ANTICANCER RESEARCH 15: 2683-2650 (1995)
The Use of a Whey Protein Concentrate
the Treatment of
Patients with Metastatic Carcinoma: A Phase I-II Clinical Study
RENEE S. KENNEDY!, GEORGE P. KONOK!, GUSTAVO BOUNOUS?, SYLVAIN BARUCHEL?
and TIMOTHY D. G. LEE
Department of Surgery, Dalhousie Universi, Halifx, Nova Scot;
2Depariment of Surgery, McGill Univesity, Montreah, Quebec:
Department of Pediatrics and Oncology, MeGil Univers, Montreal, Quebec;
‘Department of Immunology and Microbiology, Dalhousie Universi, Half, Nova Scotia, Cenada
Abstract. Gluathione (GSH) concentration is high in most
‘tumour cells and this may be an important factor in resistance to
chemotherapy. Previous in-vitro and animal experiments have
shown a differential response of tumour versus normal cells to
various cysteine delivery systems. More specifcaly, an in-vitro
‘assay showed that at concentrations that induce GSH synthesis
in normal human cells, a specially prepared whey protein
concentrate, Immunocal™, caused GSH depletion and in-
hibition of proliferation in human breast cancer cells. On the
‘basis ofthis information five patients with metastatic carcinoma
of the breast, one of the pancreas and one ofthe liver were fed 30
‘grams ofthis whey protein concentrate daily for six months. In
sic patient the blood lymphocyte GSH levels were substantially
above normal at the outset, reflecting high tumour GSH level.
Two patients (#1,#3) exhibited signs of tumour regression,
normalization of haemoglobin and peripheral lymphocyte
Authors’ addresses: Dr. Renee $. Kennedy, Halifax Infirmary
Hospital, Gerrard Hall, 4th Floor, 5303 Mortis St, Halifax,
"Nova Scotia, B3) 1B6,
Dr. George P. Konok, Halifax Infirmary Hospital, Gerrard
Hall, 4th Floor, $303 Morris St, Halifax, Nova Scotia B3J 186.
Dr. Gustavo Bounous, Immunatech Research Corporation Ltd,
2075 Rue Universite, Suite 1100, Monteeal, Quebee, Canada,
HBA2L1.
Dr. Syivain Baruchel, Montreal Children Hospital, Res. INST.
2300 Tupper St, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, H3H 1P3,
Dr, T.D.G. Lee, Transplantation and Immunology Laboratory,
oth Floor, Sir’ Charles Tupper Bldg,, Dalhousie University,
Halifax, Nova Scotia, BH 4H,
Correspondence to: Dt Gustavo Bounous, Immunotech Research
Corporation Lid, 2075 Rue Université, Suite 1100, Montres,
‘Quebec, Canada HA 2.
Key Words: Whey protein, cancer, metastatic carcinoma,
hitathione,
(0250-7005/95 $2.00+.40
counts and a sustained drop of lymphocyte GSH levels towards
normal. Two patients (#2,#7) showed stabilisation of the
‘tumour, increased haemoglobin levels. In three patients
(#4,45,#6) the disease progressed with a trend toward higher
Smphocyte GSH levels. These results indicate that whey protein
‘concentrate might deplete tumour cells of GSH and render them
‘more vulnerable to chemotherapy.
Feeding a specially formulated whey protein concentrate,
Immunocal™, appears to exert an inhibitory effect not only
on the initiation of cancer but also on its progression (1).
Indeed, in vitro studies have confirmed a direct inhibitory
effect of whey protein concentrate on human cancer cell
replication (2,3). In other human cancer cell studies the
inhibitory effect was found to be related to the serum albumin
component of whey (4) and, most recently to alpha-
lactalbumin, another major component of whey protein
concentrate (5). Feeding lactoferrin to mice inhibited the
reduced lung
colonisation by melanomas (6). Serum albumin was found to
exhibit, unlike other proteins, a strong antimutagenic effect in
‘an in vitro assay using hamster cells (7)
A. possible explanation for these newly discovered
properties of dietary whey protein may be found in recent
findings on the role of glutathione (GSH) in tumour biology.
GSH, (L-y-glutamyl-L-qysteinyl-glycine) isthe principal
cellular antioxidant and detoxifying agent (8).
‘The whey protein concentrate used in our studies
(Immunocal™) contains substrates for GSH production as it
was found in normal animals to enhance cellular OSH
sgmthesis (9). We have succeeded in concentrating in
Immunocal™ serum albumin, alphatfactalbumin and
lactoferrin containing a significant number of cystine residues,
(9).
Free qysteine cannot be used to deliver this necessary
2643ANTICANCER RESEARCH 15 263-2550 (1995)
substrate, as itis toric, and is rapidly metabolised. In the
peptide form, however, the disulphide ostine of undenatured
Immunocal™ released during gastrointestinal digestion can
be effectively transfered to target eels where it is readily
cleaved to eysteine for GSH synthesis
Unlike commercial whey concentrates, Immunocal™ is
produced using specially designed techniques aimed at
preserving the bioactive cystine rich components in their
tndenatured form, Recent experimental evidence revealed an
intriguing differential response of tumour vs. normal ells to
GSH synthesis promoting compounds.
Cellular GSH levels have been found to be several times
higher in human cancer cells than inthe adjacent normal cells
(10), This finding is presumably related to their proliferative
activity. In fact, cancer is the only condition in which an
elevation ofa tightly regulated system such as GSH bas been
reported. However, when a qjsteine and GSH-promoting
compound such as oxothiazolidine-4-carborylate (OTZ) was
added to cultured human lung cancer cels exhibiting very
high levels of GSH at the outset, no intracellular GSH
increase was noted, whereas GSH increased substantially in
normal cells (10. This differential response is even more
pronounced in vivo, In tumour bearing rats OTZ treatment
‘was found to actually deplete GSH in the tumours (11).
‘More. specifically, an in viro assay showed that at
concentrations that induce GSH synthesis in normal human
cells, Immunocal™ caused GSH depletion and inhibition of
proliferation of human breast cancer cells (submitted for
publication by Baruchel S. 1995)
(On the basis ofthese experimental data a Phase 1 clinical
‘ria was undertaken to test the effect of Immunocal™ in five
patients with metastatic breast cancer, one with pancreatic
Cancer and another with metastatic adenocarcinoma to the
liver of unknown primary.
“Materials and Methods
mn testing @ new approach to cancer teatment, patient selection and
faccrval ae eifealt issues Te selected patents must havea reasonable
Tie expectancy, and must have measurable disease. They must not be