}. 100000B mdli!I.qn tl· Niltl!crln!I5 1m ~by; ~.IS I gll'ld~Il~.1!

o tfI~

~~"hliiTIlMe.·~ tliC.Jil'SI· POI:(Wle(I~-w~l: • 1l1;llding I'J v ~~tI~~ "*~ Wli.GfSpWi. ·m.tlrunipi~ ,:IllullllTml. Wi' - litIS ~(lInii one Ui mlt ~lmil0n ei~ ';rhse Is d ~id!~pdO:P nfspt(i.:;:11 (burl!: dll:;!"~ .my~g ~.!lI.~p~tch 1}1it 1t~?).,~ 9~'!:m;~1w1:' (iiftJ!f1). '!.!o'lJh:Jl ;:L~d!lI~)'t!I~,"-e.mel 1~~I!$'I:IIi.'Wi! 51bo~d :PiJilli~ ,U fh'eatr~mii!i11 ".E:_~ th,,~ -~tIDcs bii.ii.'so ofi:em -b.~ ~diarea w:il:n tfu: l;Ql;()e; m~J: Ih.e WieR ~;_~ rl!I.e guldlmg, EI'(lp.e- ofre£,hll::1ttomc rnn Ilmm eJ.1:J~tlom" botll> !D J?f!PIlIM' r~:n ng lUl,d lit Ihe ·ra.rui pb1l~oopl nl U'IIirl~IJtll'.ll. lS llJ ltiiNlllil \;vll:': C{ " monl i:nltl:flrunp, the ~-vltll:l whim Ismes; .... ,'ol'~. rolnm~ adm!lnl"mnm~. thc'~!i:e"'l!f;bicli. t'illl- o,! beg~ ~n~ if Dill! has il,dled WIOng)y..5\lm_ply. ,;l_meQpnllf~ . T. the \ltJi.oo lliolt 00 ~1 han; iiI l'l1.l.J'e dll.I.'~n.tl 'rotc!! still ~ ~""iC:I;,. 01' 18, \lOio dIal b l1iloCr:llpiE'rc;r.] n)Wfl ~tltJOliI ~n~;rbq.!i ~l:i~'vf,'iCoe I:olii 'PJ:'()'persensl!'l, dfl§& to th~ voice: w_ .lb.e 5-QQ!Drls; 0Ilr~ l'il'IlPhrs,~r he.u~ And. why tbt) V!]kre? hs ~lritlit'1d.ty b~ll~Oif:taln i::dg;I:~. t:s ~I~'ex~~ ''l/tI<tI!:C IJ leri! ,MId 'nil mtwllill 0iII_mCil"lph9rLi!:'.Il~ Rut ptl'~~'-II.p, 'I:!W i 'tIl~ iM~ll-Q'!" whim mmlittll,1,!S 1n11l'1'nidit:y iUlcl QOiJ!lsmol:lli>ue$S, so thsr the -\Wr n.itiog, of-the: li~ru/dllema1 dep-tm.ds Ol!i! tM:iag this me!3pllm bU!!iailly.. V'lIJu.t ~ ~lll!- '1t;P11 us ,iWd l~.l.clou!· tonn, d ilfi OOm'~~11 v k:

-¢ WIIsctm~e' I~ Mh~r.;Ji ..tK!t1dU~~il"g 1.-'Q(~fGi,,'g!. th;rlluk bet'!i\-~II. ooilsdence W I!;O]il$C_ious:n~ (oolh. iUe mcdes or ~1;ij.-$c!CI-). is W]I"st:OOl:15II.1:iS5 a1:m-1lit h,W'~ voh:e'l ~[f [ 1ID'ti. boklily artill'Uilp~irl a I:!:rref hktpf}i' ar I'flll~~h~ 'i:hroi:l..gh tl'!~ !p-)I,gIL~iI of diS. 1;"~rQl, 1~1 m !ldd IDiult tD ~I)' .:ll'Id .anempt-~ btltifh1!itrnr !Jf ~tiles: in the; ~~e \l"1ili:I. T

At-the gngb'i Of this hiiSiiCFIJ( t dJeblilit-lmgWtjl of ill iDler'.al "'Qi~-e5, d:!~&tI7<ltic: vojQ:" the darimol!lvht-clt -aJTI).mpiUlics-Soe!r',ue:s tb.r().'Jigh. Pl:LL bJ~ l:if!e:. III 01" Ef rMU us passage rr~Api!olllllr- Stid'.~Ie!l"1 In h lli dc~ use in nmt or th~ Ifllbmuh

I h~w I dh1u" Qr !'p!;riMw ~Ign_ wbll,e_h_ McLd\Uh~ lb{I.~.!;l-d!!:cl!.D .1iI!!; d~p. 1l~llll'lII. 'il1ili5.hll'_-gall wl,en 1:'i\IOI-~ a chili!. It j)J; iIJ~, md W~~llm7f'l' tt ~;l;~ luu:rm,.tlie il:W~il fro.lbsom-eilimg: I am .. haw to dc. btlt It rU':!IIeI

• &I'

I'- en~.u~ge5; !'IiI!i1·;m ~D lll~ili.1ng. ~ wb.. "hll ~I~ m-' ri'c'ili

~ l*ing: part PEl Pl1'6ll!f ~~. ;md! J rl1ink' it 1h~[~.flglJ.~ In preool1!tu

,; ~ (PIn;1!:I i1t9:l1'.A!iU,a. :lId)

1li.e ~e" I!I:J¥: da.tinO!!l it ~e So~~ ~!l,~. Q'r 'h~li,gt!la:_fdi;m !.Bgd (n'udJ! ·~d, thaUhc i:CI1' 1i,e:w:~ ord~J(!J.e:U!~~]Igcl tI'! Chti:s,. tiiltlhr ,:.t.mJll\!tn1;l;1 :Wl'l~,J\!ull,L'ldllt!-J, i>(!mb\~ .iI!rsl~~~). The q'I.I~~ 1;1- ~.9Ji;1. ~~ mi,t w'l'i,~'~rJ) iWt! po~u di;d; ier..e ~OIT' f'~ltP~;:!i ,.

i . iI'l_u: ql'iBiu ~tlili IIQ C is ·\~ppt:;ied to b.: dlril.'li! BId ~UP~it.

Imll" it rnm~slimm 'h~.Olllil, )lEE it d;weIls: mllhe: ~QS:I'Iie~~ of ScJC!".Ij~' CO'1li~r-5Si.ilI, f.IIPStll'lUllIQtea:nd .1illmdimeflUS]),' tbe ms:ttr~lldHt.llljs.m ".l~p'ic.d ~ 1~;'lhEl~'~~Drdu~ jll_ ner mill Ithe. OUb$

l. II Inm~ :il p~ti~ 'Ii'Olo:. 1lOt:·~ mke fdlfuB Soqal'"ei: w!la, to ~lllt h:!u; to du:ld.oe·~1hI! hlmiall. ~~ :mm1y ~8W.rl.edIlIDl finm mrlil1] .. ~tlQ-.m~ fl\t'e'.'tt~iWiJ!);kJJII i1'llIIllJ;1 dn~ W'l'o:.l:!,l~bUl: n(Jutl'~i him IiIIJW l:O_do iOOtJ, Ih.e\!Gilctlll@:1llegJUi 1{e:,. 'iII,~trep:ttr fLmm!l2Q1.,. <inC! fn.r I:JW;. ~J! l~ 1m: <It clo:s~ ID.I'l.!!!.mJ.oo to die Soaatl_L'''!itll!~ m. pl:i.iJ.os. Glp~IY: 1h1.s ISpllll!i!!i .. dy U'lI:! SIAU~ ·!MbI 11. So~aJiu ilId'DPI-i La ~QlII. eo his JruIlYWGeilDCulon: be ,fQ]" es '10 dliml. iU kil5[ U! prill, 'pit .. in (hi:

SUle ~y that ,~ i:b.e:lllOifi relairs 110, hD_H· does Pot pro.lf,o- iuil\;"ic ·°rt OS live '!hr;:!Jrles~.-ooIy dWinde!i dwo fromln!il ~y~'cft::hWtb1I, frwn rec:uh;·ri QJ}l!l'l~tJDc.1l01 dli"Wltlng hi!; OWlt·"i~ ... 'up!m !th,Wl: he does not off19! re:!dy~:mildi! ·iJ]Jilli'iWi! (;tlrJltlllg,i! illW ~lc .li~iJllttqdlJ ·teI:!ds re ~et. bluned dU;:Ill!'\lmeill it !Ii pul m~.o p:rr;a,~). ,Ffi;; ~ func_ lIli.I1lrir~J.I_t1oo ICf:]i-b~~ b1IlP~Kp~iq he.s:In!plf WolDt!; 'It} ope:h me Mrli af phil.o.lloph.y W"1lt11~, je ~Ji dte d>ll!n'!0'!1 h.li! dGIl.t for idnl , ;mil m GIrder to ~chiC'o--e flrI~ hI!' ~ilopl$ ,thep~lme 6fJllid,~.emt!'j] md tm,l!I!Iaii.~ .II:! smre,g)!. He !urn:!! iu!to me cliamp!:O'l:Iuf dre vQi,o: w)l!li;.h";ill at. 191 fu,!u 1:!C')IC)ni!l.lW;vrU~ r ,h.tl~~tlan:.1m roll: lis it) ~romli!' I~ .agenL J

3· [[ Ii amce'With wi'! ~Il all, c.um·m, .rr~uc: Jt til not l'liliUtw of "~gbin,g dR~iIDd OOffi The'i'mcoe ~;aJ"'~'df.H1gbl, bul' );IOH!Il'Ih~ Nsm of '~Pg!Lal. i!"&lIlIlt!iiL----uh:hIm.(lel}; it is. nor a lni:!i:ef ofJQp-at.;di]I. 4, Thl.l WJI:JllOIli l.!i IID~ ~ 1iW1~'JlmJ fIllI'Lo!:IiIOJl! ""hid! 'W!:iu,Jd .P~:I1'!1:I ilU. rohl:um:U1tr ;IS sndl; it biaJOcnd!jS hl Sl;ImU,I!!l;;ai :tftlil: '!'Il!l1Il; ~niliJ dlli~

!lIto!; 01'1. tl Ii. bi:!,,~ -lIljn~ tQ' dildni''Y1 1 ,111; on .,'ltbI d~li~ tIii

- ,·1.']Ii<:"""'b, ... .! to m'" - it, 'IIii1i::¥er5aD.:r iil'i', .. lk!b'k.:£o 10m 1t Hl~

Pli!;S1: ,~m1Jilm "4t' r _ ..

;w::a oil. iiCAl forphll$!!I;P~t an. o'fWDg [6 mnve~oll.

. 5' III whE~_folbnr.'~,o,W' qUtiLi!. It ~1r~, IL~II:: 'tL,15'i1Ojl!!,l. ~.y fLt~~ s.~~~ r'r~mWimS 'pn~'tii ~Iifq, ptlli'tJI.~lllfii;: tb 'li'G1~ :. ~ ~'litbe ·wmm1law. ~ !IliPFr.,d ro tllelilo~~~t'dnm law;_S'.o{ r; .~Lll!Ilty;\tlre~~~I:ai!rJ.ed. 'b;y "m'e LmlI.'i'irltl.!:J;l, :b~" ~.hbi divide ~ '!:!vldly elu(t~mAlill~ \I;I11iIll~!L~d~\lm611 k~'!!Im I!b~ m"Jk.e ~'WflJ.~!:lD lii;Yi'I jUild ill,1t in;i!Jhm-l~ offue: j1QI:b) Wf'(J!3iJilld.'iihil>~

i ~ .-",_JII.eJ] wh~,vannVilll G!ll~ <iI (:Q.1iip]!e .of jmu.tmI~ 1MB; th-e.

~miul,,14JU " ,_ """_,__ -,

1'J,~ltioll. be,\~ LT.lOraJity ~legnl~ ~ dl"o'is nn ~g~ Qrt ~. i. I'iIC!.~maIliiUn& (lI flm dI v~ • w.1'i i):Il the ,!;"(llce. i!.[ld tb,c: hf!l:f; wUl9\-- fIiIo'rili~y is o;;on~ .... erl ;as_:a :mil.[tcf di[ [he roil\: a.nd leriliqulS ~ ~-ord:1'1i: ktteit.

• - n , . -. .......,t'~.. o:£1:'he. ~i'(;:.llis D1Qt onlY '~ be lIj;omim:d

~!J;il', .. ues ]5 .iI .......... , ..... ,__ ,~"'-d('o .

Iifuilitllg '1O>w:r'i~.:li0 !haJ his:,I'C!(dulll[J\Il m '~gbt W~ lll!rPp!Iltl.lMl uW\lly' b'y the f>l~)~l'.:C\.'lh~' v'flklewJru::h~.:li&h.d'\ ·dtiOUtij'''C_~. '~1!J~k!!!S ~mo, bllt lRpnevru-oor&tiDli; 'difull~fu.lilito.ry of phll00 Qphy, bLii& ~ o mu'llghtbgID.g~~ed.Iil!leJi'~)' hi), lh~vDke·di\tl:n·-c_edfmmtIJ.dd[~ill5aJ:;O dIll.!: dds;s~ppost:m the ~ ·i~r.8 ;su,p~tW! ~

tml!r" () ,I!ili$ dieD10Q,.of w~u¢h.1'i WII!i mCl'flylnc a.gtnt. .

I I .so • iillhou .. b

ThlsSo~C!'tllemi!:wiIl be tden:~bp, l'fcl~ ell:.a.w.tliIJID, - ..

Qrltel!lln'I\'-'l!.)rS[I]il.tdlHer.gremy ~ ru:~!i6llnl!!.:.·the"o.!Ce:D cOillcie~ . ';;umd ;0 il\mmdClJ!l:l!l tilt: Ihm .g~1iId.<; ~n. ,~tbJ.eru! m.:l.(!!l:d I rn~ ~!l!lMr ,m my.hl~iilitmttlmu ruui <t:~m;mi Imm;, the: ~l,,~e intlit.r V{)I«:e, m' ~ahle- iJ!1i.d oorepellinfj JD iTJ imIli1~mi:)! Ii_ltd Ol~dwl-ng,pres, o!!i'i~.,:!, !l'ail~ OID~~.OI. sl1.enre or d&iy-41.'mild uue ao.lll!l', ad.!.oa~1!l + . (m't~Jn ~ , !l W~ h b' i mlm 'I!.'h1~h dUcum"o'C-nl.il.ill iM:-urtiI.. ug'U·

- . ... nr~~ ...... 6ffl, Indio: m~md tu<1"n1rn1 OO¥DT.I@ dioSC'1lB:i;'I'lty..

Ii'!,mt ,po I!l ...... ,n .. " •.• o' ~ . , "-'S.

'IJ;gyond too Uamcuies.Qfd,«h,l"~om;. jfu5l:tfi.caofilil!Sc,. ,;m,d dcllber:lIiOn._~ Its allegedly ml"allible IiImmlty Si.e.In$ uom bef!l!!.d j~,

-\'ifu W11e_~ !:his mtch~lll,s:m. pw-Jup-s:n its :pm:m" in ma.1[ put of~

-that t\;!Jus&eau 1m eJJti:tI~d. ~ La ~_ro:f~iOli'! de. .rDi,du '!,oi]~ S1I\'·iJlfMd.

:II:

t

"The pm ~l ~r:fiIIl.b Q[lI~~kvof \!I.C".IT'. !,1tnlmi. ,U i~"~. p,p. 56.(.'- 601i), w .tb'em'l:lo~for I m the mlmd.lir.m,..md ;mtt~.J!lil~. i md~ In. die ~voy !iiCd:!' RnUSS.eau :filllmd! * ,""1] pdVil te SciIllA!b, .lJ~il!ll: til' 'll:tI wrJu-en; v.iot ~ -5l!1JlijlOlilial tr~ JiIlWe"VQi{je -.nil! fOllm.\riug hi 5" ~lJ 1liiiiiJ!'J" 'Od e, rb.~ e C) . IIf\l. ' liatlll1e rn thUi' :SuppOi;6d ettl.l]Qd!in1eIllt oflWllIrn.i' ~I!l I:i I1dtib.l!l'l:g b~n udlC!i hlmlfiitr.'tI ,ui! ft)t:sI:;i;]j W:i.kle';" "ti.h~~yqli;e m:l!la~U1ie~";illiI~im~~, '1{ljlic;~'" w,bl:di ~1l' ",ill. f.J.llI,bl~" ,nll~., w nElIt):

CiJru~ ~~s-ciclllee1 Di1ol'me l:nstilLle!:,..rm.ilJ~~ ilia: ed'~~jil' ¥DIg:; IfirHl,ellfdt! fow Jp~ 1I~.ll:m1rOO bq. ntQlirewhkh 18 2Ik;o in. ~lim.gmt lIiLtI f~i Ih bl&Ill,bk Jl'ld~ of good! mit 'eYll" 1.4 )"011 1b.3{ male. Il"!!m (f~ to GiJa; !I'r is )t!IJU du[ Ulde Guir lim ~ailli!:nli'f: o,fbk, [I":l~ ~lid 'ib__emtl'~,ilif)" Chli iI(~1 Il5,; winhouryon. lOOMI s~ ~Dy~ 'ill 1DfS'cl'fwlucf:J"''OIiI!IJ;! ~Ilt~ m.: ~~ ruI" be..ilt15'; I ~t dill! .Il4!,J pr Mkg.1: l'\l' SilI'ay .frnm. ~fl'rtt!' error Wim lbe b,¢1p- m ;In illfclli,gf!n(~ f(l;itumli~jl!] W:ldi~iiI!I rule ~ll.d JI .~mgwJdlou~ .~ pJtlilCQ!ft1~, (l\Q~ ~.f#~. ~p. ~~'l}.l

fluID;m aJlDIl¥ C'olruJ til lJ~ d~~ d by ~~ ;wd Wldcrstmdill,g .aJo:Qe, fur tbe;rmerely.le.ld Il!l frurn !!~l Itt mn.r jf i.b 'Y ~ ,1101 illI~ ChClRlcl m dlil1!i W,ke a.5lrll~:r ,gmae .md~Fimipl~ [be. LC.cb! .. f the di. ¥:1M '~Il. die h:1J~ hilJ.IJJ:g. TJ:i1: ~"'Oc;e.:Is .tbe 1m'ir \'i'tih God. w~e rt'olSiltJ ;mdIIIIH1W'~i'm.d-J:a1!:'QI:l,Ihtl:rOlN~I.:ml d·p.r~\'i!d fme c!I!vm:i!;~il!:', [bl:)' an ~iIIpJy ~ depT.oraN-e s;Ide of tJllJ[ ptl'Vlll:~e over mimmlti, Olh :r 'IoJ~ ~. try [(), Wl~ 'IVi.tll tlli!: diii'itJeVOi.ce'. "mi= shriII~'Oire'" of pt' Jil.1di,cll' fJ,btd., J), 60 I'. "d~ ~'Ob."e of tl:!ebody" rOOllSctence 'h- the \I'~jloe' (lIthe soul. p;~iQ.ll5 .tl'ie tl11i:' ijlJ~tlI: o.r¢~~ bod~'" JM!!! .• p. ~,':lI'!)~ 11 m'Elll'iiS 'tlnt!n~. C¢mscJ.l)us:ll~ .hi ;! ~ ~r, J[ ,i:'! ~ S~~!l:ggj~ b~l'Wll!li:n l/QICCI (puw.ps we col!ll:d CO!I1fJttive [;IS an opua.: :lOlQeifi'ifl8' lh~t Wil.'i \'Uy deH 'to B.O'"IiI!l~i.'I); ~t 111 th1iI_!ii~. the.dI"'1n~ 1i/I,)ic~ uhilhiliely im(lO$~ millf, it g:.iliU:i tbe lilppe. h~Q! We t!;'II.Ie Vo'lC1! ~llnt!lt lbl:! ilIse \"Ol~." 'TWs V'~~.is llec~tUy !!i:ld~ \'IoIi!Ib MI Im:m. dl~Ie. mot. ~utllQl'hy: llu:lWI;''I'tr lTlUU! v;.~ ("illcnJ:a~ll:a::nd i!f,gw: ilOCUU mij]7~l[ly: Jl] thiI; il;' g._ftI.1Ufl!rlM wjUl:tl,~~ iI rum fOOling .mt:he \rQI.re, It.s !l:!n.nled!iaH': m!\iilion'iI1!la lb' 'set'ltim!!l:It Jl C;1,me..~.

"Iioos5!eaU's:~j_lIiwLnuy s~m llttritilf :oai!~·e;a;.i:ldsiD!Dpl~. inn II .l\!il:s de'epir ~b dd.'I!Ci"IMlIh(Wnebttm dH~ ~uggle whlrll~edthlE eIDI~ IINUI'li!R1 J~ U.1UrJlI Iii m· Ch,umh, ~ WI: b~ Df ~~I_ Ii )!;Il OJjl1ilhm~l~ll ·;tId e,n-tb,q iI!Idlerilli tIJ.e, h'uggl\ ~I iiIn: b~.;)nh ~hh;)lm~I:IL1il:Sel!E wb~ 2~li&2I1 figlfl'cd .. a~. ~ 2D(.i!;fttplimll.. H.e,n.ittkibrop~~ !:hg"Imlrepd:loa!: OW'!:lnliliml ;mit! :e.llie:~( •. ill pat'l)Ji:'1lI{U I.";!d-ri:~!~ ~itd.J'tb-!k 1'apf.i,l (i ;~8), ", ~ wl:!lt.l! ~,iU' ~~1 m~d lm:Ftlfurutry t1£9DY ;iI'fJlU'&m:im1iLry' d:tM:r~~ ~l!!rngl!i·t:tftb; ~!iJnii!~d wiLl11U"!i!lI:mi . .md artack: gil oC'ii'iisD~y (~ Il'eJf~Wlg ,Q[n~ of the ~hlm'l~.i:lr: d~, bC~wel:!ll.~Sp ftt,m,d WII! dtu lkircld~,s~ about o h 1J\<m ~ j':gprli. wbm (hi is~, I) fmm ·,[clll" U1:).l\>OUI..~::II"

tlll~k dlt oppQE;i~e ;:i;m~ of \1;joi-oUiSly d'eliendmg reIigli»\-ft;.!' :him 1:bl!1i' tmll'd be'-mo."irtt.ie Vlim.ilUl tdigiqn.,buJ[.~ aU.1~IDl1:. "Il~l 1.1~g;m1\," ~vl1!ch.l In '!!afll e:1'!1lill~rul·~.lI~Y \I~gll(l'cm al!!dml or Ili~ GIlI:m h .i~ ~ butltudtm, ~I!.!i dggrn~ md 11:5. :PTTgjCl;l~ Illllrltil ~ttu borI'il bam: lie liI'OOl, i!; 0' y~jLatt:r. jill I(~'l,~& "'\i'<nlliimd

.. ,,- .iii, •• "" ... "" ._..,.Uo;".J ·"!Ou~!lJ an.l.hi e ............. ,Ho:st ",nih. 1:11 :Itl.e~g

U-PIJ.!JlLBiJlLWlJI-TII ~ "lIijeJ]l ~ 'IoUILU J!L ' . - .... _ "---:rr- v:.J..Ul

~~~~ ,

The n~lm-ilI mwen W3 ;rn i:tl:ller 'Onr;;le, 011 '~tH 5p"ring of i!\t/mI;a:] ll:1!I'l.bt. whil!:1: the ,Cluudi"'1lII$ based. an tile ~m of ,[lngfnal; i>m. of man. '. nnfid bidJiig, 'lf1io needs COn;5lant m:r~\&lli1Dtt and pmreenon,

'IiINwlclv mbJ~I: !DJ5\i.i!pldCll1~IX~g;!J1.dll~1l '\Iii I[~ j'i!I'il!!f Gf'Ghr _ dimiif \\11itcbgiml die Oll!l'f.h ll~ for ~i:ltTttenQl".lfuu$elI\c:}; Rfl.; i.n!i"proI-e5Uid.bfll~es.t'ifayvi~ washtlJJmilie C-OO ~n.1m IullO~1!id. mtim;u:·c .Pft.'.eJl~ 't=p1~~~<J~d ,by I:b.~ 'i'~C:~ But rH1l1]~ this rolltL?1~ !I,,.r~~N whl;dlpmne,n~ Enljh; m..lJnil~r 1m rhb.I.~l'1l!!r \fOit'll '!O c.;{mIe.ra 1lg'lu, ~ hasro be rid 'Of ill 'lhe--'~'F.I.lent or COntllpt se~ .lIICIleoes.. or!:w:li .furloo(~ inhexi~M from b ,d ldstof)' '!\mae, wl!lu ""~~ ~[l6rpb 11, '::lid I' h@. ·dlltttM b)l' t1~ T~ lfl!u. and U't-~ ~n r~n 1011 11<" tb Te.u;h~i wu om :tpDlt!aptLl: one' u, prttoe' pwr 'EmUIl U H1 II ·.ll inlluenres ,. to dhsuall.e fumfmm iu:grrill:loo ba.d haJtH IS ::;~) t ~t he ruu:11l1 dls . (JI,;t!.I thl],'lnnt:r '\"Olce' fnr himselt So be:l1ef In the jl·ure inner

WOk Bolvt: Iflli:' 'FC;iCI~er.m WI11l~I~'5 ted n~dJle 'I ) '~l~ri'l~ tlI~ MpI!:£S c:Mkl. in a mannu tali' WUrSe I.IwJi "...hM: 'tilt:: thm'i:'l:i w~, £0 'mt wtg:~m.I pll.rii)" md ortg~ ~ enWIeod Ilil!:i :5'jIJiJ.l.e effecr, Th~ pOfi~

IlhUrl is IIlill1S!jl1dti~~ :ql ~I_ ma. ~OOilll" iliJ.1· tht *l!m:.f.C ' ttl;!: Th,rlSttJ:f Emtlll! ma.wt drm;·h I'cd. {O f'b.iil: p::!l.m wblW! ,bl! M\'O~d brJ ;1' ~e !-(I' auLhm:~ b1J;llkUllll(l ~~,etIi.ly ,f _ OW~ • uth,:!dl)~ II dl,. b.o QM ~ "iIm rc ~~m. tim the.T5G!It"tt Imre tln'I 'd.erl.d~ wham nW! namre is, 'he,s dis! onl¥ CUte wlui, I(IL the da__mor Of\'oio!Je5.'~ ~ the good. o,nn f1'fJlUih~ ,!mmmfl'l~~ h~l Q'Hak ~Iel~ ~ fut· Irumr yeke du;11!I Ih~liu!i. mhl!rwq¥' ti~ up 'with !J!II: ~"'~i:I'lll1'px~ Qf the ·0th~

Ihrm.1;y ~nl ~:<@dl f.lthfi S't<lifPI;Ollutit' .d:tn: lve.~ iin.d thls l' e pC me voice m KaDt.JsO. ~ge" be~r: bat, alIbeita gm.t .uimircl' ofhks a::Elm~m~ ~~t:!iseai.!o \'rol' ~I.tbe o,,~l~!mil orth~ ~' ~ in mil~ of ~tbl!i:i;! Iitol plllild ml IN prtN!lIied Dilly bV ih mmai l;w. v.im1.1h. in ia um'~tr-OIJ nililrr; iII m I.!Ipm.,wrJ,n. to 1.IJIl~~-i:g; [pi.tN:.ly fumu.L ].1r~ molil,;tf[kw shilttlcl be Ir1l.ibnl!lu~~ kI th-!~ ,~~ ~rm1iIi'1!:rJ,l:JJb:VI o1.l:Itd I:hatl~'l'lI~to bii!II,Q rock~l far \'QI1:~ 'Q1't1m~!. f~rl:nX/l {mtk:td,.reml~lt'GUlmM :ill. il'm\11\p~ [()' g;l'ow-w moc& gIl w£I1"a.l, reclin~). Eihil:$ ':;bDtil-d be: grnlIDdecl m reason .1tIotU~ .. VVe Cllll:llIlitJi]St .R(]U~itU.·5t1tVliajj.mJ oi Il!;.!wdmcr. ~l!.1tlilOO ~I n: 'Wllh ihJ! Kroll' ,1I~'I!:!Cio1tiol!l.llfut)!':

.om}"! Thou wbl:in!l! md. mi:g!;l'ry QU[,~ tIw ~~ ,1!IUb!'i1t!:: I!lIlnhtllg chU'illiIIll&c!f ilDll'llU'~iilE: bl.1~ m:j.um:s~ ilUblfigQ'I] 11iI4 Y'='I tll:.~t WI to.Jrul~Ilh1!!·Wi.IJi brihr-eitentng aught mikl\'lfltkli!lMam.I.Is-e.n.wrr"l.a.ver. ~~[1 D~ !ce.no,r. Iml'l!Ilil~' ~~ldm I r~L~. kw w:h1t!'l.i iillf !J~f ood:o. 'II!II' tOOI;,,!dnlot.he.:mmd., _ :WJwO_~!J,f:llts;\o'~rWyo.r~ • .mt;l."rhere~~ dre roO't of ihr ilohl.c d)23.(:em wMclI prm.lrll.y ~i~a;I!: alL .hliIshtp ""'111 tile Imill:motmhUl:l;d ~t:ll'lll wlL1:r;;b [(!I bll de;,;r.:~nd~ b ib.~ 101i:!'!iipcI1Sihl; cond1t~ oi me rudy WW'1h. wh.lct IDf'.D ilAxliu:,.;an give ihml-JClI;1l!S 1 (Kam. 1<)"93" p. 9~)

The vb.JJ:lmit Ofim'OC<lIiOllI:;; thc:sa:t!l.f,.I:mlit.s pmp~ 'i!i'w.~ O'p'pQ5lte~ t:bny ;U, me moral taM! is me dit:00I 'oppO-Sire of feelhIg., it ,1$ an Injun • lllHi LO (ut ill ,t!L~ '~!(j'f.b lb~ lll~nUid, Inehn 1l0l15. ~lmtlm!l!llt~. Ltll:! itff«:· ti([l'.!~, 'IIu Lnne.~ on1d .

,And .. lu~tlllLnGJ.I:!~.t. Jt IIl:lDl-aikw~g ill tI,~ t ,l'D- ,wme-----:mwru Jaw ~ ~~tl f-t' ~(nl~n~ m:d.:WUW9'lbaWlmy-omer!5GlJ!I;cc.mml'o!Il !,ll 5<l!Ipi!nJOI.tWilLtN il few Jilil~~ ~r:I'. Wl:!.,ilit ~:I'IMW: toJm~IlM[ MJl reiJ.SQ'D i.If 'emdo\wtJ .%'id'l ·iI"VtiK.'e..\\I'!,t;hll1e debiltm,g ,,,,b:.rtca!ppoe:m, to

.;biIl1 .as; rhre<mtlll'!it:i'0u5 pm,bs.ill:a pmlMi'e olle:s own h:iiwm~ as WJr ,~. fiE~m, L'l~ c I. ~::il.Ifi_fiI:S1li.~ ~ll.hjj p!'.m~plJ;l \ ~ild. miircly tW.1]'!!Jf fiio!liToJJiIl·

It\.~ Ill! ¥ i , ~1lI" wl¢..f~~i tQ 'Ihe wll1l1fIC 5.tIi ~~ • .-o II'~,5ibl~!;w,d roo d~llflt· !l'ililiili1:l)e'l:~ rOT 1Itt: C!CImf.l IlII M ~ [d'l~ .8hlmii.( ,dJ!']V~~t.to B~ r:hllll9 ,iIl1l' iIm WlM(!QI ••• KI. (Iartlkh, III lllI~~(brli~r flll~" ltF ·'tlnm'tl:I'~.:Ible") ~ nIrd'1Il rmrJiliIdi' M. ~ v~.-d!di]. :il~ilM ,drr!~ma'r.il!litr~1;I1 mill. (Kmt 1991. po ~'5)

'i1te lDlj;lPm:iliill;$; or f;rl~ m '.l\.I~ mn' a:Jll'iin.ltt! lbrk l:]:i!lfU!!ed~eiii!,,'IiIiiIliI:!i 'O.olr' If [b-!:~ pltl,gtb.at ElJiD ~g;lt.Wi: [MC "lwiJl,'mly ~ICl [llJmm-

1fj~te&imfJlc]" fbid.), -

$a.Jtl!nl!II:'I'l)lce ohlle. blil'ill. th~ wlceOif!llmlic;. th.l: di vme ~'Qolt:e, 1bJ;~ J ilb!:J th ~. ~Icc: or I1:,tSOD, wbi h, 'WI . Ie Khlruu;. 1s tI l,IImhuJil!'B5 so Jowl [1m f.liillllilUcr hUlllrloulllr'WE err, \.;,;.c. Gii.n De ... ar,t:~ 'il'l ~flJ:rn~e it. l!.~o.n itse1f:ts 'enf!ffi.>;IEIf!' w.lrh I!h.-e divine 'l'DI.ci; It cmndd~ willL iJ!~Uid ~!~. D!!~I!9 r(lll.l.owln~!1~Doc, he JWi! ~lQ.' llee'l"l1l1iyO' il-5e i!. t.Q[lml<l'l.'!1IIi:~lpbsil' m]~iNiliacl rrQi'!'I trnd:LtlrJDi, !:lIg: d~ 1re~lDl!f' a·specific j:nsta,I]JO'I! crudill.110 dle m'l)ooon.mg of re1OO[J.~ Cru.di!!l, lIi:hc:1um!h, 1\ houkll!Wit be. there !:It die 15m ~1am 1 I~ tM.!: Ili!,e bllii.d. lp!~~ gfKJLntl.'LH rrll~~M'lr ([U' ~ ~7) ]noll;)' t:~. '!Mltlil ~( mrvo!mat:qw il diWerern: FOrni: iii r Soc:r.1~~. th C1L~mmly disiliil:jl&Ulim .lIam dol!!:g \\wl:I;g (;wd 'tv.!> l'elti~"td ro.r So(T.)ires.' ~ Qalr): for ,RoflUf&:a1.! 0 !I'll: dhill;e; and ru:t:un.l ($ilJl]C dl:lngJ 'fOl'Ce \\'o!:S tnit gWdc 1c'lIlllg tl"el}' hum'l:!l be!!J,gllow ~o ,~a. <l itOlnpW bl tNw)' ~ltIDll, p_mvl.&d caa i~n il: ~9 e'iI..r'; whl1~ Ihe GJrtLan '!IOIc~ doe:

Sill

~llH.·~cmul~md br p~ !I.'el'Jt ,mytl~!ug, ,I~ .llcl~I"_a.dvlJtl!!L ~,I"' de~-s.. ]'[1; '11rleruy ~ vQl~ hi. l~ d . Ill •• mi!Xwili ly km~. UI" " lhhlll.liICln,t ·l>l.lliJrnils5:ioIl, Qf'Jt~ ~ 1:0 1fu:,]';1IrtQiIl~ ~r'iimd ~i.y ClTrlle1llLrJnl :I:!J);\': the 1!A!i,eg_Cl:lcml.ntlpetiliVe. Thm-"lUiiM M'reMlt Is: m!!!l'ely the 11ll Wklloo ~o' wlHllnl rIo ~6l:I, ~t Jus ilO fn'het~· nt~ll J! !L:11 [l1!J1"eIi~ lOf~ v.aitl:l, lfle :mrm Iii't:il 'I'Qil:Il, tiI'j!lP~.JI1 pwl'e rQrftg]I~}i' ubml~ICln [Ql-rU'l"in.R~~JJi ]t,;clf'ls ~'t:l'h:S5"""",:"sqm.etW1g tl@I ~~iIiI de\ielep i!i! SOlll-l:= ,I~gth ~IJ rla~ ICm~~ ~·~tDIJ:It$ll?~i+). ~ w.bw~.c:b.e ,"dm:~~ilt'guI'tlrnt. \Y 'U ItIDll~ CI!.tb poswililill tb.t!1 t1idl.c .. IW Dfl'~bSophr sllf}ul be di1;1Om1d :i:Qll} ,:my levl?J)' af pw""r. yet ~cis,dr . ~, ncprt'fed. of ~ ~ ties to .J1'Ilw:er ltC3ll fely oulllle.~ of~fli wWch .vill.u1l:iiJniltl"lr ,pre'l1'~tl, 1h' M,Vruwg!! or~ ~W!l!hy of phllmofl'llf {M ~i~~d (Ill' the(l1~ l~, .pl! :medlqIlIil-) b 'lib,1I I~ ,~IUmlo;mg,'!:IlI:v IJIiIMJ om~ liar oods ofbowle.dee ami inn'!t .;md l:rec~us;e. lil dlle.i: net mingle 'r\r.l.j power" ii!: pf!l""'i>~ U ffi\\eq:io\i'!w_mg: 'flll!y ~e 1I\'i:1« whicll. lis oompt~tdr 5J!e!ll ~I' "Mf 'y''' ,atIl qrlil!! v().!; ~, nl- '1\'O~~ Qf' ~ilQ~. sLlr.:nl i1~ (IU)' hie, I~ mu pt!I'Wef cr tJI= Pt.I\!o'l3'J:~, mE: m"'l!Ilrig~~ f~~,"1: Which 'I;~rnFek us to foSklw ~Sp:D_ ~t is, 'Ih~ pCl'l'i'tl' wl\:b;;ht eru~oe~<1t th~ pmru. 0 :r.edun!oCl!:a or illol:be:J!' power.. ne \w ls lib lJI!Il.rn' 'Ill rtl1!!i1f.L

Th~ K..Unlu~ \itliO'! af~~rI i cwmlir bmlood (10 dl~~I~I~'ililJ (lrth~ silJibjtC! of tiliiltlci.itiOfl, fthf:mof'4lll.t\'i;~.md hm: ~ i "join rh Ii oJ' ~ \';O,kr;:o;;lSpll.Ire eIL'Ufli,:ia.tfQ'[I, 'Who :i:s:itiliaic ia'tld~~ ~in the secOJl!d _per.soll and adlti~~cs ~; "So acl !hoJl [he m~ ,of Y0ll]" v,' ill 'liomd ilI,Vo'il\}\-. !1Q.]d "it. dl.t~lt~ tlJn~ M, the prtndprl~ gMII,g LlIlhft:r~ bw~ (Kant 1993;P. ~Q) I \o'ibo is''D:l1:!: !:ilbjlllne11und:D:ullthr ~t8vf]e.u ID:1pe:tatl:'Ii'e? 'Nhl!chauthllflty ~es ever,obQd-y as ")'"DIll" m aa !lp~1 wMciI.l!;bo~h I!nd:ilWl:.:rod !.!Dl~'Il!t~~ nil: IlUlJlIce oJ' Wb dr - II"l1lld Obvi0u5ly ClIl1~QC ;~~idt - ttie Rl1'1I~t; jl ~p~'i 170 ~.fi~m .. P]~w.dw::i.!l UIl~l"taUl~~hll: [oX'the:StIbj'eQ. iih:il[lu&D J:tisthe "'err 1QC1 o:fd~f!.subj.e.a.'5 a.1.I1OIliOm~, Here \ .. ~ csn OIJ'gu.e iha.~ me :wbj:m of enuaCl~.n trL1ctW1, IU\! l:llinddM \vlth Ilu~ ~rj)lO!: or r~-Qi~. i,b~ V~l.o: \,,'h.~ 'Dl'igk! ~ruml:i~ he de;t~ri:nm d. The iml~rJifi,DlK n:;mn I)' (On~dU!lill!:lil5 stems from a. plaOli bqllnrl w'11,~hJ115I1ii:"S5\. itlS i!fII, ~tQpi¢:.il 1o'L}~QII: ~ddn:~1ng u.s.r!'WIT w:sb:lr; i1IfUJl!!:.r~Of !3[,~ ~ gt\'"al WAr 'lEt

, 10011 tril.tlitl.Q~} b q1 l:iliilrylitS fJl~ ~1}j; ~.I,II dtv!.n~. Li'J.ort i!1l ~\I'oon~(;1l

fit iil"l'JnI~J d1rct:ltJJ' QP.JliDs~ltJti ' [['atl ~J:ijdQ!l to ]JOSiE! a '(iilinctpk

1J\.Ik elW n" iia,m ihn;)I iii lvlrru: il'llIihDnty. Ilnd! ttl [tLl all d b~'!lI!1 ~~W;li1Jtd l~l!erltOg).

A oentu:l)1 .w,d." Iwr liner. F~,d,:Wi ,~mom; F~!fdl1gom T~~ ill'[LUt Dr !I,II1~tm(!Q (,i'JJ1~ i 1D1.;d. dw \'ely ~. mllGliPbcm:. mclIQ.:l, ~ hull:lll

Wi I Y InWl .'11 iJi~l~ a!; ~.lkke th;11 m-Q'~ .llluil:I'~- jj pmVi!~' .~ 1Il ~Jml1s:qn wilbHils.;".BJt50tilKwi1 ]j"~!: [nl~];·md we may beo 1'igh~ 'ID. thiLN~e;f!ticl!:S~. 11lJ!fo,: 15; ~~&]lIl.'CIili.ar ,~boullll1!l',w.eml~s; The il:li!'"gr~1te m"n:~U~1 tc iUi)r~ GIl:. buIlt dot:l iIIIut·rut 11'11 idw ~eii,~. ~loB:' [Vji:Si:tmllldC!i~cl.1s ~t1~,ruI!fr.~t ~ruh1lr. ~l!t:s~.~~clJ It.r.Mlr pdfoJ!,'hari,] 1I'Indly.;ill(7',~ ~Im:~~ ~!ui~~ 0.11 oI'n!'b-l.IJir~.ll$'L1 - ,*as. Tfil$jg cue Qftbe' few T-101IIt!! [ih ,~lllclJ one I'h)' hillll?!Hn!~iic ~I~.rumre of1.l!tl!1Ihlnd. im[ it. i~ 1ft l'!:Sene-a ·poo_m ~r HO ~m~Jl1ru. pGr'I~.bId f;c;r.rn '~I Oll,!i 1(".!!Ii1 du4vlll''tf olifi;- f bc~a 111- pi' 'iiI~I:Y tlf iIP=[:Ql~i:l!l;Ilies.iriHnle.Ib!ii!;.~t.~ta,DIi fUUD;. '.001 proha:PIYIil.ot iJI"'l~-IJ!I!Iiinl!~f dliltli!l~ OJI~ {~.Ill. I!!. po t.3:B)

-SQ liel!~lor !hoe' f.u~1!Ire gf:mrnnkmd,1Jit: ilgi'l'ilil ~[oe.g: ill. ~hc 'VQi~ of ~8m!,} whEc.b., soft iUld.qwer.~ It m;q< be, .... iII11lEmlhele&S:g.;Un.1:he IIl!ppu- h.md ,lind will, ul.dJ.1i\lt~~gE.t hwrlL Th' .~ of n$.Dl~ i.'~_.' :n{];Ill!l. ag'lim, in::l.its 'llti"w.e., whfiI!:C 0r¥n-=i:I~ 1", nu. rn, ,!"S~'I' I"iIt~~oi'}' m~ I( 1"13).. FI\eu,d ~nouhf:nv ... }' &wu ~ 'e:\'lm. m(lre cat~~.md It!lf~~ r'Ql'LlI,tnll1llW!l~ "Our ~A4 ho~b-di.e ru.n.rr~:l:i din int~\m-tbe ~ l:ilndiG SJ)jrit, re.1:!IOII-nuy in pl'OCI:lS$ :fL1i!~e. tf>t~blL'l;h ill:li~~~];! iII[ tli:Ull IJ:1Blul UJ:J!: ofm.a.'D Kdii~l!lihml_w jm ~drlid~Is:e~ hI~]" (pH. 2, p_ .:!(8)1. SQ thar sorr lmll!/,i:dess li'okewJilic.h rini;; Cit;!!

hilM lm!!i!;I'.~~ >Iil Ill!! 01I~~ 1mpralMlll~ C!:ndldli!li.t: rQr ;J!.dl~~l:· JiIlip, IL~ ~cl)' P rupi:liile ~c.'Iund IlOL~ ;ill ~'I m~g,s. ,w ~ futuI'C dlcra~l!iq;' D~t:y in P~lTbl.C llr-e seems ~o "bod. hII fiX the uture 0 q~~.Ml.d, nmlf!l:. aoo:tn~.i!i5 d~lrimmr.a:l.

. r.eud plU lJeilSllfl ~glill!1l. ,111~ m I! of W hh~ (11'1!bJ~~ ;llid 0fi~ pJlm 'tim two m a .pmnmefl!t C(ln.o;I~i:. fhlll?ttI. .. .te'lc of th~ ~!!i,~ ~ferm CIY!~ no Itl{phru;tioni i~ '3.'pp~:!_t!;I be selff~-evjd~l, ~in,"," drives

~!by~. fie. ~trl1'!l r"rm; '~~g ~i'!:$ ure, ,j~!t when: cl~ !:be pmn;:r ell ~rl (Q1:tle ija~J];? On ~ h.: f!l~ CUI Ii, i;lD ~y Jti 1~11r_ hilli!.! ~ t~ mp:st ~ of op,:p~~S'. [hie; IJltl.·~le_iU'lii rund:!'!Ji,1i?, ~"'~6t.:rfulm.mW'Jill~ o!5cl:fi1jVes Wilkh.OI[M,I'oily~·;bd,aWay; 11- dlIdIllig. ~iIi .IUMl MW:t!lr ,ilI.Iul 'ltli~l!llU:U,U, ~ •• ~ ~t' Ih~. !:1IIi.!iIictlWll\¥tbiit rQn;~~w· '1'IDp Uf~ Ih 'lidc.Ji bh:apmp\l).sIOrl .ro;repEUlfOl:l!~di dri~~~drlL'l'51 fi~l':rUtcl clil;U]r bet& (ifi llri~ W!I~.~l')g ~¥:IiI:lnh. m I~e;~' p[thidb.mll(laJ:ill!!oo:,,'mruy. ·IS 'md.~ 0tIi1f, ~.th. 'i.he itlny lr,'CJ'kI~ Ilrd~1! lia!ee.. Amli tt w.r)l' ~O Mil:!, wm \ltIh:t· il't 'lh:JII-:nM 'rh!!' b1m:n.g .,,-mee' or tho !ill pe;~~F. whitll ~ ne n rub le:D!l.li !nakWgili!5lt{f: :nea~ ri:i~ mice of re=~ol1iS' nm the voia: orO! I>!\I.~D\, di!S]l ~ FR:lId!\UliIl!s.Ie.a,~mg ~'Wllrp.ti.oIn~b"QJl.t 1Ih1~ eeneurf:1;i!~ of tlJe: 'IWtI. <Uid ~L i~ llC)t, Ih,~ Vl)}t.~ of tl\~ m,bJ~t , , .Iul bk ~,g,fJ) eHher-OUl it l!ipefmpS ntlt Imrebted re, !:ll~ !1ii.mnSW:I\'hR, bideiL<4, ~_n·iirq:n[cl: [0 m;ile llm.ronIIfCti,Oli:

S6F~'1 liI!!f!~ m.d'i1~If~r, cnilwm~r:: fh~~!t~tb .w ~~oll md 11.1; \iIItJ,m~e p;~~~ Im'll tbiil.~'L~ tC!I1imJr.Q an 1!.lii1!;'()i€E: ipll,!:~ 10 'ilb'l'l:c ,..~d wcll. ~~. ell1lnjl,)' with hll::~- ti ,~f· ~¢~~n:: .J'toel' 'wl;ltury -md i hat Oi!:t<!1!jI milll c~iP~iiWJr 1d~Wic pfi[i~ ..mr th.eg~!:fa[ U'~ It tfi5:!!fid-.-I,uU;t Ithe.""lrQCu.qc Olbi]m

Ib.e tr!tb.lD. ~t)4I, Of'I'elUCi.ft JS. o.u Ij;'I!)iil~t. ~q:oo. I~~j.~" YI;~ brln~ «;uiQ~ kind fdl¢ml'IO~,p~~ mil 'Pr 'liIlI'li,iIJlP, d !.G, ~1i)J1 hilS r:3\~ die mQmi]Iwe pfa d~au~. plQ itt.aJ dnl!twhen. ~~ '>ws ~~[u:~y ~g I.I:llmJIr.ill.

,f&. J1!1W~,~r CO'IIfS ,h s iil:ll Il~);liIl:d fM J~ud UJIl.~ ~l1c ,,~'l ~a In II dcl1mte! .. .ill.OD-KaniUn ""Iill. in a u:nnm wrd~'r;md I ~e ~e he biidrtdditki, -a liw:adB"~~veQr.lJ~tlfurpl'.ow1l,;;S8 iJ;lQ Jn~~lJcc~ H 1!Ium. :111: ~ ~ Wi mil'..hab:!~ ~lJlIlmll swe. winf:reall lW:J.1An rnoscm t'l bc,v,lld 5Ciw~'1!-sdlwlet JiI; ,~ WI' till' ftll' ~d,. undNsliilillmJl.J. not Y'm:lImft: HamIl. Sd'i!ttt:e: ils'm l!ffUr of ,p!'CIg~~ ·'n Imowi:edg~. b!lIU~, is1!IDt.,:md jD'iLcticill ~r:m, ",,;!ilii!.1! nw[aJIJl'l!.~ I" s:tliLi.ll~d m i't!;1!1m1 b(!}liln~ dn,~ pGSS~1tl,= Ift.cil. nf·$d.IID~e--h 00.11- C'I:!I?ml Iii Jlo,q-Ial~l. IlIr :fti~;in.im]Jllr!~, Sl~t both ~t W,(~ lfol'l!~d ~it ~~ ~11 ~nlptimLof'rbt mic~ ofr~D ~Jl:on, wiJhjlS; ~~knCllpowe!:'.llr IIhmIe,!.'rlimp&ingiit!:df;mdzammgi.h.earing ~ AU odcl'li.llllil,~~e fo~ Iw Mrhlng '~o d!r;> ''''th dllvbdcy, but. Ii dOIiSIM~ ill .piliiid~ lmk \li'iith mt~om;ciOIl3 dt:me, UiCiIIl), Ul ~oth£r &m.?U& !p~_g~. ~f3ill drew the. ndiQil COilclusiml. I[hu dJ.e: ~. iI!:~d.dlii; the ~Hm C'<lji.l!:,g:Ol;ial'lmpen!l~~ • .he.sar-;, 15 :'iimp~y d..mN llil I~. pw:~ f\orm,· tnod~i111 d.Ul, 1l!UW\~ or 1f8iroj !IS dm.n~ hy p$1dio~; l!;,.I:IJllC'I!.M W':llh ~M u"Q.cQlldditinl d).II!"U:te.r 1iI.~r nsID"'ed Jmr the .0'1:""1'": it 'tun.l\l, the om:afidl'ool!l:<l!.l i:lf !l~t; dmund. 1:01:0 om. "~IIiniIii!'! e Ildltllnl" (I..:i.c-an.! 8-9. P. ~ ; .tinil'!.:rld,Ime:! "'O!fi W.bOO1~ _tilJmr,iibtt mIW~, In mllnlt'I·II:I~:ml1e" (LIc.m Ig9;1. P. .5:1 Iii), We ml;lli!Ol!Q1:: bywhlihillfiY obJeC[f~ ~1w]'tilllld.l:!ld~mli1d "'pa;i'l1Jtl]'o~ic.lill" I!m!. di. • Emrtm sm~ of me. \\\'Ol1d. Des":I:re eanaot beat cvmpioIllisle. wnh oUIy pu-r!omr ,ah~I!Ct, 'Wb.1.cllis lI;.wys: ~I~d lU, "'dau,l'll e '(;It it," ill a J:ll(]C~~ -wh~e dcs~ rw:ifi m~i:]o ,i'II pmllaJ1l!1il dls:i~ru!ii.~tlon, ~ ethics, i>5 prmnuJ;g~l.Cd by I;agII in t"1flll'llithllo" ~r ~~!~I$I$) ~ 'Ih!:. I;!l'ri~ ur ius ~t.cna; on d~ . of. de51re ~ an m:tmm;ProllllSIllS

Thmtial fif m'i~i!il!!w. fmilill~)I'I ~hl!R. hili ir IIII11qJ ~D)":li Ih~ liIl'i1~ dll~. 1"];u;.puill . .ellmn'u: been iin-.w.o eo lite ~1Jkt lfu:tFrel!I.d ~~ eJ:lIG:tly till! ~iNnw i!.I~,..aOOtll uD~low; iil~n.]GJ ¥eke. ~M,.I!I ~Ow,hu~ ~b; UJ· idSWic!!·il> fn~ll1Icnlll,f!_ PcwP& tb~ ~ [I :RbtiOc.l!l beu1M:'.en 'Ih-e ,~ (,Laa:1'I 1'9"9'. fL.a~: UlUlJiilElllll Iilodlfkd)

5(J 'ihlii ~tt<Jngof fate ~:fb~u~ re<lrol'l wiJUld, m(!,i't'!, lQ be Imkedln lli)lw llIIJ,;ollldom.l't~n 11 JIIlb:iguOI15ly deseribednot mplr In 'tf1m.:S of WI:! .:tg.mcy of repre~h]iirl, dltlllpiltl!! i!.1l pili ponm ,clll::l<!,tc.mJ mill" but :r,itbm' .In '!em1!!; oftbe nv~~!:h <11.9 th~ w"hlc;-l!! y,;'i1l oiIw~:r- tL1DIi: it5"df bend .. blJ'!.\Ve.';Termu:.;h ~ try tG· SIl.]nili&5 it-.it"WllD get heard under tin: 1J_e.srar,i;)!i.I);l;~ps.lll.1$1l1h 1JI1OO1l5d~d~iro.'l.teason"WOuld !be ptJ¥>ul:w I fit dlicl IIOt OO'tl ,:J.U ll!Il~ In t:btlimemi.sdDn~. ,:md lI:l v6k!! 5:eems toile pnidscl}' me p~'i'otiil. pWlilt. ,.,.Wd. linb th.e rf:l~ill'" af ml.eIlftCHO tbe[pIJ'Ol.ler..!l ort~e:id. mill 'I!O'l!1!h lb.em.tp.g,~U'Jr. Cm'lili'e 11101 t1~d ll.lll[ldicad~1I of'th.i5 wN,dy ~f'l h"f vcry .mil~t~ of Tte In~~gm~ or D~ Ithl~ ffl;inl vtfgj]: f~~ lit !lq;1IW .~"j!ffOO". k~Cl'OOfl1J mtrr.r4!ol" ·tou!d ~ Ilo[ lb~d its.meMllIlg in. tIlelil!He dra.~ inl!<l.mfll»K m 'm1p1oy ~br infemal ttgioDs.m ord,ct to,:g_'el h~~ ~d [0 p.lieYail?'.!\t:Id. th~t,'i!s tenuous tl:UII, w:rtl1 ill!llis jll 'vokt2'

~\tC!i tb~ i!!lIh1,I~dQ '~liiC~ ~¥- eallL'I[lml'IW~ 'rJ;.' 1i~lr!~,~tI.!Ji~;I!I :Iu IiBf pUb"tl,Labt-objC!;l: tmp"bjc; CiIii ml:;il~ up lq iltsl:A:. omd ! ',I:Ii~· ':l.ti,re: ~~ fl!\'U)' ,g.qject..~m be:,~q!l~'ill otdes:1:Q reiii!.imll des:ltt 1II ilS"!!KIdL}t But U:is Ihi~ wy p,JJrt~ .witidi.fu!ietl,mll!!: ' me ddil!ll5e liHllI1. 10 1M! ~1Uli!iIii.&lI1J! W, 'tVlll the dUe: ~I jill-gga 'w,l!lc!l 'aes.!J U i.lf ~~ ttl ad.Uikl 'auE ~PI)l j:tJ;; ~lii (.u,bI!i:! .~I.i pUonq; [tRW; ,;md 'the vut"telS p~plnd1!ima.n:1.v:Jl1I;-.~rumwm~h en~blli$ tbis ~j~t:L(m.

! ~~~ Ma~ ~~ ·!.!Illlorl~~ p!~ !i.lfml:; '~lblc!!e!I,Q~ I.!!I' rg~\\f: 'Wllr ~~ D~t ,!lI~, Ill' ¢a,&l,cr ftlr~l1l1&l,f.'lIlrb~ Plie l\ilii 1m blI!.~ 11(11 qW~e ~1't?2!dJ,erl'ihe ~ ~ m ~1ilf~]i.Qnilil.],O' of l'~. it iJlill:Ot be. IZaw:se s'l!lbre~ SII'I'.ci: bJ dBll:t msooitd c.f IIstmw~ to i?~t.I,tjUJlc llin! cf:il'll!t,a£ry. 'lhe)lJ!R: lW'-fc~· ~n. t1cld Il:!U W ' . i'IUxlull. tI1~ fl~ \ t ~y CiI] tbm i;ie~rt. :\1!.cf gI'I,l:'l'Iln:m'~~~" ~'~~ tln:yllQ not peJ. ~~in Irhmq~esm.,

Iu! tf'l'i'l'! .IhUCI1i'Il d$1Ii!iIidim ~i!.iIgg'llSI:i.o:n" dien "l~m ,~«mdm,g {a frmtd" ~ii)uld b " (0, 'be 'i,Umri:lld rrom till1;Pl" ft'Ikin\t'f!al~ L\ll'ImiiI. blten~tiIl,aJ J:e:ro.1!I1'(ll!!i.~~ti&.PfQ8i'cil:!:" Mld 'g !;;!j],. ,1'od .~~ ~p.i:lllll. 1!!!: ~m~bed MId :re5t!r~ KiintWIse:DSlE, wh;qc [,~ v;"Quid Bf)W ~p~ ID a . .1!IL"!Io' l!!S,~t: !lC~ itiRaSOQ dfSuucd to tiHn'e. me wtl!d.fQ<I'ce:t gf mellfit:o:mclmu. 'bu~ tlw [l!~1Ii ohhm utrtCQMdop!.l!i c! t~. Itlid[ the 'IoCWi of dtlusiDm.md ilh:L~lGns wo.s U1;rt'I»\lie, a prOi:lWIng f - l1.lte.1deilHy 1}~dbL eheek .,,)' th~' mice Ofre!!>till,. £In&~d),a5wdl rullr]~ ltiru.J(!if~YU!:!l. yl'·:ld.l~g. uu~[.colltpmrnln:sll..,,·tmldlAA\'I!;'!Q' I: ~iUl"I~d in iclu t,gD, tl],,~ ~"Itfi tb,e i!l~hi:itl~f 1I&1Jl.ny hel't) ~'bliI ti, i'il~ or~tljl;:wht~,.r:~n Ifed l'U thl::W100DSdo~-slb~uldl'li'f! sat "',.«mid~JJlS reason' ~ollil:d ~«Vif',as'm. o1Ildootl! ,In thW1 ..

:So ~ the: v.ol<:e. of~Ulln, In t1tl& v~~. m ;;c~l~ ,~hm~(11IJCIi)~ It-· ~R:! Thles de:!iUe.Im'1! 'II; TtItoe.. scft at lilWi 7'vk wiD cllme hl!:k 'wm~~. bu~.lhr ~ .l!llOO1mc V;;e'. ccm1.tl 1."eltL1!rt. ~lire :totlow:mgF dwroi~ af (L1Ii~\~!.l!l) f. umI. In : e- l3:pecl'Slit~nre l!; Pfl.'hap'~' DDt W.lio1t waulld I'fOl~~t US ftom ID.: b~iIIIJ.Clill'iIIl!f}" or the m-!;'Iet'. OUII, e],llIue tJJ.~ OOIit:r.OI,IC]1I, die le<lawbicl:l i:l1iI!peL .. dm~m 1be:d:ri\"il.V.re. 'in'llm:rememher t!ul thl: "!1lffilio;m of d~lrt" (lilile .heroism of ,lim ~~e nor. to g!\fCll i,';1;if au lll'J:u'·~· d~lrl!!:") IIIIl r t~C'Ifi'BWt \\'Ord '~IlII!!t.l:I.l~ ,~~t~.'(~wJDu:df. 11<:, neiiw:r l'Ul'ilt4 to f d'tl!tdteRfI~lliiiftil1liiruh;5 (I!:lS~/6Q);,iWd "'il:.llind iin Jlll!;, ~,U~q,iLlwt 'I'oomka ~e.ndrm'rf tc;i' il. dem.o"km df de£il"e.:: iJI: 'It,JU.'IT to be:rou[ld olIiU1Q!lg Rithol fOI1:r furu:t:lm~ C'¢Ill.>lepts off.!'iYcDm.Jii!iysis.:' .tnd: w ' t:.Ui ~.w Ia.t~ hi ,E~rJI5: "'IToI' ~~ U ;l &hfcJ.~, ~. ,lnohlh!JtWI.I. as!i.i'nst g;amg b~y6nd i! [,e:L:WIiLllmil: Ii!! jil'1lillomc~'! I ~'a,! .1'- 111) the heroism oftl:esd;r'" ""'''iluld have: t.O lxilO;mdon-ed FCrrIti1I)IDe[pil:mdpJe, 1e:~La!:lJl'~f "rmJ1l. ,~h:s[re. '!.Q drwe':" $euml.lticaJly. ~he> ;e:mlC!!! or dtsite

G)1,11,d r.ie b1!lJ', : Ilflh.l: thle'S artllcH:uloo i6!1lrb IILHIrIl!~' ~o .lliIiut

puli4i,l'spm:,esrfur.nl, 1r:I Heltl.e,gK~. mtli, m~ ,,~tc~ W'Welt l'H)'lii ~ in p.m:i.ml:u- b\lt~1l5 OIS'~ pl!!11e~iJqtlC[Q& V~' brt~r; in I.b!: p.. _~'pllS r,lkluliltll/J'Tim¢ whkh. by tIu; '" f. ~M'dl dU;S-,lm]E; ¥~r, ,IIIJ~. ~lrell.r~ili~ 17iulWtllf n WllIjoll) ~~Img mill Gror~ .liTht: ~at-onH:ll!oVc;d ro·tm.dl.:uiOlil.S Qf (lQm:ciomre'; {## 15--60,,, "'~ 1:m M~ the: whole p!.lmommoirtlfY'Go.fme ~l (&rlW) o-r I:Qnscrea;l!ee;:

Wb1I~ d(l~ ih~ ~'IlllldillUll: c<l1I to b.itrJ 00' wlmm. n ~~ l'<1bE1 ~(l'1n11~ lliJ~. TI1~Cillt ~arn.il~ihlng. gl'f;'~:n_!l Wi'oil'm;1fi.crn,jJ:ltlW t!\U m'lrJ l'I"iIl.'i'r.ql;5~ ~,lllHblng 10 11:11. t, lIL I)' '.n d'~ 1llJ'}' to 1!:~.:fIg.. mg iI ;o~~m~u.)"n in thr. ~:!"wwhlmlt ~;l'Ppi!alM "Nothf:Ia:g" ge5 C!)!~~ 100 [ U~9911ktl] tW!I.~f, Ibw.J[h~ 'b~llhl'!mllmloor [ilufpl'~J lIll u- 5clf-fmt l:S.tolliO D\VIlIltlll&t f!tJ!~1ity .. ;fm~.klnJ [~I~] 'The lelldenc:v oJd!~·i;<IIJl~niJ[ sneh .l!.WO .1!U!U upfm '~lfiill1"theSeI.h'a,"''''~lfdl tb .ppW ~~ we: but 1'~C!lb ImcJin rftrlil~ (olIH'I ··fc.~N1") l[tw(.Mdi'"llDrnf·-)fUJ'ilm] bil.O iu;OWlilImml p~hlI.ltf~8; ~~. il ~n1iH.Om. to i~ D'lVpmI:;lOT ~IIDlllt1itr-rm:~kJnlil-ll.5-Sdf .... " • C~OCf 1fut.~1J1!6 d!ly alii u,tu-r 4~ llie ,m.;oi!~ IlUili:plliQ ~li:tiI' (liddc8XCf 19'1:. J I 8)

SQ ~h~~ is 11 pm nl!I; w~b 15 []In sonereus, !1m O!l!I!1lnmcl1i1.g illlf- 1$111'18', ;l fli.efe toil\1'OQlIOII DId pto1loaticm. ru:e all [0 ~J16pmb:lg 100 BWn~, tn ~:E!lm:n afthe tW5WIil' of 1t!11e~s; .!i.elf'P.1'8~fi~ Arid ~helW~DII 0' ~~bdlr -ahk;d mora] respons3billty-'is precisclJiIlIfffiPO!lie ~~ !hUB u~l~h ls Impog;llll~~Q.~ It! i'Cipollid 1.0 tlJlis ,1:i<lI!1 br o:;Y~dw,g h 0i.!C c;vad~5 grll:'~ fundam~nyl ~llUI.bi' fr,;md (JIloi:'b iilf!.Vo\YIi toll.lt:di Iilpon, '[he '''fItlY !loton of res~rnilSi.hilil}1' has the l'oke.a.~ ilS ~'~ ji( is ;)[ ~Dme t.o a \l'ot>c~

:iJ;5

-.'

iI!i

~ '\\!;blft' .. dQ$ W wltili!: ,~Gme oom, lit come!! litlm m~ irmi!m~~~

11i

oil ~~Wll rOl.!!r bdllg, hlll.~ ~~.J.H'l\~ I'tmtdUi,mimtdiling 'Lh:u 111~~ I(h

5, ll!'i. l'l: ~ Irii o1Wlili1~ flW' IliBft::mf!l~\'eS, ~~~. ~pIin",;, b~:d ;;,1: cur m~ fumw;l.e.

inli~1 tif~ I;~U ap~l1i, ~!:)i'ilfbllli Whrcll m'~ll~illl1{en Lt!'1'1' IlL~e.,.f llQf pre~ £QltilDl' Vp!\lIIl1m1yEHmr:m:ed.o!l11 ~~~ v.t ever dl;m~, "'U" CI!I!ls [ "!E!!",ruft], Ol:&alflfl~ Il!Y.l.' ~ianll:iHI oUlf[ $Il ;t;gMI' ~ DIll" ",ill. , .. Th !:.ill t.omiM bmt.im ilDd yi!!t f,ruID .~ ~ .( 1971.

po. 3:~O) ,

Th iII'tlm.l.ey flU. h.lcl), mcil]J C1m1e8 is dC;!lai~dla.~ LI_mifdJk UJI~ ("'The. ,Gill poilus fWl~ ID IJiliidll·5'pi)!.eWiaEo/-fu[-~g.md U does this;iS;I. CilU whI,dlcolIm~:rf1:lm Wlcm:Wn_~ rlli~ldm!j~lj": ihld , [), 11$,)' ne r.tn. thfi ~ 'th"oltt, the "J?~--lihgj'l"pwpelr ,1~tJglIi i5 ddr:tdf.t~, v."ith il'l flu! ambigulty thal: ]freud ~ givm th1li woN.: me m~6l!'li.iIl ,exJECn~ the ~PIl'Qpria~ed in!;fmaq" ,the 1i.~lbJagq"""""me ~~IBJlt ~u.·j.lllim ~rd1 rl!!r ~h~ 'UI~,~, So, ~hJL! call IrIi dlti !tlill, '10 ~Xl" {KIWI . tile QP~ng f!iJ Bii:iDg, whl,~~ Ul gfp';; eel 10 a ~elr..rdlcc~h~ II1IJ!lole;gue "'i1ithm Ollt!l;iI, ft hi:u~.s. W1ilhilt whi..:h. wil:hkL GD!:Self, aile· C'mfi(\[ ~ppmp:r1:ilIe. aIlil, which 8till3d:y opp,o&eS, .mill.litlr:J 000 ~eUQ!lmd!CI1I ii. 'Th! v~ Is P I ;d~ c ·I{f, II,pm'WtS" tLl{;ofcl'l:Cld ity.11l tlIb fQle It '~n! JW,ume;iil mUottl1ral fimt:liic!n d'o~y ilkfu HI rlial of ~f::,.1he 'l:emRl !;i1.t::5Q!Y ofH~ldtgger'~ book, The aoalo:SV ,goes soF.u tim seme ~ h.\~ P!oposechhLlt iIlili!i:.;!l!!.flIril'dDIllIIll2ll:Tima: wl!CI(luld rfN.'r lu:. (or 1~;Utu!) fI:Cld(JS,p~!l'puqjtt[ OI15I:MIl tmd't6j;c,"

AmI. e'\I'ell 'I!L'IQre:. jf tiR vdte hl'lihf.opmlin:g ·to'Ol.-a:rd Be'm" rut; open· I.ng,';,rJilc:,h ~m IlS from. rubm~i::lf)n1n the ~!i_liIg: th!IDgsmd dj~ ru.p~. tht! d.mcd ~1:: !)r s~-pl'C!;~m:~ md ~~-qfIrt:1jlo:l~, d!O!l$ It ta.fl;t '~()'1ltlw d'ult ml: "'~e IJJ'dm~tl:'tr !;'I;IiLnQd>~ with 'BclJlS ;LUielf; lking i~ :noiblng: but I:b~ UjJemn.g "mi!.lli!fested'" by melli'owe. "dJJdJ I11is eonseqll'llnte is t"Jm.deBs.ed m Hel.de:UeJr'!l biB[' "i.t:Jxl;. 'kuJre "'I]]I:1:::lphlJa:" l'If !'un:: !l(l.1l:~ QrlWlng," JtS'l!lDml~~Sda$ Cllu[, gMll, whet· i511'i lttnlt m:apbmidl,'t), kina is ~nili:s. ib1~ mllylihJQugb the mute, ,jphtll:ii~ voit:e:, ,ifi"~ J,uilmr: N~~ot:,

_ mil On~ ltIll.lJlI'llIIlIli,utftllli ~1111!1 a:p j" 1lQ<~ • ID ·bci!:i&l'GIiTI.~~· tlt~ ~r~@.. kiills.lI:I·e.IIiil\<lr:1e o:W;dI Iliinidm:,fibnub" I~~ iF E~ ~Ut], 'fheQlfl't wJ:io _ ',CiiU. ciJIn I, ~m.a: t,Q l!he ifuifl rlclug, h dnu ~~:urnli1all.lif lnl.l:d ~ilimil 'J LII aD ~~I~l:ial~ - .. "ThO'rigi·lIary ibGU:~~ is an #'U i:JI thy: 1ndi~n itt Iliclng Dc~lI ".rr fi1lM. ~£I Slim], lf~ wlkf~ th~ u!lifqlllt ~~hi'lmiEl'1 ~mJ!~ i~~i!<lf h~p~ [lidl!~~ ~m' !fElI'mlijlliiD tml: linn ~he. mmmt is;. 'Im ~ b» If"me.li~ re.~ ~Il' 1.'I:li'e· \\'1(1«1 .• t,b.!t m,\l.U: whl:c ~ btiliog: ''hf.~]XI~iI;.Il1' tl\IJLiI~h.I, L~·thll ~rfg~ of b,'I,umm il'~1.ld1 [li!i'-l1~l" ~likh ii'll l:n fi:r~r

r1al:e~I~dl::rsJmgil.lag~,~m;z:;:rererm<l.d';1I:1 ~~ t'iflhe.~'rd:

La ""~. (Hw;III!>~&er 1$"6, pp, 307, 310J m tr.!JMlolllii!l)

So,'Specibii.s, .. "",~-me ... ;dy" a ]'ifSPiil'lil]it, at;rreapQtW: tQ ~l<1Jr.coi, and itw.ip 'b~ '[he J:.M'IblJi'tr ill: rebrlcm to d!!e vQie or ~~~.

'!bns 'WI: lu,~1!i In!ti'!a uom rtJ! "cLhlaJ" CI~~'[Jry (lIf du~ V'Oi.Cie of ~~W~ 1);1 tIw ~rmLd~~I:Jili!l"llil QDix111)i'fcal~ Ca.lIei!lo.'l' ufdle VOiCe!; gf'Bemg l(Heidcgg!;f ..... jD I:'v!.i.llr:~n,gi~ !!lllihe ~~ term onttllom~)· .\\llhwnm dl!l.u.ktug ts a 't1Spllil.S~!,a tkut ';m;11; ~XJf.c~, me. Vcl ~ \\lJth ... ~~1~ ~'Wir!l.m('jJ!il or ~uw~t.lb,eilii4~ ~~ tbN.: l!r:I'Q,pg 111 illId !;If'~IIIIl 0.1 ~ ~'. the m~Dull wbith is, il.dulu:!JaI1ied in Lw:Jllage 100J;H!P(lSOO of 'Wordi, bul·y".mch <lit die Q]]]i: ~il~U! ,parmI!: tt j.ts-gwdel~Ile. org-mlx~glDgWLg~, 'U it.:! ~b,o. !tl:i R\I~!liH. lIS. ~;C.n'itl.l~.il- l'hl!N.hl I • il!I !'Jl.e OI.ln1J gllll}' of];! Idqgu I~tl:!im:'m'! t:h QUiC 111m! \,lli~~ ~ rliqil'i'\rednl)'( Oo:n[F or .n·a1;'[jrn.l~ti~Llbu.t of.tll pbon[u,ub$~ff' Fit is:'iI..sikll.'t ,'Oire whii:h ~preseFl.cc (dI.2.1 wW.da OOllSllliU.'ti!;() dle: ~eniW ~ thold f Ib~\'tlii:j!' tlill.'lll,gMnt Ili~ m.ll);Jpb.y~it:a.l lir.i,clldqn.): !;)JiI ~h:\l. Q~IoJ!9' bit~ he ile"'/'oJ:nhc]t:5ili ~. It Il!l th~ 1~(]l:11t or dllJ~ 'b1fDpo~;b!li:.) IJOgm. ,1 ~ berm!! 1;t.ngwg~, ;II I:aIlm !;vftk:h langnag:t: .f~pn~ as m ~cllo. fu~ m~i.c5;5 501..1.m!: of ~! me:rnlng. mtn~ fum!l..:ul'i~ [bUI ~lJIgl..l"'~~, wiu.!rt di~ ods:llJ, tU.'tb.!l\Lgh pU!r.lfi ell of idl m,gupb},!ltaI ttmti M!.~'IZI!l'5S lfuiRcLiom;as a "pure «igm," <is (fin. iirp~\'e. Uus.lOlJr \v"'here dre miCe l!'l!:b:()ol,l;IiV"i1)" mmsllllO ~'hill' (¥r1- :g~I,I!-an. ill'i:D!Q!lI!I.l.~. r(lr Wo, jlL ~ bm !:he c:t"i!k!.qllcm.':(! Dr Lh!l! ad-

II !l:Ifoogl:!iijC, ,ill ~xtiitiil~C, mrplw,

I c:mnm dwl:!ll mf.~illIg~ here-oj], thJs quelitiOri" wbiclJ deIiW1d5. <I ;IlUI,c.1i [eIl;gi:hi.er tbOOt.!.tio:n,

lac \1!illllW :J\i\!tlllill 1(1. the ted IliI'JIe.uI, Q' dt Iil)~.i!,!! W:I1.ed~ 6&ili't' Thml:!a,h iLll ~ .dlmip:t wl' ieh "Ie li~~ ~ 1"1eH.y c:om.fae· d. ;0 Ci,enain, ~" 0[1 ~as:penSislj'ed bc~ ,the irii!,~ Juo.'P!BJe irljUllcti,cUJI. L\lii .lml~~M·rc ~'iQ!t,i:!]CI!. ~~ m!; '0l!II~ l~.~.d !liP! ru ~tl~~ dll>~~'lil:;,;tl'; ~~W~I;iPI'h fllilrth.ulD ~flfh~~ Qr pilillJ 1~1rI~I1JIOl m~lr,~1 j1:ld\gm.enllS"OI; Wide vm'~t}' o:r'EidtiCill tboo,~ I_l 11i1mi.li'op);!looithm, ,alm(Jugh II ~oorleliJ 1!!11o'El'Y..difrle.re.IU:!U~u:mgi. we·i>tr.aD~e1r fIn,a ag:2l1n_ J.n a.n ilte~cd r(l:rm. tnir ;II}lll,,~ dl: l on i'ilg ~he "QI'liC-. ~ tl~ . (!bl~t,.. tid me :dgmli~, Vk'e: ('ould ~¥ fig! ,he fi~ of tb. ·.v,i) Qt (If·c ascience EmpIifs a certain tii!/W ofmo:rn1i:i}'~~lhe ~gch.a.i!l crumm be ~~l.£raJned by 1t.'ic,'\!C:lr :Il.ee~, ,li. C()o!'!ing. aJ!! .al1cl1~g€;. . , rOot in ml11e1nl'lll whil:!h t" Mlli' i:p fier. iithJI:3 lI~IiI'lm .1 \'DICi8. bl.ll .. 'immwmd:J clJ:U:ni:e:lfdo~ iiiilJlt.s:.i)f ilny1hmS' •. bcing.hy vil:tU I:lhh,u oUI. me ~Em:der,~. idls~lllte. aHt~.1]'m ~m.d:I D:llI!e canIlcK e;:soape. or. ~U~nilii itbl ~lliIOi' be ~U~d. TlIt. "];ii!" ~p.;m ~ th~ IlCl[l~ Ilptfying ,~'Ilr.allh~.e:I~u filllr11t!,iI,liIon ofcth.l~' 'B!.:u ;wh~ kind of f~iUi~d;liion1 [f.:i'l: is COIl-!i:~~~ as ~be dMne vo.i.c~-=-inF.iinible boc~u5-e m\-me, M.d.,mill::it firm p.mtee.-dlen .~t wnuld rum In~o ,~ pasith'- 11:)' wI ch ·f\'DWd. rde8~11!: dlt!: sub \'li:t ~ Ii ~~b'e Jw.e- uf anrLt\!l

ut ··rd~~11 pilhlll <jJlC:'!l11 "''''(lid ulilIyi.f ""n . l';iWl!~el;re .I'b~· ~;u;e iI.pm!;:.~ whil;;h wrm;nm.d:s. J:tQtIDng sperifi1::;m:d olfer~li() guM;mtee.Inone md ~'Same g:eSllll:ei[ d,;1i,vers m,.'[o,di.e OUier:mdm om o\l,-']l ri!s:ptlmt'lbWty.

Thl~ etht~.' ... oi~e ~n he rcb.iled log the milf;';e Orp1!!~C En~mdatJa~l wlddl ~'e b~.",b:II,'~dy .gf.:~lJ;aed 111I 'IJingms'th: !Jtclliran~: BIIJI if in I!i\gtllitl~ .~ oollkirqJfMeIll eDLIoIlctatlOll beyond j,~l.e.me;!lt.. t':IIUIl~ olaui!lf.l n I:b~ itWl.s1 bIt lfltmiall :nI:rpllJ;~ of ~t;II~n.l!lm. til !Il :In the domai!n (lif '1i11hi.~ we b;i.e to mn£roIlt millJct(ltill'l, 1'Yi.mU[ ,f! 1t Ilmmt 1- 'f.!ill: iB tbe.'CiI'OOM pot!1I. me [01!lcMIOIl.e. o:i!f:lll!Itil!Iry: lhe~'~il:t 1$ enun-

lU!On, ~~t"~ Iu~~ t ~'lJFl:r1y UIC tMcrrum~ ClI<IM"I'CL TJ1I: lTi(),I;1J U;J\!. 18 J~b 01, m~p;m(l~d ~(!lllt1~ll·'t. i1, M:n(~1i~ left hi $U~ptmt. nmj}!1 d Cli '1?'I1y;r;·miWq~ll. but ,;;j ~eJiItell~e d.~mEl.djng ~ C:OIlIID.lJ!;WOO"iI ~elJlen~ [,0 00 lJG!mpif1[ai. D)' U\Je §.ubi~CIi .. hy.ms Q!I.' .her: moe:a!l ~.eclsi.o:D< b)~

jhe.d.Il't. The~lll'tc!t~a(ln is met", but wfI~ !iutijeor 'ilB-'tti. ~ivm ~hl: • ~~m~ ;ll'lil:I!1bWi"~mb~tli.e emm~I!)n..~nd:JtDJI ~d L_ it 'I U tho iJ!I!!eh;.1'll1! '1:d1iC~d!:M:" not .. 1:t1ilUld orpmhl~~, hut

)f'll 1it1bc1e6'S.Il~lilltl:i oil (»1i,!;W\1.<· 'I i~ tlom~"11 ~e~eJ:,

)'f:[ tl:ii.f e1bi~ IDicefs ~ltWy '~illl'mim;: i:f'illiN.Uhe-very ~me of I~~ )i:t!iiC!Jl,l, ;u ml; VOicc;tlf.the pu]'(! mlunciioow:W!lUl!,Vt .pOsio'l'e I!llJl~'~~l'. it i!l.ilLso. ::u. .hI.:; m!.'~'of~b~".Ii,yID.s ~.WJiy .frOm th~ ~tJ-'dn..l, ~cIrna ltui i:wU, ~1:I1l.i~ m lllil: nmt~'l!lIr ~(ib[!;'S. iI~'r. 'hepiyt:hl)""midydc n_ rqt tb.¥.fl,~ ikti lW:SUpe!lC.go..

b Il'lUlG5l.D.)i' 1ile.1C~ dI'lS ,!he: :i,lq)!lreg:o, ~s fmm ... ~'Ok!nmd. is ll:'JIJ~q",1;!d wid~ • voim;' P.l'e~CI heps- tl)rlli:ng· ~cI 'l~ ~~ "tt Is it £m.po,ssibl.e f.ot the iili~~tI is &r 'tbe- eiQ 10 dhcl3lm i:;;s:I1ri..gln Ilrom

gs·b.1iimll [We Hitd:;imfti3IJ:lQMmm] • (p.IJ1. II. JL 394J,}ffur J'reud th.lt,'llDl:ttliqr or d!~ ~ll]l~~ iill JtlSt €fIl~ ofi ('!!lltwl;).~.!hen for ~on lll'f tlw e.sen'IJiJ i:'~Mi: ~()l:l.:Ii1;lt!ilJ1.ili~ or IJil:tl tIJl~EH "thi! SI.Ipmol!t:I ':mi~:Iin~~ im.peral;i"'ll . " . ill: a~,aI] <L "'Dk~' md ,'euy ~~t,md wltln. Dil!J olb.e:r .l!U~'I1itr man !lr~t otl:ieing,lllt.iait ,'O.tee [~FJ!~.~'(ll!- 1!:II.lf ql:l~. d'&~ In p~~ f(ll~J" (l,~ 1966, po 1iS&j.) _ l~J'Q'l'n 'this; ~ c.,a,n dtidutu.s'lh:tltl. '!'be:ii£ll!lI,l4ffi\'"IiR:IICI:I:J.eIVi "Im the [hl~ ;pg1iOeillIU;11h :!UiPEre.gO -mn:s be~ ilkem ice (If·pure etIund;ttioH :md «h~ fort m1:q Moreover, ~~ fur m1!~e, ah~s (tames up .\!l'fth mtet:d!1.E1S. bur lbe:Jle GIl be lnI;SifllOllq totb:IHIO C'. 11: iJ.fl O~. umlle.!nlili:!!I~'t~c~ tiIi~t l'l'\'! !/lltooldhA."'"em rem_rnlt wt~ n.tbt:r, it me,ral ;!Igl.mq'm rellltifiQ It! which '~iIJ1e.:!lw~ ddicifflr~ h.llW~ti ,b.;urll "'1:JT,y, .... re wilLa.h~~ h:Jl. dltI r~, DId ~ Jj,l~, ""~ i:r)11Q 1I~ 1IIl]1 to i~, iJll.e big~eiI' dJ,e gilp. his 11\'r:l1;e tb,it 1l1W;'Y!l_MU~ei tliu~!:bj«-t 'tCl.fll'Llh.lWd I.bll' ~,ulltj.er \!i.'L! itf", liIe !5Wklie:f: we: will 1wcmue:, i!tI iii s!df-pm,Jlcllm~ 'pmc~ w~ '~rcl. ub 01Il: Self-It!Pro.lCI!e1'i itndO'1lf &il1!rei,l.l1ilI.t Is lire 'O~CIm~ side ,c[ m/f. Illpl!.1't1l11: Jii! nn1l1;\~!l'lI~ Il~utlrdiq', Ja S~dr~~, .11:l lllilit"HlillS .l:ndLr~ r~iinec r III mil] ct'~'!I;IclI~t!etn8' lb put ,it III Ka.IlU,J,fi tl!lTIl:": die "'O~i:

IiIhh - mtpe:n'!ga ,;s, Ilot the 'i{)'~Qe. (If ~OJ] bur, Hcbel" tbf' vofJOe of rea- 5QD,111m.mw • l'a50D. 'b~k. n..e Sl!Iperegu ts not me n)~ .ls.w. deipltt:! F"e:ut! . d~;u:fOlL"I!S; to till! .1!1mlnry. n but 0\ WI.)' llf dlU:IJng jt

TiM! dll'\ildm,g·lin.e li ~'tliin, Vir'f: ~.11 see ,it in~~: m.m:b!i'l ~li~~!2: .lm.m. ""aWll wi eal~ Rs.~ ~tf,j~k~JUlgwj rOll: die ilIlfJroU .iii'l''- '(lilli me ([(I;Ie

99

'ii' =

. =~di:o ~t'I, wli>J;t 1lI~ c:iIISi!. (d[~ miiilrrdt) !ilfU QI'I, 1lI'm"OtlJj~r. ¢'o~mtLo:;,

,~ III me.fare?fi· a~ett1S.·I!!iI~drh"t @Dl1ieb~~ 1tili.t,<1~3. PP.l. ~ I)' Clf ~

'I:! IW!: roor,aI ~. me m:n!titilJ;nn r$' ~13. ~mp:tkm bv ili~ S!1bl~~; ~Ill

1nlll.h~ p~ !1m: on~~blg itIllI pr~"tlI1 ~~. the. nil'f'El!ll1'",lJidlOl i:tu.1 feelmg ill !l\f; "KAlitia:n edl:Ii~, Mohtl bw tim b-e.'aoII1'. oeliiei" '.i:lt.t:: oilly ~ • '!::ami::: li'Ile·;]R'dJil~ liW·re~nrCl:t l:t, ~Lil few 1jI'?!&\E:!; ~f.er.:KaJJJ.tsa~:

If! ~Ic£' bl:mnd!J~ ,~~ mr 1iL1!e: pUle m!:lf>lll, I~ ... W~!Mr: voID:m~ . .s'Hlf.die hcldBf crumer tren'J.bk; Jl:!di r~ ll..tm [0 hid{l hiIl!lsdf fr'~fJ'l i~ au" III~~ I som..:iJWlB W liil,guJ~ ih I w: eg.nUQ1. MInd r ;It m.ding tblif I:niltlml:::l! uf:! meIciI'I'tJ;Ul:~oolirul. '!tlm OIl f~.eliDg to hi: .ll"lexphl.cUI.e {O !ip(!.;:UIi1-Q:l\~r·ea:!(!IL". {1tlli:m; ]"$, pc S:d

He detcribes; thlt clFllCl of~. !law-un the :sabj(l!Ct·..s- ~d.<dlr mar '!JfhttmilWi!l!ll (!hWL. po 81 ,The Plnely I omm .mor.LI1;&v Stldditllll~, 'IXl«im~ ~I;,d!:l~~ """Vim: ". !/Oleo w~ijlcbi l,~ ~ t!'_N~, IlJ ,~!IU fmm '1ii'bicli"" . CiWIl t hid • dl mlUillillilitioo 'Cd-lt1!~Jr1rrl~lu) I \vhkb;i,s Dot just ltefpeai but ; .. bove ;all. E>1'_J', Ol.w.e-, dread;·iI1I me dmni'lIl1:; tb<lit ca.!'I. be CGRltUl.ed. by.a.!imgl.e8I:l'Ole;.lmoo'hd:l~d.l.ng of.S.~F~!!o. TlunI"Okt:l(.ll !!DlllIId.IlIOO d;J,\CI.!liIl!mih i:I fJ~~1.1II locus oJ lht! ll!lOt.:U law V.1:thlH ,gr ... ilIg 11 <liB)' posliilve :!;i..Ilb~!lm~ m DJn.ttiI:IL while, m~ 1.'Oit-e (],r'l:h~ super-ego obfv5qlt~ ~. Ipms" 161!t5. it !I .. i.th. itll ~1 ;}l. cl'llU$ s-eemin:g~' Pfl:!lemm:!!l ~ OWP.IlJEilC ,S,gmc .~ 'I tllit: Otb.tt orili~ Olb.!!r," ~'Ii~ O[h~ 'WlWOIIt ~ liek. mt;,b~dlm$ Otll~llIEM: mel' 'I,y iliG: OIhp Dn;W, ~,li rut !he !ia.mfil mn~ dw. Other of i!:5 'lfansgre--&I'o.a, Fb:r tb~ .~~ of the vui~ 11m:: f'1lln.ctlollS precise1y,a,s I:rnlS.gr~(l]\ nfLtle: bw,;. sad the ~dm[lnW:liIDrn lhlll thili; \'010: ls!;11~ C,.uUII;J.l. bm tW:fI.,l'..d lI.uu wP'!1n_ opl~ gt>dn;g utvl~1~:"l'" 'but, rn~~l.9'~ -di~"'!:i'ge (tom 1!):iiR~.~iy;

"Tlm.ob~,I:', rnQil.-mlivtiSiilluh'le"~ pmaftb~ ~ ~a''~9;e!lt!' I;K1!fiIlLO the ",,[Ii~ we can lhit:il!; ~filia>5li!m:.~ ralesaad ~dIMm ;",,:b.kbbDld OI!l:'iru.n IlOmHlllinlti~ il)l~thcr-fuIli.l$ Dr I.rutl;ltllOI:] '(m-d~dml ibe hn!:h !nn:uifutitm af:l1cwwmm-). ofbcl:o:ngDliIgl:!1I ~ jn.~l'a1lJl', the 'dJ"IldiiJ g Un.!;.hlCM'elfI! :b::mi:!= mm.oniSld;t:r'$, and so' on. Tbrneruies renld nlrl'm b~pi.itclO'l":lUIl wIEUng. weyi:t1!'~'ttO oo~'I\'I"I.I-Spete.d, hilUM ~f, ,Jin,d ["on.flI'l!t;c1 U'.I i;.ItiC' Vfl~~ Thill VQl"1:~ U climl~ll 11' w~~f dis-tiDllli!s.llesifn'l ~up',ml"&ofrcm th~ b\v: lbeJa\vhas -o,be:muiu-

,iml~' ""tlk.lcU\i'r.IlPH!~tmn~ t1J~ is plilbl±dr· ifIi'DiilS.i&tlll, tIl-prlimtipl~ a:v~t.:lir~ mes. wlIl]c n oo~vennQlIJ!,mdiD suppiltmWU m the tia~' ~.m.;up wt~J::!lt~~jj 'ill ,~1~.Ihc'.~~"'I'=gttI~ule~, \I\'hh.!b JrIi I afwo lW ~~ f~m Qihmllllr.!;1.m -1 ~h~ ~"I.m~whl!;.h j,Illtllit" ad] clfOOIDiclt- ho:'Id OOJI"!muniine;; to,g-ethtrr -md. CQllStil'1!!{le their

jn~liEigbl'.E:.

~(! • 1:1 'I'.ba~ Im,lun[olu fI!I~ 0" 1nhe.-llJlt ~, :dUWJ, ofk .. w

1IifI,d W'IIilllJ::ll P:JWil:l~~ ~, '" 11\!'I,&~~r CQml!JlOrI'itl!ip,ltr:l.ll:r~~ .:md 'mhen: is, -of (Olll(l's:e. I1o!himtij' ~ '~'fe: ~bqllr It. Bakhillit d:e'.iUj~ the l<llli om:d]li"iil<n..o.f.orn vm. [Q.OCIme·~l54iI1,w1 ,~:oDd wclll,n:lOMllf o~ b'l:U! rJ1-On 11mb.r-Cbal iOcl~.I:l~. ll~i!l:d till. ill Pl'~m':h~ ~rlld~greal em. or ,ilIlL

d!l !;lOdes, hut l:Qidin~d lO ~~fi· dml5 iII1i,d lJ'.i1'Ce5'-w lP!'tltn ... ~ tn.:n!)g~~I~ 'Pw.~tiQllI.m dEls (';;lJrn~\"il}~1l.e 1!lmlll.er,,1.l!p&loM; Sl mE M .normlLl" rllndtili!lhl~. Ili'. Ibe ~ill,"!;; iIS ,ihDlDlCma!t II p.c'rll~I!I;l:Ill" whln~lmtlmU lIS n~ , 'ft.i m..~l::Ul. a,~'iU~, W;I mooe ,.v\ld!Cb b nGl lilUiblIcly 'IiItt'el:lble; tt.s.fum: lit!. in ,··[eri~::I. pol'li.cn,l!lif mjoytLu:Dt" of l:l'OlLrui~n ,e!))jO')'ll!ll~1:. '''''li£ m. ootli~.I$.S!tl(ll!l.~c·1t_.WBe. "Q!" ili brutk'W:p t+l~ hw G:i:I"I'mi~. htl~.dWl;JIputill, H.nl:illg~ vrdI ~V IIl.rc1lrgt1icn !he I Vi' alld tf"rd v II wilD '-:itlIp'IUiS'"1.'Uth!1rH}~"i1~;f!llOlbu rultsr:il1i:he mlO!De.th:r~ _ 'lTIW.8gf'i'$§i'!:m.s"o:ht.s .uhwhloj.J~!I\!en:t.mgt)' tmdt.r1'l!ilil<!: u; '''''l!: aI-e <".Iug~l alJ !he 1iIlOl'e.in Its \;icious did " Thll "i!hh1q1]""UIL~ .. ~r:IlI.ll'I::'l:lImuk~i,o!!lJ.l1In me (lWei ~Il, !mpll~" (ljme~QB arm:. Oth:~ whl . .::11 (lIlif~r!l, m;i g1lM,tI:l,~ ami· cifO[nm:rihes f~bck.

So, jf"tb.t: vetee of .reaoon~ g!rlns. ~ posJlliYl:! .e:mEellU-1! h gM:V'S l~. Mit "''\'i:!,M =tbCll ,il WflUJ!:!.tg lhe sup~n:g Ii p::r~'tn!OQ. f'~ Unit, J.;a:c;m, in Smlilil.I', fo.rm\.lb.~ed mi.Olhe:r'ofllliU:~~Mrk"i\llhJe ~log~; "Tile ru~ga ts <II the sm:J I:! Omit: !he~' ,mdi its <te:>tnI.I!;l1ilail n (l..Acm t97r. p,. I'i~)- hi l:Iw,uxWe[~dJ!! or ~tl!li Ilii>Y ,.,. I! .r;.u:! I!l~ :m eehl,ll gf llw· pn&1il.d (i1i1111it. UlLI:;sb.lcWw wnldiw!l] O1J,WO\~ IIi;JUCW O!!1Jd hil.ll!lt i.h~ liW, U ilII freml"~ ~~;mo Lb.!! law''''''dS i:ns"t;itul1:d bv [b:e m,urdff ofthc,prinu] filJ:h.er, if it \RS, thtl' l!i!:1.v of rhe am fam-er"tru.t Is, ofhN nsme, tb.rtm dit: trou~~e utalltbe- E1L:hcr W~ nl!\iC'!' il'liUe dl:!~d-II! !Sti'n,-iVl!d as tb ~u~~ (1l!JI$ ~ tlll: f!md!lQ!1 E'I f IIbQfu) .11 The vg;~ee i'L'Ppe~J;'.'! i$ lh~ p:~d of m<: &dleJ wl::iidJ is nllt qutile dead; .it evo.bs til;;: ,figure. of

Hi'll

'en10}'lDC1l!i., ~ ml,!-O; ~~tb~t,~ ,ill lidt ~o -t~tnLrno.u. of !lJ1i:' 1i!'W bo.JR~ WI I!u lJi,illDC. 'l5bfi . I~ 1lW ra.~ ~ 1t'hmll I..bfr Vl9l~. I .md (b~ diVl.dW,g Jm. b J;emJ®5:b,ll. crntidt i dI ~p~o i! lh~ ilI!ipplel'lIt!I~ "of ~'e·liIIw" iU'i, SoBilIrll:!W, lts' ClhseLite ~dl abS(llm.e dQUlbI.e ~II Ibm, w '111lo1,l]11 i!tI~ ~f lb.!io;',ill,lI!mlidVcl:, ar di:S]Wlcliiqn, ~o'OlEEl!i,~ .l""'1:1 is; IiIOl 1!Xh.".1j.U'iiIl'~: :ch~ \;"I!l1~~ or tJ]JI,J ,1Q~l ~~Wj~t~1i:: ~nn11'~Ct: '~Uioth. dOt:::> tI~ 'ComC!d:1il 'W1.~ clbbu,

TiJoo.ndudl.i ow: br-i,ef rurve-r of me e:tWe.~.of the 'voi~ 'we em see tlw tllu~ 'VOtCflP~ a ,bfUddIY p ~'!(i'l J ml"" \'\.·!i,leh pllLl;'l:dr m 0lQ .1U11blg u~ positimL. 'TIic "ollie: wbl~b '5l1 law t'b ~ b\'it h~ bem gI]] '" dl ville 1'1)' lil!!; \1ifliioklIildition &0]]1 SOcr<!i~es to ~~I.i, :;rn;d even bo· Ka.n.t., OlIJId Ilih'divm.e lraIliScendem: lin was ott th~:same dm.e']pb.red :Jil th lt1l~ UlittJ!ll~t! ruflt:l of l1tt~!I1.Jb!jtlf:!l. Wil.h. Hi!ld~ a:hl. "". k!r !w bi1eJi11brm.ijht [0 1d wflimii!I1U om. u"mio.K '~o il; radJ~ .ull:rlty, "II opeDing ~ci ~g. ~t.a!I.Il1il:~ se1".,O!ppr~~bl,QIli ~J:l-d, :;cl[-re1!,ection, ~ilIG'tI~lig; uli1iltde: the !f:d!;tf:u~ U'ld $1''III~ud in me moWn or Idle U!Il(;UIIIIY. W1.liil ill dI~ o:adiJ~I,m b . tn I,nmmolil. ~ Ib.u :th vo:I!;; CUllleo. £ronl '!he.otlm, but tlM..~ is .nt· Olb!!. wiilhm. Tilil: ·ethlr.il t.'t!ICi! is 11m me subje.cts own,lt is moL: r[ll.' the·:Jiu.bJ~cr ItJ l!~!:>er Of OOIii!]\a1 it. ;d. !:h u~ th .illbl~i~!, ,;u;tDtlQmy (!, lUnllY dcpc;rIl~~U:1Il j:LB~! !t ~rl'll$ nol pi':fGl-ll1 $i:mp1y tQliliIe OIne.r ,u:!:thu,. otlm1;1ugb. it Ite:tm; f'r-om, LI.: II would hckm.g [O,thf 'O!b.er.lf t~ 'I?i~~ liEdu~ble. <0 pos.i'U:l;'io"t ~(('I'1:ma.Jlds. 1,( it ~VU-e! DOll meitcl.y ~ open.hang .rndl m. imll,J!ru:I.ai~~Clll. (In liim_pl!.fiOO. U.ntliillllo tw'()JU, 'We co llhl [~01JIjnlMllrI.'CJJ,~t ~[i;.m1i p~ 00· tim atlH!r, bul, ttB 'l'()i.ce d~ lij}~~)'l"h.: ;,'Oie oomes fI'~~):I ~b· Ot!1ter \1I!iifllil>UI reing pin M:ll;talbc~. i . indicates allril;V! l;es ~ roid in me owe, tiE'Cl.lml!.C!!' bbl.g t, hilt nO!. :giu.!: .It ol: pmitl'I'C C;-~ffi-r.e. .IDt baslWp~~p~rIj,·~, y .,' *t ~at be ,Cireilln m'ttl.

SiJ Jglln we. find! ilie :Jtintr.ll'llom..ontoloxy-----or, rnth~:r!, ~[I!li'obg}rafme Si..1HlSofili<!. volo:,i1S ~b~m me l\Wi.," 'JlIIi!~ prernelf<M the e~lflc;U!O JlIt~~~lill!l. 'Ibf! mlo!! call Ix: 1(JC'J'.cd.:oIl tbtt 1W+~!l!re ~f' Lhl!:

S'Ub~e<;tr ~dI 11,t Olh~ ~ bll>t ol!I ~I 'I,\'iJ5 bi:;r'llTe, 1,1] OJ; 1il1ft'C'fim~reg~&t4l:f, pll!lreQOIt thl: in~ooon ofbQd1/' i'ml bngu~\f. m~~O!'ilbltlg i ~!Ii!ti: ln both. Tile schema, 1:U6d !lbo~1~ ran D.GW be pm re :t'n:1iV ;USl!:

iL~!): ~i~ .Is: '!lL\-e; eI~ \\1h1icll,ue!ll:he '.!iubj~[.an.di !he Other to. 2P1h~r, nlilOlll bd ng _Ill! ~fI ~Uhl!J., Jlt;$[ M t fj "ned! mt: 'Iii: l!!' n~ ·aI body'oml! lilll\l~g,e_ wldH;ltll bebi,g p£t oHbenl.Vilf! call Silly lh~ 'illt s~ji%[mcd me Otheif wJ.ndde in '111m '<l!m'lID!:HJj 1'a.4 ~mh-odiw by nhl.': iKQlm. and cltill "_plllrt m~Ll:nw[l" em be u.Iren. 'a,s me ~cl. tbJie:.!lrl wJd~ t.'flIWl~U; WI:! ~~eul~'.imd ,~thfQJ .tq:lctU crtb "'('n~~.

T]Jf. polidchl dI.m.~6Drifth"f. vtI.~f., kS deep 1nml!llem~.'lnDLt:he oo'm!· ~tli Itl q c.1hh~pilIlJif~. caB per' pi be ~, II:. !\PPr~~ iIlI: ~·o:r -

'I .

glinl .auhlil Vl3"f 1lt:.11JJI lllg' f po~ 'id bU phf' mii ,Ill .Mit Illi\i,~

AdsI!otDc·. Nillie;,ThI\f'A: 'W~ 'Cilil JCeid· tms!,·

N'1iIW.11111t. ~l'1Ill maTe Qr i poll,~(lI1 iWi!:JIlill ~l'liUI b!l,~Q~ iIIl}' "w,ergre'!frt~U5 ilnIo:)~~3!~,eJ!Ti&nli ~~'B·'ilIfi!",(:I1I;e1l say. m~ l]~lbi[Ji; in \l~'ll1j ol!q~ m;;U\ ~111~.-.1y IIItm:d wl!'i;laI~I~li.,~~tli:!!rIWfdw]uj 1h!!~,1JJ: of~~U'. And wh ~~ m~N: Tdti~ [~me] b, ~Lt' m imi~~riClI1 ~f pl:e.mrri'!mpalln,. ;!]hd1.o:. tb~ttJci[1! [(mndlmL "<l~;mllmJ;s (fur iilEir IUlll'Jttll4lfiJI ~o lite ~~I!DIl orple~U1d:pllL:! MId dii: Uil1mt~tm Qf~bem ro,{Ji(l!~:ani)l'ju:r.;a:(ld M filnlw). till ~ 9'J.spe'lillh ~jm~ ~li!clIcd, 10m Wrih (b~~~i3Ilt md J:Ii~~l!Ii!t., and ~Ort Ill:eWiiM: lb JU t iI!IId \bt, "lint, llmd It I fi, Ititf~dtflr<tI!o!;;I m1!iil WI be .1!Ic!J,t ~;u!Y'sen,W td'g,ood!.;md ie'llil. Qf)1m and'tmJm:t.,~ Ihe 1!lJ; .md In ;u~ iIfi ofh'VUtll bcll:tg ~ lm~ lllb, ~~ ~ 'iJnJr II:y aM ildilm. ,(ATri!!;l\!;Ii:I~ ro~r., nt3'i. 7'-':8')

W. lltlglu ll~ Ifi).(b~ ~~:~l'Jld~ ~o tear.I! ~~ Ih~ ~ltJ;stl(U~()1l of thl: ptllIitI~aJ 1C!~nilJ; QtJ1,~ ~tijjjidhViQil oftht VQI~ili, a divi!lau wutQ~n the Tj:Q(i'I:ie,. It;S. ~iJllL i:or i£l·a:ro:ex [0 1LITId:ers~d, die pilli'ti~ ...... 'e ~\"e [0 ,cb!lr;:er.n the rn~ mtce 0'11 'Ih~ QIli.~ .!wId md speecll.lhe 'intel~ tl.gtblt 'i.'WC ,Oil !hI! Lh1!i', ThI!I)(! I.J 1I hug· dMdl! L111N'l!i1!.D JIlIiII!le ,lIlId J p;.!!!fit! ~'UJll1mi -;j;ppeiIT' lofidl!Ji\o<;,rfJcm Ih~ d~iJ:e.·IhEl.lia ~hu: ,Io~ itsclfis .stil1,~ppOO. i!:I\foi.ce; ~I j~ 15 ~mul!i!tlJ.;.t the ml:"mmgM, voiC'.c. wMcll rcl~~ lbt:- illJCre '\I"ol~ I:D p~~ry. Theft: 15 • cnu:iill d:j,~'Lcl • b~,;tw~ du~ 'wo:rdll.m:l1 l'b(1 l'Oli~u. a ,Q~ """'O!.'W of ow itniltlii iil\i'l!lebet~ (ill!'·:;ip!l.ii' md me wlal,wru~h Jill .i:mmedia'rr.: Uid: dramm~, pol!i:tiCi.lil. CiiJmieq;~.1

n" rCillflw Atillintle, mm wiD: ls , ... hILl arlihl;ll;l: .uu:l.I'iiI,Ui ~ itI (IOIl!IrI1QIl, it i.~ iliuDlm~lpir' Qf I IUL. n 1:'011. 1~~ll .. m: gnjr :plW.ll'R ~'nd Pm.. expEri:em:es .Sh~ by borh iWim.us· <llld hllmi.lill5. Ilut .~pt'Cch. ~O!f. d()e$ll!lt r.IL'U~icly' indl,c IJ<~ it UpTImes 01: better snll, :it mamf~lJs: it II aniru!..IlIllJii! alllvaHqgM:W (lHlt!lllil) nd HIll! bl!:l'i'ltf'u); m!:l m1r1"~l!tmdy 'h~lus't md rile IDJjwt.lh~' 8,ood and tb~ evil. If m1e l'et:e:i.e5i 11 hlID~!{. IDII~)lIlliIy \\<clI seream, W:liI[ 19:, emIr a .... (l;,~~:f: to venr ~e. '5 pain, iHlid wat .15 Wlhtt l!I,llQf;!!l!: IIl1i ~ d",.g !MJu1d ~~w do. iBll,t ~! th~ ~;!11~I1IDC

an'~~'~1:"'Ib?ve iDef:l!fWil'louge4" (ll!lml!;:d.:m;1nl<l!~1li ,illl~ ui.lUtb}, till: tJiIICecb ln~ tht m.~~rl:ght'i!lllll !1.~g: JI: ~l~nD( lust ~V(: Yf!lltt ~o f~gll. if:il! aodul!i!n stlild .. lId ,G:l,r IIiI~R:mmt-

,Jl;il!biebottmriafdlibisli:e'flPc r'mlht~mtv.' fell::IIU f1jf,- • . !!l. ~d b .ii.l. :il~ is ~ li&=:. b.tm liI~, liCe reiilu~1:t {i:l' ~m'r. him iG 11[ee ill.lIU! ~u:Wl,:r. lli db~ p1I!~. poU1;j,cal Jlft.

-~ ~ be~ ~~ IDtl::,~od'pt!l~(;j~~sJfu:~ ·a-s;thr:: Ii'!: tb:il!t ti:ke m.vh~~~l delillld~ ,ar .Dn!L~ ~ ".~ I~Vin~ bcm!k,U!dM~r! wju~ lH1iU:a11c . iU~~k!~ f~ t~ lib!: Mtit;l!ll~mm belWen~~_ill\d ~rlfJ!!s. • , '1'IR l;J,Il,'l;StilQll J:[ri1rWtloe:s me 1l~1Dg bf:!!ln;glla,~ l~g~" en.cly [Or" fUPOJlrb fIJI du; Iqlles'tioo '''[01 w ~ I,fjlle bi!Jt' ,11!t1e bLWbn Ilt1" Th,' Jiwing Ixmg PQ~. by'.s'l'tppre~g;antl NWnlna in iii 11:& 0Yi1l ,,g~, IUlll B ~l lDliilhl!::i ~(I'JIr b¥h~u;mg i:~ own 1m1: llfle b~ !:liI<1CCp!erJ b,ylt, (.i\~H9i7'pp. lS-i6)

Thlsdel.Uil!' :p~:!W by Agnlm.bm poin,p; ~il:dr ~1;) tb.e,(l'Ilt':Ia:! jooClJJ!l'fo:

W~ .1U1~l,g)'. wlllcl~, b :mQM doo nu,,~~,:t!o,gV' OO~ th~"!i;IllIl:J;L]:nW.l1 pbl1i1e-. nd llI~OOJ.VrJicEi b,Uke "illite 1if~, romethiTlg that 11i w[J· [pGliStldtr ~Mm W polir¢al.'!,'.,hile ~~.:iHheoo!Jntc:rpmor ~~i lOr !lOdalllre ruJ,~d by h;y,!!!i !\lid Ib~ e !fill'lCUI &IDOO.. ~ut. It.I~ '~yl 01" pcb:iI=lb~ I~ 'lit of A.gwben,ib o'k~ k6. i:if I;.DWk,. tilllt £hl:l'e J' II,f) suc;b simple wuiWi.ty: me ~c mttClur • !he t~llology of rh • poIiElC!!l., is forAg-.nnben lha!:ofan. "inclusive ~dus;iffil" of~nre.1bis \'~I"y I!!J:dll!Ullll p~CCIi, we 1.11 " ffiltn.l .Md. p!l!r;ld!~~.lI plll~ thi! '~J,:. !;lEplimL {;Ills ~llr]O ~I~tdcmty. r Lei: lIS CIII D!f: r~dWi i1I mlIplr~11 tbe e:ltltteD1€: fam, of rnI .. tiOD wmdi jll-dudt'l> 5mIlietlilitl!: 'by Us, exduliolls: Jbld., .p.. 16,)) i'hl.!!; I:il,e:n.yel agam,ptIl'S m.E 'IlQ1(.e'ln, il most l'M:cubH iII:qd pmdoxtCl!l] !IkIs-IL~ f.i: dlli! tOl¢lo~,. gf ct;tlmDCc:~ Lh~ !lilmul. GrJle~ iJJdu&onl e.ldl.l:lilr;rn. \71rlllCb. :reru.ru Itbf: ~dwio:d. ·~t i.ts ro:re:, for what pE,fgenilJ.;!! pr. hll!!lJl. is, IilO! thtl:li~ u'~~plypre-socJlIl" the OlJ.1Jtmlitl)', !he 1!.n\I!sltir: f I:he .mc_ii. h~~ tl.'iill It Per~Ii5.'3, In. itS 'I'l,ll}' 'b: r- 111 fr.JIl1/l .. ~llltbm, it th h oD~ of (h,e ~ I-JIWil iI.'l t1~ 1,11&,1 ee ,Is, nOil simply an element exterlli1l co ~ eh, but l?~St5·.1I: il;!l core, liI1~g u po5:5ib.L~ aad romCJlt!y h3J\!!.Dting jt by the t!DpoB!lS1ibili!l)' of symlbc!lbziJJ~ u, ..mil i!'\1i!f.1 [lJnJ~: th~ valOl! is nor Yll.1w t~'I:e:IJlt at' ~prI!;VlDU, pn:eWfiit~i,ilt<lI:e • .oT or~o.l11I~ JnpP'fpdI1l1Ordf-d f~J;loJl 1;,¥llell ~ we~~

I1I:!IJ'Il~pI~dbr.J:iJ!i~e .mdils n!.millM: ~1:Iil~ itiii die pIod~ -nGtof~ {tseI(~~aruI mmblmg.lt .uome.same.lli!ne:.

ll't!IR. tel 1£, ucl~dl!c]. mil ~oeby!nd nrf1ed.,l11 the, very' OO:milLHulflll1 CII r'~~ 'poiitll:.~,r~ld:lts, Ul!!lIi~dy.h1g' .\II.¢IJ (laJ:s 1o~flil.r il.1!, ~QJ.I~,n.tlJenJ. t.m~, HtlP~tl, gbm'~ ~~~~lIe:r:I~, I\~' an s~ttlitu the: '!Qiec, ip ~lS'fw"K!tLoQ ~lt~ ID~ ,EJ«fiioToOfJJ/ip_;_ [be'2ppa:renli'P~lb.Jlil;l W ,extt<l-4q.g~ 11> ~d YpJJIli u:d rime~ mcmtrli'l ~U~ d 'Ilin tI ilti CAlC! idr!O~ '11'1 ,tl~IU.A mOm dl!mlIrii pbllillOml!!'lOt, gr :md 1lI~'Il)..ur.: oBh~ U; ~a )fur,. bUl.bere oiJlI~ just;tfe'wexl\l:mpl~ gk~iI. mom. ~w, .;ug~(!nl ·t~. Th~y ~ omctm ~E Althmw 'c:ill-,:tI W@DjJ()gfrru. .'hjl~f:A,pp~iIl!ll!les~Cblll'4:!h. roml.~1illI!I"buDfY< clroit01l8-

nil di~y 111 di'Cll!:miCt be O!. paJ't5Cl!lW bi:g,hl)' cOOlfie:d Uld rinl~imd m'~. !."fltbf"l'il tJiecl'tl; L'bf.:~nle~"it(1 pmll~ ""heM their rlrn~, 6i1a.ra'i3lelt .ks. ~~ed ;md ftlIrum:JJi!d.,a:mBi ~ij- ~ymlJ~lh;; ;It':I'pa,(t-15 ~t~,!:d.

"[IJ.I.! '!inlCi! 1.1 !.~~~y llnk.ejd ~,'o':ldiJ. tille diI:lWlll~!'[n Clf dim. YIIDll~I

nod rltulll' tn lntrlc.it If ~tr'l~cmnld :lKidill ~lliU;'ItlW15 wbii:'~ lUin,g thi!4')ltt m~bs 1ft possihle ro perfoltm ,<Ii, 'c:e.rllilil aCL OI:Ie I~nm perlOll'm it ndi:gi!JU& :ritu.n withOUi( fero;r~lng ro 1b.~ VOlitC a,n·thil:t Sii:n~e:: oae has. fol' ~!lmpJ!~. IJO !la~~ ~"!ml UtI ~Ed fo.rmlilln ItIbliillur. rim ,~. In. , rei"r 11.1 :Ii! slim rnem Bd liIfIn.e WE'm 'elltii.t • .1ihl10ll1ah llIq iIR ~U 'N'i':r.iI~~1.'I.nt1Ml.ill. ~2:tn:dJel![S ~e~'El:Y'body (supposedly) ~ ~em ~~ .heert, ThOR 'I'I'~. Ql"db1!y.Slil-~d lkql [l.1ipt!:f!ll'!.d m :!!lffi"llil'!f'f, c;m. ,~Ii;~I!i!:~ p.uOOWili~'i1b ~t1'~g~h tlllW [f IlIn~y ~~ n:J~gIUOO 1,0 d~~ \l'(jic~. md i:t ill, iU if me 'IlK of I;b' .. -mte '",iJ] ulItini:i.oo!y 'l!.ti.cll;lW [lime "''aM!;; \J.~.Iih. !:he ~cter of ~edne'ss ;m::d ensure t.hci!r. ritu;ll,dficaq. in .5!P11I:t: Qf-eJl', . ~l'lu. ~~ Qi'-t1.l~ fi,; ~ .. huhe ~ ofilii! rnke dDlliUl ~dlrl mythin"g '10 Ith~i'fCmlltmt, n l~Pe.~ thilt thl , 1m: . ft'be troit'echoes tbe £UPPIJ:>edl~· m:I:i<l.it '<"oiiot', the voice nm: l>!ound by lOJl""!'~ilIJ.d 1"e!CMh: tlle useof sb.om iII J~b. 1'1,'!l:ig,iom. ri.lll;ols tliat, as we Iha ... e !@e.n.l..'t~l!rnp~ed u :t ~ .. dr Wi!! Gbiiii I mj~ The lhl~!! ,n;n "ndigbQIL'I of the lkiol;" ;lil T~ly on :H'o~' Smp(1.ll"e wbm th~ trlilth 1)0 ma.mrl':sil'cil. '~I 'Lbli: ~1~u.'!'e:, die' b(rlyJser, C3J]J, ~,Qme ~ltt('j]l,'e: amy

il-ma wh.i!iiit B.Dil'itWlila b)i ,''1l1''·inB ~'Oi~,:h gill. (II.U! liuG.a:s . {} Ii!.! ti.e, rhl! link bet\mm'me: ~il:y onltli~; ~lf~il"""hen ~ \lU.i~ pr~llwl~ wh.u ,lila! been VI)rj,~ eY§il »n.oe ml'! fu'lm&ooJUl IDQlJileJlt.:J( WI:gln ilJld swmtli 1.i¥1l'~..dititlill. :tnt! whiM .all bid! ~ kt':l;;jl in mm IIJIlmlo:rt~ imywa.<y;

S~'t' eIattIPJ:es fo!lQv,\"the:~e ~t:ta:'n;'wl!l;l'tptQ~~gs.h.i!\'~ ~·.~a!cll'ilJlw dKiu.L m,El p~m 'rJlri1!~p~Q~ IIDll'd.jht! dl!~tlom. tmt ~;;e !Qbi:1IiWIcl~ by '';b'tIl!~,A guJdt.-'I' JIUrorsi!.. Pl:mch c!JW;i:& iU- "

'lilt or!!Ibr ol"!hl; d.clr.ltcs ~ the (i.md~till n;tlE! Dr.ful!' ,Co''W't [(01lii0i d·~l·Thi5l 1:'111', decNeI 1I'h~1' III ~1I1ii'~.J:1. rom;! ju, ~QllYt«!.on ()J1ij' Oil Ike h~ts (lftbe t=1!!!U1:om imJ1y' ~iI. MIm'iId.i~ruJ::itx~rod in lh~ moo:. 'nIb ~!! w.by Ith~ ll\!INU'l .md !h.c; jUfllU ClIlllW! cQ~l;I!lt Iho:: .til~ [do»iliQ] I:bn' ·ng liWms, •• , Thk~:·.miIl,.'vbr P11l~ t'lIrun.Qnr~ Ih\' di:p CI~ltlDe. o:ih ~.Y~.,..,]h.o I!. ~mnRt1ll t.~~hlV b~e':s.he arh!: Jm; l'i!!;ilfifl(L ili¢ 'til!:' LJ ,d\'I't}'1 j Q}l]duy, {quo!ltid tn [lQ:~t ~ I ,p. 7$)

'1.h.c taC! dLi"IJI. i:1:I.J_:; i;&;iI. Frencb P[',BSO:ipt!(lIl.ha.iI> som:e &!.gnific;.ma::. 'IDee ~[m!I.' rub: gl!m~rutv !lpp1JJ.e!i,~t!l'fWh~i1 (fwu:a.mple U!.!:be Gernl.ab d!lilcooi1': "1bepu~~ debiL.I:e i1'~ .l,e;p, d,l;pillt',Q 'it! intnt gf WI; oiiIIpiph. cablcoolllt.o:nILy [mGIliDi~]";qUtJif:dbyVis:ml;a'W:Il00'l" p. 1;12)" bUI i~~ bl1'tbphl:;!l.1.!: 'I:A - Fnnl!:'b R~ltlIlI;l\lII,'J]f: p!"lll~fl o.r.oi';ilit.~ Wt! use ru b.e"lLvbal "91Q;,:'" ,md_ j:b~pl"1nt:LpJ!e tJf lb.!!1 puhlie ILl! IJfe gf CClIJcft pmc.e.edrngfi \\"I!"rl3 die'iW() uWn lalebi ,Ilfmcd by th-= ,1EriIli,g1l!~l2mn~1I ~gatmJ. l!roIl"low: lII00'es of oorttgKion (if ~aJJI 'ptMtire Uidl,e II1ItJQ ri.lfIIII~' • .mil. tIm!~. 'bQtbJ11lplell!!,~~ilid. 'byd .. ~ {l '~~obIlI01J. ~ilcb ~:'i the :r.:...nv gf I Ii-l'} $~PlcrlllhIIT ~79 ~ : '''']'111:: ~Ilte):',mBl~(1J:)Di af\vh.n~s,1P~t;a]wa.y.'> be ~td our b'rthe livi.:ng;\roice [W.VIVUitJ·] witb. (lui wrltmg do;wn. th~ !e!iUm.IJIDf$" (quOIed hyV~anEI :!OOl" p. 1<4\ ~ ). Tim, r~ltlr 'nn'l( Wi'ls. r().r~y i:.odllieLi by i:lu:. N~ IctODiC Cfjd"" (n806', The d'l:igil'i.daUm c!!he ~nM i'cwtd' lIS 5~nld~'I' (Ir) dlt' p~I!I!T. ofirs .p.ruhihiIlO'!'l) 1Wa!l. ~n with!;: d:emOC[QitizatilClll'of eourtpro ~cdln~tS;~ r.lu: ~y ~c W';L~,~gDed to mt! J uq.mrl the jlIl'O!' towd. in ,PT!!lJt:j,Fli1;: 1;n: myont ~~.ub~ct 00 ~~D ~ELlIn!(j!!!l},llJl!!l uUdlHirull)' WOIlS mat me m[joti'ty of POleTIti2.] jumu YoUof: Ulltenle, lb ' IhinK Y9jee\V~ the irulrlmllel1lihyw.hlcJJ, the le,~ ~~em roukl boi: ~rn(t~ ·l1.um ~hi!' 1:.M1,rJs(lf~~(:~1lIills-, their I!I1l;omp~usl:bieUngg.md <! bosl:

:l'Il; dJmllmJlCi .r:e.g:ufiltll)" 1'h~ !lUll: ~Vi .hl!' In~tim ill dill Dt~DmloOlflln&Ii'ff .. '~-i ... \~ m,.poru~ b't"iljn:itli~~.emliili 1l'F "po- 1ide;I! i!itikm:r 'nnQ.'"¢lr tll;u' ~a,aqr Js .Cil:nlli1rrer.~r !ll!D~q., tIw 1-1. ~d1f' mt~~ tI~i!!.'14C'J:.1 d~~~q 'Ioltloidd ~ I:iIUIDl! wb;ere ~,rw~ buliy.mull1he,iI'r-i,1'I'1!"qb~1dl.".,cl!ic.'~ ~Cf;' (U\m~t! l!.~olU'5 mooe.1 ~I! of G l1~,at). l1im prcOhibition Or Ifrnm.,g: was ;!. xoIWalllti(lom:r oomtr. .sOOTI to lie fe'IJac€d b:y rli'~ req_i.WemenL wal tif;1:rf J~,g.ill.y ~i'lJl~l y,'I)~. uu~ P)' In 1.1\'111£ \I'll ~ .. ~~Wd.Ib!l: ,wlll~ dQv.i _:.~ 11 mg ~~ ce~w:t i~ 6~ 1)}' ~ wnw~1,~l";!!;!Ql wEt1tli ilhllIJt: ~iD ~I" t1(ffi ilI;$ iii h':j;d ·,(llll_ 'tel 'die "Ii'i'fitlm w.om Ins 110 pov.tt j'~ it is nul:' p:renclw hy;. and. bu@d in, !he. li:vi!Ilg: litlWe.. n, a.uth1Jntyc:r'\\1'll11ing dlefJeJ~diQJI Illi bE n~ dt~ :liHMuII' ,C'op)l' ofm~ vo:lCtl.. Thl!.s¢«trul: let, !hII rllr ~ ,~,g! i!J le,g.ddm:IJID~lt 10 . ~l" rDllg,W'ili~ fui~ I QI!I • 'he i!.(lt Q , w'i:

Vtdlie, iIJiIjlhh~ W~by ofth(! t'Wl:lJil lD.;eQILI,!;gi ltV! firooEL

T:h~~"7 ~Q ba.SIft, ljr,lflQl!I$ e.'!:oep~IlHO ~srm11e. but theHvmg ilres~t~Ofll:¥.1 '\'O'!c:e tuby cli@]h.~lllt lO\tcblt'b d~'I!!~ ~ HW11l1.Hluu'e lOr ~l pro(j!:mKii. The rnmllechnitd de.pcs11:irin!l'b)" xpert5 hiL.. ita be·le.i!.n ;Houri by ,iliem. mdpnly me '!o'OiC'e ~rormli thetnllum mleR: mU',ta!iivlZ ~'.1i[t'!:m~lm Itnt,~p~wlmd'~ Tau:smu: !l'tUt:l:ncot a~~ quil ~ the: '1l\lll' vf ii, FIiUrnllli' ve wh~1I read olIbua .II~ fmlll !;If '1M ~~It, wbillA'! itrem~ tbe H'de,ad! kttef''' mdlCct:ru!!t;Jrin! a Lo~!!l ~silt5 ll~ wrttUID. dmmlll the ID.!!S.11ns, is 'me pdil:iU wbim.eVI!D. ru1! Prendlll!lI,l.lhhll U:SA mtnlcl Dot I~t i)M,\ilJl" with i'i w:dUilttl.d~iltlnll.OOt 1~ tD ul:'~ tile Wil,mcust .. nd, SO here ::I.8iW11 w I~' 'tlu: ~mpl'i1~, oth wrl~I~ ~r ~,nt tb~ ~5 of wllirll die COllIt hss to d~c[i:le. re[ fO.1W1I'; lloW In b!::cume dfecriR; (0)' !lie litl\!' to be enme.d, o:nt ll~ '1.0 1iL.~!11'ea 'm1t\O - to me ''CJlce, lQ Q'l"aI:!l,; !If ili~ ~O'Uin. is 1.0, dedcli!!' IorHl!:il:l!!1' tl .I!. 'pl'eSl.illl (.BE! esn .~ ~bmmed Wlft:r m~ 1:1\\1;, ~t'IW the loetJlilS' [lfi:be 1~ ~app'lies EO n. f the coun: js'jQ doeu::mtinc !he truth of me preseJ!l[ CMe. ·ol!nd rltllalc i;I I:0tb~ I:.I!w, thJ!Q.n~d.Q«H:u:df hf:I1II!:''I'~!I:f:; m!ll!lll!:t- (Wli !1nDulA Ii, -t fn puru.g ~ 'lUlIiit bc'~l:'~ thl: ~glo: DlJild !;!il.l.ilIlrdlilig l!!tll [riluh:ilher:E is it pallU wkm tJ;'1.Ilihhtti 10 be m.cail and w.l1m· t.h~\WI('l'(m tn.lth •. atmo'U,gib l~t:uaIl.:r !he sa!ri1~, \.VlII.!DfM~ do.) !

If thl! U""lng' 'l'l)]e'e 15 !!:!l~!!!,d Ill!!! J",d!.'le lh!lthe ImpDmlent.lilCIil ot till1j.VJ;, tt.us~ pllllY:; i! bym],~m I~lfh'l'~ure, n P.u,~mj'~m." ..mer ;lll. "l~t;1.lIm

If.!' III;

= fram pW~ U b ~ pl ce~rvlZd tor 5p . dl.But hue till! -lll!I.U!vn I!.

~, re\~l:SocI in *Il!OIH(I ustio:. there tl\ lv:inJv.okiHW$ oWg:.uary r. r

Ii !l~Jllilplem:enad.!morl:l!ieleirtefoftheli1w. bit~h~~l;IiHI~gilll the

U ring VnlC'l:. Qlr.l1 di~tmSI!l.1iif;lwJItb:. t4pC:>i ~I' ,r. (lb:joo:k)J1, mk~ p'il.J;oe; ill Il\l"gcr ~e KWlt I:II! ilIe lt~tl'r !Jhl~ii:' l.iw; l\.¢; t:nv iun:H Ilm pp!;!" S!lFlW:illioLl. bun [be: ~~liIeJ(1~ or ~be. v.r;)~1 rt~ U ~t be p'~d. nle:.al!i~ 1:ii;prlmdp1e, 'WLtk{lut~~~mifmm~, 't~I.}!.Bt1d:! ~iI~~OWi" :I'll lti~lr .ltr\'~OOd .!.~'!'!UIl~~'. f~I1J!L'I!I.~lJ)r £l,Ip.p~~ l?lI,~h Cltbt!C und farm tv.v h;il~ of dI 's.mll:: !i!;:!:IOOIIII! l:iim~',

II lu. !his Mer ~q" we Inab1:iW.j]lii~ ki;P ilIliil. go from an: [utbdh:.d to tb.<: Wll~(f; 1!ib,1;!fl 'lI'I! em ~ tb.at\'''Hbin~JD-Jimo(!ric.m . ~dt!nlil tllt:rt;u an l!OSti u1tWn"U:l1iIilIU., (I;illi!id 'l,1'!! Yor~, ml' JWt ,,['lId.! l he d 'lln'<e ofiil drni;em.tlon. of;J. dQUQ~all:h.=, wbli)l hlL~, Ittl bl: nll1d~ "in '1lbJ~ IhiIl.g· VllIct..·! 10 mIMI: umvemots ,iII ~iUlGm; alld ~~IS Me II.QWllrli\y~ d!t)n~ ,Ih~ ~1i'f,ltilig,. I~:(]! Il!! '~~ry OJ!Ie rolllla' ~~l!lallrlW!v:f.lI'I: t'h~!i.\·hDh: ~f'!I1~dm.h;: !life ,md I!le.i,.i\ d;eg~ wu;I!!~Ut t;!.'Ii'w. '~P!!Iilil:g Qil(l''\;;'IlIDlIdl, IJIltii1 !ho. uva; ;!it this 'pcm~, '~o;1h_Cll mI!;;!EIigrm,g: !he: key in:imrol1'ritu:d.n~~billlro'''gt~',~votJlce,''Oni!mll,st.nriljigs.tdisp4Ylln~'5 hllJ1;, ... l~dgt. blu pl:r'fbnlll 1!J!1 .' inawl~dg:Il' Th!!.(1~Pl~ Dh ca:ndfd;lle 's Imawicdg~~ ~ viTlI~~B QQ.VlI III III db5m.~1gj]. wlllcb~IJ)J. ~1' and. op.tjinri;;ij,till)':~1he.mqnhers .ortheYI:OImnli!:le~ luH,': :lJ1 Cim!fudly ft:lld. buub:hbJilOu::n~L!g\lil. ilru:~rw be maet«l '!hHillgb rile ''''O~I;;C llIul wily dl,US lludella:th1!. n~i!. g,mIU'.ru !i'.!!ip~jl!~.Q:! ur l1IoB a:ediDlIS; IXC..asiOll!l ~, &it they .lJ[1'!; h;itt;leed, ~lmti~}11 qu~l:!oD r.I! 'I'ocral dfus.fla:~; d~~pposed ~~g' lli~ qttes.ti~miC oftb_e~daiJje's bi1m1kd,&~ Iw \'e!l' .I.!~th: ~o d'tl ~1iIi~ll 'I:h..l~ biigrwk!irlge- It!>lal£ mil J.l.~:; m mrlrcly a;ltllitl liM VQl;;i1l ebf.\·r~J:~tr (lUl:ip:tam!illI~d Il¥ Jla:t<c.i:imlt Sttagglefi and ;;l"'f1anrrllmr.ll politiocs tlI1llet Ike ha.nn~ of IlKllnmillg plUle.sclellrn.

Bu.t :If tli'lll: Viva .p:!1i!~u. '(,IIle ~'ie ,p, ,t4~ IlclmQ) sf!l~ ·w. jl! rJual wt" dJe,]ll t~ 'li'Uice il; :U!;g ''.lIn,l}ipr~ Iltit m:li l!.oo:lin:g from tIn! ~\ut. set, I,g. the _PO!!:!I ofheingimpfice¢bl~ The Hlimm,a1 Infi!(.h~.isrll !1f :w:hool '(dw d~t klf!ol0f.cal5iJ~tNrp.1ll-dtlli!l fiJi:" A1.thmse:r) depe.llitb eu thQ I.i;O'ic·l!iI!1"S 'l'CilC-e, \ll\llidl dclil\~ It!l f~I,L'~~ chan~~~'f ru:td fun~l'io~l.ntl· iiI'W.1'( mii:i!1illl'h~l il.J1il1Xllg;oIl.~ ~lJ ju5~I~e. rll~ ~~l~l~b~!" I.s rllIic

~~ II!~!II .of _, jiUi!~!i:. ~y ,JiIQ, ~Ire~ ~\y.ledgl,i. l5,,<llI 5Wfl:,~ ill 111 .. ' II t ,I ~ :n hc.eomll. ¢rti:tbi1!! I1iI!JI.y whll'l!I ;llCh::iI~( _ ,I, '1'0 the ~t"e. ~ytliliJg'lIIiif weD:hlHWllterlin me ~extbook. but th1s1iWil!1b1~iW' Tile. '!lJloog~ lIDtfiI !.be ltnt2lttl' ~~ Ii: by his orhUwl'ff:whllth ~1!l!5t .11, !Nf)1;\ If iJ:lc (lr lit RliUdr'~~!!; alJl!:Nl.lrr~m th~ ~~'_tI~, AJlkQV\\\l1.. w:v: f~ ~~mb.1J~1iQ ~~IIii: till, tb~ .i§~bQW:~ btu U1C ~~t~~l ~ ~1tI11~;" [!LtmtJ!ln5mmOll~o,nIy hy:the" 'ifpiee rr~ti;[;J;b.eri\[;;I'1'j'e,hi!,d 1I"sl'll~elU whb l~tl~Q ! 'gl.\i'~ 'I1Q1.C~" in o:nrell' [O'(lj lDhfy' :at IillmvJed!le. ilienfmm lb.!! IIIIHlS1!t KnoWI~~:tIIU!i .1.0 b1! ;;l~~d by me tm£iM'f'~(l'f~

1:he lnt e:UIll¢~it sliglll1f rll!lfcrdJr.md less lrin,ginfurwMd: id,~i:Kl~.m,a ~~!iI~b'etQn~~e-s., mv:e n:lai.:Jlw,af~ll'f:ai{lD ",ilb tile 'i-Ql~glYing ones 'It'Oke fir a O1l:l,clMMe:. 'toUDling 'Ih~ ..mc:a. Ill. EBgJb;b tbiil.'tmt. ~Wi'.ilt-OA C IJntli thCi ~&u; It i!ll!VldWli[ M Ge9I1I;lQIllIl fur jl'1ll1Jrnifm ~Ur.:lm~m.m Sli!ruru m~!1bm'I~·.!i'Jjmil'lclii1!'lk JU~.r··~l)itiifilfr Jac'l'i~d~.1m m~;. Si,\~ rtI:~ ~~; in SIa.." n~fr- 1U..e:.~·~ s!ib'llrar,J,~,~I!I!:f4IlIJr! iiHlii M ~!!!.-~ ~. yd ,lI!,S:.dn! il,I:IIU:,t;,p:bo,r? .Mow t~ h Wilit m '\'Uloo~ gH1:s rIR ~Q m I!'IUlli( filU: ~pblj;j'D'w~tl~ ·iII}QIi:il'1!r1Inllnl~ 'W II;S' ~lPrli:c;: Oli,!till Is VQ~i-br die: mke ...... ~hJi 'is.. by ",iCd.lll'N!llli.rm. . ~dffll:lc bisho,ps. fo:r iiltimp~. we.re eleeted mat way \\'!ere ror a :!(j:tlg.

!!rn.e; t1101 . gmerMlr.;IlI @)~~Il_' .wdMIulll rlUlaOy. ~ll'IW1~ed e'Vdlf (;oCIfi:liJilJIiO or ,01 mooalcli. M m~I"'......(tOO fI' '!''It dl-iiiRi b~U eienrec;Dl:Vefiheli:;'liw.e peap~h<!d. t:() --giwits'vmce"""hii21 rnemOIilncb ~um~d b,i.G wk.:\ Th~OOI'PIl~th::~ll. ii1e lmngIJli!dJ!)ll. oif-a mmwclt. ,('O'UM nm b pE(lpcdy ~Cjmfii.~Jl.!d Witw.:mt ror-m.'il,ll/l;c!;alw.t10n. r~Iy1HS 0111 aJ t:~.I1a'iIi.lm.cleJi'Stmdm8: on:ll~ .:tclag,1:1 N:l: pojli;IU. ~ Dtl, In oil pa;;·.ado:!i:lcoil co,m:rectio.o., Gbd!s 'I!i.ill.maJ.tif1StJligl!Jidfm the ctJ;o.i;{]!it of the

m~u,t:h. ~ouId be ~u:ql'limll!~t""d onlJf b~' &p:renbl:1!l: ud ilimqll 'lib YI;d~ Orlnr poo;pk·, \'iht) had 00 ~<lr, Thl! i'le~pr hoM! n(l pm"1er ' deds:lon" I'l'l '0/ mtmly~~ Ihe ¥ollie [0 co done God'g wiII..,a.nd me '!I!}ia!ot God rouId mal!lif<!'81: ineIf ol!lly ftU'OliIgh Ilhe \'Ili{le cl" (ht 'Ii!opl.~. Thi! PIOOI)li! Wi(!!!il! ~ned l.!IXl!l. ~II(I IXll,J.ld ~ 5jll(Hld amy l~r tl~ rnU.1iheot:vliinofl:ln II.dag~1!tn~pd,~ Pci I~ 1;!'n51'O', !1i;j1 en ~tl!nl;'f' it I;qd. ar least ~n. ~e;comi\~tloo gf"tbe "monarch of;ill1JIDIIm~," 'c:btilrl:amgu(::, Qailtl> dile GJm: me .M:n mennon oJ ~( rome! ill.~ .. ~~l.I~r frlll,)l.,\!CLllCI'!() Cl:l,~.fl~uh.r; Gt~[ (tn 7'1)8),.1-U!i wr'O:l!l<ltiOfj, .In ,8'00.

'1'1'1

p~d' fli!IDUdi.M' proW~ 01 muil ~~t(ffi!,. !'ar h ~ cledde1j. ill OOR.~Dn.nrpoor.1ol$ CllSklm" dut ili1sa~OIl.5b.ou1d t.ah [.II, -.,ft'¢tli)e'lI:l'JimrutitlOl'Ull:l'l ~-pMr.:tde i ~llYilii!dlnBdl '1'000 l fot Rmfu...ltln:-

~II.S mvl.! ~eilm ~~ ofLhii'nlitiilistlt lJ!SeoI the 'lI'ala:, I'.!i tl.~h1.,gl!lr ~~~.y !',O~~altllt u:rd.\\~~ ~ 5dl~ ~ ,10 gl'vt~il:~ \io~'lIr Qnl! b~ 00' ~;~u~ly..'~:nn .. ,a::; 1~v. __ , [be Pfy:rh "': :J. .sOOJl'lty ()~'lli:.d..md I.lt';.d 'OOgtthtt br l'l1f! \'mw; "r~ dte peop~ are. mIl e.!lIerli.l.!.pOOl to :gi~ ItheIr Wire in;fll.IDr l'iifdi.,e-ruI.e!l'. The I!Iftde.rI,y t!'i& Ibi.u~)' I:!l tim 1M I'Gmill!Ur~ Wi whleh laiIlfI!eH'ibcn llim It"..,. t Ii! ther;gd't1~rl1:l1~wu:lt'lia]~nd.;jJi'\l ~~~u;!!hi!il.Bi!!btl:l L:. tm:iiJ",mallu-:sto 00 it ~'tiillice, (iisi!i.om{;edl ~ 1): it·has.1:O be Ii'\'eo by \\il'.hm.g (by 'CJ'OS;8!ng or atdlldblg). illild.!r ·.l:!as;lP M: jla: firmed. in a mull ublIl, i!. Cii!ll-lIlhl: nlb dll:, hi 'Cm1t}ilNe lil6hifUllJ (In ireDell i'l~ a ~alm]lv ~lledJ·.~rl, hI.O:impl te $ltlm~ l'imhe:miOr • tl hu ID 1~' 'OO[il,e lJli~ bf- mLf~ so ~1 tile .ooUemhoe C!~. o:f me ]I;~aIWioo.l)' vo!~ is i!u~km dQWJl, mppHI.tD W~ Im;d, ~1'iWliEJ}Y dl:.pl!~~·~ G;lr ails ~erltiil1 (IU~C~ and ib, S.PC:Ctllll:uI:l1r elf~~ H' I.J ~bJ!; nllolir' W.Jl'.;Utlrnd :rni! ccunred, me ·l'OJresu"b.mltted to arttbmd[c. ~b0J\TQiOf.l enreusted to <l wrlt~n.sigl'l •. i!. .mall! \'o:u:e dEpri\!leld o.f 'iD!l.y ~:my., bur no n~a!~tf 1N EwiI ~ uy (!OI1.I111 thm:- M!14 dh.lUefoQber h • .illli mil iI. W' 'L rr!lie lelm' of tlJ - c.on!RiitlJtI~· I,'tl be !ill&tfod •. ,iii. ~tr1imcn'lj~ ikl· ~ti.es. it has Jet again to be en~ted by 1Jh~ .'m1O:e

"ho:ie:I~E!r~;e:[lres, ofiliinrmtf: iII [b.e~tI.-I$t·,()-rso~;rJ fue. wbl;r,:h 111=1 :!ll'iJnlCiph: tI.!; bu~d OU "Ill!:! l~l[er ~ th~ I.lw," d'iOR ~n!3lms.hn'kN 'to qLlll.Sl ... w~ 0:1' r 1'~IIIi1!15t1c IXilSkm.!i, p~tmlt !o1~1r highly ~c.llin ~ ,a:lld ymprom<l!lic POillU5 \vhe:r . 'the. 1.l:1wI1lIw!t: of the \'Oioe' ;as such. ~ called llpO"I.I 1.0 pildonn it muoo soclll fWlcti.on... 'They po.Ii r i:O lhe

tI~';e!5"'ry ~ml::~ oJ' till!! ~ at.1:i~ f.!ill"ll'iL'U!liI Ii p4 tuu or;l,

d~y wh.t-tIlr ~t11QWngW.y govemlld amI !.:Ill!olUl.Ize~ by Wfllt ~ :~'iW5. rules.and pRS'O'J:ptiQl1S-3t Is.1iI1f ticrlou aftbl: uIlh~<!l-~essihili[~' or me le.uer. ~d of ~~ w~j)at.lj)l~ mlme wh!i.cl!i ][I:Ik~~ the' bw

pn-s!ltbl'e. ;u; ~ppo.'iol m die fl~iJ.ng n~~mirlllr 'i!i:ioims, 'V!thm dte \'itY, ce is ]}~edliid on iilior o~:.]lS'. ~t Islhe¥tlioo pJ'\1 J)l:tly ~bed. 1J!1II1ed, p.1clfiCld. Y·I nit: ,met: wl ell Jubsnhil~ ly •• ~~!) wm.· pltml~l1IIt cb tti.li4 (11'·1:0 .ml:IiI~n ". Hiid KcO)1lI!pdtsh th ~ llIii:iu. It Idlke iilli!~~;M."vbif''hi(m~bb l;(..~emmmlmt..Ja:lnJl.e Vbiiewl!ll~b.I..i1l1~. ehw::es .tlu:pl.'a~r lL1iIitl!uxlty Q{' ~n; .. Ll:l~.R Ihb!Il.i .ilitO W~JiUI!!~lr! II',I~ uJ1_ Ij)'ft~le \'iI)~ dJilfm fro.ro ~~I!II' "t~iliWU:le.J:U: W tb.rm WJ~P; \1j'hill (;s at mJ.::.a'iln the ri~lmiLl1i~ i:11E! roclilmitiOil. .of dt~ 'l'UlO~ and il:$ ·pubile ~1.i.dG~,. usm.ed.iIis;~,I~ru'SOOiJ:l.~a:r~8'IJiit:}~ 8i!:·~O.r l!!dil,flMLIDlty ntl tbl! ~cwh:c:I,gm'l!lIJl. .. Iu 'ymlDohit !!It'ie!iq', d~

n a: iii;;' !he p'r;;Jjct~~ gfdi~ leul:f;; wbile \\~I'Il!t (b itij?mgg II:!. ma.l.o pd1D[!HIl esca.pe. publicityilUr,! [o:ke~ u~ Wt,e hldil.en-l!fit mil;,i.$ ;; l1iilili.ic app<m.mel; it always .Ptodll,~·an. ~ct of the C)~.e:.

Bnt: IJI.· r:Llli"1. Uit o.flhil !iMl!II:l iI.llDi !'be iil.llif ~m1jl Or di~ whole ;rt~fjo..-.....:rH" ftom it, Ii\J'! t~~;e c~ wbilii:h'",erc b:ri'£'y gi. .. -;m lw't ~ ,~~JJf,pl't!"'~, OIl i!- .stlil,n;~ [lr$vj~-DlJ ofbbGl. ~iiit W~1 thne B a (0- exktm!iC:t! c:f ihl!le;[lu md. t'IJ~ Y9lQ!, iiUl.clh 15 qldl'C d~ \''''I!~ ilillt '-'IIhm l'llt! V,jjl.1:i~' !lhQ:uld.lnt~·&;!I!' ill'(lI,"r:b.1·r!,(D Iltiti'l~td'ii(t Ili·!ljr;.r.. The {WI) fIi~.'ttiom ;LW d~.ril)' dellmJredr ;rnd ci:roll:mmbEcl. snd the :inter~~l~,orthe vpice is ~ed upol!lll:15pedlic.iUld '1;;;ell-dEfuted p1~ md Rm.1!S. TbJ.i :d.h1.Skm gh"el1l.1'lJ.n Ip~!Qrl tlJ a. pe!'l1:1:f,ul O'J~h!IU:lI!r ~ ~iOmpl_ an'i'm I,)" .i:fthe lllt!t' ""u~jid limd bHb lliii~ uhhcvoitJ:: th· mismlig' half tE has. ke:n.sediiJ:g. lb.", woice: i1; us.ed oll1J,' in die l!llac~ ,m:d ill me time' aJ]mi:ed ~o u. md. o:."ffl~g d.e~ili OJ!l. the. bl;l~'nd!~ M.lng n3alru:illll~,.aIIl!iou.ghh callM 'blwrred cr~',IJliUb1'un:lt!e~ ~II: ~vb:l¢t'I. (,J'f~lI.lXli' ltiUwi!OiC'll the 'l~lI!r:mel the '~1:Iiw ~~l'Ig dmibt i!«jttl it: ... ;:Y:iMietll' oi ~~ t~s" but it i!!H1.e'I'e:t'weles>: Ol.t tm= ta:m.~ drae .. . tE!L'Ilal.Y •. 01 tool 10 ,oppose oi:m.nxlOIiI.Ii ~fft<;ts 'Dr po1i'i"el ;md 1.0 limit itll

eIIi!, ;t,'II'niul.gh I~ w.lu.e .. fW ~ey ll"'vc UI be r::.i..:rd"u.lly e-XlI.m1uoo th puf,lrula.l' ~e:i.

m sba4-p o:mtt.ast ~o ilii:s, !lJen~ is anofua lnnd afvfrlce, a 'V!9"}t dlfCIl:.reon.tse.;}lw. fill.l1a1UIJ ,of ~Iec ,vhf 1l.h<tY dl~. [Cl:l niltofi!lUmll~. , \u or punlng 1~1Il',"Hi. Ul:lliQII m Ill'Ilil'!f jt'iclj~ and il:S .. 1.nOur '1', It.» fl'j;'~c:i~)' th~ (~roprLUe;l'f C:ollIrol i:uihiorlw~all vrn('e, .... {ilj~e;:as.autb(jjrM~. the '\Q];ce !IS I.be OO,1llCe of ilurdlo:dtr<l(gDs~ t.h.;;!iMaer.. or [he

III III:

·'l9i~ilDt1;Urodt.'J4i!:lltiiilg bm'~~nng the 1~ 'Mos. "tellingl". aU pl!BLOmenr.:i ,ar .lutl!l.iw:lJJnl:mJ. rend to 1nfugco ~r:b~ingJ' l'II I u", '" Ice;, VJbI~ m <l!lIJvM pfll qWlI- .d fl) l!i~ Ellt"'i1I'I~ l"~ly Oflhill'l:l_ i r, - ptli (til'lialfdll)' iitia ~'uC!!rJiQ'n_ 'the: v [~\"'JlItll, .pellifE;, lLlnir1 li.~ md.1ll!lb<miJii, iliil.t ~;i.l!I1Jt bound by the 1.Cl~u,I:g~ v,'liIi~'i':S tire: 5OhU'q: ,iIlli~ i..IIl!mWl~~,IflW!.l' Qfvl~l!tmc!i!:.

Ttl J:l.b'iC' 1l.IIIll'~lt~filli'l:;l ~~ ltudl ~~Ii1~l1in 1'1, ~ili:li~d~ or W!JOlItls ill. n, .5e1fr.iIthJU:'5iilDi'l~1M.: ,.,~ ,~ ilimk <6 Cba.~"!;, l'oodiriiJJD of "the gr~1 ,dLm'tJ:)r." .lrulem.!,!the smnt:i1lii:ril.l! me o:f~ 1'lJtce.m '··ro.~imistr( ~~<:"'Cif .~~ ~\ipla~ .!n~ i;:tl-~lllnOogly. ~I ~bing :bi1ve L'LI be fiOI~i~

I. Wfui.f ~ h.tm" th~ Wttom i:l'pmilll ip1!edl, Dl' the Tonnlli~~l dirnlmH-yn:J.rn"lis;JlIlDuwst'&l.t !1q.g;ID,g.f:wlth alHhe makings ofGer- 1110m (some l'ud1ct!'ll!'l i.dell!ilia~e {l erman Words are mix~ ein} ¥.'c ~h:m"t lttufmtind. OJ. '1votd:(O<I UJt~dy Iw~ ,~.wpl',d. h~.,md molm::., llke :5itUg-~I'iJel)l; it'Iii, ihe VQi~ ;mdi !!~ t.b.ce~l)el' whlcb ue il;ul'_~~d .t!j til'!: ·tt~ 15eIlti.;d ft'Atllre of tb.e: dittatoJ:. [he: \!iJice beyond mel!iJl!ilI.g.. The w~1(;fle Sp~1 Is bm ~ !:.g. ~d a chtjrbogRplhy o.f'thl!' varne.! ~

!. At 'Il\c QI;i1e.lhlll W!Il ~'Il! m ,im'.i.$bk Ungli!fb tI'.m:dult)(I' ltlI~'Cr:pmmg the ~~clI, din b te B}·.~II m!: gn.~dQs \tQi~e with .t m~g ill ,iL roIt.of mnser:niive rr-mmnQ)l... T"bU, tlledl.lU~ » formid.iliLe all!!::! ~!l" aid seeras to III .lIll1!n1i1yu1:mtuitow;,: the mtilmpo]ogJr;t J(LIUo, ·(;awmill. WHO 11M su dii!!d I:lli.l! ,potlljf'~)ml,{! or !h~ '~\oi.Lrell3 ~'oU'I~w: ·~Or;;iCtj~. tdbi !]j 11uE in th-e Mmi. IJribem. Burtinill' ]l;~'b. fQr '::GUIiJpl~! t1iJe: chl.e.f (Ii:m~r) al~;!l ~ .~ ,1;Q. mO!l'rn,prehe.i:i!:~bljl! .klw vola un, nec-tl!.sOWil:1l~r.~ who .~]il.DI:~j 'w the ]R'Opk Wlm,ill [1111: cli.id' rii!'dlr ~MdI,' 1 :B.ut :It: til· ~[ldill thi\~ [lie c.h;l~ iJ th~ ~ (he. 5OlJl"IJe: of [be: \m.ce; he ha:s '~O cfil.i:t ~hl! roii~. [J1JI'e" voice !ivllflo'Llt ~lg_wfIQ~Ii.ou .. ~ClI Iili; vm~. !15 it W\!TI!', rome ~nd·fn.-rommruld! rh:i:d ltIka ~ of he tlle.rnhrg; "11Il! d~ ~ .U~ lu,,· run~~lnl')\ld jlil ~y ~Il:ti!l:i-S~r (I '5) n;lli -:\'Itinhed It 1111 ~ '~Jl"nth~ ~liliCf ~:il.soo~tyverymucbruJled. by Utb:I;,1._JiIt(1ftb~ \fQh.::e,''' ~ metide othll oook.~ Il~ie calli :iwl;i.I~ n, -as '1'iC llilvlilsee.n.. OlliL wmplulcly ~tmu ].~i ID the hlhllJ 1 "mi,gin:.JlIY ~~.ll~" wli1tro ~~f::!: hJ...5· 'to'lI!lj)erpfe~. me vu1n!! ~)r(joEi h~~i:d oil. MQ'I.tlll SmiLi ,[ar llite pe:oep],1!.

w1u:l oo1il<i heJr only me: tbmt~w and me 1IJ.m:\_pe:t:, 'in 11. d~ .diVw,o. l~~ED me Yfli,f_,e .JIll! iIh~ li!.w. 'rWs, QlUE dlWl'(~ !lIlOW 'fmI~1 1.1.,"", 10 d!h. ·iplliP.':i lIt@ lml~~!ij ~ Duree ~ lIIUt}' ~ I.~ 'dtbyJi ~ ~ th 'til ~n ... I.i"i'l;JlClI:n~ rpre~ dl.a~e::o . di ~Si-

3:. Dm tPt. gT,eal ~·-oflk~·~t:J~ alliw:Jtis. ~Ilk,:e;t]~ th:!!t wlntt ihe'j,n~[it'ttlf ~~ym:g lUI~l 1m ll«llfi1ilE ~~~.tIml, 'M d .• ~ J;p~h 1)'!J I, llaWIM', iu tr.imlfID:~o1li ml(o: ~m~l!kIll1:I!I'mil'l, ~ '·Ji~ljtl~ Ii:~' ~,~ ~I. fd-tt"bte 9J ¢If~llt:iil;jMs..k,i!tc.lW-tha1; IiQf imidm.tn,\i;,dt~ ~ i"S . ~ W!n&llmll thai: ,16m old, ·b.e eIrlrn:moo !D [be·\i'o"ID!.md doe; ~. bear 1cr;m.s!<iQD,fL. 'Wi; em ~IUItil!!lAl ':b-t b,1i! b. pt _ mlr.M!,£ ~

'~e rom lll,(1 nrll;:' '~w • thl: ~Ik'~ ttl .kill"', Il~ i:C is olI;l'! Implied jWjI1IR of polk, loQ(. pmnder. an t!;rgy. promi$l:: to ~:wcnd ,~~ ~'''r.-$(lmeili.lng lIla! muhi.n61 be fJt1blicly put into wmrl~wb..ih: the .jnl~tPJi;!~ I.!; pL' $IeIl:clPg~ I..h.c: wbtrl.'r: thing lnr 1Ih~1i!m:, df rhi b!B:

Qaner. ror litCo b~'1wrjc fI:(."(J,nlI. md c n~el1!:Ltii:1l'y pl~VinEl]'1 d~,"~, 1m!.. ,:&i1r.L.1II it mm a Tolilim1iJ:~ i!ll~.c~unr stnI:IliJm.S t9::pm it i"lll,~o :! lOOO pell'!fp&.tirw.-..so m~m!mp:r~~. dees Il·~[.need tt;" ~te Ill!') fIlnll]l' "~)I(d fOO' the p.tcIDn~ wllo IU1.d!!l11Ia'lld U 001, ~OQ weiLl ~ he h;t.~ fo i!;~ ~ ." If! diat~Jr flO. tie Oth~. whlch is' rillf,~nt·fio.m [be ;m:. di fI,l'e of :iru;:iciIW .. ' The' ~~o:c cJf me scene IS that we' ~,~ twfJ ¥H5iOP~, Ilbe dict~tliT~ ~!t!iC.h. .md lCl IliI'.iI'~'J,.i:lolI, IJUIt Wr 1'I'l IBiI~millnd 111 .1'1(1 ,);e~1'l! ~fdll:tl:S:i bo,,",' tlllll t'be otJ'I-r I. 'I'ihe. Still I

'\\"e 'kJulw 'perfealy ,,,-clI Wllilt is scunS on: tbe very m.srn:pmcy.iJ@· ~e:m. the N'O \'El':S:wn.s. pi'O'Of.Icres the ~}!a.c.{ d'l.l~: 1l tsln Ihi!! lilJir~01i.i.ni: or th,~ f.W(j 'I,l-I'l'd~~ W:~ "tho!: {J!b:!~tt dl.~tll''' ;l..PI}~r.;· N(l!:~ Ilh~., llw wh'l':l~!I: ~h~]la;U; pTiI.~m tli1duth~ ~1:1[ilt gf l'tl,c ~QII t;.1~ ~fjSiJi. ~~ 'i'll; 1~~ been .!'J:lpl~'~lil.d d!l;liI dIfus $3 a, nrll:le[ of "dt.u:al;d.e.~lg.·'

4- I~ spe8l!h ,ll the- ilegimliJ).,g~the ~edl. o.f WI;- dilcl~wr HynW-1 dWtl l~lil:'roNd 'I~y Itb~ Ii rcl:tl pli.,~dl. iln: ~ttoCh TIY1dc by 111 ·1 ~vi.'11l ' :ljr~ d~Uli.~ ~ Hynbl. me barb r wbo is' !he f.l:.n ,double ahhe diaalM ami. b_$gmis~ ford!. d~claull', h;m.1Q ;Ml_. :, "slime 1:'Il~Ses m dJli,tm!.c.Hbi>p~.h t1n~·\"I!:VYoPP 51a.ellr~k l!JI~. ItlilL !iJ'Ci.'.:ch: It I!: PF~\imUld 'in fo.rodul W{!rrl:'i il'inedv.i ttll ];uTl'l1ilil~rn. an il.j'lpea! tu 'hliJlrl:l:JDil:y ~!:ii:ll OWl.he:J1lIoM.t::ei:. in i fill iI iroll'y.1ih~re5p(ID!>e ~rlh~ 'liiLl~ ~,ppe~ tg be. the sa.m!;!:~ d:iere: ~ 'Ilte ~ i?,ilw,mliml,

1115,

I!I !;I

Q

iieslllfl= !hI:' frun lllllt the mm'Eif!l:'cl in~__1I8, s!J,1:; \'W'f opporit', Tli Is Imrijlimg. ~(:;I:;- W_~ mil-s\y~ dLlIl't lmo!%'iI ~t Illli,'~ not the ~al U)'DbI. 'buLli'1i- lC'!l.dm,:clpq. ~i~ 'we.ro rmm~ '!h!il:the nlas,~f.£ .ue111lfil~li(.~ gi1Wllle; iUl~V Jill til iIih.y ,m.:lllitPll!bl-lo!il.on !(:Ip f tlJ.11, 'lheJiwl~~ i&acm.l1l.pmied by m.iI~ IfuDll~~AA g,hU dllnllll, i g~tha1 eio. a~"lIelfl~~ ~ fuI~ :mi'hl'lJ;ill~ C,1IEl tb~ 1i31al Kl~1i t~.ce]. ~,t~~~" n:~~''1'~,1.tlldn, iJIIlh_'~h~efil'ens oJ till.:!: mlllL- onei gf wlllti~ 1,1 :1.5. ~Ra:uler ,Or cJr,JO dii~;'v:oicecl~Lll1.d bll~ oil j 'ihe ~Jh:~.gmAwnanl'iil ~e. li\rnd([ctD~ 'l'O' i~. im~ll8lr p~lill'l. m,g to !lOmEtihmg:ehe}

The ![utalftilrim. rlhe \'Uice is not >!It ~u th~ .same vcin il:§ iInstrullCIM· E1ifl!h~ d!ll'&?1i:m 0: 1).1~In_\Vi mtl,uld!ll.\lu:eadl!:~~, mrocMlml

fth ~'~"'l';).~ i;)fnttllIJ,'1 OJ;' ",,1.'11 t:Pl"td.!j~1b!aiII!l~this:ls noll.nC' dimees'i01), OftlUl"'iiKJIfdi a(lI:i·arJ'jjtu~:. Irrusttl, Ill~ !:'o"ti]; 1!I1:olil of;), p~ete:ttSti aflt. iilha_~' to ,mim:ic~ 'ill~mtiJajje,. to i1jii::i:he r~ as clQ~y ~d 'j!c~.my il.'Ii Lt. ClI4, Tll-e' ~,~~. I\ltligl1:1;1!1 pm OI:~ ditl'! VH:}l oor~, . his .1L \~ il'iff~~ fWlctlo!l ht:R: thl: I?likn:r mil:!' wmel I II CJWLI::cl:l\tlr orrh~ 'flnird 'Ref.i::b, mmnuncl~in drie.f lJ[iliil.tnnt'!!Ina. ocGU'P-l" Ilil.my .pol1ticd fimc:[i®s~ Yel he is .run t'!i.e.FUhrer by virtue· of tilt'! political r'Wl t!~ ht hilpp!:l1~ ~f:l htcdwgt;ii WIIdl. II ~ 1'1 ~ilIfi ~llI!!I, alsp !tt , 'on, I:lli! lbiUii5 of h& iIIbil:lti~l!t, llterclW nUilp aF til 'm'l:ce ,linid1 makes hlm. me'F!llnra; ~d ID. ;ie' btlinks the mbittl:S 10 him is CiJ. i!~,etln ~ ~11 Dr.J15o~hcrpm1.s '!hciUl:soweuCI.tbe:'IIUi.ce by m~ss U',. Cll1ltlli_~gn "1'"'I'J~clJ !:i.IIi e·ssmWl rcllijUrt o[,du,1! I~~h_ [I' b! '!h~ vol~.<.l dr,a:t llf,I.atke~ IDe b.w:~FiLltrmVllJtf&i!Ma G~f.i!tlt. ~5 !i.d~lluIDI""U1lOL~' mlerti!iiLmt; .Im Wl);lm- ,s.up:-.fl~d bV iIle ~ rnlQ;. ~E': the bw, !lit vQJ.c.(! 1:mu"!.'i!.dI.I'LeJ:~! ~ur!ll ~b9:1 ~1lO I w.lknL~; 'm..c: l'Qj~e ~!L'ipmds thr:lotw. T'bB ls wh.,t c..trl Sdmdu pmcLrmulo'd ll'l 09J': III "HJ:yrtt'~ \YilI: ;a.odpl;:q" ;ore nUIIilf{:l>EOO in Ii>raI' guid~11ne5' (ld:isiitH), which olN 'I'in immedJ~r.e and. Ill!;Ist int~ru;e '-'i:3y posiIl.ve m\l'"' 'qn~lIcd bj.' '\i'lssIntillUl i!.OCll. p. I] .,. Schlll1U\VU ~ l~g~J i:h(!Ofhl, ;rnd be!,'; Yld nnr hil.'~ hem liIlfiN! expllh:il.

.m. the peH'I'lPl ofthEJ."iW__n;;;r,mm-d bias ooinrldlt:.;+ Hi:: :r-e:Pre5Ii:iU's !.hI:! LJr:ili;y ,onYJ~ ilIIId ~B i115plr.!IlDIL<;;,.llii1 btopnbd:~<'il mlJbriaiitllu'nrnl!fld~r-~tlillro~i:;oj!u:lI·5 f~l"ItL'''bl()I)Cllj,iH:.{' tl:lnu[\'!nrls\~l,~;n nJu: MU1I-

lIililtfQIil arm r11'~1 m;!1ii' l'I';l;je<tWeBilll('iind. M __ I:h;atil'~;m (ftll"jW'tit::Dl~ ~~, ;:IJ:thjl:;5iil1fi· ·Ilime.l:ie:~ moe ~d -So tb~"b1~QHunS S~'1'JlI{)' 5 'il!l!!~credl ,~ "ma 5)\'ii1l~ the ]ellle[ tile l!I1m~.tgll !!!il1lp!l1!i. T1 ':01111'1 Df rbM d15tlntti n,t£:eSW' ~~ 1 'n jl,g:sfirru d·'

, "'.L, "L;- 1 ,£,~" 01!1! me~l:her s1.ft: rh.E! Iliff! ",,,]bl,c],.m 'hidr

11>1] .:'genet: .oj u,~, w:rJ: un;; _ . .'

~ W1 W:!~f1ilMp:wilty. ~t.lillnlll~wh!!th:~.otbe s-a.mfitlM, ~h.atisi. ii'JIIb'J€~~d. ~o iU), ~1JiI;lm:y Qf·!S'~re. g~. ~~JTii~lt,. :~ka\~Im, !In w!1U1! :g~tL'I' Qh.bi'llnl~ wi]:], Ilu: tdiw,l.e) other. SIQ~blhc Hflll ~r l~'!S. rh,~ pa't.m1tmndwIlImi:.t~l't or our Ihy.li

'rbc ~I!n dati ~)~ 1n,~l . ~y iitfil ,:uoJilll:,l1!hL!t ~n-nrthe m,!ilf~i11li '1::1101:'( Q '''t~t;ulitlJf,m,j)j'ndjQ~ i, dUf~ ~£1 of <Sm:liWJ!ro. fti:s m.l(l'Ilediml)! om:i:ous!:hi Sl~[ m1en-~'tIDing ,li'itb Selll!l himself .mt Iilievel' ~odpub1ia!'SlOOiJ:biS. The ~ m {he ;8, ,1m!u nd~ 1!: mil! \I~r C:}J!PO.ldW ,n! If!~' .1:-D.hJrIl'.Tr'!. wlC(: ~- Ulli IP~mrnlM' N;ffic~ ·WilE.!'l, w,e SWtnhi, nl]~1i" 1II~~ ;Ii pubLk ~!t~d'i. h~ rea,1h m ii, m'lniltll'lil'll1;ls:'·~i¢. v.i.thout p:U'lilopa'~Cn:~9tltm and .rhfil.OO:~ eff'oclS. 1lli jfh~ hli:llK1r:~ '[ lllu!i.a!lUuJl whnt liie.lo; ~ylI\.g..Pal'lY c:!tng~, Ww:.1!lWiil'fS~i.&~ i:!ii: monou:m.oWl TWil:ng5 of.a:~ imd]!I.';S'5 5fdoa Df ~dless ipI1~h.e.s. d~ 'w'h ch history ""~.£;~ 'to ,I<&e plaw, but v.tuib. ibad oilD.'.ine,sislibly sopt"ll'Ui.c ~eC't-tJ:llio; was ~:emutel)' .hillmy \\I'lmwt "Il!Y '~~1'I:Il. 'Tb!~ ~ . ecb, ""ill be pu1liw:led

~nl''I'I y II!bC m::.l!! ,~" ilild~~J:y m'i'NCd ~':5 gf' di~ vffi(t1l;] ~Il'W~pap«. !On, DlobodrmtlmS '(UOf'~ alilfbody.rem the Jld:pa)_'~ the piid:Ul'1lIAII~ b ~tlal w..d! m<:k~Jl~mihle-llO'l. be.caume ~f til", dcl!.1!,I!t:ue'!l, lu:I dt~ h U, ~IOir Df dlo~ ,~Ui,ple ~up,ro~t.dJ~ '~Il'I~~d I.n ~s ~CMlii t~djm "'tid! ~u~dre,~!'.. bl!lt ~ <L ~'m!: '!\'I;qg,td far 'l.Iite brmefil Qf ~e hlg Other. The pmorm'ID:C:.e: is meant fw thee ~i',l: of rnto ,big Other oJ lllS'tmy; ,and ,afml[ ,;ill. StilDnilHI~I~17e:s ~re ;dmy5 !latifu!d in. urn Dr lilt: mbi.1uUll'i g_ m~' gri!', 'l h! s.t 1(".;11 \\is, ~ vjl:W of" rurore wb.lt:h~'UU!ld ~'pposedtf v;ilidn:~ ml.UD.

Iftll~.maiD obj:et;rilol!: ofihe ~tnder was to ~cluc:e ;m .fu!l!il'r b~<ltJd .Il,OW, ll.rncislD ptlt ;ill, llli ]l'~O~ into ~hlc n'it~imIl; !;If r.llldlm~'~ol1 ilnd. ~pccl~~t,lf dl:~ 11'(:1:1 ~r: W~);: tbl! Id':iii l'iiI!:ot11 um Q proMih.lrng sud.IM!.Illl5. m. ~1"<I.h1i5bili!l~'~ diJII:Qt link beh~il tJu;';ru]B!'md

'. '. '7

da,~ lIlil~Uo:!I. ~ 1ibe.'1lUiI;!, tL"e,m,' W ~t ?lrtr !i».tlg~ ~M (hOI! I'l lllW,g 'WQu;t~ ~pptIl'i Ihtt PM;Q'I"hI.l!,g ~cld RD ec mlfJ ~ tQ 'IIJIZ ~tll.bliiili.m ~ado. Tbt' "\wrinmr 5~[ i!s" n l'l1J hoi! di~~1l.iJleid;;"'_on ~ ,(lcmll'~~~l- .staJimst ru]e:r .~ bm: ~ ~m.I~ a' tm,cIfi~y of Lilli! ilerip,li, .1114 ~ ~lric Orm!rtiC\linlll~1il!l :r~dlng I!. tl lites.m[ ~ f'1iW ar~cm ~l po iibl', N'Q4; iiEI~j!iutti.t1'r:i~ Qf.h "'!;!jtll', ·llIrttllre'Ji!Wn.ooty ahbi! l;lt~i~ ~. ' g_md~..r~ u.t: l~~m '>meh is the ~'ent lbt:""tltCJ:~i!llmt ~1i!l"'Ppen~-iI; ~~olp]lm.d.ag!.l gntt: sp_k~. b;l;\,il' 1I:iI be 100 ~Clud ~tI b~ I!If~iltlli ~ilhJlaUrui ~D.l'~ ~C'l:i; bill t!m-·vOi.ar:iSw 00 rilidu; ~d-iI!O thHr.mjnii~ pClli ibJ -qULlltfty, The. f~t i:hat I:be. ~u a:ppe'M'.s-;ru:)[ tn irmd'~tmd wha.t he IS .r~tl!Dg. ~m~ Inrnw:itI,.n~1'iII rclllCn tln oflminte!lJl~, gp;lorl(!;S. oJildlguX;h .. ;: ~-ml~ ~t \r;;iI.I rumd 10 ,tcJil the: lli' from WI ,athut.l'bJu:LILt. ilion :is,~. the oppos I:C.I.O dJJlt offusci.ml~,H!~ fimr IS '\,'rolds, fiupponed by l!hit,'WlIlOOl.ate ~atlc p~~.Q£:i:h.e ,'Oijc:e, ""1!:Xf' I.n.ullulio\ll~,y Icgbi!ilh~ ;l!1 "!/'J,1f.! In!w\''e~JG:CQ. whllll!:, ~~ l!i1~I!I' IrtJu 1:11- ii~aw~ ~~ <Jt;f:li.al. him'it;M:' and bl '7Qlc~; J!l1i: ;u nieRly rlh~ WU:nJW.1 (lr m1= Il;l.'!it" j~~.~.he Irs IIb·e.m~~'1! umllfJfdreJaQ.ofhi5.tQry; IiIOC tiliLeiir ereamr. He I~ lUJulflt1r;gl:slaJor. bru: mere.l)l1lbe swel.'Uf (.t!beH:5e! - ,elal'y~ml), ~y,ing out r!h' !:iIi m~~;md :SdJm~ly ~bl Itl:d c:a\ll'S.e . fllhillClI'f. the b&mlhle oltUtr in lb '~'lm t1'h .OW -T. H ~!C!S UOt m .b.k G'.VI1 !Ewne 1iI1J!1.tu the u1uine o;fthe jmlliCrmdl~ progre.~s. lhc Mlrlil re\I.allildon. iIlId s on, andIn lite biJ:g ~ nm:hln;g' tollllFltSI'eti 'Ill the \uh:4!=h:'!ii sll In t:hill: r~tlI'l1iI'.'lfld u~ J~,

if S:t.ilin:lS( rulers were bad spe~i~'!'~< then iI: ils perups tdlm,8J !:hOlt those ...... !tn, O'pposerlS~l "!.fet!.': eD weil!ta~i'S.l'r0.t5k.~ the arehWlit!i~ir. '\"',M ;I, htiJll.:I.llII ()r.u~~ i~cc, ',yb.iLll! ~·CII, hdlllm[, 'w;a~ (lb/l(~pp~I,~' m 1il'~~iiM::i·ell, m;td illil ~~~d \:;!'r~ICJlld.t~d on !!pilJlt~!~·,mi!Jli JI$~des ,in [Xl'I:~' I.tlu !mgwge:. dlJealy ;~ddre...o;:sing ihe '''$imp!'E: ~ple~ of \~'hlch 'I.' \'nS. l.I1eg,edly. pMt hm1~I!L 1.1re :;pc:-aid rue is ~ of Ccstro: .l.w'diy Jill opponen~ 6r:Slallni!:II', bUl 1'(]1 wlDg a \~!i.l¥y dl.lf~rmt ~og t In 1 :'public a;p~o;;es.. He ,presi;IItS IiDlIleihms lilI:~ all lmpcmbt· srn• m~m of lWQ OWosfu.8 dem.mts: CD. t:il-t: (;If;j1i nllIl[:i. he dclhrers hk. -Spi: ;:;di~ ,m,.il. ruiI~, M~]~m ilWrltl:ell prop. m.firt-l1· Sl)lk;, rd)',LJ,g .UI1:- 5rur'dY-QIl (h~ 1lII3.~!foliililll. Elf iJtIll I'nmne.tlt. WJlh ih~quc ~l~I.cr~e Ml,rJ

1!IJ1I~~g. cunfl~Ot:c tt. ~ 111l!llWdiilc,( uhh ~' c~:)"'Ioll 0.0 ~1l~ o h b.a.nct 1m i:i:nPfrvlie.~ m.oMI gild Ide Ito ~ .a",d hDL~. ~!;{llU!! U'~lf repelii!~.Uld:<spo.nioIilc~'Q!J!S1Y'mm ilD.U,",iJIa,ti~b)i' ptnJ leaders wlth f.'t1:IlMlr·s!>p01ilic clf'ects . 'I.Utl<i" J1le'l':l!D.g lihllli" lclQS J!l!J ~If hili: IDpJO$ 'l ~~fb!l~ voIll

Irl'ilrSliultnlsnll:Tj' ~i:h5;tlg: h.,;;ppcil ,in (ltIel:1:J.'Ille qft'he IJIg"Olbgr:of

b,i"~ i.1ID m f"'~~ ili~ :urn}:)_ ~eIr ~~eS ili~'l:1:lI~ 1i;;I d!E d· .:<He ha:sl!lo DflICd: for ~~~"tI.'01: l\l'~; b:i! tus.~~~IQ!I. is, ~1;iI Emllo.!!r (k m'!i~\,y Ilud .hlli: il!!P~rril~um IJhht Na'!:lou. lilt:" will ~ PO'N'!:f:' i~ iilre'ed

gr U[ie...sp;W1: ",p,(i ~r ~ pUtlfi~Ol!I~'Ufe. S'~~dJ. '~, blood. 'S[:)'TI-and Wle'voitt l om1fmiliti-oo. of!his senes:. me:m[ce: insll;,i,d or. 1lI p!.a.:[1! or;, tlh: 1)1\\'. In Ihls Itgh~. ;ill tb~ Ic,ga~ ~ . mil! ~Enn 8.·I!II.i:I'llU~l~ Inmnn11~ll" t.l lIt)c:racy, Ololld ~ I~m-\,;I .ltd Q1tIy ~ppciU' .Iii; m gb-

Wk to 1he biopolitlei1 J&.end>l..l.he Glll!Siimpb~ Qf~, 9I!! the ~', 'I'i35 m1.1t ;..~ bm to ihli! :E!W:ghtenm.lmt. and Iep'~~ed ~lil!ul!!!l' pm~.$!.~J:I. Ji:s tel.'n;lil' W~tll.t: Le~.~ ,~iI"lIro r~llCr iUiil Ill!!! I,nv ~1'~he::~un~ of th~ OtD'IIOf; bin th~ml)' bidmg Glr~~\-ohl~'b~lU:na 't~ le'll'e[ was the row« ofptluu.iJon,: the St<ili.mst's vaic:e'''!'''ti·Vi!~ (!,n!!l 111.lmOl!On,Ow.. ill mo~ ~p"'~g)e lo"tih~ ler.re:r, ,)~ ~rlls, sr.aging. th~s ~~ d~Oll or 11n~ volO!! 10 1Ih' ''1[ in'~mIlJlJ. lIS ,cI!r~df;l(omcn;L. ltI! ,mtillf to

hibit tb. - 'I Ltcr,l,li. ill. WI: more Dh] ~ti'lJ\~, !rll,d~!lend!mr fif [be sub. j¢rov11:f orjllS.'~'COii:m-dm r~~lion w~, tbesouree oftbe Stillnin', POWtli'. T e mLl!llu' hI:: si~ hl.1.'Wii!!ll' ~ b - ~~!l :IlrN~t::r 1U5 lllM'.'U, mdLl'ttd to lh~ hl,d!3 n -Ip'p~ilinbg, • tn IDV}' ~(ldlool:l gf Ille "im.!:,. ilm~ Ol.\~ 'whicli, d~dcl.es the 'l'alid1l1 of ih~Iil!l1Je[.

i\gmloeitl. in. the fir~t p,ge:g.{lfliomit~. dame;: ~am:eignw, {-I;!'!li;Jw~g.Car-l Stlm~ .tt,;s a.pumoJ:;:

The. 5O'i'lffi:igri.l!.3.t dle:Q![II~ tiDle QllISl:ik and m,side ihl! jooditi!.l 01- d..,,,, ... _ The: wn~ll:!I • .lllv.InSl d!~ tq)a.l pcM'~ tCi ~~i3pl!lid f.hiil v;illditl' afm I~w. lit Iq~lIy 'l~lt~j.cdtllllllLdliJl" 1;a",·,'TbU.W:t=;ljD.\ ihunht= liU,q.d~ '1::aJiI egjl,!ljiJIy be i'omil.11~d ,In !his w~q: "l'h.e hw l:S. O!o'l:la:Wl' m

luci(" (iii; !l;lth,1lT. "':1. m.e: mv~. Vi!l':w am o'nl!iEflE. dte:bw, Idt:t:l .. ", 1I11l1!, lhc-.\" ·If.lI}ojjJulll~dr Qfth liiWt {.n~ l'JIlI-r p. !3:J -

SOO~l1rlgDllf3.!ltlm~~!bJ.~d on ~iik.lhe!ll!livemgl:! is dJ.'l" (m.1!! wht) ~ll~ wpt=lUl the.l ~ I P"l'dl!/i anfll' todidm ·tIll: Ub:! 1;1,1' em 1'I~n!;f wm<re da: u.m:iil ,t.r; O!;R 'fir;) 1Qnli1~";1ihd. omtl ~Cl:'llia:p tkm b~ rom5 (llt I?ule. The"~~c'Q . 'enl'eql.~qr Jwi. itle mQ"it inlimilre .IlI.nk wl:d! th;!:! dlm;~lflJjl or"b,.r(:\ W'~": mdffiilt, i'l i5 :prarl.mnedi 'lVh~n LJUr b"'reli"'eu:t"'1H1,d~lIg1!!f~ I ·\!;ltlh Ilulllr.tle.iII.;UIlll ~ba" "~.ll.JIh~.l!i',iJ~, S'epl.'mlh.l:!f I q; .•• ) ,md whm Ilr:le:k'tJW:g~d; Jn Ill!: ~m)t1 On","" k~~, ID CMI.ccl th~ .. ..ilidIty rl:b.e l!UlL1~rtJl~Glna.,v. .Batit~.\!p.Wi [he '(l"V". CIiiI,gl1l tiCI.de'~,~ Wh~tlJB i:h~ld"iigt."!' I:sl.nif!(!:~ S'uclt dl;!!l~! cll!& funhi; ~L*m," mc~. 5Q lhe "ery n!l~ (Jinillw d pads n!:hi!: d~~1! ilIlcl '!he indgu1en.:r i!nUlmdfig from .l p6.mt oullS.ide the .Iil-wi And til ~·~t)' momel!tll\IWm~~j:;:d~brnd'~ tmisJmwOl,wil!JIEl: ofQru"bare b'l:fs, ml'~VIl md tl1~rQR _ IlOn'jJCIlilil~'~III!r. \)i" ~d~g witli .IJ"",'ei!'eigllty ;w_d p:iUltla; It l' tbtl; p-liH:: Iiil~,. lI"itb dlli: mQ'I';'~ of the-! PQ~iti!;',li .•

"'~ ~ 5i!.l~. ma.~ It.!w~'pariIDM la.,tgd)remnddes will:! w!Jfrelm.on:sbip b!i!L'\"@$ ~k \loti: UI!!:I' thl!..ll!tlcr thH 'I,\~ hl:\'e ~li!Il.ClI:"min:!.Jl.g. The 1C't~i!I" of l.M tL~ tn o.nl'e.r ~LJ; aQqw;lir-= ~lLmali;~r.I'm8, fl,'l .dy, in ill, I;"dlillu pabil, Oil m.e !acidy pre!1f!PPrJ!.lled rotc; it is the !\!!mmml ellmltm{ of die \'I:lIlq; w,bl~.1!W~5~[ <thcJ!!it~ :I.~llQt "w~,dea.clte:II)I,l,m;." bm e:.'i:'i:I"li!>,paw~ IlIl,d WIJ'~ r::Jll Cl.'ed 1'11J5 (,alii, t.llUli lIUi form. Will dt....uJJ~ll c,( kbor al).d .i "~eful oow:;;tenc:~ " problWl1.tk "i'~~V h b!u ~h ' lJeJl..'llOIi b~nV'een lili~ two. ~dy ~.l~ som.ewmg rM mnre WtI__;[Ie;r: I1It ~Itr it ,\trtIilIlf!lU)' II!! d!~~ ~1.1f:I st!i'mIgIli}: wJUdJi LneA.l!l~ d:u.~ I Gm 5~d 11ll' ,aliIlhY!il1' tlu~ liI.w lBld hn.'1:Uell,itJlI~ dtc. ~'1:~C~ u f em~e-JlC)l. 'llre \"OlceS[(lndl; ,iii thO p;:!int.m tlIOlpUQIl, "wlni:.hilhreareil~ III healom~ the rute,wh!!fe i1 mddilldy d~'fS Us .~M&W1d eor.t1pt~thi' \;,OUh lbr: b~.re. .1lf~, ~'al U (lj),pom=d to I!W!, tkat Aristl:l~ '~ ~I.lmll!l ~Ult Tht 'm'i.e:geng1 is t:h.l1' C!mf:~lI~c rA"th· nlW 1IiI ~I:. cWiUnmd i.l!Ig pc:sillOili. 'where ill ·oonttiiJoo -eids~m£"e .suJd>d~ beromi!!> O\WwbelMt1g ~~ !!I1!'~ll~ Th~ lfcdce lspremclp.l clle L.lJ1kIca.I:a,He t>p1:I~ I'll W f1h:£i[),l' ,mel llIae ~ui ,of the law·.\[ [1-;: !>Irnll!! iJm:c. liDd! ~~ ill penn\ll[]/m!1" ~at of.iL !>I.lIt!:! .of.~m.er,g~~

.!.o ";fki.I d~ of Wi! 1:;p:i,€,(!" fdUp\lrSli::OIl1l .~ d1s~iII.( 1!lw ' 'ol~ a.s,.pb·Qpl.;md ~~,..ileDl, ~ ~a:ge. ~ ·Y"oiC'.e '[oJop,Jj; .m !:mill 'Llil}lI'l!;)1ItIC!lil p,.'1!!;!.ag'tl \1Othl.cb, 111 11m 1ec101ld !l~. mnal~ !he );~~ ~~.~nre ,af f.ie "n'i~ .m Im~ 1:fI:I1h~ Qf tn'El ?M f C1~ If;~ n:htk~1I ~tl.b;,mal.ogo)U~o ,¢m;roeiLat:ioo. ''Di~~t1'a;,v;jf("".m m:~l th . ~o.Wt:, ~~! lil1~ ~~, .~~. pI~~, lI·t the ~IWl elf Ibpt)L 1]w:l.: bWil to bt: .~, p!IIi't m ~'OO~ wiIJu::h tl:Id.ow.l: 1I1~ .bm'Ii!F W1lh iludwrItY.Bl~is iii pcri:I1ll1"iihse mei!!'UeJr has oo,xcl~-fJifi~ 'll!.ci.ti)qlr-esu)lp4 i:ld '."l{1Ire furil!l:~trt.hf!r ty; and l:hl!i,iJwrI.dJ.Mt! ~t.lJf the \'d~.e 1!:;~1~c15

ll.Ue ~lt 10 ~MIulr ii'll dlil: ~u:ill..st..ll: m!! r~ . !~ ".,iI.-£R til£: b1~d!!i!I1, '~"Q~ !l: olf~r.iI Ill! ~ I)~irIVQ ~~l1f.i1';1l~;illir :iiI> .nd· JIll fOI It&d.f,. ~I II!. "~,,.Ih~ pa!["¥cOO{:.aiI ~QJil~togyo£.t:hr VClto;: ;'IS -wmliiillv:be'~'I~~J1- .~-U?ii[llha~ \:tt.j]iI\'l1t blfl!ll ~I!!l'SJum.!<aU ;aJO:llg:<c.m be-p~(.il!o.ng~bE!re lLJ lhe Wdilllc.m. bi!1 y,; ·ml-gl!lIr ~ md I~ 8 W~ ~. I!it ~mll;]~

k Ill] om ~5 me: t?rn.e:nooes {!overl'~ m ,111 e]f;mmt,~hidlr.do~ nql belOJIg ~:f)eiJ:.l;Je:ro.riliti1l. t'!l:L haMs ,[Mm KJ1l1&Il!!r, l'Hs Iocaf:iO!1- Ib ,. itlttl'lt!{lti.ull, the 'o:o~d"""'lmru: llu~ mi~ .In ~() s.::!ln~lbm:m .1l!J:I~1· eus mdi <lih.tih'e. iil~ entity • .fhim cml.1Ol be m ~ in Ihe foJI SlIDiJlI'lt"l ~f <t'lil. um.:tnbl!g~l)"IIS: preaeJlll::e,. 'lruI i$ !J;Qt iim.ply ~ 41l:k E:i;Jhe:r. l.hl;: m 1;1" 1l11!.m.1l~' \'0 i;;;;e bldm .IS SQ4ti:thm.:g pmltllOi! anlll cl.nupcilm.g 011. il~ Ql.1I'J!I, w;: cn~~.lht: M1!1 wl~!W! obnolt!olU romi~II~~i:!t~ ,l/fI': q'u!~k 1'1;>1 ~lIow. ill polilfl::!l.il: Qlli6t1y llim!> into:l'iB. M~" "i"'!i:Vfl~~. m]JpLmri.ng

meli:W.

BUi m UtI: ~llll ()ft.J~ "pQI1t:i1;!!; ,of lin: ~ICIe,jj we 5Jlwlliti. ilio. purW~ 'tie· 5;11'l11t. (I~r~tirm ~ Ju ~ 11MiU:1 tlhlhla;; dw ril1i!ll.inl!;ijoc~ili

III ~

ji. nSeS elf lhe 'mire md 'ILl1" ~lm:~r11 rfatl" Iifi~ d 'rr~ CC~· b(;

:: ·wbol~ ~]I 15 ~ h . ·'f.l.1Dat 1w ~~ W ~Ilmg~. fi~)m Ihe

~

111 :!i ·IiIDIDU;md.sJn1ll. wICl!!l.,. tD~ 11 ' .• !i~w. vulee: tif pillre I!!UUIlCi'i_

lig.lil.liie."~,mm-a,,.tlQn \¥id'li011.L a ~"'I~l)r ~: thu '~11l1111[IWI ee ""hJ~b eue h~!: iTG.llIl'Pplr-'liI'IUI:ll!~et!I~. 'j]m pmitlcill [i~eJill: m _ffP'I'l~~ I n ~1il1l Wi~Il..tilL}ir lJ~t~g/o.g, IJ:"iJit·hroUl.~y':"~fOrm.ril:g ~1)' cI:J1id~I." bll~ by '!!f.L~ilI~~ ~1!1 pOIldaJ ~L~!I.tC~, I'~ I<!, _" oit.~~ee pC~Llf H~1.. ,n~, 'nut anif iII IDe 11'1\'1[, bm NIIl'lO hi '~h~ wid!: !i~w-:S;fUllhQ,lla: tc::mjl'l' thE: 8'jo'mbo'lt!7[d!rlt: sroml·m. tnmi:iOliD snd 'mow:, !!;::mn~tll.mg .... c c.il]l nl!.lII:r Simply ~JlDiI! ~,y c(')lDjJ!Ii~ md.!lll~n'. but IDm<f:Ih.itlg

IIhkh dnrIOUlrl£ ~, ,-_to IJ JI.lQ,l NI.llbj~ ~i1Ikatlm! whld! C;)I~ l~ t:

m.1D}· dii'-e:n:m fQimB, 11t~ !l)',!Iloolt-c I:iiq' dl:'jpen~l. Oll th~ t:lItJrlI~. nI the \'ulce It tllaue1Jb1y ludllli.init5 entram-lil' I M3!tea tblli. section by 1n~'uk!lIg Altl1m:l~ 1 em OOll.dlll:!il: It by bricll,y ~O'uclllnf Il.pOli Ius m~11!m OoJ i!'l,tspclhxio.n. WIll h I!- llitl~ :m~h~ 11I!!lI"'e for [h~l vot~ me H1] ..... Mm· swil:aim ~injunctmtJiS ~d sy,mboli'l;: rnandU,ES. M!i.h~$ ~'a ..... 'Iil:I:}' If:lm~'~ IDe~~~'1lll'!f~pUo,n'l)r tb~ symool:ii. Ji.I1~IlI!I:~ " ~PIlI1il!:'r to II ,Ci1I!,.m1l! tit: FQVd>~uI i l ~th~ ~Uent~.aJq I~. hilt th~~ I.:; ill di'>'id.:. {l prOOJd'~OUi l~jfTtmg Im-, ill ID: ·tWjlllL!l~~nll voh~~: 011 die nne Iland. tb!f.f(! ~ lhc!lm(~ ofbec·o.mill'B 'it 'l1bj1:1 b~' ree:OgIDzl.ng {If:l~lfas Ill!! i.dmesseE o[t:bMe!lll, wI th :nuu.ld then, ~ iii \'~1'11ttn "rHh _I.1SIer's' leI!' '!;uJ..Qg pMllhre p~I!:!r~tlEl. ; eu I'll other tb~fi' 1£ lit mil: qm _ tim c I. )-vl.a: whlth iDti:rpr~U(Il~ wldwull ;w.y 1)O.S·tl1\i\!: wliLten.t--gmIl~ili!le ,,,uuJid per:ho.ps Tamer. ffi:arpt by 9l.l!;:)fln.~ the SOOQmrn 'i'O~« tlf SIl!1lc:mmls znd OOll:ml;m'Cis; D,C',i'JU:th~lr:~'llbr~ pW\~ ~_~ gf Ill!: ~'t)~t:~ jJ ru-mJl(!l!Ih:I~. :tIJ:h~tlgl1i, .it doM fl'tJ~ tcl_l us 'W':lllt' te do lUIiI. d~ riotlt offer OIlu_n;!ll~f[jof ftQ;!Hn.itiC:I:I UJ;r;i ldecn tilic.IDo)l...[i aae ~t.~ 'to lieOO:L'I'i~ iI. ~uble.cr.. ~iti(!Il:-a.nd 'Cl:!>edt· ~1lOi: ~I;! nc¥'r:J' quite ~n:puglLi In .1dditloo to and ilpaIt I'roru It!.eSe, (Jilt: hilfl Cg '[~IJ,nd 1.0 1Lhe "IUUo!! \'(J!(lt~" whh:h is jU!lr ~ [ptmiDlg, (I pt1:r(> ll:ll~lndatlcm wllilpeoJlmg aresponse, om act. ;1; ~t:l:flD OfL'bl!impo-s" iI'lg "'O,iJCI1!S ufdornil!!At!ian_ If 1n. tll~ fustase 0 ,f. mfn;:;,mto 11 5u.b;iecl J.l,l'ed~cl'l hy ~fid:n~r Ib~ f~J::Il'~ 0 th~ .lU.tWU.HI\QIJiN "J." ~YbW!!lg II,~ b~t~:i:-aIlCimk flrigfJ1, 'tt~1 i~;IOX~:r;;;iI diJo~nlfi-il.iLQtI "'tid! ~mml' Qmous :rubj,eil1vityy,'mi; lund im, .hand, ~tli.I:~lms.se:r bas Iilwefi.d~

jh .... 'U.Ih~lg, i;l111:!5r;!0In!.'~ nn beoo:IIU,u wlb] tlt o:nJybfMctl1l)" ((IlJm ""ibre;ip! Jremri.l" of fh~ voiD! whim>Qnm:J ~ "PpmpriAred·1l rll;~serr, !.h\'is~-b~' fop6:v:~~ fhe.i1J,et.erI\Ulpmj(: ~_in :whi(ib D;ll1!!l tlilUno~ ~~gru,~ !:m~ ''l:h~ (1 .. log;I'i:.d l1iil,1:l:;pdb,(un calli I\t'iQ qitIl1e i'lteri!Ci: I~ mJ'I~ "tVj~,.ul,d tb;. distwltW" befW,t:m .~ fWo ~,'W~~4l;e.~f thJ:polii:k~""

Jr.i 1I1hl'l'lli~~qlll!l(~ ill !' ~~ '~"~"'I1lhl~ ,and ml!ttm:krJ.llhk'" (~:9.J7). 'PK-L'!d !DU' ~t ihrt~ lmJiml'!ible pltlf!Oli!!iow, m ;,:;,1Ulili"WlC"'~ ~r; 11~: of \1jJ ~fu{)lmy outoo~~; ~'(}ffi1IIr:net),t. ed.uCi'itiOlr. iiDd psyullpmillly&'l;S, (S.o\. SllppJJem~y vo:tW)llC;. p. JaB).' I If WI! lOOk "~ tl .. &om·(lUf biMed plUlpOO:bW. It i oln':l!mJilI, wn. ,a1l dt1P!~ eru..mll)l' iIi'l!ll ~ the WlI ·,,·it mtii" iiom.. ThEY oue It ill p;wfrsslw'l.s: of dli:: vnl~-... ~d,~lups~:is th~·~en;[(m.f_e~EllI of t!~e-vqiQt:"..1lid]·~ ~hl!liJ ImJIDSSili.bll:! tQ. .:be .s[.p!ai~Frum mlltbl17 mgle th~ ~'H I.a b~ lIppol$libl b~~!.I.~~1 ~h~y &II ImClI ... e g~tl'tmCi!", Utd maYbe Il.h~~ li> a;.d()SE U~bel~ 'rhc' ~wo;th.e'MOi,C!1 mOl'f:\'''i'eIi lUllml:m 3 dre \:.er~till. w the Jkv.U df~~ M 'me i:f;m~el'eI1!fa1 vu.lai, m.d.:iruiybe mndkr,m !~ butmo:rher ,rwn~ for tbe lDi~~lb~ <HI1lI~~r ,o-iIJI!: cleuerly (h. mice whit;:liI ~ 11,"1: lnn Ir.WIlinllIg;

W,e h 'Veheen CWil8ida'ing the-m&t pfofe:s!i~OD. gmlmlmell.r;, with Q11l of'dlr: paradl)lt!!ll of the: polirlo: M rn,e \"Qjee_ lb .~ ," illy brit1l}~ WUdtad, uptm 'ihi! !lI!!eQilld. tb~ 'l"tlit::~ m d ~cnIml • .t mk "".,th IDll!lI!lr' lo:n.8 dUp'lm wruc'h 'WUuJid IUl~ Iln~cl.l c:J.w;v i>CfiliIlqmr; b'hlll I WlIll,t 1{Ii ,~icll:!la!UV~h. £ir,;rml:;w~~ i!ilmiptl},. o[llbe Dote of "rfu~ 'tQi:t:e' :as. dJ.~ 'pl! \'O~ Qr mi!1~)' m~e~, p:~'c::b.oona1,m B ~o ene !;If m'OS'e. ;bilUilI wbLcll ~,m bt r·ot_rr:I;td DUl of;ll~' 1lI1'(! '00. III fbi ~ht,ll]g "'t:l1Dl., bJ lhie 6'IitI:Lg pre-~em;e ottJh-e. ~l'smd ;and [he all:l.lv-_ t.l1htir 'tie j~~ ~h~ It~1; Qf!ln~",oke. (.an.uy.;:js·by W.l'tifn~, breVet! by (icl.epl:mDe. "~dlo). But ~vhos.e \'0 ce? l1u: p.nI!::;8lr the i1.a\'5.OWd. is thi! OIl'!.! wh :Qlllo pl'~,~ Ii~ Of btr .. rxi<ljl:i£Ul5, iD)'tJlin,g dme CUn,lClli to bI:i OT h f mind; i1~ lIu: prn{!JjJ~j'Jhhe.mi!lI~SLSo the pnient.is: em pl'intipll=) the p!I.'lnapal, er, ~t tile: kmlt. lire sale speake; the dlthiO,1.liS. p-rlvtli:ge: <l'f the !lii1.~k!tQU of Ulti '\'ok~ bcltarl;p 'm Iw! or Jmr. T.li~ 1I!Il.ru~Jt.lw t~ !I:~l!;p, $.11~M.~ •. leil;'it m \'lzm~:Jille ;llld W~HN:tllP'l~~OI'1~ Q.frht' 'lirii~ Buq; ~~:r~'

I C\lr fJl.!!l~. i.lI ~ p1\A ' ~. 111..1 [ll~ an I~\, wim Itili Qf ll- ,Uil'llt ~

, I

\\fko br$~ma'~·!'Ii'liba:ainn:liltrlf1.heli'm~s 115 me.ohleli1t. Sb~or I!E' [, me, ptni!)!ll!fi(awm •. m,", 1:ilDli:i)xlimml., or mB \'!Q!~ ~b~ ",ol~ Ill~[_ nate:, Inh~ilipb,g!tlC.~!m~ mll:C-l'hIs LFnl3lt Mf$~;~'~cd~e,.nt:1 ~~ 'mloo or a OOIl'a'I~nd!. ar III ltl fLIlP"elieg~ ~UJ, ra1J~_~ thv I:mp()~:;.tbt~ ~'U[~(,; III Whiih Q'nc n:i& to rell'pm:Ld, rul'i ImeVlJial \!¥ltI:Idl d.Ge:s;:Ilim~~ m-ytfu'mg. ~,di~ V'Cl5:c(j:wh1tK~:o~, lbl': g)j/:l U i:S: Ilrn.!~ v-oi;1:t- of pi ;l,ppe;JJ]! 01 tC!Ii!!'~, IliJ.lpl2L tt~ ~I!d ~o ~i'i'ullil~ ,tili'i~'~ !!i~;1l1t'e .Ii>, tb~ nllbj~> Om:- it; ~~:d 'UJlml w s~k. loud ail!! IMlll;ltt'l ~y ~I1~ th ... ! bi._p-pellS' to willie into ~e~_mindl (0 im_errJlptI11e;_2i~. to sJleIID: thlSvoite., l;(I,s:iJen_ee Ihe.sil:i!ll.ce~ b1:l!tpHLuP5'Wt w~ process or;mal,

mil. w,.r~ II)~. h~ k!i ~\ill} Ilhill'l_ :tt[~ [t, is !hI!; \'oill! m wllk.h tlu: Illll,iu:l5:th:, 'tlH! !l'Ihlciil. ~a mo [)Ol1ticd\'~ jiWt f~, coinciding :In 'what'~ tb~ ~O<II of'pun:. tiW1Im-tiOll~in diem., neey ",e bJo:t.ll~di ~fIIgl:!ther iI1'Owu;l -Wt. pt'l!tCl[iliU:~r,miJ. of'!llll! [lbje~-vof~~. Q'r h~ ~'[J(lll, m~l in, ;u~ ~Cl' U CIlT fu,' n lif.l.g~tk!. ~tbJ.cnl. PDtittt<LJ ~1.Ib lects !mit ... btfllilled m.p~;md ~~f:lIIhle.d. ~~d:.~,-aMJ.IlIled.