..

" 'I!

·T.hat, let 'Ci,tEOll Ob.s.ez:ved tha.t tJ;,..It; v",ic.t im. bad, 9.Glve:'al 1t . !':b.r:,o~n bQfieil i'n :tal,t:b ,l"eqs' and!' had sc'ra.tchee an'd. l.'II,·c~xat·ions· tJO ~i8 up.pel" ·bcd.y ·and ·f,ace... 'EbG! vi"cti.m, 'wa,s wearing ,it ~,~it :j,a,e:ket f $.h,irt and. :swea;tah1~t ~. Kis. pant $ ,B'nd undl'.:nteax" weI" ~ 8J:oO,Md. bi a: le:f't. ank.llB nte 'V,iet,1m' s
·t'ha.t o.f ;i,nj urias an, a.utomob~le:~

6~;. fi.. 6'1.1,1.'"'' 9t,

i:nj~·r.i-;s _.a.ppea.z:'ed ·to J)et .._C'artoll

received

f'rom. ,s,ameone

to

~~. 'consiet:.en·t
be'1;ng' stl'Uc:k.

Ii

wi til

'k1t,b.

8:

ii,

The, Ta:r.x:ant. County

iI'

1dten:t1.fied 8116/14 ~

the

H.adical. :B~Ui1IDi'Re:rt's Offitce' pc:isi.tlv\etl·~ viet.im a·s IGl:G!ili 'Gl,e.nn !;j,'gg,5, W..M...
II'

.SL. 'i'M,t an accld.en't SQiB(ne ita. toun.d ne·:it' the location of 1;5";1'9:"" body.. '!'t 'wa.s·.be,lle·ve.d s t.~at. Big95 bad breen, st,I'Uic.k R't tib.a,t .lo.ca:tion and. t'he,n. e·a:r,riedl :to the place W'he.'.:c:ehe 'hId been, fQ'\md. ::0 that a w,reckel:' could pUll 1, a v·' h1cle ,f.ro· •. dl teb a.t, the a=c1d.ent. si.te. ·wi"tbo,u,'t. seeing the body.
1(11@

Medl,e.l b:amlne:r S 'Of'flee t'hoat the .r$a,\llt· a.f· b-'·.q 'h.1t. by an. au,t"cmOb11e'j
r

That an. Sundla.Y.I; 10/2;9/01.,

De·t;.

Ca.rr.oll learned.

t.he' v:iJetilrn had: di!td as ·a,

ft'Olii

1.1..

OIl

Monda.y ~ :J!O/lo.lO'l, ,put: ~ffiant~ .Det.. D··.'1 - OWING"S~ :I'D., 21'19f fWPD TXllffic ·Inv&.s:tigat.io·n Uni;t.; ,raee,l.ved, ,a c·a,l.!. t.I:'~ be't.. Ca['~ol.:l ,ad"i.s.:j·ng· me, ,Of" t.~e detai,ls ,of tni 6
of.hnse..

c;c'ime ,·cene ".

.I ,di,d. :mee~t wi:th Det,~ (:1.:'1:.0.11, and. we 'Wfl'n;t t.o t,bia

12,~

Tb.at 'Q,PQl1 I'GY1ewing' the f Gets and' Ge't,a,:£.ls of' ·th1;s off~'n.,e - and vlew.ing th.e pa.o.tos~, 1. obSHV8d that. ·th.e vi,ctim IppLtal'ed _ee haye; ceen 1\)'in,;. o:n his, f,a ce fo.~ a .p,e'ri,od 'o,:f' ·t;,i:me t.ha·t a,llOffed the blood to' set:tle ee aU'8,S on. the f ron·t Q£' tb,e, vi.~·~im," ,s: bed,), ,~,
'That

1.3..

based on 't'his info,mat·1o:n. i·t appel.red that 'the ·vi,ttim. had tleern, !rt::ruek at a loeB t i,on othe 1" tha,r.'J; Cobb P',ark 'Dr.. and 'l~h.en t:ranspo,rted t.o· t.b.-· 1.oca,tioD w1lel'e t:te
wal dlscCiVS'l:'eci. ,I
Un:li..'t WQuld take

1,4:~

aori'lerj

'Det. 'I!

Ca.:tr-o,11 tha.t
OIVlU:'

at 't,hls tim ••

'the i.n,~':.Ij't i,ga.t,ion. 'of thi,s' ~ f.f'Elns e

II:h8'

T~:Qft.~c

I:~'VG~ t it'A't,;L:QlA
16

15

cO,

n=tl

res.~a.tched and found a.n offen,se'" : ,1011'S(UJ.2S'II'that. ,1n\lo, _.'v·ed_ and. asaa:u1t and. an. accident tMt bad oc.'culC':t::'ed in t·t:Lte (I a blc·c.k of' Cobb P,a,r;.k Dr .. 2:8
i'

1013 Oi/,Ol

.1

. 6.. 1

,B,5.ggs~

That ·thi s ,&:celdeflft

'W8$ not, 1n,voJlved

.in 'the ,death ,of

IG~eg'

1"]' .,

[On 1.1/[6Il01.,

Medical. Exami:n.e,r·for Ta.r.rant Co~nt:.y .. ,D):' P'eerw:a ni. ad'vised .,'" tha t, he dld Obs;&%ve:he· le'vidl ty' in tbe viet,1m" s 'body and t that the vi,ctim had, bee,n lyl:n.9 ,face, down fo,£ IH3ne t. £ me: priolJ:' ·to, his' 'having been .found Ion hi,s bae:k .. . . .
:1, Icontacted. the [Chief

Dr.t Peerwan if

, -.9·'1

...

'Tnat

Dd.gbt ha:ve

-t .~ .'io.~'l·.... '~'~k 8. :rue.' 'W]I I,,,", ".ft

.1

w·a:s furthe:r'
))e = n
",Ii!

..

'

d:a;'ge.d.

. ~ 9, _an· ., .~' ~ d' .. wa S. ··:t·, dl" .n,g up an"

I

ad.vised. t:h.a:t. _tbe _ v.i,ct1m had

'1.._ ....1 Ik&~

~~k" rra:r. ,8
'

,.~ ., ,liII,e a:SI 'if~ ...

be,n

19 ~, 'fha:t 1 e;Kpla ined ,to Dr ~ l:leJIIIrw'sn50 the locat. i ern. where ·v·J..ct1m bad beeu dl.scover.edl and he: a,greed that wh'e::rEl: 'll ict1m. w'as i'ounel tDa.L the speed 1,ndica.ted by vilct,:L.m;',$. .i.njur1e,s· [ccul,d no,t. have be.en atta.1ned .in a re··a wh,ere tbe viet im wa s :found;o
20 ..
[Tbiillt 'D.r. p\E!:8:tw,ani did .ao:[·ee! 'tha t. "the

tb e

·the:
·t~' 'the

v.ict Un, a;P'Pe.. l',e[Q, to a :h8v·e .be·en struck ,at a di.f·.fe·,lti,·,ent l·Qci.tion land ·tr,ans·porced "to 'the .locatigft w[here 'ne wa,s found",
On",
1,

f··,~·om,··-· D,·_·t·, C'a·"""::.:: .....l, that s;omeone had calJ.red 't;he T,al'~ant [County' cSh~r.lff' S,[olff,ice s:t·a, t1:n.g ·tlta t. the y had. .i.nformat i,Q,n abou t t.ne' dr·1ver '0.£ the v.enic1[e. tha;t had srtrUCk ,and killied 1:b.e man fo~nd .i'n. Cohb "ar'k.•
'

2·':'1'2. £.,/1(11". u~.

1
:' ,"_"

'¥IA,ii"!'·ei·vl&,.;3 '!illy
~I~~ I. ~

~_

-i:·n··f>,-A·¥1ii'I;a~·t· 1" 0'" .~.~~l

f' _

~II.

,rfi

..~

1.13

_,'

&.

1.'

['I"hat, I

·th.e r'e·~ide(nce at.

did. m,leet: w,!:th Mar·a.nda .Oa:niel

,aiM adv'i:sed

named S,han.t[rl,e, that

o.n
OJ:

38,40 H.il,b,a.rq,ez', ft" that thi s 1 th e· ,r.e·sidanee s·

and, w'as dt11!'ect'~ld t'Q

Q:f a - b,:lack ::femal.8'

Worth,

T,x.

'?lin.1SI

2'4,~

on

,2'1:2.5,}'[02,;1 met Iv,itib

n.Ol.ll:e

.e...bou-t s1x ,othe~ [g1.:r:)."

t;o decide
tbey

,;,bcut

2/:15/Q2"

'wi,tb. Ma.r·anda Daniel" s and she sta.ted

she

had, bee·:n at.

f:r'i·s!ndl'· s
Wli'X'te'

II!

2.5 ..

N'a:,r,anda

dr'ink.ing,.

start.ed that
'try{,nq

were
'WJ\'(JI

eb,,!y' all went out l,at,[e.r~

·tal'tin,;· and 8 ome ·was· go.ln." to dL'i,~

i

when.

26.

Mat:nda a.dvise.d thill.t Ofte· [of' the 91,l:15';, 'Whom t{he: 'kJ\o,ws a,9 S'baQtae, a blaJck fema le [ap,p.rIOO'E:ima te.l'y ,2:3 yeats 0 f a,'ge" salld sae, ,c'ou.1dn' t d,;'J.,ve"" Ma randa as;kied he'r' why [and .Shan tae about ,bit,tin, a ~:n, w.ith. he"J:' [car ..

.27 ...

Tn t

,be·;·... ,to t.a.l k:

"bat.

SnalntM said, ;I'be was, on m~~ 'W'!):Y' b~e~ fro~, the u.oi"i!,s",-,_~.,.......;;;;,\.., ,iIi;,,""~,!!I; 'I'.'.~"'I_~ "-a"',di"'''' ' ,iIi;,..~S" "'---'. H-~f ... 1Ii~'I;I!,""~"Iiol,~ ..... i!!'; ¥ ':II~! 'IiiiII, "".......r.IlI, .....". ' ''''''~' 2" 11i Shantae:_ tben, $ta,t sd ,tnat a,s, ,she was ;1l!;,PPl:08,thinq the Vill age C:reek e:~it she hit, thi 5, w,b:1;t,lI, man '\'ii th he,~ e~:t:'. .
'!OIl .... "'""""", g>!,I'!iiiI,
,""",,,...Ii

"'~;!U:li

f111 1!;Ii ..

....

'I!'!I!!Ii:II" ...

iiI"ILipj;

'2'g

, -'.1.··.,

'tha:t Marantla· ',~dvlA;;ed' t~t ~:! ,hit, Ithis wbft,e man ..n

Shan ta'e_ gigg,l,ed

__

'whSTiI
_

sbe, :sa:id"
..

:3[0;, T'ha,t Shant ae $ta't eel 'th~t, sbe _w,as meil"red up, Q~ X pill s and wa,s dNnk.. She, advised 't.hae, 'wben, she, h£:t, the m:a:n; :she 'got 'Ica.~ed and that t,ll@ 'man was, st.1,ck1.n,g ha:lfwa,y

into the! passenge'~ cgpa:rtetnt th:rou,g'h

'garage"

'the w1n<l$hiel.d ~
CeU:

31..

'.1"1 ;:':2 .'

,Sbl.nta,e ,then, ::iJtated

:s:t.icking
intlQ le.a:v,j(,n.q tne

her CDr' ,and :pa~,ke.d. t'he man on, ,herr ear,!!

that

she drove to bet house

w~i;t;'h. the:

i'n.

ber

'wiant
he 33 ~

Sfia.nttae :!iJ't,a'ted t,ha,t 3.'he~ ,t'hen we'nit :Lnside~, had seo)C wi 'th, her boy,f,r ien,d. and. thei~l she ,and, he.I:.' bc;~f,:t,ien.d" 'Ter ~'a,nelet
CU.Il,ttc 'ella 'g,iiI!,;r:aqe Wai!i; id:y.1nq..

,a.,nd the

man Wa3n' 'to de·ad :yet" bu':t:;,

•

T'hat Sha;n,ta.'e st~'t,ed _that the :ma;n,'wa 5: askln9' them: to' help, h:Lm,~ lru"t t,na.'t, 't'he:Y' j U5 t WBi,'l'ked., bil}c'k it~ side ;; 'wh:i,eh 'was a CQ~le
Shal1,\tae: adv,is,Qd, tha,\t, they' of' days .. , 'wa£ ted

34 .'~ 'Tha t

'unt,:!l

he, ,diad"

3,S.

Tha t Sha'n ta8: t.hen t-ald them 'that. wllen tbe :ma:n, died" heX" boy,f,rfend, ''1'&'t",ra;nce',t.and hi~, bxothel: took, the body and
,dumped: i t 1;~ CObb :P.'a'~'k-

,3,6"

'park,

rna t Shant,ae did

hi.~ ,leqs

stA't~ t:ha t w~,en th'ey dUJ1\Pi!.d h1m i.n the, 'were all :brolioen ,aJnd. 'twi,sted, -up.

3'7~ ft\a,t :Milra;nQa ~old :me' t'hat tthe only ear 'tAa't Shanta,e has, ,is 8. go,Ld, c.olo~ed Che~rolet Cava 11e~ w1,th t''iIiO door.s and. t'Mt, S:'h.e ha,Q'b~i9£n in, ,tha,t vehicle twice 'b~fore,.
3'8.'

'when Siha;n,tae t.old them about 'M'~r~nda -,tha,t she 'h.ael :se.'e~,'the

Shlk:eltiha,.

Tha;t

'Ma,ra'nda further

a1:so kfiDW,i, a:s

,adv'.ioed "t;;,nat ,one o:f '!,'Ij}t!e ked',; 'who, \I·al

the man ea,r hi ttiR>g'~·,gi.:age',__ la the: , --,

ber f :i,e'ncis" al,go p,~e:5Ii.'n't

t;.old

3'9;.

Tat, Shake :t,t,l1a :s ~a,t.ed to M&:r;e.nda 'tba,t, S:he had :9,e u:tl, the 'man Ii' 8 bi,~ ,and, ha,i,r' sti,l,l, in, '~fh,e: roo:fline by the, 'v,i,soli:' ~ Shie al$Cl' said that 'tne: gara.ge ~uld the :b!OU,Si8 .s~lled. ,l:ea,l

ba;d",

'. '.
rlial.'t
I ,did Obtalin ,a, w'~',i;t:t}eFti. ,5ta,'t,~ent, f'rom DI,n 111311 vf;;;Z;:'i,fy,;Lngr the altaye: t"ct lEi: and d~ta,!ls.,
,~,

Mar:anda

'!I!I'I\;,.~;.. .ii,~~~~,1M

repo~t

V~~I

2/," 2'S"i"il2'"
_ . '_ ,._',.

VI

~.

'__

.~

~'11'1M;.'" 'AI - _lIIo;!!arqe,t .. :

1002041.3[9,
'

Z',ese:,~r,',c'h ,aM f'ind O;'i'iilll, ,~~_A ~·w -1-1 ''iI!II',_ .. _.Qi_ . .II,~~ 'VIUiM '1'\ .... ,,- ""'!a! '~ha,1:; l1,sted, a S~ante M&l..lar;~ at, ,31401
~~

.olio!: A

.l..

.11'

' __

'

..

t,hxou[gn the Aut 0' Trac'k ,~:yst[elt~ t'ba-t a Cha:n. t,e ,3J " Ha.l,lard~, :31.4 w.i lbarge',1: 'I it,;, ~Io~th., TG,KaS, did haw ,C,l 0 '151'97 CifruQv~let Ca''V':a.l:t.,er' regl'isu'md. 'ito 'ttet,. I,ionae' n~er. 'YXD5,5'H ,;,
,A, 8ubs@quen,t;

I s.lso f('J,und

Ch,ante JI' .., :Ma..llat'd; 'SIr dai,t'e Q'f bli,:r;tn 6/2,2./7 (;. did 'have ,j!, Y2I,1l:d, T:8Ma~ :tJ.r:l v,e:r.~' Lice'RS0 s :1;)[,511:~!'4::'O"- w'1'th ,8'riJ
II

,check,

i:'Or a, d%,,;t -e:r; v

,$,

l.icen,s'EiI' Ei=veaLed 'that.

'I<

ad'dt'iE,!:s:s [of' 3:8:,4: '1'11b:argreE' 0 Tbat

St, '.'" :Ft ,., 'H~r.t'h,t 1): ,," "6119

4,,$.,

on, :2./"1. 0:2" :I dl.d. cQnt,act t.he T@Xia:s DI!I,parb'rvent o.f 51 fublic Sa,f',e~t,y ,ama did, ha,v·e a Dr i,ve:r" ,S L:1e.enS[El, phclt;o of Cban,t,e. ,:},'.,'Hal1a:;r:d" :BI.F 6/22/'1 6,; f,lal;ned t,Q m.>e ~ I!'
1

,jiI[a'

~!11 ~

'know;s

ident.i,fy'

T'M'I: r:1ft '2l2:S1a2, a't, '1:1),8, 'hoU,r"s"" Ma~ anda 'Oanle 1, did come t.o :tlr4Y' off lc-'e a't 11 G0 Na,shv 1l.1e ~ She: did p:osi t:iIt'ely
t,p-e :phO''tiO as that.

the gold. Cb.ev,ro.l'Eft Ca,val,i.'e:r wh.Q teld her ,that sbe hi-t, a whl te '~i!.non Hwy' 2~ 11 8 ;;

1.8'

Sha:n:t.,a;e, '''''ho

of

li,\t<i!)$

,iI,t

,s,ame, pa,J:;slcn who sb.e, 3:8 4J 0 Wi,l'ba:~g'@,x: ,a'nd, ,(tWM; ,and 't,h:ai't, ,it is: tbe pet',SM t'h,e

Thl!ll,t, Mla.ril'Dda t'urtblil,r started t,'hat, ~h,e believes the, a'bov,e veh:ji,ele' 'to ,~t.ill.l _,be in 't,he 'ga.rage of' ,3,8:,~, Wi,l'ba:fqer 0, rbls' is, d,\1ie 't,o, 'the~ ,f.ae,t the:t Sha'~,ter-e :had told. her· I'nd
,0;

t'he ,ot'h,el:$ tha;t $:he: 'w,as qain,g tc i,itllee:me 'tax e'hee'k: an.d then bu:rn ano,t'h_[er.' cal" ~ !'bs t ,on 2/26/0,2:" ':[ had, sea~ch i'n~¢i ~:f~ec;t 'by'. J~'e l:eS idenee ,at 384 " ~\i lba'3: ;er
s'ilgn~d.
I

'w,ait, 'unt.il abe gOit :h,ii!'J: th@ enev rolet, and, ,br111,Y n,WTibe:r 12 ~~S"'1,S"Si"'02: to. _ .sea_~eh, tbe geld ClheV'rQ1E!:t 't:~3 sue'; .

48, ..

wa;rrant

,C.Y~ii ~;r" a'M ev1deno~-'~u,~b'-,a5 hair,~,

E:''IidenC'e ~,

Gon;zna,le::z f at' the

f1ber;' -

't,i'a,~e:

49,~

On ,2/2.6/02, I' :!, did '!!Xle-cute ,the abG'v'e slea};:"il:;:fb Wlar,r.aJ:f;I,t. and, 'w-hell I: kin.c;lcbet ,on the doctt Of ,39;,4 I) Wil'bi,~get, Che nte J.~ Miil-la,~d. (ii,d ,com 't,o" 'tbe d,eo,): and did. ~d.n.'t,fy :h~':~!Melf: i
as Chant.a Mia llar-d '",

50.,

Upon ente.x'lt'!L9
,!;emoved .. ,

1 EH91 'Cnev.t'olet, C<av,aller ~, 'Th~: 'windshield ilnd, ~,ea: g,las:s wets, broken Olll,t and 'the ,s.@atiS and. in:t:.. e'r1,c,:t: had .been

the: ,gar,~,qlf1 o'f' th,e

l:e-sild(;!:fl,Qi;I",

t'

f'QUrlct

~I

5:1

'II'

,%

S!'tains Chevro,let, ~

observed

'tha,t 'tber.If!!' 'Wet'e' what a.ppe8!~d 'to be, dil:rk on, 'th~ f'lQc',r by' 'it,be rigb't' ,s;idle,~, Wle'.st'!iI' - ,o,f' tbe:

,5,2,.,

I did I~lll. crime scene and i'O'Iensic: ;pe:I'scMel :f:t,om, the Tar,t::ant - Coun.t,y~ :M:ed:i.lc~l :Bxa:ftl~e~1 ,5; Offii'ce 'to p:r:ocesa 'the
Tnat,

along w'1'th

Cha:n,te

M'alla,r:d.

lI),G,t ~

a.

MI

J,c'~n!soriJ.' '

;(lltd 'go, w;i't:h.

;rn~

''tic ,1,'],,00 Nla,sbtv.ill:e

.-cet,\u::nl·I!ig' fr,om, "J@o' S B~Oi :~,l1cll,t'w'() diri'n,ks" :but :fe!l t tu_nny, .1i ~,8
,tiel::!,

Ths't Chan:tle d.i.d, 't6~1 'M

iShe

'ti,na t 'on Friday"

ihe!: sc:ms't,n:ii.,n,g.~

1.0 /26102" th~t Club ,and bad onl:~t 8~O~' hael $1 ipped.
1

.l,on, C'U"", f'tam B ~ :Loc;p :8r2'O to _lh~,Y.. 21'i' Ii she struck a man .",1th herr Jl.'9"1' Cbe,v,t'O.let Ca'va,l lier,~
56,.
'f.h.at Chio'nte' ,s.ta,too tha't tbo' n-..an :1:h0 hit, C'aEIe pa:;t t..laliY' .1rrt·o the pa:&,91engil:r. oom.,pa,rtme:nt: ,on tha paSS'fU!lgar sldo of

'Inil t Chant,Q fn;rt;he'J:

u'vj,sed

tba t when.

SM, 'was ,on, the

'till., 'w,lIMsh,ie:ld;; T,h,;:t, Chan,te

•

"d,vi.sed 'tha't $he' W~$, :$!:und ar"d: kGp,t dr,:!v i:n,g' ·t.o her: ,~e_s,1d1en,c _,at, 3'8·4]'0 'N,11ba,l\g'e1r and pull,cd .. ,int;o igraz'qe a'nd...low~n:ed, ·t;hIQ d(li()\t '•

tne:

't:hat erUi' ~a't 'tbe:=:iQ' an,d, Qf,,1ed: and. kept tell! i:ng' the will tel_ M,lle: that, 'Wo.l: st.lc.k:.lng' thZ:'ClUqh ,h-ar 'W'in,dsbleld tna,t she w~a:8 so,ri'Y,.. ·She said tbat tbe~ man, 'Nould. I'ea:pond tiO; heE', _hu;!;, $'b,G ;~ou,ld not he a: w'hat he' W'i!irS

~,ha.t Chant. sta;t;e.d

sa"ring ,",

"

'!bat, C'tlap,t,f!: sta'ted,

,1y'lng in the .ki tetlen 'floor ,ana c,r:yinq ,.n,d _ WQul,(Il,_ ,,0 b'aiC!k ,cut; ·and 't,911 tdtt'Qi ma;n, ,s'be w:as: Borr.y'" but sbe' ,aov1.sled, tbat, t'he, mB,n w;aa ., ust, :mo:arnln,f '.,
N'ent, w,!lS

she'

,in1:'O, tbi8. hO\\sl1!l and

kep,t, ;goingr ·the man ,:elne 'wlas, :slio'r::.::y..

t,ook, 'the :mao 'toi dil,.

Thl. t Chante

in and

she QUl.t g'Oing oot

Gilt Of 'the, ;gara"e tell iDq Sine: d.oe,,~, Dot know brOWlon,; 1t
i,'I1'tO ,the 'ga1:'&98,~

That C!hante calle,d. a man, n~sd '~a~ghn"'1 who C'aIUe ¢rV~r ·ana Ga,w wha,t had happenied! and 'then took Chainl,te t,o, a f,ri'and" 8, hous,e and to,}d, DmZ': he bad tiC 'til,ke care 'of

so.met~in9'..
Cihan'te

~hat

'C--, t-.... .n:"'6'jI' rQI' ~I .....'iI..,'.... ..!I!I"',.... e ~-~:Jl.g

untIl

e,i,tha,r

l!tdiv'l:s·ad
la,tlQ
'ii'
f· -', .... ;b;o;;;., .: .~.,~i~!I!&y
•• :hl!"

't,'hat Fr.ida,y·

9.

A 1,lUlI.!Iiiiiil!!~

Ib.,-~.'.a

or; Sat.Qrday'
Ii!

sh.e d5.d Dent, s,e@' 'V:.augbn aga,in when he :c'a:!l\e Ov,'t:r

~l

.,ta ted t'ba.t ·VOiU,h.a ba.d! iJ r..~h,ljj:r :n'!an wi 1;:;1\ h Sim .'ffd .;hI! a3kild hm ,~t sh.e [!!Iibou'ld. do and ~a.u;M. to-,ld. he~r~, 'IjioIDQn'" t ~O~~1 ·about l~ ~ t. ·took ca~ 01' it.~'~ That. Chante 'tlh9n a$ll~@d. VI.WiQ"bn .1f the .m,'n Neli!!! d.OW'll·H t.ir: s In. the caE ,a,Dd .he 'I:)old '.MI', ...'':Ao~ Dor.:'t '''or'.!!:,' ,about, ,it,,'~ ' That, Cnante ,lunda,,. ,~,

T.h~t.. CJulin'tJ8

look

Ithat sh,@ did :0.0""= 90' ba,cl( home unt:i 3L was another day ,1)1:: 'tw.o umt,11, =h:~:,could in, tbe gail,ale and :fOi1md 't~Ji,I, the ,ma~ 'Ka~ 9OI\C',j It
advi's.;<i
t;b;at,

.:h!tl1 had t.ftkTen 'the, ~e..t I!: o~t O'f the: CIJ: ~1ld, had. bu~MJ. o.:nC!' o,:!: the ,~~a,':tl becau,'e, Gn!:' wa,:a ,.fraid, :shu wodd 'gQ; to J-Il1 ~ that
~..., .Jli!ll ~Q~~

rut, Chant~ a:tatedi

,Il ~1U.rm!d =a,r !I.lrs''; '~'aS :!'o1flnn ln, the: bKk fiJi.!"~ ....,~ ,1I!"l!iI...... ,.. ' .... "i!t!Ii' v~'t.... ,...,... ~1100. ..... "," eo'~~'" In,~~u~~~~~ ~lrldWc'l.~1 ·__ ~ .. I' 1~"1~~~1'~~~1
Q.!I;;~'~'I!!'

:ral:d of

61 .. Th.a.t: Chan,te !J.' Ma llQOO did

'UAri.fyin9' th-

ribo".

filct!l

.~d de·tall s"

f;'ozt

g!.""

;:'M!

a 'wr:t tt4!Jflj, 19't,a,t.em.nt

'!,hat;; on :Konday,,' 'M.:eh 'i!I ,', tlite IChi@.f MctdiJC!l E~ine.t'

210121 'I 'r.te:t w1th, k'~ hB::t'W'GJr:d""

!'al:'I:'an,'t,

t:eviewcd
.,Ii, __

pct;fcm.e:d

'th.e

¢'ha aurtoplY' oa 1G'r:e'lJ S1lg~:~

.iIii

a;,ueop:sy' ,r-ePQ;tt ha . h;;ld dt etarteci

~ltr;JII'!iili

Cc\lnt,y'",

'When be
- "'"""", ....

B.,

He~

""~h'''''. -D' - '" L'W,"A,.r~o!IIl""'l ''''d' \I't e.ol II'!''I!!'' -, ~ ...... Ilj v4!di ~'\o,F ._,~ I'.... ~, ~~ ~._ ,;iii,,,,"' _ I,;! 'I!i:I_il-!: 18'1' ii'i\t"V 'k!liioillil _ .Ll!!?JI:5. 1[:(1J1;~,1'pl'& in,jUI%, i~' as a l\~=-'!.ilt of ha'Vlnt b~efi .tnl:ct by a
-

v'Jih;~,c.le.,

..,i'!li I'{. !I.,~

';~'~:,f::!,t a Bt::f:e:~::;i·:~v,(:~'~'::,~:i'd~9~:r;a~:: 't:!d traua,~

-

1l"I3,j or

il1at

th.e' dc,e~

Gltated t,'h,lt tM' hea:r1;:, had no t:ra~.. bloed, yeB:~i'l danialgli ..

;it!u", ~I!:I""'''' .... u; '" .. lkil;.-<jii

or

"3·~

i!f.b~,t :Dz',;, iEJe.Z!W'i!iiri/'i __ . _ _ _ "'" __ Ji;

no ,evidence o:f' t~irWna arnd

:"~,"',;iIiiI-'" ~:'!!!' l,;Q!V\,!I

n,Q Do:n,y f=Q~,t:Iil't'e'81' 'llO<J:' W~i th.:t'Q liII"ldeoo~ to QOntu.'l'on~ he:aor1:hat9.'@~ 'or ::in.'ju~,y eo tne br.allD'I'

'tlita',t'

,t:b;Q scalp' coni;.u3.i,',ona . h~d.

'ec~lud!1;

'P~~_~.'. ",",!Jly 10

t'~A, I!i!,'s,

1,

.- ...... ii'i\1I!ii UU':;I!'QI

.'Iio;,'~€!d !IiO!'U~-~ __ ~

Thaft, Dr.
$'plftn
;0,

!!

tr~WMlitie,

'Peeliwl,;,ni 9'tiill ':,Qir;1 ,that, tu~ u,und nO evid~nc:e ifl~"u~~y'''Ct), G:t:\tg 1 1;'51:' ki,dney's" a live,r,
1

e·£'
O~

dLed

'bilt

Dr ~ Pe1!,'Wani .t,ated 'lluie in bls opinion;

of' hemoz:rila.q!c
,;shoe.k f"rO'r;'l ,:f!'ac:t:Ure,g

Gr~' B1gqa

,iI!If:id,

bl.ed. tOo

1~1~~IlI~

................'h, '

HlmM.mRB" ::E: .t:equ.~t: that an ,a!!:'.cEi~t 'IrM.I;,ran.tIi 1::5·:11,1 e £~o: the ,:su~c.t h8~ ..,lnbefIQ~e de8:l".n.a'~d acco:l;dlng- ,to '::h.a, 1,Mr,is ot 'this Stare..
NI.maS

:my ~"igr.ab.l;t"e ~'m\is ~h.e, ISS" day ,et :UUCH, :2~lH:~2~

2,QQ:2 ..

,SU'BSlcrn:'s-'-'E!;D

Mel SWOFiN to '&'EFORE

',--< •~~i/-'~
1iih~~OF1E'DI5
~~.~

JijOOEe., C, -KJr'COO](E

:SE_NI-O~ ~iiU~IC'f~UOH,

)~~
.

..

~-=t ::rT1} rc.:

~..._
.

"