Recombinant human interleukin-2 (rH IL-2) purified from E. Coli was characterized its Biological and Therapeutic Activities. In vitro augmentation of natural killer (NK) cell activity and mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) assay were shown to be comparable with other rH il-2 from different manufacturers and laboratories. Clinical trials have generally been disappointing, with results that were inferior to those obtained in a variety of animal models.
Recombinant human interleukin-2 (rH IL-2) purified from E. Coli was characterized its Biological and Therapeutic Activities. In vitro augmentation of natural killer (NK) cell activity and mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) assay were shown to be comparable with other rH il-2 from different manufacturers and laboratories. Clinical trials have generally been disappointing, with results that were inferior to those obtained in a variety of animal models.
Recombinant human interleukin-2 (rH IL-2) purified from E. Coli was characterized its Biological and Therapeutic Activities. In vitro augmentation of natural killer (NK) cell activity and mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) assay were shown to be comparable with other rH il-2 from different manufacturers and laboratories. Clinical trials have generally been disappointing, with results that were inferior to those obtained in a variety of animal models.
stRyefets| x1 (1988), M21 WZ
Korean Biochem. J. (1988), Vol. 21, No. 2, pp. 127~133
Recombinant Human Interleukin-2: I]. Biological and
Therapeutic Activities
Hye-Lim Choit, Hye-Young Yun*, James E. Talmadge” and Kyung-Soo Hahm**
Protein Chemistry Laboratory, Genetic Engineering Center, KAIST, P.O. Box 131, Cheong Ryang! Seoul, Kored! and
Preclinical Screening Laboratory, National Cancer Institute, Frederick Cancer Research Facilities, Frederick, MD, U.S.A.
(Received May 12, 1988)
Abstract : Recombinant human interleukin-2 (rH IL-2, Ser'®*-rH IL-2) purified from E.
coli was characterized its biological and therapeutic activities for the establishment of
preclinical screening system and therapeutic applications. In vitro augmentation of natu
ral killer (NK) cell activity and mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) assay were shown to
be comparable with other rH IL-2 from different manufacturers and laboratories. An
antiserum against rH IL-2 was obtained from chick, and characterized the reacticvity
with rH IL-2 reconstituted from lyophilized state in relation to the stability and confor-
mational changes of the recombinant protein. In addition, long term storage of rH IL-2
in lyophilized or solution was not shown to incur remarkable loss of MLR activities, and
any appearance of either degradation or aggregation products when analyzed by
SDS-PAGE, indicating the stability and suitability for therapeutic applications of rH
IL-2,
Human recombinant interleukin-2 (rH IL-2) has
the appeal of immunotherapy, but clinical trials
have generally been disappointing, with results that
were inferior to those obtained in a variety of anim-
al models (Terry et al, 1982; Mihibch et al, 1983;
Oldham et al, 1983; Talmadge et al, 1985a,b). the
positive results seen in experimental systems
appear to be due to the initiation of therapy in nor
mal animals with minimal tumor burden. This may
also have been the origin of the disparity between
the preclinical therapeutic activity of cytotoxic
drugs and their clinical properties, Many preclinic-
al immunotherapy studies have actually investi-
gated immune prophylaxis, since experimental im
munotherapy can be initiated prior to, or simul
taneously with tumor implantation. Also, central to
the identification of biological response modifiers
(BRMs) useful in clinical oncology is the develop-
“Reprint requests to Kyung-Soo Hahm.
*This work was supported in part by the grant (F80010)
from the Ministry of Science and Technology, Korea
ment of the experimental protocols for the treatment
of animals with preexistent, well-established metas-
tasis, as well as investigations into the therapeutic
modulation of the host immune response to primary
autochthonous neoplasms and associated metasta:
sis. To this end, many cancer research laboratories
and pharmaceutical industries developed systems
for screening drugs for antitumor activity.
‘The recombinant human IL-2 (KAIST rH IL-2)
and a mutein (KAIST Ser'*°-rH IL-2) have been
successfully cloned and over produced from E. coli
(Han, 1987), and purified to an apparent
homogeneity (Yun et al, preceding paper in this
volume). The present study was therefore under
taken in order to evaluate biological and therapeu-
tic activities, and stability of KAIST rH IL-2 and
KAIST Ser'* rH IL-2 for the establishment of pre-
clinical screening system and therapeutic applica-
tions
127128
Materials and Methods
Production of Antiserum Against Purified Ser®*-rH IL-2
Rabbit and chick antisera against KAIST
Ser!®°-rH IL-2 were obtained according to the fol-
lowing immunization regimen. Each 100 ng of
lyophilized protein was dissolved in 200 yl of
PBS (10 mM sodium phosphate, 0.15 M NaCl, pH
7.4) and mixed thoroughly with the equal volume of
complete Freund's adjuvant. After emulsification,
the solution was injected subcutaneously and
boosted after 2 weeks of first injection. After 1
week of second boosting, formation of antibody and
titers of antisera were evaluated by double immuno-
diffusion analysis (Lee and Hahm, 1986) in 1%
agarose
Biological Activity Assay
Bioassay of :H IL-2 was carried out essentially
according to the standard procedure (Gillis et al,
1978) as modified by Talmadge (1985) using IL-2
dependent cell line, CTLL. The cells were cultured
in RPMIL640 media containing fetal calf serum
(FCS, 10%), L-glutamine (10 mM), sodium pyru.
vate (1 mM), 2-mercaptoethanol (0.5 jxM), antibio-
tics (1%) and 20-30% con A supernatant. Con A
supernatant was prepared by stimulating mouse
spleen cells with con A (20 jeg/ml) for 24 hours
For assay, serially diluted IL-2 samples (100 jl)
were incubated with CTLL for 24 hours, pulsed
with*H-TdR (1 jCi/well), harvested (Brandel,
Model M-24, MD., U.S.A.) and counted cellular
radioactivity (LKB 1216 Rackbeta I Liquid Scin-
tillation Counter, LKB Bromma, Sweden) after in
cubation for 8 hours. The Biogen rH IL-2 (Biogen
Research Corporation, Cambridge, MA., U.S.A.)
was included as a reference in each assay. The
Biogen rH IL-2 was shown to have an identical
activity when compared to BRMP (Biological Re
sponse Modifiers Program, NCI, NTH) IL-2 refer-
ence reagent and the IL-2 activity for each sample
was converted to reference units (RU)/ml as de-
fined by the standard. The assay data were analy-
zed according to the program developed by Sette et
al, (1986).
Augmentation of Natural Killer (NK) Cell Activity
Augmentation of NK cell activity was assayed
Korean Biochem. J. (1988), Vol. 21(2)
Hye-Lim Choi et al.
according to the standard procedure developed by
the Preclinical Screening Laboratory (PSL) of
Biological Response Modifiers Program (BRMP),
NCI, NIH (Talmadge et al, 1985b). Spleens were
removed from C3H mice and a single cell. suspen.
sion was prepared via a water lysis. Cells were
washed in HBSS (Hank's balanced salt solution
containing calcium and magnesium), counted and
the concentration was adjusted to § X 10° cells/ml
in media (PRMI 1640 containing 10 mM gluta.
mine, 5% FCS and 0.005% gentamycin). Cells were
plated in quadruplicate in 24 well plate (Costar,
U.S.A) containing rH IL-2 samples (approximately
20,000, 2,000, 200, 20 units/ml) and the plates were
incubated overnight in 5% CO» at 37°C. Polyinosi-
nic-polycytidylic acid and poly-L-lysine solubil-
ized by carboxymethyl cellulose (Poly IC-LC,
NCI) was included as a positive control. (Talmadge
et al, 1985b; Talmadge and Hartman, 1985). Cells
were harvested into 50 ml polypropylene tubes,
washed by centrifugation and the concentration was
readjusted to 5 X 10° cells/ml in fresh media be-
fore plating (4 dilutions, 100 jl each, triplicate) in
a 96 well U bottom microtiter plate, To each well,
100 yl of Cr°!-YAC cells (YAC cells were treated
previously with chromium-51; 200 ~Ci/5 x 10°
cells) was added and incubated at 37°C for 4 hours
in 5% COz, the supernatant was counted in an LKB
1270 Rackgamma Il (LKB Bromma, Sweden) and
the data was analyzed.
Mixed Lymphocyte Reaction (MLR) Assay
Allogeneic mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR)
assay was performed according to the standard pro-
cedure of NCI, NIH (Talmadge ef al., 1984b),
Spleens were removed from both C57 BL/6 and
C3H mice and single cell suspensions were pre-
pared via a water lysis. Stimulator spleen cells,
C857 BL/6 cells (2 x 10° cells/ml) which were
irradiated at 2,000 rad were admixed with responder
spleen cells, C3H cells, (1 x 10” cells/ml) in flat--
bottomed 96 well plates. The cells were admixed in
EHAA (extra high amino acid) media, supplemented
with 5 x 10-5 M 2-mercaptoethanol and 0.5% nor.
mal mouse serum (Click et al, 1972; Heber-Katz et
al, 1972) containing different doses of rH IL-2 or
thymosin fraction 5 (Hoffman-La Roche Inc., NJ.
U.S.A), which served as a positive control (Tal-
madge, 1984; Talmadge et al, 1984). The culturesTherapeutic Activities of rH IL-2
were pulse-labeled with tritiated thymidine(1 j«Ci/
well) for 24 hours prior to harvest at 4 or 5 days
following culture initiation. The cultures were har-
vested with a Brandel 24 well automatic cell
harvester on to Whatman glass microfibre filters
Cells were water-lysed to remove soluble pools of
radiolable, and the amount of incorporated tritium-
thymidine was determined using an LKB 1216
Rackbeta IT liquid scintillation counter in PCS
scintillation fluid (Amersham, Buckinghamshire,
U.K.). The MLR results are expressed as a relative
proliferation index (RPI) (Dean et al, 1977) and
stimulation index (SI) (Talmadge et al, 19842):
PM(EAC)~CPM(CRC),
“CPM(CAC)—CPM(CRC)*
RP!
CPM allogenic culture,
=PM(CRC)
where EAC is experimental allogenic culture, CRC
is control responder culture and CAC is control
allogenic culture.
Evaluation of Stability of rH IL-2
KAIST rf IL-2 and KAIST Ser!?®-rH IL-2
were evaluated for their stability by analyzing pro-
teins using a gradient polyacryl amide gel elec
trophoresis in the presence of sodium dodecyl sul
fate (SDS-PAGE) and MLR assay after storing
samples for 6 months. Linear gradient (7.5-18%)
SDS-PAGE was carried out using 4% stacking gel
(Laemmli, 1970). Duplicate gels were run so that
one gel contained samples treated with
2-mercaptoethanol and the other in unreduced
states. For each lane, 15 jg of sample was loaded
and proteins were visualized by staining with silver
(Biorad, U.S.A.). MLR assay for the stored samples
were carried out as previously described.
Results and Discussion
The biological activity of the purified rH IL-2
was about 1-3 x 10° units/mg protein. The activ.
ity of KAIST rH IL-2 and KAIST Ser!?°-rH IL-2
was 1.0 RU x 10°/mg and 2.5 RU Xx 10°/mg pro-
tein, respectively. The result (Table 1) is an aver
age value obtained from various samples assayed at,
least in duplicte. As the data indicates, the mutein,
129
Table 1. Activity of Natural and Recombinant Human.
IL-2
IL-2 IL-2 Activity
code Specific Activity
Designation RU x 10°/mg protein
Recombinant IL-2
KAIST 1H 1L-2 10
KAIST Ser-rH IL-2 25
R- 02
R2 LI
R3 95
R4 50
Lymphoid IL-2°
Na 0.02
N-2 02
Nn 765
Nea 05
*Data for the recombinant I1,~2 of R-1 through R-4
and all of the lymphoid IL-2 samples were obtained
from the PSL (unpublished results)
KAIST Ser!?°-rH IL-2, shows more biological
activity than the wild type. Since the biological or
therapeutic activity of the mutein has been reported
to be comparable with that of wild type (Liang et
al., 1986), the present data suggest advantages for
producing mutein for preclinical and clinical stu-
dies. The activity of KAIST rH IL-2 samples was
‘compared with several recombinant or lymphoid hu
man IL-2 samples prepared from various laborator-
ies, and the result (Table 1) indicated that our re
combinant IL-2 is comparable with other products.
In vitro incubation of mouse spleen cells with
KAIST rH IL-2 and KAIST Ser!?-1H IL-2 at
doses > 10 units/ml significantly augmented NK
cell activity in vitro (Table 2). The positive control,
poly IC LC, also activated NK cells in vitro, and
200 units/ml of KAIST rH IL-2 and <180 units/
ml of KAIST Ser!-rH IL-2 were required to
obtain similar high levels of augmented NK cell
activity. the result is superior to that obtained from
Biogen rH IL-2 which showed 1,000 units/ml rH
IL-2 being required to obtain similar high levels of
augmented NK cell activity (Talmadge, 1985). The
result also showed that the mutein, KAIST
Ser'?5-rH IL-2, is better than the wild type,
KAIST rH IL-2, for the augmentation of NK cell
activity in. vitro
The allogeneic MLR was performed at a respon.
Korean Biochem. J. (1988), Vol. 21(2)130
Table 2. KAIST rll IL-2
L
and KAIST Ser'®°-rH IL-2 augmentation of
Hye-Lim Choi et ab
Percent cytotoxicity (YAC),
Agent Concentration Lytic
50:1 25:1 121 61> Units
Medium - 12,0 0 0
PolyIC-LC 1 ug/ml 519° 299° 190" 74 7
10 pg/ml 59.3 475° 24.2" 111° 10
KAIST rH IL-2 2 U/ml 372 225" 118" 66" 4
20 U/ml 46.7 433" 242 128 8
200 U/ml 45.1 50.4" 35.2 187" 9
2 18 U/ml 37.7" 216° 130" 49 4
180 U/mi 60.6" 439° 293° 166 4
1,800 U/ml 71.9 59.4" 455° 268" 17
“Significant increase in cytotoxicity;
“Indicates effector to target ratio.
P < 001 (paired Student's t test)
Table 3. KAIST rH IL-2 and KAIST Ser'#-rii IL-2 augmentation of lymphocyte
a mixed lympho
‘te response (MLR)*
Medium
Agent Dose C3H
only
1,084
Thymosin FS 50 eg/ml 11,983
KAIST rif IL-2 1,800U/ml 25,734
KAIST Ser!?°-rH IL-2 200U/ml 44,407
C3H_ Stimulation Relative
+CS7BL/6 index
index
12.999 1.00 1.00
173% 137" 1.36
39.847 23.56" 325°
47903 42.12 392°
"Medium control was in the absence of any
was thymosin fraction 5 (F5). "The values are expressed in counts per minute (cpm) and
averaged from quadruplicate samples.
paired Student's test
der/stimulator ratio of 5:1 to demonstrate maximum
immunomodulation (Talmadge et al, 1984a). When
responder and stimulator spleen cells were cocul-
tured in the presence of KAIST recombinant IL-2
samples or the postive control thymosin fraction 5
(Table 3), they significantly increased the incor
poration of tritium-thymidine into the allogeneic
mixed lymphocyte cultures. Maximal stimulation
was observed at 1,800 units/ml for KAIST rH IL-2
and 200 units/ml for KAIST Ser!°-rH IL-2, with
a stimulation of the MLR greater than that
observed with the positive control, Since the dose
tested was not minimum and the minimum dose to
give a significant increase in the allogeneic MLR
was not determined, additional experiments using
lower doses of IL-2 samples are currently being
carried out. KAIST rH IL-2 and KAIST Ser!*5-rH
Korean Biochem. J. (1988), Vol. 21(2)
immunomodulator, and the positive control
*p<001 compared with the control group by
IL-2 were a
0 found to be blastogenic when incu:
bated with C3H spleen cells alone (jie., in the abs-
ence of mitogen or allogeneic stimulation). The re-
sult is comparable to the results obtained with other
rH IL-2 (Talmadge, 1985; Thurman et al, in press)
The result also indicated that the mutein, KAIST
Ser'*-rH IL-2 is more active than the wild type,
KAIST rH IL-2, in the augmentation of MLR
which is consistent with the other results currently
obtained, implying the advantages for producing
mutein.
Although both rabbit and chick were immunized
with KAIST Ser!*-rH IL-2, chick only produced
antibody as determined by double immunodiffusion
analysis (Fig. 1). It was also observed that the re-
combinant protein when reconstituted with water
was only reactive and formed precipitin lines withTherapeutic Activities of rH IL-2
Fig. 1. Double immunodiffusion of rH IL-2 against
chick anti-rH IL-2 serum. Antiserum was two-fold
serially diluted from A to F.
chick antiserum in acidic pH. When higher pH than
5.5 was used, no precipitation reaction with anti
body was observed indicating that the IL-2 mole-
cule is stable and maintains its natural conforma.
tion at acidic pH and at neutral or alkaline pli it
aggregates.
66 K-
45 K-
ee
20 K-
14.2K —
1234
5678
131
‘The stability of the KAIST rH IL-2 and KAIST
Ser'®rH IL-2 was also tested by SDS-PAGE
Gradient gel electrophoresis was carried out in
order to observe any by-products formed in wide
molecular weight range. Although silver stain is
generally known to require less than 100 ng of pro-
tein to be visualized, more than 10 yg of each
sample was loaded in order to be able to detect any
minute quantity of either degradation or aggrega-
tion products which might be formed during the
storage. The result (Fig. 2) showed single protein
band of IL-2 for each sample which means that
there is no degradation or aggregation product
formed whether the samples were treated with
2-mercaptoethanol or not indicating that both
KAIST rH IL-2 and KAIST Ser!°-1H IL-2 are
very stable
The stability in terms of therapeutic activity was
assessed by performing MLR assay using identical
samples before and after storage for 6 months. The
result (Fig. 3) showed that although there was some
loss of biological activity, both KAIST recom:
binant proteins were able to maintain significant
therapeutic activities.
Therefore, the present study shows that both
KAIST rH IL-2 and KAIST Ser'°-rH IL-2 are
suitable for preclinical and clinical studies. Using
KAIST Ser!5-rH IL-2, phase I and II clinical stu-
1234 5678
Fig. 2. Gradient SDS-PAGE (7.5-18%) of rH IL-2 and Ser'®®-rH IL-2. Panel A shows the result obtained from the
samples treated with 2-mercaptoethanol and panel B shows the result obtained from unreduced samples. Lane 1-4
shows rH IL-2 puri
fied under reducing (lanes 1 and 2) and nonreducing (lanes 3 and 4) conditions and lane 5-8 shows
Ser!®-rH IL-2 purified under reducing (lanes-5 and 6) and nonreducing (lanes 7 and 8) conditioas.
Korean Biochem. J. (1988), Vol. 21(2)182
MLR
O ser
60 @ 10/28/87
8
15
10
stimulation index ($1)
relative proliferation index (RP1)*
SSS SSSA AAA
y
i
/
/
Yj
y
/
/
/
]
IS
SSS
thymosin Ser!25 wild
gen
FH- IL-2 (109u/mi)
Fig. 3. Augmentation of lymphocyte response in
mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR). Medium control
was in the absence of any immunomodulator, and the
positive control was thymosine fraction 5(F5)
Ser!°rH IL-2, rll IL-2, and rH IL-2 from Biogen
co, are abbreviated as Ser!?°, wild and Biogen. re-
latively.
dies are being carried out at various medical in:
stitutions.
References
Click, R-E., Benck, L., and Alter, B.J. (1972) Cell. Im-
munol. 3, 264
Korean Biochem. J. (1988), Vol. 21(2)
Hye-Lim Choi et al,
Dean, J.H., Connors, R., Herberman, R.B., Silva, J., Old
ham, R.K., and McCoy, J.L. (1977) Int. J. Cancer 20,
359.
Gillis, S., Far, M-M., Ou, W., and Smith, K.A. (1978) J.
Immunol. 120, 2027.
Han, M.H., (1987) in annual Report submitted to the
Ministry of Science and Technology, KOREA
Heber-Katz, E., and Click, R.E, (1972) Cell. Immunol. 8,
410.
Laemmli, U.K, (1970) Nature (London) 227, 680.
Lee, M.K., and Hahm, K-S. (1986) Korean Biochem. J. 19,
399.
Liang, S.M., Allet, B., Rose, K., Hirschi, M., Liang.
C.M,, and Thatcher, D.R, (1985) Biochem. J. 229,
429,
Liang, S.M,, thatcher, D.R., Liang, C.M,, and Allet, B.
(1986) J. Biol. Chem. 261, 334
Mihich, E., and Fefer, A. (1983) in biological Response
Modifiers sudcommittee report. In US. Government
Printing Office (eds.); “National Cancer Institute
Monograph 63” Washington D. C.
Oldham, P.K., and Smally R. V. (1983) J. Biol. Resp. Mod-
#21
Sette, A., Adorini, L., Marubini, E., and Doria, G. (1986)
J. Immunol. Methods 86, 265.
Talmadge, J. E. (1984) in Chemical Regulation of Immun.
ity in Veterinary Medicine, pp 457-465, Alan R.
Liss, Inc.. New York.
Talmadge, J.E. (1985) J. Biol Resp. Modif. 4, 18.
Talmadge, J.E.. Adams, J., Philips, H., Collins, M., Lenz
B. Schneider, M., and Chirogos, M. (1985a) Cencer
Res, 45, 1066
Talmadge. J.E., Benedcit, K.L., Uithoven, K.A., and
Lenz, B.E. (1984a) Immunopharmacol. 7, 17.
Talmadge, J E., Fidler, IJ. and Oldham, R. K. (1985b) ia
Screening for biological response modifiers. Methods
and Rationale, Boston. Martinus Nihjoft
Talmadge. J. E., and Hartman, D. (1985) J. Biol. Res. Mod-
if 4, 484.
Talmadge. J.E.. Uithoven, K.A.. Lenz, B.F., and Chie
gos. M., (1984b) Cancer Immunol. Immunother. 18,
185,
Terry, W.D., and Rosenberg S. A. (1982) in Immunother:
apy of Human Cancer, New York, Excerpta MedicaTherapeutic Activities of rH IL-2 133
ZR ola CIELF2ZI-2: I. WS WAIN IS
Aaa» Salg « James E. Talmadge’ - B44 (UI HIEU HAS Ge Dat
Al, ‘Preclinical Screening Laboratory, NCI-FCRF, Frederick MD., U.S.A.)
REL Bey Belaalal yee lal abel Pzl-2 (KAIST ell IL-2, KAIST Ser'?*-rHl IL-2)
AUAAG FY also] S8e7] HE SASS AeA Y aad dgse Sasi. In
vitro 4 abel fol] AEBS] SALSA YLT VITUS Aol dS ehwtoot cE saps}
AAG VABL-2 ASE) HAE ats Ach AST al Veh F229] Vaal yesh
AVES VAS 248b1 satel dala AA al UH Fal-2o] AE YQIS Fa IL
2m] SAAS ABA MSG al el Fal-29} 6] Qa se} WSS Ssh gBonl, Kak oY
ADA Led 21-22] VIAL EY UHPWS Qavids wes 2 a4 yaad age
SAVE ETUIT USA fala] WAS vel Falocl, arigga Valsad Saal sol
AAA] BELL Melsigteh, of 49] Boke KAIST aaa ala) Ve Fal-27t AYAAY Bhd
@ Sol Ssh lol AWS 44H
Korean Biochem. J. (1988), Vol. 21(2)