in the first part of August. ● I see the same people every year, they know what they are doing – actually this is a problem. There are
people who have been doing the same thing every year for many years. They are very good at it but they‟re
All children ages 3 years through high school should be registered. Questions, contact Calli: callikelly@pitel.net. The not getting any younger. We need new people to learn
first day of Church School will be Sunday, September 12th and will run through May 22nd, 2011 with a few breaks for and eventually take over.
Christmas and liturgical processions during lent. On Church School Sundays, children should go directly to their desig- ● I don‟t know anybody – this is always true in the
nated classrooms immediately following Communion. beginning. It turns out that the best way to know peo-
ple is to work together.
Class duration will range from 30 minutes for the younger children to 45 minutes for the GOYAs. Please do not disturb ● I‟m wasting my time. There‟s too many of us here
classes that are in progress by pulling your child out early or by participating in loud conversations outside the class- – this is a great problem to have. You‟re probably at a
room. There is a slight change this year to the age groupings, so check the list and make sure your child is in the correct less busy time of the day, perfect for a break to rest,
class: eat or just have fun and dance. If you leave now we
will be shorthanded when the rush hour comes.
Pre-K: Connie J, Stephanie S, Presbytera Michelle; meet in partition room #1 downstairs ● I‟ve worked all day in this heat. Why do you make
me pay $3 for a drink? – It is true that we ask you to
K-1 grade: Loredana J., Calli K.; meet in partition room #2 downstairs pay for the food and drink you consume. We recog-
nize the risk of getting dehydrated and in recent years
2-3 grades: Kris B., Kathy L.; meet in the SW room downstairs we bought bottled water in bulk for the volunteers.
We usually store it in the food cooler. If you don‟t
4-6 grades: Carl V. Terri M.; meet in the back room upstairs (old clergy office) know where it is, just ask. You can also bring your
preferred drinks and store them in the same coolers.
GOYA: Trevor H, Halina W., Bernie L.; meet in the library We ask you though not to bring any alcohol as it
would be tempting and easily accessible to underage
The GOYAs have been working hard all summer raising money for their mission trip to Project Mexico by staining decks helpers.
and cleaning parking lots. They will be in Mexico from August 10-16 and will give trip presentation to the parish in Sep-
tember. Please pray for a safe and spiritually fulfilling trip. Dan Jerghiuta
Festival Chair
Family camp will be held October 8-10 at Camp Wapogasset in Amery, Wisconsin. This year‟s speaker for family camp djerghiuta@yahoo.com
will be Father Tim Sas, formerly of St. Mary‟s Greek Orthodox Church and currently the priest at Twelve Apostles Greek 507-271-7688
Orthodox Church. SAVE THE DATE! Detailed registration information will be sent out in August.
Feast of the Dormition of our Most Holy Lady, The Theotokos and Ever-Virgin Mary August 15th, 2010 Neither the grave nor death could contain the Theotokos, the unshakable hope, ever vigilant in intercession and protection.
The death of the Theotokos was also life-bearing, translating her into a celestial and immortal life and its commemoration is a
joyful event and festivity for the entire world. It not merely renews the memory of the wondrous deeds of the Mother of God,
but also adds thereto the strange gathering at her all-sacred burial of all the sacred apostles conveyed from every nation, the
God-revealing hymns of these God-possessed ones, and the solicitous presence of the angels, and their choir, and liturgy round
about her, going on before, following after, assisting, opposing, defending, being defended. They labored and chanted together
to their uttermost with those who venerated that life- originating and God-receiving body, the saving balsam for our race and
the boast of all creation; but they strove against and opposed with a secret hand the Jews who rose up against and attacked that
body with hand and will set upon theomachy. All the while the Lord Sabaoth Himself, the Son of the Ever-Virgin, was present,
into Whose hands she rendered her divinely-minded spirit, through which and with which its companion, her body, was trans-
lated into the domain of celestial and endless life, even as was and is fitting. In truth, many have been allotted divine favor and
glory and power, as David says, "But to me exceedingly honorable are Thy friends, O Lord, their principalities are made ex-
ceeding strong. I will count them and they shall be multiplied more than the sand" (Ps. 138:17). And according to Solomon,
"many daughters have attained wealth, many have wrought valiantly; but she doth exceed, she hath surpassed all, both men and
women" (cf. Prov. 31:29). For while she alone stood between God and the whole human race, God became the Son of Man and
made men sons of God; she made earth heavenly, she deified the human race, and she alone of all women was shown forth to
be a mother by nature and the Mother of God transcending every law of nature, and by her ineffable childbirth-the Queen of all
creation, both terrestial and celestial. Thus she exalted those under her through herself, and, showing while on earth an obedi-
ence to things heavenly rather than things earthly, she partook of more excellent deserts and of superior power, and from the
And after six days he took Simon Peter and James and John his brother to a very high mountain and he was transfigured before ordination which she received from heaven by the Divine Spirit, she became the most sublime of the sublime and the su-
them, and his face shone like the sun, and his garments became white like light‟. Men whom he said would not taste death until premely blest Queen of a blessed race.
they saw the image of his coming, are those whom he took and led up the mountain and showed them how he was going to come
on the last day in the glory of his divinity and in the body of his humanity. But now the Mother of God has her dwelling in Heaven whither she was today translated, for this is meet, Heaven being a suit-
able place for her. She "stands at the right of the King of all clothed in a vesture wrought with gold and arrayed with divers
He led them up the mountain to show them who the Son is and whose he is. Because when he asked them, `Whom do men say the colors" (cf. Ps. 44:9), as the psalmic prophecy says con- cerning her. By "vesture wrought with gold" understand her divinely
Son of man is?‟ They said to him, “some Elias, others Jeremias, or one of the Prophets.” This is why he leads them up the moun- radiant body arrayed with divers colors of every virtue. She alone in her body, glorified by God, now enjoys the celestial realm
tain and shows them that he is not Elias, but the God of Elias; again, that he is not Jeremias, but the one who sanctified Jeremias together with her Son. For, earth and grave and death did not hold forever her life-originating and God-receiving body -the
in his mother‟s womb; not one of the Prophets, but the Lord of the Prophets, who also sent them. And he shows them that he is the dwelling more favored than Heaven and the Heaven of heavens. If, therefore, her soul, which was an abode of God's grace,
maker of heaven and earth, and that he is Lord of living and dead. For he gave orders to heaven and brought down Elias, and ascended into Heaven when bereaved of things here below, a thing which is abundantly evident, how could it be that the body
made a sign to the earth and raised up Moses. which not only received in itself the pre-eternal and only-begotten Son of God, the ever-flowing Wellspring of grace, but also
He led them up the mountain to show them that he is the Son of God, born from the Father before the ages and in the last times manifested His Body by way of birth, should not have also been taken up into Heaven? Or, if while yet three years of age and
incarnate from the Virgin, as he knows how, born ineffably and without seed, preserving her virginity incorrupt; for wherever not yet possessing that super- celestial in-dwelling, she seemed not to bear our flesh as she abode in the Holy of Holies, and
God wills it, the order of nature is overcome. For God the Word dwelt in the Virgin‟s womb, and the fire of his divinity did not after she became supremely perfect even as regards her body by such great marvels, how indeed could that body suffer corrup-
consume the members of the Virgin‟s body, but protected them carefully by its nine month presence. He dwelt in the Virgin‟s tion and turn to earth? How could such a thing be conceivable for anyone who thinks reasonably'? Hence, the body which gave
birth is glorified together with what was born of it with God-befitting glory, and the "ark of holiness" (Ps. 131:8) is resurrected,
womb, not abhorring the unpleasant smell of nature, and God incarnate came forth from her to save us.
after the prophetic ode, together with Christ Who formerly arose from the dead on the third day. The strips of linen and the
He led them up the mountain to show them the glory of the godhead and to make known to them that he is the redeemer of Israel, burial clothes afford the apostles a demonstration of the Theotokos' resurrection from the dead, since they remained alone in
the tomb and at the apostles' scrutiny they were found there, even as it had been with the Master. There was no necessity for
as he had shown through the Prophets, and they should not be scandalized in him when they saw his voluntary sufferings, which
her body to delay yet a little while in the earth, as was the case with her Son and God, and so it was taken up straightway from
as man he was about to suffer for us. For they knew him as a man, but did not know that he was God. They knew him as son of the tomb to a super-celestial realm, from whence she flashes forth most brilliant and divine illuminations and graces, irradiat-
Mary, going about with them in the world, and he made known to them on the mountain that he was Son of God and God. They ing earth's region; thus she is worshipped and marvelled at and hymned by all the faithful . Willing to set up an image of all
saw that he ate and drank, toiled and rested, dozed and slept, things which did not accord with his divine nature, but only with his goodness and beauty and to make clearly manifest His own therein to both angels and men, God fashioned a being supremely
humanity, and so he took them to the mountain that the Father might call him Son and show that he is truly his Son and that he is good and beautiful, uniting in her all good, seen and unseen, which when He
made the world He distributed to each thing and thereby adorned all; or rather
God.
one might say, He showed her forth as a universal mixing bowl of all divine,
He led them up the mountain and showed them his kingship before his passion, and his power before his death, and his glory be- angelic and human things good and beautiful and the supreme beauty which
embellished both worlds. By her ascension now from the tomb, she is taken
fore his disgrace, and his honor before his dishonor, so that, when he was arrested and crucified by the Jews, they might know that
from the earth and attains to Heaven and this also she surpasses, uniting those
he was not crucified through weakness, but willingly by his good pleasure for the salvation of the world. He led them up the on high with those below, and encompassing all with the wondrous deed
mountain and showed the glory of his divinity before the resurrection, so that when he rose from the dead in the glory of his di- wrought in her. In this manner she was in the beginning "a little lower than the
vine nature, they might know that it was not because of his harsh toil that he accepted glory, as if he lacked it, but it was his be- angels" (Ps. 8:6), as it is said, referring to her mortality, yet this only served to
fore the ages with the Father and together with the Father, as he said as he was coming to his voluntary passion, `Father, glorify magnify her pre-eminence as regards all creatures. Thus all things today fit-
tingly gather and commune for the festival.
me with the glory which I had with you before the world existed‟.