c c

c c 
c
c
S



c

c  c
c cc  c
c
©
c  c cc c c
c
 c Definitions
c c

c Jechem, Floydcc c
cc c ccc
cccc
¦c cc cccc  c
cc c
c
cc cc c c c
c cc
 cc c c

c cc c cc 
c c
c
 cc
c c !c 
c cc
 
c

c cc 
!
c cc cc!c cc
c cc
c"c
 c c

cc cc 
c
¦c "c  c c cc c  
c c#!c
c$c
jc  
c csovereign functionscc
jc ccreationcc c
c
cc
 cc
jc
c cc
jc   cc
jc 


c cc 
cc
jc  c cc
cc
jc c

c cc 
c c
c 
c
c

c ©dministrative Code (Exec Order No 292)c
c
¦c V
c
c%  
c c 
c&c"cV c c
c
c ! cc'

c!
 c c  
!
c
c
c'cVc cc! c
c  
c c!c
c
(c cc'cVc' !!
c cc
 c


c 
c cc) 
!
c c c c cc  c! c c ! c!  c
c

c

c
c c
cccc

cc!c
c c!c
 c c
!
c c !
c  !c c cc
c
*c
c

+c c!
!
c! c

c cc  
 (c cc cc ccc
cc c
c! c!c c c
!cc  
 c cc (c
c c

c

c cc
 +c 
cc
 

c  c cc !
c c
c 
c cc

c
ccc !
c
¦c V
c,
cV c cc'cV
c&cc"c'cVc! c c
c
c
!
 c
c

c cc) 
!
c

c 
!
&
c c
 c   
c c 
c 
c
¦c V
c
cV 
c&c"c- *c cc  c c c 
c c
c
cc
 c
c
c cc
'
cc. cc'

c' !!
c! c !
c
c c! c 
c c c
!c/ c

cc- c c 

c
c  c
c c
c
c 
c
c

c §evised Penal Code c
¦c c01
c2 c cc 3c4c/ cc c c 
cc 
c cc
cc
cc cc
 *c
c
c  ccc 
c c c  c
c c  
!
cc !
c  c c *c
 c
cc !
c cublic functionsc
cc
c) 
!
c c c !c
c c 
!
c c

c cc
cublic dutiesc c
c! c 
c c 
c  c c
c
*c c c cc
!c cc cc 
c
c
2 c Purose and Nature - #!ccc 
c cc
 c cc 
c

c c
 
!
c c567c! c! 
c  5c
c!

c c c 
cc cc c
c


c

c Public Office, as a Public Trust (987 Constitution, ©rt XI) c
¦c [ c c c cc
c
¦c [ c8c cc
 c c  
 c
c
cc
jc c ccc
cc c
c! c!c c c!ccc
 c  
 c cc cc

c
c c

c c 
c
c
 c c!c c! c
c
c  c
c
c
 c c c  !c
c8c
 c  c! c
cc
jc "c
c8 
c cc


c
cc ccc c c 
cc
c9%c
c c
cc  
cc
jc ' c c'
c c: cV
 c c$c:cc c c c!c cc
c c
;c
c

cc
c

c Public Office, not Proertycc
¦c [ c8c c!  c c

c  
c c
cc
jc åc c<cc=c*cc
c  c !c cc 
cc
jc  cc
c 
c"cc
c
 c cc c 
$c
 c cc  c c  
c c!c
 c §!  ;

c  
c c c
 c   c c c!
;
cc !
 
c
 c 9 c cc
cc *c
c c 

c cc c
¦c [ c  c
ccc
c
cc 
cc
¦c [ >cc
c
c cc
c c 

cc
jc [c! cc c !c 
c

c c c
jc Pcc c!

cc!c cc c c ccc cc c
jc !c

c c cc?
c%c $c2
cc
 c c cc?
c c
 c c c c
cc
c cc 

cc
¦c [ >cc
c c!
cc
jc '

cc ?ccc

cc >c cc
c

c Public Office, not a Contractc
"c! c! 
c  c c
c
c c !c
c! !
c c
 cc cc 
c
c


c c
c c
 c c 
c cc
 c c !c cc 
c

c c 
!
c cc
 cc!c cc
c cc(c@c c !c 
c cc 
c cc 
cc c
 c c8 c  c cc!c
c cc c ccc

cA
cc c
c c
cc
cc
 cc
c cc 
c
¦c ' c
c
  c 
c 
c c
ccc
¦c c ccc c !c
cPcc
c c
 c
cPc c cc c c 
cc
¦c )
 c
c c c c !
 

ccc
¦c V  cc!c

c
c !c
c c cc ccc
c c
 c
c c!

cc
c c
c 
c cc% cc
c

c Vecurity of Tenure in Public Office as roerty for uroses of due rocess &cc
c
]
   

 








½
cc
cc1933, Campos J.0c
S
d
c

c  c
c c
cc c
cc  ccc

c
c c
ccc c
c  c cdc
 c
cc
 ccc
c
cccc c

ccc
c c
c c ccc  ccc c c ccc c
cc
c
c c
cc
  cccc ccc cc c

cccc c

c  cc
cc  c

cc
 cc
c

cccc

c c
c c c c
cc cc cc cc  cd c cccc
cc cc
cc c
c ccc 
 c
cc c
c c

c  c
cc c

cc ccc cc ccc c
ccc cccc
d  c  cc
c cccc cc
 c cc  c
c
 cc c
c
ccc

c c c
c
 c
c
 c
 c cc c

c
cc cc
c c

cc    c  cc

cccc
c
ccc
 ccc
c
c cc
cc

c
c ccc
c cc

c
c 
c

c  ccc



c ccc
c c
 c

c
c c

c c Õ
c
c
c ccc c
 cc


c! c
 c
c

cc c
c c cc
c ccc cc

c c c
c
 ccc  c

 c
 
c

ccc cc
c
ccc ccc

cc
 c c
 c c ccc

 c
 cc
ccc
c
ccc

c
 c  ccc
c
  cccc c

c c
 ccc  c c c

c c c

 cc
cd c c  cc c
   c
 c
c

cc

c
 cc½
0ccccc 
c
cc c

cc½ 0ccc cc c
 cc
" ccc c c ccccc ccccc

c ccc
  c c c c c

c   c

c
c
 c
c
c cc ccc c c cc
cc cccc ccc

c cc c




ccc
 c  cc
c

c Distinctionsc
c
©V TO PUBLIC OFFICE PUBLIC CONT§©CT
c c 
c ' 
c

c c 
c 
c !cc c c
 
c
 c8c c! 
c! cc

cc
c c 8c ' 
c cc 
c c c c P! c  
c
c
c
c  c
 
!
 c

c 
c
c 
cc !c

c
c 
cc
 c
c c8c! c :! cc c c
c 
c
c ! c  c!c
cc 
c
c

c cc 

c
ccc

c c
c 8
cPc!c
c
c!c
 c c
 c


c
c cc
c  
c c c
c
!

c
c! c c !c  cc


c c 
cc
c
¦c "c c cc c c  c 
c c 
!
 c

c c
c
c
c c
 ccc
c cc
 c cc 
cc
c
©V TO PUBLIC OFFICE PUBLIC EJPLOYJENT
Bc
 
c cc
c c
c! !

c9 c c c c c
c
c
 c c c*c
 

cc
#

c c 
c ' cc c  *c
c cc  
c!

cc
9 c cc P
 cc c c !c 
c cc
 
c c
c
3 c Elements
c

c '§:":%c$cc
c'

c
0cc ;; ; c c
1c !c c c 
c c c c c c c c
c c

c A"[§P"Cc c c !c 
c cc 
c c ccV c cc c cA-P'cP9":§:V"c

c 2:§Vc
c/A9'"P9Vc
ccc
c'

c
0cc ;; ; c c

c %c 

c c c:§/§#:%cP9%::9%:9"Cc  c
 c c c c c c
c c
A9:VVcc c c c
c
 c c 
c c c c  +ccc c
c c
cc
cc
 c
 c c c c c c 
cc

c '9"P9AP9)c9%c:§#9:9"c
c
c
c
c  
c c
!

cc
c
´ c Creation of Public Office

c
c c

c c ´
c
c
¦c )
 cc

c c  c 
c cc  c
ccc
¦c -c'
c
jc :D':"$c c ccc

cc
jc %
c cc'
c c c c
 c c c  cc

c c c  cc c 
c

cc
jc '
 !
c cc c c c cc'
c! c* ccc?  
c c

cc
cc! c c
cc 
cc
¦c -c
cc
jc Vc1c c:c00c4cå"c
c8c cc c cc: cc
c
c c c c
!c
!c
c
c c cc


c  c c 
+cc !
 c
c ccc cc

=cc
c
Ë c ·inds and Classifications
c

c c c
c c

c

c 'c c
0
c # c c
c
-
c c c 
cc

c '

c c
0
c V  c c
c
'
c c cc !
c c 
!
c c cc
c

c  c
0
c : c
1
c . c
c
%
c c c
c c 
!
cc

c 9 
c c
0
c   c c
c
:
c c c c c c
cc?c

c E &8 c c
0
c #
 c c
c



   
½"#$cc
cc , Buena, J.0c
S

 ccc c c c½  cc c#"cc
 cc c#
% 0cc
cc
cc

 c
c&c  c

c cc  c

ccc cc   c

cc 
 c
cc
 c
c cc
 
 ccc
c
c
c  c c c  cc
 ccc c  c
c
c

c
 c
 c c c c c c
cc c

c
cc  
 cc
c cc

c

cc c cccc   ccdccc c½
c0cc
cc   c
c c

 c
 

 c

c

cc
cc cc

cc
  c c cccc
½
0c
cc   c½
c0c
½ 0c
cc½ c cc
c  0c
½"0c
c  c
cc½c
ccdc cc c
c c
ccc c cc0c
cc c  ccc cc
c cc
  cc cc  ccc
cccdc c
  c c cc
c
 cc
 c
c c c cc
cc c
ccc
  c
ccd cc
c c   c
c&ccccc c
 c ccc  c 
  cc
c cc cc cccc  cc c

c c
cc

cc cc
c  c
c
cdc
c ccc  c c

 c
c
cÔarin v Executive Secretaryccc c
cc#c½c


 cc
c&!c
"0c
c c cc$
#c½c
c&!c
0ccc$ %c½c
c&!c
#0cc c
c  c c

c
c c

c c Ë
c
c
c " c c % cc
cc  c½
$#cc 0c c cd c
ccd cc
c  cdc
## c cdc

c
c
d
     ½
cc
cc1995, Kapunan, J.0c
S
d  c ccd c   c
ccc c ccc c
cc cc
  c
c c"½
0c
cc"%
c½
cc 
cdc0 c  c   c
c c
ccd

cc

c  c c c
c cc c
cd cccc
 c
cc
 ccc c
cc c
cc  c
c

 c
c
cccc  cc
cc  c
cd cc c cc  c
 ccc cc

c

 cc
c
ccc
 c
cc ccc
 c c½  c
c
cc

c
 cc
c
 0 ccc
 c

cc
 cc  cc
c c c c c c
c c c c c
c  c
c " cc ccc c
c

 cc
 cd ccc

c

c cc
cc
c cc"%


!ccccc

c

c
ccc c c

 

cc d c  cc
 c
c'

c

'cc  c c"%
cc  c c c ½
0c

c'
ccc


c

cc
 c
c c
cccc
c c 
c c
 cc c
 
 cc c
 cc  c c c 'c
cc c c' 'c cc
 cc

c

cc c ½
0cccc

 cc c ccc'
c

c c
 c'ccc c c
c
 ccccccc
c
c c  
 

cc   

cc
cdc$%#c
  c
cc   c
cccc  cc
ccc
 c
c
$# cc
ñc 
  

cc
 ccc
c(cc
c ½
0c 
c c
c cc c
cc  cc
ccc
c c
ccccc
c ½ 0c cccc cc
 c

c
cc ccc  ccc
cc

 c  c c
c cc

 c cccc cc  c
cc
 c
 c
cc

c
 cc c
c c ccc  c
c ½
0cc

ccc
 c c 
c

c
c ½ 0ccc c

c
c
cc c cc
 ccc
 c
ccdccc
 c c
 
c

½0c
c ½"0ccc
c
c  cc
cc
cc
c

ccc
 c c 
c

c
c ½0c  c
 c c c c
 ccc ccc ccc
c c c cc


c c c
c  c
c ccc c
ccc
  c c c
c 
ccc

c

 ccc cccc ccc

c c 
cc

c c c
c cc c

c
cc c
c cc
 c
 cc c cc
c ½0c cc c
  c
c  c cc c cc c   c
c
 
d

½$$cdccc1951, Bengzon, J.0
S
d
c

c  c
cc c

c  c  cc

c
c

c   c cc  c

c c
%c
½c
0 cc
c
c  c
cc
cc

c  cc
cc
c½d
%0 cc
 c ccc

c

ccc c

cc %"
!ccc cc

c
 ccccc cc

 
 
c
c cc
c c  cc
 ccc

c

ccc c

cc %"cc cc
 c' c
c
c
  c
cc

c c c

c
c 
c  ccc
ccc

c
c

c
 c
ccd

c c cc


ccc c cc
cc
c

c ccc
 c c c

c

c ccc c 'cc

 cc c 
c
 ccc cc

cc
 cc
 c cc  c& cc

c
ccdc cc
ccc cccc
c

c

c
c
'

'cc'
 ' c
c  c
c
c

c
c

c
 c
cc
cc& cc

c
c
 c

cc
c


c
c

c
 cc

c c  cc
 cc

c

 cc
 cc c
ccc
 cc


c
cc c
c

c
 cc c c  c c cc


 c
c  cc

cc

c cc cc c

c  c
cc
c

c c
c c
c
c

c cc cc
 cc c
c
c
 ccc c
c
c

 c

c
c c

c c ë
c
c
c
 



c½"$
cc$cc , Kapunan, J.0c
S
 c cc "c
cc   c
c c
cc
 cc
$ c c  cc c c
c  c cc
$ccc
cdc c c c
 cc  cc
cc cc  ccc
c
cc c½ c
c
c

c
 c
cc& c cd ccc

c  c) 0cc
 
cd cc c
cc
 c
cc c c
c
cc  ccc
c ccc  c  c cc
c c c
c  c
cc"%
 c
c c
c  ccc cc

c

ccc

 c
cc"%
c
  cc
c
c
 
cc  cc& c cd cc ccc
cc
c 
cc
c c cc  cc cc

c

 c
c " c cc
c
ccc
 
ccc cc

c

 cc
c  c c†y vs. Sandiganbayan cc  c
cc
ccc cc 
c
cc 
c  c
c

c

c
cc #cc  cc
 c
 cc

c c
ccc #c c cc
 
cc  cc
c cc c  c c c
 c c ccc

c

c cc
cc
c
c  c
cc"%

!cc

c c
  
 
c
cc c ccc
 c
c

c

c
 ccc##%c½
c0c cc   cc

c c
c

c

ccc c  cc ccc 

c
cc
cc
cc c
 cc
c
cc c
  ccc
 c
cc c
cc cccc c
 c
cc  c
 c
cc
c c
cc
cc
cc

c
cc

 cc c cccc

c

 c
cc cc
cc

c

c  c cc cc  c

c  c
 cc c
ccc c

c cc cc  c
cc
 c
c
c ccc  c
cc
 ccc

 c
cc d c
cc c
cccc c
ccc
 c
ccc c½
0cc  c
c
  c
 c½ 0cccc

cc ccc 
 cc½"0c  cc c
ccc

 c
 c
cc ccc c
cc
cd


c  c ccc  c cc c

c c
cc  c

 c
c c
ñc c  c
$c cccc c
cc  c
 c
c ccccc c c
ccc

 ccc
c
cc c c  ccc
 c
cccc
c
cc c
c cc  ccc

c c
  cc c
c'c c
ccc
c c
cc
cc cccc
c
c ccc c
c
 cc
 cc c
 'cc c

 c
c cc
 c
cc
ccc
c
c c
c cc ccc
cc*c
cc   c c  ccc  cc  cc
 cc
c c ccccc  c
c ccc c
c cc c
cc
  ccc c   ccccc
ccc
c c
c
cc

 c ccc c
cccc

cc
 c
ccccc c  c

ccc

c c
c
cc
cc

c  c
c cc c
 ccc
c  c c
c cc

c
c
cc ccc
c'ccc
 c

'ccd c  c'cc
c
c cc ccc

cc c
c cccc

c
cc cc
c ccc c cc c
cc
cc c  c c
  'c
c
S
 

  c½  cc
 cc1995, Feliciano, J.0
S

c d
c

c  c c

ccc

c c cc

c½cc
c

0 c&ccc

 c
c

c
cd c
 cc ccccc c
cc

c
cd c  cc
c d c
cc 
cccc c c cccc   cc
c
c cc
c
 c

 ccccccc

c c
c
c

c ccccc
c c cc

c!c
cc cc   c cc
 c   c c c c
c cc

 
c

c
$#ccc ccc c cc   c  cccc cccc

c  c
c c
c

cc   cc

c
c cc  c
c ccc c
c ccc
 cc
 ccc

c
c c

c c ˜
c
c

cc  cc cc   c
cc  c
 c½ c
c
c  c

0 cc& cc

   cc c
cc

 ccc
c
 cc cc
ccccc
 cc
c

c cc

c
cc  cc c

c cc

c

c

c
cc

c c
 c

 c c c
cc  c ½#0c cccc
cc
cc
$#cc c ccc c
 cccc
  cc
ccccc
c c c
c c
cccc cc
c ccc
 cc c  c c cccc cccccc  c
cc  ccc cc
 
c
c c ccc cc c
c cc
c
cc cc
c

c cc

c(c cc c(c cc

 c c½Jiclat v. Ganadenc+
%,cJaro v. Hon. Valenciac
+
",0 c+Brillantes v. Guevarrac½
0, cc
c

 ]
c½#cdc"cc195, Jalcolm, J.0
S
d
c

c  c cc c

c
cccc cc
c cc c cc c
c c
 c
  c   cc c
cc c   cc
 cc
 c
cc c"
%#cc
 cc c
cc
cc c c
cc
cc
c


c cc ccccc c

cc
cc c
c c c c
 
c

cc
 

cc  ccc ccc cc cc
c  cc c
"c-ccc
 c
cc  c
c
cc c
%c-c cc
c  cc c
 #c-c  c c
 cc
c  cc %"cc %c½ c c
c

cc
c  c
cc c"
%#0c
ccc c
c  ccc cc ccc

ccc c
c 
c
c  ccc 
cccccc c cc

 c
cc cc c
ccc
c ccc c
ccccc

cc c
cc c  c
cc c"
%#c c
c c %"c
ccc c c c c
c c

 ccc
 
c c

c
c
 c
c c  cc
  cccc c c c %"c
ccc cc
 cc c %c
ccc cc
c c
cc
c c c

c  c c
  ccc
c

c

  c
c ccc


c c c
cc
ccc

cccc
c
c
  c
c
c
c c ccc c c c
c 
cc  cccc
 cc c c

c


cc c
c

 c
c
 c½
#cc$ccc1989, Sarmiento, J.0
S
 cd  c c"c cc
c
c   c ccc  c    cc
cc  c  c
 cc c

c½ cc c
c

c cd
0 c
c c
#c cc  c
c
 c
c
c
  cc
#c
cc   c
cc
c&cc  c
c
   cc
c   c c
c  c  c c
c cc c cc
 c
c   c c
'cc

 cc
  cc
 c
 cc c  c   c

c c
cc

c
c c
 ccc
c
 c cc c
c"c
 cc cc c
ccc c

c
 c c ccc cc c ccc
c cc #c
 ccc
 cc   c
c
c  c cccc
 c cc
 

 c c
cc
c&
 c c
$#c c


c   c
cc  cc(c
c
cc c
c

 c(cc  cc cc 
c½c c
 c 0cc c cc  ccc

 c

ccc  c½c cc
cc 
 c
cc
 c 0cccc
c

c
c c
"c
c cc c
#cc
 cc  c c c cc  ccc c
c 
c
  ccc c  cc c  c cc
cc(c cc   c c c
c
cc(ccc  cc  c c c

cc ccc
 
cc ccc
c

  ccc
c
c c c   c c
c
ccccc
c  c
c
 c   c
c

c c
 c

c
c c
c  c c c
c
 c
cc
c
c
 c
cc
 c
c c cc cc  c c
c
c"c  c
 c
c
ccc cc
c c

$c
$$ cc
cccc c'
'cc  c
c   ccc c
 cc
c
ccdcc c
c
c

ccc  c

c    c&ccccc

c c
cc

  cc c
c

c
c c

c c 
c
c
 cc c
# c cc c
c c c c cc c
#c
c
c cc    c ccc
ccccccccccc
cc  cc
c

 

c½" %cc#%"cc1999, Ynares-Santiago, J.0
S
d
c

c  ccc.ccc

 c cdc c
c cdc
ccc

ccccc

cccccc
c c

c
  ccc  ccc
 cccc  c ccc cc
c
c cdcc
 
cc


cc d c""#c cc c c c cc cc c c c
c
 cc
c


c c c c
c
 cccccccc

 c
cc 

 ccccc
ccccc  cccc

ccc

cc
%ccc c
  c c
 c c''c
c
c c
 cccd c c"c
cccccc
c

 c cc d c""# c c cc c"c
cc  cccc
 
 c
cc
 c
cc

c.c cccd ccc
c c
 cc c c
  cccc c  c c
cccc

c c cc 

ccccdc
  c ccc
cc
  c
c d c
""#c ccc
c c

cc ccc c

c cc c c
c  
c
ccc c c
 c cc
c
c
c c cc
 c
cc'
 
 'c
c

c
 c cc

  c
cc c
  cc
  c
ccc cc  c
 
 c
cc
 c
cc.c ccdc c
 c
ccc
c c cc
c
ccc cc c
c

ccc
 ccc'c
 c
c
 c
c
cc c


c c c  'cc cc 
c c  cc

c
ccc cc
cc cc
c c
ccc
c d c""# c
cc c
  c
c d c""#cc ccc
cc
c c

ccccc c

c  cc
c
ccc
 c c c cc cccc c    cc   cc

cc
 c

c
c
 c
 ccc cc c
c c

 cccc
 c c
##c
c d c""#cccc
c
cc
  cc
c c

cc c c
c c
 c cc  c  ccc  cc c cc
c
 c

c c
ccc ccc c

c cc ccc cc c c cc
cc c  c
 c c''c
c
c
 c c c"c
cccccc  c

 cc c  c
cc
cc

 c
 cc c
c  ccc  cc
ccccc c c
cccc  c
ccc c

  c c

  cc

 cc c ccc  c c

ccc

c
cc

c c
c ccccc  cccc
 c c c

ccc
 cc 
cc ccc

c
 cc cccc  c c c

cc cccc

 c   c
c
ë c De Facto Officers

  c½ 
cc" ccc1998, Jartinez, J.0

S
d
c

c  c

c

cc c ccd c c

cc  c  c c cc½c

c

c0ccc ccd c  cd  c cc

  ccccc

cc
 cc
c c½0 c
c d c  cccc  cc
  cc
 cc
c
cc c c

c
 c ccdcc&cc½ cc 0cc

ccc
 c

 cc
c c  cc c
cc cc c c c c

ccccc c   cc

c   c c

c
c  c  c
c c c cc
c c

c cc
ccc

cc  c    cccccc c c cc
 c
c c cc c  cc
cc c c  ccJenzon v Petillaccc
 c

ccc cc

cc c c
 ccccc
 c

cc cc

ccc
 
 
c
cc 


c cc#
½0c
cc#
%c½ c c 0c*c c c  ccd c  c c

c cc c c

ccc
c
c
c c
c ccccc
 c

c
c c  cccd c c
c c
c  c c
 c

c
 
c cc
c
c

 c ccc

ccccc cc cc

 c 
c
c c
c   cccc c
 c
c  c cccc  c cc

 c
c  c
c

cc  ccc

c *cddcc c
cc

c  c
cc c cc ccc
cc
 c
cc c

c

c
c c

c c 
c
c
c *cccc  cc
 c
c c c  c
cc
cc
 cccc

cc
c
c  c
ccc

 c  cc

ccc
 c
cc c c c cc

c c
 c
c  c
c

c
cccc
c cc c cc
c
c c

c c c
cc
 c c
c  cc c ccccc cc
  c
c c c ccc
cccd c cc
c cc 
 ccc

c c  c

cc
cc cc ccc  cc
 c  cc c  c
c  cc c ccc cc
 c c
 cc

c 
 ccc

ccc
c

c c ccc
c c  c
cc
   c c cc
c
cc
  c
c c c cc    c
c c&c&&cc
c c
c *c c ccc

c
 c c c  
c  c c

c
cc

ccc

c

cc c
c 

ccc cc

 ccc
c *c c ccc
 c
cc

ccc  cc c c  c

c  c
cccc  cc
 c
c c

c c c c

c ccc 
c
c ccc  c
c *c c ccc
 c
cc

ccc
cc
cc
 c c  c
cc c cc

cc c
c  c c c

cc
c  c

     c½ cc"#cc1996, Hermosisima, Jr., J.0

S
d
c

c  c c

c/
c c 
 c
cc c
 c c ccc c
 ccc ccc 
c cccc
c½ c
cc c cc0cccccc c
c c
c c c
c ccc cc c
c c 
cc
 ccc cccc  
 cc
 c ccc  
cc c
cc ccc c c
 ccc cc  
 c
 
c cc  
cc c c c cc

c cc  c

c cc
 c


 




 
 

c ccc cccccc cc ccccc
 cc
cc
 c
cc

c c
cc c
 ccc
c c c
 ccc c  cccc
c
c  c
c
c c c
cc
cc cccc c
cc c
cc ccc
ccc

  cc
cc c c

cc
cc cc c c c

c
c
cc

c c  c cc
 c
c c
ccc
 c

c cc c
ccc
 c
cc

c
cc cc c
 c ccc c cc cc  c
cc

 c

S
½ "cc$cc1993, Bellosillo, J.0
S
  c

cccc
c c

c
cc
cc
c  c½0c  c
cccc c
c  
cc
cc c c
cc# #c  ccc
c c

cc 
c c

c  
cccc cd c
 cc
  c
c
 c c
c   c
 
 c c 
c

c c cc

 cc
 cc

cc    c!c

 
c 
cc

c c  cc 
c

c

c cc
 c
cc
cc cc
c
 c
cccc

c c
 c cc ccc cc   c c
c  c
c cc c
c  
cccc
  


 

 
c! 

  



 c' c cc c c c
cc
c

ccc
c

c
c
cc cc cc c
cc
c ccc
cc

ccc
 ccc c
cc

ccc c c c c c  c
cc c
 c c

c c
 cc

cc c 
c c
 ccccc

c
ccc c c

 c

c c
c c
c c
c c cccc c 
cc
c
c c
c
 c  c cc

c c c
c c+ ,c c  c
cc c c

c
c c
 c cc

c    cc

cccc  c c
c
  c 

cc c  ccc
c. cccc
cc cc c  cccc
c
c
c
c  c
 c cc

cc
cc
c c

c c  cc c
cc ccc
c c c+ c cc   c c
  ccc  c cc c  ,c


 c½$
cdcc1948, Tuazon, J.0
S
d
c

c  ccc


cccc
cc 
c  cc
c
c c
cc
c  cc c
cc  c
 ccc
c
 c
c
cc
c
cc½c cc c
c
c 0ccc
ccc c
cc cccc
ccc c cc

c
c c

c c 

c
c
 cc
c½0c
c
c
cc
c
ccc
 
 

 c
 ccccccd cc ccc
 c

 cc  cc cc

 cc cc

cc
 cc c ccc
 c
c
 cc

cc c c
cccc cc c

cc
c
c cc
 ccccc

c
c cc c
cc c  c
ccc c c c
c
 c c
 c
cc

cc

c  cc c

cc
 
 c
c

c c cc c


c c
 cc c cc

 ccccc

cc c c
c c
c c c cc  cc

c  ccd cc c
cc
cc   ccc cc

c  c cc  c

cc cc

 ccc c c

c c
ccc c
cc
  cc
ccc
 c c c

c
c
c 
 c
cc

c c cc c 
ccc c c
c 

      ½ cc" cc1995, Kapunan, J.0

S
d
c

c   c
c c

cc   c
c c
ccc  c
c
c cd c
c  cc
cc 

ccc
cc

c
c  c cd c½ c
c cc cc c
c
cc0cc
c

c
ccdc ccccc   ccc

c  cc  c cc c cc cc

c c
 cc
c cc  c
cc"%
c
 c
cc
c c
cc
ccc c

 c
 cc

cc cc  cc

c cc cc cc
c

c
 c

cc
c
 c c
cc 
ccc ccc

c c
 c½ cc0 cc
 c
c
ccc c 
 c
c cccc
 

 c
c
ccc ccc
c c
cc c
 ccc
c
c  cc c

cc
c c
c
  cc
 ccc
 c
ccc

c
ccdc
c
cc
cc
c
c
c c c&
 c
$c
c c½$0cc
cc cc c
c

 ccc
c

ccccc cccc c
cc c
c
 cc
c &cc
c   c
c 
cccccccc
c
c  cc

cccccc
c cc
 c

c

cc c 
 c
cc c c
c c  ccc
cc
 c


ccc
  c

0cc c
ccc c

c
c 0cc c
c  c
c c c c c
cc

cc
c "0cc c
c c
c
 c
cc

cc c
 cc
c cc 
cccc
 c

c c
ccc
ccc
 ccc
c cc
 c

cccc
 cc c

c ccc
ccc

 c

cccc c

 c

c½ %cc %cc1967, Bengzon, J.0

S
d
c

c  c c

c c
cc   cc 
c  ccc
cc
c c
cccc ccc ccc
 cc  cc cc c
 c cc cc  ccc c
c ccc
cc

c
c cc
c cc
 c
c  c  cc cc c cc
c
 ccc c

c
ccc c

ccc c
 cccc
 c

c  cccccc

c
c ccccc  c
ccc cc 
c
  cd c
 c
ccc

c c

 cccccc

 c

ccc  c 
 cc

c
c c
c

c
c

c
  c c  cccc
 c

cc c cc

 cccccccc
 c c
 

 cc
cc
c
ccc c c
 c cc
c
 "cc ccc
c
 cc
  ccc
cc
cccc

c
cc  cccc c c

cc cc

c

 c
c ccc c cc  c'cc 
c 
c
cc

c

cc c

 cc

cc
 cccc

ccc  ccc
cc 
c cc ccc cc

cc c
cc c  c
c'cc


ccc
c cc  c
c  c
cc
 c
cc c ccc
 c

c cc c c

c c
ccc
c c c  cccc
 c cc
c
 c c
cc
  c
ccc

 c

c

c
cc
cc
  c
cc

cc c c c ccc

cc
c
 c

c
c c

c c 
c
c
  cc c
cc

c c
 c

c

 cc  c
c 
 c c

c

cc
 
c  cccc
 c
cc c
cc

ccc ccc

 c

c c c cccc

ccccc c
c c ccc c

c
cc c
cccc  cc
 c
cc
 
c c
cc

c

 c


  
dd


c½"$
cc %%cc , Salvador-Gutierrez, J.0
S
d
c

c  c 

cccd c c

cddc  cc

cc ddc c   c c

c
c
c
 c
c cc
c c c cccc


c c  cc  c c

cc
 c
cc c
c½ 0c c

ccc


c cc

  ccc cc 
c
cc c
ccc
 ccc

c cc
 c
 c½c

0cc cc c½c
0cccccc cc

 

c  cc

 c  cccc c
c ccc cc

c
c 
c
 c cc

 cccc c cc cc c
c
c

ccccc

c c
c cc
 c
cc
 c c

c c c
c c
cc

 c  cc

c
 cccc
c
c  cc c c
cccc
c c 
cc  c
c
c


c
c  c c

c c
c c c cc
$#c   c+c*c c c
 c
½"0,c c c
c
cccc
c
cc
cc

 c
 
c dccc c
c

cc
c cc c
cc cccc c c
 ccc cc

c ccc
 c ccc c c c
c ccc c c
c
 cc
 cc ccc
cccc  cc  ccc  cc

c cc 
c
 cccccc cc c
c c
c c c c
c

c c ccc

c
c c c
  ccc
 c
  c
 c
c cc c
 c
cc

c  cc

c
cc
 c c

 c c

c cc c

  c c
 c cc
 ccc c 
c"%c
# c
c cc
cc
 c c

c cc c

 cc ccc ccc c
 ccc
 c

c  cc

 c
cc 
 cc


 cc c ccc
 c
cc

cc c

ccc
 c c  c
cc

c c cc c c

c c cc
c  c

cJonroy vs. Court of Appealscc c ccc 
c 
c
cc

c

cc c

 ccc
 c

cc
cc
ccc  ccc
cc 
c cc cc½cc
 c

0c 
cc

cc c

cc c  c
c ccc
 c

c c cc ccccccccc c

c c c
cc c

c
ccccc  cc
 c
cc 
c  ccccc
cCivil Ôiberties †nion vs.
Executive Secretarycc c ccc
 c

c cc  c

c ccc
c cccc
 cc c

c  c
c c 'cccccccc cc c

ccc
 c

c cc c
ccc
 c
cc

ccc
c  cc c
 c cc cc cc  c
cc

cccc


c c
c  ccc
cc c 
 cc cc

 'c
c c cccccccc c

ccc
 c

c  cc 

c 
cc cc cc  c
c cc

cc
cc 
cc

cc c
 cc c c c
c

c c cc

cc
cc
cc
 c  c
cc c c
 cc
 c
cc

c ccc

c
c
c
$$cc
 cc c  ccccc
c cc  ccc c
 
 cc c c

 c cc 
 c cc c
 ccc
c
cc 
 c
  c c
c ccc
 c
ccc cc 
c

c½ c 0cc c c

c

 c
cc
 cccc 
c
c
cccc c c

c

c
cc
 c c

 cc 
 ccc

c
c ccc
cc cc cc 
c
 cc c  c
 c

c

c
c cc

c
cccc

cc
 c
c cccc

 c
cc c
c
c
c
 c c 
 c
 cccc 
c cc c
 c
c ccc

ccc c 
c"%c
#c




! "

c½
cc"
#cc1991, Fernan, C.J.0
S
c
cc    c
cc c
cc $ccc c
c
cc
cc cccc c c
c c

c c
 cc c cc
c
 c
c
c cc cc
c c
 c c c
"ccc
cc
$#c    cc
 


c
c c

c c 
c
c
c & c cc c $c c
c   c
cc c
c c
cc
c cc
 c c&   c& c cc
c c c c cc
c c
c&c c c
c
cc
 c  c  ccc
cc  c  c c cc cc c

c
c
 ccc
ccc c  c  c c  c 
 ccc
 c
c
c cc cc
cc
 cc
 c cccccc c  c 
 cc

 c 
c
c
c   cc ccc  c
 c
cc
c cc
 c

ccc cc c  c

c cc cccc
ccc'ccccc cc 

ccc
 c

c cc c
c
cc
 c
cc

ccc cc c

 c cc cc cc  c
cc

c
cccc


c c ccc
cc c 
 cc cc

 cc cc


c

c c 
c  cccc  ccc

c c

c
ccc
cc

cc

 ccc
c
c
 cc
c c
cc c
c c ccc
cc c c c  cc
c
c
c
c c
c ccccc  c
 cc
c
cc
c c


d

 c½
#cc 
cc1991, Gutierrez, Jr., J.0
S
d
c

c   c  c

cc
cc   cc cc cdcc c c
cc
 c c cc
c
  cc c cc c

c
c  cd c½ 0ccc c c
c d c c½0  0c c
 cc.c cc c
cc

 c.cccc cc

c
 cc
 cc cc ccc ccc

c
c
  cc

c
c ccc
cc
 c
 
c
c cc cccc

cc 
c
cc c 
c 
 cc c  ccccccc
c c
 c
c  c c cccc
cc c
cc

 c
c 

 cc
 c
cc ccccc
ccccc

c
cc  cc
cccc c
c  c
 cdcc

c c   cccc

cccc

c cccccc


c
c
cc c 
c
 c ccc c
cc

c
cc   cc
c cc c
 c  cc
 cdc  cc  c cc

c
cc  c  c c
  ccc c
cc   cc c
cc c
ccd c  cc
cc
c 
c
 c c c c ccccc
ccc
  cdcccdc  c 
 c cc c
  
cc cccccc

c
cc   cc
cccc
c c cc

 
c c

cc
 c ccc c
c
cc
 c  cc
 ccc cc
cc
cc c ccc c ccd c  c c cccc cc
 c

 c  cc
c

c
ccd c c c cc cc

cc
cc c   c

c c
cc  cccdc c ccc
c c c
c c
c c

cc

 cccccc
 cccc
 c

cc c 
  c
cc cc c ccc
 c cc

c
cc  c c  c
cc c

 ccc
c
c cc
 cc

c
c ccccc c

ccdccc
c c c
c
cc cc c
c

c

c c
 c   ccc

c
c
c
c c c  c cc
 c
c  cc

ccc  c

c cc
cc  ccc
cc
 c


cccccc  ccc ccc  c   c c%cc
c
ccc
 c c
 cccc c  cccc
cc

c
cc
 cccc ccc
  c c
c c
 c
cc  c
 c
cccc cc cc

c
cc   ccccc c
c
c

c
c c.
cc

c
c

c
c cccc
 c cc
cc
c  c
c cc
 c
c c  c c ccccc cc
cccc cccc c  c
cc

 c
c c
c