Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Nile Dole
Nile Dole
pih!h ? ohghshw
○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○
149
pz uh M[ 2 0 0 6
(\[t'gh puLmh} ohh;lh[ w`zp@hmhh k]% OhhYrh. Zh]thirh w`ih'n NghhAhZh}d uZh]ut w`zp@hmhh
Hhhy[s jh;s;. Zh}A\Ah;Hhhs}d Ah'!hh;iihht Ahh!h KuiI V;f}a r;s jh;s;. z]kt[
w`zp@hmhh Ohhy[ st[ Zh}A\uyr; coh}dj[ ghnzih jh;s[. uZh]th'qhth;qht
w]th;pjsh'ih; nh;M;j[ ih]tih]% yhghy;. pskt[ w`zp@hmhh cZrh"ut chy[
chLhhNhsy; chfahlh d chy[ sh;ih QhFfad ohhM Ohhyh chpmh w`zp@hmhh HhhymhhTrh
fahMRh Ah;Hhh'd[ Qh%d chy; uZh]uthirh C~hptrhyh OhM yhghy[. ihbfad w]N; uhf}ad uZh}d;
jh;s;. cghz[ Qht z]wht[ ygdghhB[ohuMihh C~hptrhihh w;bsh ohhM puOhpuyh. Cwtmrhyh ch;N
c'Zhh%d chy; jh;s;. qhkYrhAh]M; uthd; Ahhgh; uM}d whpjy; s;Ujh Srhihh ih;jth puumh" Ohhyh.
Ohhnh'ihh chpmh ch;xh'qh}d uZh}irh nh;MRh's whmh[ stMy;. w]th;pjsh'ihh Ah'!h AhZr; cnyh. s; k:tQh:t
doht;d; qhHhsih thpjy;. s; ihbfad CBy; chpmh e]aywh!hhs[y z}Zh
chy;Yrh Ah;Hhh'ihh Ah]f;awmhhd; ygdghhB[ohuM[y Srh ohMy;Yrh Qhhghhut Srh'd[ plh'wny;. chsh
k'uhz jh;s chj; ck; psyh cgd[d; chwYrh yuyuSrh pohQhh chutYrh jh;Srh. u;pzf;airh
ohhmhuy;. fahu fahu Ahrh"pzs ohhgh;s Keapbfaz[whw`Ahhmh; chsh sh; lhh'swmh; ohMs jh;sh.
fatmhhth lh;ugrhut[y Vfa Ahgh pskt[j[ w`zp@hmhh w}mh" Ohhy[. wmh chsh f]amhhih;ih pih~h pBfahmhhut
dUjs;. ohmh} Vfah clh]Qhhih; khub wny; jh;s;. uthirh Ahdhs chy;,
fahuMh fahj[ st[ zh;d uLhh=w}u[" clhhih s[d w`zp@hmhh w}mh" fa%d Vfa yhohhjh;Ah
chBuYrhw`Ahhmh; w'Gh UrupKxhswmh; k'wDd Ohhyh jh;sh. Vfa ghh;t[whd uZh} pdMRh nh;MRh'd[
eaneanus Cn}d gh;yh. jks, ygdghhB[ih; C~ht[r khuts, CSe]aYy Ahdhd; kh;dwhuy; bhfas
chsh f]aBYrhj[ @hmh[ chwYrh Ahhgh}d ihhyy[ jh;s[. psd; lh]Qh lhf]ad whyus ku" puZh[
w}mh" f;ay;. Ahgh psd; cYwhr]Lh[ fah Ujhu; lh]Qh fahr, chpmh clh]Qh
whukhyh k]%uhs jh;| fahr, kht;ih Ahdhih; Gh;M
lhfay[ cks[. chsh st cjh;, kAhohyh fah sh; w`faht s]Ajhyh gh]yhqhohhAh sh;'nhs
cpZhfaih c'Zhh%d chy;. bhfash bhfash AhhZhuthu lh;ohht[ qhky;Yrh z;lhwh'nRh'dh Ajmhhy;.
psyh chBuy;, zh;d fahr s;
chBunRh'w}u[" V;d yhohhjh;Ahirh u;M[ w`zp@hmhh Hhhyshdh duthdut[ih; C~ht[r
jh;Ahhs[y ouhM;d; Ajmh; jhsQht ohM}d gh;y;
whukhMRhirh w`ht'Qh[ cjh;, fahr wthihh fahuMh fatshr xhh;n[lh[ OhM yhghy[
AhZh]ih'z`hkhB[ chwmh C~hptrhyh, vsf'aih
AhjhqhM;luthk gh;yh; jh;sh;. xhh;n[ fahr chpmh jhsQht fahr, clh]Qhih s;. ck'ih jh;mhht dhj[
st fahr wpjy[ wSd[ ohhC|d Ahpjdhz;Gh[y dhj[ Ohhyh coh}d, sh;ih
jh z]kth puuhj. wSd[ gh;y[ s[ falh[ ghWw qhk;y cwlhf}ad fatmhhtih
s[, dhj[ fah
s[ falhhyh cwlhf}ad fat[y pfas[ lhh's KuQhhuhih[ jh;s[ s[
qhhfa[ pudhrfathuh'dh wpjy[ wSd[ k]t;Gh pAhMhy[ jh;s[. wpjYrh
c
wSd[irh s]yd;s pudhrfathu Gh}wih khuM; jh;s;, ck'ih Ajby'
@hsh qhtkYrh ygd yhghy;. c'stwhb z}t Ohhyh. jhts]t;j[ whpjoh;. dhj[ fah
Ohhy;. kWswz[ Ohhy[. yhohhjh;Ah k'wDd jh;mrhkhB[ khuM; fa]By;, fahM;ih Ajmhh dh. qhhfa[ j[ duuZh} Ahh!h Srh'irh
u;pzfahpKxhs cgd[yh uZh]uth'd[ s[d w`zp@hmhh Hhhyhrirh CtYrh. umhh"yh cghz[ cd]%w clh[ih Ajmhhryh ju[. rhdh Ohhfahu', psyh
uthirh Cwtmrhyh uZh}irh C~ht[rhih[ ghhB Ahhty[ gh;y[. CHhnhu'.
cpgdz;us;yh w`zp@hmhh Hhhyshdh ut w]N; u Srhirh Ahhgh}d uZh}d; fahr AhhZhuthu j;, pAhLBhDd Ghhshdh st[ pd'zh dfah fa%
cd]ghhAh[ Ujhrih;. u;pzf;as[y cpgd w`pzWs fatmrhkhB[ w]th;pjsh'd[ I;, I;, pd'zh dUj; jh;. uKs]pKxhs[ kh'pghsy[.
kpAhZhh HhhsYrh. wmh SrhAh]M; w`xhAh Zh}tih cpZhfa Ohhyh. vsFrhs w`Sr@h duwptpihs uZh]ut ohhs[d' gh]yhqhohhAh uhNhryh
KuiI Kuth's Ah'!h Ajby; ohhC| yhghy;. chy;. chg\j fa%d jksAh]Ghhd' duuZh} uhNs jh;s[. psirh ih;jTrhut
j; uZh}a, V;lur" w`hWSrxh" Ah[ s]Oh; whmh[g\jmh fatsh;, j; duuZh}a, chd'z ch;k'n}d ujhs jh;sh. AhHhhlh[ihh cwlhf}ad ohmh} s[ wht
Ah[ khAhz;uKu%w st s}? Xgu;zKu%w chj;k. Ah[ chfahlh%w st puk%d gh;y[ jh;s[. cghh, oh; Hhpny;pih dhj[ clh[ psih[ Zhhtmhh
s} w_xu[%w chj;k. chwmh k]w`ohh CSwDd fa%. cd;fa st|mhuZh}'d[ jh;s[.
jpuz`"Urh'irh khjh$rhd; orhyh k's]Lb f;ay; chj; ckh cpgd w`Ks]s pudhrfathuh'ih[ duuZh} y;ih[w;ih[ dhj[ jh;. Ahh;B' uKshz pzks'r
uZh}ih; w`;Ah chAjhkhB[ u_p'ghs fath;. w`fatmh. AhhZhuthu jks jks pAh!hhyh Ajmhhy;.
○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○
150
pz uh M[ 2 0 0 6
pK!hrh'irh w'ghs[AhZh}d chg\j fat[s duuZh} w]N; (\_'ghhthw;@hh dAh" chpmhfa k}ihfa ih;pLbsh'ut oh[u
pdHh}d gh;Yrhut qhhrfah chwhwkhs f]aohqh]oh} yhghYrh. ch;uhM}d bhfahrih[ s[ lhht[ptfa ch;N[j}dj[
chj; fahM[khuM[ih, wmh zhpghDrh'd[ cghz[ AhN}d cpZhfa (\[Ah's cky;Yrh Qhhufah;Ahy @hmhh'dh s[
gh;y[r jh; cpZhfa ohwhrih[. lht[tk]Ghhirh CSfab @hmhh'chn}d
Srhs fahr, eaFs AhpmhAh'ghMk}!h s;uN' du[d. Oh;whus ohhmhht[ thdb[ luhwz; psyh cKuKxh
qhhfa[ kghM; zhpghd; kus[ih; jh;s;ih dh. wmh qhhv", fathrih[. t;grh'irh w]Lfa?w]LfaMmhhTrh lhht[t
ygdhd'st f;auM zh;dih uLh= k'kht fa%d Ahtmhuhb;d' chfaLh"mhhyh C;lh}d s[ Ajmhhrih[. y'wb ch;Yrh
pdHh}d gh;y;Yrh Vfah z]z:"u[ K!h[irh CLbRh shbhut uK!hhj}d cpZhfa CHhn;dhghn; ohghhs z]kt; fahj[j[
qhkhrih' Ajmhoh;... fak'st[ih uhbs', dhj[ fah jh; dks;. pdqht Ahdhd; ohghs thjmhhTrh z]pdr;yh rh
cjh;, Srhs fahr pqhHhny' pohih' chr]Lr k'ws', ghh;Lb[AhZr;ih pulh;Lh tk ckmhht
s[ ohhs; pdHh}d Cyb pjyh ihh'ghyh cd]Qhu[ duth dhj[ Vfah chMkhuy;Yrh z]wht[ duuZh} clh[ih
fah pAhMhyh dhj[st[ kghM;ih w]t|Lh wpjYrh th!h[ yh;Ms wny[ jh;s[. pGhnfa[s}d psd' kjoh qhhj;t
Zhh'zt'bwmhhih fatshs. lh;'zhn plhwhv" Ah;y; qhhfa[ pjihh doht bhfay[. chLhhNhsy; chfahlh fahMRh
Ahh!h AhZh]ih'z` ihh'ghyhih t'gh;y jh;. Ah;Hhh'd[ Qh%d chy; jh;s;. cghz[ Qht z]wht[
j; fahr uhk's[upjd[ fahj[ pohQh;yh jhn c'Zhh%d chy; jh;s;. Ohhnh'ihh chpmh ch;xh'qh}d
oh;umhhirh w'ghs[s cky[ ihihh", V;f;ay dh f]amh[st[. chy;Yrh Ah;Hhh'ihh Ah]f;awmhhd; k'uhz jh;s chj; ck;
V;fas'r fah;mh kghMRh chwmhih st vxh', chpmh psyh ohhmhuy;. fahu fahu fatmhhth lh;ugrhut[y
kAhohh V;fay', st cjh;, kghMRh'dh kghM' Ahhj[sih Vfa fahuMh fahj[ st[ chBuYrhw`Ahhmh; w'Gh
cks'. eaneanus Cn}d gh;yh. chsh f]aBYrhj[ @hmh[
chsh Ahh!h j Ohhy[ qhhv" s]Ahirhw]N'. AhdAh]thz whukhyh k]t|uhs jh;C| lhfay[ cks[. chsh st
jkmrhihh GhMGhMhb. cpZhfaih c'Zhh%d chy;. psyh chBuy;, zh;d
Vf}amh pK!hrh's chpmh w]t|Lhh's Vfaih Vfa ihihh" chBunRh'w}u[" V;d whukhMRhirh w`ht'Qh[
jh;s[. puLhr Vfaih. pqhohut... Ahtmhuhb;u%d pdHh}d AhZh]ih'z`hkhB[ chwmh AhjhqhM;luthk gh;yh; jh;sh;.
gh;y;y[ %wk'wDDh st|mh kus... khuM[ duuZh}a... w]N; s; Ajmhhy;, cgh', puKs[mh" chQhhM,
pudhrfathuh'd[ z]kTrh puuhjhkhB[ f;ay;y[ Hhhv"... w'Zhth nh;'ghth'ih[ th'gh Ohh;fahM}d chy;y[ khuM[ chpmh
pzukh'w}u["ih wSd[ihh ihh:zhuh pzuk chpmh Srhd'st fah;kMsh whC|k pGhnfa[AhZh}d qhHhmrhsz;Gh[y
zh;dih chBunRh'd[ zhthyh yhuy;y; ygdhih; sh;tmh... cdhpAhfa chd'z cksh;. Vfah ktubhAhhgh}d
pudhrfathuh'dh rh khTrh ihih;"ih[ w]t;w}t faYwdh jh;s[. z]kt; ktub cpZhfa CAh;z[d; fah;kMs thjs;.
Srh'dh uhby;, pfas[ pupih!h ckshs j; AhhmhkhAhhmhkhsy; chwmh pGhnfa[irh chs k]tp@hs ck}dz;Gh[y
k'qh'Zh chwyh; ;lh fatmhhTrh chpmh ohjt[ b[fah pih'qh pQhohs cksh;. Ah;Hhh'irh ZhhuSrh khuy[s}d
fatmhhTrh chwYrh pAh!hAh'nM['irhplhuhr ohgh}ih lhfas chwmh peats cksh;. nh;'ghth'irh Ah;HhUrhWs
dhj[ chwmh. Zhty; st ihhus; chpmh kh;ny; st wMs;. th'ghh'AhZh}d chwmh Qhbfas thjsh;. fanRh'u%d
Ght[ ghh;Lb clh[ chj; fa[ rh ihhumrh?kh;nmrhirh Oh;whumhht;. GhMhM chwYrh dkhdkh's}d pddhzs
wy[fan; cky;y;, Ohhfah;M}d chy;y; Vfa Qhrhmh thjshs. s; faZh[ cpZhfa ohuM ktfay; chpmh
Vfahfa[wmh chwYrh Ahdhyh kz:u fahst qhdu[s cks;. Srh'd[ qhhv", faZh[ pAhB[s Hh;sy; j; faMhy;ih dhj[.
puLhmmh fatmhhTrh Srh Qhrg\Ks Vfab;wmhhw;@hh ku" cjh;, AhhOh; f;ak pukfab} dfah clh[ ybfa[
gh]mhzh;Lhh'kpjs chwYrh oh[udhyh Urhw}d bhfamhht; j; fahghhM[ f;ay[ Ah[, st Ahyh chmhGh[dih Hh]kAhb}d
Ahsyqh[ khAhhpohfa k'qh'Zh wtuny;. Ah_Sr]lh$r;ut wj]ny;Yrh bhfas s; f]aohqh]ohy;, cgh, chsh s} f_aLmh Ujhrih',
wSd[yh pzy;yh lhqz whMmrhkhB[ s]bmhht[ chsn[ Ah[ thZhh jh;mhht cghz[ jih Zh%d qhky; s;.
chpmh nh;MRh's[y c(\} ywu[s chwmh Ohbwb f;ay;yh wmh Ah[ f_aLmh jh;C|d fatmhht st[ fahr jh
jh puuhj chpmh Srh k'zQhh"s pAh!hAh'nM[fan}d k]by;yh c'qhhnh khu% st[ falh[ zh;Dj[ jhs
dhSrhghh;Srhs[y vst Ahhmhkh'fan}d yhuy[ ohhmhht[ psfan; gh]'sy;y;. thZhh pfas[ pdyhoht[ chpmh
z}Lhmh; chpmh f;ay; ohhmhht; j;Suhth;w rh khTrh'ih[ zGhy falhhkhB[ chf`aAhfa ck} lhfas;. j; Srh pzulh[ Ah[ Qhh;ghs thpjy;. Ah[ pihSfahty;,
Hrhrih[ ihht pzuk ihpih"yh ohhmhhth puLhr d'st chwh;chw puktyh Ah[ pfa'ihhMy;, Ah[ uhzMy;, Ah[ ohpAhd[s Hh]kmhht[ yGhyGhs[ u[oh
ohhsh;. ws[wSd[irh cdy'f_as dhs;k'qh'Zhhs[y cpslhr u:rpFsfa Ohhy;. s; chwy; khMk}zwmh; wn}d jh;s; chpmh VGhhh faky;Yrh
chpmh fah;uMRh ghh;Lb[ z]pdr;irh qhhohhths Ahh'nmrhih[ fahr dbkA\hbhw`Ahhmh; Ahyh nhrt;Flhd z;s jh;s;. cupihs u[oh yGhyGhy[
chulrfash chj; wSd[ Ajmh}d yhQhy;y[ s[ K!h[ Ght' st faupr!h[ih chpmh fahdBMRh qhkpumhhth chuhoh Ohhyh. puoh;irh yGhyGh[s
cpZhfa jh;s[. oh[udhut QhtQh%d w`;Ah fatmhht[ jh;s[ s[. thkub ohh'QhMRh w`fahlhhs Ahyh Vfaih CAhohy;. Ah[ faZh[ wts thZhh Ohhy;
○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○
151
pz uh M[ 2 0 0 6
chpmh s; faZh[ f_aLmh Ohhy; j; faMy;ih dhj[. yqqhhn f]aBy; Ahgh s; sk' dUj; jh;. yhohhjh;Ahhirh w`zp@hmhh Hhhys ckshdh
w]bw]by;, ckh whC|k rh chZh[ faZh[ wnyhih dhj[. c'ghhut e]ay; ygdghhB[irh Cwtmrhyh OhM wh;ihy[ Srhqhyj[ kus[ih[ khuy[
CAhy}d chy[ AhhOrh. Ahgh s; Ohh;w[ gh;y;. sxhhpw CstSrh z]wht[ qhhv"irh wny[ ck' qhh;ys ckshs qhhrfah.
ohhs[yh ck; pdyhoht;wmhhd; wn}d thjmh; qht; fah Ah[ CBy;, f;ak Srh'dh fahr z]kth Ch;gh lh;ohhtirh fahf}a'dh Ah[ kh'gh}d B;ush;,
khuty;, ghhrqh Ohhy;y[ pbfay[ kjohih doht;k wny[, s[ fawhMhut s]Orh kh;qhs[yh rhryh.
pihfabuy[. qhhxh%Ahyh ohhC|d chYrhut ih]tghMy;y[ khn[ qhzyy[. s[ Srhirhfan; Urhf]aM doht;d; whjs thpjy[. Srhd; qh{gh;s fawn;
Ahgh Ahh!h cghz[ e`;alh uhby;. Ah[ fahs bhfay[. Ahgh Ah[ w]Djh kMkMs[ Qhty; chpmh Hhhv"Hhhv"d; psihh pdth;w Hh;syh.
dhgh[mh Ohhy;. VuN' Ahh!h Ght' j'. clh[ f_aLmhhih[ Qh}pAhfah fatshdh Gh}w Srhirh whBAhh;Trh chf_as[fan; s[ qhHhs thpjy[.
fahj[ pAhMs thjs;. gh'Ahs gh qhhv" Vf;afa. wmh ckhih w`u;lh Srh'd[ d'st psih; y@h kAhh;tirh pQh's[fan; gh;y;. e]ayh'ihh Qhtghiih ghohth
psirhqhth;qhtj[ t'ghpuyh ck;y fah rh puihhthd; s[ faAhhy[ih[ khuZh AhhM}d eah;bh;sy[ kus psirhfan; whjs jks jh;s[. psirh lh;ohht[
Ohhy[. sh;ih zhthutih; qh;y w]Dh w]Djh uhohs ckYrhih; psirh y@hhs duTrhihhj[ eah;bh; jh;sh. wmh sh; c'gh ihh;%d qhkYrhkhtGhh uhbs
chy; chBumh[syh (\_'ghhtz;Gh[y pssfahih CSfabch;yh cksh; jh;sh, ohmh} sh; eah;bh; psirhkhB[ih fahNyh jh;sh. psd; doht z]kt[fan;
cgh Ahhys[, pfas[ u;M qh;y uhohush;r, fahr fats jh;s[k uMpuy[. Ghh'hyh cnfauhrih[ C'ih[ fahwn[ wk" psxh' b;qhyut jh;s[.
pudhrfathu chs r;s Ajmhhy;. s[ r;mrhirh chZh[ih[ s[ wk" jh;s[. lh;YeaAhZr; cd;fa w]Ksf;a jh;s[.
fahj[ dhj[ jh;. nh;Mh faZh[ yhghyh faMy'ih dhj[. s[ jks psd; kjoh Vfa w]Ksfa CHhny;. r]ghhDs? vthus[ fau;". utirh
C~hty[, wmh s]Aj[ AhZr;ih qht; chyhs qhhoh}yh CohUrh fah;wTrhs w`h. k]d'zh z;lhAh]Gh ck; k]t;Gh c@hths
chBumh Ohhy[ thmh[khj;qhh'ih[ qht', j; qhHh puQhhgh[r cpZhfahTrh'qhth;qht pypjy; jh;s;. psirh Hhlhhyh fah;tn wny[. whmh[ Wrhryh s[ pfaihdfan;
Ahyh ch{peakirh fahAhhkhB[ khshTrhyh ohhu' yhgh;y. chsh ihhtyh uMy[. e]aywh!h Qh%d whmh[ HhbhHhbh WrhYrhut psyh ohth j]lhht[
pdHhhryh ju'. chohihh Ah]FfahAh khshth gh;KbjhC|kAhZr;. chy[. kjoh psih; e]aywh!hhfan; y@h gh;y; st k]d'zh z;lhAh]Gh j;ih
cghqhhv", Ajmhoh;, Vfab[ih Hht[ Ah[ choh Vfab[yh Qh[s[ uhbs; dhu psyh Srh Qhh'nRhut pzky;.
jh;. th!hQht nh;MRhyh nh;Mh yhghmhht dhj[ AhhOhh. rh Hhths ku"!h k]d'zh z;lhAh]Gh Qh%d thpjy;y[ chj; ck; psyh
Qh[s[ falhhih[ ohhmhuy; chpmh s[ faAhhy[ih[ cKuKxh Ohhy[. pQh's[utirh eah;bh;ut,
cghz[ wtuh, wtuhwr=s zh;d uLh= jh;Srh dh Srh vxh' coh}d Qhh'nRh'ut, zhpghDrh'ut, fawnRh'ut chwYrh kus[ih[ Ah]z`h CAhby;y[
zh;d Ahpjd;k] h dhj[s Ohhy; Srh gh;Yrh Srh pzulh[ k'ZrhfahM[ chj; rh puihhthd; psih; Ahd Qhrf'apws Ohhy;. psyh yGGhfad ohhmhu}d
Srh'irh cGh;tirh ch'Hhh;M[d' rh Hhthih' c'ghmh ch;y' Ohhy' jh;s', ck'ih gh;y; psirh bwh;Trh Ahh;Srh'irh dxh[ut k]d'zhirh pdMRh nh;MRh's[y
fahj[qhhj[ Ahyh ohhmhus thjs' chpmh Ahdhsy[ th'ghh;M[ pukfab}d ohhs; VGhhzh c(\]pqh'z} pBqhfayh ck;y. psirh Qhtoht[ lhhy}irh wzthchn
qhHhh. psihh VGhhzh j]'zfah cnyh ck;y. qh;n%AhAhZhYrh AhiItzhmh[s
Cghhih, fahj[ st[ih chmhs;k Ohhy' Ahdhs psirh chkFs[ih[ Qhoh"t[ KuWd CAhyy[ cks[y. f{aDktih; pdzhd
○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○
152
pz uh M[ 2 0 0 6
pdAhh"mh jh;s j;hs[. lh;ohhtirh fahf}'adh pudhrfathuh'd[ ohhsh ohhsh
pdth;w B;uyh ck;yih. Srh'dh kjoh Qh;b}d st[ rhu; Ajmh}d s[ qhhj;t
wny[ st fahf}'airh Hhthyh f]ay}w. f]aB'st[ qhhj;t gh;Yrh cks[y Srh.
pdth;w pAhMhyh ck;y st Srh chYrhGh;t[oh thjmhht dhj[s.
VuNRhs kAhh;%d psih[ Ahh;yfat[mh kGh} r;shdh pzky[. s[
jk}d Ajmhhy[, u:d[ VuNRh kh'ohih' f]aB'
cgh', gh;y; jh;s; lh;ohhtirh pQhn; fahf}a'fan;, st Srh'irh Hhthyh
f]ay}w.
z]wht[ih ghhuhyh gh;Yrhs Srh. ihht pzukh'd[ r;sh[y. Srh'ih'
HhtfahAh AhhOrhfan'ih jhr fa[
qht' Ch kfahM[ yufat ihjh Hrhryhih r; gh'.
r;sh; j' u:d[. ihysh;. Hht[ wh;t' uhb qhHhs cks[y.kGh} qhHhsh
qhHhsh pzk;dhlh[ Ohhy[.
wh;th'irh ch;N[d' yghqhgh[d' Hht[ wtsmhht[ kGh} chpmh zh;d uLh=
k'kht fa%d gh;y;y[ chwy[ pdw]p!hfa kus. Ahhys[yh uhby;, kus,
fah;mh, s[ fa[ Ah[ s[ st w`xhAh rh Hhths chy[. Ajmhoh; Ah[ih psih[
kus ck'ih Ajby' whpjoh;. Ahgh psirhw`Ahhmh'ih Ah[j[ pdw]p!hfa jh;mhht
fah psyh jk} chy;. coh}dj[ AhZh]ih'z`hirh chBumh['ih' ihh'zmh'
ghh!hh;ghh!hhs zhb}d chy;y' ckshdh u;nRhkhtGhh fahj[st[ih puihht
r;sh; Ohhy' Ahdhs
psd' chwYrh Hhthih' zht CHhny' s;Ujh eah;d uhohs jh;sh.
Hhhv"Hhhv"d' psd' ptk[Ujt Cihyyh. j{yh;
faZh[ wh;ihyhs khshTrhyh Ah[ jh;r, lh;ohht[ pQhn;fahf}a'fan; gh;y;
jh;s; st Srh gh;Yrhs wtghhu[. Ch kfahM[ r;mhht dh s]Aj[ B[fa
chj;. fahj[ fahMoh[ dfah fa%. ciIh B;us;. qhhr
eah;dirh ch;N[d' s[ pzuh yhuhryhih pukty[. d'st psd' kghM'
Hht w`fahlhhd' CohM}d bhfay'.
zhthih; f]ay}w fahNs ckshdh psirh y@hhs r;C|d gh;y; fa[ w`h.
k]d'zh z;lhAh]Gh j[ psirh dhuhih[ whb[ coh}dj[ zhthut ybfay;y[
chj;. s[ chsh fahN}d bhfahryh ju[. rh Hhths[y khTrh uKs}'ut,
vsf'aih fahr, AhhOrh cpKsSuhut Ohhfah;M}d chy;y' kus dhuhih'
ih;b}fa Ah[ falh[ fahr w]k}d bhfamhht chj; s[ st chsh dk}dz;Gh[y
ku"!h Qh%d thpjy;y[ chj;. fawhbhs[y w:Bmh[yh psih[ ihhe;aghh:t
fah's[ ihh'zmrhw`Ahhmh' pihfab}d thpjy[ chj;. psirh ZhwhwmhhTrh
Ihs[s[y luhkh;iIuhk d;fay;kyh N]lhh z;s chj;s. z;uhw]N[y
OhhYrhut rh Hhths[y pQh's['d[ psihh Ah]fah chf`ah;lh V;fayh ck;y. ihh'z[irh Hh'b;yhj[ psirh Kwlhh"ihh pddhz pihfabyh chj;. qhhgh;AhZh[y
QhtYrh k'khthAhZh}d cupihs CB}d ohhu; yhghYrhAh]M; fazhpihs psihh e]ayOhhn; psirh chBumh['d[ qhj%d chy[ chj;s. vsf'aih fahr,
cs_Ws chSAhh rh uhKs}s coh}dj[ Hhh;bhMs ck;y. K!h[AhSkthd; HhthsYrh f;atk]mh[yhz;Gh[y psihh Kwlh" coh}dj[ KAhts ck;y.
thAhhrmh; Hhnshs, AhjhQhhts; st cGh'nwmh; pypjy[ ohhsih ckshs. wmh Ah[ st[ Vfah pdHh}d gh;y;Yrh K!h[puLhr[ uhf]an;wmhh fah
QhtYrh HhthAhZh}d cj;uwmh[ VGhhz[ st|mh K!h[ Ahtmhhirh uhb;ut zhGhuhuh psyh AhhOh[ Ah:!h[mh kAhohhryh fahr jtfas chj;
jMzf]a'f}a CZhM[s pdHh}d ohhs;, j[ Vfa lhh;fahfahtfa Hhbdh cks;. AhhOrhkhtGrh Vfah cdh;MGh[ K!h[ut chwYrh k'khthih[ ohqhhqhzht[
faAhMhs}d faAhM d CAhyshih ohhu; yhghmh; j; st cpZhfa z]z:"u[ cks;. bhf}ad s[ pdHh}d gh;y[ ck' Ah[ fah kAhoh} dr; chwYrh k'khthih[
chohfahy u:falhhK!hhd; Ahhs_Su k'faYwd;ih[ cd]Qh}s[ cd;fa cw]t[ KuWd' AhhOrh ch;b[s Hhhy}d s[ pdHh}d gh;y[ j;ih Ght' dh
lhFrsh'd[ CohM}d bhfay[ chj;, sxhhpw cKky s; cKkyih. yhyQhnfa pbfaYrhqhth;qhtih ihh'z[ihh fat'nhj[ psd' f]'afauhd' Qh%d
k'ZrhfahMih; kjh uhohhryh chy; jh;s;. whplihAh;yh Nghh'ih[ xhh;n[ B;uy;yh chj;. jh;AhhQhh;us[ s[d e;aTrh Hhhyshdh wzt ohMhyh sh;
wh'ghhwh'gh Ohhy[ jh;s[. AhhuMs[ihh Vfa VuNhkh fah;wth kh;d;t[ f;auM cwHhhs jh;sh ck' kAhohhryh fahr jtfas chj; s[ falhhyh
w`fahlhhd; CohM}d pdHhhyh jh;sh. qhhfa[ih; kghM;ih chfahlh Nghh'd[ cwlhf}ad fat[y puuhjhkhtGrh lh]Qhw`k'gh[ w`zp@hmhh Hhhys
Ohhfah;M}d bhfay; jh;s;. kAhh;tirh b;pyeah;dirh sht;u%d Vf;afa xh;'qh ckshdh AhhOrh wzthd; w;b Hh;syh rhqhy psyh uhv"bz;Gh[y uhby;
Ghhy[ bwfas jh;sh chpmh ohpAhd[utirh Ih;bRhlhh nqhFrhs us]"M; ck;y. kus Ajmhoh; uhv"b, ck'ih fah Ahhys[d; Czqh~h[ w;buy[,
○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○
153
pz uh M[ 2 0 0 6
154
pz uh M[ 2 0 0 6
ghh;Lb Ajmhoh; psd' pQh's[utihh k]d'zhihh eah;bh;j[ fahN}d bhfayh. sh; fahj[j[ ihhy;y
eah;bh; psyh cKuKxh fat[s jh;sh Ajmh;. UrFs[ Ah_s Ohhy[ fa[ psirh psyh Vfa u;ghM[ih lh'fah chy[. coh}dj[ s; wpjYrh wSd[irh
eah;bh;s[y doht;s xhtfahw Cnpumhhth faht|mrQhhu fahj[ u;Mh ohhmhus chBumh[sih jtuy; chj;s fah ohhC| h. chsh Srhihh dhj[ fathrihh
thjsh;. kghM' qhHhmhhTrhirh doht;s cks' j; st Ght'ih, wmh sh; puplhLb puihht.
Ah}n UrFs fatmhht[j[ UrFs[ chsh jrhs dhj[, psih[ st faZh[ih d'stih; pzuk QhthQht pdHh}d gh;y;. nh;jhM;, ch;b[ Qhtmh', nh;jhM
ohM}d thGh Ohhy;y[ chj;, j;j[ qhHhmhhTrhyh ohhmhus thjs' chpmh Srhih' ? oh;umh, Ahhj;tih[ khn[, vst fah;nfah:s]f'a, ws[qhth;qhtih[ ih;pLbs; rh
Ahd Czhk?jMu' jh;s'. k]d'zhirh Srh eah;bh;AhZh}d chd'zhih; w`fahlh? khTrh kh;jMRhs duUrh AhpjDrhsyh wpjyh w'Zhtunh faZh[ Cybyh
pfatmh whOhts ckshdh Ahhys[d' Qhrg\Ks fah qht' Ujhu' ygdhs[y s; faMy;ih dhj[. nh{Fbt[mhqhhv"d[j[ kh'pghsy'', uhN UrupKxhs chj;,
ohMhy;Yrh C~hptrhih[ kh'ghn psd; kus[irh uhv"b doht;lh[ fah pnpyUjt[khB[ Ahhj;t[ ohhryh fahj[ih jtfas dhj[.
Hhhyhu[ psih[ whwz_Lb[ chwYrh k'khthut wn} dr; ck; psyh uhbs Ahhys[ Ahhj;t[ gh;y[ chpmh pudhrfathuh'dh Hht Ahh;faM' Ahh;faM' uhb}
ckhu'. wmh ckh fah;mhshj[ C;lh k]d'zhihh dUjshih. pf'aqhj]dh psirh yhghy'. Srh'dh ck'qh KuWd' wn} yhghy[. faZh[ Ahhys[ih[ ghnz t'ghhih[
Ah_Sr}whk}d AhpjdhQhths Ah[ puuhj fathuh ckh psd' AhhOrhfan}d lhqz khn[ d;k}d k]d'zhih Oht"fad, pdHh}d ohhrih[. faZh[ k]d'zhih;ih
Hh;syh. Ah_Sr}d'stih; w'Zhth pzuk pf`arhfaAhh"sih gh;y; Cty;Yrh w'Zhth pnpyUjt[ih; pzuk Qhts chy; chj;s ck; f]amh[st[ KuWdhs
pzukhs pdun[yh eahtkh cuZh[ d pAhMhYrhd; Vfah AhZrAh zohh"irh k]ihuhrih;. chsh chwmh Ahhys[irh Hhths thjsh;r ck' uhbhrih'. rh
Ah]y[lh[ AhhOhh puuhj k'wDd Ohhyh. Ght' st AhSkthyhj[ fahj[ k[Ahh chZh[ih[ j[ih uhKs} k]d'zhih[ chpmh AhhOh[, clh[ chAjh zh;Hhh'ih[ jh;s[.
cks;. wmh j; kh'ghhrih; fak' chpmh s; Ahhdmhht st[ fah;mh fahyh'sthd' chmh chsh?
Vfahih w]t|Lhhlh[ ts jh;mhhTrh zh;d pK!hrh's vsfa[ w`ih'n zt[ pdAhh"mh Ahhys[ Ahhj;t[ gh;y[ rhyhj[ w'Zhth pzuk Cyby;.
jh;s ck;y st Srhqhy fahr qhh;ymhht Qh}sfahMhut chwmh ohgh} Ahh;qhhv"y uhohsh;r Ajmh}d pudhrfathuh'd[ k'wf"a khZhyh, uh,
lhfas dhj[ j;ih Ght;. us"AhhdfahM chwmhhyh kh;kus dhj[ chpmh Ah]ygh[ Ohhy[ fah Ihd. KuhQhhpufa, d:kpgh"fa w`k}s[ chpmh
QhpuLrfahMhut f]amhhih[j[ k~hh dks;. Ahhys[lh[ ohAhu}d Hh;mh'ih chsh qhhM?qhhM's[mh k]Gh%w rhih[ih pulh;Lh chd'z uhbsh;. cjh;, Ah[ vxh'
pjshih'. k]d'zh z}ths}d j; kht; wjhs ck;y st s[ dFfa[ih @hAhh Ah]'qhv"j}d qhh;ysh;r. ch{peakirh fahj[ oh%t[irh fahAhhkhB[ rhu'
fat[y. pfa'qhj]dh chwmhhyh lhFrsh; yufat pukty; ohhu; rhkhB[ st yhghy'. zh;ds[d pzuk xhh'qhmhht chj; vxh'. whihu[yh Ah[ r;sh; psfan'.
psd' Supts ygdhpuLhr[ chg\j Zhtyh dk;y dh k]d'zh, @hAhh fat. chiIh.
s]Orh chr]Lrhs pdrs[d; s]Orhut Hhh;t cDrhr f;ayh. chwYrh tkw}mh" w`k}s[d'stirh whihUrh pzulh[ kfahM[ pudhrfathu khk]tuhn[k
KuWd[y nh;MRh'd[ ohgh whjmrhih[ s} uh'Ih f;ay[k Srhih s]Orh KuWdhM} wh;ihy;.
nh;MRh'ih[ pdrs[d; thGh fa%d bhfay[ chpmh chsh Ah[j[ s]Orhut qhhxh%AhAhZr; jhswhr Zh]u}d, ih}M Qh%d s; qhhM'psmh[irh Ghh;y[fan;
sh;ih cDrhr fat[s chj;. wmh rh Gh;w;yh pdrs[ Vfah AhSktg\Ks uMy;.
j[ K!h[irh %whd; cus[mh" Ohhy;y[ chj; chpmh psd; Ahyh f;auM Ahhys[ohuM s; ohhC|d qhkshs d qhkshih sh;ih j[ qhHhh s]Ahih[
pdpAh~hAhh!h qhduy'ih gh Ah]ygh[ Ajmhs khk]qhhv"d[ Ahh;tw'Gh[ Zh]wbRhsy; Vfa vuy;k; Ah]bf]aM;
kht' Hht t'ghuhryh chB pzuk yhghy;. dhj[ Ajby' st[ Hhths[y Srh'irh jhs[ pzy;.
khAhhd fahNmh', KuiI fatmh', yhumh' rh khTrh qhht[fakht[fa ghh;Lb[ut Ah]ygh[ ghh;t[whd jh;s[ chpmh psih; nh;M; pdM; jh;s;. pudhrfathuh'd[
y@h B;umh' j;z;Gh[y zghzgh[ih' fahAh cks'. rh khTrh Ahhdpkfa chpmh Ah]bf]aM; wts khk}qhhv=fan' pzy; chpmh Ahhys[irh c'ghhut w`;AhQhthd;
lhht[ptfa (\Ahhd; Ahhys[ xhf}ad gh;y[. psih[ w`f_as[ pqhHhny[. psyh jhs B;uyh d qhh;ysh psd; chwy; sh;'n pQh's[fan; uMpuy;. psirh
pw~hhihhj[ pulh;Lh !hhk ohhmhu} yhghyh. nh{. lhh;Qhh yhgh} rh'irhfan; psyh nh;MRh's}d c(\} ujhs jh;s;.
Hh;C|d ohhrih; ck; pudhrfathuh'd[ Btpuy;. u;M pdplihs f;ay[. w}mh" yhohhjh;Ahhirh w`zp@hmh;s[y fahj[ ch;M[ pudhrfathuh'dh c'Zh]fa
swhkmh[ f;aYrhut nh{. yhgh} AjmhhYrh, fah+g\{ir]y;lhDk Ahhys[qhhv" chBuYrh
s]Aj[ chv" jh;mhht chjhs Ahhys[ih[ Ihs[ ZhnZhny[ chpmh Vfa j; duuZh},
cdhpAhfa plhtplht[ psyh ohhmhuy[. pudhrfathuh'dhj[ puluhak chpmh Ah[ chfahlhKu%w chj;
cpQhAhhd uhbyh. fahj[ bh{pdfa chpmh ghh;MRh nh{Fbth'd[ pyj}d pzYrh chpmh s} w_xu[Ku%w chj;k
u w`Sr;fa AhpjDrhyh swhkmh[khB[ rhryh kh'pghsy'. Ah[ chQhhM chj;
Hht[ chYrhut Ahhys[ Ajmhhy[, Ahyh st qhhv", wpjYrh Gh;w;yh chpmh AhhOrh wy[fan; cd's chQhhM; chj;s
Ah]yghhih juh. ghh;whMf_aLmhhkhtGhh khuMh HhdlrhAh k]'zt Ah]yghh. s;xh[y d@h!hh'ih[ gh}N ihhj}y Ahyh ohhmhus thjs;
s]Ajhyh fahr ju', Ah]yghh fa[ Ah]ygh[ s[ pudhrfathuhdh Ajmhhy[, Ah[ Ah;Hh jh;C|d qhtksh; s;Ujh
Ahyh st Ah]ygh[z;Gh[y ihhy;y jh; s; C~hty;. c#hshih[ ihhj}yj[ qhtks thjs;.
Ahhys[ Srh'irhfan; qhHhsih thpjy[. ckyh fakyh rh'ihh VfahVfa[ Ah]ygh[ tn} yhghy[. psirh tnmrhd; pudhrfathu
z_pLbfah;d ihFfa, fahj[j[ ihhy;y ck' Ajmhshs. Ght' st clhh w`k'gh[ Qhhdhut chy;. ckh chuhoh chwmh w}u[" V;fay;yh chj; ck; Srh'dh
duTrhd' CAhy}d C~h;pohs Ujhryh ju'. qhhrfah;yh ohuM Hh;s, f]atuhMs ohhmhuy; chpmh Ahgh Srh'ihh ih;jth CohM}d pdHhhyh.
xhh;n[ AhKs[j[ fathryh whpjoh;. j; kht' thpjy' qhhoh}yh, chpmh Ajmh;, ll
○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ ○
155