Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 187 views

    Holland-Pizzo Findings and Conclusions-Judge Vernoia 8-24-11

    Uploaded by

    Benjamin G. Kelsen
    Judge Vernoia's findings in Holland and Pizzo are in (on the subject of the State's substitution of the Control Co digital temperature device for the Ertco Hart device) Remember that the findings are not law, are not precedent, and are not a subject for judicial notice. In other words, they may be used as persuasive in other cases, but are not binding. While it is unlikely that the App Div will fail to adopt them ... until the App. Div adopts them, we are legally in no different position that before you read them. There will likely be briefs and oral argument further scheduled at the App Div before a final decision. That being said, of course, you may wish to plan now for where it is likely this will all end up now. In short, Judge Vernoia concluded : Conclusion ...this court finds the Control Company digital thermometer is comparable in all material respects to the Ertco-Hart digital thermometer previously used during the Alcotest calibration process. This court further finds that the Control Company certificate is facially valid and satisfies the requirements as a foundational document as required in A Chun. The court also rejects defendants' contention that the State had a burden to present evidence as to each of the elements required to prove NIST traceability.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content

    You might also like

    Holland-Pizzo Findings and Conclusions-Judge Vernoia 8-24-11

    Uploaded by

    Benjamin G. Kelsen
    187 views67 pages
    Judge Vernoia's findings in Holland and Pizzo are in (on the subject of the State's substitution of the Control Co digital temperature device for the Ertco Hart device) Remember that the findings are not law, are not precedent, and are not a subject for judicial notice. In other words, they may be used as persuasive in other cases, but are not binding. While it is unlikely that the App Div will fail to adopt them ... until the App. Div adopts them, we are legally in no different position that before you read them. There will likely be briefs and oral argument further scheduled at the App Div before a final decision. That being said, of course, you may wish to plan now for where it is likely this will all end up now. In short, Judge Vernoia concluded : Conclusion ...this court finds the Control Company digital thermometer is comparable in all material respects to the Ertco-Hart digital thermometer previously used during the Alcotest calibration process. This court further finds that the Control Company certificate is facially valid and satisfies the requirements as a foundational document as required in A Chun. The court also rejects defendants' contention that the State had a burden to present evidence as to each of the elements required to prove NIST traceability.

    Copyright

    © Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    Judge Vernoia's findings in Holland and Pizzo are in (on the subject of the State's substitution of the Control Co digital temperature device for the Ertco Hart device) Remember that the findings are not law, are not precedent, and are not a subject for judicial notice. In other words, they may be used as persuasive in other cases, but are not binding. While it is unlikely that the App Div will fail to adopt them ... until the App. Div adopts them, we are legally in no different position that before you read them. There will likely be briefs and oral argument further scheduled at the App Div before a final decision. That being said, of course, you may wish to plan now for where it is likely this will all end up now. In short, Judge Vernoia concluded : Conclusion ...this court finds the Control Company digital thermometer is comparable in all material respects to the Ertco-Hart digital thermometer previously used during the Alcotest calibration process. This court further finds that the Control Company certificate is facially valid and satisfies the requirements as a foundational document as required in A Chun. The court also rejects defendants' contention that the State had a burden to present evidence as to each of the elements required to prove NIST traceability.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    187 views67 pages

    Holland-Pizzo Findings and Conclusions-Judge Vernoia 8-24-11

    Uploaded by

    Benjamin G. Kelsen
    Judge Vernoia's findings in Holland and Pizzo are in (on the subject of the State's substitution of the Control Co digital temperature device for the Ertco Hart device) Remember that the findings are not law, are not precedent, and are not a subject for judicial notice. In other words, they may be used as persuasive in other cases, but are not binding. While it is unlikely that the App Div will fail to adopt them ... until the App. Div adopts them, we are legally in no different position that before you read them. There will likely be briefs and oral argument further scheduled at the App Div before a final decision. That being said, of course, you may wish to plan now for where it is likely this will all end up now. In short, Judge Vernoia concluded : Conclusion ...this court finds the Control Company digital thermometer is comparable in all material respects to the Ertco-Hart digital thermometer previously used during the Alcotest calibration process. This court further finds that the Control Company certificate is facially valid and satisfies the requirements as a foundational document as required in A Chun. The court also rejects defendants' contention that the State had a burden to present evidence as to each of the elements required to prove NIST traceability.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 67

    You might also like