2011 1 amy 99 \\ yma nmin? mmnn AID OW PTA NYT NINN 1 WARY AND 1399 Ne, TN SRST AENY -Odwa MAMNA MME WINS IPTA BINNS OMANA OWA YA obs MBN Nw Jon93 Mya WI} 9992 WIA MNSWoNN AYPYTA DISS 8d THT APM OMI wan >pYA TPR en an MWATTA NRW AY ATW! NO TE Aa APRA AN WEY AWOINT AW riaba omdyn orpeyAdY ENSM HeAN IT Sy MeyAOND 1 pdr AVIA %3 Two Tada PMDYETN OMawMd AIM ANd WY PINS 9 NIAID WTONA 2 B>wA mands INNSW TAYPN) OTA MeN DraprAD PIN OIA IN (°60-M '5O-A ABW dV SN) by wbean ming psa Nb IAD , Ot TNA MBVIY orm OMpATD dia» wR 2dr (MUA peaina pwn pai o> Pe PoInD AT _ PW BY FAN Oa WEN Mya HWA ANA AID ym TaD NAA dv ADE AYPTD NSN AMO ASTIN APY APPT AT NWI TINY MIO YIM PERMIT AIDY IT 43796 by 2010 mvA THY WT NYPNY by Mbyan APY ATT MASP IANA OINNa NEVO AbYORA 2 8206 pn TYME ATP TANDa Tem AN EPSA IIA DW EMVA Pom Pavan P¥AD ANWD TO TIAA DYE SY MARI IPTA STD bY PHP _AN B_IVS WEB mM AIRY Ma 23 mystban_nySsbsm_AYAMANA mMbyM mwhinA TS SY MMM BWANA AbdIon aI yond252 AP! a WEA Now? OE ANY ANAND STAN SU Rho WNT AINA APN AV ARP DYTTTA PNW NOWA DA SY MbYAD NVPAND NIA AAT ANN qwA dy IMA ANYT POND IW ONY OMAN Jone MN NNSINW TaN NINN MSP OMT NWS IND OAINK AMINA’ a} ONN - OrPyAVD ANAT WT yeaa 92Y PAR TANNIN HD APTS SY IPT AV PTD BrHAa TWA bIPSAA bY wan THAT nawAD LmapN MITE SY OPTW BIdTh “Taba >PdN JOINT MONE MI OMwY yey MaIyEAdTIAAY Low-a sora sp me rinse 429 OECD -n mrt senate msn mare nnaven tee po Housing & Development Board (HDB) aio >v smar¥n wren man >¥ oKIn TAN OIMPS aM? Valter 8 900 99 1spp 712 Sv mwtn NOVA OP2WIN TID 5-2 OOdONDA WON MI ONTA OMN NswPE MDT NAPE, Paayn VN Thea FY MbOSIOA AYMAN MPAA AIAN NS AYMEADY 1965 MWA ATEWA Ie Wha WN ANDVSY .ANNN O27 AA YVAN BY THaNAy mMna ndvAKA ram Ps ow Pete APA IANS AMIE OW AVARY AYIA APPT AOA TAB ANN -TeNbI TNayd OOMINA Yana >ymaven AANA Tae SY SYTA APE_2 O39 ~P dy neSNN PIMONNAW ,PAP-n yodwA Mb|s (MPRA NOV) '6O-N1 'SO-A MMW SY NNT SNTW? HN TONY JOINS JPM MAN PS BON THY Daye WEAN wT AVITEA ANNA OMA WIOHPN IPA “Pan NS ,P9H] MMM MY? AMIN NAY Wyo mVAd 22 TOE WN INT | IMINSA AIA MINA SY _oNIEA AAW M»ANd TIME bY ~IMBRWA FMM (Park, 1998) M99 ATYMSa nomINA OS MNPY Ww by wws ,BMbyaa APTA PID a3 2D AUP NDIMNTDY (Asset) 2 TB ANT DOAN 1 yn ond MMIBY AAD AID? AN ye dY TIE? My NO TANT SY Mya? PT ANWID IN PPDETA-OTNOAA MUA WINNS MIND AYN NsIPEA MNDWPA-AAMINA AwAT mpaye2 ON MAM Mapy THD APHMa Na ToIPE NDN ,DdNN Ny waIP dv BPINENW Pan nx UND FBwaY OnNra ATA pIvA WWD "PPAR APNE AMMAN SAW BL YD MAMINA MAN nAYYEa "ISA PEM rwaINA PH ywoe SY NaRw. AN NEMS MA IEA PEN waIH MaI!A YD -joIMD APT PID ID NdVINE TIM SY NIBN WI MAYER IAA STD -TPAVINy IPT MND yam My p> 59 APHY wa NYS pdr APNEA MdyAD 7A (7596) TREIMED MYPIPA MAND SND. Paw 12W |FFPRPA yeTA ATID ANTID W GOIN Phang, 2001) ow 99 bw naPAd mAPIN BEENA orbyad >onoA WIA STA WIA AVA HaRPEA ANA EMV WIA NS ,ObwA Ny MIT) DNWwD sm an 72 “Tha Lot aN AmAD MBIA *yAd Sb9 TTA Wa NOB Yop dy MYoA YIN TIAIW ANT HANS mwtnn anpa aeinna rbyan (Housing & Development Board) HDB-A AMAA MYDPSA WIA mandy Soom DSVINN MIIBS WT NTN NPSOND ,'20-N ANON SW 6O-n MDW SNA | AANN ANNA dpm opin enna meson S22 bya yINS NaI pndwoeA Men TWIRy naEEN HDB AMET 2pr9n pw ONT201 OMIOW ,-rEDIN SymIa Adar V2Ra1 FAYMAA Nay ~ITPYA MENA abwe dpe Yeonn AMIS APTA pIva BIdVs MND OVENN SY ANY FbYOR HDB myveNs IPA AbYNAA ton aptan ayMDS AMA’ AYPIP MPIAA MA PI ATIN!A ATA -MWPIPA AN Sw Ordyan OA’ WpIAA Ts DW 99 SW FAIPAD NMOMINA AMbyAIY MYPIPA Ww DIN’ INT MD AND ADYSNY BND! PN BNI OY VIdYS ATTN) NDSA ITA ANT Mbapd ANA Naw Ody MPAA VAN PIT SY ApINA NY MND NN FAIA Yt MINN ,ABIOAR PAD bY ONIN oHddion as TS 3nd. DPD Pm MPD OYIPIaNY MANDI psd TM OYYBN OMK D9 (Pin Lee, 2002) »»79n PES siowres paw mmeNTA mynEA Ins Wow NpNN People’s Action Party-n * Publle -: mpnws mipspn mara simima arias Se THs mV AAAS MT! me WSN uN AN Synas ms AN HDB-n® fon avs eviit BN on EYpmive Qrinw na Reserve fst method -2 vsnvn> nn nvwnNn ones First seated bid auction w tender {in Lee, 2008) ave ye ano Mar MVM EE MNLSIY OYA Wn YS AN YY 2IMD bmope STD 9 mbsm oMPya ,mPIVA We OONSTA AN dan MW OPNIN TPE BIA 1D bb2 TTA TvT TNA JOP NIA S221 TESA IPTA WEE Pa NYVIvA PW ABW MPM mavAd IPT MoN|Y MNBVIE PATON IN ONY JAPA AawIN AeIEA Mya MADw> IMT INAS. AMAA AMA Pw .NePOvA PIA? AW aNd MTNA AMTA prea ATEN ManWANd gona “Park, 1998) MHPSA WTA ondwnm mprsd YD NIA Nw? HDB AMM IAB ANNI AMA waIBY (PAPA “YD OPIwA ATTA, PONDY Ata DAW "T2992 PANTY OATS aM pa AWONN AHN HDB ,nt pwA AAMT MENA (Phang, 2001)12ba mM TH3a ova DED SY MINE Mya WM wierd MY AMAW MENA pIEA NIA WypAA Ta AbvIEAA SY ANA OMUNA NPYMEA *oD TNA, DN IVD) SyDAe MovIaRd WHEY BID A OBA Yo INNA BIND MEA TTA PWR WD MNPoY DIY SY TVD OMMYTA APIA MN Ta MSA Wanw Jad War oMAA MyaA AY Central Provident -n 1 sbwienn naina nme Np pa> HOB pa nwo gIMW MD NIN At Be OND YAP AIA AWAIT pore 7 (Park, 1998) -MaPEN WT Dan OVA wsOND NVAWAW (CPF Fund AIT Mia’ OMMADEAS O37 WAND ANN MAES AYTRS OM>aPRD MWA -AdvIDA MOAN inna APY 2A MENMN yOMED HDB SW npbN ,CPF TY> “ondw MMEN NENA AN Tay aD yao nviIn HDB APIA MVa TweN2 ANSE AAW DUA OrPPENA $95 qeMA ANY -MIANMDVAN AMAA TATA WEN ATTEAw! MAME PEON) MBSA I MAIWeN pIW dy AVA YIN 25..0n og —PAA TINAN ASIA AVIA TAPIA “wD 80-9099 SY SS> TTA “Taw NawwEN TID WN FADE ONAN *v2 599 TD Naw |CPEA Mab dyn 0.0195-5 yapH HDB-A Sw MAMA ra me SPxana minbAY AD HDB .waeMEN AMPYE NN posh 7 .cPMNoINN OrpIAA SY MNNIDvA SY MAPA (McCarthy et al.,) meayan ns AN AYIA TD ANT MNMDvON WANE MEIN AbYBEAE OND FUND] *pINA @ NON COND ONIN NMS hea PT A WN MPT woNd rNdUMIEA YMA 2001 *,$60,000-5 ypand OPV OsyIwA TNVTA PIA IN HDB-n NW Awan AT) Fan Sy PRY INNA DYaVAN YoY NMSA ABOMNER ANN OTA IMD YAR MwA Maw HDB Sy nyTasA AMTA PN| sOMNAA YONA APY? MaWNAD OB NOPD *Pd ANA WA oMNA wrod wor man ‘pw ddoe 90% MADDY MvATb MADNED NAT nan PUD SY MYMIBBA nOITe OND SUA WAT A!TN EVAN 4 NPT WITS HIP TaN UDB 7096-1 "THIW "PY AMYT PIR OMAN 3. (2001 ov) be any any ymis nay ars aM AmrOvTA MBDA NaNPEDW THAIY wy EOIN avAN BANA SNAWNE MUNBWAN BPRS Hon BHT Ys oon 200829 nan) naes mWNaNN FEN RaANN AN TYP 9E10% MaWNe AMOR IOP NN WAAR BraYna TAM TIEN NE SNA THN” Urban Redevelopment -n 5¥ sein ann sense reson MID TTY HISD Nase MBMw MVTHA MTAD Tes o39 MO favraa ann sins» ssn Yauven ranan 73W=> HDB =n as son a Mawoe Autharty tpn ura. gov 69 UURA-m ans mio? im.rnanvo D9 man? ‘retin ura ge 59MO MIBPEA ITA YI AIA PIV dy ADU nD AMID’ TAME NOPD AAW MHD-A AYIA NMBD (Executive )ymbmman sme nbs PY omens NIN MWIND PSI NPBAPT OWA THN? nev MANNA Tye AMT NooEN bY ind Taw NeMT AT DW IER vad condominiums EC Sima mpP mad ayn vipa AN INN TR Wee! Mw ANAS NNN “A ,PANWAN MEAT namin maty 9 DANA AIT OPO .rMIAN bY OM PNA MOY AB AN WAS’ ND MW THD PoNIA nyiad avn a PAA YENI PWwA MPP ANH TAUN vAPIAd YD AND “WY ,7oISA WePEM HDB SY sayay nyyPAT ANT nda TWA Ama TWA HDB-N Sv mMMeR MEI I TMA MAND ys MINDY, 3p -AAMS AN ANY ON > ,NBV_Nd MAbYADN MBTWaNY noe INP APIPIMS TMB ;MAMONPAN dD AWN AAT wT Sed sHayd DUTT OF DapHA BON ,$40,0005¥ >ndwnn PrN OWN OND WA wins IMA Tab NOL OW wen TwHd ODA I MEPNAM Ae MPA Mrs DY>sI2 Ww NIN Nvanvt (Pin Lee, 2002) manana NAPW HDB -2 ANT Paya Wars Owe BN YD w2.Md 12s INNSY oy Penn HDB 12v JOINA NoR NTA BINna onbwIB|A yA DY APRA NN wonA Abow noPD Papin MTB TINT Sv Om INIEN AMbY WNS— MONE“ TMOENTAY -MIMNNA ws WTA AND wy yan pw SY OrAYDI OWA IDA WH HN OWS NB_PA NID AY ID MMyBVA AD yopn2 MUP? HDB 725 MYR. OVA TNS AND ANY MIAME NNT PTA woo" {br Sdwa owed JDAW DODD SY >a "Sb OMAMAN NAIA OTN 1-3 NTT NMA SY AP_IA Hos" ,OAYAD Orr Spe TWN SERA NAN APM AVE AMT INNS ANWON? OMY? OND wBNAD VIPM Yow (Phang, 2001) JOP ANDY PIT HONE TNA At -NDNOME gn WN MOEA ITA STs HVS NA PIwA NINDS AYIA AIP AND aMbsban APIA Nb "PS OPN IMPS OvrAA Ya Oh Pmbsne OW PI On ne neiby nie amp O2017b “PAID WN NBA IwTA MAM TPAbYODA AIDA Ed AMA porBA WE 2 by UMD nas EPA YPDIOR NDNA MOE -NWEYAA PrN AN Td ANwENA Yap ANA Pt pw MMANNOA MPATINA 9933 OND IMIN NWN 7291 23" OSB PNAS MrAMOA TINA Pon >P dy won OYDD JOINA OrDYD Y";RA PA MANA TN wD MNMIVEA PY rpNUA MANNA by APH Ta” MASA DYN MNT NM paIN wIBA PEA WN ,orNdvIND etna OrEsN EeNEAYpA PowAN SY MAYA I TINS -THVD Day ON PAC’ .OyNE NENA Tye wNTSTIAA 3 STAN TRY PyA WON onban dia Sy PAY YPN Tb AMIN YoND Me ANE on OTPY DPeDIn TY bY TEV’ ANONY APIA MUdSMNA NMby ayes APTA AONE ANDYNA NomIA AYIA mrpand nvyD AbyMen WA TNT paey MoMA BWI ANN *bya AYA dy pAb TaD > paw Tab!y nbwaNN AN MOND T AMIN .crpMan nydy bua PREM Nd NIA DUA TOD yama onda INA SNPY “PAYA APEIINA SypN ANIA aIA NYP IPA YA NIV ANT PIA ON ,PePEaION Ma AN aw aw DAS AbwnN by MINa NADAY WIN AIA NBOD MbYS 4Spy nx DeTanb YN FbvINNA TID ANSIND “P 2wenB OMNI M9 bY OVD) “PeRDAb YONN NVA shar Mow TAB APT YIM AMAA WSpHA SM IA pon “AWS pordnd IW AY MASA yaya “HERON PYAR AN }2bd dy Ph) nbwABA|ypAA Any APIA AYIA VTP MM navn Pman MEN oMDsA IVT BAYPS Bape OM>TAW IWIN MN dSyaATY Ndw TYP =MOMENN sd D7 nenae yes WHA psqYA Edwa OME OND MNADD AOD APNY ,CIMPVA ND AMIDA UND NDINDDA MAP ANT TAY ,OAw>A OMIN bo SY MPN ARNT PI OA AMAA DIVE ATA *omappn UN-HABITAT Scroll of Honor-n p19 HDB-> payin 2010-2, So nY2"ETE AMOWeN -AEIN TEIN APT TS INA YH» PIN dw aid wW EB MDIMEA STEN INS. NAPE w2 MVP MPT IY ABN Nov AVS AADIEAY "NN JM MBWIM APBNMT Job any Syn may PEA pa MVITY OMNTDA ATAY PW MVE AMOI OY mde AMT Dv ern STi vind vRTT TINA WIN Nad THe bY OM TAMA MIMONDY AAAWA AN gINd 7 oemmann emnien AN AMR YM OANA INN D'sT NyIpH WAY OW? onda IME Oran BbI AIAN, pind bro? HaaP!A ITA Ses ANY $247 MIDI API MVENRY ,WIPIOT Non MBIA NOWAM panna ANDAN|A a"AWA AIA ON - PYM THD MAA DTS MIN|A 23d IN NINO ANAWAD IPD UPD_IOWA ATA OND ,AAVIND PIE Narn ADTEAY OMBYIN pawwA AN TIA’ AIBA MAP gpg MOIPOA STAY Oro7 bY NPOMPAA NPR NPNa|a rw. “Pd ANIA Pay AYAWD AyD AAV NID NSW NBD -OANA D3 by ~IPIEAN YIN TOW TAN IT STI ww? ONT Jam» .|B|I NEMIOM! PHIOND 9NA Svs AyD NS ID MA WOINA PIA NIN eT MP bY OVD ND TT Dine ANN SAMY m>AB AE WN NENW 72 9 YM SNS WIA PIA OPE TY Ayan NPMTY 09 Sy Brdyia Dyapeay MEMEN STAD AN AON SY ONT! NI wD ,J95) Tad vwTBA Pren by DOMAN bo dw mengipes nDNA jpHN ND pqyba1 TTA prAA TIDY FOMNSW PNW ONO NN DT NYDN DY AMbY now ADIN AaYOA -WareRAIA MPAA TINA ONA AT AYN Tbs AWE AYMNS mnaA AX AYE AINSI AYMTSN vA MAO’ MENwE TMNT MAW ;B»MTaIN OAM DOAYPN Jay OMEN IPT ANT TIAN APTA 92 IN TIPO SRW ONT APT AYETA Sv IWAN AAPA OIA nova AA mS TMDA SSW IED AWEYPP Wd a WYNN NA Y2r aVIN Tay TO nt MWA prpa2 THYY oA OWA AN napwR NON’ AAA “Tade PVA TID) DIN MMA Noe MPMI MIDdvA Span WWRA BY NAAN APNVE NPawAT MI MERA Ne NAN WN AAWAA NAN sMAbwERA APIMAA SePoPAN MNT AYIA AVINAD hip: nd. gow =oRAW AISMNO ZO xe ass yn Frown ora 7,730 5,076 " ‘ovabwa Bare Fiz Tena nee 1s 18 8) 29,500 57,200 2 Gy voH aH, M302 “arg ore 2010 ys"? CIA-n aww 20105 7199 hilps we ela.govitbearylpublieationsthe-worldfactboaklindex hina 208 yo" 2o08-> 92937 35 "SSN Fa PUB STD RYToN AAA 9 7 % “rmowsomn Toe 697 935 neta mein sa ped awd ° 40% yreny myvin Ss Ten 2010 mova nabwrn 776 aN Dae mos 7716 (map romano 715.95 097m 200 p21"? 2008 ya? | Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland-n ans z007-> n> http://www. dastatis de/etepesciporta/ems/Sites/destatis/nternevEN/Cortend/Statstice/nternationaloe/intornationalStatistos/T ‘opieTables/BacisData..HousingExp templatele-render rine pomifankerAcia 200s oy Department of Statice Singapote-n ans rns tps /waw singstat gov.colpubnireterence/mdcaprt pdf 2010-5 pay” orworooe> mionsn naan 2008 pewonie TPB? nip: sw cbs gov eensus/cense/pnim_ page. htmPidtopie=12 7myn Housing & Development Board (HDB) naane by ™asA ITA MANSY wEIAINNA © sihttp://www.hdb.gov.sg Urban Redevelopment Authority Sv x2vaAAANA # ¢http://www.ura.gov.sg, Cin ov mvnaraNA © httos://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/index.html Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland-nanN httpy//www.destatis.de/jetspeed/portal/cms/Sites/destatis/internet/EN/Content/Statistics/Int ‘enderPr ernationales/InternationalStatistics/Topic/Tables/BasicData__HousingExp,templatel int.psmi#AnkerAsia Departmentof Statistics Singapore-nanN ¢ http://www.singstat.gov.sg/pubn/reference/mdsapr11.pdf PP YEWYES MIayEA NavdA 2008 POINT TPIS & http://www..cbs.gov.il/census/census/pnimi_page.html?id_topic=12 ‘+ Park, Bae-Gyoon. Where Do Tigers Sleep at Night? The State's Role in Housing Policy in South Korea and Singapore, Economic Geography, Vol.74, No.3, 1998, pp.272-288, * Phang, Sock-Yong. Housing Policy, Wealth Formation and the Singapore Economy, Housing Studies, Vol.16, No.4, 443-459, 2001. © Pin Lee, Yean. Determinants of Singapore Residential Land Value, Master Thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 2002. ‘* McCarthy, David, Mitchell, Olivia S. Piggiott, John. Asset Rich and Cash Poor: Retirement Provision and Housing Policy in Singapore, Pension Research Council Working Paper, Wharton school of the University of Pennsylvania, 2001.