Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Kim (2008) Concurrent Monthly CisFU Vs Weekly Cis With EBRT HDRBT For Locally Advanced Cervical CA
Kim (2008) Concurrent Monthly CisFU Vs Weekly Cis With EBRT HDRBT For Locally Advanced Cervical CA
CERVICAL CANCER
Neoadjuvant chemotherapy trials showed no benefit over RT alone.
• Tattersall (JCO, 1995)
– EC3 (epirubicin, cisplatin)
– Inferior local control and OS
• Kumar (Gynecol Oncol, 1994)
– BIP2 (bleomycin, ifosfamide-mesna, cisplatin)
– Similar OS and DFS, toxic: 2 CT related deaths
• Souhami (JCO, 1991)
– BOMP3 (bleomycin, vincristine, mitomycin, cisplatin)
– Inferior OS, toxic
Five trials provided evidence for concurrent cisplatin-based chemotherapy.
CONCURRENT CISPLATIN-BASED CHEMOTHERAPY VERSUS RT ALONE
SURVIVAL (%)
POPULATION CHEMO RT CCRT p VALUE TOX
Keys IB2 (pre-op) C 40 q1w 68 84 0.008
GOG 123 x6c
Peters pIA2-IIA + any: CF 70/5g 63 81 0.010
SWOG PLN+, R1, q3w x4c
8797 microscopic
parametrial
involvement
(post-op)
Eifel IIB-IVA, IB-IIA CF 75/5g 41* 67 0.004 Similar rates of
RTOG 9001 >5cm, PLN+ q3w x3c late
complications
Five trials provided evidence for concurrent cisplatin-based chemotherapy.
CONCURRENT CISPLATIN-BASED CHEMO VERUS HYDROXYUREA
CHEMO SURVIVAL (%)
POP H C H C p VALUE TOX
Whitney IIB-IVA H 80/k CF 50/4g 39.8 50.8 0.018
GOG 85 2/w q3w x2
Rose IIB-IVA H 3g 2/w C 40 q1w 39 64 0.002 Hematoxicity
GOG 120 x6c increased with
H 3g 2/w CF 50/4g 39 66 0.002 CHF than either
+ H 2g C or H.
2/w
POPULATION AND TREATMENT ARMS
• Compliance
• Acute toxicity (RTOG criteria)
• Response (CR, PR, clinical or radiologic – MRI 3mos post)
• Failure (LR, DM)
• Survival (DFS, OS)
For the definitive CRT trials, compliance rates of 70-80% were achieved.*
CONCURRENT CISPLATIN-BASED CHEMOTHERAPY
WEEKLY CISPLATIN
Keys (GOG 123) IB2 (pre-op) C 40 q1w x6c C 240
Rose (GOG 120)* IIB-IVA C 40 q1w x6c C 240
Kim, 2005 IIB-IVA C 30 q1w x 6c C 180
3-4 WEEKLY CF
Peters (SWOG 8797) pIA2-IIA + any: PLN+, R1, CF 70/5g q3w x4c CF 280/20g
microscopic parametrial
involvement (post-op)
Eifel (RTOG 9001)* IIB-IVA, IB-IIA >5cm, PLN+ CF 75/5g q3w x3c CF 225/15g
Whitney (GOG 85)* IIB-IVA CF 50/4g q3w x2c CF 100/8g
Kim, 2005 IIB-IVA CF 100/5g q4w x3c CF 300/15g
RESULTS
PATIENT CHARACTERISTICS
COMPLIANCE
TOXICITY
FAILURE AND SURVIVAL RATES
UPDATED RESULTS (2008)
• n=155
• Median follow-up: 39mos
• Compliance: 60% vs 71%, in favor of weekly cisplatin
• Acute grade 3/4 hematologic toxicity: 43% vs 26% (p = 0.037)
• CR: 91% vs 91%
• 4y OS and PFS: 70% and 67% vs 67% and 66%