Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ค่าเสียหายในเชียงลงโทษในระบบกฎหมายไทย
ค่าเสียหายในเชียงลงโทษในระบบกฎหมายไทย
"
#! ,- . . /01 2 3
#! ,- , 345 46 3
'D '8 6$& . 5 :7- ) F ',8 ) ! (
$ ?D ' ' < ) 2OCCC )P (! 67'8 ' < '
: ,- 8 $ ' D ,- 8 $
' "# 'D ' 7 < : 7- H,
%#< < 8 ' ?D ' 6 ' . 5 67') F8 $ D
2
) ?D 'Q , . 5 "# )* ) ?D '$
)* ' ' $< < 'D '7 H, = 67' $ , 'D '$ 7%#<
:) 7 $H, = D 7: - )* D - & % $= % +,- $=
7 < "# 78 - 'D ' < N $ H# NC $ % $ '( $H, $=
8D- 7 'D ' D +,-87 6 @ 7D ) ?D 'Q ,
:7- 8D-+,- $= < - H, 7 8D- 78 -6 )* = NC )* - 7 < H- +,-87:7-
6 :) )* = $ 87 78 - 'D ' ; $ , = $) ?D 'Q ,
:7- : -8 ' 'D '8 6$&:7- 8 $ D ?D ' '
- % ' %#< 67' L 8 ) $!$8 - ?D ' ) . 5
- - %- , 8 $ ) ! ( ?D ' 'D '8 6$&:7- $#
)* ' & ( & ' 7 8 7 7% ) $! >& # H :7-
) $! >& )* ) $! $ = D 'D '8 6$& : - )* ?D ' '
)* $ 67'8 )P ! @0AN 'D '8 6$&:7-H, = D 7%#< ' )* &
< 8 7 ! " "# )* 7 ' 7 % %, $= - '
= 67' 7- ' ?D ' - D - $% M:7- 6 $ ( : - 6 7':
D ' % ! "# ! >& D; $= 67') ! = < )*
' ' ) H# - 6 $ ( : :7- '87R $= < $< :7-
= 'D '$ 7%#< )* = ' 2C ) 7( 8 7 < , % :7- = D 7
'D '8D-6 $ ( )* = H# NCC ) 7( "# )* = $ , 8 ' < ' :) <
8 )P 7' 'D ' 6$& ;:7-H, D 8D- D; ' 7 < 8 7 # ! "#
"# )* 7 ' $ $ # ! :7- (D $ %
D < %- D ) $ H D & '( - D - $% M# :7- %- :) - -
'#7$ '( % 6 $ (67' 7- ' ?D ' 6 $ (:7- = $= 7 SK -
7 "# ! >&:7- = 'D '8 6$&8D- 6 $ (67'8D- D +
2
&"' (
! "( ) * + ,
) T( # ( -../( " 012
3
$! 7
3 'D '8 6$& 4 )* = $ ) ! $( & >&$
"# D ' 'D '$ = D 7%#< )* 6$& = '
< ' H- ' = R$ H8 - ' 'D '8 & 7' < 67' '
' D # 3 'D ' )* '' ' 4 . 5 D 3 'D '$ 78 -
8 - - D 6$&4 .5 5 )* - ' : ; - 'D '
7 < ' $ ; H ) 1,(
+% 23!## .( %& ,4
% # & # .+ #-% ! -1.
+ 5 %& ,4# $ 6!#$ . (7. " 1 $3
N
$ 6 "& ( $ % & $ (
75 8 ) 9( :;;0( " /
/
%! 3 8 " 397
= D 7 'D '8 6$& < H, = D 7%#< 8 % $=
7$ > (-' ) : = ?D ' D $- $ ' = ?D '
% - "# ! 8 -7 = D 7 'D '8D- )* D , )
)* 6$&+,- $= 7 "# ) $!$8 - ?D ' ) . 5
8 D ') $!:7-8D- ' ' = D 7 'D '8 6$&7 <
) $! >& ) $! D M ) $! " 7( ) $! ' ) $!
3
7 )* - $< < 'D '8 6$& < & = 7 :) <
@ )* 'D '$ = D 7%#< 6$&+,- $= 7 )K ) 8D-
7 $= 67' 7- ' ?D ' < % 7' ' D ' 8D- )* '' '
8D- $= < 8
2 )* 'D '$IJ '6 $ (: - , (H# = , 'D '8 <
)* 7 % ! $ = D 7:7- D 67' = # H# &
-' D 7 M $ ! &M % = ' 'D '$6 $ (:7- + D
$= 7 <
N )* 'D '$ = D 7 8D- %#< D 'D '$ $-
.* 5 "# 8 7 : ) F 'D '$ $- $ = ' - 78 -8D-
6 $ ( 67'! = D 7L 'D '8 6$& < ' H 7' ;:7-
3 ! = D 78D- L 8 % $= 7$ > (
"# & % $= 7' 8 7 8 - = $= - ' % %, D D
D 8 - L-L "# +,- $= 7 D '8D- 7 $ $ 8 % +,- 'D ' D
$= 8D-+,- 'D ' 7 ' D $= 8D-+,- 'D ':7- 7,H, D''7D' )* -
3
>& & 6 ! O O $' G( ! D U
V ( D $' 'O2/N@OD - @0
A
&! " / , 5 : %
= D 7 'D '8 6$&8 ) $!$8 - ?D '
< H ' :7- )* 2 & @5 ) $!$ = D 7 'D '8
6$&8 & ;" 3/7 747 : 3 3 ) $! >& ) $! ' )* -
25 ) $!$ = D 7 'D '8 6$&8 & $ /:;" 3/7 74 : 3 3
) $! D M )* -
&! , 5 " / 3 8 ;" 3/7 74
7 : 3 3
&! ! , 53 <
) $! >&:7- = D ' = D 7 'D '8
6$& 8 - 8 M )* %; 8D- ?D '
'8 ) $! 67' 6$& $ $= 7 $G8 $ $ '(
$= 78 $ ' "# 8 )P ! @43A ! % >& . =
5 :7- D U( %- = 78 =D 7 'D '8 6$&%#<
8 7< ! " /
67':7- = D 7% % %- = 78 = D 7 'D '
8 6$&: - N 7 :) <
.@5 )* 7$ - % M8 - = 7%% D )
67' )* 8 - = = 8 D )* $= 7$IJ IW ?D ' MG ,
.25 )* 7$ = ' $= 767' 8 D
+ ) 6' ( "# = ' H = :7- :7- ) 6' ( $= 7$ ,
, 'D '$ - 78 -8D- 6 $ (D 8 7$ = ' 7 (:7- 6 $ ( : H
SK - :7- 6 $ (: $ 7= 7
.N5 )* 7$ $ D ?D ' :- ' - 7
8D- = D 7 'D '8 6$& = D +7 < R
67'$ :) 'D '8 6$&8 ) $! >& H,
= D 7%#< 67' , % # :7- , % )* $< +,- 7 )* +,-) =
, 'D '8 = D 7 'D '8 6$& = D 7 < R ' : ; ,%
8 ) $! >&:7- = D 7%- = 7$ - = 8 - ) =D 7
'D '8 6$&: - A ) 7 :) <
.@5 - )* $! 7 8D-6 $ (:7- 78 -
'D '$ 7%#< )* = ' ; - ' 7 (:7- = ' : %;7D
HD $= 78 > 7 :7-
* < ( 3$ ) * ,
/
* $ 4( ' !
( ( -..1( " /1;
0
$ 6 "& (3 ,* * 4( %
' ! ( :;;/( " 0..>/;;
B
0
) O / /O $' G( ! D U
! ( D $' 'G ! (O2//COD - B/
& % (- )" " " 7- 9 1( ? 7)" " -?2/9
B
"
4
'! " / = , 5 : . %
, 5 3
D U( = D 7 'D '8 6$&8 ) $!$8 - )
?D ' . 5 < :7- ?D '6 ) 78
7 :< 7- 8 - ' D ' ',8 ?D ' ) 7 9 $= 8D-
78 'D '8 6$& )* $' 8 ) $!$8 - ) ?D '
' %#< %- , $ ) ! ( ?D ' ) $! ' :7-
= D 7 'D '8 6$&: -8 ?D ' )* ' ' $ 78 7 ) $!$
8- ) ?D '7- ' 8 7 & @ -:2(- .-5 = & 7 -D (6 : (
D6 6 . 5! , 7 7 % '
. A ) 5 :7- 7 'D '$ = D 7 < )* 'D '
' '< )K ) "# 7 8D- D; = D 7 'D ' )* ' '< )K ) < H )*
D #% H) (8 = D 7 'D '8 6$&8 )9 D 8 7 5
0/( :1. .:1.5 ? 7 7 7 6" D D .A ) + 5
7 <! , 7 7 % ' :7- = 7 % ! , D Q (
. ) 5 67'8D- D + 3 = 'D '$! < -
= D 78D- < : ' ' '< )K ) 4 ! , 7 7 % '
@C
; ; O " > , .0 . 0 8 6 /: /.
0 39934 3 ?/ /7 ;: : 0!5!#&$*O $ D ,D ! U(
O2/3/OD - NB2
@C
5 ! 3 * &
@@
4( % )*
( .A :;;05 , -01
@2
7 D%
&$SX ) ( . 5 )P ! 2CC/ ! , D M
S ( '. ) 5 :7- L': - +*
& : * @0 #$ A/* +/- B , "
: !" 7' /*
' 6* *& ! #$ *& !7 #3*# /A /0 4 B C/6
& ++ , - & ,
@@
<C= 0# & 6 :
$= 7 ) $$ = ' $= %#< < H -
+ ) 6' (:7- )* = 8 $ ) ' $' = 78 - 'D '
$6 $ ( :7- = ' ; - ' $ < "# - : )* G 8 + D 7
7:7- $< < D ! = 7 ' L = D 7 'D '$ 7%#<
$ $6 $ ( , (:7-' + $ $= 8D-+,- $= 7: %;7D $=
7D < D = + ) 6' ($+,- $= 7 . = '5 :7- $= 7
)* )9 '8 ) = 'D '8 6$& - ' + 8D- = ' 7
8 , '+ ) 6' ($ - , ':) $= 8D- 7 8
$= 78 :7-
<D= +/- + *
$= 787R = ':7- 'D ' 7%#< -
= ':7- %- ' '' ' D $ 'D '8 + D $= 7 < "# +
$= 8D-+,- 'D ':7- 'D ' 7 - ' D , 7 :7- 7 ; ' %#< $
'D '% = '8 <' - = ) 8 = D 7 'D '
8 6$&7- ' )* 7D' 8 = 'D '8 6$&$ = ' - 78 -
)! " / , 5
)! .44 " /. " 3 " "
= 3 :D $7 $ 4 $8 - 8 ?D ':$' < )* = $ )
! $( & >& 3 4 "# D ' 7 ' 'D '
:7-D 'H# L ' = $! = D 7%#< 7 ' 'D ' ' $
' 3 'D ' 4 . 5 $ < D 1 .+
$ " 5 3# $#$ & $3 6! # " & ! : %. &
1.#.# $ . ; ( #. <= & ## $#$ ." 6 &" &
@N
6 O " > , .0 . 0 8 6 /: 1
B/ B; 3 ,O $ D , O2/30O @/0Y@/B
@2
@3
! $'(O " > , .0 . 0 8 6 0 # 4 $&%
DE 4 %&#O ( < $/ $ D ,6 ( - O( 2/2AO 244
@/
3NB :D $7 $ # 8 -67' H 87 ' 87 < 8D-! L'
> ( -' D 7
# :D $7 $ < :7- $ '( +,- 'D ' - ':) 7
D 8- $ '( < $< 'D ' # 8D-8 - 'D ' ' 87R :7- %#< < 7- '
@N
@A
!: ) G(O " > , .0 . 0 8 6 3 8 /O
( < $ @CO $ D , = ( O2/3AOD - @//Y@/A
@3
@0
! $'(O " > , .0 . 0 8 6 0 # 4 $&%
DE 4 %&#O ( < $ /O $ D ,6 ( - (O2/2AO 24/
@/
*! 6 3 " ,3 : 3 / / , 5
*! 43 ,3 : , 5
7 $:7- - %- - D < M8 = D 7 'D '8
6$& =D 7 :D $7 $ $ :)8 7 7 ) D
= D 7 'D '8 6$&' :7- $ % ?D ' $< 8 % ?D '
$ )* D ?D '8 7 7 .) ?D ' '(5 D 8 ?D '
!& . ?D ' 7 5 $= 8D-: H = ) 8 -8D- 7+ 8 $ )F :7-
' : ; - - %- , ) F+ 'D '8 6$& ) F8
?D '% ) $!:$' )P ! 2303 67') F8 ,)% D + ) = &%
! ? "# ! :7- ) 8 - 67'+ $ $ 3NB D ) ?D '
'( =D 7 :D $7 $ 8D- = , %#< 'D '$ 7%#<
+,- 'D ' 8 )9 :7- = D 7 'D '8 6$&: -8 ?D ' !& . ?D ' 7
5 L "# 7 8D- D; = D 7 'D '8 6$&8 ?D ':$'
)* $' ' %#< $< < ) F ' ) 8 - 'D '8 6$&8 ) $!:$'
H ' :7- 2 & :7- .@5 = &% ! ? .25 ?D ' 7
"# ' '7 7 :) <
*! ! " 00
7 5
" 00 $''H#%(%
8 7 < 7 ! :7- 7 6$& = 'M ' ' Z 6 $ (
6 $ (:7-SK ' :D $7 $ = ' = D # ! $< 7 8D- = '8 - :D
$7 $ 6 $ (! ? - D; ;" /: " = ;. : .
$ = ' ' 6 $ ( = ':7- 7 ' 7,D 6 $ (67' :7- % 8 = "#
6 $ (:7-)F D - $ ',8 % < $< ' $- $ '6 $ (8D- :) )* > (
' ! $< :7- " / /. : A 7E1 78 -8D- 6 $ ( # -
&'
# " 00 $$'H#%(&
= ': ' L7 $= 6 $ ($ < 8 < $
= 'H, SK 8 $ = '' :7- 8D- = ' %- = ' 6$ ( '
) $= 8D-6 $ ( ' ' ' '! :7- ' =D 7=
:D $7 $ D <'$= % 8 'D '% 7 < # " / : 3 4= ; 6
/: 3 1" " ;. 0 : ,- " 3 ,I 3 " ?/ 3 8 1
@A
J : ! ? D; $! D 7 $ = D 7 = :D $7 $ D <'$= %
8D- 6 $ ( # D (8 7 < -
$ " 00 '%H#&+
= '8 - $ )* &$ ' $6 $ (8 -
$= 8D-6 $ ( 'D ' D( - D; 0<4 864 K ; 6 " . / DE
: . . /7 ;" 67' L ' ' +,-$ $- D ' < - ' IW 8 -
% 6$ ( )* ' 7 $ 7 $G% 6 $ ( )
?D ' '( 3NB 5 " ; " / /. : /:4 . 8
= & ? $< ? < D; :7- - 'D '
$! = D 78D- = , 'D '$ $- ; )* :) H) (D 8
=D 7 :D $7 $ 67'$ :) )* 78 - 'D '8D-6 $ ( ,
7 $ 7 67' :7- )* :) 6$& = '8D- %;7D )K ) 8D- $=
7 < 7 $ )* H) (D % = D 7 'D '8 6$&67' $-
*! !# /3 0 39934
- H- ' = 3 'D '8 6$&4 )* H- ' = 8 $
8 )9 H- ' = 7 <' :7- = D 7 D '$ 7 8 $ ?D ' 7 D;
:7- $= D ! $( ! ( >& >:$' :$' > >& L
U ' H . ( < $ /5 ! 2/30 D ! $( ?D ':$' L
U ' H . ( < $ N5 ! 2/33 "# H )* D - $+,- %' :7-
8 % = %' $ < : ) F D '% H- ' = < ) 87 ' : ;
H- ' = < 8 ?D ' 7 8 ?D ':$' < =
3 'D '8 6$&4 ) F8 R 3 L :7-
0 3 934
9 3 : 0!5!#&%&
67':7- = D 7 'D '8 6$&: -8 @N
D $ - ! 2/3/ "#
3 @N 8 =D 7 :D $7 $
SK 7 B .25 ! = =D 7 D U( 7 :) <
.@5 =D 7 :D $7 $ L 8
'D '$ 7%#< ' $- ! = 8D-+,- 7 $G8 $ - + ) 6' (
$:7- D 767' 7 %- :)8 :D $7 $ :7-
.25 8 $: =D 7 :D $7 $ .@5
:7- 8D-! =D 7 :D $7 $ 8D- +,- $ - = $! D;
.N5 8 $) FD M 7 7 $G
8 $ - )* $= 67' 8 D - )* D 8D- $
-7 < )* $ - 8D-! 8D-+,- 7 ' /. 0
@0
$- < $< < 67' = # H# > ( R -' % 'D '$+,- 'D '
:7- $+,-) ,-H# : ) 7 '% - ' $+,-) ) )X7
: ) 7 '% - 7= % +,-) $ - < )* - $:
) 7 ' + ) 6' ( $ +,- ) :7- H $ % +,- ) $
+,-) :7- $ 'D '$ 7%#< 7 $+,- 'D ' 8 8D- 7
'D '7- '4
% 0 39934>0; 8 /?A: J 0!5!#&&
67':7- = D 7 'D '8 6$&: -8 32
D G 7+,- 6 ! 2//@ "#
3 32 H- $= $H, SK - 7 $
+,-) G $= 67' ) ' +,- 6 67': )* G D 8 8D-+,- 6 :7-
'D 'D ) $ ' -' : = 'D '$ 7 +,- 6 D
$= )* IJ IW +7 8 M +,- D G ' )* $: - 8
% ) ! = & 8D-+,-) G 78 - 'D ' +,- 6 8D-!
= 8D-+,-) G ' 0 %#< = 'D '$ $-
$! = D 7:7- $ D; $< < 67' = # H# > ( R 'D '$
+,- 6 :7- + ) 6' ($+,-) G :7- H $ % +,-) G $
+,-) G :7- $ 'D '$ 7%#< 7 $+,- 6 8 8D- 7
'D '7- '
=D 7 0 D #
8D-! = = D 7:7-: $% 'D '$ $- $! = D 7 H- 'D '$
$- $! = D 7 = : D- D $ 8D-! = =D 7 0
:7-: D- $ % 'D '$ $- $! = D 74
*!# , 76 " 3 :
=D 'D '8 6$& ) 8 - 8 ?D ':$'
H 8D- 7) 6' (:7- 7 :) <
.@5 $= 8D- 7= 7$ 8 $ ' 7 7 %- %;
) $G ' %#< $< < H) (D % =D 7 'D '8
6$& 6$& = '8D- %;7D )K $= +7$ 7%#<
8 : 7%#< 67' = 'D 67' "# + $= 8D- %
' 8 $G %#<
.25 H )* 8 7= 6' ' ) % M$
) (8D- 7 8 $ ?D ' ' $ -D
)F $: )* G )* -
@4
+! =,
=D ' 'D '8 6$& ) 8 - 7 78
) $!:$' < H )* $ '7 )* ' ' $< < 8 ?D '% :$'
:7-' D =D 7 :D $7 $ 78 - 'D '$ $- )* '
) ) ' 7 D $ :) < 8 '
' 8D- 7)9 D 8 $ )F :7- ' : ; & % $ -3 A # $(
, +, & # $#$ . $!,+"" ; #.(
%A # $( # * + .#.( 1,. . # $ ## $ #/
,$ ): %+ : %" " ,4$!,)$$ %& ,$" # #"# $# .
. @% 2 35,$ - %& ,4# $ 6!#$ 6. # "
#$ . # * #+ ,9 ,$ ! 5+ . #.(
0 . .# = D 7 'D '8 6$& # H :7- = )* '
- :%)9 D ' 7 7 ,) 8D R 8 = 'D '8
6$& ) 8 - H -:%)9 D 8 < :7- - 'D '8 6$&'
& )* - D =D 7 :D $7 $ $8 - ',8 )9 8D- ) $G
' %#< L< =D 'D '8 6$& ) 8 -67' = D 7D U(8D-
& $7 $ D ?D ' 8 -8D- D % )9 D $
7%#< & < RD ' 'D '8 6$&' H - ) 6' (
8D- ?D ' & 7% :$':7- )* - ' G 8D- 7
$ D # 7- ' 7'